-
Creep tide theory. Equations for differentiated bodies with aligned layers
Authors:
Sylvio Ferraz-Mello,
Hugo A. Folonier,
Gabriel O. Gomes
Abstract:
The creep tide theory is used to establish the basic equations of the tidal evolution of differentiated bodies formed by aligned homogeneous layers in co-rotation. The mass concentration of the body is given by the fluid Love number $k_f$. The formulas are given by series expansions valid for high eccentricity systems. They are equivalent to Darwin's equations, but formally more compact. An applic…
▽ More
The creep tide theory is used to establish the basic equations of the tidal evolution of differentiated bodies formed by aligned homogeneous layers in co-rotation. The mass concentration of the body is given by the fluid Love number $k_f$. The formulas are given by series expansions valid for high eccentricity systems. They are equivalent to Darwin's equations, but formally more compact. An application to the case of Enceladus, with $k_f=0.942$, is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Ellipsoidal equilibrium figure and Cassini states of rotating planets and satellites deformed by a tidal potential in the spatial case
Authors:
Hugo A. Folonier,
Gwenaël Boué,
Sylvio Ferraz-Mello
Abstract:
The equilibrium figure of an inviscid tidally deformed body is the starting point for the construction of many tidal theories such as Darwinian tidal theories or the hydrodynamical Creep tide theory. This paper presents the ellipsoidal equilibrium figure when the spin rate vector of the deformed body is not perpendicular to the plane of motion of the companion. We obtain the equatorial and the pol…
▽ More
The equilibrium figure of an inviscid tidally deformed body is the starting point for the construction of many tidal theories such as Darwinian tidal theories or the hydrodynamical Creep tide theory. This paper presents the ellipsoidal equilibrium figure when the spin rate vector of the deformed body is not perpendicular to the plane of motion of the companion. We obtain the equatorial and the polar flattenings as functions of the Jeans and the Maclaurin flattenings, and of the angle $θ$ between the spin rate vector and the radius vector. The equatorial vertex of the equilibrium ellipsoid does not point toward the companion, which produces a torque perpendicular to the rotation vector, which introduces terms of precession and nutation. We find that the direction of spin may differ significantly from the direction of the principal axis of inertia $C$, so the classical approximation $\mathsf{I}\vecω\approx C\vecω$ only makes sense in the neighborhood of the planar problem. We also study the so-called Cassini states. Neglecting the short-period terms in the differential equation for the spin direction and assuming a uniform precession of the line of the orbital ascending node, we obtain the same differential equation as that found by Colombo (1966). That is, a tidally deformed inviscid body has exactly the same Cassini states as a rotating axisymmetric rigid body, the tidal bulge having no secular effect at first order.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Creep Tide Model for the 3-Body Problem. The rotational evolution of a circumbinary planet
Authors:
F. A. Zoppetti,
H. Folonier,
A. M. Leiva,
C. Beaugé
Abstract:
We present a tidal model for treating the rotational evolution in the general three-body problem with arbitrary viscosities, in which all the masses are considered to be extended and all the tidal interactions between pairs are taken into account. Based on the creep tide theory, we present the set of differential equations that describes the rotational evolution of each body, in a formalism that i…
▽ More
We present a tidal model for treating the rotational evolution in the general three-body problem with arbitrary viscosities, in which all the masses are considered to be extended and all the tidal interactions between pairs are taken into account. Based on the creep tide theory, we present the set of differential equations that describes the rotational evolution of each body, in a formalism that is easily extensible to the N tidally-interacting body problem. We apply our model to the case of a circumbinary planet and use a Kepler-38 like binary system as a working example. We find that, in this low planetary eccentricity case, the most likely final stationary rotation state is the 1:1 spin-orbit resonance, considering an arbitrary planetary viscosity inside the estimated range for the solar system planets. We derive analytical expressions for the mean rotational stationary state, based on high-order power series of the semimajor axes ratio a1 /a2 and low-order expansions of the eccentricities. These are found to reproduce very accurately the mean behaviour of the low-eccentric numerical integrations for arbitrary planetary relaxation factors, and up to a1/a2 \sim 0.4. Our analytical model is used to predict the stationary rotation of the Kepler circumbinary planets and find that most of them are probably rotating in a sub-synchronous state, although the synchrony shift is much less important than the one estimated in Zoppetti et al. (2019, 2020). We present a comparison of our results with those obtained with the Constant Time Lag and find that, unlike what we assumed in our previous works, the cross torques have a non-negligible net secular contribution, and must be taken into account when computing the tides over each body in an N-extended-body system from an arbitrary reference frame. These torques are naturally taken into account in the creep theory.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Tidal friction in satellites and planets. The new version of the creep tide theory
Authors:
Sylvio Ferraz-Mello,
Cristian Beaugé,
Hugo Alberto Folonier,
Gabriel Oliveira Gomes
Abstract:
Paper on the creep tide theory and its applications to satellites and planets with emphasis on a new set of differential equations allowing easier numerical studies. The creep tide theory is a new paradigm that does not fix a priori the tidal deformation of the body, but considers the deformation as a low-Reynolds-number flow. The evolution under tidal forces is ruled by an approximate solution of…
▽ More
Paper on the creep tide theory and its applications to satellites and planets with emphasis on a new set of differential equations allowing easier numerical studies. The creep tide theory is a new paradigm that does not fix a priori the tidal deformation of the body, but considers the deformation as a low-Reynolds-number flow. The evolution under tidal forces is ruled by an approximate solution of the Navier-Stokes equation depending on the body's viscosity with no ad hoc assumptions on its shape and orientation. It reproduces closely the results of Darwinian theories in the case of gaseous planets and stars, but the results are completely different in the case of stiff satellites and planets. It explains the tidal dissipations of Enceladus and Mimas. The extension of the theory to nonhomogeneous icy satellites with a subsurface ocean allows the amplitude of the forced oscillations around synchronization (librations) to be better determined.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Rotation and figure evolution in the creep tide theory. A new approach and application to Mercury
Authors:
Gabriel O. Gomes,
Hugo A. Folonier,
Sylvio Ferraz-Mello
Abstract:
This paper deals with the rotation and figure evolution of a planet near the 3/2 spin-orbit resonance and the exploration of a new formulation of the creep tide theory (Folonier et al. 2018). This new formulation is composed by a system of differential equations for the figure and the rotation of the body simultaneously (which is the same system of equations used in Folonier et al. 2018), differen…
▽ More
This paper deals with the rotation and figure evolution of a planet near the 3/2 spin-orbit resonance and the exploration of a new formulation of the creep tide theory (Folonier et al. 2018). This new formulation is composed by a system of differential equations for the figure and the rotation of the body simultaneously (which is the same system of equations used in Folonier et al. 2018), different from the original one (Ferraz-Mello, 2013, 2015a) in which rotation and figure were considered separately. The time evolution of the figure of the body is studied for both the 3/2 and 2/1 spin-orbit resonances. Moreover, we provide a method to determine the relaxation factor gamma of non-rigid homogeneous bodies whose endpoint of rotational evolution from tidal interactions is the 3/2 spin-orbit resonance, provided that (i) an initially faster rotation is assumed and (ii) no permanent components of the flattenings of the body existed at the time of the capture in the 3/2 spin-orbit resonance. The method is applied to Mercury, since it is currently trapped in a 3/2 spin-orbit resonance with its orbital motion and we obtain 4.8 times 10 -8 s -1 lower than gamma lower than 4.8 times 10 -9 s -1 . The equatorial prolateness and polar oblateness coefficients obtained for Mercury's figure with such range of values of gamma are the same as the ones given by the Darwin-Kaula model (Matsuyama and Nimmo 2009). However, comparing the values of the flattenings obtained for such range of gamma with those obtained from MESSENGER's measurements (Perry et al. 2015), we see that the current values for Mercury's equatorial prolateness and polar oblateness are 2-3 orders of magnitude larger than the values given by the tidal theories.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
A self-consistent weak friction model for the tidal evolution of circumbinary planets
Authors:
F. A. Zoppetti,
C. Beaugé,
A. M. Leiva,
H. Folonier
Abstract:
We present a self-consistent model for the tidal evolution of circumbinary planets. Based on the weak-friction model, we derive expressions of the resulting forces and torques considering complete tidal interactions between all the bodies of the system. Although the tidal deformation suffered by each extended mass must take into account the combined gravitational effects of the other two bodies, t…
▽ More
We present a self-consistent model for the tidal evolution of circumbinary planets. Based on the weak-friction model, we derive expressions of the resulting forces and torques considering complete tidal interactions between all the bodies of the system. Although the tidal deformation suffered by each extended mass must take into account the combined gravitational effects of the other two bodies, the only tidal forces that have a net effect on the dynamic are those that are applied on the same body that exerts the deformation, as long as no mean-motion resonance exists between the masses. We apply the model to the Kepler-38 binary system. The evolution of the spin equations shows that the planet reaches a stationary solution much faster than the stars, and the equilibrium spin frequency is sub-synchronous. The binary components evolve on a longer timescale, reaching a super-synchronous solution very close to that derived for the 2-body problem. After reaching spin stationarity, the eccentricity is damped in all bodies and for all the parameters analyzed here. A similar effect is noted for the binary separation. The semimajor axis of the planet, on the other hand, may migrate inwards or outwards, depending on the masses and orbital parameters. In some cases the secular evolution of the system may also exhibit an alignment of the pericenters, requiring to include additional terms in the tidal model. Finally, we derived analytical expressions for the variational equations of the orbital evolution and spin rates based on low-order elliptical expansions in the semimajor axis ratio and the eccentricities. These are found to reduce to the 2-body case when one of the masses is taken equal to zero. This model allow us to find a close and simple analytical expression for the stationary spin rates of all the bodies, as well as predicting the direction and magnitude of the orbital migration.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Tidal synchronization of close-in satellites and exoplanets. III. Tidal dissipation revisited and application to Enceladus
Authors:
Hugo A. Folonier,
Sylvio Ferraz-Mello,
Eduardo Andrade-Ines
Abstract:
This paper deals with a new formulation of the creep tide theory (Ferraz-Mello, Cel. Mech. Dyn. Astron. {\bf 116}, 109, 2013 $-$ Paper I) and with the tidal dissipation predicted by the theory in the case of stiff bodies whose rotation is not synchronous but is oscillating around the synchronous state with a period equal to the orbital period. We show that the tidally forced libration influences t…
▽ More
This paper deals with a new formulation of the creep tide theory (Ferraz-Mello, Cel. Mech. Dyn. Astron. {\bf 116}, 109, 2013 $-$ Paper I) and with the tidal dissipation predicted by the theory in the case of stiff bodies whose rotation is not synchronous but is oscillating around the synchronous state with a period equal to the orbital period. We show that the tidally forced libration influences the amount of energy dissipated in the body and the average perturbation of the orbital elements. This influence depends on the libration amplitude and is generally neglected in the study of planetary satellites. However, they may be responsible for a 27 percent increase in the dissipation of Enceladus. The relaxation factor necessary to explain the observed dissipation of Enceladus ($γ=1.2-3.8\times 10^{-7}\ {\rm s}^{-1}$) has the expected order of magnitude for planetary satellites and corresponds to the viscosity $0.6-1.9 \times 10^{14}$ Pa s, which is in reasonable agreement with the value recently estimated by Efroimsky (2018) ($0.24 \times 10^{14}$ Pa s) and with the value adopted by Roberts and Nimmo (2008) for the viscosity of the ice shell ($10^{13}-10^{14}$ Pa s). For comparison purposes, the results are extended also to the case of Mimas and are consistent with the negligible dissipation and the absence of observed tectonic activity. The corrections of some mistakes and typos of paper II (Ferraz-Mello, Cel. Mech. Dyn. Astron. {\bf 122}, 359, 2015) are included at the end of the paper.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2019; v1 submitted 28 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Tidal synchronization of an anelastic multi-layered body: Titan's synchronous rotation
Authors:
Hugo A. Folonier,
Sylvio Ferraz-Mello
Abstract:
This paper presents one analytical tidal theory for a viscoelastic multi-layered body with an arbitrary number of homogeneous layers. Starting with the static equilibrium figure, modified to include tide and differential rotation, and using the Newtonian creep approach, we find the dynamical equilibrium figure of the deformed body, which allows us to calculate the tidal potential and the forces ac…
▽ More
This paper presents one analytical tidal theory for a viscoelastic multi-layered body with an arbitrary number of homogeneous layers. Starting with the static equilibrium figure, modified to include tide and differential rotation, and using the Newtonian creep approach, we find the dynamical equilibrium figure of the deformed body, which allows us to calculate the tidal potential and the forces acting on the tide generating body, as well as the rotation and orbital elements variations. In the particular case of the two-layer model, we study the tidal synchronization when the gravitational coupling and the friction in the interface between the layers is added. For high relaxation factors (low viscosity), the stationary solution of each layer is synchronous with the orbital mean motion (n) when the orbit is circular, but the spin rates increase if the orbital eccentricity increases. For low relaxation factors (high viscosity), as in planetary satellites, if friction remains low, each layer can be trapped in different spin-orbit resonances with frequencies n/2,n,3n/2,... . We apply the theory to Titan. The main results are: i) the rotational constraint does not allow us confirm or reject the existence of a subsurface ocean in Titan; and ii) the crust-atmosphere exchange of angular momentum can be neglected. Using the rotation estimate based on Cassini's observation, we limit the possible value of the shell relaxation factor, when a subsurface ocean is assumed, to 10^-9 Hz, which correspond to a shell's viscosity 10^18 Pa s, depending on the ocean's thickness and viscosity values. In the case in which the ocean does not exist, the maximum shell relaxation factor is one order of magnitude smaller and the corresponding minimum shell's viscosity is one order higher.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2017; v1 submitted 26 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
The flattenings of the layers of rotating planets and satellites deformed by a tidal potential
Authors:
Hugo Folonier,
Sylvio Ferraz-Mello,
Konstantin V. Kholshevnikov
Abstract:
We consider the Clairaut theory of the equilibrium ellipsoidal figures for differentiated non-homogeneous bodies in non-synchronous rotation adding to it a tidal deformation due to the presence of an external gravitational force. We assume that the body is a fluid formed by $n$ homogeneous layers of ellipsoidal shape and we calculate the external polar flattenings and the mean radius of each layer…
▽ More
We consider the Clairaut theory of the equilibrium ellipsoidal figures for differentiated non-homogeneous bodies in non-synchronous rotation adding to it a tidal deformation due to the presence of an external gravitational force. We assume that the body is a fluid formed by $n$ homogeneous layers of ellipsoidal shape and we calculate the external polar flattenings and the mean radius of each layer, or, equivalently, their semiaxes. To first order in the flattenings, the general solution can be written as $ε_k={\cal H}_k*ε_h$ and $μ_k={\cal H}_k*μ_h$, where $\cal{H}_k$ is a characteristic coefficient for each layer which only depends on the internal structure of the body and $ε_h, μ_h$ are the flattenings of the equivalent homogeneous problem. For the continuous case, we study the Clairaut differential equation for the flattening profile, using the Radau transformation to find the boundary conditions when the tidal potential is added. Finally, the theory is applied to several examples: i) a body composed of two homogeneous layers; ii) bodies with simple polynomial density distribution laws and iii) bodies following a polytropic pressure-density law.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Interplay of tidal evolution and stellar wind braking in the rotation of stars hosting massive close-in planets
Authors:
S. Ferraz-Mello,
M. Tadeu dos Santos,
H. Folonier,
Sz. Csizmadia,
J. -D. do Nascimento Jr,
M. Pätzold
Abstract:
This paper deals with the application of the creep tide theory (Ferraz-Mello, Cel. Mech. Dyn. Astron. vol. 116, 109, 2013) to the study of the rotation of stars hosting massive close-in planets. The stars have nearly the same tidal relaxation factors as gaseous planets and the evolution of their rotation is similar to that of close-in hot Jupiters: they tidally evolve towards a stationary solution…
▽ More
This paper deals with the application of the creep tide theory (Ferraz-Mello, Cel. Mech. Dyn. Astron. vol. 116, 109, 2013) to the study of the rotation of stars hosting massive close-in planets. The stars have nearly the same tidal relaxation factors as gaseous planets and the evolution of their rotation is similar to that of close-in hot Jupiters: they tidally evolve towards a stationary solution. However, stellar rotation may also be affected by stellar wind braking. Thus, while the rotation of a quiet host star evolves towards a stationary attractor with a frequency ($1+6e^2$) times the orbital mean-motion of the companion, the continuous loss of angular momentum in an active star displaces the stationary solution towards slower values: Active host stars with big close-in companions tend to have rotational periods larger than the orbital periods of their companions. The study of some hypothetical examples shows that because of tidal evolution, the rules of gyrochronology cannot be used to estimate the age of one system with a large close-in companion, no matter if the star is quiet or active, if the current semi-major axis of the companion is smaller than 0.03--0.04 AU. Details on the evolution of the systems: CoRoT LRc06E21637, CoRoT-27, Kepler-75, CoRoT-2, CoRoT-18, CoRoT-14 and on hypothetical systems with planets of mass 1--4 M_Jup in orbit around a star similar to the Sun are given.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2015; v1 submitted 14 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Capture Probability in the 3:1 Mean Motion Resonance with Jupiter
Authors:
H. Folonier,
F. Roig,
C. Beaugé
Abstract:
We study the capture and crossing probabilities into the 3:1 mean motion resonance with Jupiter for a small asteroid that migrates from the inner to the middle Main Belt under the action of the Yarkovsky effect. We use an algebraic map** of the averaged planar restricted three-body problem based on the symplectic map** of Hadjidemetriou (1993), adding the secular variations of the orbit of Jup…
▽ More
We study the capture and crossing probabilities into the 3:1 mean motion resonance with Jupiter for a small asteroid that migrates from the inner to the middle Main Belt under the action of the Yarkovsky effect. We use an algebraic map** of the averaged planar restricted three-body problem based on the symplectic map** of Hadjidemetriou (1993), adding the secular variations of the orbit of Jupiter and non-symplectic terms to simulate the migration. We found that, for fast migration rates, the captures occur at discrete windows of initial eccentricities whose specific locations depend on the initial resonant angles, indicating that the capture phenomenon is not probabilistic. For slow migration rates, these windows become narrower and start to accumulate at low eccentricities, generating a region of mutual overlap where the capture probability tends to 100%, in agreement with the theoretical predictions for the adiabatic regime. Our simulations allow to predict the capture probabilities in both the adiabatic and non-adiabatic cases, in good agreement with results of Gomes (1995) and Quillen (2006). We apply our model to the case of the Vesta asteroid family in the same context as Roig et al. (2008), and found results indicating that the high capture probability of Vesta family members into the 3:1 mean motion resonance is basically governed by the eccentricity of Jupiter and its secular variations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
