-
Statistics and spectral analysis of turbulent duct flows with flexible and rigid polymer solutions
Authors:
Rodrigo S. Mitishita,
Gwynn J. Elfring,
Ian A. Frigaard
Abstract:
We present an experimental investigation of turbulent drag reduction with flexible and rigid polymer solutions. The flexible polymer is partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) and the rigid polymer is xanthan gum (XG). The experiments are carried out at low drag reduction ($\%DR < 40$), high drag reduction ($\%DR > 40$) and maximum drag reduction (where the velocity profile $U^+$ roughly matche…
▽ More
We present an experimental investigation of turbulent drag reduction with flexible and rigid polymer solutions. The flexible polymer is partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) and the rigid polymer is xanthan gum (XG). The experiments are carried out at low drag reduction ($\%DR < 40$), high drag reduction ($\%DR > 40$) and maximum drag reduction (where the velocity profile $U^+$ roughly matches Virk's asymptote). We compare velocity profiles, streamwise and wall-normal Reynolds stresses and power spectra of streamwise velocity fluctuations measured by Laser Doppler Anemometry (LDA). Our results show that the effects of both XG and HPAM polymers on turbulence are similar, provided that the Reynolds numbers and $\%DR$ are also similar. At high levels of $\%DR$, the power spectral densities of streamwise velocity fluctuations of both XG and HPAM flows show a power-law decay near $-3$ instead of $-5/3$ in the inertial range. A slope of the power spectra of $-3$ was recently interpreted as evidence of elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT) in polymer jets. At relatively low concentrations, we observe that flexible polymer solutions are more effective at reducing drag, while XG only reaches MDR at very high concentrations. Thus, we hypothesize that the formation of polymer aggregates with higher concentrations contributes to increase viscoelasticity, and thus $\%DR$, with XG and other rigid polymer solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Fully turbulent flows of viscoplastic fluids in a rectangular duct
Authors:
Rodrigo S. Mitishita,
Jordan A. MacKenzie,
Gwynn J. Elfring,
Ian A. Frigaard
Abstract:
Turbulent flows of viscoplastic fluids at high Reynolds numbers have been investigated recently with direct numerical simulations (DNS) but experimental results have been limited. For this reason, we carry out an experimental study of fully turbulent flows of a yield stress fluid in a rectangular aspect ratio channel with a high-resolution laser doppler velocimetry (LDA) setup. We employ aqueous C…
▽ More
Turbulent flows of viscoplastic fluids at high Reynolds numbers have been investigated recently with direct numerical simulations (DNS) but experimental results have been limited. For this reason, we carry out an experimental study of fully turbulent flows of a yield stress fluid in a rectangular aspect ratio channel with a high-resolution laser doppler velocimetry (LDA) setup. We employ aqueous Carbopol solutions, often considered to be a simple yield stress fluid. We formulate different concentrations to address the effect of the rheology of the fluid on the turbulence statistics at an approximately constant Reynolds number. Additionally, we also perform experiments with a single Carbopol formulation at different Reynolds numbers to study its effect. The flow analysis is performed via rheology measurements, turbulence statistics and power spectral densities of velocity fluctuations. The addition of Carbopol to the flow increases turbulence anisotropy, with an enhancement of streamwise velocity fluctuations and a decrease in wall normal velocity fluctuations in comparison to water at the same mean velocity. This change is reflected on the power spectral densities of streamwise velocity fluctuations, where we observe a large increase in energy of large scale turbulent structures. Conversely, the energy of smaller scales is decreased in comparison to water, where the energy drops with a steeper scale than the Newtonian power law of $k_x^{-5/3}$. As we increase the Reynolds number with a Carbopol solution, the streamwise Reynolds stresses approach Newtonian values in the core, which suggests diminishing effects of shear-thinning. The power spectral densities reveal that the energy content at larger scales decreases slightly with the Reynolds number. However, the shear thinning effects do not disappear even as the Reynolds number approaches 50000.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Turbulent drag reduction of viscoelastic wormlike micellar gels
Authors:
Rodrigo S. Mitishita,
Gwynn J. Elfring,
Ian A. Frigaard
Abstract:
Long-chained, viscoelastic surfactant solutions (VES) have been widely employed in the oil and gas industry, particularly in hydraulic fracturing and gravel-packing operations, where turbulence is commonly reached due to high pum** rates. With this motivation, we experimentally investigate the turbulent duct flow of an under-studied class of wormlike micellar solutions that forms a gel at room t…
▽ More
Long-chained, viscoelastic surfactant solutions (VES) have been widely employed in the oil and gas industry, particularly in hydraulic fracturing and gravel-packing operations, where turbulence is commonly reached due to high pum** rates. With this motivation, we experimentally investigate the turbulent duct flow of an under-studied class of wormlike micellar solutions that forms a gel at room temperature. The fluid is characterized via rotational rheometry, and the turbulent velocity and Reynolds stress profiles are measured via Laser Doppler Anemometry (LDA). Three surfactant concentrations are investigated at increasing Reynolds numbers. The turbulent flow fields of water, and semi-dilute solutions of partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) and xanthan gum (XG) are used as comparisons. Our study reveals that the gel-like structure of the wormlike micellar gel is mostly broken down during turbulent flow, especially in the near-wall region where the results indicate the presence of a water layer. Turbulent flow at low concentrations of surfactant show a Newtonian-like flow field throughout most of the duct, where the energy spectra shows a -5/3 power law scale with wavenumber, whereas higher concentrations lead to drag reduction and lower power spectral densities at large wavenumbers. A comparison of the flow of polymeric fluids and the wormlike micellar solutions at maximum drag reduction (MDR) shows comparable drag-reduction effects, with a large decrease in Reynolds shear stresses, and increased turbulence anisotropy in the buffer layer due to the large streamwise fluctuations and near-zero wall-normal fluctuations. Additionally, the MDR regime was bounded by Virk's asymptote for both polymers and the micellar gel, which implies a similar mechanism of drag reduction at MDR.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Flow onset for a single bubble in yield-stress fluids
Authors:
Ali Pourzahedi,
Emad Chaparian,
Ali Roustaei,
Ian A. Frigaard
Abstract:
We use computational methods to determine the minimal yield-stress required in order to hold static a buoyant bubble in a yield-stress liquid. The static limit is governed by the bubble shape, the dimensionless surface tension ($γ$) and the ratio of the yield-stress to the buoyancy stress ($Y$). For a given geometry, bubbles are static for $Y > Y_c$, which we determine for a range of shapes. Given…
▽ More
We use computational methods to determine the minimal yield-stress required in order to hold static a buoyant bubble in a yield-stress liquid. The static limit is governed by the bubble shape, the dimensionless surface tension ($γ$) and the ratio of the yield-stress to the buoyancy stress ($Y$). For a given geometry, bubbles are static for $Y > Y_c$, which we determine for a range of shapes. Given that surface tension is negligible, long prolate bubbles require larger yield-stress to hold static compared to oblate bubbles. Non-zero $γ$ increases $Y_c$ and for large $γ$ the yield-capillary number ($Y/γ$) determines the static boundary. In this limit, although bubble shape is important, bubble orientation is not. 2D planar and axisymmetric bubbles are studied.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2021; v1 submitted 15 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Bubble clouds in viscoplastic fluids
Authors:
Emad Chaparian,
Ian A. Frigaard
Abstract:
Viscoplastic fluids can hold bubbles/particles stationary by balancing the buoyancy stress with the yield stress. In the present study, we investigate a suspension of bubbles in a yield-stress fluid. More precisely, we compute how much the gas fraction $φ$ that could be held trapped in a yield-stress fluid without motion. The key parameter is the yield number which represents the ratio of the yiel…
▽ More
Viscoplastic fluids can hold bubbles/particles stationary by balancing the buoyancy stress with the yield stress. In the present study, we investigate a suspension of bubbles in a yield-stress fluid. More precisely, we compute how much the gas fraction $φ$ that could be held trapped in a yield-stress fluid without motion. The key parameter is the yield number which represents the ratio of the yield stress to the buoyancy stress. Here the goal is to shed light on how the bubbles feel their neighbours through the stress field and to compute the critical yield number for a bubble cloud beyond which the flow is suppressed. We perform 2D computations in a full periodic box with randomized positions of the monosized circular bubbles. A large number of configurations are investigated to obtain statistically converged results. We intuitively expect that for higher volume fractions the critical yield number is larger. Not only here do we establish that this is the case, but also we show that short range interactions of bubbles increase the critical yield number even more dramatically for bubble clouds. The results show that the critical yield number is a linear function of volume fraction in the dilute regime. An algebraic expression model is given to approximate the critical yield number (semi-empirically) based on the numerical experiment in the studied range of $0\le φ\le 0.31$, together with lower and upper estimates.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Rheology of Wormlike Micellar Gels Formed By Long-Chained Zwitterionic Surfactants
Authors:
Ronak Gupta,
Rodrigo Mitishita,
Ian A. Frigaard,
Gwynn J. Elfring
Abstract:
Long-chained surfactant solutions have found widespread use in the oil and gas industry due to a host of attractive properties. In this paper, we characterize one such commercially used viscoelastic surfactant that forms a wormlike micellar gel at room temperature and a viscoelastic solution at higher temperatures. We probe both states by conducting linear and nonlinear rheological tests and analy…
▽ More
Long-chained surfactant solutions have found widespread use in the oil and gas industry due to a host of attractive properties. In this paper, we characterize one such commercially used viscoelastic surfactant that forms a wormlike micellar gel at room temperature and a viscoelastic solution at higher temperatures. We probe both states by conducting linear and nonlinear rheological tests and analyze their behaviour under the framework of micellar rheology. Our study outlines departure from behaviour exhibited by more conventional micellar systems and uncovers interesting dynamics like shear-induced fracture and possible shear-banding in these materials. In doing so we provide a detailed understanding of a novel class of wormlike micellar solutions
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2021; v1 submitted 8 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Computing the Yield Limit in Three-dimensional Flows of a Yield Stress Fluid About a Settling Particle
Authors:
José A. Iglesias,
Gwenael Mercier,
Emad Chaparian,
Ian A. Frigaard
Abstract:
Calculating the yield limit $Y_c$ (the critical ratio of the yield stress to the driving stress), of a viscoplastic fluid flow is a challenging problem, often needing iteration in the rheological parameters to approach this limit, as well as accurate computations that account properly for the yield stress and potentially adaptive meshing. For particle settling flows, in recent years calculating…
▽ More
Calculating the yield limit $Y_c$ (the critical ratio of the yield stress to the driving stress), of a viscoplastic fluid flow is a challenging problem, often needing iteration in the rheological parameters to approach this limit, as well as accurate computations that account properly for the yield stress and potentially adaptive meshing. For particle settling flows, in recent years calculating $Y_c$ has been accomplished analytically for many antiplane shear flow configurations and also computationally for many geometries, under either two dimensional (2D) or axisymmetric flow restrictions. Here we approach the problem of 3D particle settling and how to compute the yield limit directly, i.e. without iteratively changing the rheology to approach the yield limit. The presented approach develops tools from optimization theory, taking advantage of the fact that $Y_c$ is defined via a minimization problem. We recast this minimization in terms of primal and dual variational problems, develop the necessary theory and finally implement a basic but workable algorithm. We benchmark results against accurate axisymmetric flow computations for cylinders and ellipsoids, computed using adaptive meshing. We also make comparisons of accuracy in calculating $Y_c$ on comparable fixed meshes. This demonstrates the feasibility and benefits of directly computing $Y_c$ in multiple dimensions. Lastly, we present some sample computations for complex 3D particle shapes.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2020; v1 submitted 13 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Critical yield numbers of rigid particles settling in Bingham fluids and Cheeger sets
Authors:
Ian A. Frigaard,
José A. Iglesias,
Gwenael Mercier,
Christiane Pöschl,
Otmar Scherzer
Abstract:
We consider the fluid mechanical problem of identifying the critical yield number $Y_c$ of a dense solid inclusion (particle) settling under gravity within a bounded domain of Bingham fluid, i.e. the critical ratio of yield stress to buoyancy stress that is sufficient to prevent motion. We restrict ourselves to a two-dimensional planar configuration with a single anti-plane component of velocity.…
▽ More
We consider the fluid mechanical problem of identifying the critical yield number $Y_c$ of a dense solid inclusion (particle) settling under gravity within a bounded domain of Bingham fluid, i.e. the critical ratio of yield stress to buoyancy stress that is sufficient to prevent motion. We restrict ourselves to a two-dimensional planar configuration with a single anti-plane component of velocity. Thus, both particle and fluid domains are infinite cylinders of fixed cross-section. We show that such yield numbers arise from an eigenvalue problem for a constrained total variation. We construct particular solutions to this problem by consecutively solving two Cheeger-type set optimization problems. We present a number of example geometries in which these geometric solutions can be found explicitly and discuss general features of the solutions. Finally, we consider a computational method for the eigenvalue problem, which is seen in numerical experiments to produce these geometric solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2017; v1 submitted 3 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
On the stability of plane Couette-Poiseuille flow with uniform cross-flow
Authors:
Anirban Guha,
Ian A. Frigaard
Abstract:
We present a detailed study of the linear stability of plane Couette-Poiseuille flow in the presence of a cross-flow. The base flow is characterised by the cross flow Reynolds number, $R_{inj}$ and the dimensionless wall velocity, $k$. Squire's transformation may be applied to the linear stability equations and we therefore consider 2D (spanwise-independent) perturbations. Corresponding to each di…
▽ More
We present a detailed study of the linear stability of plane Couette-Poiseuille flow in the presence of a cross-flow. The base flow is characterised by the cross flow Reynolds number, $R_{inj}$ and the dimensionless wall velocity, $k$. Squire's transformation may be applied to the linear stability equations and we therefore consider 2D (spanwise-independent) perturbations. Corresponding to each dimensionless wall velocity, $k\in[0,1]$, two ranges of $R_{inj}$ exist where unconditional stability is observed. In the lower range of $R_{inj}$, for modest $k$ we have a stabilisation of long wavelengths leading to a cut-off $R_{inj}$. This lower cut-off results from skewing of the velocity profile away from a Poiseuille profile, shifting of the critical layers and the gradual decrease of energy production. Cross-flow stabilisation and Couette stabilisation appear to act via very similar mechanisms in this range, leading to the potential for robust compensatory design of flow stabilisation using either mechanism. As $R_{inj}$ is increased, we see first destabilisation and then stabilisation at very large $R_{inj}$. The instability is again a long wavelength mechanism. Analysis of the eigenspectrum suggests the cause of instability is due to resonant interactions of Tollmien-Schlichting waves. A linear energy analysis reveals that in this range the Reynolds stress becomes amplified, the critical layer is irrelevant and viscous dissipation is completely dominated by the energy production/negation, which approximately balances at criticality. The stabilisation at very large $R_{inj}$ appears to be due to decay in energy production, which diminishes like $R_{inj}^{-1}$. Our study is limited to two dimensional, spanwise independent perturbations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
A novel shear flow instability triggered by a chemical reaction in the absence of inertia
Authors:
T. Burghelea,
K. Wielage-Burchard,
I. A. Frigaard,
D. M. Martinez,
J. J. Feng
Abstract:
We present an experimental investigation of a novel low Reynolds number shear flow instability triggered by a chemical reaction. An acid-base reaction taking place at the interface between a Newtonian fluid and Carbopol-940 solution leads to a strong viscosity stratification, which locally destabilizes the flow. Our experimental observations are made in the context of a miscible displacement flo…
▽ More
We present an experimental investigation of a novel low Reynolds number shear flow instability triggered by a chemical reaction. An acid-base reaction taking place at the interface between a Newtonian fluid and Carbopol-940 solution leads to a strong viscosity stratification, which locally destabilizes the flow. Our experimental observations are made in the context of a miscible displacement flow, for which the flow instability promotes local mixing and subsequently improves the displacement efficiency. The experimental study is complemented by a simplified normal mode analysis to shed light on the origin of the instability
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2006;
originally announced November 2006.
