-
Multimodal operando microscopy reveals that interfacial chemistry and nanoscale performance disorder dictate perovskite solar cell stability
Authors:
Kyle Frohna,
Cullen Chosy,
Amran Al-Ashouri,
Florian Scheler,
Yu-Hsien Chiang,
Milos Dubajic,
Julia E. Parker,
Jessica M. Walker,
Lea Zimmermann,
Thomas A. Selby,
Yang Lu,
Bart Roose,
Steve Albrecht,
Miguel Anaya,
Samuel D. Stranks
Abstract:
Next-generation low-cost semiconductors such as halide perovskites exhibit optoelectronic properties dominated by nanoscale variations in their structure, composition and photophysics. While microscopy provides a proxy for ultimate device function, past works have focused on neat thin-films on insulating substrates, missing crucial information about charge extraction losses and recombination losse…
▽ More
Next-generation low-cost semiconductors such as halide perovskites exhibit optoelectronic properties dominated by nanoscale variations in their structure, composition and photophysics. While microscopy provides a proxy for ultimate device function, past works have focused on neat thin-films on insulating substrates, missing crucial information about charge extraction losses and recombination losses introduced by transport layers. Here we use a multimodal operando microscopy toolkit to measure nanoscale current-voltage curves, recombination losses and chemical composition in an array of state-of-the-art perovskite solar cells before and after extended operational stress. We apply this toolkit to the same scan areas before and after extended operation to reveal that devices with the highest performance have the lowest initial performance spatial heterogeneity - a crucial link that is missed in conventional microscopy. We find that subtle compositional engineering of the perovskite has surprising effects on local disorder and resilience to operational stress. Minimising variations in local efficiency, rather than compositional disorder, is predictive of improved performance and stability. Modulating the interfaces with different contact layers or passivation treatments can increase initial performance but can also lead to dramatic nanoscale, interface-dominated degradation even in the presence of local performance homogeneity, inducing spatially varying transport, recombination, and electrical losses. These operando measurements of full devices act as screenable diagnostic tools, uniquely unveiling the microscopic mechanistic origins of device performance losses and degradation in an array of halide perovskite devices and treatments. This information in turn reveals guidelines for future improvements to both performance and stability.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Spatially resolved photoluminescence analysis of Se passivation and defect formation in CdSe$_{x}$Te$_{1-x}$ thin films
Authors:
Alan R Bowman,
Jacob J Leaver,
Kyle Frohna,
Samuel D Stranks,
Giulia Tagliabue,
Jon D Major
Abstract:
CdTe is the most commercially successful thin-film photovoltaic technology to date. The recent development of Se-alloyed CdSe$_{x}$Te$_{1-x}$ layers in CdTe solar cells has led to higher device efficiencies, due to a lowered bandgap improving the photocurrent, improved voltage characteristics and longer carrier lifetimes. Evidence from cross-sectional electron microscopy is widely believed to indi…
▽ More
CdTe is the most commercially successful thin-film photovoltaic technology to date. The recent development of Se-alloyed CdSe$_{x}$Te$_{1-x}$ layers in CdTe solar cells has led to higher device efficiencies, due to a lowered bandgap improving the photocurrent, improved voltage characteristics and longer carrier lifetimes. Evidence from cross-sectional electron microscopy is widely believed to indicate that Se passivates defects in CdSe$_{x}$Te$_{1-x}$ solar cells, and that this is the reason for better lifetimes and voltages in these devices. Here, we utilise spatially resolved photoluminescence measurements of CdSe$_{x}$Te$_{1-x}$ thin films on glass to study the effects of Se on carrier recombination in the material, isolated from the impact of conductive interfaces and without the need to prepare cross-sections through the samples. We find further evidence to support Se passivation of grain boundaries, but also identify an associated increase in below-bandgap photoluminescence that indicates the presence of Se-enhanced luminescent defects. Our results show that Se treatment, in tandem with Cl passivation, does increase radiative efficiencies. However, the simultaneous enhancement of defects within the grain interiors suggests that although it is overall beneficial, Se incorporation may still ultimately limit the maximum attainable efficiency of CdSe$_{x}$Te$_{1-x}$ solar cells.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Imaging Light-Induced Migration of Dislocations in Halide Perovskites with 3D Nanoscale Strain Map**
Authors:
Kieran W. P. Orr,
Jiecheng Diao,
Muhammad Naufal Lintangpradipto,
Darren J. Batey,
Affan N. Iqbal,
Simon Kahmann,
Kyle Frohna,
Milos Dubajic,
Szymon J. Zelewski,
Alice E. Dearle,
Thomas A. Selby,
Peng Li,
Tiarnan A. S. Doherty,
Stephan Hofmann,
Osman M. Bakr,
Ian K. Robinson,
Samuel D. Stranks
Abstract:
In recent years, halide perovskite materials have been used to make high performance solar cell and light-emitting devices. However, material defects still limit device performance and stability. Here, we use synchrotron-based Bragg Coherent Diffraction Imaging to visualise nanoscale strain fields, such as those local to defects, in halide perovskite microcrystals. We find significant strain heter…
▽ More
In recent years, halide perovskite materials have been used to make high performance solar cell and light-emitting devices. However, material defects still limit device performance and stability. Here, we use synchrotron-based Bragg Coherent Diffraction Imaging to visualise nanoscale strain fields, such as those local to defects, in halide perovskite microcrystals. We find significant strain heterogeneity within MAPbBr$_{3}$ (MA = CH$_{3}$NH$_{3}^{+}$) crystals in spite of their high optoelectronic quality, and identify both $\langle$100$\rangle$ and $\langle$110$\rangle$ edge dislocations through analysis of their local strain fields. By imaging these defects and strain fields in situ under continuous illumination, we uncover dramatic light-induced dislocation migration across hundreds of nanometres. Further, by selectively studying crystals that are damaged by the X-ray beam, we correlate large dislocation densities and increased nanoscale strains with material degradation and substantially altered optoelectronic properties assessed using photoluminescence microscopy measurements. Our results demonstrate the dynamic nature of extended defects and strain in halide perovskites and their direct impact on device performance and operational stability.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
The electronic disorder landscape of mixed halide perovskites
Authors:
Yun Liu,
Jean-Philippe Banon,
Kyle Frohna,
Yu-Hsien Chiang,
Ganbaatar Tumen-Ulzii,
Samuel D. Stranks,
Marcel Filoche,
Richard H. Friend
Abstract:
Bandgap tunability of lead mixed-halide perovskites makes them promising candidates for various applications in optoelectronics since they exhibit sharp optical absorption onsets despite the presence of disorder from halide alloying. Here we use localization landscape theory to reveal that the static disorder due to compositional alloying for iodide:bromide perovskite contributes at most 3 meV to…
▽ More
Bandgap tunability of lead mixed-halide perovskites makes them promising candidates for various applications in optoelectronics since they exhibit sharp optical absorption onsets despite the presence of disorder from halide alloying. Here we use localization landscape theory to reveal that the static disorder due to compositional alloying for iodide:bromide perovskite contributes at most 3 meV to the Urbach energy. Our modelling reveals that the reason for this small contribution is due to the small effective masses in perovskites, resulting in a natural length scale of around 20nm for the "effective confining potential" for electrons and holes, with short range potential fluctuations smoothed out. The increase in Urbach energy across the compositional range agrees well with our optical absorption measurements. We model systems of sizes up to 80 nm in three dimensions, allowing us to explore halide segregation, accurately reproducing the experimentally observed absorption spectra and demonstrating the scope of our method to model electronic structures on large length scales. Our results suggest that we should look beyond static contribution and focus on the dynamic temperature dependent contribution to the Urbach energy.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Efficient all-perovskite tandem solar cells by dual-interface optimisation of vacuum-deposited wide-bandgap perovskite
Authors:
Yu-Hsien Chiang,
Kyle Frohna,
Hayden Salway,
Anna Abfalterer,
Bart Roose,
Miguel Anaya,
Samuel D. Stranks
Abstract:
Tandem perovskite solar cells beckon as lower cost alternatives to conventional single junction solar cells, with all-perovskite tandem photovoltaic architectures showing power conversion efficiencies up to 26.4%. Solution-processing approaches for the perovskite layers have enabled rapid 2optimization of perovskite solar technologies, but new deposition routes are necessary to enable modularity a…
▽ More
Tandem perovskite solar cells beckon as lower cost alternatives to conventional single junction solar cells, with all-perovskite tandem photovoltaic architectures showing power conversion efficiencies up to 26.4%. Solution-processing approaches for the perovskite layers have enabled rapid 2optimization of perovskite solar technologies, but new deposition routes are necessary to enable modularity and scalability, facilitating further efficiency improvements and technology adoption. Here, we utilise a 4-source vacuum deposition method to deposit FA$_{0.7}$ Cs$_{0.3}$Pb(I$_x$Br$_{1-x}$)$_3$ perovskite, where the bandgap is widened through fine control over the halide content. We show how the combined use of a MeO-2PACz self-assembled monolayer as hole transporting material and passivation of the perovskite absorber with ethylenediammonium diiodide reduces non-radiative losses, with this dual-interface treatment resulting in efficiencies of 17.8% in solar cells based on vacuum deposited perovskites with bandgap of 1.76 eV. By similarly passivating a narrow bandgap FA$_{0.75}$Cs$_{0.25}$Pb$_{0.5}$Sn$_{0.5}$I$_3$ perovskite and combining it with sub-cells of evaporated FA$_{0.7}$Cs$_{0.3}$Pb(I$_{0.64}$Br$_{0.36}$)$_3$, we report a 2-terminal all-perovskite tandem solar cell with champion open circuit voltage and power conversion efficiency of 2.06 V and 24.1%, respectively. The implementation of our dry deposition method enables high reproducibility in complex device architectures, opening avenues for modular, scalable multi-junction devices where the substrate choice is unrestricted.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Unraveling the varied nature and roles of defects in hybrid halide perovskites with time-resolved photoemission electron microscopy
Authors:
Sofiia Kosar,
Andrew J. Winchester,
Tiarnan A. S. Doherty,
Stuart Macpherson,
Christopher E. Petoukhoff,
Kyle Frohna,
Miguel Anaya,
Nicholas S. Chan,
Julien Madéo,
Michael K. L. Man,
Samuel D. Stranks,
Keshav M. Dani
Abstract:
With rapidly growing photoconversion efficiencies, hybrid perovskite solar cells have emerged as promising contenders for next generation, low-cost photovoltaic technologies. Yet, the presence of nanoscale defect clusters, that form during the fabrication process, remains critical to overall device operation, including efficiency and long-term stability. To successfully deploy hybrid perovskites,…
▽ More
With rapidly growing photoconversion efficiencies, hybrid perovskite solar cells have emerged as promising contenders for next generation, low-cost photovoltaic technologies. Yet, the presence of nanoscale defect clusters, that form during the fabrication process, remains critical to overall device operation, including efficiency and long-term stability. To successfully deploy hybrid perovskites, we must understand the nature of the different types of defects, assess their potentially varied roles in device performance, and understand how they respond to passivation strategies. Here, by correlating photoemission and synchrotron-based scanning probe X-ray microscopies, we unveil three different types of defect clusters in state-of-the-art triple cation mixed halide perovskite thin films. Incorporating ultrafast time-resolution into our photoemission measurements, we show that defect clusters originating at grain boundaries are the most detrimental for photocarrier trap**, while lead iodide defect clusters are relatively benign. Hexagonal polytype defect clusters are only mildly detrimental individually, but can have a significant impact overall if abundant in occurrence. We also show that passivating defects with oxygen in the presence of light, a previously used approach to improve efficiency, has a varied impact on the different types of defects. Even with just mild oxygen treatment, the grain boundary defects are completely healed, while the lead iodide defects begin to show signs of chemical alteration. Our findings highlight the need for multi-pronged strategies tailored to selectively address the detrimental impact of the different defect types in hybrid perovskite solar cells.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Local Nanoscale Defective Phase Impurities Are the Sites of Degradation in Halide Perovskite Devices
Authors:
Stuart Macpherson,
Tiarnan A. S. Doherty,
Andrew J. Winchester,
Sofiia Kosar,
Duncan N. Johnstone,
Yu-Hsien Chiang,
Krzystof Galkowski,
Miguel Anaya,
Kyle Frohna,
Affan N. Iqbal,
Bart Roose,
Zahra Andaji-Garmaroudi,
Paul A. Midgley,
Keshav M. Dani,
Samuel D. Stranks
Abstract:
Halide perovskites excel in the pursuit of highly efficient thin film photovoltaics, with power conversion efficiencies reaching 25.5% in single junction and 29.5% in tandem halide perovskite/silicon solar cell configurations. Operational stability of perovskite solar cells remains a barrier to their commercialisation, yet a fundamental understanding of degradation processes, including the specifi…
▽ More
Halide perovskites excel in the pursuit of highly efficient thin film photovoltaics, with power conversion efficiencies reaching 25.5% in single junction and 29.5% in tandem halide perovskite/silicon solar cell configurations. Operational stability of perovskite solar cells remains a barrier to their commercialisation, yet a fundamental understanding of degradation processes, including the specific sites at which failure mechanisms occur, is lacking. Recently, we reported that performance-limiting deep sub-bandgap states appear in nanoscale clusters at particular grain boundaries in state-of-the-art $Cs_{0.05}FA_{0.78}MA_{0.17}Pb(I_{0.83}Br_{0.17})_{3}$ (MA=methylammonium, FA=formamidinium) perovskite films. Here, we combine multimodal microscopy to show that these very nanoscale defect clusters, which go otherwise undetected with bulk measurements, are sites at which degradation seeds. We use photoemission electron microscopy to visualise trap clusters and observe that these specific sites grow in defect density over time under illumination, leading to local reductions in performance parameters. Scanning electron diffraction measurements reveal concomitant structural changes at phase impurities associated with trap clusters, with rapid conversion to metallic lead through iodine depletion, eventually resulting in pinhole formation. By contrast, illumination in the presence of oxygen reduces defect densities and reverses performance degradation at these local clusters, where phase impurities instead convert to amorphous and electronically benign lead oxide. Our work shows that the trap** of charge carriers at sites associated with phase impurities, itself reducing performance, catalyses redox reactions that compromise device longevity. Importantly, we reveal that both performance losses and intrinsic degradation can be mitigated by eliminating these defective clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Nanoscale Chemical Heterogeneity Dominates the Optoelectronic Response over Local Electronic Disorder and Strain in Alloyed Perovskite Solar Cells
Authors:
Kyle Frohna,
Miguel Anaya,
Stuart Macpherson,
Jooyoung Sung,
Tiarnan A. S. Doherty,
Yu-Hsien Chiang,
Andrew J. Winchester,
Keshav M. Dani,
Akshay Rao,
Samuel D. Stranks
Abstract:
Halide perovskites perform remarkably in optoelectronic devices including tandem photovoltaics. However, this exceptional performance is striking given that perovskites exhibit deep charge carrier traps and spatial compositional and structural heterogeneity, all of which should be detrimental to performance. Here, we resolve this long-standing paradox by providing a global visualisation of the nan…
▽ More
Halide perovskites perform remarkably in optoelectronic devices including tandem photovoltaics. However, this exceptional performance is striking given that perovskites exhibit deep charge carrier traps and spatial compositional and structural heterogeneity, all of which should be detrimental to performance. Here, we resolve this long-standing paradox by providing a global visualisation of the nanoscale chemical, structural and optoelectronic landscape in halide perovskite devices, made possible through the development of a new suite of correlative, multimodal microscopy measurements combining quantitative optical spectroscopic techniques and synchrotron nanoprobe measurements. We show that compositional disorder dominates the optoelectronic response, while nanoscale strain variations even of large magnitude (~1 %) have only a weak influence. Nanoscale compositional gradients drive carrier funneling onto local regions associated with low electronic disorder, drawing carrier recombination away from trap clusters associated with electronic disorder and leading to high local photoluminescence quantum efficiency. These measurements reveal a global picture of the competitive nanoscale landscape, which endows enhanced defect tolerance in devices through spatial chemical disorder that outcompetes both electronic and structural disorder.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Relaxed current matching requirements in highly luminescent perovskite tandem solar cells and their fundamental efficiency limits
Authors:
Alan R. Bowman,
Felix Lang,
Yu-Hsien Chiang,
Alberto Jiménez-Solano,
Kyle Frohna,
Giles E. Eperon,
Edoardo Ruggeri,
Mojtaba Abdi-Jalebi,
Miguel Anaya,
Bettina V. Lotsch,
Samuel D. Stranks
Abstract:
Here we use time-resolved and steady-state optical spectroscopy on state-of-the-art low- and high-bandgap perovskite films for tandems to quantify intrinsic recombination rates and absorption coefficients. We apply these data to calculate the limiting efficiency of perovskite-silicon and all-perovskite two-terminal tandems employing currently available bandgap materials as 42.0 % and 40.8 % respec…
▽ More
Here we use time-resolved and steady-state optical spectroscopy on state-of-the-art low- and high-bandgap perovskite films for tandems to quantify intrinsic recombination rates and absorption coefficients. We apply these data to calculate the limiting efficiency of perovskite-silicon and all-perovskite two-terminal tandems employing currently available bandgap materials as 42.0 % and 40.8 % respectively. By including luminescence coupling between sub-cells, i.e. the re-emission of photons from the high-bandgap sub-cell and their absorption in the low-bandgap sub-cell, we reveal the stringent need for current matching is relaxed when the high-bandgap sub-cell is a luminescent perovskite compared to calculations that do not consider luminescence coupling. We show luminescence coupling becomes important in all-perovskite tandems when charge carrier trap** rates are < 10$^{6}$ s$^{-1}$ (corresponding to carrier lifetimes longer than 1 $μ$s at low excitation densities) in the high-bandgap sub-cell, which is lowered to 10$^{5}$ s$^{-1}$ in the better-bandgap-matched perovskite-silicon cells. We demonstrate luminescence coupling endows greater flexibility in both sub-cell thicknesses, increased tolerance to different spectral conditions and a reduction in the total thickness of light absorbing layers. To maximally exploit luminescence coupling we reveal a key design rule for luminescent perovskite-based tandems: the high-bandgap sub-cell should always have the higher short-circuit current. Importantly, this can be achieved by reducing the bandgap or increasing the thickness in the high-bandgap sub-cell with minimal reduction in efficiency, thus allowing for wider, unstable bandgap compositions (>1.7 eV) to be avoided. Finally, we experimentally visualise luminescence coupling in an all-perovskite tandem device stack through cross-section luminescence images.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Revealing nanomechanical domains and their transient behavior in mixed-halide perovskite films
Authors:
Ioanna Mela,
Chetan Poudel,
Miguel Anaya,
Geraud Delport,
Kyle Frohna,
Stuart Macpherson,
Tiarnan A. S. Doherty,
Samuel D. Stranks,
Clemens F. Kaminski
Abstract:
Halide perovskites are a versatile class of semiconductors employed for high performance emerging optoelectronic devices, including flexoelectric systems, yet the influence of their ionic nature on their mechanical behaviour is still to be understood. Here, a combination of atomic-force, optical and compositional X-ray microscopy techniques is employed to shed light on the mechanical properties of…
▽ More
Halide perovskites are a versatile class of semiconductors employed for high performance emerging optoelectronic devices, including flexoelectric systems, yet the influence of their ionic nature on their mechanical behaviour is still to be understood. Here, a combination of atomic-force, optical and compositional X-ray microscopy techniques is employed to shed light on the mechanical properties of halide perovskite films at the nanoscale. We reveal mechanical domains within and between morphological grains, enclosed by mechanical boundaries of higher Young's Modulus than the bulk parent material. These mechanical boundaries are associated with the presence of bromide-rich clusters as visualized by nano-X-ray fluorescence map**. Stiffer regions are specifically selectively modified upon light soaking the sample, resulting in an overall homogenization of the mechanical properties towards the bulk Young's Modulus. We attribute this behaviour to light-induced ion migration processes that homogenize the local chemical distribution, which is accompanied by photobrightening of the photoluminescence within the same region. Our work highlights critical links between mechanical, chemical and optoelectronic characteristics in this family of perovskites, and demonstrates the potential of combinational imaging studies to understand and design halide perovskite films for emerging applications such as photoflexoelectricity.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
