-
Cluster Radio Halos at the crossroads between astrophysics and cosmology in the SKA era
Authors:
R. Cassano,
G. Bernardi,
G. Brunetti,
M. Brüggen,
T. Clarke,
D. Dallacasa,
K. Dolag,
S. Ettori,
S. Giacintucci,
C. Giocoli,
M. Gitti,
M. Johnston-Hollitt,
R. Kale,
M. Markevitch,
R. Norris,
M. Pandey-Pommier,
G. W. Pratt,
H. Röttgering,
T. Venturi
Abstract:
Giant Radio Halos (RH) are diffuse, Mpc-sized, synchrotron radio sources observed in a fraction of merging galaxy clusters. The current scenario for the origin of RHs assumes that turbulence generated during cluster mergers re-accelerates pre-existing fossil and/or secondary electrons in the intra-cluster-medium (ICM) to the energies necessary to produce the observed radio emission. Moreover, more…
▽ More
Giant Radio Halos (RH) are diffuse, Mpc-sized, synchrotron radio sources observed in a fraction of merging galaxy clusters. The current scenario for the origin of RHs assumes that turbulence generated during cluster mergers re-accelerates pre-existing fossil and/or secondary electrons in the intra-cluster-medium (ICM) to the energies necessary to produce the observed radio emission. Moreover, more relaxed clusters could host diffuse "off state" halos produced by secondary electrons. In this Chapter we use Monte Carlo simulations, that combine turbulent-acceleration physics and the generation of secondaries in the ICM, to calculate the occurrence of RHs in the Universe, their spectral properties and connection with properties of the hosting clusters. Predictions for SKA1 surveys are presented at low (100-300 MHz) and mid (1-2 GHz) frequencies assuming the expected sensitivities and spatial resolutions of SKA1. SKA1 will step into an unexplored territory allowing us to study the formation and evolution of RHs in a totally new range of cluster masses and redshift, allowing firm tests of the current theoretical hypothesis. In particular, the combination of SKA1-LOW and SUR will allow the discovery of ~1000 ultrasteep- spectrum halos and to detect for the very first time "off state" RHs. We expect that at least ~2500 giant RHs will be discovered by SKA1-LOW surveys up to z~0.6. Remarkably these surveys will be sensitive to RHs in a cluster mass range (down to ~10^14 solar masses) and redshifts (up to ~1) that are unexplored by current observations. SKA1 surveys will be highly competitive with present and future SZ-surveys in the detection of high-redshift massive objects.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
The SKA view of cool-core clusters: evolution of radio mini-halos and AGN feedback
Authors:
Myriam Gitti,
Paolo Tozzi,
Gianfranco Brunetti,
Rossella Cassano,
Daniele Dallacasa,
Alastair Edge,
Stefano Ettori,
Luigina Feretti,
Chiara Ferrari,
Simona Giacintucci,
Gabriele Giovannini,
Michael Hogan,
Tiziana Venturi
Abstract:
In about 70% of the population of relaxed, cool-core galaxy clusters, the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) is radio loud, showing non-thermal radio jets and lobes ejected by the central active galactic nucleus (AGN). In recent years such relativistic plasma has been unambiguously shown to interact with the surrounding thermal intra-cluster medium (ICM) thanks to spectacular images where the lobe rad…
▽ More
In about 70% of the population of relaxed, cool-core galaxy clusters, the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) is radio loud, showing non-thermal radio jets and lobes ejected by the central active galactic nucleus (AGN). In recent years such relativistic plasma has been unambiguously shown to interact with the surrounding thermal intra-cluster medium (ICM) thanks to spectacular images where the lobe radio emission is observed to fill the cavities in the X-ray-emitting gas. This `radio feedback' phenomenon is widespread and is critical to understand the physics of the inner regions of galaxy clusters and the properties of the central BCG. At the same time, mechanically-powerful AGN are likely to drive turbulence in the central ICM which may also play a role for the origin of non-thermal emission on cluster-scales. Diffuse non-thermal emission has been observed in a number of cool-core clusters in the form of a radio mini-halo surrounding the radio-loud BCG on scales comparable to that of the cooling region. Large mini-halo samples are necessary to establish their origin and connection with the cluster thermal properties and dynamics, especially in light of future X-ray characterization of the cluster cores as it is expected by Athena-XIFU. We show that All-Sky reference survey at Band 2 with SKA1 at confusion limit (rms ~2 μJy per beam) has the potential to detect up to ~620 mini-halos at redshift z<0.6, whereas Deep Tier reference surveys at Band 1/2 with SKA1 at sub-arcsec resolution (rms ~0.2 μJy per beam) will allow a complete census of the radio-loud BCGs at any redshift down to a 1.4 GHz power of 10^{22} W/Hz. We further anticipate that SKA2 might detect up to ~1900 new mini-halos at redshift z<0.6 and characterize the radio-mode AGN feedback in every cluster and group up to redshift z ~1.7 (the highest-z where virialized clusters are currently detected).
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
The physics inside the scaling relations for X-ray galaxy clusters: gas clumpiness, gas mass fraction and slope of the pressure profile
Authors:
S. Ettori
Abstract:
In galaxy clusters, the relations between observables in X-ray and millimeter wave bands and the total mass have normalizations, slopes and redshift evolutions that are simple to estimate in a self-similar scenario. We study these scaling relations and show that they can be efficiently expressed, in a more coherent picture, by fixing the normalizations and slopes to the self-similar predictions, a…
▽ More
In galaxy clusters, the relations between observables in X-ray and millimeter wave bands and the total mass have normalizations, slopes and redshift evolutions that are simple to estimate in a self-similar scenario. We study these scaling relations and show that they can be efficiently expressed, in a more coherent picture, by fixing the normalizations and slopes to the self-similar predictions, and advocating, as responsible of the observed deviations, only three physical mass-dependent quantities: the gas clumpiness $C$, the gas mass fraction $f_g$ and the logarithmic slope of the thermal pressure profile $β_P$. We use samples of the observed gas masses, temperature, luminosities, and Compton parameters in local clusters to constrain normalization and mass dependence of these 3 physical quantities, and measure: $C^{0.5} f_g = 0.110 (\pm 0.002 \pm 0.002) \left( E_z M / 5 \times 10^{14} M_{\odot} \right)^{0.198 (\pm 0.025 \pm 0.04)}$ and $β_P = -d \ln P/d \ln r = 3.14 (\pm 0.04 \pm 0.02) \left( E_z M / 5 \times 10^{14} M_{\odot} \right)^{0.071 (\pm 0.012 \pm 0.004)}$, where both a statistical and systematic error (the latter mainly due to the cross-calibration uncertainties affecting the \cxo\ and \xmm\ results used in the present analysis) are quoted. The degeneracy between $C$ and $f_g$ is broken by using the estimates of the Compton parameters. Together with the self-similar predictions, these estimates on $C$, $f_g$ and $β_P$ define an inter-correlated internally-consistent set of scaling relations that reproduces the mass estimates with the lowest residuals.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
The mass-concentration relation in lensing clusters: the role of statistical biases and selection effects
Authors:
Mauro Sereno,
Carlo Giocoli,
Stefano Ettori,
Lauro Moscardini
Abstract:
The relation between mass and concentration of galaxy clusters traces their formation and evolution. Massive lensing clusters were observed to be over-concentrated and following a steep scaling in tension with predictions from the concordance $Λ$CDM paradigm. We critically revise the relation in the CLASH, the SGAS, the LOCUSS, and the high-redshift samples of weak lensing clusters. Measurements o…
▽ More
The relation between mass and concentration of galaxy clusters traces their formation and evolution. Massive lensing clusters were observed to be over-concentrated and following a steep scaling in tension with predictions from the concordance $Λ$CDM paradigm. We critically revise the relation in the CLASH, the SGAS, the LOCUSS, and the high-redshift samples of weak lensing clusters. Measurements of mass and concentration are anti-correlated, which can bias the observed relation towards steeper values. We corrected for this bias and compared the measured relation to theoretical predictions accounting for halo triaxiality, adiabatic contraction of the halo, presence of a dominant BCG and, mostly, selection effects in the observed sample. The normalisation, the slope and the scatter of the expected relation are strongly sample-dependent. For the considered samples, the predicted slope is much steeper than that of the underlying relation characterising dark-matter only clusters. We found that the correction for statistical and selection biases in observed relations mostly solve the tension with the $Λ$CDM model.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2015; v1 submitted 16 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
The strip** of a galaxy group diving into the massive cluster A2142
Authors:
D. Eckert,
S. Molendi,
M. Owers,
M. Gaspari,
T. Venturi,
L. Rudnick,
S. Ettori,
S. Paltani,
F. Gastaldello,
M. Rossetti
Abstract:
Structure formation in the current Universe operates through the accretion of group-scale systems onto massive clusters. The detection and study of such accreting systems is crucial to understand the build-up of the most massive virialized structures we see today. We report the discovery with XMM-Newton of an irregular X-ray substructure in the outskirts of the massive galaxy cluster Abell 2142. T…
▽ More
Structure formation in the current Universe operates through the accretion of group-scale systems onto massive clusters. The detection and study of such accreting systems is crucial to understand the build-up of the most massive virialized structures we see today. We report the discovery with XMM-Newton of an irregular X-ray substructure in the outskirts of the massive galaxy cluster Abell 2142. The tip of the X-ray emission coincides with a concentration of galaxies. The bulk of the X-ray emission of this substructure appears to be lagging behind the galaxies and extends over a projected scale of at least 800 kpc. The temperature of the gas in this region is 1.4 keV, which is a factor of ~4 lower than the surrounding medium and is typical of the virialized plasma of a galaxy group with a mass of a few 10^13M_sun. For this reason, we interpret this structure as a galaxy group in the process of being accreted onto the main dark-matter halo. The X-ray structure trailing behind the group is due to gas stripped from its original dark-matter halo as it moves through the intracluster medium (ICM). This is the longest X-ray trail reported to date. For an infall velocity of ~1,200 km s-1 we estimate that the stripped gas has been surviving in the presence of the hot ICM for at least 600 Myr, which exceeds the Spitzer conduction timescale in the medium by a factor of >~400. Such a strong suppression of conductivity is likely related to a tangled magnetic field with small coherence length and to plasma microinstabilities. The long survival time of the low-entropy intragroup medium suggests that the infalling material can eventually settle within the core of the main cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
CoMaLit - II. The scaling relation between mass and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich signal for Planck selected galaxy clusters
Authors:
Mauro Sereno,
Stefano Ettori,
Lauro Moscardini
Abstract:
We discuss the scaling relation between mass and integrated Compton parameter of a sample of galaxy clusters from the all-sky {\it Planck} Sunyaev-Zel'dovich catalogue. Masses were measured with either weak lensing, caustics techniques, or assuming hydrostatic equilibrium. The retrieved $Y_{500}$-$M_{500}$ relation does not strongly depend on the calibration sample. We found a slope of 1.4-1.9, in…
▽ More
We discuss the scaling relation between mass and integrated Compton parameter of a sample of galaxy clusters from the all-sky {\it Planck} Sunyaev-Zel'dovich catalogue. Masses were measured with either weak lensing, caustics techniques, or assuming hydrostatic equilibrium. The retrieved $Y_{500}$-$M_{500}$ relation does not strongly depend on the calibration sample. We found a slope of 1.4-1.9, in agreement with self-similar predictions, with an intrinsic scatter of $20\pm10$ per cent. The absolute calibration of the relation can not be ascertained due to systematic differences of $\sim$20-40 per cent in mass estimates reported by distinct groups. Due to the scatter, the slope of the conditional scaling relation, to be used in cosmological studies of number counts, is shallower, $\sim$1.1-1.6. The regression methods employed account for intrinsic scatter in the mass measurements too. We found that Planck mass estimates suffer from a mass dependent bias.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2015; v1 submitted 29 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Comparing Masses in Literature (CoMaLit)-I. Bias and scatter in weak lensing and X-ray mass estimates of clusters
Authors:
Mauro Sereno,
Stefano Ettori
Abstract:
The first building block to use galaxy clusters in astrophysics and cosmology is the accurate determination of their mass. Two of the most well regarded direct mass estimators are based on weak lensing (WL) determinations or X-ray analyses assuming hydrostatic equilibrium (HE). By comparing these two mass measurements in samples of rich clusters, we determined the intrinsic scatters,…
▽ More
The first building block to use galaxy clusters in astrophysics and cosmology is the accurate determination of their mass. Two of the most well regarded direct mass estimators are based on weak lensing (WL) determinations or X-ray analyses assuming hydrostatic equilibrium (HE). By comparing these two mass measurements in samples of rich clusters, we determined the intrinsic scatters, $σ_\mathrm{WL}\sim$15 per cent for WL masses and $σ_\mathrm{HE}\sim$25 per cent for HE masses. The certain assessment of the bias is hampered by differences as large as $\sim$40 per cent in either WL or HE mass estimates reported by different groups. If the intrinsic scatter in the mass estimate is not considered, the slope of any scaling relation `observable--mass' is biased towards shallower values, whereas the intrinsic scatter of the scaling is over-estimated.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2015; v1 submitted 29 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
CLASH-X: A Comparison of Lensing and X-ray Techniques for Measuring the Mass Profiles of Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Megan Donahue,
G. Mark Voit,
Andisheh Mahdavi,
Keiichi Umetsu,
Stefano Ettori,
Julian Merten,
Marc Postman,
Aaron Hoffer,
Alessandro Baldi,
Dan Coe,
Nicole Czakon,
Mattias Bartelmann,
Narciso Benitez,
Rychard Bouwens,
Larry Bradley,
Tom Broadhurst,
Holland Ford,
Fabio Gastaldello,
Claudio Grillo,
Leopoldo Infante,
Stephanie Jouvel,
Anton Koekemoer,
Daniel Kelson,
Ofer Lahav,
Doron Lemze
, et al. (13 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present profiles of temperature (Tx), gas mass, and hydrostatic mass estimated from new and archival X-ray observations of CLASH clusters. We compare measurements derived from XMM and Chandra observations with one another and compare both to gravitational lensing mass profiles derived with CLASH HST and ground-based lensing data. Radial profiles of Chandra and XMM electron density and enclosed…
▽ More
We present profiles of temperature (Tx), gas mass, and hydrostatic mass estimated from new and archival X-ray observations of CLASH clusters. We compare measurements derived from XMM and Chandra observations with one another and compare both to gravitational lensing mass profiles derived with CLASH HST and ground-based lensing data. Radial profiles of Chandra and XMM electron density and enclosed gas mass are nearly identical, indicating that differences in hydrostatic masses inferred from X-ray observations arise from differences in Tx measurements. Encouragingly, cluster Txs are consistent with one another at ~100-200 kpc radii but XMM Tx systematically decline relative to Chandra Tx at larger radii. The angular dependence of the discrepancy suggests additional investigation on systematics such as the XMM point spread function correction, vignetting and off-axis responses. We present the CLASH-X mass-profile comparisons in the form of cosmology-independent and redshift-independent circular-velocity profiles. Ratios of Chandra HSE mass profiles to CLASH lensing profiles show no obvious radial dependence in the 0.3-0.8 Mpc range. However, the mean mass biases inferred from the WL and SaWLens data are different. e.g., the weighted-mean value at 0.5 Mpc is <b> = 0.12 for the WL comparison and <b> = -0.11 for the SaWLens comparison. The ratios of XMM HSE mass profiles to CLASH lensing profiles show a pronounced radial dependence in the 0.3-1.0 Mpc range, with a weighted mean mass bias of value rising to <b>~0.3 at ~1 Mpc for the WL comparison and <b> of 0.25 for SaWLens comparison. The enclosed gas mass profiles from both Chandra and XMM rise to a value 1/8 times the total-mass profiles inferred from lensing at 0.5 Mpc and remain constant outside of that radius, suggesting that [8xMgas] profiles may be an excellent proxy for total-mass profiles at >0.5 Mpc in massive galaxy clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2015; v1 submitted 30 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Dark matter-baryons separation at the lowest mass scale: the Bullet Group
Authors:
F. Gastaldello,
M. Limousin,
G. Foëx,
R. P. Muñoz,
T. Verdugo,
V. Motta,
A. More,
R. Cabanac,
D. A. Buote,
D. Eckert,
S. Ettori,
A. Fritz,
S. Ghizzardi,
P. J. Humphrey,
M. Meneghetti,
M. Rossetti
Abstract:
We report on the X-ray observation of a strong lensing selected group, SL2S J08544-0121, with a total mass of $2.4 \pm 0.6 \times 10^{14}$ $\rm{M_\odot}$ which revealed a separation of $124\pm20$ kpc between the X-ray emitting collisional gas and the collisionless galaxies and dark matter (DM), traced by strong lensing. This source allows to put an order of magnitude estimate to the upper limit to…
▽ More
We report on the X-ray observation of a strong lensing selected group, SL2S J08544-0121, with a total mass of $2.4 \pm 0.6 \times 10^{14}$ $\rm{M_\odot}$ which revealed a separation of $124\pm20$ kpc between the X-ray emitting collisional gas and the collisionless galaxies and dark matter (DM), traced by strong lensing. This source allows to put an order of magnitude estimate to the upper limit to the interaction cross section of DM of 10 cm$^2$ g$^{-1}$. It is the lowest mass object found to date showing a DM-baryons separation and it reveals that the detection of bullet-like objects is not rare and confined to mergers of massive objects opening the possibility of a statistical detection of DM-baryons separation with future surveys.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2014; v1 submitted 22 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
The MUSIC of CLASH: predictions on the concentration-mass relation
Authors:
M. Meneghetti,
E. Rasia,
J. Vega,
J. Merten,
M. Postman,
G. Yepes,
F. Sembolini,
M. Donahue,
S. Ettori,
K. Umetsu,
I. Balestra,
M. Bartelmann,
N. Benitez,
A. Biviano,
R. Bouwens,
L. Bradley,
T. Broadhurst,
D. Coe,
N. Czakon,
M. De Petris,
H. Ford,
C. Giocoli,
S. Gottloeber,
C. Grillo,
L. Infante
, et al. (20 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present the results of a numerical study based on the analysis of the MUSIC-2 simulations, aimed at estimating the expected concentration-mass relation for the CLASH cluster sample. We study nearly 1400 halos simulated at high spatial and mass resolution, which were projected along many lines-of-sight each. We study the shape of both their density and surface-density profiles and fit them with…
▽ More
We present the results of a numerical study based on the analysis of the MUSIC-2 simulations, aimed at estimating the expected concentration-mass relation for the CLASH cluster sample. We study nearly 1400 halos simulated at high spatial and mass resolution, which were projected along many lines-of-sight each. We study the shape of both their density and surface-density profiles and fit them with a variety of radial functions, including the Navarro-Frenk-White, the generalised Navarro-Frenk-White, and the Einasto density profiles. We derive concentrations and masses from these fits and investigate their distributions as a function of redshift and halo relaxation. We use the X-ray image simulator X-MAS to produce simulated Chandra observations of the halos and we use them to identify objects resembling the X-ray morphologies and masses of the clusters in the CLASH X-ray selected sample. We also derive a concentration-mass relation for strong-lensing clusters. We find that the sample of simulated halos which resemble the X-ray morphology of the CLASH clusters is composed mainly by relaxed halos, but it also contains a significant fraction of un-relaxed systems. For such a sample we measure an average 2D concentration which is ~11% higher than found for the full sample of simulated halos. After accounting for projection and selection effects, the average NFW concentrations of CLASH clusters are expected to be intermediate between those predicted in 3D for relaxed and super-relaxed halos. Matching the simulations to the individual CLASH clusters on the basis of the X-ray morphology, we expect that the NFW concentrations recovered from the lensing analysis of the CLASH clusters are in the range [3-6], with an average value of 3.87 and a standard deviation of 0.61. Simulated halos with X-ray morphologies similar to those of the CLASH clusters are affected by a modest orientation bias.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2014; v1 submitted 4 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Intra Cluster Light properties in the CLASH-VLT cluster MACS J1206.2-0847
Authors:
V. Presotto,
M. Girardi,
M. Nonino,
A. Mercurio,
C. Grillo,
P. Rosati,
A. Biviano,
M. Annunziatella,
I. Balestra,
W. Cui,
B. Sartoris,
D. Lemze,
B. Ascaso,
J. Moustakas,
H. Ford,
A. Fritz,
O. Czoske,
S. Ettori,
U. Kuchner,
M. Lombardi,
C. Maier,
E. Medezinski,
A. Molino,
M. Scodeggio,
V. Strazzullo
, et al. (24 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We aim at constraining the assembly history of clusters by studying the intra cluster light (ICL) properties, estimating its contribution to the fraction of baryons in stars, f*, and understanding possible systematics/bias using different ICL detection techniques. We developed an automated method, GALtoICL, based on the software GALAPAGOS to obtain a refined version of typical BCG+ICL maps. We app…
▽ More
We aim at constraining the assembly history of clusters by studying the intra cluster light (ICL) properties, estimating its contribution to the fraction of baryons in stars, f*, and understanding possible systematics/bias using different ICL detection techniques. We developed an automated method, GALtoICL, based on the software GALAPAGOS to obtain a refined version of typical BCG+ICL maps. We applied this method to our test case MACS J1206.2-0847, a massive cluster located at z=0.44, that is part of the CLASH sample. Using deep multi-band SUBARU images, we extracted the surface brightness (SB) profile of the BCG+ICL and we studied the ICL morphology, color, and contribution to f* out to R500. We repeated the same analysis using a different definition of the ICL, SBlimit method, i.e. a SB cut-off level, to compare the results. The most peculiar feature of the ICL in MACS1206 is its asymmetric radial distribution, with an excess in the SE direction and extending towards the 2nd brightest cluster galaxy which is a Post Starburst galaxy. This suggests an interaction between the BCG and this galaxy that dates back to t <= 1.5 Gyr. The BCG+ICL stellar content is 8% of M_(*,500) and the (de-) projected baryon fraction in stars is f*=0.0177 (0.0116), in excellent agreement with recent results. The SBlimit method provides systematically higher ICL fractions and this effect is larger at lower SB limits. This is due to the light from the outer envelopes of member galaxies that contaminate the ICL. Though more time consuming, the GALtoICL method provides safer ICL detections that are almost free of this contamination. This is one of the few ICL study at redshift z > 0.3. At completion, the CLASH/VLT program will allow us to extend this analysis to a statistically significant cluster sample spanning a wide redshift range: 0.2<z<0.6.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
CLASH-VLT: Constraints on the Dark Matter Equation of State from Accurate Measurements of Galaxy Cluster Mass Profiles
Authors:
Barbara Sartoris,
Andrea Biviano,
Piero Rosati,
Stefano Borgani,
Keiichi Umetsu,
Matthias Bartelmann,
Marisa Girardi,
Claudio Grillo,
Doron Lemze,
Adi Zitrin,
Italo Balestra,
Amata Mercurio,
Mario Nonino,
Marc Postman,
Nicole Czakon,
Larry Bradley,
Tom Broadhurst,
Dan Coe,
Elinor Medezinski,
Peter Melchior,
Massimo Meneghetti,
Julian Merten,
Marianna Annunziatella,
Narciso Benitez,
Oliver Czoske
, et al. (17 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
A pressureless scenario for the Dark Matter (DM) fluid is a widely adopted hypothesis, despite the absence of a direct observational evidence. According to general relativity, the total mass-energy content of a system shapes the gravitational potential well, but different test particles perceive this potential in different ways depending on their properties. Cluster galaxy velocities, being $\ll$c…
▽ More
A pressureless scenario for the Dark Matter (DM) fluid is a widely adopted hypothesis, despite the absence of a direct observational evidence. According to general relativity, the total mass-energy content of a system shapes the gravitational potential well, but different test particles perceive this potential in different ways depending on their properties. Cluster galaxy velocities, being $\ll$c, depend solely on the gravitational potential, whereas photon trajectories reflect the contributions from the gravitational potential plus a relativistic-pressure term that depends on the cluster mass. We exploit this phenomenon to constrain the Equation of State (EoS) parameter of the fluid, primarily DM, contained in galaxy clusters. We use the complementary information provided by the kinematic and lensing mass profiles of the galaxy cluster MACS 1206.2-0847 at $z=0.44$, as obtained in an extensive imaging and spectroscopic campaign within the CLASH survey. The unprecedented high quality of our data-set and the properties of this cluster are well suited to determine the EoS parameter of the cluster fluid. Since baryons contribute at most $15\%$ to the total mass in clusters and their pressure is negligible, the EoS parameter we derive describes the behavior of the DM fluid. We obtain the most stringent constraint on the DM EoS parameter to date, $w=(p_r+2\,p_t)/(3\,c^2ρ)=0.00\pm0.15\mathrm{(stat)}\pm0.08\mathrm{(syst)}$, averaged over the radial range $0.5\,\mathrm{Mpc}\leq$$r$$\leq$$r_{200}$, where $p_r$ and $p_t$ are the radial and tangential pressure, and $ρ$ is the density. We plan to further improve our constraint by applying the same procedure to all clusters from the ongoing CLASH-VLT program.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Can AGN feedback break the self-similarity of galaxies, groups, and clusters?
Authors:
M. Gaspari,
F. Brighenti,
P. Temi,
S. Ettori
Abstract:
It is commonly thought that AGN feedback can break the self-similar scaling relations of galaxies, groups, and clusters. Using high-resolution 3D hydrodynamic simulations, we isolate the impact of AGN feedback on the $L_{\rm x}-T_{\rm x} $ relation, testing the two archetypal and common regimes, self-regulated mechanical feedback and a quasar thermal blast. We find that AGN feedback has severe dif…
▽ More
It is commonly thought that AGN feedback can break the self-similar scaling relations of galaxies, groups, and clusters. Using high-resolution 3D hydrodynamic simulations, we isolate the impact of AGN feedback on the $L_{\rm x}-T_{\rm x} $ relation, testing the two archetypal and common regimes, self-regulated mechanical feedback and a quasar thermal blast. We find that AGN feedback has severe difficulty in breaking the relation in a consistent way. The similarity breaking is directly linked to the gas evacuation within $R_{500}$, while the central cooling times are inversely proportional to the core density. Breaking self-similarity implies thus breaking the cool core, morphing all systems to non-cool-core objects, which is in clear contradiction with the observed data populated by several cool-core systems. Self-regulated feedback, which quenches cooling flows and preserves cool cores, prevents the dramatic evacuation and similarity breaking at any scale; the relation scatter is also limited. The impulsive thermal blast can break the core-included $L_{\rm x}-T_{\rm x}$ at $T_{500} < 1$ keV, but substantially empties and overheats the halo, generating a perennial non-cool-core group, as experienced by cosmological simulations. Even with partial evacuation, massive systems remain overheated. We show the action of purely AGN feedback is to lower the luminosity and heating the gas, perpendicular to the fit.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Mass and Concentration estimates from Weak and Strong Gravitational Lensing: a Systematic Study
Authors:
Carlo Giocoli,
Massimo Meneghetti,
R. Benton Metcalf,
Stefano Ettori,
Lauro Moscardini
Abstract:
We study how well halo properties of galaxy clusters, like mass and concentration, are recovered using lensing data. In order to generate a large sample of systems at different redshifts we use the code MOKA. We measure halo mass and concentration using weak lensing data alone (WL), fitting to an NFW profile the reduced tangential shear profile, or by combining weak and strong lensing data, by add…
▽ More
We study how well halo properties of galaxy clusters, like mass and concentration, are recovered using lensing data. In order to generate a large sample of systems at different redshifts we use the code MOKA. We measure halo mass and concentration using weak lensing data alone (WL), fitting to an NFW profile the reduced tangential shear profile, or by combining weak and strong lensing data, by adding information about the size of the Einstein radius (WL+SL). For different redshifts, we measure the mass and the concentration biases and find that these are mainly caused by the random orientation of the halo ellipsoid with respect to the line-of-sight. Since our simulations account for the presence of a bright central galaxy, we perform mass and concentration measurements using a generalized NFW profile which allows for a free inner slope. This reduces both the mass and the concentration biases. We discuss how the mass function and the concentration mass relation change when using WL and WL+SL estimates. We investigate how selection effects impact the measured concentration-mass relation showing that strong lens clusters may have a concentration 20-30% higher than the average, at fixed mass, considering also the particular case of strong lensing selected samples of relaxed clusters. Finally, we notice that selecting a sample of relaxed galaxy clusters, as is done in some cluster surveys, explain the concentration-mass relation biases.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2014; v1 submitted 5 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Gas clum** in galaxy clusters
Authors:
D. Eckert,
M. Roncarelli,
S. Ettori,
S. Molendi,
F. Vazza,
F. Gastaldello,
M. Rossetti
Abstract:
The reconstruction of galaxy cluster's gas density profiles is usually performed by assuming spherical symmetry and averaging the observed X-ray emission in circular annuli. In the case of a very inhomogeneous and asymmetric gas distribution, this method has been shown to return biased results in numerical simulations because of the $n^2$ dependence of the X-ray emissivity. We propose a method to…
▽ More
The reconstruction of galaxy cluster's gas density profiles is usually performed by assuming spherical symmetry and averaging the observed X-ray emission in circular annuli. In the case of a very inhomogeneous and asymmetric gas distribution, this method has been shown to return biased results in numerical simulations because of the $n^2$ dependence of the X-ray emissivity. We propose a method to recover the true density profiles in the presence of inhomogeneities, based on the derivation of the azimuthal median of the surface brightness in concentric annuli. We demonstrate the performance of this method with numerical simulations, and apply it to a sample of 31 galaxy clusters in the redshift range 0.04-0.2 observed with ROSAT/PSPC. The clum** factors recovered by comparing the mean and the median are mild and show a slight trend of increasing bias with radius. For $R<R_{500}$, we measure a clum** factor $\sqrt{C}<1.1$, which indicates that the thermodynamic properties and hydrostatic masses measured in this radial range are only mildly affected by this effect. Comparing our results with three sets of hydrodynamical numerical simulations, we found that non-radiative simulations significantly overestimate the level of inhomogeneities in the ICM, while the runs including cooling, star formation, and AGN feedback reproduce the observed trends closely. Our results indicate that most of the accretion of X-ray emitting gas is taking place in the diffuse, large-scale accretion patterns rather than in compact structures.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2014; v1 submitted 31 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Athena+: The first Deep Universe X-ray Observatory
Authors:
D. Barret,
K. Nandra,
X. Barcons,
A Fabian,
J-W den Herder,
L. Piro,
M. Watson,
J. Aird,
G. Branduardi-Raymont,
M. Cappi,
F. Carrera,
A. Comastri,
E. Costantini,
J. Croston,
A. Decourchelle,
C. Done,
M. Dovciak,
S. Ettori,
A. Finoguenov,
A. Georgakakis,
P. Jonker,
J. Kaastra,
G. Matt,
C. Motch,
P. O'Brien
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Advanced Telescope for High-energy Astrophysics (Athena+) is being proposed to ESA as the L2 mission (for a launch in 2028) and is specifically designed to answer two of the most pressing questions for astrophysics in the forthcoming decade: How did ordinary matter assemble into the large scale structures we see today? and how do black holes grow and shape the Universe? For addressing these tw…
▽ More
The Advanced Telescope for High-energy Astrophysics (Athena+) is being proposed to ESA as the L2 mission (for a launch in 2028) and is specifically designed to answer two of the most pressing questions for astrophysics in the forthcoming decade: How did ordinary matter assemble into the large scale structures we see today? and how do black holes grow and shape the Universe? For addressing these two issues, Athena+ will provide transformational capabilities in terms of angular resolution, effective area, spectral resolution, grasp, that will make it the most powerful X-ray observatory ever flown. Such an observatory, when opened to the astronomical community, will be used for virtually all classes of astrophysical objects, from high-z gamma-ray bursts to the closest planets in our solar neighborhood. In this paper, we briefly review the core science objectives of Athena+, present the science requirements and the foreseen implementation of the mission, and illustrate its transformational capabilities compared to existing facilities.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
The generalized scaling relations for X-ray galaxy clusters: the most powerful mass proxy
Authors:
S. Ettori
Abstract:
The application to observational data of the generalized scaling relations (gSR) presented in Ettori et al. (2012) is here discussed. We extend further the formalism of the gSR in the self-similar model for X-ray galaxy clusters, showing that for a generic relation M_tot ~ L^a M_g^b T^c, where L, M_g and T are the gas luminosity, mass and temperature, respectively, the values of the slopes lay in…
▽ More
The application to observational data of the generalized scaling relations (gSR) presented in Ettori et al. (2012) is here discussed. We extend further the formalism of the gSR in the self-similar model for X-ray galaxy clusters, showing that for a generic relation M_tot ~ L^a M_g^b T^c, where L, M_g and T are the gas luminosity, mass and temperature, respectively, the values of the slopes lay in the plane 4*a+3*b+2*c=3. Using published dataset, we show that some projections of the gSR are the most efficient relations, holding among observed physical X-ray quantities, to recover the cluster mass. This conclusion is based on the evidence that they provide the lowest chi^2, the lowest total scatter and the lowest intrinsic scatter among the studied scaling laws on both galaxy group and cluster mass scales. By the application of the gSR, the intrinsic scatter is reduced in all the cases down to a relative error on M_tot below 16 per cent. The best-fit relations are: M_tot ~ M_g^a T^{1.5-1.5a}, with a~0.4, and M_tot ~ L^a T^{1.5-2a}, with a~0.15. As a by product of this study, we provide the estimates of the gravitating mass at Delta=500 for 120 objects (50 from the Mahdavi et al. 2013 sample, 16 from Maughan 2012; 31 from Pratt et al. 2009; 23 from Sun et al. 2009), 114 of which are unique entries. The typical relative error in the mass provided from the gSR only (i.e. not propagating any uncertainty associated with the observed quantities) ranges between 3-5 per cent on cluster scale and is about 10 per cent for galaxy groups. With respect to the hydrostatic values used to calibrate the gSR, the masses are recovered with deviations in the order of 10 per cent due to the different mix of relaxed/disturbed objects present in the considered samples. In the extreme case of a gSR calibrated with relaxed systems, the hydrostatic mass in disturbed objects is over-estimated by about 20 per cent.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
CLASH-VLT: The mass, velocity-anisotropy, and pseudo-phase-space density profiles of the z=0.44 galaxy cluster MACS 1206.2-0847
Authors:
A. Biviano,
P. Rosati,
I. Balestra,
A. Mercurio,
M. Girardi,
M. Nonino,
C. Grillo,
M. Scodeggio,
D. Lemze,
D. Kelson,
K. Umetsu,
M. Postman,
A. Zitrin,
O. Czoske,
S. Ettori,
A. Fritz,
M. Lombardi,
C. Maier,
E. Medezinski,
S. Mei,
V. Presotto,
V. Strazzullo,
P. Tozzi,
B. Ziegler,
M. Annunziatella
, et al. (22 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We use an unprecedented data-set of about 600 redshifts for cluster members, obtained as part of a VLT/VIMOS large programme, to constrain the mass profile of the z=0.44 cluster MACS J1206.2-0847 over the radial range 0-5 Mpc (0-2.5 virial radii) using the MAMPOSSt and Caustic methods. We then add external constraints from our previous gravitational lensing analysis. We invert the Jeans equation t…
▽ More
We use an unprecedented data-set of about 600 redshifts for cluster members, obtained as part of a VLT/VIMOS large programme, to constrain the mass profile of the z=0.44 cluster MACS J1206.2-0847 over the radial range 0-5 Mpc (0-2.5 virial radii) using the MAMPOSSt and Caustic methods. We then add external constraints from our previous gravitational lensing analysis. We invert the Jeans equation to obtain the velocity-anisotropy profiles of cluster members. With the mass-density and velocity-anisotropy profiles we then obtain the first determination of a cluster pseudo-phase-space density profile. The kinematics and lensing determinations of the cluster mass profile are in excellent agreement. This is very well fitted by a NFW model with mass M200=(1.4 +- 0.2) 10^15 Msun and concentration c200=6 +- 1, only slightly higher than theoretical expectations. Other mass profile models also provide acceptable fits to our data, of (slightly) lower (Burkert, Hernquist, and Softened Isothermal Sphere) or comparable (Einasto) quality than NFW. The velocity anisotropy profiles of the passive and star-forming cluster members are similar, close to isotropic near the center and increasingly radial outside. Passive cluster members follow extremely well the theoretical expectations for the pseudo-phase-space density profile and the relation between the slope of the mass-density profile and the velocity anisotropy. Star-forming cluster members show marginal deviations from theoretical expectations. This is the most accurate determination of a cluster mass profile out to a radius of 5 Mpc, and the only determination of the velocity-anisotropy and pseudo-phase-space density profiles of both passive and star-forming galaxies for an individual cluster [abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2013; v1 submitted 22 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Revisiting scaling relations for giant radio halos in galaxy clusters
Authors:
R. Cassano,
S. Ettori,
G. Brunetti,
S. Giacintucci,
G. W. Pratt,
T. Venturi,
R. Kale,
K. Dolag,
M. Markevitch
Abstract:
Many galaxy clusters host Megaparsec-scale radio halos, generated by ultrarelativistic electrons in the magnetized intracluster medium. Correlations between the power of radio halos and the thermal properties of the hosting clusters were established in the last decade, including the connection between the presence of a halo and cluster mergers. The X-ray luminosity and redshift limited Extended GM…
▽ More
Many galaxy clusters host Megaparsec-scale radio halos, generated by ultrarelativistic electrons in the magnetized intracluster medium. Correlations between the power of radio halos and the thermal properties of the hosting clusters were established in the last decade, including the connection between the presence of a halo and cluster mergers. The X-ray luminosity and redshift limited Extended GMRT Radio Halo Survey provides a rich and unique dataset for statistical studies of the halos. We uniformly analyze the radio and X-ray data for the GMRT cluster sample, and use the new Planck SZ catalog, to revisit the correlations between the power of halos and the thermal properties of galaxy clusters. We find that the radio power of halos at 1.4 GHz scales with the cluster X-ray (0.1--2.4 keV) luminosity computed within R_500 as P_1.4 L_500^2.0. Our bigger and more homogenous sample confirms that the X-ray luminous (L_500 > 5x10^44 erg/s) clusters branch into two populations --- radio halos lie on the correlation, while clusters with upper limits to radio-halo emission are well below that correlation. This bimodality remains if we excise cool cores from the X-ray luminosities. Correlating with Planck data, we find that P_1.4 scales with the cluster integrated SZ signal within R_500 as P_1.4 Y_500^2.1, in line with previous findings. However, contrary to previous studies that were limited by incompleteness and small sample size, we find that the "SZ-luminous" Y_500 > 6x10^-5 Mpc^2 clusters show a bimodal behavior similar to that in the radio-X-ray diagram. Bimodality of both correlations can be traced to clusters dynamics, with radio halos found exclusively in merging clusters. These results confirm the key role of mergers for the origin of giant radio halos, suggesting that they trigger the relativistic particle acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2013; v1 submitted 18 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: The missing baryons and the warm-hot intergalactic medium
Authors:
Jelle Kaastra,
Alexis Finoguenov,
Fabrizio Nicastro,
Enzo Branchini,
Joop Schaye,
Nico Cappelluti,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Xavier Barcons,
Joel Bregman,
Judith Croston,
Klaus Dolag,
Stefano Ettori,
Massimiliano Galeazzi,
Takaya Ohashi,
Luigi Piro,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Gabriel Pratt,
Thomas Reiprich,
Mauro Roncarelli,
Jeremy Sanders,
Yoh Takei,
Eugenio Ursino
Abstract:
The backbone of the large-scale structure of the Universe is determined by processes on a cosmological scale and by the gravitational interaction of the dominant dark matter. However, the mobile baryon population shapes the appearance of these structures. Theory predicts that most of the baryons reside in vast unvirialized filamentary structures that connect galaxy groups and clusters, but the obs…
▽ More
The backbone of the large-scale structure of the Universe is determined by processes on a cosmological scale and by the gravitational interaction of the dominant dark matter. However, the mobile baryon population shapes the appearance of these structures. Theory predicts that most of the baryons reside in vast unvirialized filamentary structures that connect galaxy groups and clusters, but the observational evidence is currently lacking. Because the majority of the baryons are supposed to exist in a large-scale, hot and dilute gaseous phase, X-rays provide the ideal tool to progress our understanding. Observations with the Athena+ X-ray Integral Field Unit will reveal the location, chemical composition, physical state and dynamics of the active population of baryons.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: AGN feedback in galaxy clusters and groups
Authors:
J. H. Croston,
J. S. Sanders,
S. Heinz,
M. J. Hardcastle,
I. Zhuravleva,
L. Bîrzan,
R. G. Bower,
M. Brüggen,
E. Churazov,
A. C. Edge,
S. Ettori,
A. C. Fabian,
A. Finoguenov,
J. Kaastra,
M. Gaspari,
M. Gitti,
P. E. J. Nulsen,
B. R. McNamara,
E. Pointecouteau,
T. J. Ponman,
G. W. Pratt,
D. A. Rafferty,
T. H. Reiprich,
D. Sijacki,
D. M. Worrall
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Mechanical feedback via Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) jets in the centres of galaxy groups and clusters is a crucial ingredient in current models of galaxy formation and cluster evolution. Jet feedback is believed to regulate gas cooling and thus star formation in the most massive galaxies, but a robust physical understanding of this feedback mode is currently lacking. The large collecting area, ex…
▽ More
Mechanical feedback via Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) jets in the centres of galaxy groups and clusters is a crucial ingredient in current models of galaxy formation and cluster evolution. Jet feedback is believed to regulate gas cooling and thus star formation in the most massive galaxies, but a robust physical understanding of this feedback mode is currently lacking. The large collecting area, excellent spectral resolution and high spatial resolution of Athena+ will provide the breakthrough diagnostic ability necessary to develop this understanding, via: (1) the first kinematic measurements on relevant spatial scales of the hot gas in galaxy, group and cluster haloes as it absorbs the impact of AGN jets, and (2) vastly improved ability to map thermodynamic conditions on scales well-matched to the jets, lobes and gas disturbances produced by them. Athena+ will therefore determine for the first time how jet energy is dissipated and distributed in group and cluster gas, and how a feedback loop operates in group/cluster cores to regulate gas cooling and AGN fuelling. Athena+ will also establish firmly the cumulative impact of powerful radio galaxies on the evolution of baryons from the epoch of group/cluster formation to the present day.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: The astrophysics of galaxy groups and clusters
Authors:
S. Ettori,
G. W. Pratt,
J. de Plaa,
D. Eckert,
J. Nevalainen,
E. S. Battistelli,
S. Borgani,
J. H. Croston,
A. Finoguenov,
J. Kaastra,
M. Gaspari,
F. Gastaldello,
M. Gitti,
S. Molendi,
E. Pointecouteau,
T. J. Ponman,
T. H. Reiprich,
M. Roncarelli,
M. Rossetti,
J. S. Sanders,
M. Sun,
G. Trinchieri,
F. Vazza,
M. Arnaud,
H. Böringher
, et al. (6 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
As the nodes of the cosmic web, clusters of galaxies trace the large-scale distribution of matter in the Universe. They are thus privileged sites in which to investigate the complex physics of structure formation. However, the complete story of how these structures grow, and how they dissipate the gravitational and non-thermal components of their energy budget over cosmic time, is still beyond our…
▽ More
As the nodes of the cosmic web, clusters of galaxies trace the large-scale distribution of matter in the Universe. They are thus privileged sites in which to investigate the complex physics of structure formation. However, the complete story of how these structures grow, and how they dissipate the gravitational and non-thermal components of their energy budget over cosmic time, is still beyond our grasp. Fundamental questions such as How do hot diffuse baryons accrete and dynamically evolve in dark matter potentials? How and when was the energy that we observe in the ICM generated and distributed? Where and when are heavy elements produced and how are they circulated? are still unanswered. Most of the cluster baryons exists in the form of a diffuse, hot, metal-enriched plasma that radiates primarily in the X-ray band (the intracluster medium, ICM), allowing the X-ray observations of the evolving cluster population to provide a unique opportunity to address these topics. Athena+ with its large collecting area and unprecedented combination of high spectral and angular resolution offers the only way to make major advances in answering these questions. Athena+ will show how the baryonic gas evolves in the dark matter potential wells by studying the motions and turbulence in the ICM. Athena+ will be able to resolve the accreting region both spatially and spectroscopically, probing the true nature and physical state of the X-ray emitting plasma. Athena+ has the capabilities to permit a definitive understanding of the formation and evolution of large-scale cosmic structure through the study of the cluster population.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: The evolution of galaxy groups and clusters
Authors:
E. Pointecouteau,
T. H. Reiprich,
C. Adami,
M. Arnaud,
V. Biffi,
S. Borgani,
K. Borm,
H. Bourdin,
M. Brueggen,
E. Bulbul,
N. Clerc,
J. H. Croston,
K. Dolag,
S. Ettori,
A. Finoguenov,
J. Kaastra,
L. Lovisari,
B. Maughan,
P. Mazzotta,
F. Pacaud,
J. de Plaa,
G. W. Pratt,
M. Ramos-Ceja,
E. Rasia,
J. Sanders
, et al. (23 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Major astrophysical questions related to the formation and evolution of structures, and more specifically of galaxy groups and clusters, will still be open in the coming decade and beyond: what is the interplay of galaxy, supermassive black hole, and intergalactic gas evolution in the most massive objects in the Universe - galaxy groups and clusters? What are the processes driving the evolution of…
▽ More
Major astrophysical questions related to the formation and evolution of structures, and more specifically of galaxy groups and clusters, will still be open in the coming decade and beyond: what is the interplay of galaxy, supermassive black hole, and intergalactic gas evolution in the most massive objects in the Universe - galaxy groups and clusters? What are the processes driving the evolution of chemical enrichment of the hot diffuse gas in large-scale structures? How and when did the first galaxy groups in the Universe, massive enough to bind more than 10^7 K gas, form? Focussing on the period when groups and clusters assembled (0.5<z<2.5), we show that, due to the continuum and line emission of this hot intergalactic gas at X-ray wavelengths, Athena+, combining high sensitivity with excellent spectral and spatial resolution, will deliver breakthrough observations in view of the aforementioned issues. Indeed, the physical and chemical properties of the hot intra-cluster gas, and their evolution across time, are a key to understand the co-evolution of galaxy and supermassive black hole within their environments.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: A White Paper presenting the science theme motivating the Athena+ mission
Authors:
Kirpal Nandra,
Didier Barret,
Xavier Barcons,
Andy Fabian,
Jan-Willem den Herder,
Luigi Piro,
Mike Watson,
Christophe Adami,
James Aird,
Jose Manuel Afonso,
Dave Alexander,
Costanza Argiroffi,
Lorenzo Amati,
Monique Arnaud,
Jean-Luc Atteia,
Marc Audard,
Carles Badenes,
Jean Ballet,
Lucia Ballo,
Aya Bamba,
Anil Bhardwaj,
Elia Stefano Battistelli,
Werner Becker,
Michaël De Becker,
Ehud Behar
, et al. (215 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This White Paper, submitted to the recent ESA call for science themes to define its future large missions, advocates the need for a transformational leap in our understanding of two key questions in astrophysics: 1) How does ordinary matter assemble into the large scale structures that we see today? 2) How do black holes grow and shape the Universe? Hot gas in clusters, groups and the intergalacti…
▽ More
This White Paper, submitted to the recent ESA call for science themes to define its future large missions, advocates the need for a transformational leap in our understanding of two key questions in astrophysics: 1) How does ordinary matter assemble into the large scale structures that we see today? 2) How do black holes grow and shape the Universe? Hot gas in clusters, groups and the intergalactic medium dominates the baryonic content of the local Universe. To understand the astrophysical processes responsible for the formation and assembly of these large structures, it is necessary to measure their physical properties and evolution. This requires spatially resolved X-ray spectroscopy with a factor 10 increase in both telescope throughput and spatial resolving power compared to currently planned facilities. Feedback from supermassive black holes is an essential ingredient in this process and in most galaxy evolution models, but it is not well understood. X-ray observations can uniquely reveal the mechanisms launching winds close to black holes and determine the coupling of the energy and matter flows on larger scales. Due to the effects of feedback, a complete understanding of galaxy evolution requires knowledge of the obscured growth of supermassive black holes through cosmic time, out to the redshifts where the first galaxies form. X-ray emission is the most reliable way to reveal accreting black holes, but deep survey speed must improve by a factor ~100 over current facilities to perform a full census into the early Universe. The Advanced Telescope for High Energy Astrophysics (Athena+) mission provides the necessary performance (e.g. angular resolution, spectral resolution, survey grasp) to address these questions and revolutionize our understanding of the Hot and Energetic Universe. These capabilities will also provide a powerful observatory to be used in all areas of astrophysics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Gas rotation in galaxy clusters: signatures and detectability in X-rays
Authors:
Matteo Bianconi,
Stefano Ettori,
Carlo Nipoti
Abstract:
We study simple models of massive galaxy clusters in which the intracluster medium (ICM) rotates differentially in equilibrium in the cluster gravitational potential. We obtain the X-ray surface brightness maps, evaluating the isophote flattening due to the gas rotation. Using a set of different rotation laws, we put constraint on the amplitude of the rotation velocity, finding that rotation curve…
▽ More
We study simple models of massive galaxy clusters in which the intracluster medium (ICM) rotates differentially in equilibrium in the cluster gravitational potential. We obtain the X-ray surface brightness maps, evaluating the isophote flattening due to the gas rotation. Using a set of different rotation laws, we put constraint on the amplitude of the rotation velocity, finding that rotation curves with peak velocity up to \sim 600 km s^-1 are consistent with the ellipticity profiles of observed clusters. We convolve each of our models with the instrument response of the X-ray Calorimeter Spectrometer on board the ASTRO-H to calculate the simulated X-ray spectra at different distance from the X-ray centre. We demonstrate that such an instrument will allow us to measure rotation of the ICM in massive clusters, even with rotation velocities as low as \sim 100 km s^-1
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2013; v1 submitted 23 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Cold fronts and metal anisotropies in the X-ray cool core of the galaxy cluster Zw1742+3306
Authors:
S. Ettori,
F. Gastaldello,
M. Gitti,
E. O'Sullivan,
M. Gaspari,
F. Brighenti,
L. David,
A. C. Edge
Abstract:
(Context) In recent years, our understanding of the cool cores of galaxy clusters has changed. Once thought to be relatively simple places where gas cools and flows toward the centre, now they are believed to be very dynamic places where heating from the central Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN) and cooling, as inferred from active star formation, molecular gas, and Halpha nebulosity, find an uneasy e…
▽ More
(Context) In recent years, our understanding of the cool cores of galaxy clusters has changed. Once thought to be relatively simple places where gas cools and flows toward the centre, now they are believed to be very dynamic places where heating from the central Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN) and cooling, as inferred from active star formation, molecular gas, and Halpha nebulosity, find an uneasy energetic balance. (Aims) We want to characterize the X-ray properties of the nearby cool-core cluster Zw1742+3306, selected because it is bright at X-ray (with a flux greater than 1e-11 erg/s/cm2 in the 0.1-2.4 keV band) and Halpha wavelengths (Halpha luminosity > 1e40 erg/s). (Methods) We used Chandra data to analyze the spatial and spectral properties of the cool core of Zw1742+3306, a galaxy cluster at z=0.0757 that emits in Halpha and presents the brightest central galaxy located in a diffuse X-ray emission with multiple peaks in surface brightness. (Results) We show that the X-ray cool core of the galaxy cluster Zw1742+3306 is thermodynamically very active with evidence of cold fronts and a weak shock in the surface brightness map and of an apparently coherent, elongated structure with metallicity greater than the value measured in the surrounding ambient gas by about 50 per cent. This anisotropic structure is 280 x 90 kpc2 and is aligned with the cold fronts and with the X-ray emission on larger scales. We suggest that all these peculiarities in the X-ray emission of Zw1742+3306 are either a very fine-tuned output of a sloshing gas in the cluster core or the product of a metal-rich outflow from the central AGN.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2013; v1 submitted 16 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Scaling relations for galaxy clusters: properties and evolution
Authors:
S. Giodini,
L. Lovisari,
E. Pointecouteau,
S. Ettori,
T. H. Reiprich,
H. Hoekstra
Abstract:
Well-calibrated scaling relations between the observable properties and the total masses of clusters of galaxies are important for understanding the physical processes that give rise to these relations. They are also a critical ingredient for studies that aim to constrain cosmological parameters using galaxy clusters. For this reason much effort has been spent during the last decade to better unde…
▽ More
Well-calibrated scaling relations between the observable properties and the total masses of clusters of galaxies are important for understanding the physical processes that give rise to these relations. They are also a critical ingredient for studies that aim to constrain cosmological parameters using galaxy clusters. For this reason much effort has been spent during the last decade to better understand and interpret relations of the properties of the intra-cluster medium. Improved X-ray data have expanded the mass range down to galaxy groups, whereas SZ surveys have openened a new observational window on the intracluster medium. In addition,continued progress in the performance of cosmological simulations has allowed a better understanding of the physical processes and selection effects affecting the observed scaling relations. Here we review the recent literature on various scaling relations, focussing on the latest observational measurements and the progress in our understanding of the deviations from self similarity.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Sloshing cold fronts in galaxy groups and their perturbing disk galaxies: an X-ray, Optical and Radio Case Study
Authors:
F. Gastaldello,
L. Di Gesu,
S. Ghizzardi,
S. Giacintucci,
M. Girardi,
E. Roediger,
M. Rossetti,
F. Brighenti,
D. A. Buote,
D. Eckert,
S. Ettori,
P. J. Humphrey,
W. G. Mathews
Abstract:
We present a combined X-ray, optical, and radio analysis of the galaxy group IC 1860 using the currently available Chandra and XMM data, literature multi-object spectroscopy data and GMRT data. The Chandra and XMM imaging and spectroscopy reveal two surface brightness discontinuities at 45 and 76 kpc shown to be consistent with a pair of cold fronts. These features are interpreted as due to sloshi…
▽ More
We present a combined X-ray, optical, and radio analysis of the galaxy group IC 1860 using the currently available Chandra and XMM data, literature multi-object spectroscopy data and GMRT data. The Chandra and XMM imaging and spectroscopy reveal two surface brightness discontinuities at 45 and 76 kpc shown to be consistent with a pair of cold fronts. These features are interpreted as due to sloshing of the central gas induced by an off-axis minor merger with a perturber. This scenario is further supported by the presence of a peculiar velocity of the central galaxy IC 1860 and the identification of a possible perturber in the optically disturbed spiral galaxy IC 1859. The identification of the perturber is consistent with the comparison with numerical simulations of sloshing. The GMRT observation at 325 MHz shows faint, extended radio emission contained within the inner cold front, as seen in some galaxy clusters hosting diffuse radio mini-halos. However, unlike mini-halos, no particle reacceleration is needed to explain the extended radio emission, which is consistent with aged radio plasma redistributed by the sloshing. There is strong analogy of the X-ray and optical phenomenology of the IC 1860 group with two other groups, NGC 5044 and NGC 5846, showing cold fronts. The evidence presented in this paper is among the strongest supporting the currently favored model of cold-front formation in relaxed objects and establishes the group scale as a chief environment to study this phenomenon.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2013; v1 submitted 19 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Large-scale inhomogeneities of the intracluster medium: improving mass estimates using the observed azimuthal scatter
Authors:
M. Roncarelli,
S. Ettori,
S. Borgani,
K. Dolag,
D. Fabjan,
L. Moscardini
Abstract:
Using a set of hydrodynamical simulations of 62 galaxy clusters and groups we study the ICM of inhomogeneities, focusing on the ones on the large scale that, unlike clumps, are the most difficult to identify. To this purpose we introduce the concept of residual clumpiness, C_R, that quantifies the large-scale inhomogeneity of the ICM. After showing that this quantity can be robustly defined for re…
▽ More
Using a set of hydrodynamical simulations of 62 galaxy clusters and groups we study the ICM of inhomogeneities, focusing on the ones on the large scale that, unlike clumps, are the most difficult to identify. To this purpose we introduce the concept of residual clumpiness, C_R, that quantifies the large-scale inhomogeneity of the ICM. After showing that this quantity can be robustly defined for relaxed systems, we characterize how it varies with radius, mass and dynamical state of the halo. Most importantly, we observe that it introduces an overestimate in the determination of the density profile from the X-ray emission, which translates into a systematic overestimate of 6 (12)% in the measurement of M_gas at R_200 for our relaxed (perturbed) cluster sample. At the same time, the increase of C_R with radius introduces also a ~2% systematic underestimate in the measurement of the hydrostatic-equilibrium mass (M_he), which adds to the previous one generating a systematic ~8.5% overestimate in f_gas in our relaxed sample. Since the residual clumpiness of the ICM is not directly observable, we study its correlation with the azimuthal scatter in the X-ray surface brightness of the halo and in the y-parameter profiles. We find that their correlation is highly significant (r_S = 0.6-0.7), allowing to define the azimuthal scatter measured in the X-ray surface brightness profile and in the y-parameter as robust proxies of C_R. After providing a function that connects the two quantities, we obtain that correcting the observed gas density profiles using the azimuthal scatter eliminates the bias in the measurement of M_gas for relaxed objects, which becomes (0+/-2)% up to 2R_200, and reduces it by a factor of 3 for perturbed ones. This method allows also to eliminate the systematics on the measurements of M_he and f_gas, although a significant halo to halo scatter remains. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Mass profiles of Galaxy Clusters from X-ray analysis
Authors:
S. Ettori,
A. Donnarumma,
E. Pointecouteau,
T. H. Reiprich,
S. Giodini,
L. Lovisari,
R. W. Schmidt
Abstract:
We review the methods adopted to reconstruct the mass profiles in X-ray luminous galaxy clusters. We discuss the limitations and the biases affecting these measurements and how these mass profiles can be used as cosmological proxies.
We review the methods adopted to reconstruct the mass profiles in X-ray luminous galaxy clusters. We discuss the limitations and the biases affecting these measurements and how these mass profiles can be used as cosmological proxies.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2013; v1 submitted 14 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Outskirts of Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Thomas H. Reiprich,
Kaustuv Basu,
Stefano Ettori,
Holger Israel,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Silvano Molendi,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Mauro Roncarelli
Abstract:
Until recently, only about 10% of the total intracluster gas volume had been studied with high accuracy, leaving a vast region essentially unexplored. This is now changing and a wide area of hot gas physics and chemistry awaits discovery in galaxy cluster outskirts. Also, robust large-scale total mass profiles and maps are within reach. First observational and theoretical results in this emerging…
▽ More
Until recently, only about 10% of the total intracluster gas volume had been studied with high accuracy, leaving a vast region essentially unexplored. This is now changing and a wide area of hot gas physics and chemistry awaits discovery in galaxy cluster outskirts. Also, robust large-scale total mass profiles and maps are within reach. First observational and theoretical results in this emerging field have been achieved in recent years with sometimes surprising findings. Here, we summarize and illustrate the relevant underlying physical and chemical processes and review the recent progress in X-ray, Sunyaev--Zel'dovich, and weak gravitational lensing observations of cluster outskirts, including also brief discussions of technical challenges and possible future improvements.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
On the Discrepancy between Theoretical and X-Ray Concentration-Mass Relations for Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Elena Rasia,
Stefano Borgani,
Stefano Ettori,
Pasquale Mazzotta,
Massimo Meneghetti
Abstract:
[Abridged] In the past 15 years, the concentration-mass relation has been investigated diffusely in theoretical studies. On the other hand, only recently has this relation been derived from X-ray observations. When that happened, the results caused a certain level of concern: the X-ray normalizations and slopes were found significantly dissimilar from those predicted by theory.
We analyzed 52 ob…
▽ More
[Abridged] In the past 15 years, the concentration-mass relation has been investigated diffusely in theoretical studies. On the other hand, only recently has this relation been derived from X-ray observations. When that happened, the results caused a certain level of concern: the X-ray normalizations and slopes were found significantly dissimilar from those predicted by theory.
We analyzed 52 objects, simulated each time with different physical recipes for the baryonic component, as well as 60 synthetic X-ray images, to determine if these discrepancies are real or artificial. In particular, we investigate how the simulated concentration-mass relation depends (1) on the radial range used to derive the concentration, (2) on the presence of baryons in the simulations, and on the prescription used to reproduce the gas. Finally, we evaluate (3) how the results differ when adopting an X-ray approach for the analysis and (4) how the selection functions based on X-ray luminosity can impact the results. All effects studied go in the direction of alleviating the discrepancy between observations and simulations, although with different significance: while the fitting radial range and the baryonic component play only a minor role, the X-ray approach and selection function have profound repercussion on the resulting concentration-mass relation.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2013; v1 submitted 30 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
The X-ray/SZ view of the virial region. II. Gas mass fraction
Authors:
Dominique Eckert,
Stefano Ettori,
Silvano Molendi,
Franco Vazza,
Stéphane Paltani
Abstract:
Several recent studies used the hot gas fraction of galaxy clusters as a standard ruler to constrain dark energy, which provides competitive results compared to other techniques. This method, however, relies on the assumption that the baryon fraction in clusters agrees with the cosmic value Omega_b/Omega_m, and does not differ from one system to another. We test this hypothesis by measuring the ga…
▽ More
Several recent studies used the hot gas fraction of galaxy clusters as a standard ruler to constrain dark energy, which provides competitive results compared to other techniques. This method, however, relies on the assumption that the baryon fraction in clusters agrees with the cosmic value Omega_b/Omega_m, and does not differ from one system to another. We test this hypothesis by measuring the gas mass fraction over the entire cluster volume in a sample of local clusters. Combining the SZ thermal pressure from Planck and the X-ray gas density from ROSAT, we measured for the first time the average gas fraction (fgas) out to the virial radius and beyond in a large sample of clusters. We also obtained azimuthally-averaged measurements of the gas fraction for 18 individual systems, which we used to compute the scatter of fgas around the mean value at different radii and its dependence on the cluster's temperature. The gas mass fraction increases with radius and reaches the cosmic baryon fraction close to R200. At R200, we measure fgas,200=0.176+/-0.009. We find significant differences between the baryon fraction of relaxed, cool-core (CC) systems and unrelaxed, non-cool core (NCC) clusters in the outer regions. In average, the gas fraction in NCC clusters slightly exceeds the cosmic baryon fraction, while in CC systems the gas fraction converges to the expected value when accounting for the stellar content, without any evidence for variations from one system to another. We find that fgas estimates in NCC systems slightly disagree with the cosmic value approaching R200. This result could be explained either by a violation of the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium or by an inhomogeneous distribution of the gas mass. Conversely, cool-core clusters are found to provide reliable constraints on fgas at overdensities >200, which makes them suitable for cosmological studies.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2015; v1 submitted 3 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
The X-ray/SZ view of the virial region. I. Thermodynamic properties
Authors:
Dominique Eckert,
Silvano Molendi,
Franco Vazza,
Stefano Ettori,
Stéphane Paltani
Abstract:
We measure the thermodynamic properties of cluster outer regions to provide constraints on the processes that rule the formation of large scale structures. We derived the thermodynamic properties of the intracluster gas (temperature, entropy) by combining the SZ thermal pressure from Planck and the X-ray gas density from ROSAT. This method allowed us to reconstruct for the first time temperature a…
▽ More
We measure the thermodynamic properties of cluster outer regions to provide constraints on the processes that rule the formation of large scale structures. We derived the thermodynamic properties of the intracluster gas (temperature, entropy) by combining the SZ thermal pressure from Planck and the X-ray gas density from ROSAT. This method allowed us to reconstruct for the first time temperature and entropy profiles out to the virial radius and beyond in a large sample of objects. At variance with several recent Suzaku studies, we find that the entropy rises steadily with radius, albeit at at a somewhat lower rate than predicted by self-similar expectations. We note significant differences between relaxed, cool-core systems and unrelaxed clusters in the outer regions. Relaxed systems appear to follow the self-similar expectations more closely than perturbed objects. Our results indicate that the well-known entropy excess observed in cluster cores extends well beyond the central regions. When correcting for the gas depletion, the observed entropy profiles agree with the prediction from gravitational collapse only, especially for cool-core clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2015; v1 submitted 3 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
X-ray morphological estimators for galaxy clusters
Authors:
Elena Rasia,
Massimo Meneghetti,
Stefano Ettori
Abstract:
The classification of galaxy clusters according to their X-ray appearance is a powerful tool to discriminate between regular clusters (associated to relaxed objects) and disturbed ones (linked to dynamically active systems). The compilation of the two subsamples is a necessary step both for cosmological studies - oriented towards spherical and virialized systems- and for astrophysical investigatio…
▽ More
The classification of galaxy clusters according to their X-ray appearance is a powerful tool to discriminate between regular clusters (associated to relaxed objects) and disturbed ones (linked to dynamically active systems). The compilation of the two subsamples is a necessary step both for cosmological studies - oriented towards spherical and virialized systems- and for astrophysical investigations - focused on phenomena typically present in highly disturbed clusters such as turbulence, particle re-acceleration, magneto-astrophysics . In this paper, we review several morphological parameters: asymmetry and fluctuation of the X-ray surface brightness, hardness ratios, X-ray surface-brightness concentration, centroid shift, and third-order power ratio. We test them against 60 Chandra-like images obtained from hydrodynamical simulations through the X-ray Map Simulator and visually classified as regular and disturbed. The best performances are registered when the parameters are computed using the largest possible region (either within R500 or 1000 kpc). The best indicators are the third-order power ratio, the asymmetry parameter, and the X-ray-surface-brightness concentration. All their combinations offer an efficient way to distinguish between the two morphological classes achieving values of purity extremely close to 1. A new parameter, M, is defined. It combines the strengths of the aforementioned indicators and, therefore, resulted to be the most effective parameter analyzed.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2013; v1 submitted 29 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Properties of gas clumps and gas clum** factor in the intra cluster medium
Authors:
F. Vazza,
D. Eckert,
A. Simionescu,
M. Brueggen,
S. Ettori
Abstract:
The spatial distribution of gas matter inside galaxy clusters is not completely smooth, but may host gas clumps associated with substructures. These overdense gas substructures are generally a source of unresolved bias of X-ray observations towards high density gas, but their bright luminosity peaks may be resolved sources within the ICM, that deep X-ray exposures may be (already) capable to detec…
▽ More
The spatial distribution of gas matter inside galaxy clusters is not completely smooth, but may host gas clumps associated with substructures. These overdense gas substructures are generally a source of unresolved bias of X-ray observations towards high density gas, but their bright luminosity peaks may be resolved sources within the ICM, that deep X-ray exposures may be (already) capable to detect. In this paper we aim at investigating both features, using a set of high-resolution cosmological simulations with ENZO. First, we monitor how the bias by unresolved gas clum** may yield incorrect estimates of global cluster parameters and affects the measurements of baryon fractions by X-ray observations. We find that based on X-ray observations of narrow radial strips, it is difficult to recover the real baryon fraction to better than 10 - 20 percent uncertainty. Second, we investigated the possibility of observing bright X-ray clumps in the nearby Universe (z<=0.3). We produced simple mock X-ray observations for several instruments (XMM, Suzaku and ROSAT) and extracted the statistics of potentially detectable bright clumps. Some of the brightest clumps predicted by simulations may already have been already detected in X- ray images with a large field of view. However, their small projected size makes it difficult to prove their existence based on X-ray morphology only. Preheating, AGN feedback and cosmic rays are found to have little impact on the statistical properties of gas clumps.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Order statistics applied to the most massive and most distant galaxy clusters
Authors:
Jean-Claude Waizmann,
Stefano Ettori,
Matthias Bartelmann
Abstract:
In this work we present for the first time an analytic framework for calculating the individual and joint distributions of the n-th most massive or n-th highest redshift galaxy cluster for a given survey characteristic allowing to formulate LCDM exclusion criteria. We show that the cumulative distribution functions steepen with increasing order, giving them a higher constraining power with respect…
▽ More
In this work we present for the first time an analytic framework for calculating the individual and joint distributions of the n-th most massive or n-th highest redshift galaxy cluster for a given survey characteristic allowing to formulate LCDM exclusion criteria. We show that the cumulative distribution functions steepen with increasing order, giving them a higher constraining power with respect to the extreme value statistics. Additionally, we find that the order statistics in mass (being dominated by clusters at lower redshifts) is sensitive to the matter density and the normalisation of the matter fluctuations, whereas the order statistics in redshift is particularly sensitive to the geometric evolution of the Universe. For a fixed cosmology, both order statistics are efficient probes of the functional shape of the mass function at the high mass end. To allow a quick assessment of both order statistics, we provide fits as a function of the survey area that allow percentile estimation with an accuracy better than two per cent. Furthermore, we discuss the joint distributions in the two-dimensional case for different combinations of order.
Having introduced the theory, we apply the order statistical analysis to the SPT massive cluster sample and MCXC catalogue and find that the ten most massive clusters in the sample are consistent with LCDM and the Tinker mass function. In turn, by assuming the LCDM reference cosmology, order statistics can also be utilised for consistency checks of the completeness of the observed sample and of the modelling of the survey selection function. [abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Mass, shape and thermal properties of A1689 by a multi-wavelength X-ray, lensing and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich analysis
Authors:
Mauro Sereno,
Stefano Ettori,
Keiichi Umetsu,
Alessandro Baldi
Abstract:
Knowledge of mass and concentration of galaxy clusters is crucial to understand their formation and evolution. Unbiased estimates require the understanding of the shape and orientation of the halo as well as its equilibrium status. We propose a novel method to determine the intrinsic properties of galaxy clusters from a multi-wavelength data set spanning from X-ray spectroscopic and photometric da…
▽ More
Knowledge of mass and concentration of galaxy clusters is crucial to understand their formation and evolution. Unbiased estimates require the understanding of the shape and orientation of the halo as well as its equilibrium status. We propose a novel method to determine the intrinsic properties of galaxy clusters from a multi-wavelength data set spanning from X-ray spectroscopic and photometric data to gravitational lensing to the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect (SZe). The method relies on two quite non informative geometrical assumptions: the distributions of total matter or gas are approximately ellipsoidal and co-aligned; they have different, constant axial ratios but share the same degree of triaxiality. Weak and strong lensing probe the features of the total mass distribution in the plane of the sky. X-ray data measure size and orientation of the gas in the plane of the sky. Comparison with the SZ amplitude fixes the elongation of the gas along the line of sight. These constraints are deprojected thanks to Bayesian inference. The mass distribution is described as a Navarro-Frenk-White halo with arbitrary orientation, gas density and temperature are modelled with parametric profiles. We applied the method to Abell 1689. Independently of the priors, the cluster is massive, M_{200}=(1.3+-0.2)*10^{15}M_sun, and over-concentrated, c_{200}=8+-1, but still consistent with theoretical predictions. The total matter is triaxial (minor to major axis ratio ~0.5+-0.1 exploiting priors from N-body simulations) with the major axis nearly orientated along the line of sight. The gas is rounder (minor to major axis ratio ~0.6+-0.1) and deviates from hydrostatic equilibrium. The contribution of non-thermal pressure is ~20-50 per cent in inner regions, <~ 300 kpc, and ~25+-5 per cent at ~1.5 Mpc.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
The Three-Dimensional Shapes of Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Marceau Limousin,
Andrea Morandi,
Mauro Sereno,
Massimo Meneghetti,
Stefano Ettori,
Matthias Bartelmann,
Tomas Verdugo
Abstract:
While clusters of galaxies are considered one of the most important cosmological probes, the standard spherical modelling of the dark matter and the intracluster medium is only a rough approximation. Indeed, it is well established both theoretically and observationally that galaxy clusters are much better approximated as triaxial objects. However, investigating the asphericity of galaxy clusters i…
▽ More
While clusters of galaxies are considered one of the most important cosmological probes, the standard spherical modelling of the dark matter and the intracluster medium is only a rough approximation. Indeed, it is well established both theoretically and observationally that galaxy clusters are much better approximated as triaxial objects. However, investigating the asphericity of galaxy clusters is still in its infancy. We review here this topic which is currently gathering a growing interest from the cluster community. We begin by introducing the triaxial geometry. Then we discuss the topic of deprojection and demonstrate the need for combining different probes of the cluster's potential. We discuss the different works that have been addressing these issues. We present a general parametric framework intended to simultaneously fit complementary data sets (X-ray, Sunyaev Zel'dovich and lensing data). We discuss in details the case of Abell 1689 to show how different models/data sets lead to different haloe parameters. We present the results obtained from fitting a 3D NFW model to X-ray, SZ, and lensing data for 4 strong lensing clusters. We argue that a triaxial model generally allows to lower the inferred value of the concentration parameter compared to a spherical analysis. This may alleviate tensions regarding, e.g. the over-concentration problem. However, we stress that predictions from numerical simulations rely on a spherical analysis of triaxial halos. Given that triaxial analysis will have a growing importance in the observational side, we advocate the need for simulations to be analysed in the very same way, allowing reliable and meaningful comparisons. Besides, methods intended to derive the three dimensional shape of galaxy clusters should be extensively tested on simulated multi-wavelength observations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Baryon Census in Hydrodynamical Simulations of Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Susana Planelles,
Stefano Borgani,
Klaus Dolag,
Stefano Ettori,
Dunja Fabjan,
Giuseppe Murante,
Luca Tornatore
Abstract:
We carry out an analysis of a set of cosmological SPH hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy clusters and groups aimed at studying the total baryon budget in clusters, and how this budget is shared between the hot diffuse component and the stellar component. Using the TreePM+SPH GADGET-3 code, we carried out one set of non-radiative simulations, and two sets of simulations including radiative coolin…
▽ More
We carry out an analysis of a set of cosmological SPH hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy clusters and groups aimed at studying the total baryon budget in clusters, and how this budget is shared between the hot diffuse component and the stellar component. Using the TreePM+SPH GADGET-3 code, we carried out one set of non-radiative simulations, and two sets of simulations including radiative cooling, star formation and feedback from supernovae (SN), one of which also accounting for the effect of feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGN). The analysis is carried out with the twofold aim of studying the implication of stellar and hot gas content on the relative role played by SN and AGN feedback, and to calibrate the cluster baryon fraction and its evolution as a cosmological tool. We find that both radiative simulation sets predict a trend of stellar mass fraction with cluster mass that tends to be weaker than the observed one. However this tension depends on the particular set of observational data considered. Including the effect of AGN feedback alleviates this tension on the stellar mass and predicts values of the hot gas mass fraction and total baryon fraction to be in closer agreement with observational results. We further compute the ratio between the cluster baryon content and the cosmic baryon fraction, Y_b, as a function of cluster-centric radius and redshift. At R_500 we find for massive clusters with M_500>2\times10^{14} h^{-1} M_sun that Y_b is nearly independent of the physical processes included and characterized by a negligible redshift evolution: Y_{b,500}=0.85+/-0.03 with the error accounting for the intrinsic r.m.s. scatter within the set of simulated clusters. At smaller radii, R_2500, the typical value of Y_b slightly decreases, by an amount that depends on the physics included in the simulations, while its scatter increases by about a factor of two.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2013; v1 submitted 23 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Self-similarity of temperature profiles in distant galaxy clusters: the quest for a Universal law
Authors:
Alessandro Baldi,
Stefano Ettori,
Silvano Molendi,
Fabio Gastaldello
Abstract:
We present the XMM-Newton temperature profiles of 12 bright clusters of galaxies at 0.4<z<0.9, with 5<kT<11 keV. The normalized temperature profiles (normalized by the mean temperature T500) are found to be generally self-similar. The sample was subdivided in 5 cool-core (CC) and 7 non cool-core (NCC) clusters, by introducing a pseudo-entropy ratio sigma=(T_IN/T_OUT)X(EM_IN/EM_OUT)^-1/3 and defini…
▽ More
We present the XMM-Newton temperature profiles of 12 bright clusters of galaxies at 0.4<z<0.9, with 5<kT<11 keV. The normalized temperature profiles (normalized by the mean temperature T500) are found to be generally self-similar. The sample was subdivided in 5 cool-core (CC) and 7 non cool-core (NCC) clusters, by introducing a pseudo-entropy ratio sigma=(T_IN/T_OUT)X(EM_IN/EM_OUT)^-1/3 and defining the objects with sigma<0.6 as CC clusters and those with sigma>=0.6 as NCC clusters. The profiles of CC and NCC clusters differ mainly in the central regions, with the latters exhibiting a marginally flatter central profile. A significant dependence of the temperature profiles on the pseudo-entropy ratio sigma is detected by fitting a function of both r and sigma, showing an indication that the outer part of the profiles becomes steeper for higher values of sigma (i.e. transitioning towards the NCC clusters). No significant evidence of redshift evolution could be found within the redshift range sampled by our clusters (0.4<z<0.9). A comparison of our high-z sample with intermediate clusters at 0.1<z<0.3, showed how both the CC and NCC clusters temperature profiles have experienced some sort of evolution. This can be due by the fact that higher z clusters are at less advanced stage of their formation and did not have enough time to create a relaxed structure, characterized by a central temperature dip in CC clusters and by flatter profiles in NCC clusters. This is the first time that a systematic study of the temperature profiles of galaxy clusters at z>0.4 has been attempted, as we were able to define the closest possible relation to a Universal law for the temperature profiles of galaxy clusters at 0.1<z<0.9, showing a dependence on both the state of relaxation of the clusters and the redshift.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2012; v1 submitted 28 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy clusters in dark energy cosmologies: II. c-M relation
Authors:
Cristiano De Boni,
Stefano Ettori,
Klaus Dolag,
Lauro Moscardini
Abstract:
We use hydrodynamical simulations of different dark energy cosmologies to investigate the concentration-mass (c-M) relation in galaxy clusters. In particular, we consider a reference ΛCDM model, two quintessence models with inverse power-law potentials (RP and SUGRA), and two extended quintessence models, one with positive and one with negative coupling with gravity (EQp and EQn respectively). All…
▽ More
We use hydrodynamical simulations of different dark energy cosmologies to investigate the concentration-mass (c-M) relation in galaxy clusters. In particular, we consider a reference ΛCDM model, two quintessence models with inverse power-law potentials (RP and SUGRA), and two extended quintessence models, one with positive and one with negative coupling with gravity (EQp and EQn respectively). All the models are normalized in order to match CMB data from WMAP3. We fit both the dark matter only and the total mass profile with a NFW profile, and recover the concentration of each halo from the fit using different definition. We consider both the complete catalog of clusters and groups and subsamples of objects at different level of relaxation. We find that the definition itself of the concentration can lead to differences up to 20% in its value and that these differences are smaller when more relaxed objects are considered. The c-M relation of our reference ΛCDM model is in good agreement with the results in literature, and relaxed objects have a higher normalization and a shallower slope with respect to the complete sample. The inclusion of baryon physics is found to influence more high-mass systems than low-mass ones, due to a higher concentration of baryons in the inner regions of massive halos. For the different dark energy models, we find that for ΛCDM, RP and SUGRA the normalization of the c-M relation is linked to the growth factor, with models having a higher value of σ8 D+ having also a higher normalization. This simple scheme is no longer valid for EQp and EQn because in these models a time dependent effective gravitational interaction, whose redshift evolution depends on the sign of the coupling, is present. This leads to a decrease (increase) of the expected normalization in the EQp (EQn) model. [Abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2012; v1 submitted 14 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Cosmology in 2D: the concentration-mass relation for galaxy clusters
Authors:
Carlo Giocoli,
Massimo Meneghetti,
Stefano Ettori,
Lauro Moscardini
Abstract:
The aim of this work is to perform a systematic study of the measures of the mass and concentration estimated by fitting the convergence profile of a large sample of mock galaxy cluster size lenses, created with the publicly available code MOKA. We found that the main contribution to the bias in mass and in concentration is due to the halo triaxiality and second to the presence of substructures wi…
▽ More
The aim of this work is to perform a systematic study of the measures of the mass and concentration estimated by fitting the convergence profile of a large sample of mock galaxy cluster size lenses, created with the publicly available code MOKA. We found that the main contribution to the bias in mass and in concentration is due to the halo triaxiality and second to the presence of substructures within the host halo virial radius. We show that knowing the cluster elongation along the line of sight helps in correcting the mass bias, but still keeps a small negative bias for the concentration. If these mass and concentration biases will characterize the galaxy cluster sample of a wide field survey it will be difficult to well recover within one sigma the cosmological parameters that mainly influence the c - M relation, using as reference a 3D c - M relation measured in cosmological N-body simulation. In this work we propose how to correct the c - M relation for projection effects and for adiabatic contraction and suggest to use these as reference for real observed data. Correcting mass and concentration estimates, as we propose, gives a measurement of the cosmological parameter within 1 - σ confidence contours.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2012; v1 submitted 10 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
A Chandra - VLA Investigation of the X-ray Cavity System and Radio Mini-Halo in the Galaxy Cluster RBS 797
Authors:
Alberto Doria,
Myriam Gitti,
Stefano Ettori,
Fabrizio Brighenti,
Paul E. J. Nulsen,
Brian R. McNamara
Abstract:
We present a study of the cavity system in the galaxy cluster RBS 797 based on Chandra and VLA data. RBS 797 (z = 0.35), is one of the most distant galaxy clusters in which two pronounced X-ray cavities have been discovered. The Chandra data confirm the presence of a cool core and indicate an higher metallicity along the cavity directions. This is likely due to the AGN outburst, which lifts cool m…
▽ More
We present a study of the cavity system in the galaxy cluster RBS 797 based on Chandra and VLA data. RBS 797 (z = 0.35), is one of the most distant galaxy clusters in which two pronounced X-ray cavities have been discovered. The Chandra data confirm the presence of a cool core and indicate an higher metallicity along the cavity directions. This is likely due to the AGN outburst, which lifts cool metal-rich gas from the center along the cavities, as seen in other systems. We find indications that the cavities are hotter than the surrounding gas. Moreover, the new Chandra images show bright rims contrasting with the deep, X-ray deficient cavities. The likely cause is that the expanding 1.4 GHz radio lobes have displaced the gas, compressing it into a shell that appears as bright cool arms. Finally we show that the large-scale radio emission detected with our VLA observations may be classified as a radio mini-halo, powered by the cooling flow (CF), as it nicely follows the trend P_radio vs. P_CF predicted by the re-acceleration model.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
On the modelling of the excesses of galaxy clusters over high-mass thresholds
Authors:
Jean-Claude Waizmann,
Stefano Ettori,
Lauro Moscardini
Abstract:
In this work we present for the first time an application of the Pareto approach to the modelling of the excesses of galaxy clusters over high-mass thresholds. The distribution of those excesses can be described by the generalized Pareto distribution (GPD), which is closely related to the generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution. After introducing the formalism, we study the impact of differen…
▽ More
In this work we present for the first time an application of the Pareto approach to the modelling of the excesses of galaxy clusters over high-mass thresholds. The distribution of those excesses can be described by the generalized Pareto distribution (GPD), which is closely related to the generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution. After introducing the formalism, we study the impact of different thresholds and redshift ranges on the distributions, as well as the influence of the survey area on the mean excess above a given mass threshold. We also show that both the GPD and the GEV approach lead to identical results for rare, thus high-mass and high-redshift, clusters. As an example, we apply the Pareto approach to ACT-CL J0102-4915 and SPT-CL J2106-5844 and derive the respective cumulative distribution functions of the exceedance over different mass thresholds. We also study the possibility to use the GPD as a cosmological probe. Since in the maximum likelihood estimation of the distribution parameters all the information from clusters above the mass threshold is used, the GPD might offer an interesting alternative to GEV-based methods that use only the maxima in patches. When comparing the accuracy with which the parameters can be estimated, it turns out that the patch-based modelling of maxima is superior to the Pareto approach. In an ideal case, the GEV approach is capable to estimate the location parameter with a percent level precision for less than 100 patches. This result makes the GEV based approach potentially also interesting for cluster surveys with a smaller area.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2012; v1 submitted 17 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
Lensing and X-ray mass estimates of clusters (SIMULATION)
Authors:
E. Rasia,
M. Meneghetti,
R. Martino,
S. Borgani,
A. Bonafede,
K. Dolag,
S. Ettori,
D. Fabjan,
C. Giocoli,
P. Mazzotta,
J. Merten,
M. Radovich,
L. Tornatore
Abstract:
[Abridged] We present a comparison between weak-lensing (WL) and X-ray mass estimates of a sample of numerically simulated clusters. The sample consists on the 20 most massive objects at redshift z=0.25 and Mvir > 5 x 10^{14} Msun h^{-1}. They were found in a cosmological simulation of volume 1 h^{-3} Gpc^3, evolved in the framework of a WMAP-7 normalized cosmology. Each cluster has been resimulat…
▽ More
[Abridged] We present a comparison between weak-lensing (WL) and X-ray mass estimates of a sample of numerically simulated clusters. The sample consists on the 20 most massive objects at redshift z=0.25 and Mvir > 5 x 10^{14} Msun h^{-1}. They were found in a cosmological simulation of volume 1 h^{-3} Gpc^3, evolved in the framework of a WMAP-7 normalized cosmology. Each cluster has been resimulated at higher resolution and with more complex gas physics. We processed it thought Skylens and X-MAS to generate optical and X-ray mock observations along three orthogonal projections. The optical simulations include lensing effects on background sources. Standard observational tools and methods of analysis are used to recover the mass profiles of each cluster projection from the mock catalogues. Given the size of our sample, we could also investigate the dependence of the results on cluster morphology, environment, temperature inhomogeneity, and mass. We confirm previous results showing that WL masses obtained from the fit of the cluster tangential shear profiles with NFW functionals are biased low by ~ 5-10% with a large scatter (~10-25%). We show that scatter could be reduced by optimally selecting clusters either having regular morphology or living in substructure-poor environment. The X-ray masses are biased low by a large amount (~25-35%), evidencing the presence of both non-thermal sources of pressure in the ICM and temperature inhomogeneity, but they show a significantly lower scatter than weak-lensing-derived masses. The X-ray mass bias grows from the inner to the outer regions of the clusters. We find that both biases are weakly correlated with the third-order power ratio, while a stronger correlation exists with the centroid shift. Finally, the X-ray bias is strongly connected with temperature inhomogeneities.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
An XMM-Newton spatially-resolved study of metal abundance evolution in distant galaxy clusters
Authors:
Alessandro Baldi,
Stefano Ettori,
Silvano Molendi,
Italo Balestra,
Fabio Gastaldello,
Paolo Tozzi
Abstract:
We present an XMM-Newton analysis of the X-ray spectra of 39 clusters of galaxies at 0.4<z<1.4, covering a temperature range of 1.5<=kT<=11 keV. We performed a spatially resolved spectral analysis to study how the abundance evolves with redshift not only through a single emission measure performed on the whole cluster but also spatially resolving the cluster emission. We do not observe a statistic…
▽ More
We present an XMM-Newton analysis of the X-ray spectra of 39 clusters of galaxies at 0.4<z<1.4, covering a temperature range of 1.5<=kT<=11 keV. We performed a spatially resolved spectral analysis to study how the abundance evolves with redshift not only through a single emission measure performed on the whole cluster but also spatially resolving the cluster emission. We do not observe a statistically significant (>2sigma) abundance evolution with redshift. The most significant deviation from no evolution (90% c.l.) is observed in the emission from the whole cluster (r<0.6r500), that could be parametrized as Z=A*(1+z)^(-0.8+/-0.5). Dividing the emission in 3 radial bins, no significant evidence of abundance evolution could be observed fitting the data with a power-law. A substantial agreement with measures presented in previous works is found. The error-weighted mean of the spatially resolved abundances in 3 redshift bins is consistent to be constant with z. Although the large error bars in the measure of the weighted-mean abundance prevent us from claiming any significant spatially resolved evolution, the trend with z in the 0.15-0.4r500 radial bin complements nicely the measures of Maughan et al., and broadly agrees with theoretical predictions. We also found that the data points derived from the spatially resolved analysis are well fitted by the relation Z(r,z)=Z0*(1+(r/0.15r500)^2)^(-a)*((1+z)/1.6)^(-gamma), showing a significant negative trend of Z with the radius and no significant evolution with the redshift. The present study is the first attempt made to spatially resolve the evolution of abundance with redshift. However, the sample size and the low statistics associated with most of the clusters in the sample prevents us to draw any statistically significant conclusion on the different evolutionary path that the different regions of the clusters may have traversed.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2011; v1 submitted 18 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Pointing to the minimum scatter: the generalized scaling relations for galaxy clusters
Authors:
S. Ettori,
E. Rasia,
D. Fabjan,
S. Borgani,
K. Dolag
Abstract:
We introduce a generalized scaling law, M_tot = 10^K A^a B^b, to look for the minimum scatter in reconstructing the total mass of hydrodynamically simulated X-ray galaxy clusters, given gas mass M_gas, luminosity L and temperature T. We find a locus in the plane of the logarithmic slopes $a$ and $b$ of the scaling relations where the scatter in mass is minimized. This locus corresponds to b_M = -3…
▽ More
We introduce a generalized scaling law, M_tot = 10^K A^a B^b, to look for the minimum scatter in reconstructing the total mass of hydrodynamically simulated X-ray galaxy clusters, given gas mass M_gas, luminosity L and temperature T. We find a locus in the plane of the logarithmic slopes $a$ and $b$ of the scaling relations where the scatter in mass is minimized. This locus corresponds to b_M = -3/2 a_M +3/2 and b_L = -2 a_L +3/2 for A=M_gas and L, respectively, and B=T. Along these axes, all the known scaling relations can be identified (at different levels of scatter), plus a new one defined as M_tot ~ (LT)^(1/2). Simple formula to evaluate the expected evolution with redshift in the self-similar scenario are provided. In this scenario, no evolution of the scaling relations is predicted for the cases (b_M=0, a_M=1) and (b_L=7/2, a_L=-1), respectively. Once the single quantities are normalized to the average values of the sample under considerations, the normalizations K corresponding to the region with minimum scatter are very close to zero. The combination of these relations allows to reduce the number of free parameters of the fitting function that relates X-ray observables to the total mass and includes the self-similar redshift evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2011; v1 submitted 7 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
The gas distribution in the outer regions of galaxy clusters
Authors:
D. Eckert,
F. Vazza,
S. Ettori,
S. Molendi,
D. Nagai,
E. T. Lau,
M. Roncarelli,
M. Rossetti,
S. L. Snowden,
F. Gastaldello
Abstract:
We present the analysis of a local (z = 0.04 - 0.2) sample of 31 galaxy clusters with the aim of measuring the density of the X-ray emitting gas in cluster outskirts. We compare our results with numerical simulations to set constraints on the azimuthal symmetry and gas clum** in the outer regions of galaxy clusters. We exploit the large field-of-view and low instrumental background of ROSAT/PSPC…
▽ More
We present the analysis of a local (z = 0.04 - 0.2) sample of 31 galaxy clusters with the aim of measuring the density of the X-ray emitting gas in cluster outskirts. We compare our results with numerical simulations to set constraints on the azimuthal symmetry and gas clum** in the outer regions of galaxy clusters. We exploit the large field-of-view and low instrumental background of ROSAT/PSPC to trace the density of the intracluster gas out to the virial radius. We perform a stacking of the density profiles to detect a signal beyond r200 and measure the typical density and scatter in cluster outskirts. We also compute the azimuthal scatter of the profiles with respect to the mean value to look for deviations from spherical symmetry. Finally, we compare our average density and scatter profiles with the results of numerical simulations. As opposed to some recent Suzaku results, and confirming previous evidence from ROSAT and Chandra, we observe a steepening of the density profiles beyond \sim r500. Comparing our density profiles with simulations, we find that non-radiative runs predict too steep density profiles, whereas runs including additional physics and/or treating gas clum** are in better agreement with the observed gas distribution. We report for the first time the high-confidence detection of a systematic difference between cool-core and non-cool core clusters beyond \sim 0.3r200, which we explain by a different distribution of the gas in the two classes. Beyond \sim r500, galaxy clusters deviate significantly from spherical symmetry, with only little differences between relaxed and disturbed systems. We find good agreement between the observed and predicted scatter profiles, but only when the 1% densest clumps are filtered out in the simulations. [Abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2015; v1 submitted 31 October, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
An application of extreme value statistics to the most massive galaxy clusters at low and high redshifts
Authors:
Jean-Claude Waizmann,
Stefano Ettori,
Lauro Moscardini
Abstract:
In this work we present an application of general extreme value statistics (GEV) to very massive single clusters at high and low redshifts. After introducing the formalism, we apply this statistics to four very massive high redshift clusters. Those clusters comprise ACT-CL J0102-4915 with a mass of M_200m=(2.16+/-0.32)x10^{15} M_sun at a redshift of z=0.87, SPT-CL J2106-5844 with a mass of M_200m=…
▽ More
In this work we present an application of general extreme value statistics (GEV) to very massive single clusters at high and low redshifts. After introducing the formalism, we apply this statistics to four very massive high redshift clusters. Those clusters comprise ACT-CL J0102-4915 with a mass of M_200m=(2.16+/-0.32)x10^{15} M_sun at a redshift of z=0.87, SPT-CL J2106-5844 with a mass of M_200m=(1.27+/-0.21)x10^{15} M_sun at z=1.132 and two clusters found by the XMM-Newton Distant Cluster Project survey: XMMU J2235.32557 with a mass of M_200c= (7.3+/-1.3)x10^{14} M_sun located at a redshift of z=1.4 and XMMU J0044.0-2033 having a mass in the range of M_200c= (3.5-5.0)x10^{14} M_sun at z=1.579. By relating those systems to their corresponding distribution functions of being the most massive system in a given survey area, we find that none of the systems alone is in extreme tension with LCDM. We confront these results with a GEV analysis of four very massive low redshift clusters: A2163, A370, RXJ1347-1145 and 1E0657-558, finding no tendency of the high-z systems to be more extreme than the low-z ones. In addition, we study the extreme quantiles of single clusters at high-z and present contour plots for fixed quantiles in the mass vs. survey area plane for four redshift intervals, finding that, in order to be significantly in conflict with LCDM, cluster masses would have to be substantially higher than the currently observed ones.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2011; v1 submitted 22 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.