-
Efficiency in Pure-Exchange Economies with Risk-Averse Monetary Utilities
Authors:
Mario Ghossoub,
Michael Boyuan Zhu
Abstract:
We study Pareto efficiency in a pure-exchange economy where agents' preferences are represented by risk-averse monetary utilities. These coincide with law-invariant monetary utilities, and they can be shown to correspond to the class of monotone, (quasi-)concave, Schur concave, and translation-invariant utility functionals. This covers a large class of utility functionals, including a variety of l…
▽ More
We study Pareto efficiency in a pure-exchange economy where agents' preferences are represented by risk-averse monetary utilities. These coincide with law-invariant monetary utilities, and they can be shown to correspond to the class of monotone, (quasi-)concave, Schur concave, and translation-invariant utility functionals. This covers a large class of utility functionals, including a variety of law-invariant robust utilities. We show that Pareto optima exist and are comonotone, and we provide a crisp characterization thereof in the case of law-invariant positively homogeneous monetary utilities. This characterization provides an easily implementable algorithm that fully determines the shape of Pareto-optimal allocations. In the special case of law-invariant comonotone-additive monetary utility functionals (concave Yaari-Dual utilities), we provide a closed-form characterization of Pareto optima. As an application, we examine risk-sharing markets where all agents evaluate risk through law-invariant coherent risk measures, a widely popular class of risk measures. In a numerical illustration, we characterize Pareto-optimal risk-sharing for some special types of coherent risk measures.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Allocation Mechanisms in Decentralized Exchange Markets with Frictions
Authors:
Mario Ghossoub,
Giulio Principi,
Ruodu Wang
Abstract:
The classical theory of efficient allocations of an aggregate endowment in a pure-exchange economy has hitherto primarily focused on the Pareto-efficiency of allocations, under the implicit assumption that transfers between agents are frictionless, and hence costless to the economy. In this paper, we argue that certain transfers cause frictions that result in costs to the economy. We show that the…
▽ More
The classical theory of efficient allocations of an aggregate endowment in a pure-exchange economy has hitherto primarily focused on the Pareto-efficiency of allocations, under the implicit assumption that transfers between agents are frictionless, and hence costless to the economy. In this paper, we argue that certain transfers cause frictions that result in costs to the economy. We show that these frictional costs are tantamount to a form of subadditivity of the cost of transferring endowments between agents. We suggest an axiomatic study of allocation mechanisms, that is, the mechanisms that transform feasible allocations into other feasible allocations, in the presence of such transfer costs. Among other results, we provide an axiomatic characterization of those allocation mechanisms that admit representations as robust (worst-case) linear allocation mechanisms, as well as those mechanisms that admit representations as worst-case conditional expectations. We call the latter Robust Conditional Mean Allocation mechanisms, and we relate our results to the literature on (decentralized) risk sharing within a pool of agents.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
A Nonlinear Sandwich Theorem
Authors:
Mario Ghossoub,
Giulio Principi,
Lorenzo Stanca
Abstract:
We provide a Sandwich Theorem (König (1972)) for positively homogeneous functionals that satisfy additivity only on a restricted domain. Our relaxation of additivity is based on a binary relation called convex-conic symmetric preorder, whereby additivity is restricted to all couples of elements that belong to such relation. We then study applications of our nonlinear Sandwich Theorem, proving exte…
▽ More
We provide a Sandwich Theorem (König (1972)) for positively homogeneous functionals that satisfy additivity only on a restricted domain. Our relaxation of additivity is based on a binary relation called convex-conic symmetric preorder, whereby additivity is restricted to all couples of elements that belong to such relation. We then study applications of our nonlinear Sandwich Theorem, proving extension and envelope representation results. Finally, we consider some applications to comonotonicity, a key property in decision theory, risk measurement, and the theory of risk sharing.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Multiarmed Bandits Problem Under the Mean-Variance Setting
Authors:
Hongda Hu,
Arthur Charpentier,
Mario Ghossoub,
Alexander Schied
Abstract:
The classical multi-armed bandit (MAB) problem involves a learner and a collection of K independent arms, each with its own ex ante unknown independent reward distribution. At each one of a finite number of rounds, the learner selects one arm and receives new information. The learner often faces an exploration-exploitation dilemma: exploiting the current information by playing the arm with the hig…
▽ More
The classical multi-armed bandit (MAB) problem involves a learner and a collection of K independent arms, each with its own ex ante unknown independent reward distribution. At each one of a finite number of rounds, the learner selects one arm and receives new information. The learner often faces an exploration-exploitation dilemma: exploiting the current information by playing the arm with the highest estimated reward versus exploring all arms to gather more reward information. The design objective aims to maximize the expected cumulative reward over all rounds. However, such an objective does not account for a risk-reward tradeoff, which is often a fundamental precept in many areas of applications, most notably in finance and economics. In this paper, we build upon Sani et al. (2012) and extend the classical MAB problem to a mean-variance setting. Specifically, we relax the assumptions of independent arms and bounded rewards made in Sani et al. (2012) by considering sub-Gaussian arms. We introduce the Risk Aware Lower Confidence Bound (RALCB) algorithm to solve the problem, and study some of its properties. Finally, we perform a number of numerical simulations to demonstrate that, in both independent and dependent scenarios, our suggested approach performs better than the algorithm suggested by Sani et al. (2012).
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Bounds on Choquet Risk Measures in Finite Product Spaces with Ambiguous Marginals
Authors:
Mario Ghossoub,
David Saunders,
Kelvin Shuangjian Zhang
Abstract:
We investigate the problem of finding upper and lower bounds for a Choquet risk measure of a nonlinear function of two risk factors, when the marginal distributions of the risk factors are ambiguous and represented by nonadditive measures on the marginal spaces and the joint nonadditive distribution on the product space is unknown. We treat this problem as a generalization of the optimal transport…
▽ More
We investigate the problem of finding upper and lower bounds for a Choquet risk measure of a nonlinear function of two risk factors, when the marginal distributions of the risk factors are ambiguous and represented by nonadditive measures on the marginal spaces and the joint nonadditive distribution on the product space is unknown. We treat this problem as a generalization of the optimal transport problem to the setting of nonadditive measures. We provide explicit characterizations of the optimal solutions for finite marginal spaces, and we investigate some of their properties. We further discuss the connections with linear programming, showing that the optimal transport problems for capacities are linear programs, and we also characterize their duals explicitly. Finally, we investigate a series of numerical examples, including a comparison with the classical optimal transport problem, and applications to counterparty credit risk.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2023; v1 submitted 2 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Maximum Spectral Measures of Risk with given Risk Factor Marginal Distributions
Authors:
Mario Ghossoub,
Jesse Hall,
David Saunders
Abstract:
We consider the problem of determining an upper bound for the value of a spectral risk measure of a loss that is a general nonlinear function of two factors whose marginal distributions are known, but whose joint distribution is unknown. The factors may take values in complete separable metric spaces. We introduce the notion of Maximum Spectral Measure (MSP), as a worst-case spectral risk measure…
▽ More
We consider the problem of determining an upper bound for the value of a spectral risk measure of a loss that is a general nonlinear function of two factors whose marginal distributions are known, but whose joint distribution is unknown. The factors may take values in complete separable metric spaces. We introduce the notion of Maximum Spectral Measure (MSP), as a worst-case spectral risk measure of the loss with respect to the dependence between the factors. The MSP admits a formulation as a solution to an optimization problem that has the same constraint set as the optimal transport problem, but with a more general objective function. We present results analogous to the Kantorovich duality, and we investigate the continuity properties of the optimal value function and optimal solution set with respect to perturbation of the marginal distributions. Additionally, we provide an asymptotic result characterizing the limiting distribution of the optimal value function when the factor distributions are simulated from finite sample spaces. The special case of Expected Shortfall and the resulting Maximum Expected Shortfall is also examined.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Optimal Insurance under Maxmin Expected Utility
Authors:
Corina Birghila,
Tim J. Boonen,
Mario Ghossoub
Abstract:
We examine a problem of demand for insurance indemnification, when the insured is sensitive to ambiguity and behaves according to the Maxmin-Expected Utility model of Gilboa and Schmeidler (1989), whereas the insurer is a (risk-averse or risk-neutral) Expected-Utility maximizer. We characterize optimal indemnity functions both with and without the customary ex ante no-sabotage requirement on feasi…
▽ More
We examine a problem of demand for insurance indemnification, when the insured is sensitive to ambiguity and behaves according to the Maxmin-Expected Utility model of Gilboa and Schmeidler (1989), whereas the insurer is a (risk-averse or risk-neutral) Expected-Utility maximizer. We characterize optimal indemnity functions both with and without the customary ex ante no-sabotage requirement on feasible indemnities, and for both concave and linear utility functions for the two agents. This allows us to provide a unifying framework in which we examine the effects of the no-sabotage condition, marginal utility of wealth, belief heterogeneity, as well as ambiguity (multiplicity of priors) on the structure of optimal indemnity functions. In particular, we show how the singularity in beliefs leads to an optimal indemnity function that involves full insurance on an event to which the insurer assigns zero probability, while the decision maker assigns a positive probability. We examine several illustrative examples, and we provide numerical studies for the case of a Wasserstein and a Renyi ambiguity set.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On the Continuity of the Feasible Set Map** in Optimal Transport
Authors:
Mario Ghossoub,
David Saunders
Abstract:
Consider the set of probability measures with given marginal distributions on the product of two complete, separable metric spaces, seen as a correspondence when the marginal distributions vary. In problems of optimal transport, continuity of this correspondence from marginal to joint distributions is often desired, in light of Berge's Maximum Theorem, to establish continuity of the value function…
▽ More
Consider the set of probability measures with given marginal distributions on the product of two complete, separable metric spaces, seen as a correspondence when the marginal distributions vary. In problems of optimal transport, continuity of this correspondence from marginal to joint distributions is often desired, in light of Berge's Maximum Theorem, to establish continuity of the value function in the marginal distributions, as well as stability of the set of optimal transport plans. Bergin (1999) established the continuity of this correspondence, and in this note, we present a novel and considerably shorter proof of this important result. We then examine an application to an assignment game (transferable utility matching problem) with unknown type distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.