-
Bridging Methodologies: Angrist and Imbens' Contributions to Causal Identification
Authors:
Lucas Girard,
Yannick Guyonvarch
Abstract:
In the 1990s, Joshua Angrist and Guido Imbens studied the causal interpretation of Instrumental Variable estimates (a widespread methodology in economics) through the lens of potential outcomes (a classical framework to formalize causality in statistics). Bridging a gap between those two strands of literature, they stress the importance of treatment effect heterogeneity and show that, under defend…
▽ More
In the 1990s, Joshua Angrist and Guido Imbens studied the causal interpretation of Instrumental Variable estimates (a widespread methodology in economics) through the lens of potential outcomes (a classical framework to formalize causality in statistics). Bridging a gap between those two strands of literature, they stress the importance of treatment effect heterogeneity and show that, under defendable assumptions in various applications, this method recovers an average causal effect for a specific subpopulation of individuals whose treatment is affected by the instrument. They were awarded the Nobel Prize primarily for this Local Average Treatment Effect (LATE). The first part of this article presents that methodological contribution in-depth: the origination in earlier applied articles, the different identification results and extensions, and related debates on the relevance of LATEs for public policy decisions. The second part reviews the main contributions of the authors beyond the LATE. J. Angrist has pursued the search for informative and varied empirical research designs in several fields, particularly in education. G. Imbens has complemented the toolbox for treatment effect estimation in many ways, notably through propensity score reweighting, matching, and, more recently, adapting machine learning procedures.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Explicit non-asymptotic bounds for the distance to the first-order Edgeworth expansion
Authors:
Alexis Derumigny,
Lucas Girard,
Yannick Guyonvarch
Abstract:
In this article, we obtain explicit bounds on the uniform distance between the cumulative distribution function of a standardized sum $S_n$ of $n$ independent centered random variables with moments of order four and its first-order Edgeworth expansion. Those bounds are valid for any sample size with $n^{-1/2}$ rate under moment conditions only and $n^{-1}$ rate under additional regularity constrai…
▽ More
In this article, we obtain explicit bounds on the uniform distance between the cumulative distribution function of a standardized sum $S_n$ of $n$ independent centered random variables with moments of order four and its first-order Edgeworth expansion. Those bounds are valid for any sample size with $n^{-1/2}$ rate under moment conditions only and $n^{-1}$ rate under additional regularity constraints on the tail behavior of the characteristic function of $S_n$. In both cases, the bounds are further sharpened if the variables involved in $S_n$ are unskewed. We also derive new Berry-Esseen-type bounds from our results and discuss their links with existing ones. We finally apply our results to illustrate the lack of finite-sample validity of one-sided tests based on the normal approximation of the mean.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2022; v1 submitted 14 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
On the construction of confidence intervals for ratios of expectations
Authors:
Alexis Derumigny,
Lucas Girard,
Yannick Guyonvarch
Abstract:
In econometrics, many parameters of interest can be written as ratios of expectations. The main approach to construct confidence intervals for such parameters is the delta method. However, this asymptotic procedure yields intervals that may not be relevant for small sample sizes or, more generally, in a sequence-of-model framework that allows the expectation in the denominator to decrease to $0$ w…
▽ More
In econometrics, many parameters of interest can be written as ratios of expectations. The main approach to construct confidence intervals for such parameters is the delta method. However, this asymptotic procedure yields intervals that may not be relevant for small sample sizes or, more generally, in a sequence-of-model framework that allows the expectation in the denominator to decrease to $0$ with the sample size. In this setting, we prove a generalization of the delta method for ratios of expectations and the consistency of the nonparametric percentile bootstrap. We also investigate finite-sample inference and show a partial impossibility result: nonasymptotic uniform confidence intervals can be built for ratios of expectations but not at every level. Based on this, we propose an easy-to-compute index to appraise the reliability of the intervals based on the delta method. Simulations and an application illustrate our results and the practical usefulness of our rule of thumb.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Damage-cluster distributions and size effect on strength in compressive failure
Authors:
Lucas Girard,
Jerome Weiss,
David Amitrano
Abstract:
We investigate compressive failure of heterogeneous materials on the basis of a continuous progressive damage model. The model explicitely accounts for tensile and shear local damage and reproduces the main features of compressive failure of brittle materials like rocks or ice. We show that the size distribution of damage-clusters, as well as the evolution of an order parameter, the size of the la…
▽ More
We investigate compressive failure of heterogeneous materials on the basis of a continuous progressive damage model. The model explicitely accounts for tensile and shear local damage and reproduces the main features of compressive failure of brittle materials like rocks or ice. We show that the size distribution of damage-clusters, as well as the evolution of an order parameter, the size of the largest damage-cluster, argue for a critical interpretation of fracture. The compressive failure strength follows a normal distribution with a very small size effect on the mean strength, in good agreement with experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2012; v1 submitted 5 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
An indirect dark matter search with diffuse gamma rays from the Galactic Centre with the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer
Authors:
A. Jacholkowska,
G. Lamanna,
E. Nuss,
J. Bolmont,
C. Adloff,
J. Alcaraz,
R. Battiston,
P. Brun,
W. J. Burger,
V. Choutko,
G. Coignet,
A. Falvard,
E. Flandrini,
L. Girard,
C. Goy,
K. Jedamzik,
R. Kossakowski,
G. Moultaka,
S. Natale,
J. Pochon,
M. Pohl,
S. Rosier-Lees,
M. Sapinski,
I. Sevilla Noarbe,
JP. Vialle
Abstract:
The detection of non-baryonic dark matter through its gamma-ray annihilation in the centre of our galaxy has been studied. The gamma fluxes according to different models have been simulated and compared to those expected to be observed with the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS), during a long-term mission on board of the International Space Station. Under the assumption that the dark matter halo…
▽ More
The detection of non-baryonic dark matter through its gamma-ray annihilation in the centre of our galaxy has been studied. The gamma fluxes according to different models have been simulated and compared to those expected to be observed with the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS), during a long-term mission on board of the International Space Station. Under the assumption that the dark matter halo is composed of the lightest, stable supersymmetric particle, the neutralino, the results of the simulations in the framework of mSUGRA models, show that with a cuspy dark matter halo or a clumpy halo, the annihilation gamma-ray signal would be detected by AMS. More optimistic perspectives are obtained with the Anomaly Mediated Supersymmetry Breaking (AMSB) model. The latter leads also to a cosmologically important 6Li abundance. Finally, the discovery potential for the massive Kaluza-Klein dark matter candidates has been evaluated and their detection looks feasible.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2006; v1 submitted 16 August, 2005;
originally announced August 2005.
-
Optical Tests of a 2.5-m diameter Liquid Mirror: Behavior under External Perturbations and Scattered Light Measurements
Authors:
Luc Girard,
Ermanno F. Borra
Abstract:
Interferometric tests of a f/1.2 2.5-m diameter liquid mirror show RMS surface deviations about wave/20 and Strehl ratios of order 0.6, showing that it is diffraction limited. The mirror is certainly better than implied by the data because of aberrations introduced by the auxiliary testing optics. We have made detailed studies of the scattered light of the mirror. We have studied the behavior of…
▽ More
Interferometric tests of a f/1.2 2.5-m diameter liquid mirror show RMS surface deviations about wave/20 and Strehl ratios of order 0.6, showing that it is diffraction limited. The mirror is certainly better than implied by the data because of aberrations introduced by the auxiliary testing optics. We have made detailed studies of the scattered light of the mirror. We have studied the behavior of the mirror under external perturbations. With this article we have reached an important milestone since we now have a good understanding of liquid mirrors.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 1997;
originally announced June 1997.
-
Liquid Mirror Telescopes: A progress report
Authors:
Ermanno F. Borra,
Marc Ferrari,
Luc Girard,
Gilberto Moretto,
Gregoire Tremblay,
Gerard Lemaitre
Abstract:
We review the present status of liquid mirror telescopes. Interferometric tests of liquid mirrors (the largest one having a diameter of 2.5 meters ) show excellent optical qualities. The basic technology is now sufficiently reliable that it can be put to work. Indeed, a handful of liquid mirrors have now been built that are used for scientific work. A 3.7-m diameter LMT is presently being built…
▽ More
We review the present status of liquid mirror telescopes. Interferometric tests of liquid mirrors (the largest one having a diameter of 2.5 meters ) show excellent optical qualities. The basic technology is now sufficiently reliable that it can be put to work. Indeed, a handful of liquid mirrors have now been built that are used for scientific work. A 3.7-m diameter LMT is presently being built in the new Laval upgraded testing facilities. Construction of the mirror can be followed on the Web site: http://astrosun.phy.ulaval.ca/lmt/lmt- home.html. Finally we address the issue of the field accessible to LMTs equipped with novel optical correctors. Optical design work, and some exploratory laboratory work, indicate that a single LMT should be able to access, with excellent images, small regions anywhere inside fields as large as 45 degrees.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 1996;
originally announced August 1996.
