-
Sherlock Holmes Doesn't Play Dice: The significance of Evidence Theory for the Social and Life Sciences
Authors:
V. L. Raju Chinthalapati,
Guido Fioretti
Abstract:
While Evidence Theory (Demster-Shafer Theory, Belief Functions Theory) is being increasingly used in data fusion, its potentialities in the Social and Life Sciences are often obscured by lack of awareness of its distinctive features. With this paper we stress that Evidence Theory can express the uncertainty deriving from the fear that events may materialize, that one has not been able to figure ou…
▽ More
While Evidence Theory (Demster-Shafer Theory, Belief Functions Theory) is being increasingly used in data fusion, its potentialities in the Social and Life Sciences are often obscured by lack of awareness of its distinctive features. With this paper we stress that Evidence Theory can express the uncertainty deriving from the fear that events may materialize, that one has not been able to figure out. By contrast, Probability Theory must limit itself to the possibilities that a decision-maker is currently envisaging.
Subsequently, we illustrate how Dempster-Shafer's combination rule relates to Bayes' Theorem for various versions of Probability Theory and discuss which applications of Information Theory can be enhanced by Evidence Theory. Finally, we illustrate our claims with an example where Evidence Theory is used to make sense of the partially overlap**, partially contradictory solutions that appear in an auditing exercise.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 1 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Measuring Non-Probabilistic Uncertainty: A cognitive, logical and computational assessment of known and unknown unknowns
Authors:
Florian Ellsaesser,
Guido Fioretti,
Gail E. James
Abstract:
There are two reasons why uncertainty may not be adequately described by Probability Theory. The first one is due to unique or nearly-unique events, that either never realized or occurred too seldom for frequencies to be reliably measured. The second one arises when one fears that something may happen, that one is not even able to figure out, e.g., if one asks: "Climate change, financial crises, p…
▽ More
There are two reasons why uncertainty may not be adequately described by Probability Theory. The first one is due to unique or nearly-unique events, that either never realized or occurred too seldom for frequencies to be reliably measured. The second one arises when one fears that something may happen, that one is not even able to figure out, e.g., if one asks: "Climate change, financial crises, pandemic, war, what next?"
In both cases, simple one-to-one cognitive maps between available alternatives and possible consequences eventually melt down. However, such destructions reflect into the changing narratives of business executives, employees and other stakeholders in specific, identifiable and differential ways. In particular, texts such as consultants' reports or letters to shareholders can be analysed in order to detect the impact of both sorts of uncertainty onto the causal relations that normally guide decision-making.
We propose structural measures of cognitive maps as a means to measure non-probabilistic uncertainty, eventually suggesting that automated text analysis can greatly augment the possibilities offered by these techniques. Prospective applications may concern actors ranging from statistical institutes to businesses as well as the general public.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2023; v1 submitted 15 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
A Unified View of Algorithms for Path Planning Using Probabilistic Inference on Factor Graphs
Authors:
Francesco A. N. Palmieri,
Krishna R. Pattipati,
Giovanni Di Gennaro,
Giovanni Fioretti,
Francesco Verolla,
Amedeo Buonanno
Abstract:
Even if path planning can be solved using standard techniques from dynamic programming and control, the problem can also be approached using probabilistic inference. The algorithms that emerge using the latter framework bear some appealing characteristics that qualify the probabilistic approach as a powerful alternative to the more traditional control formulations. The idea of using estimation on…
▽ More
Even if path planning can be solved using standard techniques from dynamic programming and control, the problem can also be approached using probabilistic inference. The algorithms that emerge using the latter framework bear some appealing characteristics that qualify the probabilistic approach as a powerful alternative to the more traditional control formulations. The idea of using estimation on stochastic models to solve control problems is not new and the inference approach considered here falls under the rubric of Active Inference (AI) and Control as Inference (CAI). In this work, we look at the specific recursions that arise from various cost functions that, although they may appear similar in scope, bear noticeable differences, at least when applied to typical path planning problems. We start by posing the path planning problem on a probabilistic factor graph, and show how the various algorithms translate into specific message composition rules. We then show how this unified approach, presented both in probability space and in log space, provides a very general framework that includes the Sum-product, the Max-product, Dynamic programming and mixed Reward/Entropy criteria-based algorithms. The framework also expands algorithmic design options for smoother or sharper policy distributions, including generalized Sum/Max-product algorithm, a Smooth Dynamic programming algorithm and modified versions of the Reward/Entropy recursions. We provide a comprehensive table of recursions and a comparison through simulations, first on a synthetic small grid with a single goal with obstacles, and then on a grid extrapolated from a real-world scene with multiple goals and a semantic map.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
The Less Intelligent the Elements, the More Intelligent the Whole. Or, Possibly Not?
Authors:
Guido Fioretti,
Andrea Policarpi
Abstract:
We explore a Leviathan analogy between neurons in a brain and human beings in society, asking ourselves whether individual intelligence is necessary for collective intelligence to emerge and, most importantly, what sort of individual intelligence is conducive of greater collective intelligence. We first review disparate insights from connectionist cognitive science, agent-based modeling, group psy…
▽ More
We explore a Leviathan analogy between neurons in a brain and human beings in society, asking ourselves whether individual intelligence is necessary for collective intelligence to emerge and, most importantly, what sort of individual intelligence is conducive of greater collective intelligence. We first review disparate insights from connectionist cognitive science, agent-based modeling, group psychology, economics and physics. Subsequently, we apply these insights to the sort and degrees of intelligence that in the Lotka-Volterra model lead to either co-existence or global extinction of predators and preys.
We find several individual behaviors -- particularly of predators -- that are conducive to co-existence, eventually with oscillations around an equilibrium. However, we also find that if both preys and predators are sufficiently intelligent to extrapolate one other's behavior, co-existence comes along with indefinite growth of both populations. Since the Lotka-Volterra model is also interpreted to represent the business cycle, we understand this finding as a condition for economic growth around oscillations. Specifically, we hypothesize that pre-modern societies may not have exhibited limitless growth also because capitalistic future-oriented thinking based on saving and investing concerned at most a fraction of the population.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2023; v1 submitted 23 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Path Planning Using Probability Tensor Flows
Authors:
Francesco A. N. Palmieri,
Krishna R. Pattipati,
Giovanni Fioretti,
Giovanni Di Gennaro,
Amedeo Buonanno
Abstract:
Probability models have been proposed in the literature to account for "intelligent" behavior in many contexts. In this paper, probability propagation is applied to model agent's motion in potentially complex scenarios that include goals and obstacles. The backward flow provides precious background information to the agent's behavior, viz., inferences coming from the future determine the agent's a…
▽ More
Probability models have been proposed in the literature to account for "intelligent" behavior in many contexts. In this paper, probability propagation is applied to model agent's motion in potentially complex scenarios that include goals and obstacles. The backward flow provides precious background information to the agent's behavior, viz., inferences coming from the future determine the agent's actions. Probability tensors are layered in time in both directions in a manner similar to convolutional neural networks. The discussion is carried out with reference to a set of simulated grids where, despite the apparent task complexity, a solution, if feasible, is always found. The original model proposed by Attias has been extended to include non-absorbing obstacles, multiple goals and multiple agents. The emerging behaviors are very realistic and demonstrate great potentials of the application of this framework to real environments.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
The Production Function
Authors:
Guido Fioretti
Abstract:
Productions functions map the inputs of a firm or a productive system onto its outputs. This article expounds generalizations of the production function that include state variables, organizational structures and increasing returns to scale. These extensions are needed in order to explain the regularities of the empirical distributions of some economic variables.
Productions functions map the inputs of a firm or a productive system onto its outputs. This article expounds generalizations of the production function that include state variables, organizational structures and increasing returns to scale. These extensions are needed in order to explain the regularities of the empirical distributions of some economic variables.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
