An institutional study on plan quality and variation of manual forward planning for Gamma Knife radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma
Authors:
Zhen Tian,
Tonghe Wang,
Xiaofeng Yang,
Matt D. Giles,
Elizabeth Butker,
Matthew C. Walb,
Tian Liu,
Shannon Kahn
Abstract:
Due to the complexity and cumbersomeness of Gamma Knife (GK) manual forward planning, the quality of the resulting treatment plans heavily depends on the planners skill, experience and the amount of effort devoted to plan development. Hence, GK plan quality may vary significantly among institutions and planners, and even for a same planner at different cases. This is particularly a concern for cha…
▽ More
Due to the complexity and cumbersomeness of Gamma Knife (GK) manual forward planning, the quality of the resulting treatment plans heavily depends on the planners skill, experience and the amount of effort devoted to plan development. Hence, GK plan quality may vary significantly among institutions and planners, and even for a same planner at different cases. This is particularly a concern for challenging cases with complicated geometry, such as vestibular schwannoma cases. The purpose of this retrospective study is to investigate the plan quality and variation in the manually forward planned, clinically acceptable GK treatment plans of 22 previous vestibular schwannoma cases. Considering the impacts of different patient geometry and different trade-offs among the planning objectives in GK planning, it is difficult to objectively assess the plan quality across different cases. To reduce these confounding factors on plan quality assessment, we employed our recently developed multiresolution-level inverse planning algorithm to generate a golden plan for each case, which is expected to be on or close to the pareto surface with a similar trade-off as used in the manual plan. The plan quality of the manual plan is then quantified in terms of its deviation from the golden plan. A scoring criterion between 0-100 was designed to calculate a final score for each manual plan to simplify our analysis. Large quality variation was observed in these 22 cases, with two cases having a score lower than 75, three cases scoring between 80 and 85, two cases between 85 and 90, eight cases between 90 and 95, and seven cases higher than 95. Inter- and intra- planner variability was also observed in our study. This large variation in GK manual planning deserves high attention, and merits further investigation on how to reduce the variation in GK treatment plan quality.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
A plan quality control method of treatment planning for Gamma Knife radiosurgery
Authors:
Tonghe Wang,
Matt D. Giles,
Elizabeth Butker,
Matthew C. Walb,
Xiaofeng Yang,
Tian Liu,
Shannon Kahn,
Zhen Tian
Abstract:
With many variables to adjust, conventional manual forward planning for Gamma Knife (GK) radiosurgery is very complicated and cumbersome. The resulting plan quality heavily depends on planners skills, experiences and devoted efforts, and varies significantly among cases, planners, and institutions. Quality control for GK planning is desired to consistently provide high-quality plan to each patient…
▽ More
With many variables to adjust, conventional manual forward planning for Gamma Knife (GK) radiosurgery is very complicated and cumbersome. The resulting plan quality heavily depends on planners skills, experiences and devoted efforts, and varies significantly among cases, planners, and institutions. Quality control for GK planning is desired to consistently provide high-quality plan to each patient. In this study, we proposed a quality control method for GK planning by building a database of high-quality GK plans. Patient anatomy was described by target volume, target shape complexity, and spatial relationship between target and nearby organs, which determine GK planning difficulty level. Plan quality was evaluated using target coverage, selectivity, intermediate dose spillage, maximum dose to 0.1 cc of brainstem, mean dose of ipsilateral cochlea, and beam-on time. When a new plan is created, a high-quality plan that has the most similar target volume size and shape complexity will be identified from the database. A model has also been built to predict the dose to brainstem and cochlea based on their overlap volume histograms. The identified reference plan and the predicted organ dose will help planners to make quality control decisions accordingly. To validate this method, we have built a database for vestibular schwannoma, which are considered to be challenging for GK planning due to the irregularly-shaped target and its proximity to brainstem and cochlea. Five cases were tested, among which one case was considered to be of high quality and four cases had a lower plan quality than prediction. These four cases were replanned and got substantially improved. Our results have demonstrated the efficacy of our proposed quality control method. This method may also be used as a plan quality prediction method to facilitate the development of automatic treatment planning for GK radiosurgery.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
