Showing 1–17 of 17 results for author: Golub, B

Equity Pay In Networked Teams

Authors: Krishna Dasaratha, Benjamin Golub, Anant Shah

Abstract: A group of agents each exert effort to produce a joint output, with the complementarities between their efforts represented by a (weighted) network. Under equity compensation, a principal motivates the agents to work by giving them shares of the output. We describe the optimal equity allocation. It is characterized by a neighborhood balance condition: any two agents receiving equity have the same… ▽ More A group of agents each exert effort to produce a joint output, with the complementarities between their efforts represented by a (weighted) network. Under equity compensation, a principal motivates the agents to work by giving them shares of the output. We describe the optimal equity allocation. It is characterized by a neighborhood balance condition: any two agents receiving equity have the same (weighted) total equity assigned to their neighbors. We also study the problem of selecting the team of agents who receive positive equity, and show this team must form a tight-knit subset of the complementarity network, with any pair being complementary to one another or jointly to another team member. Finally, we give conditions under which the amount of equity used for compensation is increasing in the strength of a team's complementarities and discuss several other applications. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: 37 pages, 4 figures

On the Difficulty of Characterizing Network Formation with Endogenous Behavior

Authors: Benjamin Golub, Yu-Chi Hsieh, Evan Sadler

Abstract: Bolletta (2021, Math. Soc. Sci. 114:1-10) studies a model in which a network is strategically formed and then agents play a linear best-response investment game in it. The model is motivated by an application in which people choose both their study partners and their levels of educational effort. Agents have different one-dimensional types $\unicode{x2013}$ private returns to effort. A main result… ▽ More Bolletta (2021, Math. Soc. Sci. 114:1-10) studies a model in which a network is strategically formed and then agents play a linear best-response investment game in it. The model is motivated by an application in which people choose both their study partners and their levels of educational effort. Agents have different one-dimensional types $\unicode{x2013}$ private returns to effort. A main result claims that pairwise Nash stable networks have a locally complete structure consisting of possibly overlap** cliques: if two agents are linked, they are part of a clique composed of all agents with types between theirs. We offer a counterexample showing that the claimed characterization is incorrect, highlight where the analysis errs, and discuss implications for network formation models. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2023; v1 submitted 11 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Corporate Culture and Organizational Fragility

Authors: Matthew Elliott, Benjamin Golub, Matthieu V. Leduc

Abstract: Complex organizations accomplish tasks through many steps of collaboration among workers. Corporate culture supports collaborations by establishing norms and reducing misunderstandings. Because a strong corporate culture relies on costly, voluntary investments by many workers, we model it as an organizational public good, subject to standard free-riding problems, which become severe in large organ… ▽ More Complex organizations accomplish tasks through many steps of collaboration among workers. Corporate culture supports collaborations by establishing norms and reducing misunderstandings. Because a strong corporate culture relies on costly, voluntary investments by many workers, we model it as an organizational public good, subject to standard free-riding problems, which become severe in large organizations. Our main finding is that voluntary contributions to culture can nevertheless be sustained, because an organization's equilibrium productivity is endogenously highly sensitive to individual contributions. However, the completion of complex tasks is then necessarily fragile to small shocks that damage the organization's culture. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Electric dipole moments and the search for new physics

Authors: Ricardo Alarcon, Jim Alexander, Vassilis Anastassopoulos, Takatoshi Aoki, Rick Baartman, Stefan Baeßler, Larry Bartoszek, Douglas H. Beck, Franco Bedeschi, Robert Berger, Martin Berz, Hendrick L. Bethlem, Tanmoy Bhattacharya, Michael Blaskiewicz, Thomas Blum, Themis Bowcock, Anastasia Borschevsky, Kevin Brown, Dmitry Budker, Sergey Burdin, Brendan C. Casey, Gianluigi Casse, Giovanni Cantatore, Lan Cheng, Timothy Chupp , et al. (118 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Static electric dipole moments of nondegenerate systems probe mass scales for physics beyond the Standard Model well beyond those reached directly at high energy colliders. Discrimination between different physics models, however, requires complementary searches in atomic-molecular-and-optical, nuclear and particle physics. In this report, we discuss the current status and prospects in the near fu… ▽ More Static electric dipole moments of nondegenerate systems probe mass scales for physics beyond the Standard Model well beyond those reached directly at high energy colliders. Discrimination between different physics models, however, requires complementary searches in atomic-molecular-and-optical, nuclear and particle physics. In this report, we discuss the current status and prospects in the near future for a compelling suite of such experiments, along with developments needed in the encompassing theoretical framework. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2022; v1 submitted 15 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Contribution to Snowmass 2021; updated with community edits and endorsements

Taxes and Market Power: A Principal Components Approach

Authors: Andrea Galeotti, Benjamin Golub, Sanjeev Goyal, Eduard Talamàs, Omer Tamuz

Abstract: Suppliers of differentiated goods make simultaneous pricing decisions, which are strategically linked. Because of market power, the equilibrium is inefficient. We study how a policymaker should target a budget-balanced tax-and-subsidy policy to increase welfare. A key tool is a certain basis for the goods space, determined by the network of interactions among suppliers. It consists of eigenbundles… ▽ More Suppliers of differentiated goods make simultaneous pricing decisions, which are strategically linked. Because of market power, the equilibrium is inefficient. We study how a policymaker should target a budget-balanced tax-and-subsidy policy to increase welfare. A key tool is a certain basis for the goods space, determined by the network of interactions among suppliers. It consists of eigenbundles -- orthogonal in the sense that a tax on any eigenbundle passes through only to its own price -- with pass-through coefficients determined by associated eigenvalues. Our basis permits a simple characterization of optimal interventions. A planner maximizing consumer surplus should tax eigenbundles with low pass-through and subsidize ones with high pass-through. The Pigouvian leverage of the system -- the gain in consumer surplus achievable by an optimal tax scheme -- depends only on the dispersion of the eigenvalues of the matrix of strategic interactions. We interpret these results in terms of the network structure of the market. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2022; v1 submitted 15 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

A Network Approach to Public Goods: A Short Summary

Authors: Matthew Elliott, Benjamin Golub

Abstract: Suppose agents can exert costly effort that creates nonrival, heterogeneous benefits for each other. At each possible outcome, a weighted, directed network describing marginal externalities is defined. We show that Pareto efficient outcomes are those at which the largest eigenvalue of the network is 1. An important set of efficient solutions, Lindahl outcomes, are characterized by contributions be… ▽ More Suppose agents can exert costly effort that creates nonrival, heterogeneous benefits for each other. At each possible outcome, a weighted, directed network describing marginal externalities is defined. We show that Pareto efficient outcomes are those at which the largest eigenvalue of the network is 1. An important set of efficient solutions, Lindahl outcomes, are characterized by contributions being proportional to agents' eigenvector centralities in the network. The outcomes we focus on are motivated by negotiations. We apply the results to identify who is essential for Pareto improvements, how to efficiently subdivide negotiations, and whom to optimally add to a team. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Discord and Harmony in Networks

Authors: Andrea Galeotti, Benjamin Golub, Sanjeev Goyal, Rithvik Rao

Abstract: Consider a coordination game played on a network, where agents prefer taking actions closer to those of their neighbors and to their own ideal points in action space. We explore how the welfare outcomes of a coordination game depend on network structure and the distribution of ideal points throughout the network. To this end, we imagine a benevolent or adversarial planner who intervenes, at a cost… ▽ More Consider a coordination game played on a network, where agents prefer taking actions closer to those of their neighbors and to their own ideal points in action space. We explore how the welfare outcomes of a coordination game depend on network structure and the distribution of ideal points throughout the network. To this end, we imagine a benevolent or adversarial planner who intervenes, at a cost, to change ideal points in order to maximize or minimize utilitarian welfare subject to a constraint. A complete characterization of optimal interventions is obtained by decomposing interventions into principal components of the network's adjacency matrix. Welfare is most sensitive to interventions proportional to the last principal component, which focus on local disagreement. A welfare-maximizing planner optimally works to reduce local disagreement, bringing the ideal points of neighbors closer together, whereas a malevolent adversary optimally drives neighbors' ideal points apart to decrease welfare. Such welfare-maximizing/minimizing interventions are very different from ones that would be done to change some traditional measures of discord, such as the cross-sectional variation of equilibrium actions. In fact, an adversary sowing disagreement to maximize her impact on welfare will minimize her impact on global variation in equilibrium actions, underscoring a tension between improving welfare and increasing global cohesion of equilibrium behavior. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Games on Endogenous Networks

Authors: Evan Sadler, Benjamin Golub

Abstract: We study network games in which players choose both the partners with whom they associate and an action level (e.g., effort) that creates spillovers for those partners. We introduce a framework and two solution concepts, extending standard approaches for analyzing each choice in isolation: Nash equilibrium in actions and pairwise stability in links. Our main results show that, under suitable order… ▽ More We study network games in which players choose both the partners with whom they associate and an action level (e.g., effort) that creates spillovers for those partners. We introduce a framework and two solution concepts, extending standard approaches for analyzing each choice in isolation: Nash equilibrium in actions and pairwise stability in links. Our main results show that, under suitable order conditions on incentives, stable networks take simple forms. The first condition concerns whether links create positive or negative payoff spillovers. The second concerns whether actions are strategic complements to links, or strategic substitutes. Together, these conditions yield a taxonomy of the relationship between network structure and economic primitives organized around two network architectures: ordered overlap** cliques and nested split graphs. We apply our model to understand the consequences of competition for status, to microfound matching models that assume clique formation, and to interpret empirical findings that highlight unintended consequences of group design. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2024; v1 submitted 2 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Expectations, Networks, and Conventions

Authors: Benjamin Golub, Stephen Morris

Abstract: In coordination games and speculative over-the-counter financial markets, solutions depend on higher-order average expectations: agents' expectations about what counterparties, on average, expect their counterparties to think, etc. We offer a unified analysis of these objects and their limits, for general information structures, priors, and networks of counterparty relationships. Our key device is… ▽ More In coordination games and speculative over-the-counter financial markets, solutions depend on higher-order average expectations: agents' expectations about what counterparties, on average, expect their counterparties to think, etc. We offer a unified analysis of these objects and their limits, for general information structures, priors, and networks of counterparty relationships. Our key device is an interaction structure combining the network and agents' beliefs, which we analyze using Markov methods. This device allows us to nest classical beauty contests and network games within one model and unify their results. Two applications illustrate the techniques: The first characterizes when slight optimism about counterparties' average expectations leads to contagion of optimism and extreme asset prices. The second describes the tyranny of the least-informed: agents coordinating on the prior expectations of the one with the worst private information, despite all having nearly common certainty, based on precise private signals, of the ex post optimal action. △ Less

Submitted 29 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Notes on a Social Transmission Model with a Continuum of Agents

Authors: Benjamin Golub

Abstract: This note presents a simple overlap**-generations (OLG) model of the transmission of a trait, such as a culture. Initially, some fraction of agents carry the trait. In each time period, young agents are "born" and are influenced by some older agents. Agents adopt the trait only if at least a certain number of their influencers have the trait. This influence may occur due to rational choice (e.g.… ▽ More This note presents a simple overlap**-generations (OLG) model of the transmission of a trait, such as a culture. Initially, some fraction of agents carry the trait. In each time period, young agents are "born" and are influenced by some older agents. Agents adopt the trait only if at least a certain number of their influencers have the trait. This influence may occur due to rational choice (e.g., because the young agents are playing a coordination game with old agents who are already committed to a strategy), or for some other reason. Our interest is in how the process of social influence unfolds over time, and whether a trait will persist or die out. We characterize the dynamics of the fraction of active agents and relate the analysis to classic results on branching processes and random graphs. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2020; v1 submitted 10 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Supply Network Formation and Fragility

Authors: Matthew Elliott, Benjamin Golub, Matthew V. Leduc

Abstract: We model the production of complex goods in a large supply network. Each firm sources several essential inputs through relationships with other firms. Individual supply relationships are at risk of idiosyncratic failure, which threatens to disrupt production. To protect against this, firms multisource inputs and strategically invest to make relationships stronger, trading off the cost of investmen… ▽ More We model the production of complex goods in a large supply network. Each firm sources several essential inputs through relationships with other firms. Individual supply relationships are at risk of idiosyncratic failure, which threatens to disrupt production. To protect against this, firms multisource inputs and strategically invest to make relationships stronger, trading off the cost of investment against the benefits of increased robustness. A supply network is called fragile if aggregate output is very sensitive to small aggregate shocks. We show that supply networks of intermediate productivity are fragile in equilibrium, even though this is always inefficient. The endogenous configuration of supply networks provides a new channel for the powerful amplification of shocks. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2023; v1 submitted 12 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Introduction to Network Games with Linear Best Responses

Authors: Benjamin Golub

Abstract: This note, suitable for a lecture in an advanced undergraduate or basic graduate course on the economic theory of networks, exposits basic ideas of linear best-response games and their equilibria. This note, suitable for a lecture in an advanced undergraduate or basic graduate course on the economic theory of networks, exposits basic ideas of linear best-response games and their equilibria. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Learning from Neighbors about a Changing State

Authors: Krishna Dasaratha, Benjamin Golub, Nir Hak

Abstract: Agents learn about a changing state using private signals and their neighbors' past estimates of the state. We present a model in which Bayesian agents in equilibrium use neighbors' estimates simply by taking weighted sums with time-invariant weights. The dynamics thus parallel those of the tractable DeGroot model of learning in networks, but arise as an equilibrium outcome rather than a behaviora… ▽ More Agents learn about a changing state using private signals and their neighbors' past estimates of the state. We present a model in which Bayesian agents in equilibrium use neighbors' estimates simply by taking weighted sums with time-invariant weights. The dynamics thus parallel those of the tractable DeGroot model of learning in networks, but arise as an equilibrium outcome rather than a behavioral assumption. We examine whether information aggregation is nearly optimal as neighborhoods grow large. A key condition for this is signal diversity: each individual's neighbors have private signals that not only contain independent information, but also have sufficiently different distributions. Without signal diversity $\unicode{x2013}$ e.g., if private signals are i.i.d. $\unicode{x2013}$ learning is suboptimal in all networks and highly inefficient in some. Turning to social influence, we find it is much more sensitive to one's signal quality than to one's number of neighbors, in contrast to standard models with exogenous updating rules. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2022; v1 submitted 6 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: final manuscript submitted to journal -- revised exposition throughout, corrected details in Section 3.1

Revisiting Imidazolium Based Ionic Liquids: Effect of the Conformation Bias of the [NTf$_{2}$] Anion Studied By Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Authors: Benjamin Golub, Jan Neumann, Lisa-Marie Odebrecht, Ralf Ludwig, Dietmar Paschek

Abstract: We study ionic liquids composed 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium cations and bis(trifluoromethyl-sulfonyl)imide anions ([C$_n$MIm][NTf$_2$]) with varying chain-length $n\!=\!2, 4, 6, 8$ by using molecular dynamics simulations. We show that a reparametrization of the dihedral potentials as well as charges of the [NTf$_2$] anion leads to an improvment of the force field model introduced by Köddermann {\e… ▽ More We study ionic liquids composed 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium cations and bis(trifluoromethyl-sulfonyl)imide anions ([C$_n$MIm][NTf$_2$]) with varying chain-length $n\!=\!2, 4, 6, 8$ by using molecular dynamics simulations. We show that a reparametrization of the dihedral potentials as well as charges of the [NTf$_2$] anion leads to an improvment of the force field model introduced by Köddermann {\em et al.} [ChemPhysChem, \textbf{8}, 2464 (2007)] (KPL-force field). A crucial advantage of the new parameter set is that the minimum energy conformations of the anion ({\em trans} and {\em gauche}), as deduced from {\em ab initio} calculations and {\sc Raman} experiments, are now both well represented by our model. In addition, the results for [C$_n$MIm][NTf$_2$] show that this modification leads to an even better agreement between experiment and molecular dynamics simulation as demonstrated for densities, diffusion coefficients, vaporization enthalpies, reorientational correlation times, and viscosities. Even though we focused on a better representation of the anion conformation, also the alkyl chain-length dependence of the cation behaves closer to the experiment. We strongly encourage to use the new NGKPL force field for the [NTf$_2$] anion instead of the earlier KPL parameter set for computer simulations aiming to describe the thermodynamics, dynamics and also structure of imidazolium based ionic liquids. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: 10 pages, 15 figures

Targeting Interventions in Networks

Authors: Andrea Galeotti, Benjamin Golub, Sanjeev Goyal

Abstract: We study games in which a network mediates strategic spillovers and externalities among the players. How does a planner optimally target interventions that change individuals' private returns to investment? We analyze this question by decomposing any intervention into orthogonal principal components, which are determined by the network and are ordered according to their associated eigenvalues. The… ▽ More We study games in which a network mediates strategic spillovers and externalities among the players. How does a planner optimally target interventions that change individuals' private returns to investment? We analyze this question by decomposing any intervention into orthogonal principal components, which are determined by the network and are ordered according to their associated eigenvalues. There is a close connection between the nature of spillovers and the representation of various principal components in the optimal intervention. In games of strategic complements (substitutes), interventions place more weight on the top (bottom) principal components, which reflect more global (local) network structure. For large budgets, optimal interventions are simple -- they involve a single principal component. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2020; v1 submitted 16 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: updated v5 by adding bibliography so that it compiles

Strategic Random Networks: Why Social Networking Technology Matters

Authors: Benjamin Golub, Yair Livne

Abstract: This paper develops strategic foundations for an important statistical model of random networks with heterogeneous expected degrees. Based on this, we show how social networking services that subtly alter the costs and indirect benefits of relationships can cause large changes in behavior and welfare. In the model, agents who value friends and friends of friends choose how much to socialize, which… ▽ More This paper develops strategic foundations for an important statistical model of random networks with heterogeneous expected degrees. Based on this, we show how social networking services that subtly alter the costs and indirect benefits of relationships can cause large changes in behavior and welfare. In the model, agents who value friends and friends of friends choose how much to socialize, which increases the probabilities of links but is costly. There is a sharp transition from fragmented, sparse equilibrium networks to connected, dense ones when the value of friends of friends crosses a cost-dependent threshold. This transition mitigates an extreme inefficiency. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2010; v1 submitted 6 April, 2010; originally announced April 2010.

Comments: 34 pages, 3 figures; v2 and v3 correct typographical errors

How Homophily Affects Diffusion and Learning in Networks

Authors: Benjamin Golub, Matthew O. Jackson

Abstract: We examine how three different communication processes operating through social networks are affected by homophily -- the tendency of individuals to associate with others similar to themselves. Homophily has no effect if messages are broadcast or sent via shortest paths; only connection density matters. In contrast, homophily substantially slows learning based on repeated averaging of neighbors'… ▽ More We examine how three different communication processes operating through social networks are affected by homophily -- the tendency of individuals to associate with others similar to themselves. Homophily has no effect if messages are broadcast or sent via shortest paths; only connection density matters. In contrast, homophily substantially slows learning based on repeated averaging of neighbors' information and Markovian diffusion processes such as the Google random surfer model. Indeed, the latter processes are strongly affected by homophily but completely independent of connection density, provided this density exceeds a low threshold. We obtain these results by establishing new results on the spectra of large random graphs and relating the spectra to homophily. We conclude by checking the theoretical predictions using observed high school friendship networks from the Adolescent Health dataset. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2009; v1 submitted 24 November, 2008; originally announced November 2008.

Comments: Expanded version includes additional empirical analysis