-
Sensitivity Analysis for Piecewise-Affine Approximations of Nonlinear Programs with Polytopic Constraints
Authors:
Leila Gharavi,
Changrui Liu,
Bart De Schutter,
Simone Baldi
Abstract:
Nonlinear Programs (NLPs) are prevalent in optimization-based control of nonlinear systems. Solving general NLPs is computationally expensive, necessitating the development of fast hardware or tractable suboptimal approximations. This paper investigates the sensitivity of the solutions of NLPs with polytopic constraints when the nonlinear continuous objective function is approximated by a PieceWis…
▽ More
Nonlinear Programs (NLPs) are prevalent in optimization-based control of nonlinear systems. Solving general NLPs is computationally expensive, necessitating the development of fast hardware or tractable suboptimal approximations. This paper investigates the sensitivity of the solutions of NLPs with polytopic constraints when the nonlinear continuous objective function is approximated by a PieceWise-Affine (PWA) counterpart. By leveraging perturbation analysis using a convex modulus, we derive guaranteed bounds on the distance between the optimal solution of the original polytopically-constrained NLP and that of its approximated formulation. Our approach aids in determining criteria for achieving desired solution bounds. Two case studies on the Eggholder function and nonlinear model predictive control of an inverted pendulum demonstrate the theoretical results.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Proactive Emergency Collision Avoidance for Automated Driving in Highway Scenarios
Authors:
Leila Gharavi,
Azita Dabiri,
Jelske Verkuijlen,
Bart De Schutter,
Simone Baldi
Abstract:
Uncertainty in the behavior of other traffic participants is a crucial factor in collision avoidance for automated driving; here, stochastic metrics should often be considered to avoid overly conservative decisions. This paper introduces a Stochastic Model Predictive Control (SMPC) planner for emergency collision avoidance in highway scenarios to proactively minimize collision risk while ensuring…
▽ More
Uncertainty in the behavior of other traffic participants is a crucial factor in collision avoidance for automated driving; here, stochastic metrics should often be considered to avoid overly conservative decisions. This paper introduces a Stochastic Model Predictive Control (SMPC) planner for emergency collision avoidance in highway scenarios to proactively minimize collision risk while ensuring safety through chance constraints. To address the challenge of guaranteeing the feasibility for the emergency trajectory, we incorporate nonlinear tire dynamics in the prediction model of the ego vehicle. Further, we exploit Max-Min-Plus-Scaling (MMPS) approximations of the nonlinearities to avoid conservatism, enforce proactive collision avoidance, and improve computational efficiency in terms of performance and speed. Consequently, our contributions include integrating a dynamic ego vehicle model into the SMPC planner, introducing the MMPS approximation for real-time implementation in emergency scenarios, and integrating SMPC with hybridized chance constraints and risk minimization. We evaluate our SMPC formulation in terms of proactivity and efficiency in various hazardous scenarios. Moreover, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed approach by comparing it with a state-of-the-art SMPC planner and validate the feasibility of generated trajectories using a high-fidelity vehicle model in IPG CarMaker.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Efficient MPC for Emergency Evasive Maneuvers, Part II: Comparative Assessment for Hybrid Control
Authors:
Leila Gharavi,
Bart De Schutter,
Simone Baldi
Abstract:
Optimization-based approaches such as Model Predictive Control (MPC) are promising approaches in proactive control for safety-critical applications with changing environments such as automated driving systems. However, the computational complexity of the MPC optimization problem coupled with the need for real-time control in hazardous scenarios is the main bottleneck in realization of automation l…
▽ More
Optimization-based approaches such as Model Predictive Control (MPC) are promising approaches in proactive control for safety-critical applications with changing environments such as automated driving systems. However, the computational complexity of the MPC optimization problem coupled with the need for real-time control in hazardous scenarios is the main bottleneck in realization of automation levels four and five for driving systems. In this paper, we construct hybrid formulations of the nonlinear MPC problem for tracking control during emergency evasive maneuvers and assess their computational efficiency in terms of accuracy and solution time. To hybridize the MPC problem, we combine three hybrid approximations of the prediction model and four approximations of the nonlinear stability and tire saturation constraints and simulate the closed-loop behavior of the resulting controllers during five emergency maneuvers for different prediction horizons. Further, we compare the robustness of the controllers in the presence of friction uncertainty as well to assess the accuracy-time trade-off in cases where the friction of the road is either unknown or has an offset error with respect to the prediction model. This robustness is studied for different levels of friction uncertainty, as well as investigated with respect to the proximity to the vehicle handling limits. We show that the hybridization of the MPC problem is an efficient approach for real-time implementation of MPC during emergency evasive maneuvers, paving the way for implementation of high levels of automation.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Efficient MPC for Emergency Evasive Maneuvers, Part I: Hybridization of the Nonlinear Problem
Authors:
Leila Gharavi,
Bart De Schutter,
Simone Baldi
Abstract:
Despite the extensive application of nonlinear Model Predictive Control (MPC) in automated driving, balancing its computational efficiency with respect to the control performance and constraint satisfaction remains a challenge in emergency scenarios: in such situations, sub-optimal but computationally fast responses are more valuable than optimal responses obtained after long computations. In this…
▽ More
Despite the extensive application of nonlinear Model Predictive Control (MPC) in automated driving, balancing its computational efficiency with respect to the control performance and constraint satisfaction remains a challenge in emergency scenarios: in such situations, sub-optimal but computationally fast responses are more valuable than optimal responses obtained after long computations. In this paper, we introduce a hybridization approach for efficient approximation of nonlinear vehicle dynamics and non-convex constraints using a hybrid systems modeling framework. Hybridization allows to reformulate the nonlinear MPC problem during emergency evasive maneuvers as a hybrid MPC problem. In this regard, Max-Min-Plus-Scaling (MMPS) hybrid modeling is used to approximate the nonlinear vehicle dynamics. Meanwhile, different formulations for constraint approximation are presented, and various grid-generation methods are compared to solve these approximation problems. Among these, two novel grid types are introduced to structurally include the influence of the system dynamics on the grid point distributions in the state domain. Overall, the work presents and compares three hybrid models and four hybrid constraints for efficient MPC synthesis and offers guidelines for implementation of the presented hybridization framework in other applications.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
CHARTOPOLIS: A Small-Scale Labor-art-ory for Research and Reflection on Autonomous Vehicles, Human-Robot Interaction, and Sociotechnical Imaginaries
Authors:
Sangeet Sankaramangalam Ulhas,
Aditya Ravichander,
Kathryn A. Johnson,
Theodore P. Pavlic,
Lance Gharavi,
Spring Berman
Abstract:
CHARTOPOLIS is a multi-faceted sociotechnical testbed meant to aid in building connections among engineers, psychologists, anthropologists, ethicists, and artists. Superficially, it is an urban autonomous-vehicle testbed that includes both a physical environment for small-scale robotic vehicles as well as a high-fidelity virtual replica that provides extra flexibility by way of computer simulation…
▽ More
CHARTOPOLIS is a multi-faceted sociotechnical testbed meant to aid in building connections among engineers, psychologists, anthropologists, ethicists, and artists. Superficially, it is an urban autonomous-vehicle testbed that includes both a physical environment for small-scale robotic vehicles as well as a high-fidelity virtual replica that provides extra flexibility by way of computer simulation. However, both environments have been developed to allow for participatory simulation with human drivers as well. Each physical vehicle can be remotely operated by human drivers that have a driver-seat point of view that immerses them within the small-scale testbed, and those same drivers can also pilot high-fidelity models of those vehicles in a virtual replica of the environment. Juxtaposing human driving performance across these two contexts will help identify to what extent human driving behaviors are sensorimotor responses or involve psychological engagement with a system that has physical, not virtual, side effects and consequences. Furthermore, through collaboration with artists, we have designed the physical testbed to make tangible the reality that technological advancement causes the history of a city to fork into multiple, parallel timelines that take place within populations whose increasing isolation effectively creates multiple independent cities in one. Ultimately, CHARTOPOLIS is meant to challenge engineers to take a more holistic view when designing autonomous systems, while also enabling them to gather novel data that will assist them in making these systems more trustworthy.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
