-
Developments on frequency domain multiplexing readout for large arrays of transition-edge sensor X-ray micro-calorimeters
Authors:
D. Vaccaro,
H. Akamatsu,
L. Gottardi,
M. de Wit,
M. P. Bruijn,
J. van der Kuur,
K. Nagayoshi,
E. Taralli,
K. Ravensberg,
J. R. Gao,
J. W. A. den Herder
Abstract:
At SRON we have been develo** X-ray TES micro-calorimeters as backup technology for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) of the Athena mission, demonstrating excellent resolving powers both under DC and AC bias. We also developed a frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) readout technology, where each TES is coupled to a superconducting band-pass LC resonator and AC biased at MHz frequencies throug…
▽ More
At SRON we have been develo** X-ray TES micro-calorimeters as backup technology for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) of the Athena mission, demonstrating excellent resolving powers both under DC and AC bias. We also developed a frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) readout technology, where each TES is coupled to a superconducting band-pass LC resonator and AC biased at MHz frequencies through a common readout line. The TES signals are summed at the input of a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID), which performs a first amplification at cryogenic stage. Custom analog front-end electronics and digital boards take care of further amplifying the signals at room temperature and of the modulation/demodulation of the TES signals and bias carrier, respectively. We report on the most recent developments on our FDM technology, which involves a two-channel demonstration with a total of 70 pixels with a summed energy resolution of 2.34 +/- 0.02 eV at 5.9 keV without spectral performance degradation with respect to single-channel operation. Moreover, we discuss prospects towards the scaling-up to a larger multiplexing factor up to 78 pixels per channel in a 1-6 MHz readout bandwidth.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
System performance of a TDM test-bed with long flex harness towards the new X-IFU FPA-DM
Authors:
D. Vaccaro,
M. de Wit,
J. van der Kuur,
L. Gottardi,
K. Ravensberg,
E. Taralli,
J. Adams,
S. R. Bandler,
J. A. Chervenak,
W. B. Doriese,
M. Durkin,
C. Reintsema,
K. Sakai,
S. J. Smith,
N. A. Wakeham,
B. Jackson,
P. Khosropanah,
J. R. Gao,
J. W. A. den Herder,
P. Roelfsema
Abstract:
SRON (Netherlands Institute for Space Research) is develo** the Focal Plane Assembly (FPA) for Athena X-IFU, whose Demonstration Model (DM) will use for the first time a time domain multiplexing (TDM)-based readout system for the on-board transition-edge sensors (TES). We report on the characterization activities on a TDM setup provided by NASA Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC) and National Ins…
▽ More
SRON (Netherlands Institute for Space Research) is develo** the Focal Plane Assembly (FPA) for Athena X-IFU, whose Demonstration Model (DM) will use for the first time a time domain multiplexing (TDM)-based readout system for the on-board transition-edge sensors (TES). We report on the characterization activities on a TDM setup provided by NASA Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC) and National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST) and tested in SRON cryogenic test facilities. The goal of these activities is to study the impact of the longer harness, closer to X-IFU specs, in a different EMI environment and switching from a single-ended to a differential readout scheme. In this contribution we describe the advancement in the debugging of the system in the SRON cryostat, which led to the demonstration of the nominal spectral performance of 2.8 eV at 5.9~keV with 16-row multiplexing, as well as an outlook for the future endeavours for the TDM readout integration on X-IFU's FPA-DM at SRON.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Demonstration of Weak-Link Physics in the Dynamical Response of Transition-Edge Sensors
Authors:
Marios Kounalakis,
Luciano Gottardi,
Martin de Wit,
Yaroslav M. Blanter
Abstract:
We theoretically predict and experimentally observe the onset of weak-link physics in the dynamical response of transition edge sensors (TES). We develop a theoretical framework based on a Fokker-Planck description that incorporates both the TES electrical response, stemming from Josephson phenomena, and the electrothermal effects due to coupling to a thermal bath. Our measurements of a varying dy…
▽ More
We theoretically predict and experimentally observe the onset of weak-link physics in the dynamical response of transition edge sensors (TES). We develop a theoretical framework based on a Fokker-Planck description that incorporates both the TES electrical response, stemming from Josephson phenomena, and the electrothermal effects due to coupling to a thermal bath. Our measurements of a varying dynamic resistance are in excellent agreement with our theory, thereby establishing weak-link phenomena as the main mechanism underlying the operation of TES. Furthermore, our description enables the calculation of power spectral densities, paving the way for a more thorough investigation of the unexplained "excess noise" in long diffusive junctions and TES reported in recent experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2023; v1 submitted 13 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
A Review of X-ray Microcalorimeters Based on Superconducting Transition Edge Sensors for Astrophysics and Particle Physics
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Kenichiro Nagayoshi
Abstract:
The state-of-the-art technology of X-ray microcalorimeters based on superconducting transition edge sensors (TESs), for applications in astrophysics and particle physics, is reviewed. We will show the advance in understanding the detector physics and describe the recent breakthroughs in the TES design that are opening the way towards the fabrication and the read-out of very large arrays of pixels…
▽ More
The state-of-the-art technology of X-ray microcalorimeters based on superconducting transition edge sensors (TESs), for applications in astrophysics and particle physics, is reviewed. We will show the advance in understanding the detector physics and describe the recent breakthroughs in the TES design that are opening the way towards the fabrication and the read-out of very large arrays of pixels with unprecedented energy resolution. The most challenging low temperature instruments for space- and ground-base experiments will be described.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Voltage Fluctuations in ac Biased Superconducting Transition-Edge Sensors
Authors:
L. Gottardi,
M. de Wit,
E. Taralli,
K. Nagayashi,
A. Kozorezov
Abstract:
We present a detailed analysis of the fundamental noise sources in superconducting transition-edge sensors (TESs), ac voltage biased at MHz frequencies and treated as superconducting weak links. We have studied the noise in the resistive transition as a function of bath temperature of several detectors with different normal resistances and geometries. We show that the excess noise, typically obser…
▽ More
We present a detailed analysis of the fundamental noise sources in superconducting transition-edge sensors (TESs), ac voltage biased at MHz frequencies and treated as superconducting weak links. We have studied the noise in the resistive transition as a function of bath temperature of several detectors with different normal resistances and geometries. We show that the excess noise, typically observed in the TES electrical bandwidth, can be explained by the equilibrium Johnson noise of the quasiparticles generated within the weak link. The fluctuations at the Josephson frequency and higher harmonics contribute significantly to the measured voltage noise at the detector bandwidth through the nonlinear response of the weak link with a sinusoidal current-phase relation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Transition-Edge Sensors for cryogenic X-ray imaging spectrometers
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Stephen Smith
Abstract:
Large arrays of superconducting transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters are becoming the key technology for future space-based X-ray observatories and ground-based experiments in the fields of astrophysics, laboratory astrophysics, plasma physics, particle physics and material analysis. Thanks to their sharp superconducting-to-normal transition, TESs can achieve very high sensitivity in det…
▽ More
Large arrays of superconducting transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters are becoming the key technology for future space-based X-ray observatories and ground-based experiments in the fields of astrophysics, laboratory astrophysics, plasma physics, particle physics and material analysis. Thanks to their sharp superconducting-to-normal transition, TESs can achieve very high sensitivity in detecting small temperature changes at very low temperature. TES based X-ray detectors are non-dispersive spectrometers bringing together high resolving power, imaging capability and high-quantum efficiency simultaneously. In this chapter, we highlight the basic principles behind the operation and design of TESs, and their fundamental noise limits. We will further elaborate on the key fundamental physics processes that guide the design and optimization of the detector. We will then describe pulse-processing and important calibration considerations for space flight instruments, before introducing novel multi-pixel TES designs and discussing applications in future X-ray space missions over the coming decades.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The Athena X-ray Integral Field Unit: a consolidated design for the system requirement review of the preliminary definition phase
Authors:
Didier Barret,
Vincent Albouys,
Jan-Willem den Herder,
Luigi Piro,
Massimo Cappi,
Juhani Huovelin,
Richard Kelley,
J. Miguel Mas-Hesse,
Stéphane Paltani,
Gregor Rauw,
Agata Rozanska,
Jiri Svoboda,
Joern Wilms,
Noriko Yamasaki,
Marc Audard,
Simon Bandler,
Marco Barbera,
Xavier Barcons,
Enrico Bozzo,
Maria Teresa Ceballos,
Ivan Charles,
Elisa Costantini,
Thomas Dauser,
Anne Decourchelle,
Lionel Duband
, et al. (274 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Athena X-ray Integral Unit (X-IFU) is the high resolution X-ray spectrometer, studied since 2015 for flying in the mid-30s on the Athena space X-ray Observatory, a versatile observatory designed to address the Hot and Energetic Universe science theme, selected in November 2013 by the Survey Science Committee. Based on a large format array of Transition Edge Sensors (TES), it aims to provide sp…
▽ More
The Athena X-ray Integral Unit (X-IFU) is the high resolution X-ray spectrometer, studied since 2015 for flying in the mid-30s on the Athena space X-ray Observatory, a versatile observatory designed to address the Hot and Energetic Universe science theme, selected in November 2013 by the Survey Science Committee. Based on a large format array of Transition Edge Sensors (TES), it aims to provide spatially resolved X-ray spectroscopy, with a spectral resolution of 2.5 eV (up to 7 keV) over an hexagonal field of view of 5 arc minutes (equivalent diameter). The X-IFU entered its System Requirement Review (SRR) in June 2022, at about the same time when ESA called for an overall X-IFU redesign (including the X-IFU cryostat and the cooling chain), due to an unanticipated cost overrun of Athena. In this paper, after illustrating the breakthrough capabilities of the X-IFU, we describe the instrument as presented at its SRR, browsing through all the subsystems and associated requirements. We then show the instrument budgets, with a particular emphasis on the anticipated budgets of some of its key performance parameters. Finally we briefly discuss on the ongoing key technology demonstration activities, the calibration and the activities foreseen in the X-IFU Instrument Science Center, and touch on communication and outreach activities, the consortium organisation, and finally on the life cycle assessment of X-IFU aiming at minimising the environmental footprint, associated with the development of the instrument. Thanks to the studies conducted so far on X-IFU, it is expected that along the design-to-cost exercise requested by ESA, the X-IFU will maintain flagship capabilities in spatially resolved high resolution X-ray spectroscopy, enabling most of the original X-IFU related scientific objectives of the Athena mission to be retained. (abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2022; v1 submitted 30 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Frequency domain multiplexing readout for large arrays of transition-edge sensors
Authors:
Davide Vaccaro,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Luciano Gottardi,
Jan van der Kuur,
Kenichiro Nagayoshi,
Emanuele Taralli,
Martin de Wit,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Anton J. van der Linden,
Bert-Joost van Leeuwen,
Paul van der Hulst,
Kevin Ravensberg,
Cor P. de Vries,
Mikko Kiviranta,
Jian-Rong Gao,
Jan-Willem A. den Herder
Abstract:
We report our most recent progress and demonstration of a frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) readout technology for transition-edge sensor (TES) arrays, both of which we have been develo**, in the framework of the X-IFU instrument on board the future Athena X-ray telescope. Using Ti/Au TES micro-calorimeters, high-Q LC filters and analog/digital electronics developed at SRON and low-noise two-s…
▽ More
We report our most recent progress and demonstration of a frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) readout technology for transition-edge sensor (TES) arrays, both of which we have been develo**, in the framework of the X-IFU instrument on board the future Athena X-ray telescope. Using Ti/Au TES micro-calorimeters, high-Q LC filters and analog/digital electronics developed at SRON and low-noise two-stage SQUID amplifiers from VTT Finland, we demonstrated feasibility of our FDM readout technology, with the simultaneous readout of 37 pixels with an energy resolution at of 2.23 eV at an energy of 6 keV. We finally outline our plans for further scaling up and improving our technology.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Performance of the SRON Ti/Au Transition Edge Sensor X-ray Calorimeters
Authors:
Martin de Wit,
Luciano Gottardi,
Kenichiro Nagayoshi,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Marcel L. Ridder,
Emanuele Taralli,
Davide Vaccaro,
Jian-Rong Gao,
Jan-Willem A. den Herder
Abstract:
In the early 2030s, ESAs new X-ray observatory, Athena, is scheduled to be launched. It will carry two main instruments, one of which is the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU), an X-ray imaging spectrometer, which will consist of an array of several thousand transition-edge sensors (TESs) with a proposed energy resolution of 2.5 eV for photon energies up to 7 keV. At SRON we develop the backup TES…
▽ More
In the early 2030s, ESAs new X-ray observatory, Athena, is scheduled to be launched. It will carry two main instruments, one of which is the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU), an X-ray imaging spectrometer, which will consist of an array of several thousand transition-edge sensors (TESs) with a proposed energy resolution of 2.5 eV for photon energies up to 7 keV. At SRON we develop the backup TES array based on Ti/Au bilayers with a transition temperature just below 100 mK. In this contribution we will give a broad overview of the properties and capabilities of these state-of-the-art detectors. Over the years we have fabricated and studied a large number of detectors with various geometries, providing us with a good understanding of how to precisely control the properties of our detectors. We are able to accurately vary the most important detector properties, such as the normal resistance, thermal conductance and critical temperature. This allows us to finely tune our detectors to meet the demands of various applications. The detectors have demonstrated excellent energy resolutions of below 1.8 eV for 5.9 keV X-rays. By tuning the properties of the devices, they can be optimally matched to various read-out schemes using both AC and DC biasing. The next step is to increase the size of our TES arrays from our current kilo-pixel arrays towards the full-sized array for X-IFU.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Susceptibility study of TES micro-calorimeters for X-ray spectroscopy under FDM readout
Authors:
Davide Vaccaro,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Luciano Gottardi,
Jan van der Kuur,
Emanuele Taralli,
Martin de Wit,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Roland den Hartog,
Mikko Kiviranta,
Anton J. van der Linden,
Kenichiro Nagayoshi,
Kevin Ravensberg,
Marcel L. Ridder,
Sven Visser,
Brian D. Jackson,
Jian-Rong Gao,
Ruud W. M. Hoogeveen,
Jan-Willem A. den Herder
Abstract:
We present a characterization of the sensitivity of TES X-ray micro-calorimeters to environmental conditions under frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) readout. In the FDM scheme, each TES in a readout chain is in series with a LC band-pass filter and AC biased with an independent carrier at MHz range. Using TES arrays, cold readout circuitry and warm electronics fabricated at SRON and SQUIDs produ…
▽ More
We present a characterization of the sensitivity of TES X-ray micro-calorimeters to environmental conditions under frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) readout. In the FDM scheme, each TES in a readout chain is in series with a LC band-pass filter and AC biased with an independent carrier at MHz range. Using TES arrays, cold readout circuitry and warm electronics fabricated at SRON and SQUIDs produced at VTT Finland, we characterize the sensitivity of the detectors to bias voltage, bath temperature and magnetic field. We compare our results with the requirements for the Athena X-IFU instrument, showing the compliance of the measured sensitivities. We find in particular that FDM is intrinsically insensitive to the magnetic field because of TES design and AC readout.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Mitigation of the Magnetic Field Susceptibility of Transition Edge Sensors using a Superconducting Groundplane
Authors:
Martin de Wit,
Luciano Gottardi,
Marcel L. Ridder,
Kenichiro Nagayoshi,
Emanuele Taralli,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Davide Vaccaro,
Jan-Willem A. den Herder,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Jian-Rong Gao
Abstract:
Transition edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters and bolometers are used for a variety of applications. The sensors are based on the steep temperature-dependent resistance of the normal-to-superconducting transition, and are thus intrinsically sensitive to magnetic fields. Conventionally the detectors are shielded from stray magnetic fields using external magnetic shields. However, in particular for…
▽ More
Transition edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters and bolometers are used for a variety of applications. The sensors are based on the steep temperature-dependent resistance of the normal-to-superconducting transition, and are thus intrinsically sensitive to magnetic fields. Conventionally the detectors are shielded from stray magnetic fields using external magnetic shields. However, in particular for applications with strict limits on the available space and mass of an instrument, external magnetic shields might not be enough to obtain the required shielding factors or field homogeneity. Additionally, these shields are only effective for magnetic fields generated external to the TES array, and are ineffective to mitigate the impact of internally generated magnetic fields. Here we present an alternative shielding method based on a superconducting groundplane deposited directly on the backside of the silicon nitride membrane on which the TESs are located. We demonstrate that this local shielding for external magnetic fields has a shielding factor of at the least ~ 75, and is also effective at reducing internal self-induced magnetic fields, as demonstrated by measurements and simulation of the eddy current losses in our AC biased detectors. Measurements of 5.9 keV X-ray photons show that our shielded detectors have a high resilience to external magnetic fields, showing no degradation of the energy resolution or shifts of the energy scale calibration for fields of several microTesla, values higher than expected in typical real-world applications.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
ATHENA X-IFU Demonstration Model: First joint operation of the main TES Array and its Cryogenic AntiCoincidence Detector (CryoAC)
Authors:
M. D'Andrea,
K. Ravensberg,
A. Argan,
D. Brienza,
S. Lotti,
C. Macculi,
G. Minervini,
L. Piro,
G. Torrioli,
F. Chiarello,
L. Ferrari Barusso,
M. Biasotti,
G. Gallucci,
F. Gatti,
M. Rigano,
H. Akamatsu,
J. Dercksen,
L. Gottardi,
F. de Groote,
R. den Hartog,
J. -W. den Herder,
R. Hoogeveen,
B. Jackson,
A. McCalden,
S. Rosman
, et al. (6 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The X-IFU is the cryogenic spectrometer onboard the future ATHENA X-ray observatory. It is based on a large array of TES microcalorimeters, which works in combination with a Cryogenic AntiCoincidence detector (CryoAC). This is necessary to reduce the particle background level thus enabling part of the mission science goals. Here we present the first joint test of X-IFU TES array and CryoAC Demonst…
▽ More
The X-IFU is the cryogenic spectrometer onboard the future ATHENA X-ray observatory. It is based on a large array of TES microcalorimeters, which works in combination with a Cryogenic AntiCoincidence detector (CryoAC). This is necessary to reduce the particle background level thus enabling part of the mission science goals. Here we present the first joint test of X-IFU TES array and CryoAC Demonstration Models, performed in a FDM setup. We show that it is possible to operate properly both detectors, and we provide a preliminary demonstration of the anti-coincidence capability of the system achieved by the simultaneous detection of cosmic muons.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Thermal crosstalk of X-ray transition-edge sensor micro-calorimeters under frequency domain multiplexing readout
Authors:
Davide Vaccaro,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Luciano Gottardi,
Roland den Hartog,
Jan van der Kuur,
A. J. van der Linden,
Kenichiro Nagayoshi,
Kevin Ravensberg,
Marcel L. Ridder,
Emanuele Taralli,
Martin de Wit,
Jian-Rong Gao,
Ruud W. M. Hoogeveen,
Jan-Willem A. den Herder
Abstract:
We have measured and characterized the thermal crosstalk in two different arrays of transition-edge sensor (TES) X-ray micro-calorimeters with frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) readout. The TES arrays are fabricated at SRON and are a 8$\times$8 and a 32$\times$32 "kilo-pixel" uniform array. The amount of crosstalk is evaluated as the ratio between the averaged crosstalk signal and the X-ray puls…
▽ More
We have measured and characterized the thermal crosstalk in two different arrays of transition-edge sensor (TES) X-ray micro-calorimeters with frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) readout. The TES arrays are fabricated at SRON and are a 8$\times$8 and a 32$\times$32 "kilo-pixel" uniform array. The amount of crosstalk is evaluated as the ratio between the averaged crosstalk signal and the X-ray pulse amplitudes. The crosstalk ratios (CR) for our detectors are compliant with the requirements for future X-ray space missions, such as Athena X-IFU (CR$< 10^{-3}$ for first-neighbour pixels): we measured a nearest-neighbour thermal crosstalk ratio at a level of $10^{-4}$, with a highest crosstalk ratio of $4\times 10^{-4}$ for the kilo-pixel array (worst case, center of array) and $1\times 10^{-4}$ for the 8$\times$8 array, with a margin of improvement achievable by optimizing the Cu metallization and the width of the Si supporting structures (muntins) in the backside of the TES array chip. Based on the measured crosstalk ratios, we have estimated the impact on the spectral resolution by means of noise equivalent power (NEP) considerations and a Monte Carlo simulation, finding an average degradation in quadrature of less than 40~meV, compliant with the < 0.2~eV requirement for Athena X-IFU.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Demonstration of MHz frequency domain multiplexing readout of 37 transition edge sensors for high-resolution x-ray imaging spectrometers
Authors:
H. Akamatsu,
D. Vaccaro,
L. Gottardi,
J. van der Kuur,
C. P. de Vries,
M. Kiviranta,
K. Ravensberg,
M. D'Andrea,
E. Taralli,
M. de Wit,
M. P. Bruijn,
P. van der Hulst,
R. H. den Hartog,
B-J. van Leeuwen,
A. J. van der Linden,
A. J McCalden,
K. Nagayoshi,
A. C. T. Nieuwenhuizen,
M. L. Ridder,
S. Visser,
P. van Winden,
J. R. Gao,
R. W. M. Hoogeveen,
B. D. Jackson,
J-W. A. den Herder
Abstract:
We report on the development and demonstration of a MHz frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) technology to read out arrays of cryogenic transition edge sensor (TES) X-ray microcalorimeters. In our FDM scheme, TESs are AC-biased at different resonant frequencies in the low MHz range through an array of high-$Q$ LC resonators. The current signals of all TESs are summed at superconducting quantum inte…
▽ More
We report on the development and demonstration of a MHz frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) technology to read out arrays of cryogenic transition edge sensor (TES) X-ray microcalorimeters. In our FDM scheme, TESs are AC-biased at different resonant frequencies in the low MHz range through an array of high-$Q$ LC resonators. The current signals of all TESs are summed at superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDs). We have demonstrated multiplexing for a readout of 31 pixels using room temperature electronics, high-$Q$ LC filters and TES arrays developed at SRON, and SQUID arrays from VTT. We repeated this on a second setup with 37 pixels. The summed X-ray spectral resolutions $@$ 5.9 keV are $ΔE_{\rm 31 pix ~MUX}=2.14\pm0.03$ eV and $ΔE_{\rm 37 pix ~MUX}=2.23\pm0.03$ eV. The demonstrated results are comparable with other multiplexing approaches. There is potential to further improve the spectral resolution and to increase the number of multiplexed TESs, and to open up applications for TES X-ray microcalorimeters.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Impact of the absorber coupling design for Transition Edge Sensor X-ray Calorimeters
Authors:
M. de Wit,
L. Gottardi,
E. Taralli,
K. Nagayoshi,
M. L. Ridder,
H. Akamatsu,
M. P. Bruijn,
R. W. M. Hoogeveen,
J. van der Kuur,
K. Ravensberg,
D. Vaccaro,
J-R. Gao,
J-W. A. den Herder
Abstract:
Transition Edge Sensors (TESs) are the selected technology for future spaceborne X-ray observatories, such as Athena, Lynx, and HUBS. These missions demand thousands of pixels to be operated simultaneously with high energy-resolving power. To reach these demanding requirements, every aspect of the TES design has to be optimized. Here we present the experimental results of tests on different device…
▽ More
Transition Edge Sensors (TESs) are the selected technology for future spaceborne X-ray observatories, such as Athena, Lynx, and HUBS. These missions demand thousands of pixels to be operated simultaneously with high energy-resolving power. To reach these demanding requirements, every aspect of the TES design has to be optimized. Here we present the experimental results of tests on different devices where the coupling between the x-ray absorber and the TES sensor is varied. In particular, we look at the effects of the diameter of the coupling stems and the distance between the stems and the TES bilayer. Based on measurements of the AC complex impedance and noise, we observe a reduction in the excess noise as the spacing between the absorber stem and the bilayer is decreased. We identify the origin of this excess noise to be internal thermal fluctuation noise between the absorber stem and the bilayer. Additionally, we see an impact of the coupling on the superconducting transition in the appearance of kinks. Our observations show that these unwanted structures in the transition shape can be avoided with careful design of the coupling geometry. Also the stem diameter appears to have a significant impact on the smoothness of the TES transition. This observation is still poorly understood, but is of great importance for both AC and DC biased TESs.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
High Aspect Ratio Transition Edge Sensors for X-ray Spectrometry
Authors:
M. de Wit,
L. Gottardi,
E. Taralli,
K. Nagayoshi,
M. L. Ridder,
H. Akamatsu,
M. P. Bruijn,
M. D'Andrea,
J. van der Kuur,
K. Ravensberg,
D. Vaccaro,
S. Visser,
J. R. Gao,
J. -W. A. den Herder
Abstract:
We are develo** large TES arrays in combination with FDM readout for the next generation of X-ray space observatories. For operation under AC-bias, the TESs have to be carefully designed and optimized. In particular, the use of high aspect ratio devices will help to mitigate non-ideal behaviour due to the weak-link effect. In this paper, we present a full characterization of a TES array containi…
▽ More
We are develo** large TES arrays in combination with FDM readout for the next generation of X-ray space observatories. For operation under AC-bias, the TESs have to be carefully designed and optimized. In particular, the use of high aspect ratio devices will help to mitigate non-ideal behaviour due to the weak-link effect. In this paper, we present a full characterization of a TES array containing five different device geometries, with aspect ratios (width:length) ranging from 1:2 up to 1:6. The complex impedance of all geometries is measured in different bias configurations to study the evolution of the small-signal limit superconducting transition parameters, as well as the excess noise. We show that high aspect ratio devices with properly tuned critical temperatures (around 90 mK) can achieve excellent energy resolution, with an array average of 2.03 +- 0.17 eV at 5.9 keV and a best achieved resolution of 1.63 +- 0.17 eV. This demonstrates that AC-biased TESs can achieve a very competitive performance compared to DC-biased TESs. The results have motivated a push to even more extreme device geometries currently in development.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
A test platform for the detection and readout chain for the Athena X-IFU
Authors:
Gabriele Betancourt-Martinez,
François Pajot,
Sophie Beaumont,
Gilles Roudil,
Joseph Adams,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Simon Bandler,
Bernard Bertrand,
Marcel Bruijn,
Florent Castellani,
Edoardo Cucchetti,
William Doriese,
Michel Dupieux,
Hervé Geoffray,
Luciano Gottardi,
Brian Jackson,
Jan van der Kuur,
Mikko Kiviranta,
Antoine Miniussi,
Phillipe Peille,
Kevin Ravensberg,
Laurent Ravera,
Carl Reintsema,
Kazuhiro Sakai,
Stephen Smith
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a test platform for the Athena X-IFU detection chain, which will serve as the first demonstration of the representative end-to-end detection and readout chain for the X-IFU, using prototypes of the future flight electronics and currently available subsystems. This test bench, housed in a commercial two-stage ADR cryostat, includes a focal plane array placed at the 50 mK cold stage of th…
▽ More
We present a test platform for the Athena X-IFU detection chain, which will serve as the first demonstration of the representative end-to-end detection and readout chain for the X-IFU, using prototypes of the future flight electronics and currently available subsystems. This test bench, housed in a commercial two-stage ADR cryostat, includes a focal plane array placed at the 50 mK cold stage of the ADR with a kilopixel array of transition-edge sensor microcalorimeter spectrometers and associated cold readout electronics. Prototype room temperature electronics for the X-IFU provide the readout, and will evolve over time to become more representative of the X-IFU mission baseline. The test bench yields critical feedback on subsystem designs and interfaces, in particular the warm readout electronics, and will provide an in-house detection system for continued testing and development of the warm readout electronics and for the validation of X-ray calibration sources. In this paper, we describe the test bench subsystems and design, characterization of the cryostat, and current status of the project.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
TiAu TES 32$\times$32 pixel array: uniformity, thermal crosstalk and performance at different X-ray energies
Authors:
E. Taralli,
M. D'Andrea,
L. Gottardi,
K. Nagayoshi,
M. Ridder,
S. Visser,
M. de Wit,
D. Vaccaro,
H. Akamatsu,
K. Ravensberg,
R. Hoogeveen,
M. Bruijn,
J. R. Gao
Abstract:
Large format arrays of transition edge sensor (TES) are crucial for the next generation of X-ray space observatories. Such arrays are required to achieve an energy resolution of $\mathrmΔE<$3 eV full-width-half-maximum (FWHM) in the soft X-ray energy range. We are currently develo** X-ray microcalorimeter arrays as a backup option for the X-IFU instrument on board of ATHENA space telescope, led…
▽ More
Large format arrays of transition edge sensor (TES) are crucial for the next generation of X-ray space observatories. Such arrays are required to achieve an energy resolution of $\mathrmΔE<$3 eV full-width-half-maximum (FWHM) in the soft X-ray energy range. We are currently develo** X-ray microcalorimeter arrays as a backup option for the X-IFU instrument on board of ATHENA space telescope, led by ESA and foreseen to be launched in 2031. In this contribution, we report on the development and the characterization of a uniform 32$\times$32 pixel array with (length$\times $width) 140$\times$30 $μ$m$^2$ TiAu TESs, which have \textcolor{black}{a 2.3 $μ$m} thick Au absorber for X-ray photons. The pixels have a typical normal resistance $R_\mathrm{n}$ = 121 m$Ω$ and a critical temperature $T_\mathrm{c}\sim$ 90 mK. We performed extensive measurements on 60 pixels out of the array in order to show the uniformity of the array. We obtained an energy resolutions between 2.4 and 2.6 eV (FWHM) at 5.9 keV, measured in a single-pixel mode at AC bias frequencies ranging from 1 to 5 MHz, with a frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) readout system, which is developed at SRON/VTT. We also present the detector energy resolution at X-ray with different photon energies generated by a modulated external X-ray source from 1.45 keV up to 8.9 keV. Multiplexing readout across several pixels has also been performed to evaluate the impact of the thermal crosstalk to the instrument's energy resolution budget requirement. This value results in a derived requirement, for the first neighbour, that is less than 1$\times$10$^{-3}$ when considering the ratio between the amplitude of the crosstalk signal to an X-ray pulse (for example at 5.9 keV)
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
AC/DC characterization of a Ti/Au TES with Au/Bi absorber for X-ray detection
Authors:
E. Taralli,
C. Pobes,
P. Khosropanah,
L. Fabrega,
A. Camon,
L. Gottardi,
K. Nagayoshi,
M. Ridder,
M. Bruijn,
J. R. Gao
Abstract:
Transition-edge sensors (TESs) are used as very sensitive thermometers in microcalorimeters aimed at detection of different wavelengths. In particular, for soft X-ray astrophysics, science goals require very high resolution microcalorimeters which can be achieved with TESs coupled to suitable absorbers. For many applications there is also need for a high number of pixels which typically requires m…
▽ More
Transition-edge sensors (TESs) are used as very sensitive thermometers in microcalorimeters aimed at detection of different wavelengths. In particular, for soft X-ray astrophysics, science goals require very high resolution microcalorimeters which can be achieved with TESs coupled to suitable absorbers. For many applications there is also need for a high number of pixels which typically requires multiplexing in the readout stage. Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) is a common scheme and is the baseline proposed for the ATHENA mission. FDM requires biasing the TES in AC at MHz frequencies. Recently there has been reported degradation in performances under AC with respect to DC bias. In order to assess the performances of TESs to be used with FDM, it is thus of great interest to compare the performances of the same device both under AC and DC bias. This requires two different measurement setups with different processes for making the characterization. We report in this work the preliminary results of a single pixel characterization performed on a TiAu TES under AC and afterwards under DC bias in different facilities. Extraction of dynamical parameters and noise performances are compared in both cases as a first stage for further AC/DC comparison of these devices.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Characterization of high aspect ratio TiAu TES X-ray microcalorimeters array using the X-IFU Frequency Domain Multiplexing readout
Authors:
E. Taralli,
L. Gottardi,
K. Nagayoshi,
M. Ridder,
S. Visser,
P. Khosropanah,
H. Akamatsu,
J. van der Kuur,
M. Bruijn,
J. R. Gao
Abstract:
We are develo** X-ray microcalorimeters as a backup option for the baseline detectors in the X-IFU instrument on board the ATHENA space mission led by ESA and to be launched in the early 2030s.5$\times$5 mixed arrays with TiAu transition-edge sensor (TES), which have different high aspect ratios and thus high resistances, have been designed and fabricated to meet the energy resolution requiremen…
▽ More
We are develo** X-ray microcalorimeters as a backup option for the baseline detectors in the X-IFU instrument on board the ATHENA space mission led by ESA and to be launched in the early 2030s.5$\times$5 mixed arrays with TiAu transition-edge sensor (TES), which have different high aspect ratios and thus high resistances, have been designed and fabricated to meet the energy resolution requirement of the X-IFU instrument. Such arrays can also be used to optimise the performance of the Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) readout and lead to the final steps for the fabrication of a large detector array. In this work we present the experimental results from tens of the devices with an aspect ratio (length-to-width) ranging from 1-to-1 up to 6-to-1, measured in a single-pixel mode with a FDM readout system developed at SRON/VTT. We observed a nominal energy resolution of about 2.5 eV at 5.9 keV at bias frequencies ranging from 1 to 5 MHz. These detectors are proving to be the best TES microcalorimeters ever reported in Europe, being able to meet not only the requirements of the X-IFU instrument, but also those of other future challenging X-ray space missions, fundamental physics experiments, plasma characterization and material analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Complex impedance of TESs under AC bias using FDM readout system
Authors:
E. Taralli,
P. Khosropanah,
L. Gottardi,
K. Nagayoshi,
M. L. Ridder,
M. P. Bruijn,
J. R. Gao
Abstract:
The next generation of Far-infrared and X-ray space observatories will require detector arrays with thousands of transition edge sensor (TES) pixel. It is extremely important to have a tool that is able to characterize all the pixels and that can give a clear picture of the performance of the devices. In particular, we refer to those aspects that can affect the global energy resolution of the arra…
▽ More
The next generation of Far-infrared and X-ray space observatories will require detector arrays with thousands of transition edge sensor (TES) pixel. It is extremely important to have a tool that is able to characterize all the pixels and that can give a clear picture of the performance of the devices. In particular, we refer to those aspects that can affect the global energy resolution of the array: logarithmic resistance sensitivity with respect to temperature and current ($α$ and $β$ parameters, respectively), uniformity of the TESs and the correct understanding of the detector thermal model. Complex impedance measurement of a TES is the only technique that can give all this information at once, but it has been established only for a single pixel under DC bias. We have developed a complex impedance measurement method for TESs that are AC biased since we are using a MHz frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) system to readout an array. We perform a complete set of AC impedance measurements for different X-ray TES microcalorimeters based on superconducting TiAu bilayers with or without normal metal Au bar structures. We discuss the statistical analysis of the residual between impedance data and fitting model to determine the proper calorimeter thermal model for our detectors. Extracted parameters are used to improve our understanding of the differences and capabilities among the detectors and additionally the quality of the array. Moreover, we use the results to compare the calculated noise spectra with the measured data.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Performance and uniformity of a kilo-pixel array of Ti/Au transition-edge sensor microcalorimeters
Authors:
E. Taralli,
M. D'Andrea,
L. Gottardi,
K. Nagayoshi,
M. L. Ridder,
M. de Wit,
D. Vaccaro,
H. Akamatsu,
M. P. Bruijn,
J. R. Gao
Abstract:
Uniform large transition-edge sensor (TES) arrays are fundamental for the next generation of X-ray space observatories. These arrays are required to achieve an energy resolution $ΔE$ < 3 eV full-width-half-maximum (FWHM) in the soft X-ray energy range. We are currently develo** X-ray microcalorimeter arrays for use in future laboratory and space-based X-ray astrophysics experiments and ground-ba…
▽ More
Uniform large transition-edge sensor (TES) arrays are fundamental for the next generation of X-ray space observatories. These arrays are required to achieve an energy resolution $ΔE$ < 3 eV full-width-half-maximum (FWHM) in the soft X-ray energy range. We are currently develo** X-ray microcalorimeter arrays for use in future laboratory and space-based X-ray astrophysics experiments and ground-based spectrometers.
In this contribution we report on the development and the characterization of a uniform 32$\times$32 pixel array with 140$\times$30 $μ$m$^2$ Ti/Au TESs with Au X-ray absorber. We report upon extensive measurements on 60 pixels in order to show the uniformity of our large TES array. The averaged critical temperature is $T_\mathrm{c}$ = 89.5$\pm$0.5 mK and the variation across the array ($\sim$1 cm) is less than 1.5 mK. We found a large region of detector's bias points between 20\% and 40\% of the normal-state resistance where the energy resolution is constantly lower than 3 eV. In particular, results show a summed X-ray spectral resolution $ΔE_\mathrm{FWHM}$ = 2.50$\pm$0.04 eV at a photon energy of 5.9 keV, measured in a single-pixel mode using a frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) readout system developed at SRON/VTT at bias frequencies ranging from 1 to 5 MHz. Moreover we compare the logarithmic resistance sensitivity with respect to temperature and current ($α$ and $β$ respectively) and their correlation with the detector's noise parameter $M$, showing an homogeneous behaviour for all the measured pixels in the array.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Single pixel performance of a 32$\times$32 Ti/Au TES array with broadband X-ray spectra
Authors:
Matteo D'Andrea,
Emanuele Taralli,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Luciano Gottardi,
Kenichiro Nagayoshi,
Kevin Ravensberg,
Marcel L. Ridder,
Davide Vaccaro,
Cor P. de Vries,
Martin de Wit,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Ruud W. M. Hoogeveen,
Jian-Rong Gao
Abstract:
We are develo** a kilo-pixels Ti/Au TES array as a backup option for Athena X-IFU. Here we report on single-pixel performance of a 32$\times$32 array operated in a Frequency Division Multiplexing (FDM) readout system, with bias frequencies in the range 1-5 MHz. We have tested the pixels response at several photon energies, by means of a $^{55}$Fe radioactive source (emitting Mn-K$α$ at 5.9 keV)…
▽ More
We are develo** a kilo-pixels Ti/Au TES array as a backup option for Athena X-IFU. Here we report on single-pixel performance of a 32$\times$32 array operated in a Frequency Division Multiplexing (FDM) readout system, with bias frequencies in the range 1-5 MHz. We have tested the pixels response at several photon energies, by means of a $^{55}$Fe radioactive source (emitting Mn-K$α$ at 5.9 keV) and a Modulated X-ray Source (MXS, providing Cr-K$α$ at 5.4 keV and Cu-K$α$ at 8.0 keV). First, we report the procedure used to perform the detector energy scale calibration, usually achieving a calibration accuracy better than $\sim$ 0.5 eV in the 5.4 - 8.9 keV energy range. Then, we present the measured energy resolution at the different energies (best single pixel performance: $Δ$E$_{FWHM}$ = 2.40 $\pm$ 0.09 eV @ 5.4 keV; 2.53 $\pm$ 0.10 eV @ 5.9 keV; 2.78 $\pm$ 0.16 eV @ 8.0 keV), investigating also the performance dependency from the pixel bias frequency and the count rate. Thanks to long background measurements ($\sim$ 1 day), we finally detected also the Al-K$α$ line at 1.5 keV, generated by fluorescence inside the experimental setup. We analyzed this line to obtain a first assessment of the single-pixel performance also at low energy ($Δ$E$_{FWHM}$ = 1.91 eV $\pm$ 0.21 eV @ 1.5 keV), and to evaluate the linearity of the detector response in a large energy band (1.5 - 8.9 keV).
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Frequency Shift Algorithm: Application to a Frequency-Domain Multiplexing Readout of X-ray Transition-Edge Sensor Microcalorimeters
Authors:
D. Vaccaro,
H. Akamatsu,
J. van der Kuur,
P. van der Hulst,
A. C. T. Nieuwenhuizen,
P. van Winden,
L. Gottardi,
R. den Hartog,
M. P. Bruijn,
M. D'Andrea,
J. R. Gao,
J. W. A. den Herder,
R. W. M. Hoogeveen,
B. Jackson,
A. J. van der Linden,
K. Nagayoshi,
K. Ravensberg,
M. L. Ridder,
E. Taralli,
M. de Wit
Abstract:
In the frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) scheme, transition-edge sensors (TES) are individually coupled to superconducting LC filters and AC biased at MHz frequencies through a common readout line. To make efficient use of the available readout bandwidth and to minimize the effect of non-linearities, the LC resonators are usually designed to be on a regular grid. The lithographic processes howev…
▽ More
In the frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) scheme, transition-edge sensors (TES) are individually coupled to superconducting LC filters and AC biased at MHz frequencies through a common readout line. To make efficient use of the available readout bandwidth and to minimize the effect of non-linearities, the LC resonators are usually designed to be on a regular grid. The lithographic processes however pose a limit on the accuracy of the effective filter resonance frequencies. Off-resonance bias carriers could be used to suppress the impact of intermodulation distortions, which nonetheless would significantly affect the effective bias circuit and the detector spectral performance. In this paper we present a frequency shift algorithm (FSA) to allow off-resonance readout of TES's while preserving the on-resonance bias circuit and spectral performance, demonstrating its application to the FDM readout of a X-ray TES microcalorimeter array. We discuss the benefits in terms of mitigation of the impact of intermodulation distortions at the cost of increased bias voltage and the scalability of the algorithm to multi-pixel FDM readout. We show that with FSA, in multi-pixel and frequencies shifted on-grid, the line noises due to intermodulation distortion are placed away from the sensitive region in the TES response and the X-ray performance is consistent with the single-pixel, on-resonance level.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Progress in the development of frequency domain multiplexing for the X-ray Integral Field Unit on board the Athena mission
Authors:
H. Akamatsu,
L. Gottardi,
J. van der Kuur,
C. P. de Vries,
M. P. Bruijn,
J. A. Chervenak,
M. Kiviranta,
A. J. van den Linden,
B. D. Jackson,
A. Miniussi,
K. Ravensberg,
K. Sakai,
S. J. Smith,
N. Wakeham
Abstract:
Frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) is the baseline readout system for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) on board the Athena mission. Under the FDM scheme, TESs are coupled to a passive LC filter and biased with alternating current (AC bias) at MHz frequencies. Using high-quality factor LC filters and room temperature electronics developed at SRON and low-noise two-stage SQUID amplifiers provi…
▽ More
Frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) is the baseline readout system for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) on board the Athena mission. Under the FDM scheme, TESs are coupled to a passive LC filter and biased with alternating current (AC bias) at MHz frequencies. Using high-quality factor LC filters and room temperature electronics developed at SRON and low-noise two-stage SQUID amplifiers provided by VTT, we have recently demonstrated good performance with the FDM readout of Mo/Au TES calorimeters with Au/Bi absorbers. We have achieved a performance requested for the demonstration model (DM) with the single pixel AC bias ($ΔE=$1.8 eV) and 9 pixel multiplexing ($ΔE=$2.6 eV) modes. We have also demonstrated 14-pixel multiplexing with an average energy resolution of 3.3 eV, which is limited by non-fundamental issues related to FDM readout in our lab setup.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Proximity effect model for x-ray Transition Edge Sensors
Authors:
R. C. Harwin,
D. J. Goldie,
S. Withington,
P. Khosropanah,
L. Gottardi,
J. -R. Gao
Abstract:
Transition Edge Sensors are ultra-sensitive superconducting detectors with applications in many areas of research, including astrophysics. The device consists of a superconducting thin film, often with additional normal metal features, held close to its transition temperature and connected to two superconducting leads of a higher transition temperature. There is currently no way to reliably assess…
▽ More
Transition Edge Sensors are ultra-sensitive superconducting detectors with applications in many areas of research, including astrophysics. The device consists of a superconducting thin film, often with additional normal metal features, held close to its transition temperature and connected to two superconducting leads of a higher transition temperature. There is currently no way to reliably assess the performance of a particular device geometry or material composition without making and testing the device. We have developed a proximity effect model based on the Usadel equations to predict the effects of device geometry and material composition on sensor performance. The model is successful in reproducing I-V curves for two devices currently under study. We use the model to suggest the optimal size and geometry for TESs, considering how small the devices can be made before their performance is compromised. In the future, device modelling prior to manufacture will reduce the need for time-consuming and expensive testing.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2018; v1 submitted 16 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Optimising the multiplex factor of the frequency domain multiplexed readout of the TES-based microcalorimeter imaging array for the X-IFU instrument on the Athena Xray observatory
Authors:
J. van der Kuur,
L. G. Gottardi,
H. Akamatsu,
B. J. van Leeuwen,
R. den Hartog,
D. Haas,
M. Kiviranta,
B. J. Jackson
Abstract:
Athena is a space-based X-ray observatory intended for exploration of the hot and energetic universe. One of the science instruments on Athena will be the X-ray Integrated Field Unit (X-IFU), which is a cryogenic X-ray spectrometer, based on a large cryogenic imaging array of Transition Edge Sensors (TES) based microcalorimeters operating at a temperature of 100mK. The imaging array consists of 38…
▽ More
Athena is a space-based X-ray observatory intended for exploration of the hot and energetic universe. One of the science instruments on Athena will be the X-ray Integrated Field Unit (X-IFU), which is a cryogenic X-ray spectrometer, based on a large cryogenic imaging array of Transition Edge Sensors (TES) based microcalorimeters operating at a temperature of 100mK. The imaging array consists of 3800 pixels providing 2.5 eV spectral resolution, and covers a field of view with a diameter of of 5 arc minutes. Multiplexed readout of the cryogenic microcalorimeter array is essential to comply with the cooling power and complexity constraints on a space craft. Frequency domain multiplexing has been under development for the readout of TES-based detectors for this purpose, not only for the X-IFU detector arrays but also for TES-based bolometer arrays for the Safari instrument of the Japanese SPICA observatory. This paper discusses the design considerations which are applicable to optimise the multiplex factor within the boundary conditions as set by the space craft. More specifically, the interplay between the science requirements such as pixel dynamic range, pixel speed, and cross talk, and the space craft requirements such as the power dissipation budget, available bandwidth, and electromagnetic compatibility will be discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Development of frequency domain multiplexing for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) on the Athena
Authors:
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Luciano Gottardi,
Jan van der Kuur,
Cor P. de Vries,
Kevin Ravensberg,
Joseph S. Adams,
Simon R. Bandler,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
James A. Chervenak,
Caroline A Kilbourne,
Mikko Kiviranta,
A. J. van den Linden,
Brian D. Jackson,
Stephen J. Smith
Abstract:
We are develo** the frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) read-out of transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) instrument on board of the future European X-Ray observatory Athena. The X-IFU instrument consists of an array of $\sim$3840 TESs with a high quantum efficiency ($>$90 \%) and spectral resolution $ΔE$=2.5 eV $@$ 7 keV ($E/ΔE\sim$2800). FDM i…
▽ More
We are develo** the frequency domain multiplexing (FDM) read-out of transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) instrument on board of the future European X-Ray observatory Athena. The X-IFU instrument consists of an array of $\sim$3840 TESs with a high quantum efficiency ($>$90 \%) and spectral resolution $ΔE$=2.5 eV $@$ 7 keV ($E/ΔE\sim$2800). FDM is currently the baseline readout system for the X-IFU instrument. Using high quality factor LC filters and room temperature electronics developed at SRON and low-noise two stage SQUID amplifiers provided by VTT, we have recently demonstrated good performance with the FDM readout of Mo/Au TES calorimeters with Au/Bi absorbers. An integrated noise equivalent power resolution of about 2.0 eV at 1.7 MHz has been demonstrated with a pixel from a new TES array from NASA/Goddard (GSFC-A2). We have achieved X-ray energy resolutions $\sim$2.5 eV at AC bias frequency at 1.7 MHz in the single pixel read-out. We have also demonstrated for the first time an X-ray energy resolution around 3.0 eV in a 6 pixel FDM read-out with TES array (GSFC-A1). In this paper we report on the single pixel performance of these microcalorimeters under MHz AC bias, and further results of the performance of these pixels under FDM.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Microcalorimeter pulse analysis by means of principle component decomposition
Authors:
C. P. de Vries,
R. M. Schouten,
J. van der Kuur,
L. Gottardi,
H. Akamatsu
Abstract:
The X-ray integral field unit for the Athena mission consists of a microcalorimeter transition edge sensor pixel array. Incoming photons generate pulses which are analyzed in terms of energy, in order to assemble the X-ray spectrum. Usually this is done by means of optimal filtering in either time or frequency domain.
In this paper we investigate an alternative method by means of principle compo…
▽ More
The X-ray integral field unit for the Athena mission consists of a microcalorimeter transition edge sensor pixel array. Incoming photons generate pulses which are analyzed in terms of energy, in order to assemble the X-ray spectrum. Usually this is done by means of optimal filtering in either time or frequency domain.
In this paper we investigate an alternative method by means of principle component analysis. This method attempts to find the main components of an orthogonal set of functions to describe the data.
We show, based on simulations, what the influence of various instrumental effects is on this type of analysis. We compare analyses both in time and frequency domain. Finally we apply these analyses on real data, obtained via frequency domain multiplexing readout.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
A multiplexer for the ac/dc characterization of TES based bolometers and microcalorimeters
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Marcel Bruijn,
Jan R. Gao,
Roland den Hartog,
Richard Hijmering,
Henk Hoevers,
Pourya Khosropanah,
Jan van der Kuur,
Anoton van der Linden,
Marcel Lindeman,
Marcel Ridder
Abstract:
At SRON we are develo** the Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) for the read-out of the TES-based detector array for the future infrared and X-ray space mission. We describe the performances of a multiplexer designed to increase the experimental throughput in the characterisation of ultra-low noise equivalent power (NEP) TES bolometers and high energy resolving power X-ray microcalorimeters arra…
▽ More
At SRON we are develo** the Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) for the read-out of the TES-based detector array for the future infrared and X-ray space mission. We describe the performances of a multiplexer designed to increase the experimental throughput in the characterisation of ultra-low noise equivalent power (NEP) TES bolometers and high energy resolving power X-ray microcalorimeters arrays under ac and dc bias. We discuss the results obtained using the TiAu TES bolometers array fabricated at SRON with measured dark NEP below $5\cdot 10^{-19}W/Hz^{1/2}$ and saturation power of several fW
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Study of the dependency on magnetic field and bias voltage of an AC-biased TES microcalorimeter
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
James Adams,
Catherine Bailey,
Simon Bandler,
Marcel Bruijn,
James Chervenak,
Megan Eckart,
Frank Finkbeiner,
Roland den Hartog,
Henk Hoevers,
Richard Kelley,
Caroline Kilbourne,
Piet de Korte,
Jan van der Kuur,
Mark Lindeman,
Frederick Porter,
Jack Sadleir,
Steve Smith
Abstract:
At SRON we are studying the performance of a Goddard Space Flight Center single pixel TES microcalorimeter operated in an AC bias configuration. For x-ray photons at 6 keV the pixel shows an x-ray energy resolution $dE_{FWHM} = 3.7\mathrm{eV}$, which is about a factor 2 worse than the energy resolution observed in an identical DC-biased pixel. In order to better understand the reasons for this dis…
▽ More
At SRON we are studying the performance of a Goddard Space Flight Center single pixel TES microcalorimeter operated in an AC bias configuration. For x-ray photons at 6 keV the pixel shows an x-ray energy resolution $dE_{FWHM} = 3.7\mathrm{eV}$, which is about a factor 2 worse than the energy resolution observed in an identical DC-biased pixel. In order to better understand the reasons for this discrepancy we characterised the detector as a function of temperature, bias working point and applied perpendicular magnetic field. A strong periodic dependency of the detector noise on the TES AC bias voltage is measured. We discuss the results in the framework of the recently observed weak-link behaviour of a TES microcalorimeter
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
AC bias characterization of low noise bolometers for SAFARI using an Open-Loop Frequency Domain SQUID-based multiplexer operating between 1 and 5 MHz
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Marcel Bruijn,
Jan-R. Gao,
Roland den Hartog,
Richard Hijmering,
Henk Hoevers,
Pourya Khosropanah,
Piet de Korte,
Jan van der Kuur,
Mark Lindeman,
Marcel Ridder
Abstract:
SRON is develo** the Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) readout and the ultra low NEP TES bolometers array for the infrared spectrometer SAFARI on board of the Japanese space mission SPICA. The FDM prototype of the instrument requires critical and complex optimizations. For single pixel characterization under AC bias we are develo** a simple FDM system working in the frequency range from 1 to…
▽ More
SRON is develo** the Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) readout and the ultra low NEP TES bolometers array for the infrared spectrometer SAFARI on board of the Japanese space mission SPICA. The FDM prototype of the instrument requires critical and complex optimizations. For single pixel characterization under AC bias we are develo** a simple FDM system working in the frequency range from 1 to 5 MHz, based on the open loop read-out of a linearized two-stage SQUID amplifier and high Q lithographic LC resonators. We describe the details of the experimental set-up required to achieve low power loading (< 1 fW) and low noise (NEP $\sim 10^{-19} W/Hz^{1/2}$) in the TES bolometers. We conclude the paper by comparing the performance of a $4 \cdot 10^{-19} W/Hz^{1/2}$ TES bolometer measured under DC and AC bias.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Performance of an X-ray single pixel TES microcalorimeter under DC and AC biasing
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Jan van der Kuur,
Piet A. J. de Korte,
Roland Den Hartog,
Bob Dirks,
Manuela Popescu,
Henk F. C. Hoevers,
Marcel Bruijn,
Maria Parra Borderias,
Y. Takei
Abstract:
We are develo** Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) for the read-out of TES imaging microcalorimeter arrays for future X-ray missions like IXO. In the FDMconfiguration the TES is AC voltage biased at a well defined frequencies (between 0.3 to 10MHz) and acts as an AM modulating element. In this paper we will present a full comparison of the performance of a TES microcalorimeter under DC bias and…
▽ More
We are develo** Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) for the read-out of TES imaging microcalorimeter arrays for future X-ray missions like IXO. In the FDMconfiguration the TES is AC voltage biased at a well defined frequencies (between 0.3 to 10MHz) and acts as an AM modulating element. In this paper we will present a full comparison of the performance of a TES microcalorimeter under DC bias and AC bias at a frequency of 370kHz. In both cases we measured the current-to-voltage characteristics, the complex impedance, the noise, the X-ray responsivity, and energy resolution. The behaviour is very similar in both cases, but deviations in performances are observed for detector working points low in the superconducting transition (R/RN < 0.5). The measured energy resolution at 5.89keV is 2.7eV for DC bias and 3.7eV for AC bias, while the baseline resolution is 2.8eV and 3.3eV, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Characterisation of a TES-Based X-ray Microcalorimeter in the Energy Range from 150 to 1800 eV Using an Adiabatic Demagnetisation Refrigerator
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Yoh Takei,
Jan van der Kuur,
Piet A. J. de Korte,
Henk F. C. Hoevers,
Dirk Boersma,
Marcel Bruijn,
Wim Mels,
Marcel L. Ridder,
Dick Takken,
Henk van Weers
Abstract:
We characterised a TES-based X-ray microcalorimeter in an adiabatic demagnetisation refrigerator (ADR) using synchrotron radiation. The detector response and energy resolution was measured at the beam-line in the PTB radiometry laboratory at the electron storage ring BESSY II in the range from 200 to 1800 eV. We present and discuss the results of the energy resolution measurements as a function of…
▽ More
We characterised a TES-based X-ray microcalorimeter in an adiabatic demagnetisation refrigerator (ADR) using synchrotron radiation. The detector response and energy resolution was measured at the beam-line in the PTB radiometry laboratory at the electron storage ring BESSY II in the range from 200 to 1800 eV. We present and discuss the results of the energy resolution measurements as a function of energy, beam intensity and detector working point. The measured energy resolution ranges between 1.5 to 2.1 eV in the investigated energy range and is weakly dependent on the detector set point. A first analysis shows a count-rate capability, without considerable loss of performance, of about 500 counts per second.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Weak-Link Phenomena in AC-Biased Transition Edge Sensors
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Marcel Bruijn,
Jan-R. Gao,
Roland den Hartog,
Richard Hijmering,
Henk Hoevers,
Pourya Khosropanah,
Alex Kozorezov,
Jan van der Kuur,
Anton van der Linden,
Marcel Ridder
Abstract:
It has been recently demonstrated that superconducting transition edge sensors (TESs) behave as weak-links due to longitudinally induced superconductivity from the leads with higher Tc. In this work we study the implication of this behaviour for TES-based bolometers and microcalorimeter under ac bias. The TESs are read-out at frequencies between 1 and 5 MHz by a Frequency Domain Multiplexer based…
▽ More
It has been recently demonstrated that superconducting transition edge sensors (TESs) behave as weak-links due to longitudinally induced superconductivity from the leads with higher Tc. In this work we study the implication of this behaviour for TES-based bolometers and microcalorimeter under ac bias. The TESs are read-out at frequencies between 1 and 5 MHz by a Frequency Domain Multiplexer based on a linearised two-stage SQUID amplifier and high- Q lithographically made superconducting LC resonators. In particular, we focus on SRON TiAu TES bolometers with a measured dark Noise Equivalent Power (NEP) of $3.2 \cdot 10^{-19} W/Hz^{1/2}$ developed for the short wavelength band for the instrument SAFARI on the SPICA telescope.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Development of the superconducting detectors and read-out for the X-IFU instrument on board of the X-ray observatory Athena
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Roland den Hartog,
Jan-Willem den Herder,
Brian Jackson,
Mikko Kiviranta,
Jan van der Kuur,
Henk van Weers
Abstract:
The Advanced Telescope for High-Energy Astrophysics (Athena) has been selected by ESA as its second large-class mission. The future European X-ray observatory will study the hot and energetic Universe with its launch foreseen in 2028. Microcalorimeters based on superconducting Transition-edge sensor (TES) are the chosen technology for the detectors array of the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) on…
▽ More
The Advanced Telescope for High-Energy Astrophysics (Athena) has been selected by ESA as its second large-class mission. The future European X-ray observatory will study the hot and energetic Universe with its launch foreseen in 2028. Microcalorimeters based on superconducting Transition-edge sensor (TES) are the chosen technology for the detectors array of the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) on board of Athena. The X-IFU is a 2-D imaging integral-field spectrometer operating in the soft X-ray band (0.3 -12 keV). The detector consists of an array of 3840 TESs coupled to X-ray absorbers and read out in the MHz bandwidth using Frequency Domain Multiplexing (FDM) based on Superconducting QUantum Interference Devices (SQUIDs). The proposed design calls for devices with a high filling-factor, high quantum efficiency, relatively high count-rate capability and an energy resolution of 2.5 eV at 5.9 keV. The paper will review the basic principle and the physics of the TES-based microcalorimeters and present the state-of-the art of the FDM read-out.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Development of TES-based detectors array for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) on the future x-ray observatory ATHENA
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Didier Barret,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Roland H. den Hartog,
Jan-Willem den Herder,
Henk F. C. Hoevers,
Mikko Kiviranta,
Jan van der Kuur,
Anton J. van der Linden,
Brian D. Jackson,
Madu Jambunathan,
Marcel L. Ridder
Abstract:
We are develo** transition-edge sensor (TES)-based microcalorimeters for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (XIFU) of the future European X-Ray Observatory Athena. The microcalorimeters are based on TiAu TESs coupled to 250μm squared, AuBi absorbers. We designed and fabricated devices with different contact geometries between the absorber and the TES to optimise the detector performance and with diff…
▽ More
We are develo** transition-edge sensor (TES)-based microcalorimeters for the X-ray Integral Field Unit (XIFU) of the future European X-Ray Observatory Athena. The microcalorimeters are based on TiAu TESs coupled to 250μm squared, AuBi absorbers. We designed and fabricated devices with different contact geometries between the absorber and the TES to optimise the detector performance and with different wiring topology to mitigate the self-magnetic field. The design is tailored to optimise the performance under Frequency Domain Multiplexing. In this paper we review the main design feature of the pixels array and we report on the performance of the 18 channels, 2-5MHz frequency domain multiplexer that will be used to characterised the detector array.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Josephson effects in an alternating current biased transition edge sensor
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi,
Alex Kozorezov,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Jan van der Kuur,
Marcel P. Bruijn,
Roland H. den Hartog,
Richard Hijmering,
Pourya Khosropanah,
Colin Lambert,
Anton. J. van der Linden,
Marcel L. Ridder,
Toyo Suzuki,
Jan R. Gao
Abstract:
We report the experimental evidence of the ac Josephson effect in a transition edge sensor (TES) operating in a frequency domain multiplexer and biased by ac voltage at MHz frequencies. The effect is observed by measuring the non-linear impedance of the sensor. The TES is treated as a weakly linked superconducting system and within the resistively shunted junction model framework. We provide a ful…
▽ More
We report the experimental evidence of the ac Josephson effect in a transition edge sensor (TES) operating in a frequency domain multiplexer and biased by ac voltage at MHz frequencies. The effect is observed by measuring the non-linear impedance of the sensor. The TES is treated as a weakly linked superconducting system and within the resistively shunted junction model framework. We provide a full theoretical explanation of the results by finding the analytic solution of the non-inertial Langevian equation of the system and calculating the non-linear response of the detector to a large ac bias current in the presence of noise.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Multiplexed readout demonstration of a TES-based detector array in a resistance locked loop
Authors:
Jan van der Kuur,
Luciano Gottardi,
Mikko Kiviranta,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Pourya Khosropanah,
Roland den Hartog,
Toyoaki Suzuki,
Brian Jackson
Abstract:
TES-based bolometer and microcalorimeter arrays with thousands of pixels are under development for several space-based and ground-based applications. A linear detector response and low levels of cross talk facilitate the calibration of the instruments. In an effort to improve the properties of TES-based detectors, fixing the TES resistance in a resistance-locked loop (RLL) under optical loading ha…
▽ More
TES-based bolometer and microcalorimeter arrays with thousands of pixels are under development for several space-based and ground-based applications. A linear detector response and low levels of cross talk facilitate the calibration of the instruments. In an effort to improve the properties of TES-based detectors, fixing the TES resistance in a resistance-locked loop (RLL) under optical loading has recently been proposed. Earlier theoretical work on this mode of operation has shown that the detector speed, linearity and dynamic range should improve with respect to voltage biased operation.
This paper presents an experimental demonstration of multiplexed readout in this mode of operation in a TES-based detector array with noise equivalent power values (NEP) of $3.5\cdot 10^{-19} $W/$\sqrt{\mathrm{Hz}}$. The measured noise and dynamic properties of the detector in the RLL will be compared with the earlier modelling work. Furthermore, the practical implementation routes for future FDM systems for the readout of bolometer and microcalorimeter arrays will be discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: The X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) for Athena+
Authors:
D. Barret,
J. W. den Herder,
L. Piro,
L. Ravera,
R. Den Hartog,
C. Macculi,
X. Barcons,
M. Page,
S. Paltani,
G. Rauw,
J. Wilms,
M. Ceballos,
L. Duband,
L. Gottardi,
S. Lotti,
J. de Plaa,
E. Pointecouteau,
C. Schmid,
H. Akamatsu,
D. Bagliani,
S. Bandler,
M. Barbera,
P. Bastia,
M. Biasotti,
M. Branco
, et al. (33 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Athena+ mission concept is designed to implement the Hot and Energetic Universe science theme submitted to the European Space Agency in response to the call for White Papers for the definition of the L2 and L3 missions of its science program. The Athena+ science payload consists of a large aperture high angular resolution X-ray optics and twelve meters away, two interchangeable focal plane ins…
▽ More
The Athena+ mission concept is designed to implement the Hot and Energetic Universe science theme submitted to the European Space Agency in response to the call for White Papers for the definition of the L2 and L3 missions of its science program. The Athena+ science payload consists of a large aperture high angular resolution X-ray optics and twelve meters away, two interchangeable focal plane instruments: the X-ray Integral Field Unit (X-IFU) and the Wide Field Imager (WFI). The X-IFU is a cryogenic X-ray spectrometer, based on a large array of Transition Edge Sensors (TES), offering 2.5 eV spectral resolution, with ~5" pixels, over a field of view of 5 arc minutes in diameter. In this paper, we briefly describe the Athena+ mission concept and the X-IFU performance requirements. We then present the X-IFU detector and readout electronics principles, the current design of the focal plane assembly, the cooling chain and review the global architecture design. Finally, we describe the current performance estimates, in terms of effective area, particle background rejection, count rate capability and velocity measurements. Finally, we emphasize on the latest technology developments concerning TES array fabrication, spectral resolution and readout performance achieved to show that significant progresses are being accomplished towards the demanding X-IFU requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Sensitivity of the spherical gravitational wave detector MiniGRAIL operating at 5 K
Authors:
L. Gottardi,
A. de Waard,
A. Usenko,
G. Frossati,
M. Podt,
J. Flokstra,
M. Bassan,
V. Fafone,
Y. Minenkov,
A. Rocchi
Abstract:
We present the performances and the strain sensitivity of the first spherical gravitational wave detector equipped with a capacitive transducer and read out by a low noise two-stage SQUID amplifier and operated at a temperature of 5 K. We characterized the detector performance in terms of thermal and electrical noise in the system output sygnal. We measured a peak strain sensitivity of…
▽ More
We present the performances and the strain sensitivity of the first spherical gravitational wave detector equipped with a capacitive transducer and read out by a low noise two-stage SQUID amplifier and operated at a temperature of 5 K. We characterized the detector performance in terms of thermal and electrical noise in the system output sygnal. We measured a peak strain sensitivity of $1.5\cdot 10^{-20} Hz^{-1/2}$ at 2942.9 Hz. A strain sensitivity of better than $5\cdot 10{-20}Hz{-1/2}$ has been obtained over a bandwidth of 30 Hz. We expect an improvement of more than one order of magnitude when the detector will operate at 50 mK. Our results represent the first step towards the development of an ultracryogenic omnidirectional detector sensitive to gravitational radiation in the 3kHz range.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
On the Sensitivity of a Hollow Sphere as a Multi-modal Resonant Gravitational Wave Detector
Authors:
Florian Dubath,
Jerome Extermann,
Luciano Gottardi
Abstract:
We present a numerical analysis to simulate the response of a spherical resonant gravitational wave detector and to compute its sensitivity. Under the assump- tion of optimal filtering, we work out the sensitivity curve for a sphere first taking into account only a single transducer, and then using a coherent analysis of the whole set of transducers.
We present a numerical analysis to simulate the response of a spherical resonant gravitational wave detector and to compute its sensitivity. Under the assump- tion of optimal filtering, we work out the sensitivity curve for a sphere first taking into account only a single transducer, and then using a coherent analysis of the whole set of transducers.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2007; v1 submitted 23 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
-
Complete model of a spherical gravitational wave detector with capacitive transducers. Calibration and sensitivity optimization
Authors:
Luciano Gottardi
Abstract:
We report the results of a detailed numerical analysis of a real resonant spherical gravitational wave antenna operating with six resonant two-mode capacitive transducers read out by superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUID) amplifiers. We derive a set of equations to describe the electro-mechanical dynamics of the detector. The model takes into account the effect of all the noise sou…
▽ More
We report the results of a detailed numerical analysis of a real resonant spherical gravitational wave antenna operating with six resonant two-mode capacitive transducers read out by superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUID) amplifiers. We derive a set of equations to describe the electro-mechanical dynamics of the detector. The model takes into account the effect of all the noise sources present in each transducer chain: the thermal noise associated with the mechanical resonators, the thermal noise from the superconducting impedance matching transformer, the back-action noise and the additive current noise of the SQUID amplifier. Asymmetries in the detector signal-to-noise ratio and bandwidth, coming from considering the transducers not as point-like objects but as sensor with physically defined geometry and dimension, are also investigated. We calculate the sensitivity for an ultracryogenic, 30 ton, 2 meter in diameter, spherical detector with optimal and non-optimal impedance matching of the electrical read-out scheme to the mechanical modes. The results of the analysis is useful not only to optimize existing smaller mass spherical detector like MiniGrail, in Leiden, but also as a technological guideline for future massive detectors. Furthermore we calculate the antenna patterns when the sphere operates with one, three and six resonators. The sky coverage for two detectors based in The Netherlands and Brasil and operating in coincidence is also estimated. Finally, we describe and numerically verify a calibration and filtering procedure useful for diagnostic and detection purposes in analogy with existing resonant bar detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2007; v1 submitted 20 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.