-
Water lifting and outflow gain of kinetic energy in tropical cyclones
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Alexander V. Chikunov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio Donato Nobre,
Paulo Nobre,
Günter Plunien,
Ruben D. Molina
Abstract:
While water lifting plays a recognized role in the global atmospheric power budget, estimates for this role in tropical cyclones vary from no effect to a major reduction in storm intensity. To better assess this impact, here we consider the work output of an infinitely narrow thermodynamic cycle with two streamlines connecting the top of the boundary layer in the vicinity of maximum wind (without…
▽ More
While water lifting plays a recognized role in the global atmospheric power budget, estimates for this role in tropical cyclones vary from no effect to a major reduction in storm intensity. To better assess this impact, here we consider the work output of an infinitely narrow thermodynamic cycle with two streamlines connecting the top of the boundary layer in the vicinity of maximum wind (without assuming gradient-wind balance) to an arbitrary level in the inviscid free troposphere. The reduction of a storm's maximum wind speed due to water lifting is found to decline with increasing efficiency of the cycle and is about 5% for maximum observed Carnot efficiencies. In the steady-state cycle, there is an extra heat input associated with the warming of precipitating water. The corresponding positive extra work is of an opposite sign and several times smaller than that due to water lifting. We also estimate the gain of kinetic energy in the outflow region. Contrary to previous assessments, this term is found to be large when the outflow radius is small (comparable to the radius of maximum wind). Using our framework, we show that Emanuel's maximum potential intensity (E-PI) corresponds to a cycle where total work equals work performed at the top of the boundary layer (net work in the free troposphere is zero). This constrains a dependence between the outflow temperature and heat input at the point of maximum wind, but does not constrain the radial pressure gradient. We outline the implications of the established patterns for assessing real storms.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2021; v1 submitted 23 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Hurricane's maximum potential intensity and surface heat fluxes
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Alexander V. Chikunov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio Donato Nobre,
Paulo Nobre,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
Emanuel's concept of Maximum Potential Intensity (E-PI) relates the maximum velocity $V_{\rm max}$ of tropical storms, assumed to be in gradient wind balance, to environmental parameters. Several studies suggested that the unbalanced flow is responsible for E-PI sometimes significantly underpredicting $V_{\rm max}$. Additionally, two major modifications generated a considerable range of E-PI predi…
▽ More
Emanuel's concept of Maximum Potential Intensity (E-PI) relates the maximum velocity $V_{\rm max}$ of tropical storms, assumed to be in gradient wind balance, to environmental parameters. Several studies suggested that the unbalanced flow is responsible for E-PI sometimes significantly underpredicting $V_{\rm max}$. Additionally, two major modifications generated a considerable range of E-PI predictions: the dissipative heating and the power expended to lift water were respectively suggested to increase and reduce E-PI $V_{\rm max}$ by about 20%. Here we re-derive the E-PI concept separating its dynamic and thermodynamic assumptions and lifting the gradient wind balance limitation. Our analysis reveals that E-PI formulations for a balanced and a radially unbalanced flow are similar, while the systematic underestimate of $V_{\rm max}$ reflects instead an incompatibility between several E-PI assumptions. We discuss how these assumptions can be modified. We further show that irrespective of whether dissipative heating occurs or not, E-PI uniquely relates $V_{\rm max}$ to the latent heat flux (not to the total oceanic heat flux as originally proposed). We clarify that, in contrast to previous suggestions, lifting water has little impact on E-PI. We demonstrate that in E-PI the negative work of the pressure gradient in the upper atmosphere consumes all the kinetic energy generated in the boundary layer. This key dynamic constraint is independent of other E-PI assumptions and thus can apply to diverse circulation patterns. Finally, we show that the E-PI maximum kinetic energy per unit volume equals the local partial pressure of water vapor and discuss the implications of this finding for predicting $V_{\rm max}$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2019; v1 submitted 29 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Comments on "Is condensation-induced atmospheric dynamics a new theory of the origin of the winds?" by Jaramillo et al. (2018)
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Antonio Donato Nobre,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Douglas Sheil,
Paulo Nobre,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
Our comments on paper "Is Condensation-Induced Atmospheric Dynamics a New Theory of the Origin of the Winds?" by A. Jaramillo, O. J. Mesa, and D. J. Raymond published in J. Atmos. Sci. 75, 3305 (2018).
Our comments on paper "Is Condensation-Induced Atmospheric Dynamics a New Theory of the Origin of the Winds?" by A. Jaramillo, O. J. Mesa, and D. J. Raymond published in J. Atmos. Sci. 75, 3305 (2018).
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Hurricane's Maximum Potential Intensity and the Gravitational Power of Precipitation
Authors:
A. M. Makarieva,
V. G. Gorshkov,
A. V. Nefiodov,
A. V. Chikunov,
D. Sheil,
A. D. Nobre,
B. -L. Li
Abstract:
The concept of Maximum Potential Intensity (MPI) is widely used in tropical cyclone research to estimate the minimum central pressure and the maximum velocity of tropical storms from environmental parameters. The MPI pressure derives from consideration of an idealized thermodynamic cycle, while the MPI velocity additionally requires information about real-time power and heat flows within the storm…
▽ More
The concept of Maximum Potential Intensity (MPI) is widely used in tropical cyclone research to estimate the minimum central pressure and the maximum velocity of tropical storms from environmental parameters. The MPI pressure derives from consideration of an idealized thermodynamic cycle, while the MPI velocity additionally requires information about real-time power and heat flows within the storm. Recently MPI velocity was proposed to be a substantial overestimate (by 10-30 percent) presumably neglecting the power needed to lift precipitating water (the gravitational power of precipitation). This conclusion did not involve a theoretical analysis of the MPI concept but was based on observed hurricane rainfall to estimate gravitational power of precipitation. However, since the MPI pressure estimate does explicitly account for lifting water, and the MPI velocity derives from this pressure, the question arises whether a correction to MPI velocity is required. Here we represent and examine the MPI derivations in their most general form and show that although a correction to MPI velocity is justified, it is an order of magnitude or so smaller than originally proposed. We show that the neglect of gravitational power of precipitation in the MPI velocity estimate was caused by the incomplete formulation of the general relationship between pressure work and dissipation of kinetic energy, taken per unit time and integrated over the storm. We highlight the importance of an internally consistent framework to estimate both storm energy and power and provide some perspectives for further investigating the role of moisture.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
The water budget of a hurricane as dependent on its movement
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Alexander V. Chikunov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio D. Nobre,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
Despite the dangers associated with tropical cyclones and their rainfall, the origins of storm moisture remains unclear. Existing studies have focused on the region 40-400 km from the cyclone center. It is known that the rainfall within this area cannot be explained by local processes alone but requires imported moisture. Nonetheless, the dynamics of this imported moisture appears unknown. Here, c…
▽ More
Despite the dangers associated with tropical cyclones and their rainfall, the origins of storm moisture remains unclear. Existing studies have focused on the region 40-400 km from the cyclone center. It is known that the rainfall within this area cannot be explained by local processes alone but requires imported moisture. Nonetheless, the dynamics of this imported moisture appears unknown. Here, considering a region up to three thousand kilometers from storm center, we analyze precipitation, atmospheric moisture and movement velocities for North Atlantic hurricanes. Our findings indicate that even over such large areas a hurricane's rainfall cannot be accounted for by concurrent evaporation. We propose instead that a hurricane consumes pre-existing atmospheric water vapor as it moves. The propagation velocity of the cyclone, i.e. the difference between its movement velocity and the mean velocity of the surrounding air (steering flow), determines the water vapor budget. Water vapor available to the hurricane through its movement makes the hurricane self-sufficient at about 700 km from the hurricane center obviating the need to concentrate moisture from greater distances. Such hurricanes leave a dry wake, whereby rainfall is suppressed by up to 40 per cent compared to its long-term mean. The inner radius of this dry footprint approximately coincides with the radius of hurricane self-sufficiency with respect to water vapor. We discuss how Carnot efficiency considerations do not constrain the power of such open systems that deplete the pre-existing moisture. Our findings emphasize the incompletely understood role and importance of atmospheric moisture supplies, condensation and precipitation in hurricane dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2016; v1 submitted 18 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Quantifying the global atmospheric power budget
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio Donato Nobre,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
The power of atmospheric circulation is a key measure of the Earth's climate system. The mismatch between predictions and observations under a warming climate calls for a reassessment of how atmospheric power $W$ is defined, estimated and constrained. Here we review published formulations for $W$ and show how they differ when applied to a moist atmosphere. Three factors, a non-zero source/sink in…
▽ More
The power of atmospheric circulation is a key measure of the Earth's climate system. The mismatch between predictions and observations under a warming climate calls for a reassessment of how atmospheric power $W$ is defined, estimated and constrained. Here we review published formulations for $W$ and show how they differ when applied to a moist atmosphere. Three factors, a non-zero source/sink in the continuity equation, the difference between velocities of gaseous air and condensate, and interaction between the gas and condensate modifying the equations of motion, affect the formulation of $W$. Starting from the thermodynamic definition of mechanical work, we derive an expression for $W$ from an explicit consideration of the equations of motion and continuity. Our analyses clarify how some past formulations are incomplete or invalid. Three caveats are identified. First, $W$ critically depends on the boundary condition for gaseous air velocity at the Earth's surface. Second, confusion between gaseous air velocity and mean velocity of air and condensate in the expression for $W$ results in gross errors despite the observed magnitudes of these velocities are very close. Third, $W$ expressed in terms of measurable atmospheric parameters, air pressure and velocity, is scale-specific; this must be taken into account when adding contributions to $W$ from different processes. We present a formulation of the atmospheric power budget, which distinguishes three components of $W$: the kinetic power associated with horizontal pressure gradients ($W_K$), the gravitational power of precipitation ($W_P$) and the condensate loading ($W_c$). We use MERRA and NCAR/NCEP re-analyses to evaluate the atmospheric power budget at different scales: $W_K$ increases with temporal resolution approaching our theoretical estimate for condensation-induced circulation when all convective motion is resolved.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2017; v1 submitted 11 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Reassessing thermodynamic and dynamic constraints on global wind power
Authors:
A. M. Makarieva,
V. G. Gorshkov,
A. V. Nefiodov,
D. Sheil,
A. D. Nobre,
B. -L. Li
Abstract:
Starting from basic physical principles, we present a novel derivation linking the global wind power to measurable atmospheric parameters. The resulting expression distinguishes three components of the atmospheric power (the kinetic power associated with horizontal and vertical motion and the gravitational power of precipitation) and highlights problems with previous approaches. Focusing on Lalibe…
▽ More
Starting from basic physical principles, we present a novel derivation linking the global wind power to measurable atmospheric parameters. The resulting expression distinguishes three components of the atmospheric power (the kinetic power associated with horizontal and vertical motion and the gravitational power of precipitation) and highlights problems with previous approaches. Focusing on Laliberté et al. (2015), we show how inappropriate treatment of material derivatives in the presence of phase transitions leads to significant errors in wind power analyses. We discuss the physical constraints on global wind power and the opportunities provided by considering the dynamic effects of water vapor condensation.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2015; v1 submitted 18 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Heat engines and heat pumps in a hydrostatic atmosphere: How surface pressure and temperature constrain wind power output and circulation cell size
Authors:
A. M. Makarieva,
V. G. Gorshkov,
A. V. Nefiodov,
D. Sheil,
A. D. Nobre,
P. L. Shearman,
B. -L. Li
Abstract:
The kinetic energy budget of the atmosphere's meridional circulation cells is analytically assessed. In the upper atmosphere kinetic energy generation grows with increasing surface temperature difference \$ΔT_s\$ between the cold and warm ends of a circulation cell; in the lower atmosphere it declines. A requirement that kinetic energy generation is positive in the lower atmosphere limits the pole…
▽ More
The kinetic energy budget of the atmosphere's meridional circulation cells is analytically assessed. In the upper atmosphere kinetic energy generation grows with increasing surface temperature difference \$ΔT_s\$ between the cold and warm ends of a circulation cell; in the lower atmosphere it declines. A requirement that kinetic energy generation is positive in the lower atmosphere limits the poleward cell extension \$L\$ of Hadley cells via a relationship between \$ΔT_s\$ and surface pressure difference \$Δp_s\$: an upper limit exists when \$Δp_s\$ does not grow with increasing \$ΔT_s\$. This pattern is demonstrated here using monthly data from MERRA re-analysis. Kinetic energy generation along air streamlines in the boundary layer does not exceed \$40\$~J~mol\$^{-1}\$; it declines with growing \$L\$ and reaches zero for the largest observed \$L\$ at 2~km height. The limited meridional cell size necessitates the appearance of heat pumps -- circulation cells with negative work output where the low-level air moves towards colder areas. These cells consume the positive work output of the heat engines -- cells where the low-level air moves towards the warmer areas -- and can in theory drive the global efficiency of atmospheric circulation down to zero. Relative contributions of \$Δp_s\$ and \$ΔT_s\$ to kinetic energy generation are evaluated: \$ΔT_s\$ dominates in the upper atmosphere, while \$Δp_s\$ dominates in the lower. Analysis and empirical evidence indicate that the net kinetic power output on Earth is dominated by surface pressure gradients, with minor net kinetic energy generation in the upper atmosphere. The role of condensation in generating surface pressure gradients is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2016; v1 submitted 11 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Comment on "The Tropospheric Land-Sea Warming Contrast as the Driver of Tropical Sea Level Pressure Changes" by Bayr and Dommenget
Authors:
A. M. Makarieva,
V. G. Gorshkov,
A. V. Nefiodov,
D. Sheil,
A. D. Nobre,
B. -L. Li
Abstract:
T Bayr and D Dommenget [J. Climate 26 (2013) 1387] proposed a model of temperature-driven air redistribution to quantify the ratio between changes of sea level pressure $p_s$ and mean tropospheric temperature $T_a$ in the tropics. This model assumes that the height of the tropical troposphere is isobaric. Here problems with this model are identified. A revised relationship between $p_s$ and $T_a$…
▽ More
T Bayr and D Dommenget [J. Climate 26 (2013) 1387] proposed a model of temperature-driven air redistribution to quantify the ratio between changes of sea level pressure $p_s$ and mean tropospheric temperature $T_a$ in the tropics. This model assumes that the height of the tropical troposphere is isobaric. Here problems with this model are identified. A revised relationship between $p_s$ and $T_a$ is derived governed by two parameters -- the isobaric and isothermal heights -- rather than just one. Further insight is provided by the model of R S Lindzen and S Nigam [J. Atmos. Sci. 44 (1987) 2418], which was the first to use the concept of isobaric height to relate tropical $p_s$ to air temperature, and did this by assuming that isobaric height is always around 3 km and isothermal height is likewise near constant. Observational data, presented here, show that neither of these heights is spatially universal nor do their mean values match previous assumptions. Analyses show that the ratio of the long-term changes in $p_s$ and $T_a$ associated with land-sea temperature contrasts in a warming climate -- the focus of Bayr and Dommenget [2013] -- is in fact determined by the corresponding ratio of spatial differences in the annual mean $p_s$ and $T_a$. The latter ratio, reflecting lower pressure at higher temperature in the tropics, is dominated by meridional pressure and temperature differences rather than by land-sea contrasts. Considerations of isobaric heights are shown to be unable to predict either spatial or temporal variation in $p_s$. As noted by Bayr and Dommenget [2013], the role of moisture dynamics in generating sea level pressure variation remains in need of further theoretical investigations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Spatiotemporal relationships between sea level pressure and air temperature in the tropics
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio Donato Nobre,
Bai-Lian Larry Li
Abstract:
While surface temperature gradients have been highlighted as drivers of low-level atmospheric circulation, the underlying physical mechanisms remain unclear. Lindzen and Nigam (1987) noted that sea level pressure (SLP) gradients are proportional to surface temperature gradients if isobaric height (the height where pressure does not vary in the horizontal plane) is constant; their own model of low-…
▽ More
While surface temperature gradients have been highlighted as drivers of low-level atmospheric circulation, the underlying physical mechanisms remain unclear. Lindzen and Nigam (1987) noted that sea level pressure (SLP) gradients are proportional to surface temperature gradients if isobaric height (the height where pressure does not vary in the horizontal plane) is constant; their own model of low-level circulation assumed that isobaric height in the tropics is around 3 km. Recently Bayr and Dommenget (2013) proposed a simple model of temperature-driven air redistribution from which they derived that the isobaric height in the tropics again varies little but occurs higher (at the height of the troposphere). Here investigations show that neither the empirical assumption of Lindzen and Nigam (1987) nor the theoretical derivations of Bayr and Dommenget (2013) are plausible. Observations show that isobaric height is too variable to determine a universal spatial or temporal relationship between local values of air temperature and SLP. Since isobaric height cannot be determined from independent considerations, the relationship between SLP and temperature is not evidence that differential heating drives low-level circulation. An alternative theory suggests SLP gradients are determined by the condensation of water vapor as moist air converges towards the equator. This theory quantifies the meridional SLP differences observed by season across the Hadley cells reasonably well. Higher temperature of surface air where SLP is low may be determined by equatorward transport and release of latent heat below the trade wind inversion layer. The relationship between atmospheric circulation and moisture dynamics merits further investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Examining the physical principles behind the motion of moist air: Which expressions are sound?
Authors:
A. M. Makarieva,
V. G. Gorshkov,
A. V. Nefiodov,
D. Sheil,
A. D. Nobre,
P. Bunyard,
B. -L. Li
Abstract:
The physical equations determining the motion of moist atmospheric air in the presence of condensation remain controversial. Two distinct formulations have been proposed, published and cited. The equation of Bannon [2002, J. Atmos. Sci. 59: 1967--1982] includes a term for a "reactive motion" that arises when water vapor condenses and droplets begin to fall; according to this term the remaining gas…
▽ More
The physical equations determining the motion of moist atmospheric air in the presence of condensation remain controversial. Two distinct formulations have been proposed, published and cited. The equation of Bannon [2002, J. Atmos. Sci. 59: 1967--1982] includes a term for a "reactive motion" that arises when water vapor condenses and droplets begin to fall; according to this term the remaining gas moves upwards so as to conserve momentum. In the equation of Ooyama[2001, J. Atmos. Sci. 58: 2073--2102] the reactive motion term is absent. Both equations contain a term for condensate loading, but in the formulation of Ooyama [2001] there are two additional terms. In some modern nonhydrostatic models of moist atmospheric circulation, however, formulations have been mixed. Here we examine the contrasting equations for the motion of moist air. We discuss inconsistencies in the application of Newton's second and third laws to an air and condensate mixture. We show that the concept of reactive motion in this context is based on a misunderstanding of the conservation of momentum in the presence of a gravitational field: such a reactive motion does not exist. We show that the "mixed" equation used in some models is not physically consistent either. We examine why consideration of total momentum, that is air and condensate combined, has been misleading in the search for valid equations of motion in the presence of phase transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Why does air passage over forest yield more rain? Examining the coupling between rainfall, pressure and atmospheric moisture content
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio D. Nobre,
Peter Bunyard,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
The influence of forest loss on rainfall remains poorly understood. Addressing this challenge Spracklen et al. recently presented a pan-tropical study of rainfall and land-cover that showed that satellite-derived rainfall measures were positively correlated with the degree to which model-derived air trajectories had been exposed to forest cover. This result confirms the influence of vegetation on…
▽ More
The influence of forest loss on rainfall remains poorly understood. Addressing this challenge Spracklen et al. recently presented a pan-tropical study of rainfall and land-cover that showed that satellite-derived rainfall measures were positively correlated with the degree to which model-derived air trajectories had been exposed to forest cover. This result confirms the influence of vegetation on regional rainfall patterns suggested in previous studies. However, we find that the conclusion of Spracklen et al. -- that differences in rainfall reflect air moisture content resulting from evapotranspiration while the circulation pattern remains unchanged -- appears undermined by methodological inconsistencies. We identify methodological problems with the underlying analyses and the quantitative estimates for rainfall change predicted if forest cover is lost in the Amazon. We discuss some alternative explanations that include the distinct role of forest evapotranspiration in creating low pressure systems that draw moisture from the oceans to the continental hinterland. Our analysis of meteorological data from three regions in Brazil, including the central Amazon forest, reveal a tendency for rainy days during the wet season with column water vapor (CWV) exceeding 50 mm to have higher pressure than rainless days; while at lower CWV rainy days tend to have lower pressure than rainless days. The coupling between atmospheric moisture content and circulation dynamics underlines that the danger posed by forest loss is greater than suggested by focusing only on moisture recycling alone.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2013; v1 submitted 14 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
The equations of motion for moist atmospheric air
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio D. Nobre,
Peter Bunyard,
Paulo Nobre,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
How phase transitions affect the motion of moist atmospheric air remains controversial. In the early 2000s two distinct differential equations of motion were proposed. Besides their contrasting formulations for the acceleration of condensate, the equations differ concerning the presence/absence of a term equal to the rate of phase transitions multiplied by the difference in velocity between conden…
▽ More
How phase transitions affect the motion of moist atmospheric air remains controversial. In the early 2000s two distinct differential equations of motion were proposed. Besides their contrasting formulations for the acceleration of condensate, the equations differ concerning the presence/absence of a term equal to the rate of phase transitions multiplied by the difference in velocity between condensate and air. This term was interpreted in the literature as the "reactive motion" associated with condensation. The reasoning behind this "reactive motion" was that when water vapor condenses and droplets begin to fall the remaining gas must move upwards to conserve momentum. Here we show that the two contrasting formulations imply distinct assumptions about how gaseous air and condensate particles interact. We show that these assumptions cannot be simultaneously applicable to condensation and evaporation. "Reactive motion" leading to an upward acceleration of air during condensation does not exist. The "reactive motion" term can be justified for evaporation only; it describes the downward acceleration of air. We emphasize the difference between the equations of motion (i.e., equations constraining velocity) and those constraining momentum (i.e., equations of motion and continuity combined). We show that, owing to the imprecise nature of the continuity equations, consideration of total momentum can be misleading and that this led to the "reactive motion" controversy. Finally, we provide a revised and generally applicable equation for the motion of moist air.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2017; v1 submitted 13 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
The key physical parameters governing frictional dissipation in a precipitating atmosphere
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov,
Douglas Sheil,
Antonio Nobre,
Peter Bunyard,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
Precipitation generates small-scale turbulent air flows the energy of which ultimately dissipates to heat. The power of this process has previously been estimated to be around 2-4 W m-2 in the tropics: a value comparable in magnitude to the dynamic power of the global circulation. Here we suggest that this previous power estimate is approximately double the true figure. Our result reflects a revis…
▽ More
Precipitation generates small-scale turbulent air flows the energy of which ultimately dissipates to heat. The power of this process has previously been estimated to be around 2-4 W m-2 in the tropics: a value comparable in magnitude to the dynamic power of the global circulation. Here we suggest that this previous power estimate is approximately double the true figure. Our result reflects a revised evaluation of the mean precipitation path length Hp. We investigate the dependence of Hp on surface temperature,relative humidity,temperature lapse rate and degree of condensation in the ascending air. We find that the degree of condensation,defined as the relative change of the saturated water vapor mixing ratio in the region of condensation, is a major factor determining Hp. We estimate from theory that the mean large-scale rate of frictional dissipation associated with total precipitation in the tropics lies between 1 and 2 W m-2 and show that our estimate is supported by empirical evidence. We show that under terrestrial conditions frictional dissipation constitutes a minor fraction of the dynamic power of condensation-induced atmospheric circulation,which is estimated to be at least 2.5 times larger. However,because Hp increases with surface temperature Ts, the rate of frictional dissipation would exceed that of condensation-induced dynamics, and thus block major circulation, at Ts >~320 K in a moist adiabatic atmosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2012; v1 submitted 18 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Condensation of water vapor in the gravitational field
Authors:
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Andrei V. Nefiodov
Abstract:
Physical peculiarities of water vapor condensation under conditions of hydrostatic equilibrium are considered. The power of stationary dynamic air fluxes and the vertical temperature distribution caused by condensation on large horizontal scales are estimated.
Physical peculiarities of water vapor condensation under conditions of hydrostatic equilibrium are considered. The power of stationary dynamic air fluxes and the vertical temperature distribution caused by condensation on large horizontal scales are estimated.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Condensational theory of stationary tornadoes
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Andrei V. Nefiodov
Abstract:
Using the Bernoulli integral for air streamline with condensing water vapor a stationary axisymmetric tornado circulation is described. The obtained profiles of vertical, radial and tangential velocities are in agreement with observations for the Mulhall tornado, world's largest on record and longest-lived among the three tornadoes for which 3D velocity data are available. Maximum possible vortex…
▽ More
Using the Bernoulli integral for air streamline with condensing water vapor a stationary axisymmetric tornado circulation is described. The obtained profiles of vertical, radial and tangential velocities are in agreement with observations for the Mulhall tornado, world's largest on record and longest-lived among the three tornadoes for which 3D velocity data are available. Maximum possible vortex velocities are estimated.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
On the nature of intraspecific genetic variability: Evidence against the ruling paradigm
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov
Abstract:
Empirical evidence is presented which contradicts the established interpretation of the intraspecific genetic variability as the adaptive potential of the species: the uniform evolutionary tempo across the life kingdom, species discreteness, and absence of correlation between genetic variability and prosperity of extant species testify against the ruling paradigm. Consistent interpretation of the…
▽ More
Empirical evidence is presented which contradicts the established interpretation of the intraspecific genetic variability as the adaptive potential of the species: the uniform evolutionary tempo across the life kingdom, species discreteness, and absence of correlation between genetic variability and prosperity of extant species testify against the ruling paradigm. Consistent interpretation of the nature of intraspecific genetic variability is based on recognizing the limited sensitivity of stabilising selection, which allows for accumulation and persistence in the population of a considerable amount of mutational substitutions, which, to some degree, erase the meaningful genetic information of the species. The proposed interpretation also provides solution to the inbreeding paradox in the invasive species.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Comprehending environmental and economic sustainability: Comparative analysis of stability principles in the biosphere and free market economy
Authors:
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Bai-Lian Li
Abstract:
Using the formalism of Lyapunov potential function it is shown that the stability principles for biomass in the ecosystem and for employment in economics are mathematically similar. The ecosystem is found to have a stable and an unstable stationary state with high (forest) and low (grasslands) biomass, respectively. In economics, there is a stable stationary state with high employment, which corre…
▽ More
Using the formalism of Lyapunov potential function it is shown that the stability principles for biomass in the ecosystem and for employment in economics are mathematically similar. The ecosystem is found to have a stable and an unstable stationary state with high (forest) and low (grasslands) biomass, respectively. In economics, there is a stable stationary state with high employment, which corresponds to mass production of conventional goods sold at low cost price, and an unstable stationary state with lower employment, which corresponds to production of novel goods appearing in the course of technological progress. An additional stable stationary state is described for economics, the one corresponding to very low employment in production of life essentials such as energy and raw materials. In this state the civilization currently pays 10% of global GDP for energy produced by a negligible minority of the working population (currently ~0.2%) and sold at prices greatly exceeding the cost price by 40 times. It is shown that economic ownership over energy sources is equivalent to equating measurable variables of different dimensions (stores and fluxes), which leads to effective violation of the laws of energy and matter conservation.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Reply to comment of Bister and co-authors on the critique of the dissipative heat engine
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov,
Bai-Lian Li,
Antonio Donato Nobre
Abstract:
The dissipative heat engine (DHE) is based on a Carnot cycle with external heat Qin received at temperature Ts and released at To < Ts. In contrast to the classical Carnot engine, mechanical work Ad in the DHE is not exported to external environment but dissipates to heat within the engine. Makarieva et al. (2010, hereafter MGLN) asserted that the laws of thermodynamics prohibit an increase of Ad…
▽ More
The dissipative heat engine (DHE) is based on a Carnot cycle with external heat Qin received at temperature Ts and released at To < Ts. In contrast to the classical Carnot engine, mechanical work Ad in the DHE is not exported to external environment but dissipates to heat within the engine. Makarieva et al. (2010, hereafter MGLN) asserted that the laws of thermodynamics prohibit an increase of Ad beyond the Carnot limit: Ad <= epsilon Qin, epsilon = (Ts - To)/Ts. Bister et al. (2010, hereafter BRPE) counterargued that such an increase is possible and that hurricanes can be viewed as a natural DHE. Here we show that the arguments of BRPE are not consistent with the energy conservation law and thus do not refute MGLN's claims.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Where do winds come from? A new theory on how water vapor condensation influences atmospheric pressure and dynamics
Authors:
A. M. Makarieva,
V. G. Gorshkov,
D. Sheil,
A. D. Nobre,
B. -L. Li
Abstract:
Phase transitions of atmospheric water play a ubiquitous role in the Earth's climate system, but their direct impact on atmospheric dynamics has escaped wide attention. Here we examine and advance a theory as to how condensation influences atmospheric pressure through the mass removal of water from the gas phase with a simultaneous account of the latent heat release. Building from the fundamental…
▽ More
Phase transitions of atmospheric water play a ubiquitous role in the Earth's climate system, but their direct impact on atmospheric dynamics has escaped wide attention. Here we examine and advance a theory as to how condensation influences atmospheric pressure through the mass removal of water from the gas phase with a simultaneous account of the latent heat release. Building from the fundamental physical principles we show that condensation is associated with a decline in air pressure in the lower atmosphere. This decline occurs up to a certain height, which ranges from 3 to 4 km for surface temperatures from 10 to 30 deg C. We then estimate the horizontal pressure differences associated with water vapor condensation and find that these are comparable in magnitude with the pressure differences driving observed circulation patterns. The water vapor delivered to the atmosphere via evaporation represents a store of potential energy available to accelerate air and thus drive winds. Our estimates suggest that the global mean power at which this potential energy is released by condensation is around one per cent of the global solar power -- this is similar to the known stationary dissipative power of general atmospheric circulation. We conclude that condensation and evaporation merit attention as major, if previously overlooked, factors in driving atmospheric dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Potential energy of atmospheric water vapor and the air motions induced by water vapor condensation on different spatial scales
Authors:
Anastassia M. Makarieva,
Victor G. Gorshkov
Abstract:
Basic physical principles are considered that are responsible for the origin of dynamic air flow upon condensation of water vapor, the partial pressure of which represents a store of potential energy in the atmosphere of Earth. Quantitative characteristics of such flow are presented for several spatial scales. It is shown that maximum condensation-induced velocities reach 160 m/s and are realized…
▽ More
Basic physical principles are considered that are responsible for the origin of dynamic air flow upon condensation of water vapor, the partial pressure of which represents a store of potential energy in the atmosphere of Earth. Quantitative characteristics of such flow are presented for several spatial scales. It is shown that maximum condensation-induced velocities reach 160 m/s and are realized in compact circulation patterns like tornadoes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Dissipative heat engine is thermodynamically inconsistent
Authors:
A. M. Makarieva,
V. G. Gorshkov
Abstract:
A heat engine operating on the basis of the Carnot cycle is considered, where the mechanical work performed is dissipated within the engine at the temperature of the warmer isotherm and the resulting heat is added to the engine together with an external heat input. The resulting work performed by the engine per cycle is increased at the expense of dissipated work produced in the previous cycle.…
▽ More
A heat engine operating on the basis of the Carnot cycle is considered, where the mechanical work performed is dissipated within the engine at the temperature of the warmer isotherm and the resulting heat is added to the engine together with an external heat input. The resulting work performed by the engine per cycle is increased at the expense of dissipated work produced in the previous cycle. It is shown that such a dissipative heat engine is thermodynamically inconsistent violating the first and second laws of thermodynamics. The existing physical models employing the dissipative heat engine concept, in particular, the heat engine model of hurricane development, are physically invalid.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
