-
Approaching human 3D shape perception with neurally mappable models
Authors:
Thomas P. O'Connell,
Tyler Bonnen,
Yoni Friedman,
Ayush Tewari,
Josh B. Tenenbaum,
Vincent Sitzmann,
Nancy Kanwisher
Abstract:
Humans effortlessly infer the 3D shape of objects. What computations underlie this ability? Although various computational models have been proposed, none of them capture the human ability to match object shape across viewpoints. Here, we ask whether and how this gap might be closed. We begin with a relatively novel class of computational models, 3D neural fields, which encapsulate the basic princ…
▽ More
Humans effortlessly infer the 3D shape of objects. What computations underlie this ability? Although various computational models have been proposed, none of them capture the human ability to match object shape across viewpoints. Here, we ask whether and how this gap might be closed. We begin with a relatively novel class of computational models, 3D neural fields, which encapsulate the basic principles of classic analysis-by-synthesis in a deep neural network (DNN). First, we find that a 3D Light Field Network (3D-LFN) supports 3D matching judgments well aligned to humans for within-category comparisons, adversarially-defined comparisons that accentuate the 3D failure cases of standard DNN models, and adversarially-defined comparisons for algorithmically generated shapes with no category structure. We then investigate the source of the 3D-LFN's ability to achieve human-aligned performance through a series of computational experiments. Exposure to multiple viewpoints of objects during training and a multi-view learning objective are the primary factors behind model-human alignment; even conventional DNN architectures come much closer to human behavior when trained with multi-view objectives. Finally, we find that while the models trained with multi-view learning objectives are able to partially generalize to new object categories, they fall short of human alignment. This work provides a foundation for understanding human shape inferences within neurally mappable computational architectures.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2023; v1 submitted 22 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Logarithmic aging via instability cascades in disordered systems
Authors:
Dor Shohat,
Yaniv Friedman,
Yoav Lahini
Abstract:
Many complex and disordered systems fail to reach equilibrium after they have been quenched or perturbed. Instead, they sluggishly relax toward equilibrium at an ever-slowing, history-dependent rate, a process termed physical aging. The microscopic processes underlying the dynamic slow-down during aging and the reason for its similar occurrence in different systems remain poorly understood. Here,…
▽ More
Many complex and disordered systems fail to reach equilibrium after they have been quenched or perturbed. Instead, they sluggishly relax toward equilibrium at an ever-slowing, history-dependent rate, a process termed physical aging. The microscopic processes underlying the dynamic slow-down during aging and the reason for its similar occurrence in different systems remain poorly understood. Here, we reveal the structural mechanism underlying logarithmic aging in disordered mechanical systems, through experiments in crumpled sheets and simulations of a disordered network of bi-stable elastic elements. We show that under load, the system self-organizes to a metastable state poised on the verge of an instability, where it can remain for long, but finite times. The system's relaxation is intermittent, advancing via rapid sequences of instabilities, grouped into self-similar, aging avalanches. Crucially, the quiescent dwell times between avalanches grow in proportion to the system's age, due to a slow increase of the lowest effective energy barrier, which leads to logarithmic aging.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2023; v1 submitted 1 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Unsupervised Segmentation in Real-World Images via Spelke Object Inference
Authors:
Honglin Chen,
Rahul Venkatesh,
Yoni Friedman,
Jiajun Wu,
Joshua B. Tenenbaum,
Daniel L. K. Yamins,
Daniel M. Bear
Abstract:
Self-supervised, category-agnostic segmentation of real-world images is a challenging open problem in computer vision. Here, we show how to learn static grou** priors from motion self-supervision by building on the cognitive science concept of a Spelke Object: a set of physical stuff that moves together. We introduce the Excitatory-Inhibitory Segment Extraction Network (EISEN), which learns to e…
▽ More
Self-supervised, category-agnostic segmentation of real-world images is a challenging open problem in computer vision. Here, we show how to learn static grou** priors from motion self-supervision by building on the cognitive science concept of a Spelke Object: a set of physical stuff that moves together. We introduce the Excitatory-Inhibitory Segment Extraction Network (EISEN), which learns to extract pairwise affinity graphs for static scenes from motion-based training signals. EISEN then produces segments from affinities using a novel graph propagation and competition network. During training, objects that undergo correlated motion (such as robot arms and the objects they move) are decoupled by a bootstrap** process: EISEN explains away the motion of objects it has already learned to segment. We show that EISEN achieves a substantial improvement in the state of the art for self-supervised image segmentation on challenging synthetic and real-world robotics datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2022; v1 submitted 17 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Identifying concept libraries from language about object structure
Authors:
Catherine Wong,
William P. McCarthy,
Gabriel Grand,
Yoni Friedman,
Joshua B. Tenenbaum,
Jacob Andreas,
Robert D. Hawkins,
Judith E. Fan
Abstract:
Our understanding of the visual world goes beyond naming objects, encompassing our ability to parse objects into meaningful parts, attributes, and relations. In this work, we leverage natural language descriptions for a diverse set of 2K procedurally generated objects to identify the parts people use and the principles leading these parts to be favored over others. We formalize our problem as sear…
▽ More
Our understanding of the visual world goes beyond naming objects, encompassing our ability to parse objects into meaningful parts, attributes, and relations. In this work, we leverage natural language descriptions for a diverse set of 2K procedurally generated objects to identify the parts people use and the principles leading these parts to be favored over others. We formalize our problem as search over a space of program libraries that contain different part concepts, using tools from machine translation to evaluate how well programs expressed in each library align to human language. By combining naturalistic language at scale with structured program representations, we discover a fundamental information-theoretic tradeoff governing the part concepts people name: people favor a lexicon that allows concise descriptions of each object, while also minimizing the size of the lexicon itself.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Accelerated Gradient Descent Learning over Multiple Access Fading Channels
Authors:
Raz Paul,
Yuval Friedman,
Kobi Cohen
Abstract:
We consider a distributed learning problem in a wireless network, consisting of N distributed edge devices and a parameter server (PS). The objective function is a sum of the edge devices' local loss functions, who aim to train a shared model by communicating with the PS over multiple access channels (MAC). This problem has attracted a growing interest in distributed sensing systems, and more rece…
▽ More
We consider a distributed learning problem in a wireless network, consisting of N distributed edge devices and a parameter server (PS). The objective function is a sum of the edge devices' local loss functions, who aim to train a shared model by communicating with the PS over multiple access channels (MAC). This problem has attracted a growing interest in distributed sensing systems, and more recently in federated learning, known as over-the-air computation. In this paper, we develop a novel Accelerated Gradient-descent Multiple Access (AGMA) algorithm that uses momentum-based gradient signals over noisy fading MAC to improve the convergence rate as compared to existing methods. Furthermore, AGMA does not require power control or beamforming to cancel the fading effect, which simplifies the implementation complexity. We analyze AGMA theoretically, and establish a finite-sample bound of the error for both convex and strongly convex loss functions with Lipschitz gradient. For the strongly convex case, we show that AGMA approaches the best-known linear convergence rate as the network increases. For the convex case, we show that AGMA significantly improves the sub-linear convergence rate as compared to existing methods. Finally, we present simulation results using real datasets that demonstrate better performance by AGMA.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2021; v1 submitted 26 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Representation of symmetry transformations on the sets of tripotents of spin and Cartan factors
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Antonio M. Peralta
Abstract:
There are six different mathematical formulations of the symmetry group in quantum mechanics, among them the set of pure states $\mathbf{P}$ -- i.e., the set of one-dimensional projections on a complex Hilbert space $H$ -- and the orthomodular lattice $\mathbf{L}$ of closed subspaces of $H$. These six groups are isomorphic when the dimension of $H$ is $\geq 3$. Despite of the difficulties caused b…
▽ More
There are six different mathematical formulations of the symmetry group in quantum mechanics, among them the set of pure states $\mathbf{P}$ -- i.e., the set of one-dimensional projections on a complex Hilbert space $H$ -- and the orthomodular lattice $\mathbf{L}$ of closed subspaces of $H$. These six groups are isomorphic when the dimension of $H$ is $\geq 3$. Despite of the difficulties caused by $M_2(\mathbb{C})$, rank two algebras are used for quantum mechanics description of the spin state of spin-$\frac12$ particles, there is a counterexample for Uhlhorn's version of Wigner's theorem for such state space.
In this note we prove that in order that the description of the spin will be relativistic, it is not enough to preserve the projection lattice equipped with its natural partial order and orthogonality, but we also need to preserve the partial order set of all tripotents and orthogonality among them (a set which strictly enlarges the lattice of projections). Concretely, let $M$ and $N$ be two atomic JBW$^*$-triples not containing rank-one Cartan factors, and let $\mathcal{U} (M)$ and $\mathcal{U} (N)$ denote the set of all tripotents in $M$ and $N$, respectively. We show that each bijection $Φ: \mathcal{U} (M)\to \mathcal{U} (N)$, preserving the partial ordering in both directions, orthogonality in one direction and satisfying some mild continuity hypothesis can be extended to a real linear triple automorphism. This, in particular, extends a result of Moln{á}r to the wider setting of atomic JBW$^*$-triples not containing rank-one Cartan factors, and provides new models to present quantum behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2021; v1 submitted 3 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Relativity from the Geometrization of Newtonian Dynamics
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Tzvi Scarr
Abstract:
Based on the Generalized Principle of Inertia, which states that: \emph{An inanimate object moves freely, that is, with zero acceleration, in its own spacetime, whose geometry is determined by all of the forces affecting it,} we geometrize Newtonian dynamics for any conservative force. For an object moving in a spherically symmetric force field, using a variational principle, conservation of angul…
▽ More
Based on the Generalized Principle of Inertia, which states that: \emph{An inanimate object moves freely, that is, with zero acceleration, in its own spacetime, whose geometry is determined by all of the forces affecting it,} we geometrize Newtonian dynamics for any conservative force. For an object moving in a spherically symmetric force field, using a variational principle, conservation of angular momentum and a classical limit, we construct a metric with respect to which the object's worldline is a geodesic. For the gravitational field of a static, spherically symmetric mass, this metric is the Schwarzschild metric. The resulting dynamics reduces in the weak field, low velocity limit to classical Newtonian dynamics and exactly reproduces the classical tests of General Relativity. The metric of gravitoelectromagnetism is extended to handle a gravitational field generated by several sources.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
A geometric relativistic dynamics under any conservative force
Authors:
Y. Friedman,
T. Scarr,
J. Steiner
Abstract:
Riemann's principle "force equals geometry" provided the basis for Einstein's General Relativity - the geometric theory of gravitation. In this paper, we follow this principle to derive the dynamics for any static, conservative force. The geometry of spacetime of a moving object is described by a metric obtained from the potential of the force field acting on it. We introduce a generalization of N…
▽ More
Riemann's principle "force equals geometry" provided the basis for Einstein's General Relativity - the geometric theory of gravitation. In this paper, we follow this principle to derive the dynamics for any static, conservative force. The geometry of spacetime of a moving object is described by a metric obtained from the potential of the force field acting on it. We introduce a generalization of Newton's First Law - the \emph{Generalized Principle of Inertia} stating that: \emph{An inanimate object moves inertially, that is, with constant velocity, in \emph{its own} spacetime whose geometry is determined by the forces affecting it}. Classical Newtonian dynamics is treated within this framework, using a properly defined \emph{Newtonian metric} with respect to an inertial lab frame. We reveal a physical deficiency of this metric (responsible for the inability of Newtonian dynamics to account for relativistic behavior), and remove it. The dynamics defined by the corrected Newtonian metric leads to a new \emph{Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics} for both massive objects and massless particles moving in any static, conservative force field, not necessarily gravitational. This dynamics reduces in the weak field, low velocity limit to classical Newtonian dynamics and also exactly reproduces the classical tests of General Relativity, as well as the post-Keplerian precession of binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
New metrics of a spherically symmetric gravitational field passing classical tests of General Relativity
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Shmuel Stav
Abstract:
A general form of a metric preserving all symmetries of a spherically symmetric gravitational field and angular momentum in spherical coordinates is obtained. Such metric may have $g_{01}(r)\neq 0$. The Newtonian limit uniquely defines $g_{00}(r)$. Geodesic motion under such metric exactly reproduces the precession of a planetary orbit, periastron advance of a binary, deflection of light and {Shap…
▽ More
A general form of a metric preserving all symmetries of a spherically symmetric gravitational field and angular momentum in spherical coordinates is obtained. Such metric may have $g_{01}(r)\neq 0$. The Newtonian limit uniquely defines $g_{00}(r)$. Geodesic motion under such metric exactly reproduces the precession of a planetary orbit, periastron advance of a binary, deflection of light and {Shapiro time delay} if the determinant of the time-radial parts of the metric is $-1$. In this model, the total time for a radial round trip of light is as in the Schwarzschild model, but it allows for light rays to have different speeds propagating toward or from the massive object. The value of $g_{01}(r) $ could be obtained by measuring these speeds. All of these metrics do satisfy Einstein's field equations
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Testing the influence of acceleration on time dilation using a rotating MÖssbauer absorber
Authors:
Y. Friedman,
J. M. Steiner,
S. Livshitz,
E. Perez,
I. Nowik,
I. Felner,
H. -C. Wille,
G. Wortmann,
O. Efrati,
A. Finkelstein,
S. Petitgirard,
A. I. Chumakov,
D. Bessas
Abstract:
The aim of the experiment series was to test the influence of acceleration on time dilation by measuring the relative spectral shift between the resonance spectra of a rotating Mossbauer absorber with acceleration anti-parallel and parallel to the direction of the incident beam. Based on the experiences and know-how acquired in our previous experiments, We collected data for rotation frequencies u…
▽ More
The aim of the experiment series was to test the influence of acceleration on time dilation by measuring the relative spectral shift between the resonance spectra of a rotating Mossbauer absorber with acceleration anti-parallel and parallel to the direction of the incident beam. Based on the experiences and know-how acquired in our previous experiments, We collected data for rotation frequencies up to 510Hz in both directions of rotation and also used different slits. For each run with high rotation, we observed a stable statistically significant relative shift between the spectra of the two states with opposite acceleration. This indicates the influence of acceleration on time dilation. However, we found that this shift also depends on the choice of the slit, and on the direction of rotation. These new unexpected findings, resulting from the loss of symmetry in obtaining the resonant lines in the two states, could overshadow the relative shift due to acceleration. This loss of the symmetry is caused by the deflection of the radiative decay due to the Nuclear Lighthouse effect from the rotating Mossbauer absorber. We also found that it is impossible to keep the alignment (between the optical and the dynamical rotor systems) with accuracy needed for such experiment, for long runs, which resulted in the reduction of the accuracy of the observed relative shift. These prevent us to claim with certainty the influence of acceleration on time dilation using the currently available technology. An improved KB optics with focal spot of less than 1 micron to avoid the use of a slit and a more rigid mounting of the rotor system, are necessary for the success of such experiment. Hopefully, these findings together with the indispensable plan for a conclusive experiment presented in the paper, will prove useful to future experimentalists wishing to pursue such an experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Gravitational Deflection in Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics
Authors:
Y. Friedman,
J. M. Steiner
Abstract:
In a recent series of papers, the authors introduced a new Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics (RND) and tested its validity by the accurate prediction of the gravitational time dilation, the anomalous precession of Mercury, the periastron advance of any binary and the Shapiro time delay. This dynamics incorporates the influence of potential energy on spacetime in Newtonian dynamics and, unlike Einste…
▽ More
In a recent series of papers, the authors introduced a new Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics (RND) and tested its validity by the accurate prediction of the gravitational time dilation, the anomalous precession of Mercury, the periastron advance of any binary and the Shapiro time delay. This dynamics incorporates the influence of potential energy on spacetime in Newtonian dynamics and, unlike Einstein's General Relativity, treats gravity as a force without the need to curve spacetime. In this paper, this dynamics is applied to derive the gravitational deflection of both objects with non-zero mass and of massless particles passing the strong gravitating field of a massive body. Equations for the trajectory and the resulting analytical expressions for the deflection angle, in terms of the distance and velocity at the point of closest approach to the massive object, were derived in both cases. It is shown that with a carefully defined limit, the trajectory of a massless particle is the limiting case of that of an object with non-zero mass. In the "weak" deflection limit, the derived expression for the deflection angle of a massless particle (photon) reproduces the experimentally tested Einstein's formula for weak gravitational lensing of a light ray, thereby providing another test for the validity of the RND.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics for Objects and Particles
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics (RND) was introduced in a series of recent papers by the author, in partial cooperation with J. M. Steiner. RND was capable of describing non-classical behavior of motion under a central attracting force. RND incorporates the influence of potential energy on spacetime in Newtonian dynamics, treating gravity as a force in flat spacetime. It was shown that this dynami…
▽ More
Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics (RND) was introduced in a series of recent papers by the author, in partial cooperation with J. M. Steiner. RND was capable of describing non-classical behavior of motion under a central attracting force. RND incorporates the influence of potential energy on spacetime in Newtonian dynamics, treating gravity as a force in flat spacetime. It was shown that this dynamics predicts accurately gravitational time dilation, the anomalous precession of Mercury and the periastron advance of any binary.
In this paper the model is further refined and extended to describe also the motion of both objects with non-zero mass and massless particles, under a conservative attracting force. It is shown that for any conservative force a properly defined energy is conserved on the trajectories and if this force is central, the angular momentum is also preserved. An RND equation of motion is derived for motion under a conservative force. As an application, it is shown that RND predicts accurately also the Shapiro time delay - the fourth test of GR.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Predicting the relativistic periastron advance of a binary without curving spacetime
Authors:
Y. Friedman,
S. Livshitz,
J. M. Steiner
Abstract:
Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics, the simple model used previously for predicting accurately the anomalous precession of Mercury, is now applied to predict the periastron advance of a binary. The classical treatment of a binary as a two-body problem is modified to account for the influence of the gravitational potential on spacetime. Without curving spacetime, the model predicts the identical equat…
▽ More
Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics, the simple model used previously for predicting accurately the anomalous precession of Mercury, is now applied to predict the periastron advance of a binary. The classical treatment of a binary as a two-body problem is modified to account for the influence of the gravitational potential on spacetime. Without curving spacetime, the model predicts the identical equation for the relativistic periastron advance as the post-Newtonian approximation of general relativity formalism thereby providing further substantiation of this model.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
Planck's formula and General Relativity indicate that potential energy influences spacetime. Using Einstein's Equivalence Principle and an extension of his Chock Hypothesis, an explicit description of this influence is derived. We present a new relativity model by incorporating the influence of the potential energy on spacetime in Newton's dynamics for motion under a central force. This model exte…
▽ More
Planck's formula and General Relativity indicate that potential energy influences spacetime. Using Einstein's Equivalence Principle and an extension of his Chock Hypothesis, an explicit description of this influence is derived. We present a new relativity model by incorporating the influence of the potential energy on spacetime in Newton's dynamics for motion under a central force. This model extends the model used by Friedman and Steiner to obtain the exact precession of Mercury without curving spacetime. We also present a solution of this model for a hydrogen-like atom, which explains the reason for a probabilistic description.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Predicting Mercury's Precession using Simple Relativistic Newtonian Dynamics
Authors:
Y. Friedman,
J. M. Steiner
Abstract:
We present a new simple relativistic model for planetary motion describing accurately the anomalous precession of the perihelion of Mercury and its origin. The model is based on transforming Newton's classical equation for planetary motion from absolute to real spacetime influenced by the gravitational potential and introducing the concept of influenced direction.
We present a new simple relativistic model for planetary motion describing accurately the anomalous precession of the perihelion of Mercury and its origin. The model is based on transforming Newton's classical equation for planetary motion from absolute to real spacetime influenced by the gravitational potential and introducing the concept of influenced direction.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Uniform Acceleration in General Relativity
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Tzvi Scarr
Abstract:
We extend de la Fuente and Romero's defining equation for uniform acceleration in a general curved spacetime from linear acceleration to the full Lorentz covariant uniform acceleration. In a flat spacetime background, we have explicit solutions. We use generalized Fermi-Walker transport to parallel transport the Frenet basis along the trajectory. In flat spacetime, we obtain velocity and accelerat…
▽ More
We extend de la Fuente and Romero's defining equation for uniform acceleration in a general curved spacetime from linear acceleration to the full Lorentz covariant uniform acceleration. In a flat spacetime background, we have explicit solutions. We use generalized Fermi-Walker transport to parallel transport the Frenet basis along the trajectory. In flat spacetime, we obtain velocity and acceleration transformations from a uniformly accelerated system to an inertial system. We obtain the time dilation between accelerated clocks. We apply our acceleration transformations to the motion of a charged particle in a constant electromagnetic field and recover the Lorentz-Abraham-Dirac equation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
The wave-function description of the electromagnetic field
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
For an arbitrary electromagnetic field, we define a prepotential $S$, which is a complex-valued function of spacetime. The prepotential is a modification of the two scalar potential functions introduced by E. T. Whittaker. The prepotential is Lorentz covariant under a spin half representation. For a moving charge and any observer, we obtain a complex dimensionless scalar. The prepotential is a fun…
▽ More
For an arbitrary electromagnetic field, we define a prepotential $S$, which is a complex-valued function of spacetime. The prepotential is a modification of the two scalar potential functions introduced by E. T. Whittaker. The prepotential is Lorentz covariant under a spin half representation. For a moving charge and any observer, we obtain a complex dimensionless scalar. The prepotential is a function of this dimensionless scalar. The prepotential $S$ of an arbitrary electromagnetic field is described as an integral over the charges generating the field. The Faraday vector at each point may be derived from $S$ by a convolution of the differential operator with the alpha matrices of Dirac. Some explicit examples will be calculated. We also present the Maxwell equations for the prepotential.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Spacetime Transformations from a Uniformly Accelerated Frame
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Tzvi Scarr
Abstract:
We use Generalized Fermi-Walker transport to construct a one-parameter family of inertial frames which are instantaneously comoving to a uniformly accelerated observer. We explain the connection between our approach and that of Mashhoon. We show that our solutions of uniformly accelerated motion have constant acceleration in the comoving frame. Assuming the Weak Hypothesis of Locality, we obtain l…
▽ More
We use Generalized Fermi-Walker transport to construct a one-parameter family of inertial frames which are instantaneously comoving to a uniformly accelerated observer. We explain the connection between our approach and that of Mashhoon. We show that our solutions of uniformly accelerated motion have constant acceleration in the comoving frame. Assuming the Weak Hypothesis of Locality, we obtain local spacetime transformations from a uniformly accelerated frame $K'$ to an inertial frame $K$. The spacetime transformations between two uniformly accelerated frames with the same acceleration are Lorentz. We compute the metric at an arbitrary point of a uniformly accelerated frame.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Making the Relativistic Dynamics Equation Covariant: Explicit Solutions for Motion under a Constant Force
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Tzvi Scarr
Abstract:
We derive a 4D covariant Relativistic Dynamics Equation. This equation canonically extends the 3D relativistic dynamics equation $\mathbf{F}=\frac{d\mathbf{p}}{dt}$, where $\mathbf{F}$ is the 3D force and $\mathbf{p}=m_0γ\mathbf{v}$ is the 3D relativistic momentum. The standard 4D equation $F=\frac{dp}{dτ}$ is only partially covariant. To achieve full Lorentz covariance, we replace the four-force…
▽ More
We derive a 4D covariant Relativistic Dynamics Equation. This equation canonically extends the 3D relativistic dynamics equation $\mathbf{F}=\frac{d\mathbf{p}}{dt}$, where $\mathbf{F}$ is the 3D force and $\mathbf{p}=m_0γ\mathbf{v}$ is the 3D relativistic momentum. The standard 4D equation $F=\frac{dp}{dτ}$ is only partially covariant. To achieve full Lorentz covariance, we replace the four-force $F$ by a rank 2 antisymmetric tensor acting on the four-velocity. By taking this tensor to be constant, we obtain a covariant definition of uniformly accelerated motion. This solves a problem of Einstein and Planck.
We compute explicit solutions for uniformly accelerated motion. The solutions are divided into four Lorentz-invariant types: null, linear, rotational, and general. For null acceleration, the worldline is cubic in the time. Linear acceleration covariantly extends 1D hyperbolic motion, while rotational acceleration covariantly extends pure rotational motion.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Testing Einstein's time dilation under acceleration using Mössbauer spectroscopy
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Israel Nowik
Abstract:
The Einstein time dilation formula was tested in several experiments. Many trials have been made to measure the transverse second order Doppler shift by Mössbauer spectroscopy using a rotating absorber, to test the validity of this formula. Such experiments are also able to test if the time dilation depends only on the velocity of the absorber, as assumed by Einstein's clock hypothesis, or the pre…
▽ More
The Einstein time dilation formula was tested in several experiments. Many trials have been made to measure the transverse second order Doppler shift by Mössbauer spectroscopy using a rotating absorber, to test the validity of this formula. Such experiments are also able to test if the time dilation depends only on the velocity of the absorber, as assumed by Einstein's clock hypothesis, or the present centripetal acceleration contributes to the time dilation. We show here that the fact that the experiment requires $γ$-ray emission and detection slits of finite size, the absorption line is broadened; by geometric longitudinal first order Doppler shifts immensely. Moreover, the absorption line is non-Lorenzian. We obtain an explicit expression for the absorption line for any angular velocity of the absorber.
The analysis of the experimental results, in all previous experiments which did not observe the full absorption line itself, were wrong and the conclusions doubtful. The only proper experiment was done by Kündig (Phys. Rev. 129 (1963) 2371), who observed the broadening, but associated it to random vibrations of the absorber. We establish necessary conditions for the successful measurement of a transverse second order Doppler shift by Mössbauer spectroscopy. We indicate how the results of such an experiment can be used to verify the existence of a Doppler shift due to acceleration and to test the validity of Einstein's clock hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Dynamics of hydrogen-like atom bounded by maximal acceleration
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Emanuel Resin
Abstract:
The existence of a maximal acceleration for massive objects was conjectured by Caianiello 30 years ago based on the Heisenberg uncertainty relations. Many consequences of this hypothesis have been studied, but until now, there has been no evidence that boundedness of the acceleration may lead to quantum behavior. In previous research, we predicted the existence of a universal maximal acceleration…
▽ More
The existence of a maximal acceleration for massive objects was conjectured by Caianiello 30 years ago based on the Heisenberg uncertainty relations. Many consequences of this hypothesis have been studied, but until now, there has been no evidence that boundedness of the acceleration may lead to quantum behavior. In previous research, we predicted the existence of a universal maximal acceleration and developed a new dynamics for which all admissible solutions have an acceleration bounded by the maximal one. Based on W. Kündig's experiment, as reanalyzed by Kholmetskii et al, we estimated its value to be of the order $10^{19}m/s^2$.
We present here a solution of our dynamical equation for a classical hydrogen-like atom and show that this dynamics leads to some aspects of quantum behavior. We show that the position of an electron in a hydrogen-like atom can be described only probabilistically. We also show that in this model, the notion of "center of mass" must be modified. This modification supports the non-existence of a magnetic moment in the atom and explains the relevance of the conformal group in the quantum region.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Covariant Uniform Acceleration
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Tzvi Scarr
Abstract:
We show that standard Relativistic Dynamics Equation F=dp/dτis only partially covariant. To achieve full Lorentz covariance, we replace the four-force F by a rank 2 antisymmetric tensor acting on the four-velocity. By taking this tensor to be constant, we obtain a covariant definition of uniformly accelerated motion. We compute explicit solutions for uniformly accelerated motion which are divided…
▽ More
We show that standard Relativistic Dynamics Equation F=dp/dτis only partially covariant. To achieve full Lorentz covariance, we replace the four-force F by a rank 2 antisymmetric tensor acting on the four-velocity. By taking this tensor to be constant, we obtain a covariant definition of uniformly accelerated motion. We compute explicit solutions for uniformly accelerated motion which are divided into four types: null, linear, rotational, and general. For null acceleration, the worldline is cubic in the time. Linear acceleration covariantly extends 1D hyperbolic motion, while rotational acceleration covariantly extends pure rotational motion.
We use Generalized Fermi-Walker transport to construct a uniformly accelerated family of inertial frames which are instantaneously comoving to a uniformly accelerated observer. We explain the connection between our approach and that of Mashhoon. We show that our solutions of uniformly accelerated motion have constant acceleration in the comoving frame. Assuming the Weak Hypothesis of Locality, we obtain local spacetime transformations from a uniformly accelerated frame K' to an inertial frame K. The spacetime transformations between two uniformly accelerated frames with the same acceleration are Lorentz. We compute the metric at an arbitrary point of a uniformly accelerated frame.
We obtain velocity and acceleration transformations from a uniformly accelerated system K' to an inertial frame K. We derive the general formula for the time dilation between accelerated clocks. We obtain a formula for the angular velocity of a uniformly accelerated object. Every rest point of K' is uniformly accelerated, and its acceleration is a function of the observer's acceleration and its position. We obtain an interpretation of the Lorentz-Abraham-Dirac equation as an acceleration transformation from K' to K.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2013; v1 submitted 3 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
The scalar complex potential and the Aharonov-Bohm effect
Authors:
Y. Friedman,
V. Ostapenko
Abstract:
The Aharonov-Bohm effect is traditionally attributed to the effect of the electromagnetic 4-potential $A$, even in regions where both the electric field $\mathbf{E}$ and the magnetic field $\mathbf{B}$ are zero. The AB effect reveals that multiple-valued functions play a crucial role in the description of an electromagnetic field. We argue that the quantity measured by AB experiments is a differ…
▽ More
The Aharonov-Bohm effect is traditionally attributed to the effect of the electromagnetic 4-potential $A$, even in regions where both the electric field $\mathbf{E}$ and the magnetic field $\mathbf{B}$ are zero. The AB effect reveals that multiple-valued functions play a crucial role in the description of an electromagnetic field. We argue that the quantity measured by AB experiments is a difference in values of a multiple-valued complex function, which we call a complex potential or {pre-potential. We show that any electromagnetic field can be described by this pre-potential, and give an explicit expression for the electromagnetic field tensor through this potential. The pre-potential is a modification of the two scalar potential functions.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
Testing Doppler type shift for an accelerated source and determination of the universal maximal acceleration
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
An experiment for testing Doppler type shift for an accelerated source and determination of the universal maximal acceleration is proposed.
An experiment for testing Doppler type shift for an accelerated source and determination of the universal maximal acceleration is proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2010; v1 submitted 24 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
The maximal acceleration, Extended Relativistic Dynamics and Doppler type shift for an accelerated source
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
Based on the generalized principle of relativity and the ensuing symmetry, we have shown that there are only two possible types of transformations between uniformly accelerated systems. The first allowable type of transformation holds if and only if the Clock Hypothesis is true. If the Clock Hypothesis is not true, the transformation is of Lorentz-type and implies the existence of a universal maxi…
▽ More
Based on the generalized principle of relativity and the ensuing symmetry, we have shown that there are only two possible types of transformations between uniformly accelerated systems. The first allowable type of transformation holds if and only if the Clock Hypothesis is true. If the Clock Hypothesis is not true, the transformation is of Lorentz-type and implies the existence of a universal maximal acceleration $a_m$.
We present an extension of relativistic dynamics for which all admissible solutions will have have a speed bounded by the speed of light $c$ and the acceleration bounded by $a_m$. An additional Doppler type shift for an accelerated source is predicted. The formulas for such shift are the same as for the usual Doppler shift with $v/c$ replaced by $a/a_m$.
The W. Kündig experiment of measurement of the transverse Doppler shift in an accelerated system was also exposed to a longtitudal shift due to the acceleration. This experiment, as reanalyzed by Kholmetskii et al, shows that the Clock Hypothesis is not valid. Based on the results of this experiment, we predict that the value of the maximal acceleration $a_m$ is of the order $10^{19}m/s^2$. Moreover, our analysis provides a way to measure experimentally the maximal acceleration with existing technology.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2010; v1 submitted 29 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
The scalar complex potential of the electromagnetic field
Authors:
Y. Friedman,
S. Gwertzman
Abstract:
In this paper, we define a scalar complex potential $\mathcal{S}$ for an arbitrary electromagnetic field. This potential is a modification of the two scalar potential functions introduced by E. T. Whittaker. By use of a complexified Minkowski space $M$, we decompose the usual Lorentz group representation on $M$ into a product of two commuting new representations. These representations are based…
▽ More
In this paper, we define a scalar complex potential $\mathcal{S}$ for an arbitrary electromagnetic field. This potential is a modification of the two scalar potential functions introduced by E. T. Whittaker. By use of a complexified Minkowski space $M$, we decompose the usual Lorentz group representation on $M$ into a product of two commuting new representations. These representations are based on the complex Faraday tensor. For a moving charge and for any observer, we obtain a complex dimensionless scalar which is invariant under one of our new representations. The scalar complex potential is the logarithm of this dimensionless scalar times the charge value. We define a conjugation on $M$ which is invariant under our representation. We show that the Faraday tensor is the derivative of the conjugate of the gradient of the complex potential. The real part of the Faraday tensor coincides with the usual electromagnetic tensor of the field.
The potential $\mathcal{S}$, as a complex-valued function on space-time, is described as an integral over the distribution of the charges generating the electromagnetic field. This potential is like a wave function description of the field. If we chose the Bondi tetrad (called also Newman-Penrose basis) as a basis on $M$, the components of the Faraday vector at each point may be derived from $\mathcal{S}$ by $ F_j=E_j+iB_j={\partial}^ν(α_j)_ν^λ{\partial}_λ\mathcal{S}$, where $(α_j)$ are the known $α$-matrices of Dirac. This fact indicates that our potential may build a "bridge" between classical and quantum physics.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2009; v1 submitted 4 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
The relativistic phase space and Newman-Penrose basis
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
We define a complex relativistic phase space which is the space $\mathbb{C}^4$ equipped with the Minkowski metric and with a geometric tri-product on it. The geometric tri-product is similar to the triple product of the bounded symmetric domain of type IV in Cartan's classification, called the spin domain. We show that there are to types of tripotents-the basic elements of the tri-product in the…
▽ More
We define a complex relativistic phase space which is the space $\mathbb{C}^4$ equipped with the Minkowski metric and with a geometric tri-product on it. The geometric tri-product is similar to the triple product of the bounded symmetric domain of type IV in Cartan's classification, called the spin domain. We show that there are to types of tripotents-the basic elements of the tri-product in the relativistic phase space. We construct a spectral decomposition for elements of this space. A description of compatibility of element of the relativistic phase space is given. We show that the relativistic phase space has two natural bases consisting of compatible tripotents. The fist one is the natural basis for four-vectors and the second one is the Newman-Penrose basis. The second one determine Dirac bi-spinors on the phase space. Thus, the relativistic phase space has similar features to the quantum mechanical state space.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Backwards on Minkowski's road. From 4D to 3D Maxwellian electromagnetism
Authors:
Y. Itin,
Y. Friedman
Abstract:
Minkowski's concept of a four-dimensional physical space is a central paradigm of modern physics. The three-dimensional Maxwellian electrodynamics is uniquely generalized to the covariant four-dimensional form. Is the (1+3) decomposition of the covariant four-dimensional form unique? How do the different sign assumptions of electrodynamics emerge from this decomposition? Which of these assumptio…
▽ More
Minkowski's concept of a four-dimensional physical space is a central paradigm of modern physics. The three-dimensional Maxwellian electrodynamics is uniquely generalized to the covariant four-dimensional form. Is the (1+3) decomposition of the covariant four-dimensional form unique? How do the different sign assumptions of electrodynamics emerge from this decomposition? Which of these assumptions are fundamental and which of them may be modified? How does the Minkowski space-time metric emerge from this preliminary metric-free construction? In this paper we are looking for answers to the problems mentioned. Our main result is the derivation of four different possible sets of electrodynamic equations which may occur in different types of isotropic electromagnetic media. The wave propagation in each of these media is described by the Minkowskian optical metrics. Moreover, the electric and magnetic energies are nonnegative in all cases. We also show that the correct directions of the Lorentz force (as a consequence of the Dufay and the Lenz rules) hold true for all these cases. However, the differences between these four types of media must have a physical meaning. In particular, the signs of the three electromagnetic invariants are different.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
Representations of the Poincare group on relativistic phase space
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
We introduce a complex relativistic phase space as the space $\mathbb{C}^4$ equipped with the Minkowski metric and with a geometric tri-product on it. The geometric tri-product is similar to the triple product of the bounded symmetric domain of type IV in Cartan's classification, called the spin domain. We define a spin 1 representations of the Lie algebra of the Poincaré group by natural operat…
▽ More
We introduce a complex relativistic phase space as the space $\mathbb{C}^4$ equipped with the Minkowski metric and with a geometric tri-product on it. The geometric tri-product is similar to the triple product of the bounded symmetric domain of type IV in Cartan's classification, called the spin domain. We define a spin 1 representations of the Lie algebra of the Poincaré group by natural operators of this tri-product on the complex relativistic phase space. This representation is connected with the electromagnetic tensor. A spin 1/2 representation on the complex relativistic phase space is constructed be use of the complex Faraday electromagnetic tensor. We show that the Newman-Penrose basis for the phase space determines the Dirac bi-spinors under this representation. Quite remarkable that the tri-product representation admits only spin 1 and spin 1/2 representations which correspond to most particles of nature.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
-
A new view on relativity: Part 2. Relativistic dynamics
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
The Lorentz transformations are represented on the ball of relativistically admissible velocities by Einstein velocity addition and rotations. This representation is by projective maps. The relativistic dynamic equation can be derived by introducing a new principle which is analogous to the Einstein's Equivalence Principle, but can be applied for any force. By this principle, the relativistic dy…
▽ More
The Lorentz transformations are represented on the ball of relativistically admissible velocities by Einstein velocity addition and rotations. This representation is by projective maps. The relativistic dynamic equation can be derived by introducing a new principle which is analogous to the Einstein's Equivalence Principle, but can be applied for any force. By this principle, the relativistic dynamic equation is defined by an element of the Lie algebra of the above representation. If we introduce a new dynamic variable, called symmetric velocity, the above representation becomes a representation by conformal, instead of projective maps. In this variable, the relativistic dynamic equation for systems with an invariant plane, becomes a non-linear analytic equation in one complex variable. We obtain explicit solutions for the motion of a charge in uniform, mutually perpendicular electric and magnetic fields. By the above principle, we show that the relativistic dynamic equation for the four-velocity leads to an analog of the electromagnetic tensor. This indicates that force in special relativity is described by a differential two-form.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
A new view on relativity: Part 1. Kinematic relations between inertial and relativistically accelerated systems based on symmetry
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
Several new ideas related to Special and General Relativity are proposed. The black-box method is used for the synchronization of the clocks and the space axes between two inertial systems or two accelerated systems and for the derivation of the transformations between them. There are two consistent ways of defining the inputs and outputs to describe the transformations and relative motion betwe…
▽ More
Several new ideas related to Special and General Relativity are proposed. The black-box method is used for the synchronization of the clocks and the space axes between two inertial systems or two accelerated systems and for the derivation of the transformations between them. There are two consistent ways of defining the inputs and outputs to describe the transformations and relative motion between the systems. The standard approach uses a mixture of the two ways. By formulating the principle of special and general relativity as a symmetry principle we are able to specify these transformations to depend only on a constant.
The transformations become Galilean if the constant is zero. Validity of the Clock Hypothesis for uniformly accelerated systems implies zero constant. If the constant is not zero, we can introduce a metric under which the transformations become self adjoint. In case of inertial systems, the metric is the Minkowski metric and we obtain a unique invariant maximal velocity. The ball of the relativistically admissible velocities is a bounded symmetric domain under projective maps. For uniformly accelerated systems the existence of an invariant \textit{maximal acceleration} is predicted. This is the only method of describing transformations between uniformly accelerated systems without assuming the Clock Hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Explicit solutions for relativistic acceleration and rotation
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
The Lorentz transformations are represented by Einstein velocity addition on the ball of relativistically admissible velocities. This representation is by projective maps. The Lie algebra of this representation defines the relativistic dynamic equation. If we introduce a new dynamic variable, called symmetric velocity, the above representation becomes a representation by conformal, instead of pr…
▽ More
The Lorentz transformations are represented by Einstein velocity addition on the ball of relativistically admissible velocities. This representation is by projective maps. The Lie algebra of this representation defines the relativistic dynamic equation. If we introduce a new dynamic variable, called symmetric velocity, the above representation becomes a representation by conformal, instead of projective maps. In this variable, the relativistic dynamic equation for systems with an invariant plane, becomes a non-linear analytic equation in one complex variable. We obtain explicit solutions for the motion of a charge in uniform, mutually perpendicular electric and magnetic fields. By assuming the Clock Hypothesis and using these solutions, we are able to describe the space-time transformations between two uniformly accelerated and rotating systems.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2005;
originally announced December 2005.
-
Geometric tri-product of the spin domain and Clifford algebras
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman
Abstract:
We show that the triple product defined by the spin domain (Bounded Symmetric Domain of type 4 in Cartan's classification) is closely related to the geometric product in Clifford algebras. We present the properties of this tri-product and compare it with the geometric product.
The spin domain can be used to construct a model in which spin 1 and spin1/2 particles coexist. Using the geometric tri…
▽ More
We show that the triple product defined by the spin domain (Bounded Symmetric Domain of type 4 in Cartan's classification) is closely related to the geometric product in Clifford algebras. We present the properties of this tri-product and compare it with the geometric product.
The spin domain can be used to construct a model in which spin 1 and spin1/2 particles coexist. Using the geometric tri-product, we develop the geometry of this domain. We present a geometric spectral theorem for this domain and obtain both spin 1 and spin 1/2 representations of the Lorentz group on this domain.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
A new relativistic kinematics of accelerated systems
Authors:
Yaakov Friedman,
Yuriy Gofman
Abstract:
We consider transformations between uniformly accelerated systems, assuming that the Clock Hypothesis is false. We use the proper velocity-time description of events rather than the usual space-time description in order to obtain linear transformations. Based on the generalized principle of relativity and the ensuing symmetry, we obtain transformations of Lorentz-type. We predict the existence of…
▽ More
We consider transformations between uniformly accelerated systems, assuming that the Clock Hypothesis is false. We use the proper velocity-time description of events rather than the usual space-time description in order to obtain linear transformations. Based on the generalized principle of relativity and the ensuing symmetry, we obtain transformations of Lorentz-type. We predict the existence of a maximal acceleration and time dilation due to acceleration. We also predict a Doppler shift due to acceleration of the source in addition to the shift due to the source's velocity. Based on our results, we explain the W. Kündig experiment, as reanalyzed by Kholmetski \textit{et al}, and obtain an estimate of the maximal acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2010; v1 submitted 1 September, 2005;
originally announced September 2005.
