-
Internally Driven $β$-plane Plasma Turbulence Using the Hasegawa-Wakatani System
Authors:
Özgür D. Gürcan
Abstract:
General problem of plasma turbulence can be formulated as advection of potential vorticity (PV), which handles flow self-organization, coupled to a number of other fields, whose gradients provide free energy sources. Therefore, focusing on PV evolution separates the underlying linear instability from the flow self-organization, and clarifies key spatial scales in terms of balances between various…
▽ More
General problem of plasma turbulence can be formulated as advection of potential vorticity (PV), which handles flow self-organization, coupled to a number of other fields, whose gradients provide free energy sources. Therefore, focusing on PV evolution separates the underlying linear instability from the flow self-organization, and clarifies key spatial scales in terms of balances between various time scales. Considering the Hasegawa-Wakatani model as a minimal, nontrivial model of plasma turbulence where the energy is injected internally by a linear instability, we find that the critical wavenumber $k_{c}=C/κ$ where $C$ is the adiabaticity parameter and $κ$ is the normalized density gradient separates the adiabatic (or highly zonostrophic) behavior for large scales from the hydrodynamic behavior at small scales. In the adiabatic range the non-zonal part of the wave-number spectrum goes from $E(k)\proptoγ_{k}U^{-1}k^{-2}$ around the peak to $E(k) \propto ω_{k}^{2} k^{-3}$ in the "inertial" range, where $γ_{k}$ and $ω_{k}$ are the linear growth and frequency and $U$ is the rms zonal velocity. This proposed spectrum fits very well for the large $k_{c}$ case, where the bulk of the spectrum is in the adiabatic range. In contrast for small $k_{c}$, we get the usual forward enstrophy cascade with $E(k)\proptoε_{W}^{2/3}k^{-3}$, where $ε_{W}$ is the enstrophy dissipation. In contrast for $k_{c}\approx 1$, the system transitions to hydrodynamic forward enstrophy cascade right after the injection range, with zonal flows at large scales and forward enstrophy cascade at small scales. It is argued that the ratio $R_β\equiv k_β/k_{\text{peak}}\approx k_{c}/k_{\text{peak}}$ where $k_{\text{peak}}$ is the peak wave-number can be defined as the zonostrophy parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Phase and amplitude evolution in the network of triadic interactions of the Hasegawa-Wakatani system
Authors:
Ö. D. Gürcan,
J. Anderson,
S. Moradi,
A. Biancalani,
P. Morel
Abstract:
Hasegawa-Wakatani system, commonly used as a toy model of dissipative drift waves in fusion devices is revisited with considerations of phase and amplitude dynamics of its triadic interactions. It is observed that a single resonant triad can saturate via three way phase locking where the phase differences between dominant modes converge to constant values as individual phases increase in time. Thi…
▽ More
Hasegawa-Wakatani system, commonly used as a toy model of dissipative drift waves in fusion devices is revisited with considerations of phase and amplitude dynamics of its triadic interactions. It is observed that a single resonant triad can saturate via three way phase locking where the phase differences between dominant modes converge to constant values as individual phases increase in time. This allows the system to have approximately constant amplitude solutions. Non-resonant triads show similar behavior only when one of its legs is a zonal wave number. However when an additional triad, which is a reflection of the original one with respect to the $y$ axis is included, the behavior of the resulting triad pair is shown to be more complex. In particular, it is found that triads involving small radial wave numbers (large scale zonal flows) end up transferring their energy to the subdominant mode which keeps growing exponentially, while those involving larger radial wave numbers (small scale zonal flows) tend to find steady chaotic or limit cycle states (or decay to zero). In order to study the dynamics in a connected network of triads, a network formulation is considered including a pump mode, and a number of zonal and non-zonal subdominant modes as a dynamical system. It was observed that the zonal modes become clearly dominant only when a large number of triads are connected. When the zonal flow becomes dominant as a 'collective mean field', individual interactions between modes become less important, which is consistent with the inhomogeneous wave-kinetic picture. Finally, the results of direct numerical simulation is discussed for the same parameters and various forms of the order parameter are computed. It is observed that nonlinear phase dynamics results in a flattening of the large scale phase velocity as a function of scale in direct numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Dynamical Complex Network Models of the Turbulent Cascade
Authors:
Özgür D. Gürcan
Abstract:
Cascade models based on dynamical complex networks are proposed as models of turbulent energy cascade. Taking a simple shell model as the initial regular lattice with only nearest neighbor interactions, small world network models are constructed by adding or replacing some of the existing local interactions by nonlocal ones. The models are then evolved over time, both by solving for the shell vari…
▽ More
Cascade models based on dynamical complex networks are proposed as models of turbulent energy cascade. Taking a simple shell model as the initial regular lattice with only nearest neighbor interactions, small world network models are constructed by adding or replacing some of the existing local interactions by nonlocal ones. The models are then evolved over time, both by solving for the shell variable for velocity using an arbitrary network generalization of the shell model evolution and by rewiring the network each time from the original lattice in regular time intervals. This results in a more intermittent time evolution with larger variations of the wave-number spectrum. It also results in an actual increase in intermittency as computed from the fitted exponents of structure functions as computed from these models. It appears that the intermittency increases as the ratio of random nonlocal connections to local nearest neighbor connections increases.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2020; v1 submitted 2 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
A Differential Approximation Model For Passive Scalar Turbulence
Authors:
Pierre Morel,
Shaokang Xu,
Özgür D. Gürcan
Abstract:
Two dimensional passive scalar turbulence is studied by means of a k-space diffusion model based on a third order differential approximation. This simple description of local nonlinear interactions in Fourier space is shown to present a general expression, in line with previous seminal works, and appears to be suitable for various 2D turbulence problems. Steady state solutions for the spectral ene…
▽ More
Two dimensional passive scalar turbulence is studied by means of a k-space diffusion model based on a third order differential approximation. This simple description of local nonlinear interactions in Fourier space is shown to present a general expression, in line with previous seminal works, and appears to be suitable for various 2D turbulence problems. Steady state solutions for the spectral energy density of the flow is shown to recover the Kraichnan-Kolmogorov phenomenology of the dual cascade, while various passive scalar spectra, such as Batchelor or Obukhov-Corssin spectra are recovered as steady state solutions of the spectral energy density of the passive scalar. These analytical results are then corroborated by numerical solutions of the time evolving problem with energy and passive scalar injection and dissipation on a logarithmic wavenumber space grid over a large range of scales. The particular power law spectra that is obtained is found to depend mainly on the location of the kinetic and passive scalar energy injections.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Spiral chains in wavenumber space of two dimensional turbulence
Authors:
Ö. D. Gürcan,
Shaokang Xu,
P. Morel
Abstract:
Abstract Self-similar, fractal nature of turbulence is discussed in the context of two dimensional turbulence, by considering the fractal structure of the wave-number domain using spirals. In loose analogy with phyllotaxis in plants, each step of the cascade can be represented by a rotation and a scaling of the interacting triad. Using a constant divergence angle and a constant scaling factor, one…
▽ More
Abstract Self-similar, fractal nature of turbulence is discussed in the context of two dimensional turbulence, by considering the fractal structure of the wave-number domain using spirals. In loose analogy with phyllotaxis in plants, each step of the cascade can be represented by a rotation and a scaling of the interacting triad. Using a constant divergence angle and a constant scaling factor, one obtains a family of such fractals depending on the distance of interactions. Scaling factors in such sequences are given by the square roots of known ratios such as the plastic ratio, the supergolden ratio or some small Pisot numbers. While spiral chains can represent mono-fractal models of self-similar cascade, which can span a very large range in wave-number domain with good angular coverage, it is also possible that spiral chains or chains of consecutive triads play an important role in the cascade. As numerical models, the spiral chain models based on decimated Fourier coefficients have problems such as the dual cascade being overwhelmed by statistical chain equipartition due to almost stochastic evolution of the complex phases. A generic spiral chain model based on evolution of energy is proposed, which is shown to recover the dual cascade behavior in two-dimensional turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
A nested polyhedra model of isotropic MHD turbulence
Authors:
Ö. D. Gürcan
Abstract:
A nested polyhedra model has been developed for magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence. Driving only the velocity field at large scales with random, divergence free forcing results in a clear, stationary $k^{-5/3}$ spectrum for both kinetic and magnetic energies. Since the model naturaly effaces disparate scale interactions, does not have a guide field and avoids injecting any sign of helicity by ra…
▽ More
A nested polyhedra model has been developed for magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence. Driving only the velocity field at large scales with random, divergence free forcing results in a clear, stationary $k^{-5/3}$ spectrum for both kinetic and magnetic energies. Since the model naturaly effaces disparate scale interactions, does not have a guide field and avoids injecting any sign of helicity by random forcing, the resulting three dimensional k-spectrum is statistically isotropic. The strengths and weaknesses of the model are demonstrated by considering large or small magnetic Prandtl numbers. It was also observed that the time scale for the equipartition offset with those of the smallest scales shows a $k^{-1/2}$ scaling.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Generalized curvature modified plasma dispersion functions and Dupree renormalization of toroidal ITG
Authors:
Ö. Gültekin,
Ö. D. Gürcan
Abstract:
A new generalization of curvature modified plasma dispersion functions is introduced in order to express Dupree renormalized dispersion relations used in quasi-linear theory. For instance the Dupree renormalized dispersion relation for gyrokinetic, toroidal ion temperature gradient driven (ITG) modes, where the Dupree's diffusion coefficient is assumed to be a low order polynomial of the velocity,…
▽ More
A new generalization of curvature modified plasma dispersion functions is introduced in order to express Dupree renormalized dispersion relations used in quasi-linear theory. For instance the Dupree renormalized dispersion relation for gyrokinetic, toroidal ion temperature gradient driven (ITG) modes, where the Dupree's diffusion coefficient is assumed to be a low order polynomial of the velocity, can be written entirely using generalized curvature modified plasma dispersion functions: Knm's. Using those, Dupree's formulation of renormalized quasi-linear theory is revisited for the toroidal ITG mode. The Dupree diffusion coefficient has been obtained as a function of velocity using an iteration scheme, first by assuming that the diffusion coefficient is constant at each v (i.e. applicable for slow dependence), and then substituting the resulting v dependence in the form of complex polynomial coefficients into the Knm's for verification. The algorithm generally converges rapidly after only a few iterations. Since the quasi-linear calculation relies on an assumed form for the wave-number spectrum, especially around its peak, practical usefullness of the method is to be determined in actual applications.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2019; v1 submitted 30 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Envelope modulations of kinetic plasma waves: A general framework
Authors:
Ö. D. Gürcan,
P. Donnel
Abstract:
The general framework of envelope modulations for plasma turbulence in the presence of strong magnetic fields is discussed. It is shown that the problem can be formulated using a functional which is equivalent to the plasma dielectric function for monochromatic waves. Therefore expanding around its linear wave solutions, one can describe the weakly nonlinear evolution of waves. The resulting "quas…
▽ More
The general framework of envelope modulations for plasma turbulence in the presence of strong magnetic fields is discussed. It is shown that the problem can be formulated using a functional which is equivalent to the plasma dielectric function for monochromatic waves. Therefore expanding around its linear wave solutions, one can describe the weakly nonlinear evolution of waves. The resulting "quasi-linear" dielectric tensor, can describe the evolution of small scale fluctuations advected and modulated by background flows and corrugations, as well as the evolution of the large scale flows driven by small scales. As a concrete example of the framework, gyrokinetic evolution of zonal flows and drift waves is considered and the resulting nonlinear Schrödinger equation is derived.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Linear gyrokinetic investigation of the geodesic acoustic modes in realistic tokamak configurations
Authors:
I. Novikau,
A. Biancalani,
A. Bottino,
G. D. Conway,
Ö. D. Gürcan,
P. Manz,
P. Morel,
E. Poli,
A. Di Siena,
the ASDEX Upgrade Team
Abstract:
Geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs) are studied by means of the gyrokinetic global particle-in-cell code ORB5. Linear electromagnetic simulations in the low electron beta limit have been performed, in order to separate acoustic and Alfvénic time scales and obtain more accurate measurements. The dependence of the frequency and dam** rate on several parameters such as the safety factor, the GAM radial…
▽ More
Geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs) are studied by means of the gyrokinetic global particle-in-cell code ORB5. Linear electromagnetic simulations in the low electron beta limit have been performed, in order to separate acoustic and Alfvénic time scales and obtain more accurate measurements. The dependence of the frequency and dam** rate on several parameters such as the safety factor, the GAM radial wavenumber and the plasma elongation is studied. All simulations have been performed with kinetic electrons with realistic electron/ion mass ratio. Interpolating formulae for the GAM frequency and dam** rate, based on the results of the gyrokinetic simulations, have been derived. Using these expressions, the influence of the temperature gradient on the dam** rate is also investigated. Finally, the results are applied to the study of a real discharge of the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Stable and unstable roots of ion temperature gradient driven mode using curvature modified plasma dispersion functions
Authors:
Özgür Gültekin,
Özgür D. Gürcan
Abstract:
Basic, local kinetic theory of ion temperature gradient driven (ITG) mode, with adiabatic electrons is reconsidered. Standard unstable, purely oscillating as well as damped solutions of the local dispersion relation are obtained using a bracketing technique that uses the argument principle. This method requires computing the plasma dielectric function and its derivatives, which are implemented her…
▽ More
Basic, local kinetic theory of ion temperature gradient driven (ITG) mode, with adiabatic electrons is reconsidered. Standard unstable, purely oscillating as well as damped solutions of the local dispersion relation are obtained using a bracketing technique that uses the argument principle. This method requires computing the plasma dielectric function and its derivatives, which are implemented here using modified plasma dispersion functions with curvature and their derivatives, and allows bracketing/following the zeros of the plasma dielectric function which corresponds to different roots of the ITG dispersion relation. We provide an open source implementation of the derivatives of modified plasma dispersion functions with curvature, which are used in this formulation. Studying the local ITG dispersion, we find that near the threshold of instability the unstable branch is rather asymmetric with oscillating solutions towards lower wave numbers (i.e. drift waves), and damped solutions toward higher wave numbers. This suggests a process akin to inverse cascade by coupling to the oscillating branch towards lower wave numbers may play a role in the nonlinear evolution of the ITG, near the instability threshold. Also, using the algorithm, the linear wave diffusion is estimated for the marginally stable ITG mode.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
A nested polyhedra model of turbulence
Authors:
Ö. D. Gürcan
Abstract:
A discretization of the wave-number space is proposed, using nested polyhedra, in the form of alternating dodecahedra and icosahedra that are self-similarly scaled. This particular choice allows the possibility of forming triangles using only discretized wave-vectors when the scaling between two consecutive dodecahedra is equal to the golden ratio, and the icosahedron between the two dodecahedra i…
▽ More
A discretization of the wave-number space is proposed, using nested polyhedra, in the form of alternating dodecahedra and icosahedra that are self-similarly scaled. This particular choice allows the possibility of forming triangles using only discretized wave-vectors when the scaling between two consecutive dodecahedra is equal to the golden ratio, and the icosahedron between the two dodecahedra is the dual of the inner dodecahedron. Alternatively, the same discretization can be described as a logarithmically spaced (with a scaling equal to the golden ratio), nested dodecahedron-icosahedron compounds. A wave-vector which points from the origin to a vertex of such a mesh, can always find two other discretized wave-vectors that are also on the vertices of the mesh (which is not true for an arbitrary mesh). Thus, the nested polyhedra grid can be thought of as a reduction (or decimation) of the Fourier space using a particular set of self-similar triads aranged approximately in a spherical form. For each vertex (i.e. discretized wave-vector) in this space, there are either 9 or 15 pairs of vertices (i.e. wave-vectors) with which the initial vertex can interact to form a triangle. This allows the reduction of the convolution integral in the Navier-Stokes equation to a sum over 9 or 15 interaction pairs. Transforming the equation in Fourier space, to a network of interacting nodes, that can be constructed as a numerical model, which evolves each component of the velocity vector on each node of the network. Such a model gives the usual Kolmogorov spectrum. Since the scaling is logarithmic, and the number of nodes for each scale is constant, a very large inertial range can be considered with a much lower number of degrees of freedom. Incidentally, by assuming isotropy and a certain relation between the phases, the model can be used to systematically derive three dimensional shell models.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2017; v1 submitted 4 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Geodesic acoustic modes with poloidal mode couplings ad infinitum
Authors:
Rameswar Singh,
Ö D Gürcan,
X Garbet,
P Hennequin,
L Vermare,
P Morel,
R Singh
Abstract:
Geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs) are studied, for the first time, including all poloidal mode $(m)$ couplings using drift reduced fluid equations. The nearest neighbor coupling pattern, due to geodesic curvature, leads to a semi-infinite chain model of the GAM with the mode-mode coupling matrix elements proportional to the radial wave number $k_{r}$. The infinite chain can be reduced to a renormaliz…
▽ More
Geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs) are studied, for the first time, including all poloidal mode $(m)$ couplings using drift reduced fluid equations. The nearest neighbor coupling pattern, due to geodesic curvature, leads to a semi-infinite chain model of the GAM with the mode-mode coupling matrix elements proportional to the radial wave number $k_{r}$. The infinite chain can be reduced to a renormalized bi-nodal chain with a matrix continued fractions. Convergence study of linear GAM dispersion with respect to $k_{r}$ and the $m$-spectra confirms that high m couplings become increasingly important with $k_{r}$. The radially sorted roots overlap with experimentally measured GAM frequency profile in low collisionality shots in Tore Supra thus explaining the reduced frequency of GAM in Tore Supra.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Geodesic acoustic modes in a fluid model of tokamak plasma : the effects of finite beta and collisionality
Authors:
Rameswar Singh,
A Storelli,
Ozgur D Gurcan,
Pascale Hennequin,
L Vermare,
Pierre Morel,
Raghvendra Singh
Abstract:
Starting from the Braginskii equations, relevant for the tokamak edge region, a complete set of nonlinear equations for the geodesic acoustic modes (GAM) has been derived which includes collisionality, plasma beta and external sources of particle, momentum and heat. Local linear analysis shows that the GAM frequency increases with collisionality at low radial wave number $k_{r}$ and decreases at h…
▽ More
Starting from the Braginskii equations, relevant for the tokamak edge region, a complete set of nonlinear equations for the geodesic acoustic modes (GAM) has been derived which includes collisionality, plasma beta and external sources of particle, momentum and heat. Local linear analysis shows that the GAM frequency increases with collisionality at low radial wave number $k_{r}$ and decreases at high $k_{r}$. GAM frequency also decreases with plasma beta. Radial profiles of GAM frequency for two Tore Supra shots, which were part of a collisionality scan, are compared with these calculations. Discrepency between experiment and theory is observed, which seems to be explained by a finite $k_{r}$ for the GAM when flux surface averaged density $\langle n \rangle$ and temperature $\langle T \rangle$ are assumed to vanish. It is shown that this agreement is incidental and self-consistent inclusion of $\langle n \rangle$ and $\langle T \rangle$ responses enhances the disagreement more with $k_r$ at high $k_{r}$ . So the discrepancy between the linear GAM calculation, (which persist also for more "complete" linear models such as gyrokinetics) can probably not be resolved by simply adding a finite $k_{r}$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Angular momentum transport modeling: achievements of a gyrokinetic quasi-linear approach
Authors:
P. Cottier,
C. Bourdelle,
Y. Camenen,
O. D. Gurcan,
F. J. Casson,
X. Garbet,
P. Hennequin,
T. Tala
Abstract:
QuaLiKiz, a model based on a local gyrokinetic eigenvalue solver is expanded to include momentum flux modeling in addition to heat and particle fluxes. Essential for accurate momentum flux predictions, the parallel asymmetrization of the eigenfunctions is successfully recovered by an analytical fluid model. This is tested against self-consistent gyrokinetic calculations and allows for a correct pr…
▽ More
QuaLiKiz, a model based on a local gyrokinetic eigenvalue solver is expanded to include momentum flux modeling in addition to heat and particle fluxes. Essential for accurate momentum flux predictions, the parallel asymmetrization of the eigenfunctions is successfully recovered by an analytical fluid model. This is tested against self-consistent gyrokinetic calculations and allows for a correct prediction of the ExB shear impact on the saturated potential amplitude by means of a mixing length rule. Hence, the effect of the ExB shear is recovered on all the transport channels including the induced residual stress. Including these additions, QuaLiKiz remains ~10 000 faster than non-linear gyrokinetic codes allowing for comparisons with experiments without resorting to high performance computing. The example is given of momentum pinch calculations in NBI modulation experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Characterization of predator-prey dynamics, using the evolution of free energy in plasma turbulence
Authors:
P. Morel,
Ö. D. Gürcan,
V. Berionni
Abstract:
A simple dynamical cascade model for the evolution of free energy is considered in the context of gyrokinetic formalism. It is noted that the dynamics of free energy, that characterize plasma micro-turbulence in magnetic fusion devices, exhibit a clear predator prey character. Various key features of predatory prey dynamics such as the time delay between turbulence and large scale flow structures,…
▽ More
A simple dynamical cascade model for the evolution of free energy is considered in the context of gyrokinetic formalism. It is noted that the dynamics of free energy, that characterize plasma micro-turbulence in magnetic fusion devices, exhibit a clear predator prey character. Various key features of predatory prey dynamics such as the time delay between turbulence and large scale flow structures, or the intermittency of the dynamics are identifed in the quasi-steady state phase of the nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations. A novel prediction on the ratio of turbulence amplitudes in different parts of the wave-number domain that follows from this simple predator prey model is compared to a set of nonlinear simulation results and is observed to hold quite well in a large range of physical parameters. Detailed validation of the predator prey hypothesis using nonlinear gyrokinetics provides a very important input for the effort to apprehend plasma microturbulence, since the predator prey idea can be used as a very effective intuitive tool for understanding.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
