Showing 1–15 of 15 results for author: Frantti, J

In Quest of a Ferromagnetic Insulator -- Structure Controlled Magnetism in Mg-Ti-O Thin Films

Authors: Johannes Frantti, Yukari Fujioka, Christopher Rouleau, Alexandra Steffen, Alexander Puretzky, Nickolay Lavrik, Ilia N. Ivanov, Harry M. Meyer

Abstract: Ferromagnetic insulator thin films can convey information by spin waves, avoiding charge displacement and Eddy current losses. The sparsity of high-temperature insulating ferromagnetic materials hinders the development of spin wave based devices. Stoichiometric magnesium titanate, MgTiO$_3$, has an electronic-energy-band structure in which all bands are either full or empty, being a paramagnetic i… ▽ More Ferromagnetic insulator thin films can convey information by spin waves, avoiding charge displacement and Eddy current losses. The sparsity of high-temperature insulating ferromagnetic materials hinders the development of spin wave based devices. Stoichiometric magnesium titanate, MgTiO$_3$, has an electronic-energy-band structure in which all bands are either full or empty, being a paramagnetic insulator. The MgTiO$_3$ ilmenite consists of ordered octahedra and cation network in which one third of the octahedra are vacant, one third host magnesium and one third titanium. By giving up these characteristics, a rich variety of different magnetic structures can be formed. Our experiments and electronic-energy-band-structure computations show that the magnetic and electric properties of Mg-Ti-O films can drastically be changed and controlled by Mg- and Ti-cation arrangement and abundancy in the octahedra. Insulating titanium- and semiconducting magnesium-rich films were ferromagnetic up to elevated temperatures. The presence and origin of ferromagnetic insulating phase in the films is not apparent - the expectation, based on the well-established rules set by Goodenough and Kanamori, is paramagnetic or antiferromagnetic ordering. We show that ferro- and paramagnetic phases, possessing the same stoichiometry, can be obtained by merely rearranging the cations, thus allowing defect-free interfaces in multilayer structures. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Journal ref: J. Phys. Chem. C 2019 123,32,19970-19978

Room-temperature insulating ferromagnetic (Ni,Co)1+2xTi1-xO3 thin films

Authors: Yukari Fujioka, Johannes Frantti, Christopher Rouleau, Alexander Puretzky, Zheng Gai, Nickolay Lavrik, Andreas Herklotz, Ilia N. Ivanov, Harry M. Meyer

Abstract: Insulating uniaxial room-temperature ferromagnets are a prerequisite for commonplace spin wave-based devices, the obstacle in contemporary ferromagnets being the coupling of ferromagnetism with large conductivity. We show that the uniaxial $A^{1+2x}$Ti$^{4+}$$_{1-x}$O$_3$ (ATO), $A=$Ni$^{2+}$,Co$^{2+}$ and $0.6<x \leq 1$, thin films are electrically insulating ferromagnets already at room-temperat… ▽ More Insulating uniaxial room-temperature ferromagnets are a prerequisite for commonplace spin wave-based devices, the obstacle in contemporary ferromagnets being the coupling of ferromagnetism with large conductivity. We show that the uniaxial $A^{1+2x}$Ti$^{4+}$$_{1-x}$O$_3$ (ATO), $A=$Ni$^{2+}$,Co$^{2+}$ and $0.6<x \leq 1$, thin films are electrically insulating ferromagnets already at room-temperature. The octahedra network of the ATO and ilmenite structures are similar yet different octahedra-filling proved to be a route to switch from the antiferromagnetic to ferromagnetic regime. Octahedra can continuously be filled up to $x=1$, or vacated $(-0.24<x<0)$ in the ATO structure. TiO-layers, which separate the ferromagnetic (Ni,Co)O-layers and intermediate the antiferromagnetic coupling between the ferromagnetic layers in the NiTiO$_3$ and CoTiO$_3$ ilmenites, can continuously be replaced by (Ni,Co)O-layers to convert the ATO-films to ferromagnetic insulator with abundant direct cation interactions. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2019; v1 submitted 26 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Journal ref: Annalen der Physik 2019

Nickel-cobalt-titanate thin films - new sustainable magnetic oxides

Authors: Yukari Fujioka, Johannes Frantti, Christopher Rouleau, Alexander Puretzky, Harry M. Meyer

Abstract: Single phase nickel-cobalt-titanate thin films with a formula A1+2xTi1-xO3, where A is Ni2+,Co2+ and -0.25<x<1, were grown by pulsed laser deposition on sapphire substrates. There is a large window in which both Ni/Co ratio and x can be chosen independently. In the prototype ilmenite and corundum structures one third of the octahedra are vacant. The reported structure is obtained by filling vacant… ▽ More Single phase nickel-cobalt-titanate thin films with a formula A1+2xTi1-xO3, where A is Ni2+,Co2+ and -0.25<x<1, were grown by pulsed laser deposition on sapphire substrates. There is a large window in which both Ni/Co ratio and x can be chosen independently. In the prototype ilmenite and corundum structures one third of the octahedra are vacant. The reported structure is obtained by filling vacant (x>0) or emptying filled (x<0) octahedra. When x = 1 all octahedra are filled. Two factors controlling the magnetism and crystal distortion are identified. First is a direct overlap between the adjacent cation d-orbitals resulting in a bond formation and magnetic interactions between the cations. This is most clearly revealed as a crystal distortion in the x approximately 0 compositions with approximately equal amounts of Ni and Co: the distortion of the x approximately 0 compound is a function of Ni/Co ratio. The second factor is x, which controls the cation shift towards a vacant octahedron. The displacement decreases and the symmetry increases with decreasing Ti content as was revealed by x-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy. When all octahedra are filled the cations prefer octahedron center positions. Also the number density of cations has increased by a factor of 50 percent when compared to the ilmenite structure. The number density ratios of Ni/Co cations between x=1 and x=0 compounds is 3. The Raman and x-ray diffraction data collected on samples with x = 1 or close to 1 are interpreted in terms of P63/mmc space group. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2016; v1 submitted 14 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: Results were given in the oral presentation on January 26, 2016 in the Energy, Materials and Nanotechnology (EMN) conference held in Hong Kong, China

X-ray and neutron scattering on disordered nanosize clusters: a case study of lead-zirconate-titanate solid solutions

Authors: Johannes Frantti, Yukari Fujioka

Abstract: Defects and defect models of solids are reviewed. A numerical method able to treat non-periodical solids possessing several simultaneous defect types is given for simulating scattering in nanosize clusters. The approach takes particle size, shape, and defects into account and isolates element specific signals. Examples illustrating how laboratory scale facilities can be used to extract crucial inf… ▽ More Defects and defect models of solids are reviewed. A numerical method able to treat non-periodical solids possessing several simultaneous defect types is given for simulating scattering in nanosize clusters. The approach takes particle size, shape, and defects into account and isolates element specific signals. Examples illustrating how laboratory scale facilities can be used to extract crucial information about defects are given. As a case study a statistical approximation model for lead-zirconate-titanate (PZT) is introduced. PZT is a material possessing several defect types, including substitutional, displacement and surface defects. Spatial composition variation is taken into account by introducing a model in which the edge lengths of each cell depend on the distribution of Zr and Ti ions in the cluster. Spatially varying edge lengths and angles are referred to as microstrain. The Pb, Zr and Ti cation positions were adjusted by bond-valence sum (BVS) model to fullfil nominal valence requirement. The model is applied to compute the scattering from ellipsoid shaped PZT clusters and to simulate the structural changes as a function of average composition. Two-phase co-existence range, the so called morphotropic phase boundary (MPB) composition is given correctly. To make a comparison with commonly used x-ray and neutron diffraction data selected Bragg reflection intensities and line shapes were simulated. Examples of the effect of size and shape of the scattering clusters on diffraction patterns are given and the particle dimensions, computed through Scherrer equation, are compared with the exact cluster dimensions. Scattering from two types of 180 degree domains in spherical particles, one type assigned to Ti-rich PZT and the second to the MPB and Zr rich PZT, is computed. We show how the method can be used for modelling polarization reversal. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2015; v1 submitted 30 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: Typographical and grammatical errors were corrected. Figure 14 was fixed. Section 1.3 was added. References were added and updated

Phase transitions and thermal-stress-induced structural changes in a ferroelectric Pb(Zr0.80Ti0.20)O3 single crystal

Authors: J. Frantti, Y. Fujioka, A. Puretzky, Y. Xie, Z. -G. Ye, C. Parish, A. M. Glazer

Abstract: A single crystal of lead-zirconate-titanate (PZT), composition Pb(Zr0.80Ti0.20)O3, was studied by polarized-Raman scattering as a function of temperature. Raman spectra reveal that the local structure deviates from the average structure in both ferroelectric and paraelectric phases. We show that the crystal possesses several, inequivalent complex domain boundaries which show no sign of instability… ▽ More A single crystal of lead-zirconate-titanate (PZT), composition Pb(Zr0.80Ti0.20)O3, was studied by polarized-Raman scattering as a function of temperature. Raman spectra reveal that the local structure deviates from the average structure in both ferroelectric and paraelectric phases. We show that the crystal possesses several, inequivalent complex domain boundaries which show no sign of instability even 200 K above the ferroelectric-to-paraelectric phase transition temperature TC. Two types of boundaries are addressed. The first boundary was formed between ferroelectric domains below TC. This boundary remained stable up to the highest measurement temperatures, and stabilized the domains so that they had the same orientation after repeated heating and cooling cycles. These domains transformed normally to the cubic paraelectric phase. Another type of boundary was formed at 673 K and exhibited no signs of instability up to 923 K. The boundary formation was reversible: it formed and vanished between 573 and 673 K during heating and cooling, respectively. A model in which the crystal is divided into thin slices with different Zr/Ti ratios is proposed. The physical mechanism behind the thermal-stress-induced structural changes is related to the different thermal expansion of the slices, which forces the domain to grow similarly after each heating and cooling cycle. The results are interesting for non-volatile memory development, as it implies that the original ferroelectric state can be restored after the material has been transformed to the paraelectric phase. It also suggests that a low-symmetry structure, stable up to high-temperatures, can be prepared through controlled deposition of layers with desired compositions. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Triclinic Ni0.6Co0.4TiO3 Ilmenite Oxide

Authors: Yukari Fujioka, Johannes Frantti, Anna Llobet, Graham King, Steven N. Ehrlich

Abstract: Forming a solid-solution of NiTiO3 and CoTiO3, two isostructural (ilmenite) and isosymmetrical (space group R-3) compounds, result in a single-phase compound with a remarkably low crystal symmetry. By neutron and X-ray synchrotron powder diffraction techniques, the space group symmetry of the Ni0.6Co0.4TiO3 sample was found to be triclinic P-1 at room temperature, far above the magnetic transition… ▽ More Forming a solid-solution of NiTiO3 and CoTiO3, two isostructural (ilmenite) and isosymmetrical (space group R-3) compounds, result in a single-phase compound with a remarkably low crystal symmetry. By neutron and X-ray synchrotron powder diffraction techniques, the space group symmetry of the Ni0.6Co0.4TiO3 sample was found to be triclinic P-1 at room temperature, far above the magnetic transition temperature. Ni and Co ions were found to prefer positions close to the octahedron center, whereas Ti ions took off-center positions. This structural distortion is the first known case in ilmenites and opens up ways to modify functional properties of magnetic oxides. Origin of the symmetry lowering is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 24 May, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: 12 pages, 4 color figures, 3 tables

A statistical model approximation for perovskite solid-solutions: a Raman study of lead-zirconate-titanate single crystal

Authors: J. Frantti, Y. Fujioka, A. Puretzky, Y. Xie, Z. -G. Ye, A. M. Glazer

Abstract: Lead titanate (PbTiO3) is a classical example of a ferroelectric perovskite oxide illustrating a displacive phase transition accompanied by a softening of a symmetry-breaking mode. The underlying assumption justifying the soft-mode theory is that the crystal is macroscopically sufficiently uniform so that a meaningful free energy function can be formed. In contrast to PbTiO3, experimental studies… ▽ More Lead titanate (PbTiO3) is a classical example of a ferroelectric perovskite oxide illustrating a displacive phase transition accompanied by a softening of a symmetry-breaking mode. The underlying assumption justifying the soft-mode theory is that the crystal is macroscopically sufficiently uniform so that a meaningful free energy function can be formed. In contrast to PbTiO3, experimental studies show that the phase transition behaviour of lead-zirconate-titanate solid solution (PZT) is far more subtle. Most of the studies on the PZT system have been dedicated to ceramic or powder samples, in which case an unambiguous soft-mode study is not possible, as modes with different symmetries appear together. Our Raman scattering study on titanium-rich PZT single crystal shows that the phase transitions in PZT cannot be described by a simple soft-mode theory. In strong contrast to PbTiO3, splitting of transverse E-symmetry modes reveals that there are different locally-ordered regions. The role of crystal defects, random distribution of Ti and Zr at the B-cation site and Pb ions shifted away from their ideal positions, dictates the phase transition mechanism. A statistical model explaining the observed peak splitting and phase transformation to a complex state with spatially varying local order in the vicinity of the morphotropic phase boundary is given. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: Article contains four black-and-white figures, one colour figure and one Table. Symmetry analysis and details of the model are given in Appendices I and II, respectively

High-pressure neutron study of the morphotropic PZT: phase transitions in a two-phase system

Authors: J. Frantti, Y. Fujioka, J. Zhang, S. Wang, S. C. Vogel, R. M. Nieminen, A. M. Asiri, Y. Zhao, A. Y. Obaid

Abstract: In piezoelectric ceramics the changes in the phase stabilities versus stress and temperature in the vicinity of the phase boundary play a central role. The present study was dedicated to the classical piezoelectric, lead-zirconate-titanate (PZT) ceramic with composition Pb(Zr$_{0.54}$Ti$_{0.46}$)O$_3$ at the Zr-rich side of the morphotropic phase boundary at which both intrinsic and extrinsic cont… ▽ More In piezoelectric ceramics the changes in the phase stabilities versus stress and temperature in the vicinity of the phase boundary play a central role. The present study was dedicated to the classical piezoelectric, lead-zirconate-titanate (PZT) ceramic with composition Pb(Zr$_{0.54}$Ti$_{0.46}$)O$_3$ at the Zr-rich side of the morphotropic phase boundary at which both intrinsic and extrinsic contributions to piezoelectricity are significant. The pressure-induced changes in this two-phase (rhombohedral $R3c$+monoclinic $Cm$ at room temperature and $R3c+P4mm$ above 1 GPa pressures) system were studied by high-pressure neutron powder diffraction technique. The experiments show that applying pressure favors the $R3c$ phase, whereas the $Cm$ phase transforms continuously to the $P4mm$, which is favored at elevated temperatures due to the competing entropy term. The $Cm\rightarrow R3c$ phase transformation is discontinuous. The transformation contributes to the extrinsic piezoelectricity. An important contribution to the intrinsic piezoelectricity was revealed: a large displacement of the $B$ cations (Zr and Ti) with respect to the oxygen anions is induced by pressure. Above 600 K a phase transition to a cubic phase took place. Balance between the competing terms dictates the curvature of the phase boundary. After high-pressure experiments the amount of rhombohedral phase was larger than initially, suggesting that on the Zr-rich side of the phase boundary the monoclinic phase is metastable. △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2012; originally announced February 2012.

Comments: 6 figures

DC and AC Magnetization Study of Complex Ilmenite Oxides (Ni1-xCox)TiO3 (0.05 < x < 0.8)

Authors: Yukari Fujioka, Johannes Frantti

Abstract: Ilmenite solid-solutions, (Ni1-xCox)TiO3 (0.05 < x < 0.8), were synthesized at ambient atmosphere through solid-state reaction and were studied by energy dispersive spectroscopy of X-rays, X-ray diffraction, and DC and AC magnetometry. Temperature dependent DC magnetic measurements revealed two transitions. The first took place at around 27 K and the second at 63 K. The low-temperature phase was a… ▽ More Ilmenite solid-solutions, (Ni1-xCox)TiO3 (0.05 < x < 0.8), were synthesized at ambient atmosphere through solid-state reaction and were studied by energy dispersive spectroscopy of X-rays, X-ray diffraction, and DC and AC magnetometry. Temperature dependent DC magnetic measurements revealed two transitions. The first took place at around 27 K and the second at 63 K. The low-temperature phase was antiferromagnetic. The phase observed between 27 and 63 K is characteristic to the solid-solution and is not found in either of the constituent members. A fit of the data to the Curie-Weiss law gave magnetic moment values which were significantly larger than the values based on the quenched orbital momentum assumption. Zero-field-cooled magnetization measurements with weak magnetic field revealed unexpected negative magnetization at low temperatures. Below 63 K the DC magnetization exhibited time dependent behavior. Frequency and magnetic field dependent AC magnetization is also addressed. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 8 figures

Evidence against the polarization rotation model of piezoelectric perovskites at the morphotropic phase boundary

Authors: Johannes Frantti, Yukari Fujioka, Risto M. Nieminen

Abstract: The origin of the very large piezoelectric response observed in the vicinity of the morphotropic phase boundary (MPB) in perovskite lead zirconate titanate and related systems has been under intensive studies. Polarization rotation ideas are frequently invoked to explain the piezoelectric properties. It was recently reported that lead titanate undergoes a phase transformation sequence… ▽ More The origin of the very large piezoelectric response observed in the vicinity of the morphotropic phase boundary (MPB) in perovskite lead zirconate titanate and related systems has been under intensive studies. Polarization rotation ideas are frequently invoked to explain the piezoelectric properties. It was recently reported that lead titanate undergoes a phase transformation sequence $P4mm\to Pm\to Cm\to R\bar{3}c$ at 10 K as a function of hydrostatic pressure [M. Ahart et al. Nature Letters. \textbf{451}, 545 (2008)]. We demonstrate that this interpretation is not correct by (i) simulating the reported diffraction patterns, and (ii) by density-functional theory computations which show that neither the $Pm$, $Cm$ nor $Pmm2$ phase is stable in the studied pressure range, and further show that octahedral tilting is the key stabilization mechanism under high pressure. Notes on a more general ground are given to demonstrate that a continuous phase transition between rhombohedral and tetragonal phases via intermediate monoclinic phase is not possible. Thus, two-phase co-existence in the vicinity of the phase transition region is probable and has an important role for electromechanical properties. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2008; originally announced October 2008.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures

Computational study of (111) epitaxially strained ferroelectric perovskites BaTiO3 and PbTiO3

Authors: Riku Oja, Karen Johnston, Johannes Frantti, Risto M. Nieminen

Abstract: The phase transition behaviour of PbTiO3 and BaTiO3 under (111) epitaxial strain is investigated using density-functional theory calculations. From tensile strains of +0.015 to compressive strains of -0.015, PbTiO3 undergoes phase transitions from C2 through two Cm phases and then to R3m. The total polarisation is found to be almost independent of strain. For the same range of strains BaTiO3 und… ▽ More The phase transition behaviour of PbTiO3 and BaTiO3 under (111) epitaxial strain is investigated using density-functional theory calculations. From tensile strains of +0.015 to compressive strains of -0.015, PbTiO3 undergoes phase transitions from C2 through two Cm phases and then to R3m. The total polarisation is found to be almost independent of strain. For the same range of strains BaTiO3 undergoes phase transitions from a single Cm phase, through R3m and then to R-3m. In this case the application of compressive strain inhibits and then completely suppresses the polarisation on transition to the non-polar R-3m phase. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2008; v1 submitted 3 June, 2008; originally announced June 2008.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures, REVTeX 4; text, references and corrections added, to be published in Phys. Rev. B

Pressure induced phase transitions in PbTiO$_3$ - a query for the polarization rotation theory

Authors: J. Frantti, Y. Fujioka, R. M. Nieminen

Abstract: Our first-principles computations show that the ground state of PbTiO$_3$ under hydrostatic pressure transforms discontinuously from $P4mm$ to $R3c$ at 9 GPa. Spontaneous polarization decreases with increasing pressure so that the $R3c$ phase transforms to the centrosymmetric $R\bar{3}c$ phase at around 30 GPa. The first-order phase transition between tetragonal and rhombohedral phase is excepti… ▽ More Our first-principles computations show that the ground state of PbTiO$_3$ under hydrostatic pressure transforms discontinuously from $P4mm$ to $R3c$ at 9 GPa. Spontaneous polarization decreases with increasing pressure so that the $R3c$ phase transforms to the centrosymmetric $R\bar{3}c$ phase at around 30 GPa. The first-order phase transition between tetragonal and rhombohedral phase is exceptional since there is no evidence for a bridging phase. The essential feature of the $R3c$ and $R\bar{3}c$ phases is that they allow the oxygen octahedron to increase its volume $V_B$ at the expense of cuboctahedral volume $V_A$ around a Pb ion. This is further supported by the fact that neither the $R3m$ nor $Cm$ phase, which keep the $V_A/V_B$ ratio constant, is a ground state within the pressure range between 0 and 40 GPa. Thus tetragonal strain is dominant up to 9 GPa, whereas at higher pressures efficient compression through oxygen octahedra tilting plays the central role for PbTiO$_3$. Previously predicted pressure induced colossal enhancement of piezoelectricity in PbTiO$_3$ corresponds to unstable $Cm$ and $R3m$ phases. This suggests that the phase instability, in contrast to the polarization rotation, is responsible for the large piezoelectric properties observed in systems like Pb(Zr,Ti)O$_3$ in the vicinity of the morphotropic phase boundary. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2007; originally announced February 2007.

Review of the recent x-ray and neutron powder diffraction studies on lead zirconate titanate

Authors: Johannes Frantti

Abstract: The issues related to the structure refinement of Pb(ZrxTi1-x)O3 (PZT) solid solutions are discussed. Particular attention is paid on the modelling of the co-existing phases in the vicinity of the morphotropic phase boundary (MPB), where local symmetry is often significantly lower than the average symmetry. According to recent studies, two-phase co-existence in the vicinity of the MPB is a therm… ▽ More The issues related to the structure refinement of Pb(ZrxTi1-x)O3 (PZT) solid solutions are discussed. Particular attention is paid on the modelling of the co-existing phases in the vicinity of the morphotropic phase boundary (MPB), where local symmetry is often significantly lower than the average symmetry. According to recent studies, two-phase co-existence in the vicinity of the MPB is a thermodynamical necessity. Significantly different structural models for PZT with $x$ in the vicinity of the MPB have recently been published. Structural models, based on x-ray, neutron and electron diffraction studies, are reviewed and two essentially different approaches were identified: (i) a method where space group symmetry was decreased untill the features due to the local distortions were 'modelled' and (ii) a method where the highest space group symmetry compatible with the powder diffraction data was used together with a model for a local disorder. Related to the method (ii), the essential features of a model taking the hkl-dependent line broadening into account are summarized. The underlying theme is to consider how local regions, with symmetry lower than the average symmetry, should be modelled. Method (i) often introduces unjustified structural parameters and should be avoided. By studying the temperature and composition dependence of the structural parameters, including line shape parameters and phase fractions in the case of the two phase samples, one can further test the proposed models. The significance of the local structure for electrical properties (switchable polarization and electrical conductivity) is discussed by considering the local Pb ion displacements and their dependence on the neighbouring B-cation configuration. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2006; v1 submitted 6 March, 2006; originally announced March 2006.

Comments: 16 pages, 5 figures

Can buckling account for the features seen in graphite's Raman spectra?

Authors: Y. Fujioka, J. Frantti, E. Yasuda, Y. Tanabe, M. Kakihana

Abstract: Raman scattering data were collected on graphite monochromator. Spectra were interpreted in terms of the space group $P6_3mc$, a subgroup of space group $P6_3/mmc$. The latter has commonly been used for the interpretation of Raman scattering data. Space group $P6_3mc$ corresponds to the buckling of graphene sheets and is consistent with many spectral features. Both the first and second order sca… ▽ More Raman scattering data were collected on graphite monochromator. Spectra were interpreted in terms of the space group $P6_3mc$, a subgroup of space group $P6_3/mmc$. The latter has commonly been used for the interpretation of Raman scattering data. Space group $P6_3mc$ corresponds to the buckling of graphene sheets and is consistent with many spectral features. Both the first and second order scattering were considered. Many first order results (most notably the assignments of the band at 1350 and the peak at 1620 cm$^{-1}$) were found to agree with previous observations [Y. Kawashima and G. Katagiri, Phys. Rev. B \textbf{66}, 104109 (2002)] carried out on highly oriented pyrolytic graphite samples. To check the consistency of the model, symmetry analysis was applied to the second order spectra. Also a simple test for buckling model was done. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2005; originally announced October 2005.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures (one color figure and one black and white figure)

Comment on ``Comparison of the $Cc$ and $R3c$ space groups for the superlattice phase of Pb(Zr$_{0.52}$Ti$_{0.48}$)O$_3$''

Authors: Johannes Frantti

Abstract: The two-phase (space groups $Cc$ and $Cm$) structural model recently proposed for the modeling of the neutron powder diffaction pattern collected on Pb(Zr$_x$Ti$_{1-x}$)O$_3$ (PZT) sample with $x\approx 0.52$ [R. Ranjan, A. K. Singh, Ragini, and D. Pandey. \textit{Phys. Rev. B} \textbf{71}, 092101 (2005)] is shown to neglect the $hkl$ dependent (anisotropic) line broadening. The most serious pro… ▽ More The two-phase (space groups $Cc$ and $Cm$) structural model recently proposed for the modeling of the neutron powder diffaction pattern collected on Pb(Zr$_x$Ti$_{1-x}$)O$_3$ (PZT) sample with $x\approx 0.52$ [R. Ranjan, A. K. Singh, Ragini, and D. Pandey. \textit{Phys. Rev. B} \textbf{71}, 092101 (2005)] is shown to neglect the $hkl$ dependent (anisotropic) line broadening. The most serious problem with this model is that it assigns octahedral tilts to a wrong phase. Instead of correctly taking the anisotropic line broadening into account, this model used low symmetry phases to minimize the residuals during Rietveld refinement. The essential features of a model taking the $hkl$ dependent line broadening into account are summarized. It has already been reported that once the anisotropic line broadening, revealed by high resolution neutron powder diffraction instrument, is correctly taken into account the model with $R3c$ and $Cm$ space group symmetries describes all Bragg peaks and their intensities well [J. Frantti, S. Eriksson, S. Hull, V. Lantto, H. Rundlöf, and M. Kakihana. \textit{J. Phys.: Condens. Matter} \textbf{15}, 6031 (2003).]. It was further shown that the $Cm+R3c$ model is consistent with the structural features observed at other compositions and temperatures, which is particularly important in the vicinity of the phase boundary. Also problems related to sample preparation and data collection are pointed out. △ Less

Submitted 4 July, 2005; v1 submitted 18 April, 2005; originally announced April 2005.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures