Showing 1–50 of 54 results for author: Gastine, T

Zonostrophic turbulence in the subsurface oceans of the Jovian and Saturnian moons

Authors: S. Cabanes, T. Gastine, A. Fournier

Abstract: In order to characterize the global circulation of the subsurface ocean of Jovian and Saturnian moons, we analyze the properties of 21 three-dimensional simulations of Boussinesq thermal convection in a rapidly rotating spherical shell. Flow is driven by an adverse temperature contrast imposed across the domain, and is subjected to no-slip boundary conditions. We cover a region of parameter space… ▽ More In order to characterize the global circulation of the subsurface ocean of Jovian and Saturnian moons, we analyze the properties of 21 three-dimensional simulations of Boussinesq thermal convection in a rapidly rotating spherical shell. Flow is driven by an adverse temperature contrast imposed across the domain, and is subjected to no-slip boundary conditions. We cover a region of parameter space previously unexplored by global simulations, both in terms of rapid rotation and vigor of convective forcing, closer to, yet still admittedly far from, the conditions appropriate for the subsurface ocean of Ganymede, Europa, Enceladus, and Titan. Our most extreme simulations exhibit a dynamic global circulation that combines powerful east-west zonal jets, planetary waves, and vortices. A spectral analysis of the kinetic energy distribution performed in cylindrical geometry reveals a high degree of anisotropy of the simulated flows. Specifically, the axisymmetric zonal energy spectra follow a steep $-5$ slope in wavenumber space, with the energy amplitude exclusively controlled by the rotation rate. In contrast, the non-axisymmetric residual spectra display a gentle $-5/3$ slope, with the energy amplitude controlled by the thermal buoyancy input power. This spectral behavior conforms with the theory of zonostrophic turbulence and allows us to propose tentative extrapolations of these findings to the more extreme conditions of icy satellites. By assuming that kinetic energy dissipates via Ekman friction we predict an upper bound for the zonal velocity ranging from a few centimeters per second for Enceladus to about one meter per second for Ganymede, with residual velocities smaller than the zonal velocity by an order of magnitude on each moon. These predictions yield typical jets size approaching the ocean depth of Titan, Ganymede and Europa and $10$ to $40\%$ of the ocean depth on Enceladus. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2024; v1 submitted 4 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 24 pages, 12 figures, 3 tables, accepted for publication in Icarus

Quasi-geostrophic convection-driven dynamos in a thick spherical shell

Authors: Olivier Barrois, Thomas Gastine, Christopher C. Finlay

Abstract: We present dynamos computed using a hybrid QG-3D numerical scheme in a thick spherical shell geometry. Our model is based on a quasi-geostrophic convection code extended with a 3D treatment of heat transport and magnetic induction. We find a collection of self-sustained, multipolar, weak field dynamos with magnetic energy one or two orders of magnitude lower than the kinetic energy. The poloidal m… ▽ More We present dynamos computed using a hybrid QG-3D numerical scheme in a thick spherical shell geometry. Our model is based on a quasi-geostrophic convection code extended with a 3D treatment of heat transport and magnetic induction. We find a collection of self-sustained, multipolar, weak field dynamos with magnetic energy one or two orders of magnitude lower than the kinetic energy. The poloidal magnetic energy is weak and, by construction, there is a lack of equatorially anti-symmetric components in the Buoyancy and Lorentz forces. This leads to configurations where the velocity field is only weakly impacted by the magnetic field, similar to dynamos found in 3D simulations where zonal flows and the $Ω$-effect dominate. The time-dependence of these dynamos is characterised by quasi-periodic oscillations that we attribute to dynamo waves. The QG-3D dynamos found so far are not Earth-like. The inability of our setup to produce strong, dipole-dominated, magnetic fields likely points to a missing ingredient in our QG flows, and a related lack of helicity and $α$-effect. The models presented here may be more relevant for studying stellar dynamos where zonal flows are known to dominate. This study was carried out at modest control parameters, however moving to lower Ekman numbers, when smaller values of both the magnetic and hydrodynamic Prandtl numbers can be of interest, our approach will be able to gain in efficiency by using relatively coarse grids for the 3D magnetic and temperature fields and a finer grid for the QG velocity field. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: Geophysical Journal International publication; Earth core magnetic field; Dynamo modelling; Quasi-geostrophic flows; 18 pages; 9 figures

Comparison of Quasi-Geostrophic, Hybrid and 3D models of planetary core convection

Authors: Olivier Barrois, Thomas Gastine, Christopher C. Finlay

Abstract: We present investigations of rapidly-rotating convection in a thick spherical shell geometry relevant to planetary cores, comparing results from Quasi-Geostrophic, 3D and hybrid QG-3D models. The 170 reported calculations span Ekman numbers, $Ek$, between $10^{-4}$ and $10^{-10}$, Rayleigh numbers, $Ra$, between $2$ and $150$ times supercritical, and Prandtl numbers, $Pr$, between $10$ and… ▽ More We present investigations of rapidly-rotating convection in a thick spherical shell geometry relevant to planetary cores, comparing results from Quasi-Geostrophic, 3D and hybrid QG-3D models. The 170 reported calculations span Ekman numbers, $Ek$, between $10^{-4}$ and $10^{-10}$, Rayleigh numbers, $Ra$, between $2$ and $150$ times supercritical, and Prandtl numbers, $Pr$, between $10$ and $10^{-2}$. In general, we find convection is dominated by zonal jets at mid-depths in the shell, with thermal Rossby waves prominent close to the outer boundary when the driving is weaker. For the specific geometry studied here the hybrid method is best suited for studying convection at modest forcing, $Ra \leq 10 \, Ra_c$ when $Pr=1$, and departs from the 3D model results at higher $Ra$, displaying systematically lower heat transport. We find that the lack of equatorially anti-symmetric and $z$-correlations between temperature and velocity in the buoyancy force contributes to the weaker flows in the hybrid formulation. On the other hand, the QG models yield broadly similar results to the 3D models, for the specific range of parameters explored here. We cannot point to major disagreements between these two datasets at $Pr \geq 0.1$, although the QG model is effectively more strongly driven than the hybrid case. When $Pr$ is decreased, the range of agreement between the Hybrid and 3D models expands, indicating the hybrid method may be better suited to study convection in the regime $Pr \ll 1$. Previously proposed scaling laws for rapidly-rotating convection are retrieved: our simulations are overall well described by a triple balance between Coriolis, inertia and Archimedean forces with the length-scale of the convection following the diffusion-free Rhines-scaling. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: Geophysical Journal International publication; Earth core; Thermal convection; Quasi-geostrophic flows; 29 pages; 15 figures

Journal ref: GJI, 2022, 231, 129-158

Fingering convection in a spherical shell

Authors: T. Tassin, T. Gastine, A. Fournier

Abstract: We use 123 three dimensional direct numerical simulations to study fingering convection in non-rotating spherical shells. We investigate the scaling behaviour of the flow lengthscale, the non-dimensional heat and compositional fluxes $Nu$ and $Sh$ and the mean convective velocity over the fingering convection instability domain defined by $1 \leq R_ρ< Le$, $R_ρ$ being the ratio of density perturba… ▽ More We use 123 three dimensional direct numerical simulations to study fingering convection in non-rotating spherical shells. We investigate the scaling behaviour of the flow lengthscale, the non-dimensional heat and compositional fluxes $Nu$ and $Sh$ and the mean convective velocity over the fingering convection instability domain defined by $1 \leq R_ρ< Le$, $R_ρ$ being the ratio of density perturbations of thermal and compositional origins and $Le$ the Lewis number. We show that the chemical boundary layers are marginally unstable and adhere to the laminar Prandtl-Blasius model, hence explaining the asymmetry between the inner and outer spherical shell boundary layers. We develop scaling laws for two asymptotic regimes close to the two edges of the instability domain, namely $R_ρ\lesssim Le$ and $R_ρ\gtrsim 1$. For the former, we develop novel power laws of a small parameter $ε$ measuring the distance to onset, which differ from theoretical laws published to date in Cartesian geometry. For the latter, we find that the Sherwood number $Sh$ gradually approaches a scaling $Sh\sim Ra_ξ^{1/3}$ when $Ra_ξ\gg 1$; and that the Péclet number accordingly follows $Pe \sim Ra_ξ^{2/3} |Ra_T|^{-1/4}$, $Ra_ξ$ being the chemical Rayleigh number. When the Reynolds number exceeds a few tens, we report on a secondary instability which takes the form of large-scale toroidal jets which span the entire spherical domain. Jets distort the fingers resulting in Reynolds stress correlations, which in turn feed the jet growth until saturation. This nonlinear phenomenon can yield relaxation oscillation cycles. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2024; v1 submitted 4 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 45 pages, 21 figures, 3 tables, accepted for publication in JFM

Latitudinal regionalization of rotating spherical shell convection

Authors: T. Gastine, J. M. Aurnou

Abstract: Convection occurs ubiquitously on and in rotating geophysical and astrophysical bodies. Prior spherical shell studies have shown that the convection dynamics in polar regions can differ significantly from the lower latitude, equatorial dynamics. Yet most spherical shell convective scaling laws use globally-averaged quantities that erase latitudinal differences in the physics. Here we quantify thos… ▽ More Convection occurs ubiquitously on and in rotating geophysical and astrophysical bodies. Prior spherical shell studies have shown that the convection dynamics in polar regions can differ significantly from the lower latitude, equatorial dynamics. Yet most spherical shell convective scaling laws use globally-averaged quantities that erase latitudinal differences in the physics. Here we quantify those latitudinal differences by analyzing spherical shell simulations in terms of their regionalized convective heat transfer properties. This is done by measuring local Nusselt numbers in two specific, latitudinally separate, portions of the shell, the polar and the equatorial regions, $Nu_p$ and $Nu_e$, respectively. In rotating spherical shells, convection first sets in outside the tangent cylinder such that equatorial heat transfer dominates at small and moderate supercriticalities. We show that the buoyancy forcing, parameterized by the Rayleigh number $Ra$, must exceed the critical equatorial forcing by a factor of $\approx 20$ to trigger polar convection within the tangent cylinder. Once triggered, $Nu_p$ increases with $Ra$ much faster than does $Nu_e$. The equatorial and polar heat fluxes then tend to become comparable at sufficiently high $Ra$. Comparisons between the polar convection data and Cartesian numerical simulations reveal quantitative agreement between the two geometries in terms of heat transfer and averaged bulk temperature gradient. This agreement indicates that spherical shell rotating convection dynamics are accessible both through spherical simulations and via reduced investigatory pathways, be they theoretical, numerical or experimental. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 6 figures, accepted for publication in JFM

Transition from multipolar to dipolar dynamos in stratified systems

Authors: B. Zaire, L. Jouve, T. Gastine, J-F. Donati, J. Morin, N. Landin, C. P. Folsom

Abstract: Observations of surface magnetic fields of cool stars reveal a large diversity of configurations. Although there is now a consensus that these fields are generated through dynamo processes occurring within the convective zone, the physical mechanism driving such a variety of field topologies is still debated. This paper discusses the possible origins of dipole and multipole-dominated morphologies… ▽ More Observations of surface magnetic fields of cool stars reveal a large diversity of configurations. Although there is now a consensus that these fields are generated through dynamo processes occurring within the convective zone, the physical mechanism driving such a variety of field topologies is still debated. This paper discusses the possible origins of dipole and multipole-dominated morphologies using three-dimensional numerical simulations of stratified systems where the magnetic feedback on the fluid motion is significant. Our main result is that dipolar solutions are found at Rossby numbers up to 0.4 in strongly stratified simulations, where previous works suggested that only multipolar fields should exist. We argue that these simulations are reminiscent of the outlier stars observed at Rossby numbers larger than 0.1, whose large-scale magnetic field is dominated by their axisymmetric poloidal component. As suggested in previous Boussinesq calculations, the relative importance of inertial over Lorentz forces is again controlling the dipolar to multipolar transition. Alternatively, we find that the ratio of kinetic to magnetic energies can equally well capture the transition in the field morphology. We test the ability of this new proxy to predict the magnetic morphology of a few M-dwarf stars whose internal structure matches that of our simulations and for which homogeneous magnetic field characterization is available. Finally, the magnitude of the differential rotation obtained in our simulations is compared to actual measurements reported in the literature for M-dwarfs. In our simulations, we find a clear relationship between anti-solar differential rotation and the emergence of dipolar fields. △ Less

Submitted 23 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 15 pages, 15 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

An assessment of implicit-explicit time integrators for the pseudo-spectral approximation of Boussinesq thermal convection in an annulus

Authors: V. Gopinath, A. Fournier, T. Gastine

Abstract: We analyze the behaviour of an ensemble of time integrators applied to the semi-discrete problem resulting from the spectral discretization of the equations describing Boussinesq convection in a cylindrical annulus. The equations are cast in a vorticity-streamfunction formulation that yields a differential algebraic equation (DAE). The ensemble comprises 28 members: 4 implicit-explicit multistep s… ▽ More We analyze the behaviour of an ensemble of time integrators applied to the semi-discrete problem resulting from the spectral discretization of the equations describing Boussinesq convection in a cylindrical annulus. The equations are cast in a vorticity-streamfunction formulation that yields a differential algebraic equation (DAE). The ensemble comprises 28 members: 4 implicit-explicit multistep schemes, 22 implicit-explicit Runge-Kutta (IMEX-RK) schemes, and 2 fully explicit schemes used for reference. The schemes are assessed for 11 different physical setups that cover laminar and turbulent regimes. Multistep and order 2 IMEX-RK methods exhibit their expected order of convergence under all circumstances. IMEX-RK methods of higher-order show occasional order reduction that impacts both algebraic and differential field variables. We ascribe the order reduction to the stiffness of the problem and, to a larger extent, the presence of the DAE. Using the popular Crank-Nicolson Adams-Bashforth of order 2 (CNAB2) integrator as reference, performance is defined by the ratio of maximum admissible time step to the cost of performing one iteration; the maximum admissible time step is determined by inspection of the time series of viscous dissipation within the system, which guarantees a physically acceptable solution. Relative performance is bounded between 0.5 and 1.5 across all studied configurations. Considering accuracy jointly with performance, we find that 6 schemes consistently outperform CNAB2, meaning that in addition to allowing for a more efficient calculation, the accuracy that they achieve at their operational limit of stability yields a lower error. In our most turbulent setup, where the behaviour of the methods is almost entirely dictated by their explicit component, 13 IMEX-RK integrators outperform CNAB2 in terms of accuracy and efficiency. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 39 pages, 15 figures, 5 tables, accepted for publication in JCP

Geomagnetic semblance and dipolar-multipolar transition in top-heavy double-diffusive geodynamo models

Authors: Théo Tassin, Thomas Gastine, Alexandre Fournier

Abstract: Convection in the liquid outer core of the Earth is driven by thermal and chemical perturbations. The main purpose of this study is to examine the impact of double-diffusive convection on magnetic field generation by means of 3D global geodynamo models, in the so-called "top-heavy" regime of double-diffusive convection, when both thermal and compositional background gradients are destabilizing. Us… ▽ More Convection in the liquid outer core of the Earth is driven by thermal and chemical perturbations. The main purpose of this study is to examine the impact of double-diffusive convection on magnetic field generation by means of 3D global geodynamo models, in the so-called "top-heavy" regime of double-diffusive convection, when both thermal and compositional background gradients are destabilizing. Using a linear eigensolver, we begin by confirming that, compared to the standard single-diffusive configuration, the onset of convection is facilitated by the addition of a second buoyancy source. We next carry out a systematic parameter survey by performing $79$ numerical dynamo simulations. We show that a good agreement between simulated magnetic fields and the geomagnetic field can be attained for any partitioning of the convective input power between its thermal and chemical components. On the contrary, the transition between dipole-dominated and multipolar dynamos is found to strongly depend on the nature of the buoyancy forcing. Classical parameters expected to govern this transition, such as the local Rossby number or the degree of equatorial symmetry of the flow, fail to capture the dipole breakdown. A scale-dependent analysis of the force balance instead reveals that the transition occurs when the ratio of inertial to Lorentz forces at the dominant length scale reaches $0.5$, regardless of the partitioning of the buoyancy power. The ratio of integrated kinetic to magnetic energy $E_k/E_m$ provides a reasonable proxy of this force ratio. Given that $E_k/E_m \ll 1$ in the Earth's core, the geodynamo is expected to operate far from the dipole-multipole transition. It hence appears that the occurrence of geomagnetic reversals is unlikely related to dramatic and punctual changes of the amplitude of inertial forces in the Earth's core, and that another mechanism must be sought. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2021; v1 submitted 11 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Stable stratification promotes multiple zonal jets in a turbulent Jovian dynamo model

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Wicht

Abstract: The ongoing NASA's Juno mission puts new constraints on the internal dynamics of Jupiter. Data gathered by its onboard magnetometer reveal a dipole-dominated surface magnetic field accompanied by strong localised magnetic flux patches. The gravity measurements indicate that the fierce surface zonal jets extend several thousands of kilometers below the cloud level before rapidly decaying below… ▽ More The ongoing NASA's Juno mission puts new constraints on the internal dynamics of Jupiter. Data gathered by its onboard magnetometer reveal a dipole-dominated surface magnetic field accompanied by strong localised magnetic flux patches. The gravity measurements indicate that the fierce surface zonal jets extend several thousands of kilometers below the cloud level before rapidly decaying below $0.94-0.96\,R_J$, $R_J$ being the mean Jovian radius at the one bar level. Several internal models suggest an intricate internal structure with a thin intermediate region in which helium would segregate from hydrogen, forming a compositionally-stratified layer. Here, we develop the first global Jovian dynamo which incorporates an intermediate stably-stratified layer between $0.82\,R_J$ and $0.86\,R_J$. Analysing the energy balance reveals that the magnetic energy is almost one order of magnitude larger than kinetic energy in the metallic region, while most of the kinetic energy is pumped into zonal motions in the molecular envelope. Those result from the different underlying force hierarchy with a triple balance between Lorentz, Archimedean and ageostrophic Coriolis forces in the metallic core and inertia, buoyancy and ageostrophic Coriolis forces controlling the external layers. The simulation presented here is the first to demonstrate that multiple zonal jets and dipole-dominated dynamo action can be consolidated in a global simulation. The inclusion of an stable layer is a necessary ingredient that allows zonal jets to develop in the outer envelope without contributing to the dynamo action in the deeper metallic region. Stable stratification however also smooths out the small-scale features of the magnetic field by skin effect. These constraints suggest that possible stable layers in Jupiter should be located much closer to the surface ($0.9-0.95\,R_J$). △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 2021; v1 submitted 11 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 23 pages, 16 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in Icarus

Relating force balances and flow length scales in geodynamo simulations

Authors: Tobias Schwaiger, Thomas Gastine, Julien Aubert

Abstract: In fluid dynamics, the scaling behaviour of flow length scales is commonly used to infer the governing force balance of a system. The key to a successful approach is to measure length scales that are representative of the energy contained in the solution (energetically relevant) and indicative of the established force balance (dynamically relevant). In numerical simulations of rotating convection… ▽ More In fluid dynamics, the scaling behaviour of flow length scales is commonly used to infer the governing force balance of a system. The key to a successful approach is to measure length scales that are representative of the energy contained in the solution (energetically relevant) and indicative of the established force balance (dynamically relevant). In numerical simulations of rotating convection and magneto-hydrodynamic dynamos in spherical shells, it has remained difficult to measure length scales that are both energetically and dynamically relevant, which has led to conflicting interpretations of the underlying force balance. By analysing an extensive set of magnetic and non-magnetic models, we focus on two length scales that achieve both energetic and dynamical relevance. The first one is the peak of the poloidal kinetic energy spectrum, which we successfully compare to crossover points on spectral representations of the force balance. In most dynamo models, this result confirms that the dominant length scale of the system is controlled by a quasi-geostrophic (QG-) MAC (Magneto-Archimedean-Coriolis) balance. In non-magnetic convection models, the analysis favours a QG-CIA (Coriolis-Inertia-Archimedean) balance. In dynamo models, we introduce a second energetically relevant length scale associated with the loss of axial invariance in the flow. We again relate this length scale to a crossover point in scale-dependent force balance diagrams, which marks the transition between large-scale geostrophy (the equilibrium of Coriolis and pressure forces) and small-scale magnetostrophy, where the Lorentz force overtakes the Coriolis force. Scaling analysis of these two energetically and dynamically relevant length scales suggests that the Earth's dynamo is controlled by a QG-MAC balance at a dominant scale of about 200 km, while magnetostrophic effects are deferred to scales smaller than 50 km. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Magnetar formation through a convective dynamo in protoneutron stars

Authors: Raphaël Raynaud, Jérôme Guilet, Hans-Thomas Janka, Thomas Gastine

Abstract: The release of spin-down energy by a magnetar is a promising scenario to power several classes of extreme explosive transients. However, it lacks a firm basis because magnetar formation still represents a theoretical challenge. Using the first three-dimensional simulations of a convective dynamo based on a protoneutron star interior model, we demonstrate that the required dipolar magnetic field ca… ▽ More The release of spin-down energy by a magnetar is a promising scenario to power several classes of extreme explosive transients. However, it lacks a firm basis because magnetar formation still represents a theoretical challenge. Using the first three-dimensional simulations of a convective dynamo based on a protoneutron star interior model, we demonstrate that the required dipolar magnetic field can be consistently generated for sufficiently fast rotation rates. The dynamo instability saturates in the magnetostrophic regime with the magnetic energy exceeding the kinetic energy by a factor of up to 10. Our results are compatible with the observational constraints on galactic magnetar field strength and provide strong theoretical support for millisecond protomagnetar models of gamma-ray burst and superluminous supernova central engines. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Science Advances, 2020, Vol. 6, no. 11, eaay2732

Dynamo-based limit to the extent of a stable layer atop Earth's core

Authors: Thomas Gastine, Julien Aubert, Alexandre Fournier

Abstract: The existence of a stably stratified layer underneath the core-mantle boundary (CMB) has been recently revived by corroborating evidences coming from seismic studies, mineral physics and thermal evolution models. Such a layer could find its physical origination either in compositional stratification due to the accumulation of light elements at the top or the core or in thermal stratification due t… ▽ More The existence of a stably stratified layer underneath the core-mantle boundary (CMB) has been recently revived by corroborating evidences coming from seismic studies, mineral physics and thermal evolution models. Such a layer could find its physical origination either in compositional stratification due to the accumulation of light elements at the top or the core or in thermal stratification due to the heat flux becoming locally sub-adiabatic. The exact properties of this stably-stratified layer, namely its size $\mathcal{H}_S$ and the degree of its stratification characterised by the Brunt-Väisälä frequency $N$, are however uncertain and highly debated. A stable layer underneath the CMB can have crucial dynamical impacts on the geodynamo. Because of the inhibition of the convective motions, a stable layer is expected to primarily act as a low-pass filter on the magnetic field, smoothing out the rapidly-varying and small-scale features by skin effect. To investigate this effect more systematically, we compute 70 global geodynamo models varying the size of the stably-stratified layer from 0 to 300~km and its amplitude from $N/Ω= 0$ to $N/Ω\simeq 50$, $Ω$ being the rotation rate. We show that the penetration of the convective flow in the stably-stratified layer is controlled by the typical size of the convective eddies and by the local variations of the ratio $N/Ω$. Using quantitative measures of the degree of morphological semblance between the magnetic field obtained in numerical models and the geomagnetic field at the CMB, we establish an upper bound for the stable layer thickness $\mathcal{H}_s < (N/Ω)^{-1} d_c$, $d_c$ being the horizontal size of the convective flow at the base of the stable layer. This defines a strong geomagnetic constraint on the properties of a stably-stratified layer beneath the CMB. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2020; v1 submitted 11 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 17 pages, 9 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in GJI

Dynamo Action of Jupiter's Zonal Winds

Authors: Johannes Wicht, Thomas Gastine, Lucia D. V. Duarte, Wieland Dietrich

Abstract: The new data delivered by NASA's Juno spacecraft significantly increase our understanding of Jupiter's internal dynamics. The gravity data constrain the depth of the zonal flows observed at cloud level and suggest that they slow down considerably at a depth of about $0.96\,r_J$, where $r_J$ is the mean radius at the one bar level. Juno's magnetometer reveals the planet's internal magnetic field. W… ▽ More The new data delivered by NASA's Juno spacecraft significantly increase our understanding of Jupiter's internal dynamics. The gravity data constrain the depth of the zonal flows observed at cloud level and suggest that they slow down considerably at a depth of about $0.96\,r_J$, where $r_J$ is the mean radius at the one bar level. Juno's magnetometer reveals the planet's internal magnetic field. We combine the new zonal flow and magnetic field models with an updated electrical conductivity profile to assess the zonal wind induced dynamo action, concentrating on the outer part of Jupiter's molecular hydrogen region where the conductivity increases very rapidly with depth. Dynamo action remains quasi-stationary and can thus reasonably be estimated where the magnetic Reynolds number remains smaller than one, which is roughly the region above $0.96\,r_J$. We calculate that the locally induced radial magnetic field reaches rms values of about $10^{-6}\,$T in this region and may just be detectable by the Juno mission. Very localized dynamo action and a distinct pattern that reflects the zonal wind system increases the chance to disentangle this locally induced field from the background field. The estimates of the locally induced currents also allow calculating the zonal flow related Ohmic heating and associated entropy production. The respective quantities remain below new revised predictions for the total dissipative heating and total entropy production in Jupiter for any of the explored model combinations. Thus neither Ohmic heating nor entropy production offer additional constraints on the depth of the zonal winds. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 17 pages, 8 figures

Force balance in numerical geodynamo simulations: a systematic study

Authors: T. Schwaiger, T. Gastine, J. Aubert

Abstract: Dynamo action in the Earth's outer core is expected to be controlled by a balance between pressure, Coriolis, buoyancy and Lorentz forces, with marginal contributions from inertia and viscous forces. Current numerical simulations of the geodynamo, however, operate at much larger inertia and viscosity because of computational limitations. This casts some doubt on the physical relevance of these mod… ▽ More Dynamo action in the Earth's outer core is expected to be controlled by a balance between pressure, Coriolis, buoyancy and Lorentz forces, with marginal contributions from inertia and viscous forces. Current numerical simulations of the geodynamo, however, operate at much larger inertia and viscosity because of computational limitations. This casts some doubt on the physical relevance of these models. Our work aims at finding dynamo models in a moderate computational regime which reproduce the leading-order force balance of the Earth. By performing a systematic parameter space survey with Ekman numbers in the range $10^{-6} \leq E \leq 10^{-4}$, we study the variations of the force balance when changing the forcing (Rayleigh number, $Ra$) and the ratio between viscous and magnetic diffusivities (magnetic Prandtl number, $Pm$). For dipole-dominated dynamos, we observe that the force balance is structurally robust throughout the investigated parameter space, exhibiting a quasi-geostrophic (QG) balance (balance between Coriolis and pressure forces) at zeroth order, followed by a first-order MAC balance between the ageostrophic Coriolis, buoyancy and Lorentz forces. At second order this balance is disturbed by contributions from inertia and viscous forces. Dynamos with a different sequence of the forces, where inertia and/or viscosity replace the Lorentz force in the first-order force balance, can only be found close to the onset of dynamo action and in the multipolar regime. Our study illustrates that most classical numerical dynamos are controlled by a QG-MAC balance, while cases where viscosity and inertia play a dominant role are the exception rather than the norm. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

pizza: An open-source pseudo-spectral code for spherical quasi-geostrophic convection

Authors: T. Gastine

Abstract: We present a new pseudo-spectral open-source code nicknamed pizza. It is dedicated to the study of rapidly-rotating Boussinesq convection under the 2-D spherical quasi-geostrophic approximation, a physical hypothesis that is appropriate to model the turbulent convection that develops in planetary interiors. The code uses a Fourier decomposition in the azimuthal direction and supports both a Chebys… ▽ More We present a new pseudo-spectral open-source code nicknamed pizza. It is dedicated to the study of rapidly-rotating Boussinesq convection under the 2-D spherical quasi-geostrophic approximation, a physical hypothesis that is appropriate to model the turbulent convection that develops in planetary interiors. The code uses a Fourier decomposition in the azimuthal direction and supports both a Chebyshev collocation method and a sparse Chebyshev integration formulation in the cylindrically-radial direction. It supports several temporal discretisation schemes encompassing multi-step time steppers as well as diagonally-implicit Runge-Kutta schemes. The code has been tested and validated by comparing weakly-nonlinear convection with the eigenmodes from a linear solver. The comparison of the two radial discretisation schemes has revealed the superiority of the Chebyshev integration method over the classical collocation approach both in terms of memory requirements and operation counts. The good parallelisation efficiency enables the computation of large problem sizes with $\mathcal{O}(10^4\times 10^4)$ grid points using several thousands of ranks. This allows the computation of numerical models in the turbulent regime of quasi-geostrophic convection characterised by large Reynolds $Re$ and yet small Rossby numbers $Ro$. A preliminary result obtained for a strongly supercritical numerical model with a small Ekman number of $10^{-9}$ and a Prandtl number of unity yields $Re\simeq 10^5$ and $Ro \simeq 10^{-4}$. pizza is hence an efficient tool to study spherical quasi-geostrophic convection in a parameter regime inaccessible to current global 3-D spherical shell models. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2019; v1 submitted 19 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 20 pages, 10 figures, 4 tables, accepted for publication in GJI

Dynamo Action in the Steeply Decaying Conductivity Region of Jupiter-like Dynamo Models

Authors: Johannes Wicht, Thomas Gastine, Lucia D. V. Duarte

Abstract: The Juno mission is delivering spectacular data of Jupiter's magnetic field, while the gravity measurements finally allow constraining the depth of the winds observed at cloud level. However, to which degree the zonal winds contribute to the planet's dynamo action remains an open question. Here we explore numerical dynamo simulations that include an Jupiter-like electrical conductivity profile and… ▽ More The Juno mission is delivering spectacular data of Jupiter's magnetic field, while the gravity measurements finally allow constraining the depth of the winds observed at cloud level. However, to which degree the zonal winds contribute to the planet's dynamo action remains an open question. Here we explore numerical dynamo simulations that include an Jupiter-like electrical conductivity profile and successfully model the planet's large scale field. We concentrate on analyzing the dynamo action in the Steeply Decaying Conductivity Region (SDCR) where the high conductivity in the metallic Hydrogen region drops to the much lower values caused by ionization effects in the very outer envelope of the planet. Our simulations show that the dynamo action in the SDCR is strongly ruled by diffusive effects and therefore quasi stationary. The locally induced magnetic field is dominated by the horizontal toroidal field, while the locally induced currents flow mainly in the latitudinal direction. The simple dynamics can be exploited to yield estimates of surprisingly high quality for both the induced field and the electric currents in the SDCR. These could be potentially be exploited to predict the dynamo action of the zonal winds in Jupiter's SDCR but also in other planets. △ Less

Submitted 16 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 39 pages, 19 figures, submitted to JGR planets

Gravity darkening in late-type stars. The Coriolis effect

Authors: Raphaël Raynaud, Michel Rieutord, Ludovic Petitdemange, Thomas Gastine, Bertrand Putigny

Abstract: Recent interferometric data have been used to constrain the brightness distribution at the surface of nearby stars, in particular the so-called gravity darkening that makes fast rotating stars brighter at their poles than at their equator. However, good models of gravity darkening are missing for stars that posses a convective envelope. In order to better understand how rotation affects the heat t… ▽ More Recent interferometric data have been used to constrain the brightness distribution at the surface of nearby stars, in particular the so-called gravity darkening that makes fast rotating stars brighter at their poles than at their equator. However, good models of gravity darkening are missing for stars that posses a convective envelope. In order to better understand how rotation affects the heat transfer in stellar convective envelopes, we focus on the heat flux distribution in latitude at the outer surface of numerical models. We carry out a systematic parameter study of three-dimensional, direct numerical simulations of anelastic convection in rotating spherical shells. Restricting our investigations to hydrodynamical models with a thermal Prandtl number fixed to unity, we consider both thick and thin (solar-like) shells, and vary the stratification over three orders of magnitude. We measure the heat transfer efficiency in terms of the Nusselt number, defined as the output luminosity normalised by the conductive state luminosity. We report diverse Nusselt number profiles in latitude, ranging from brighter (usually at the onset of convection) to darker equator and uniform profiles. We find that the variations of the surface brightness are mainly controlled by the surface value of the local Rossby number: when the Coriolis force dominates the dynamics, the heat flux is weakened in the equatorial region by the zonal wind and enhanced at the poles by convective motions inside the tangent cylinder. In the presence of a strong background density stratification however, as expected in real stars, the increase of the local Rossby number in the outer layers leads to uniformisation of the surface heat flux distribution. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: A&A 609, A124 (2017)

Physical conditions for Jupiter-like dynamo models

Authors: Lucia D. V. Duarte, Johannes Wicht, Thomas Gastine

Abstract: The Juno mission will measure Jupiter's magnetic field with unprecedented precision and provide a wealth of additional data that will allow to constrain the planet's interior structure and dynamics. Here we analyse 66 numerical simulations in order to explore the sensitivity of the dynamo-generated magnetic field to the planets interior properties. The degree l=4 field model VIP4 and up-to-date in… ▽ More The Juno mission will measure Jupiter's magnetic field with unprecedented precision and provide a wealth of additional data that will allow to constrain the planet's interior structure and dynamics. Here we analyse 66 numerical simulations in order to explore the sensitivity of the dynamo-generated magnetic field to the planets interior properties. The degree l=4 field model VIP4 and up-to-date interior models based on ab initio simulations serve as benchmarks. Our results suggest that VIP4-like magnetic fields can be found for a number of different models. We find that whether we assume an ideal gas or use the more realistic interior model based on ab initio simulations makes no difference. However, two other factors are important. Low Rayleigh number leads to strong axial dipole contribution while the axial dipole dominance is lost when the convective driving is too strong. The required intermediate range that yields Jupiter-like magnetic fields depends on the other system properties. The second factor is the convective magnetic Reynolds number profile Rmc(r), a product of the non-axisymmetric flow velocity and electrical conductivity. We find that the depth where Rmc exceeds about 50 is a good proxy for the top of the dynamo region. When the dynamo region sits too deep, the axial dipole is once more too dominant due to geometric reasons. We extrapolated our results to Jupiter and the result suggests that the Jovian dynamo extends to 95% of the planetary radius. The zonal flows in our simulations are dominated by an equatorial jet largely confined to the molecular layer. Where the jet reaches down to higher electrical conductivities, it is gives rise to a secondary alpha-Omega dynamo that modifies the dipole-dominated field produced deeper in the planet. This secondary dynamo can lead to strong magnetic field patches at low latitudes that seem compatible with the VIP4 model. △ Less

Submitted 12 September, 2017; v1 submitted 8 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 22 pages, 12 figures, 3 tables, submitted to Icarus

Spherical convective dynamos in the rapidly rotating asymptotic regime

Authors: Julien Aubert, Thomas Gastine, Alexandre Fournier

Abstract: Self-sustained convective dynamos in planetary systems operate in an asymptotic regime of rapid rotation, where a balance is thought to hold between the Coriolis, pressure, buoyancy and Lorentz forces (the MAC balance). Classical numerical solutions have previously been obtained in a regime of moderate rotation where viscous and inertial forces are still significant. We define a unidimensional pat… ▽ More Self-sustained convective dynamos in planetary systems operate in an asymptotic regime of rapid rotation, where a balance is thought to hold between the Coriolis, pressure, buoyancy and Lorentz forces (the MAC balance). Classical numerical solutions have previously been obtained in a regime of moderate rotation where viscous and inertial forces are still significant. We define a unidimensional path in parameter space between classical models and asymptotic conditions from the requirements to enforce a MAC balance and to preserve the ratio between the magnetic diffusion and convective overturn times (the magnetic Reynolds number). Direct numerical simulations performed along this path show that the spatial structure of the solution at scales larger than the magnetic dissipation length is largely invariant. This enables the definition of large-eddy simulations resting on the assumption that small-scale details of the hydrodynamic turbulence are irrelevant to the determination of the large-scale asymptotic state. These simulations are shown to be in good agreement with direct simulations in the range where both are feasible, and can be computed for control parameter values far beyond the current state of the art, such as an Ekman number $E=10^{-8}$. We obtain strong-field convective dynamos approaching the MAC balance and a Taylor state to an unprecedented degree of accuracy. The physical connection between classical models and asymptotic conditions is shown to be devoid of abrupt transitions, demonstrating the asymptotic relevance of classical numerical dynamo mechanisms. The fields of the system are confirmed to follow diffusivity-free, power-based scaling laws along the path. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2018; v1 submitted 15 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: 32 pages, 13 figures. ATTENTION: the version published in JFM has a legend mismatch in figure 2. The correct figure 2 can be found here. A corrigendum was submitted to JFM but its publication was declined (correction being too minor)

Journal ref: J. Fluid. Mech. 813, 558-593, 2017

Approaching a realistic force balance in geodynamo simulations

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Thomas Gastine, Ulrich R. Christensen, Scott J. Wolk, Katja Poppenhaeger

Abstract: Earth sustains its magnetic field by a dynamo process driven by convection in the liquid outer core. Geodynamo simulations have been successful in reproducing many observed properties of the geomagnetic field. However, while theoretical considerations suggest that flow in the core is governed by a balance between Lorentz force, rotational force and buoyancy (called MAC balance for Magnetic, Archim… ▽ More Earth sustains its magnetic field by a dynamo process driven by convection in the liquid outer core. Geodynamo simulations have been successful in reproducing many observed properties of the geomagnetic field. However, while theoretical considerations suggest that flow in the core is governed by a balance between Lorentz force, rotational force and buoyancy (called MAC balance for Magnetic, Archimedean, Coriolis) with only minute roles for viscous and inertial forces, dynamo simulations must employ viscosity values that are many orders of magnitude larger than in the core due to computational constraints. In typical geodynamo models viscous and inertial forces are not much smaller than the Coriolis force and the Lorentz force plays a sub-dominant role. This has led to conclusions that these simulations are viscously controlled and do not represent the physics of the geodynamo. Here we show by a direct analysis of the relevant forces that a MAC balance can be achieved when the viscosity is reduced to values close to the current practical limit. Lorentz force, buoyancy and the uncompensated (by pressure) part of the Coriolis force are of very similar strength, whereas viscous and inertia are smaller by a factor of at least 20 in the bulk of the fluid volume. Compared to non-magnetic convection at otherwise identical parameters, the dynamo flow is of larger scale, less invariant parallel to the rotation axis (less geostrophic) and convection transports twice as much heat, all of which is expected when the Lorentz force strongly influences the convection properties. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: Accepted for publication in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)

Reversal and amplification of zonal flows by boundary enforced thermal wind

Authors: Wieland Dietrich, Thomas Gastine, Johannes Wicht

Abstract: Zonal flows in rapidly-rotating celestial objects such as the Sun, gas or ice giants form in a variety of surface patterns and amplitudes. Whereas the differential rotation on the Sun, Jupiter and Saturn features a super-rotating equatorial region, the ice giants, Neptune and Uranus harbour an equatorial jet slower than the planetary rotation. Global numerical models covering the optically thick,… ▽ More Zonal flows in rapidly-rotating celestial objects such as the Sun, gas or ice giants form in a variety of surface patterns and amplitudes. Whereas the differential rotation on the Sun, Jupiter and Saturn features a super-rotating equatorial region, the ice giants, Neptune and Uranus harbour an equatorial jet slower than the planetary rotation. Global numerical models covering the optically thick, deep-reaching and rapidly rotating convective envelopes of gas giants reproduce successfully the prograde jet at the equator. In such models, convective columns shaped by the dominant Coriolis force typically exhibit a consistent prograde tilt. Hence angular momentum is pumped away from the rotation axis via Reynolds stresses. Those models are found to be strongly geostrophic, hence a modulation of the zonal flow structure along the axis of rotation, e.g. introduced by persistent latitudinal temperature gradients, seems of minor importance. Within our study we stimulate these thermal gradients and the resulting ageostrophic flows by applying an axisymmetric and equatorially symmetric outer boundary heat flux anomaly ($Y_{20}$) with variable amplitude and sign. Such a forcing pattern mimics the thermal effect of intense solar or stellar irradiation. Our results suggest that the ageostrophic flows are linearly amplified with the forcing amplitude $q^\star$ leading to a more pronounced dimple of the equatorial jet (alike Jupiter). The geostrophic flow contributions, however, are suppressed for weak $q^\star$, but inverted and re-amplified once $q^\star$ exceeds a critical value. The inverse geostrophic differential rotation is consistently maintained by now also inversely tilted columns and reminiscent of zonal flow profiles observed for the ice giants. Analysis of the main force balance and parameter studies further foster these results. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Scaling regimes in spherical shell rotating convection

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Wicht, J. Aubert

Abstract: Rayleigh-Bénard convection in rotating spherical shells can be considered as a simplified analogue of many astrophysical and geophysical fluid flows. Here, we use three-dimensional direct numerical simulations to study this physical process. We construct a dataset of more than 200 numerical models that cover a broad parameter range with Ekman numbers spanning $3\times 10^{-7} \leq E \leq 10^{-1}$,… ▽ More Rayleigh-Bénard convection in rotating spherical shells can be considered as a simplified analogue of many astrophysical and geophysical fluid flows. Here, we use three-dimensional direct numerical simulations to study this physical process. We construct a dataset of more than 200 numerical models that cover a broad parameter range with Ekman numbers spanning $3\times 10^{-7} \leq E \leq 10^{-1}$, Rayleigh numbers within the range $10^3 < Ra < 2\times 10^{10}$ and a Prandtl number unity. We investigate the scaling behaviours of both local (length scales, boundary layers) and global (Nusselt and Reynolds numbers) properties across various physical regimes from onset of rotating convection to weakly-rotating convection. Close to critical, the convective flow is dominated by a triple force balance between viscosity, Coriolis force and buoyancy. For larger supercriticalities, a subset of our numerical data approaches the asymptotic diffusivity-free scaling of rotating convection $Nu\sim Ra^{3/2}E^{2}$ in a narrow fraction of the parameter space delimited by $6\,Ra_c \leq Ra \leq 0.4\,E^{-8/5}$. Using a decomposition of the viscous dissipation rate into bulk and boundary layer contributions, we establish a theoretical scaling of the flow velocity that accurately describes the numerical data. In rapidly-rotating turbulent convection, the fluid bulk is controlled by a triple force balance between Coriolis, inertia and buoyancy, while the remaining fraction of the dissipation can be attributed to the viscous friction in the Ekman layers. Beyond $Ra \simeq E^{-8/5}$, the rotational constraint on the convective flow is gradually lost and the flow properties vary to match the regime changes between rotation-dominated and non-rotating convection. The quantity $Ra E^{12/7}$ provides an accurate transition parameter to separate rotating and non-rotating convection. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2016; v1 submitted 8 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 42 pages, 20 figures, 3 tables, accepted for publication in JFM

Helicity inversion in spherical convection as a means for equatorward dynamo wave propagation

Authors: Lúcia D. V. Duarte, Johannes Wicht, Matthew K. Browning, Thomas Gastine

Abstract: We discuss here a purely hydrodynamical mechanism to invert the sign of the kinetic helicity, which plays a key role in determining the direction of propagation of cyclical magnetism in most models of dynamo action by rotating convection. Such propagation provides a prominent, and puzzling constraint on dynamo models. In the Sun, active regions emerge first at mid-latitudes, then appear nearer the… ▽ More We discuss here a purely hydrodynamical mechanism to invert the sign of the kinetic helicity, which plays a key role in determining the direction of propagation of cyclical magnetism in most models of dynamo action by rotating convection. Such propagation provides a prominent, and puzzling constraint on dynamo models. In the Sun, active regions emerge first at mid-latitudes, then appear nearer the equator over the course of a cycle, but most previous global-scale dynamo simulations have exhibited poleward propagation (if they were cyclical at all). Here, we highlight some simulations in which the direction of propagation of dynamo waves is altered primarily by an inversion of the kinetic helicity throughout much of the interior, rather than by changes in the differential rotation. This tends to occur in cases with a low Prandtl number and internal heating, in regions where the local density gradient is relatively small. We analyse how this inversion arises, and contrast it to the case of convection that is either highly columnar (i.e., rapidly rotating) or locally very stratified; in both of those situations, the typical profile of kinetic helicity (negative throughout most of the northern hemisphere) instead prevails. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2015; v1 submitted 18 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 17 pages, 16 figures, 1 table, accepted in MNRAS

Explaining the coexistence of large-scale and small-scale magnetic fields in fully convective stars

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Ulrich R. Christensen, Julien Morin, Thomas Gastine, Ansgar Reiners, Katja Poppenhaeger, Scott J. Wolk

Abstract: Despite the lack of a shear-rich tachocline region low-mass fully convective stars are capable of generating strong magnetic fields, indicating that a dynamo mechanism fundamentally different from the solar dynamo is at work in these objects. We present a self-consistent three dimensional model of magnetic field generation in low-mass fully convective stars. The model utilizes the anelastic magnet… ▽ More Despite the lack of a shear-rich tachocline region low-mass fully convective stars are capable of generating strong magnetic fields, indicating that a dynamo mechanism fundamentally different from the solar dynamo is at work in these objects. We present a self-consistent three dimensional model of magnetic field generation in low-mass fully convective stars. The model utilizes the anelastic magnetohydrodynamic equations to simulate compressible convection in a rotating sphere. A distributed dynamo working in the model spontaneously produces a dipole-dominated surface magnetic field of the observed strength. The interaction of this field with the turbulent convection in outer layers shreds it, producing small-scale fields that carry most of the magnetic flux. The Zeeman-Doppler-Imaging technique applied to synthetic spectropolarimetric data based on our model recovers most of the large-scale field. Our model simultaneously reproduces the morphology and magnitude of the large-scale field as well as the magnitude of the small-scale field observed on low-mass fully convective stars. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: Double column format, 6 pages, 5 figures. To appear in ApJL

Effect of shear and magnetic field on the heat-transfer efficiency of convection in rotating spherical shells

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Thomas Gastine, Ulrich R. Christensen, Lucia Duarte, Ansgar Reiners

Abstract: We study rotating thermal convection in spherical shells. We base our analysis on a set of about 450 direct numerical simulations of the (magneto)hydrodynamic equations under the Boussinesq approximation. The Ekman number ranges from $10^{-3}$ to $10^{-5}$. The supercriticality of the convection reaches about 1000 in some models. Four sets of simulations are considered: non-magnetic simulations an… ▽ More We study rotating thermal convection in spherical shells. We base our analysis on a set of about 450 direct numerical simulations of the (magneto)hydrodynamic equations under the Boussinesq approximation. The Ekman number ranges from $10^{-3}$ to $10^{-5}$. The supercriticality of the convection reaches about 1000 in some models. Four sets of simulations are considered: non-magnetic simulations and dynamo simulations with either free-slip or no-slip flow boundary conditions. The non-magnetic setup with free-slip boundaries generates the strongest zonal flows. Both non-magnetic simulations with no-slip flow boundary conditions and self-consistent dynamos with free-slip boundaries have drastically reduced zonal-flows. Suppression of shear leads to a substantial gain in heat-transfer efficiency, increasing by a factor of 3 in some cases. Such efficiency enhancement occurs as long as the convection is significantly influenced by rotation. At higher convective driving the heat-transfer efficiency tends towards that of the classical non-rotating Rayleigh-Bénard system. Analysis of the latitudinal distribution of heat flow at the outer boundary reveals that the shear is most effective at suppressing heat-transfer in the equatorial regions. Furthermore, we explore the influence of the magnetic field on the {\em non-zonal} flow components of the convection. For this we compare the heat-transfer efficiency of no-slip non-magnetic cases with that of the no-slip dynamo simulations. We find that at $E=10^{-5}$ magnetic field significantly affects the convection and a maximum gain of about 30\% (as compared to the non-magnetic case) in heat-transfer efficiency is obtained for an Elsasser number of about 3. Our analysis motivates us to speculate that convection in the polar regions in dynamos at $E=10^{-5}$ is probably in a `magnetostrophic' regime. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2015; v1 submitted 13 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 15 pages, double column format, 10 figures. Substantial modifications in version 2. Data for shells with aspect ratio 0.35 ("Supple_data") can be found in the source. To appear in "Geophysical Journal International"

Evolution of a magnetic field in a differentially rotating radiative zone

Authors: Mathieu Gaurat, Laurène Jouve, François Lignières, Thomas Gastine

Abstract: Recent spectropolarimetric surveys of main-sequence intermediate-mass stars have exhibited a dichotomy in the distribution of the observed magnetic field between the kG dipoles of Ap/Bp stars and the sub-Gauss magnetism of Vega and Sirius. We would like to test whether this dichotomy is linked to the stability versus instability of large-scale magnetic configurations in differentially rotating rad… ▽ More Recent spectropolarimetric surveys of main-sequence intermediate-mass stars have exhibited a dichotomy in the distribution of the observed magnetic field between the kG dipoles of Ap/Bp stars and the sub-Gauss magnetism of Vega and Sirius. We would like to test whether this dichotomy is linked to the stability versus instability of large-scale magnetic configurations in differentially rotating radiative zones. We computed the axisymmetric magnetic field obtained from the evolution of a dipolar field threading a differentially rotating shell. A full parameter study including various density profiles and initial and boundary conditions was performed with a 2D numerical code. We then focused on the ratio between the toroidal and poloidal components of the magnetic field and discuss the stability of the configurations dominated by the toroidal component using local stability criteria and insights from recent 3D numerical simulations. The numerical results and a simple model show that the ratio between the toroidal and the poloidal magnetic fields is highest after an Alfvén crossing time of the initial poloidal field. For high density contrasts, this ratio converges towards an asymptotic value that can thus be extrapolated to realistic stellar cases. We then consider the stability of the magnetic configurations to non-axisymmetric perturbations and find that configurations dominated by the toroidal component are likely to be unstable if the shear strength is significantly higher than the poloidal Alfvén frequency. An expression for the critical poloidal field below which magnetic fields are likely to be unstable is found and is compared to the lower bound of Ap/Bp magnetic fields. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 13 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: A&A 580, A103 (2015)

Turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection in spherical shells

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Wicht, J. M. Aurnou

Abstract: We simulate numerically Boussinesq convection in non-rotating spherical shells for a fluid with a unity Prandtl number and Rayleigh numbers up to $10^9$. In this geometry, curvature and radial variations of the gravitationnal acceleration yield asymmetric boundary layers. A systematic parameter study for various radius ratios (from $η=r_i/r_o=0.2$ to $η=0.95$) and gravity profiles allows us to exp… ▽ More We simulate numerically Boussinesq convection in non-rotating spherical shells for a fluid with a unity Prandtl number and Rayleigh numbers up to $10^9$. In this geometry, curvature and radial variations of the gravitationnal acceleration yield asymmetric boundary layers. A systematic parameter study for various radius ratios (from $η=r_i/r_o=0.2$ to $η=0.95$) and gravity profiles allows us to explore the dependence of the asymmetry on these parameters. We find that the average plume spacing is comparable between the spherical inner and outer bounding surfaces. An estimate of the average plume separation allows us to accurately predict the boundary layer asymmetry for the various spherical shell configurations explored here. The mean temperature and horizontal velocity profiles are in good agreement with classical Prandtl-Blasius laminar boundary layer profiles, provided the boundary layers are analysed in a dynamical frame, that fluctuates with the local and instantaneous boundary layer thicknesses. The scaling properties of the Nusselt and Reynolds numbers are investigated by separating the bulk and boundary layer contributions to the thermal and viscous dissipation rates using numerical models with $η=0.6$ and a gravity proportional to $1/r^2$. We show that our spherical models are consistent with the predictions of Grossmann \& Lohse's (2000) theory and that $Nu(Ra)$ and $Re(Ra)$ scalings are in good agreement with plane layer results. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2015; v1 submitted 10 April, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Comments: 43 pages, 25 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in JFM

3D evolution of magnetic fields in a differentially rotating stellar radiative zone

Authors: Laurène Jouve, Thomas Gastine, François Lignières

Abstract: The question of the origin and evolution of magnetic fields in stars possessing a radiative envelope, like the A-type stars, is still regarded as a challenge for stellar physics. Those zones are likely to be differentially rotating, which suggests that strong interactions between differential rotation and magnetic fields could be at play. We numerically compute the joint evolution of the magnetic… ▽ More The question of the origin and evolution of magnetic fields in stars possessing a radiative envelope, like the A-type stars, is still regarded as a challenge for stellar physics. Those zones are likely to be differentially rotating, which suggests that strong interactions between differential rotation and magnetic fields could be at play. We numerically compute the joint evolution of the magnetic and velocity fields in a 3D spherical shell starting from an initial profile for the poloidal magnetic field and differential rotation. The poloidal magnetic field is initially wound-up by the differential rotation to produce a toroidal field which becomes unstable. In the particular setup studied here where the differential rotation is dominant, the magneto-rotational instability is triggered. The growth rate of the instability depends mainly on the initial rotation rate, while the background state typically oscillates over a poloidal Alfvén time. We thus find that the axisymmetric magnetic configuration is strongly modified by the instability only if the ratio between the poloidal Alfvén frequency and the rotation rate is sufficiently small. An enhanced transport of angular momentum is found in the most unstable cases: the typical time to flatten the rotation profile is then much faster than the diffusion time scale. We conclude that the magneto-rotational instability is always favored (over the Tayler instability) in unstratified spherical shells when an initial poloidal field is sheared by a sufficiently strong cylindrical differential rotation. A possible application to the magnetic desert observed among A stars is given. We argue that the dichotomy between stars exhibiting strong axisymmetric fields (Ap stars) and those harboring a sub-Gauss magnetism could be linked to the threshold for the instability. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2014; v1 submitted 9 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A, 21 pages, 13 figures

Explaining Jupiter's magnetic field and equatorial jet dynamics

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Wicht, L. Duarte, M. Heimpel, A. Becker

Abstract: Spacecraft data reveal a very Earth-like Jovian magnetic field. This is surprising since numerical simulations have shown that the vastly different interiors of terrestrial and gas planets can strongly affect the internal dynamo process. Here we present the first numerical dynamo that manages to match the structure and strength of the observed magnetic field by embracing the newest models for Jupi… ▽ More Spacecraft data reveal a very Earth-like Jovian magnetic field. This is surprising since numerical simulations have shown that the vastly different interiors of terrestrial and gas planets can strongly affect the internal dynamo process. Here we present the first numerical dynamo that manages to match the structure and strength of the observed magnetic field by embracing the newest models for Jupiter's interior. Simulated dynamo action primarily occurs in the deep high electrical conductivity region while zonal flows are dynamically constrained to a strong equatorial jet in the outer envelope of low conductivity. Our model reproduces the structure and strength of the observed global magnetic field and predicts that secondary dynamo action associated to the equatorial jet produces banded magnetic features likely observable by the Juno mission. Secular variation in our model scales to about 2000 nT per year and should also be observable during the one year nominal mission duration. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2014; v1 submitted 22 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in Geophysical Research Letters

Formation of starspots in self-consistent global dynamo models: Polar spots on cool stars

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Thomas Gastine, Ulrich R. Christensen, Ansgar Reiners

Abstract: Observations of cool stars reveal dark spot-like features on their surfaces. Compared to sunspots, starspots can be bigger or cover a larger fraction of the stellar surface. While sunspots appear only at low latitudes, starspots are also found in polar regions, in particular on rapidly rotating stars. Sunspots are believed to result from the eruption of magnetic flux-tubes rising from the deep int… ▽ More Observations of cool stars reveal dark spot-like features on their surfaces. Compared to sunspots, starspots can be bigger or cover a larger fraction of the stellar surface. While sunspots appear only at low latitudes, starspots are also found in polar regions, in particular on rapidly rotating stars. Sunspots are believed to result from the eruption of magnetic flux-tubes rising from the deep interior of the Sun. The strong magnetic field locally reduces convective heat transport to the solar surface. Such flux-tube models have also been invoked to explain starspot properties. However, these models use several simplifications and so far the generation of either sunspots or starspots has not been demonstrated in a self-consistent simulation of stellar magnetic convection. Here we show that direct numerical simulations of a distributed dynamo operating in a density-stratified rotating spherical shell can spontaneously generate cool spots. Convection in the interior of the model produces a large scale magnetic field which interacts with near surface granular convection leading to strong concentrations of magnetic flux and formation of starspots. Prerequisites for the formation of sizeable high-latitude spots in the model are sufficiently strong density stratification and rapid rotation. Our model presents an alternate mechanism for starspot formation by distributed dynamo action. △ Less

Submitted 20 November, 2014; v1 submitted 11 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 14 pages; Important additions in version 2; To appear in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 573, A68 (2015)

Zonal flow scaling in rapidly-rotating compressible convection

Authors: T. Gastine, M. Heimpel, J. Wicht

Abstract: The surface winds of Jupiter and Saturn are primarily zonal. Each planet exhibits strong prograde equatorial flow flanked by multiple alternating zonal winds at higher latitudes. The depth to which these flows penetrate has long been debated and is still an unsolved problem. Previous rotating convection models that obtained multiple high latitude zonal jets comparable to those on the giant planets… ▽ More The surface winds of Jupiter and Saturn are primarily zonal. Each planet exhibits strong prograde equatorial flow flanked by multiple alternating zonal winds at higher latitudes. The depth to which these flows penetrate has long been debated and is still an unsolved problem. Previous rotating convection models that obtained multiple high latitude zonal jets comparable to those on the giant planets assumed an incompressible (Boussinesq) fluid, which is unrealistic for gas giant planets. Later models of compressible rotating convection obtained only few high latitude jets which were not amenable to scaling analysis. Here we present 3-D numerical simulations of compressible convection in rapidly-rotating spherical shells. To explore the formation and scaling of high-latitude zonal jets, we consider models with a strong radial density variation and a range of Ekman numbers, while maintaining a zonal flow Rossby number characteristic of Saturn. All of our simulations show a strong prograde equatorial jet outside the tangent cylinder. At low Ekman numbers several alternating jets form in each hemisphere inside the tangent cylinder. To analyse jet scaling of our numerical models and of Jupiter and Saturn, we extend Rhines scaling based on a topographic $β$-parameter, which was previously applied to an incompressible fluid in a spherical shell, to compressible fluids. The jet-widths predicted by this modified Rhines length are found to be in relatively good agreement with our numerical model results and with cloud tracking observations of Jupiter and Saturn. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2014; v1 submitted 15 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: 17 pages, 12 figures, 3 tables, accepted for publication in PEPI

A Bcool magnetic snapshot survey of solar-type stars

Authors: S. C. Marsden, P. Petit, S. V. Jeffers, J. Morin, R. Fares, A. Reiners, J. D. do Nascimento Jr., M. Auriere, J. Bouvier, B. D. Carter, C. Catala, B. Dintrans, J. -F. Donati, T. Gastine, M. Jardine, R. Konstantinova-Antova, J. Lanoux, F. Lignieres, A. Morgenthaler, J. C. Ramirez-Velez, S. Theado, V. Van Grootel, the Bcool Collaboration

Abstract: Stellar magnetic field measurements obtained from spectropolarimetry offer key data for activity and dynamo studies, and we present the results of a major high-resolution spectropolarimetric Bcool project magnetic snapshot survey of 170 solar-type stars from observations with the Telescope Bernard Lyot and the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope. For each target star a high signal-to-noise circularly p… ▽ More Stellar magnetic field measurements obtained from spectropolarimetry offer key data for activity and dynamo studies, and we present the results of a major high-resolution spectropolarimetric Bcool project magnetic snapshot survey of 170 solar-type stars from observations with the Telescope Bernard Lyot and the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope. For each target star a high signal-to-noise circularly polarised Stokes V profile has been obtained using Least-Squares Deconvolution, and used to detect surface magnetic fields and measure the corresponding mean surface longitudinal magnetic field ($B_{l}$). Chromospheric activity indicators were also measured. Surface magnetic fields were detected for 67 stars, with 21 of these stars classified as mature solar-type stars, a result that increases by a factor of four the number of mature solar-type stars on which magnetic fields have been observed. In addition, a magnetic field was detected for 3 out of 18 of the subgiant stars surveyed. For the population of K-dwarfs the mean value of $B_{l}$ ($|B_{l}|_{mean}$) was also found to be higher (5.7 G) than $|B_{l}|_{mean}$ measured for the G-dwarfs (3.2 G) and the F-dwarfs (3.3 G). For the sample as a whole $|B_{l}|_{mean}$ increases with rotation rate and decreases with age, and the upper envelope for $|B_{l}|$ correlates well with the observed chromospheric emission. Stars with a chromospheric S-index greater than about 0.2 show a high magnetic field detection rate and so offer optimal targets for future studies. This survey constitutes the most extensive spectropolarimetric survey of cool stars undertaken to date, and suggests that it is feasible to pursue magnetic map** of a wide range of moderately active solar-type stars to improve understanding of their surface fields and dynamos. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2013; originally announced November 2013.

Comments: 36 pages, 26 figures, 7 tables, submitted to MNRAS

From solar-like to anti-solar differential rotation in cool stars

Authors: T. Gastine, R. K. Yadav, J. Morin, A. Reiners, J. Wicht

Abstract: Stellar differential rotation can be separated into two main regimes: solar-like when the equator rotates faster than the poles and anti-solar when the polar regions rotate faster than the equator. We investigate the transition between these two regimes with 3-D numerical simulations of rotating spherical shells. We conduct a systematic parameter study which also includes models from different res… ▽ More Stellar differential rotation can be separated into two main regimes: solar-like when the equator rotates faster than the poles and anti-solar when the polar regions rotate faster than the equator. We investigate the transition between these two regimes with 3-D numerical simulations of rotating spherical shells. We conduct a systematic parameter study which also includes models from different research groups. We find that the direction of the differential rotation is governed by the contribution of the Coriolis force in the force balance, independently of the model setup (presence of a magnetic field, thickness of the convective layer, density stratification). Rapidly-rotating cases with a small Rossby number yield solar-like differential rotation, while weakly-rotating models sustain anti-solar differential rotation. Close to the transition, the two kinds of differential rotation are two possible bistable states. This study provides theoretical support for the existence of anti-solar differential rotation in cool stars with large Rossby numbers. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2013; originally announced November 2013.

Comments: 5 pages, 6 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Bridging planets and stars using scaling laws in anelastic spherical shell dynamos

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Thomas Gastine, Ulrich R. Christensen, Lucia D. V. Duarte

Abstract: Dynamos operating in the interiors of rapidly rotating planets and low-mass stars might belong to a similar category where rotation plays a vital role. We quantify this similarity using scaling laws. We analyse direct numerical simulations of Boussinesq and anelastic spherical shell dynamos. These dynamos represent simplified models which span from Earth-like planets to rapidly rotating low-mass s… ▽ More Dynamos operating in the interiors of rapidly rotating planets and low-mass stars might belong to a similar category where rotation plays a vital role. We quantify this similarity using scaling laws. We analyse direct numerical simulations of Boussinesq and anelastic spherical shell dynamos. These dynamos represent simplified models which span from Earth-like planets to rapidly rotating low-mass stars. We find that magnetic field and velocity in these dynamos are related to the available buoyancy power via a simple power law which holds over wide variety of control parameters. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 2 pages; Proceedings of IAUS 302: Magnetic fields throughout stellar evolution (August 2013, Biarritz, France)

What controls the large-scale magnetic fields of M dwarfs?

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Morin, L. Duarte, A. Reiners, U. Christensen, J. Wicht

Abstract: Observations of active M dwarfs show a broad variety of large-scale magnetic fields encompassing dipole-dominated and multipolar geometries. We detail the analogy between some anelastic dynamo simulations and spectropolarimetric observations of 23 M stars. In numerical models, the relative contribution of inertia and Coriolis force in the global force balance -estimated by the so-called local Ross… ▽ More Observations of active M dwarfs show a broad variety of large-scale magnetic fields encompassing dipole-dominated and multipolar geometries. We detail the analogy between some anelastic dynamo simulations and spectropolarimetric observations of 23 M stars. In numerical models, the relative contribution of inertia and Coriolis force in the global force balance -estimated by the so-called local Rossby number- is known to have a strong impact on the magnetic field geometry. We discuss the relevance of this parameter in setting the large-scale magnetic field of M dwarfs. △ Less

Submitted 24 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 4 pages, 3 figures, conference proceeding, IAUS 302 'Magnetic Fields Throughout the Stellar Evolution', (26-30 Aug 2013, Biarritz, France)

Consistent scaling laws in anelastic spherical shell dynamos

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Thomas Gastine, Ulrich R. Christensen, Lúcia D. V. Duarte

Abstract: Numerical dynamo models always employ parameter values that differ by orders of magnitude from the values expected in natural objects. However, such models have been successful in qualitatively reproducing properties of planetary and stellar dynamos. This qualitative agreement fuels the idea that both numerical models and astrophysical objects may operate in the same asymptotic regime of dynamics.… ▽ More Numerical dynamo models always employ parameter values that differ by orders of magnitude from the values expected in natural objects. However, such models have been successful in qualitatively reproducing properties of planetary and stellar dynamos. This qualitative agreement fuels the idea that both numerical models and astrophysical objects may operate in the same asymptotic regime of dynamics. This can be tested by exploring the scaling behavior of the models. For convection-driven incompressible spherical shell dynamos with constant material properties, scaling laws had been established previously that relate flow velocity and magnetic field strength to the available power. Here we analyze 273 direct numerical simulations using the anelastic approximation, involving also cases with radius-dependent magnetic, thermal and viscous diffusivities. These better represent conditions in gas giant planets and low-mass stars compared to Boussinesq models. Our study provides strong support for the hypothesis that both mean velocity and mean magnetic field strength scale as a function of power generated by buoyancy forces in the same way for a wide range of conditions. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 2013; v1 submitted 23 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures, 1 table; data used in the paper can be found in "Dataset.txt" file available in the source; to appear in ApJ

What controls the magnetic geometry of M dwarfs?

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Morin, L. Duarte, A. Reiners, U. R. Christensen, J. Wicht

Abstract: Context: observations of rapidly rotating M dwarfs show a broad variety of large-scale magnetic fields encompassing dipole-dominated and multipolar geometries. In dynamo models, the relative importance of inertia in the force balance -- quantified by the local Rossby number -- is known to have a strong impact on the magnetic field geometry. Aims: we aim to assess the relevance of the local Rossby… ▽ More Context: observations of rapidly rotating M dwarfs show a broad variety of large-scale magnetic fields encompassing dipole-dominated and multipolar geometries. In dynamo models, the relative importance of inertia in the force balance -- quantified by the local Rossby number -- is known to have a strong impact on the magnetic field geometry. Aims: we aim to assess the relevance of the local Rossby number in controlling the large-scale magnetic field geometry of M dwarfs. Methods: we explore the similarities between anelastic dynamo models in spherical shells and observations of active M-dwarfs, focusing on field geometries derived from spectropolarimetric studies. To do so, we construct observation-based quantities aimed to reflect the diagnostic parameters employed in numerical models. Results: the transition between dipole-dominated and multipolar large-scale fields in early to mid M dwarfs is tentatively attributed to a Rossby number threshold. We interpret late M dwarfs magnetism to result from a dynamo bistability occurring at low Rossby number. By analogy with numerical models, we expect different amplitudes of differential rotation on the two dynamo branches. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2012; originally announced December 2012.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

Scaling laws in spherical shell dynamos with free-slip boundaries

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Thomas Gastine, Ulrich R. Christensen

Abstract: Numerical simulations of convection driven rotating spherical shell dynamos have often been performed with rigid boundary conditions, as is appropriate for the metallic cores of terrestrial planets. Free-slip boundaries are more appropriate for dynamos in other astrophysical objects, such as gas-giants or stars. Using a set of 57 direct numerical simulations, we investigate the effect of free-slip… ▽ More Numerical simulations of convection driven rotating spherical shell dynamos have often been performed with rigid boundary conditions, as is appropriate for the metallic cores of terrestrial planets. Free-slip boundaries are more appropriate for dynamos in other astrophysical objects, such as gas-giants or stars. Using a set of 57 direct numerical simulations, we investigate the effect of free-slip boundary conditions on the scaling properties of heat flow, flow velocity and magnetic field strength and compare it with earlier results for rigid boundaries. We find that the nature of the mechanical boundary condition has only a minor influence on the scaling laws. We also find that although dipolar and multipolar dynamos exhibit approximately the same scaling exponents, there is an offset in the scaling pre-factors for velocity and magnetic field strength. We argue that the offset can be attributed to the differences in the zonal flow contribution between dipolar and multipolar dynamos. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2013; v1 submitted 20 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: 10 pages, 9 figures, 1 table. To appear in ICARUS

Zonal flow regimes in rotating anelastic spherical shells: an application to giant planets

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Wicht, J. M. Aurnou

Abstract: The surface zonal winds observed in the giant planets form a complex jet pattern with alternating prograde and retrograde direction. While the main equatorial band is prograde on the gas giants, both ice giants have a pronounced retrograde equatorial jet. We use three-dimensional numerical models of compressible convection in rotating spherical shells to explore the properties of zonal flows in… ▽ More The surface zonal winds observed in the giant planets form a complex jet pattern with alternating prograde and retrograde direction. While the main equatorial band is prograde on the gas giants, both ice giants have a pronounced retrograde equatorial jet. We use three-dimensional numerical models of compressible convection in rotating spherical shells to explore the properties of zonal flows in different regimes where either rotation or buoyancy dominates the force balance. We conduct a systematic parameter study to quantify the dependence of zonal flows on the background density stratification and the driving of convection. We find that the direction of the equatorial zonal wind is controlled by the ratio of buoyancy and Coriolis force. The prograde equatorial band maintained by Reynolds stresses is found in the rotation-dominated regime. In cases where buoyancy dominates Coriolis force, the angular momentum per unit mass is homogenised and the equatorial band is retrograde, reminiscent to those observed in the ice giants. In this regime, the amplitude of the zonal jets depends on the background density contrast with strongly stratified models producing stronger jets than comparable weakly stratified cases. Furthermore, our results can help to explain the transition between solar-like and "anti-solar" differential rotations found in anelastic models of stellar convection zones. In the strongly stratified cases, we find that the leading order force balance can significantly vary with depth (rotation-dominated inside and buoyancy-dominated in a thin surface layer). This so-called "transitional regime" has a visible signature in the main equatorial jet which shows a pronounced dimple where flow amplitudes notably decay towards the equator. A similar dimple is observed on Jupiter, which suggests that convection in the planet interior could possibly operate in this regime. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2013; v1 submitted 14 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: 20 pages, 15 figures, 4 tables, accepted for publication in Icarus

Anelastic dynamo models with variable electrical conductivity: an application to gas giants

Authors: Lúcia D. V. Duarte, Thomas Gastine, Johannes Wicht

Abstract: The observed surface dynamics of Jupiter and Saturn is dominated by a banded system of zonal winds. Their depth remains unclear but they are thought to be confined to the very outer envelopes where hydrogen remains molecular and the electrical conductivity is small. The dynamo maintaining the dipole-dominated magnetic fields of both gas giants likely operates in the deeper interior where hydrogen… ▽ More The observed surface dynamics of Jupiter and Saturn is dominated by a banded system of zonal winds. Their depth remains unclear but they are thought to be confined to the very outer envelopes where hydrogen remains molecular and the electrical conductivity is small. The dynamo maintaining the dipole-dominated magnetic fields of both gas giants likely operates in the deeper interior where hydrogen assumes a metallic state. Here, we present numerical simulations that attempt to model both the zonal winds and the interior dynamo action in an integrated approach. Using the anelastic version of the MHD code MagIC, we explore the effects of density stratification and radial electrical conductivity variation. The electrical conductivity is mostly assumed to remain constant in the thicker inner metallic region and it decays exponentially towards the outer boundary throughout the molecular envelope. Our results show that the combination of stronger density stratification and weaker conducting outer layer is essential for reconciling dipole dominated dynamo action and a fierce equatorial zonal jet. Previous simulations with homogeneous electrical conductivity show that both are merely exclusive, with solutions either having strong zonal winds and multipolar magnetic fields or weak zonal winds and dipole-dominated magnetic fields. All jets tend to be geostrophic and therefore reach right through the convective shell in our simulations. The particular setup explored here allows a strong equatorial jet to remain confined to the weaker conducting outer region where it does not interfere with the deeper seated dynamo action. The flanking mid to high latitude jets, on the other hand, have to remain faint to yield a strongly dipolar magnetic field. The fiercer jets on Jupiter and Saturn only seem compatible with the observed dipolar fields when they remain confined to a weaker conducting outer layer. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2013; v1 submitted 11 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 16 pages, 11 figures, 2 tables, submitted to PEPI

Dipolar versus multipolar dynamos: the influence of the background density stratification

Authors: T. Gastine, L. Duarte, J. Wicht

Abstract: Context: dynamo action in giant planets and rapidly rotating stars leads to a broad variety of magnetic field geometries including small scale multipolar and large scale dipole-dominated topologies. Previous dynamo models suggest that solutions become multipolar once inertia becomes influential. Being tailored for terrestrial planets, most of these models neglected the background density stratific… ▽ More Context: dynamo action in giant planets and rapidly rotating stars leads to a broad variety of magnetic field geometries including small scale multipolar and large scale dipole-dominated topologies. Previous dynamo models suggest that solutions become multipolar once inertia becomes influential. Being tailored for terrestrial planets, most of these models neglected the background density stratification. Aims: we investigate the influence of the density stratification on convection-driven dynamo models. Methods: three-dimensional nonlinear simulations of rapidly rotating spherical shells are employed using the anelastic approximation to incorporate density stratification. A systematic parametric study for various density stratifications and Rayleigh numbers allows to explore the dependence of the magnetic field topology on these parameters. Results: anelastic dynamo models tend to produce a broad range of magnetic field geometries that fall on two distinct branches with either strong dipole-dominated or weak multipolar fields. As long as inertia is weak, both branches can coexist but the dipolar branch vanishes once inertia becomes influential. The dipolar branch also vanishes for stronger density stratifications. The reason is the concentration of the convective columns in a narrow region close to the outer boundary equator, a configuration that favors non-axisymmetric solutions. In multipolar solutions, zonal flows can become significant and participate in the toroidal field generation. Parker dynamo waves may then play an important role close to onset of dynamo action leading to a cyclic magnetic field behavior. Conclusion: Our simulations also suggest that the fact that late M dwarfs have dipolar or multipolar magnetic fields can be explained in two ways. They may differ either by the relative influence of inertia or fall into the regime where both types of solutions coexist. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: 13 pages, 13 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in A&A

Effects of compressibility on driving zonal flow in gas giants

Authors: T. Gastine, J. Wicht

Abstract: The banded structures observed on the surfaces of the gas giants are associated with strong zonal winds alternating in direction with latitude. We use three-dimensional numerical simulations of compressible convection in the anelastic approximation to explore the properties of zonal winds in rapidly rotating spherical shells. Since the model is restricted to the electrically insulating outer envel… ▽ More The banded structures observed on the surfaces of the gas giants are associated with strong zonal winds alternating in direction with latitude. We use three-dimensional numerical simulations of compressible convection in the anelastic approximation to explore the properties of zonal winds in rapidly rotating spherical shells. Since the model is restricted to the electrically insulating outer envelope, we therefore neglect magnetic effects. A systematic parametric study for various density scaleheights and Rayleigh numbers allows to explore the dependence of convection and zonal jets on these parameters and to derive scaling laws. While the density stratification affects the local flow amplitude and the convective scales, global quantities and zonal jets properties remain fairly independent of the density stratification. The zonal jets are maintained by Reynolds stresses, which rely on the correlation between zonal and cylindrically radial flow components. The gradual loss of this correlation with increasing supercriticality hampers all our simulations and explains why the additional compressional source of vorticity hardly affects zonal flows. All these common features may explain why previous Boussinesq models were already successful in reproducing the morphology of zonal jets in gas giants. △ Less

Submitted 19 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 17 pages, 15 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in Icarus

Nonlinear simulations of the convection-pulsation coupling

Authors: T. Gastine, B. Dintrans

Abstract: In cold Cepheids close to the red edge of the classical instability strip, a strong coupling between the stellar pulsations and the surface convective motions occurs. This coupling is by now poorly described by 1-D models of convection, the so-called "time-dependent convection models" (TDC). The intrinsic weakness of such models comes from the large number of unconstrained free parameters entering… ▽ More In cold Cepheids close to the red edge of the classical instability strip, a strong coupling between the stellar pulsations and the surface convective motions occurs. This coupling is by now poorly described by 1-D models of convection, the so-called "time-dependent convection models" (TDC). The intrinsic weakness of such models comes from the large number of unconstrained free parameters entering in the description of turbulent convection. A way to overcome these limits is to compute two-dimensional direct simulations (DNS), in which all the nonlinearities are correctly solved. Two-dimensional DNS of the convection-pulsation coupling are presented here. In an appropriate parameter regime, convective motions can actually quench the radial pulsations of the star, as suspected in Cepheids close to the red edge of the instability strip. These nonlinear simulations can also be used to determine the limits and the relevance of the TDC models. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, sf2a proceeding

Long-term magnetic field monitoring of the Sun-like star ξBootis A

Authors: A. Morgenthaler, P. Petit, S. Saar, S. K. Solanki, J. Morin, S. C. Marsden, M. Auriere, B. Dintrans, R. Fares, T. Gastine, J. Lanoux, F. Lignieres, F. Paletou, J. C. Ramirez Velez, S. Theado, V. Van Grootel

Abstract: Aims. We aim to investigate the long-term temporal evolution of the magnetic field of the solar-type star ξBootis A, both from direct magnetic field measurements and from the simultaneous estimate of indirect activity indicators. Methods. We obtained seven epochs of high-resolution, circularly-polarized spectra from the NARVAL spectropolarimeter between 2007 and 2011, for a total of 76 spectra. Us… ▽ More Aims. We aim to investigate the long-term temporal evolution of the magnetic field of the solar-type star ξBootis A, both from direct magnetic field measurements and from the simultaneous estimate of indirect activity indicators. Methods. We obtained seven epochs of high-resolution, circularly-polarized spectra from the NARVAL spectropolarimeter between 2007 and 2011, for a total of 76 spectra. Using approximately 6,100 photospheric spectral lines covering the visible domain, we employed a cross-correlation procedure to compute a mean polarized line profile from each spectrum. The large-scale photospheric magnetic field of the star was then modelled by means of Zeeman-Doppler Imaging, allowing us to follow the year-to-year evolution of the reconstructed magnetic topology. Simultaneously, we monitored the width of several magnetically sensitive spectral lines, the radial velocity, the line asymmetry of intensity line profiles, and the chromospheric emission in the cores of the Ca II H and Halpha lines. Results. During the highest observed activity states, in 2007 and 2011, the large-scale field of ξBoo A is almost completely axisymmetric and is dominated by its toroidal component. The magnetic topologies reconstructed for these activity maxima are very similar, suggesting a form of short cyclicity in the large-scale field distribution. Correlated temporal evolution, due to both rotational modulation and seasonal variability, is observed between the Ca II emission, the Halpha emission and the width of magnetically sensitive lines. When measurable, the differential rotation reveals a strong latitudinal shear in excess of 0.2 rad/d. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2012; v1 submitted 23 September, 2011; originally announced September 2011.

Comments: 16 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in A&A, abstract shortened to respect the 1920 characters required

A test of time-dependent theories of stellar convection

Authors: T. Gastine, B. Dintrans

Abstract: Context: In Cepheids close to the red edge of the classical instability strip, a coupling occurs between the acoustic oscillations and the convective motions close to the surface.The best topical models that account for this coupling rely on 1-D time-dependent convection (TDC) formulations. However, their intrinsic weakness comes from the large number of unconstrained free parameters entering in t… ▽ More Context: In Cepheids close to the red edge of the classical instability strip, a coupling occurs between the acoustic oscillations and the convective motions close to the surface.The best topical models that account for this coupling rely on 1-D time-dependent convection (TDC) formulations. However, their intrinsic weakness comes from the large number of unconstrained free parameters entering in the description of turbulent convection. Aims: We compare two widely used TDC models with the first two-dimensional nonlinear direct numerical simulations (DNS) of the convection-pulsation coupling in which the acoustic oscillations are self-sustained by the kappa-mechanism. Methods: The free parameters appearing in the Stellingwerf and Kuhfuss TDC recipes are constrained using a chi2-test with the time-dependent convective flux that evolves in nonlinear simulations of highly-compressible convection with kappa-mechanism. Results: This work emphasises some inherent limits of TDC models, that is, the temporal variability and non-universality of their free parameters. More importantly, within these limits, Stellingwerf's formalism is found to give better spatial and temporal agreements with the nonlinear simulation than Kuhfuss's one. It may therefore be preferred in 1-D TDC hydrocodes or stellar evolution codes. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2011; originally announced March 2011.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in A&A

Long-term magnetic field monitoring of the Sun-like star Ksi Bootis A

Authors: A. Morgenthaler, P. Petit, M. Auriere, B. Dintrans, R. Fares, T. Gastine, J. Lanoux, F. Lignieres, J. Morin, J. Ramirez, S. Saar, S. K. Solanki, S. Theado, V. Van Grootel

Abstract: Phase-resolved observations of the solar-type star Ksi Bootis A were obtained using the NARVAL spectropolarimeter at the Telescope Bernard Lyot (Pic du Midi, France) during years 2007, 2008, 2009 and 2010. The data sets enable us to study both the rotational modulation and the long-term evolution of various magnetic and activity tracers. Here, we focus on the large-scale photospheric magnetic fiel… ▽ More Phase-resolved observations of the solar-type star Ksi Bootis A were obtained using the NARVAL spectropolarimeter at the Telescope Bernard Lyot (Pic du Midi, France) during years 2007, 2008, 2009 and 2010. The data sets enable us to study both the rotational modulation and the long-term evolution of various magnetic and activity tracers. Here, we focus on the large-scale photospheric magnetic field (reconstructed by Zeeman-Doppler Imaging), the Zeeman broadening of the FeI 846.84 nm magnetic line, and the chromospheric CaII H and H alpha emission. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2010; v1 submitted 1 December, 2010; originally announced December 2010.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures, Cool Stars 16 proceeding

Exploring the magnetic topologies of cool stars

Authors: J. Morin, J. -F. Donati, P. Petit, L. Albert, M. Auriere, R. Cabanac, C. Catala, X. Delfosse, B. Dintrans, R. Fares, T. Forveille, T. Gastine, M. Jardine, R. Konstantinova-Antova, J. Lanoux, F. Lignieres, A. Morgenthaler, F. Paletou, J. C. Ramirez Velez, S. K. Solanki, S. Theado, V. Van Grootel

Abstract: Magnetic fields of cool stars can be directly investigated through the study of the Zeeman effect on photospheric spectral lines using several approaches. With spectroscopic measurement in unpolarised light, the total magnetic flux averaged over the stellar disc can be derived but very little information on the field geometry is available. Spectropolarimetry provides a complementary information on… ▽ More Magnetic fields of cool stars can be directly investigated through the study of the Zeeman effect on photospheric spectral lines using several approaches. With spectroscopic measurement in unpolarised light, the total magnetic flux averaged over the stellar disc can be derived but very little information on the field geometry is available. Spectropolarimetry provides a complementary information on the large-scale component of the magnetic topology. With Zeeman-Doppler Imaging (ZDI), this information can be retrieved to produce a map of the vector magnetic field at the surface of the star, and in particular to assess the relative importance of the poloidal and toroidal components as well as the degree of axisymmetry of the field distribution. The development of high-performance spectropolarimeters associated with multi-lines techniques and ZDI allows us to explore magnetic topologies throughout the Hertzsprung-Russel diagram, on stars spanning a wide range of mass, age and rotation period. These observations bring novel constraints on magnetic field generation by dynamo effect in cool stars. In particular, the study of solar twins brings new insight on the impact of rotation on the solar dynamo, whereas the detection of strong and stable dipolar magnetic fields on fully convective stars questions the precise role of the tachocline in this process. △ Less

Submitted 14 September, 2010; originally announced September 2010.

Comments: 6 pages, 2 figures, IAU Symposium 273 "Physics of Sun and Star Spots", 22-26 August 2010

Convective quenching of stellar pulsations

Authors: T. Gastine, B. Dintrans

Abstract: Context: we study the convection-pulsation coupling that occurs in cold Cepheids close to the red edge of the classical instability strip. In these stars, the surface convective zone is supposed to stabilise the radial oscillations excited by the kappa-mechanism. Aims: we study the influence of the convective motions onto the amplitude and the nonlinear saturation of acoustic modes excited by ka… ▽ More Context: we study the convection-pulsation coupling that occurs in cold Cepheids close to the red edge of the classical instability strip. In these stars, the surface convective zone is supposed to stabilise the radial oscillations excited by the kappa-mechanism. Aims: we study the influence of the convective motions onto the amplitude and the nonlinear saturation of acoustic modes excited by kappa-mechanism. We are interested in determining the physical conditions needed to lead to a quenching of oscillations by convection. Methods: we compute two-dimensional nonlinear simulations (DNS) of the convection-pulsation coupling, in which the oscillations are sustained by a continuous physical process: the kappa-mechanism. Thanks to both a frequential analysis and a projection of the physical fields onto an acoustic subspace, we study how the convective motions affect the unstable radial oscillations. Results: depending on the initial physical conditions, two main behaviours are obtained: (i) either the unstable fundamental acoustic mode has a large amplitude, carries the bulk of the kinetic energy and shows a nonlinear saturation similar to the purely radiative case; (ii) or the convective motions affect significantly the mode amplitude that remains very weak. In this second case, convection is quenching the acoustic oscillations. We interpret these discrepancies in terms of the difference in density contrast: larger stratification leads to smaller convective plumes that do not affect much the purely radial modes, while large-scale vortices may quench the oscillations. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2011; v1 submitted 24 August, 2010; originally announced August 2010.

Comments: 15 pages, 17 figures, 3 tables, accepted for publication in A&A

Numerical simulations of the kappa-mechanism with convection

Authors: T. Gastine, B. Dintrans

Abstract: A strong coupling between convection and pulsations is known to play a major role in the disappearance of unstable modes close to the red edge of the classical Cepheid instability strip. As mean-field models of time-dependent convection rely on weakly-constrained parameters, we tackle this problem by the means of 2-D Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of kappa-mechanism with convection. Using… ▽ More A strong coupling between convection and pulsations is known to play a major role in the disappearance of unstable modes close to the red edge of the classical Cepheid instability strip. As mean-field models of time-dependent convection rely on weakly-constrained parameters, we tackle this problem by the means of 2-D Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of kappa-mechanism with convection. Using a linear stability analysis, we first determine the physical conditions favourable to the kappa-mechanism to occur inside a purely-radiative layer. Both the instability strips and the nonlinear saturation of unstable modes are then confirmed by the corresponding DNS. We next present the new simulations with convection, where a convective zone and the driving region overlap. The coupling between the convective motions and acoustic modes is then addressed by using projections onto an acoustic subspace. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2010; v1 submitted 4 January, 2010; originally announced January 2010.

Comments: 5 pages, 6 figures, accepted for publication in Astrophysics and Space Science, HELAS workshop (Rome june 2009)

DNS of the kappa-mechanism

Authors: T. Gastine, B. Dintrans

Abstract: We present a purely-radiative hydrodynamic model of the kappa-mechanism that sustains radial oscillations in Cepheid variables. We determine the physical conditions favourable for the kappa-mechanism to occur by the means of a configurable hollow in the radiative conductivity profile. By starting from these most favourable conditions, we complete nonlinear direct numerical simulations (DNS) and… ▽ More We present a purely-radiative hydrodynamic model of the kappa-mechanism that sustains radial oscillations in Cepheid variables. We determine the physical conditions favourable for the kappa-mechanism to occur by the means of a configurable hollow in the radiative conductivity profile. By starting from these most favourable conditions, we complete nonlinear direct numerical simulations (DNS) and compare them with the results given by a linear-stability analysis of radial modes. We find that well-defined instability strips are generated by changing the location and shape of the conductivity hollow. For a given position in the layer, the hollow amplitude and width stand out as the key parameters governing the appearance of unstable modes driven by the kappa-mechanism. The DNS confirm both the growth rates and structures of the linearly-unstable modes. The nonlinear saturation that arises is produced by intricate couplings between the excited fundamental mode and higher damped overtones. These couplings are measured by projecting the DNS fields onto an acoustic subspace built from regular and adjoint eigenvectors and a 2:1 resonance is found to be responsible for the saturation of the kappa-mechanism instability. △ Less

Submitted 29 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: 4 pages, 5 figures, sf2a proceeding