-
An Efficient Quantum Decoder for Prime-Power Fields
Authors:
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
We consider a version of the nearest-codeword problem on finite fields $\mathbb{F}_q$ using the Manhattan distance, an analog of the Hamming metric for non-binary alphabets. Similarly to other lattice related problems, this problem is NP-hard even up to constant factor approximation. We show, however, that for $q = p^m$ where $p$ is small relative to the code block-size $n$, there is a quantum alg…
▽ More
We consider a version of the nearest-codeword problem on finite fields $\mathbb{F}_q$ using the Manhattan distance, an analog of the Hamming metric for non-binary alphabets. Similarly to other lattice related problems, this problem is NP-hard even up to constant factor approximation. We show, however, that for $q = p^m$ where $p$ is small relative to the code block-size $n$, there is a quantum algorithm that solves the problem in time ${\rm poly}(n)$, for approximation factor $1/n^2$, for any $p$. On the other hand, to the best of our knowledge, classical algorithms can efficiently solve the problem only for much smaller inverse polynomial factors. Hence, the decoder provides an exponential improvement over classical algorithms, and places limitations on the cryptographic security of large-alphabet extensions of code-based cryptosystems like Classic McEliece.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2023; v1 submitted 20 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
An efficient quantum algorithm for lattice problems achieving subexponential approximation factor
Authors:
Lior Eldar,
Sean Hallgren
Abstract:
We give a quantum algorithm for solving the Bounded Distance Decoding (BDD) problem with a subexponential approximation factor on a class of integer lattices. The quantum algorithm uses a well-known but challenging-to-use quantum state on lattices as a type of approximate quantum eigenvector to randomly self-reduce the BDD instance to a random BDD instance which is solvable classically. The runnin…
▽ More
We give a quantum algorithm for solving the Bounded Distance Decoding (BDD) problem with a subexponential approximation factor on a class of integer lattices. The quantum algorithm uses a well-known but challenging-to-use quantum state on lattices as a type of approximate quantum eigenvector to randomly self-reduce the BDD instance to a random BDD instance which is solvable classically. The running time of the quantum algorithm is polynomial for one range of approximation factors and subexponential time for a second range of approximation factors.
The subclass of lattices we study has a natural description in terms of the lattice's periodicity and finite abelian group rank. This view makes for a clean quantum algorithm in terms of finite abelian groups, uses very relatively little from lattice theory, and suggests exploring approximation algorithms for lattice problems in parameters other than dimension alone.
A talk on this paper sparked many lively discussions and resulted in a new classical algorithm matching part of our result. We leave it as a challenge to give a classcial algorithm matching the general case.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Approximating the Determinant of Well-Conditioned Matrices by Shallow Circuits
Authors:
Enric Boix-Adserà,
Lior Eldar,
Saeed Mehraban
Abstract:
The determinant can be computed by classical circuits of depth $O(\log^2 n)$, and therefore it can also be computed in classical space $O(\log^2 n)$. Recent progress by Ta-Shma [Ta13] implies a method to approximate the determinant of Hermitian matrices with condition number $κ$ in quantum space $O(\log n + \log κ)$. However, it is not known how to perform the task in less than $O(\log^2 n)$ space…
▽ More
The determinant can be computed by classical circuits of depth $O(\log^2 n)$, and therefore it can also be computed in classical space $O(\log^2 n)$. Recent progress by Ta-Shma [Ta13] implies a method to approximate the determinant of Hermitian matrices with condition number $κ$ in quantum space $O(\log n + \log κ)$. However, it is not known how to perform the task in less than $O(\log^2 n)$ space using classical resources only. In this work, we show that the condition number of a matrix implies an upper bound on the depth complexity (and therefore also on the space complexity) for this task: the determinant of Hermitian matrices with condition number $κ$ can be approximated to inverse polynomial relative error with classical circuits of depth $\tilde O(\log n \cdot \log κ)$, and in particular one can approximate the determinant for sufficiently well-conditioned matrices in depth $\tilde{O}(\log n)$. Our algorithm combines Barvinok's recent complex-analytic approach for approximating combinatorial counting problems [Bar16] with the Valiant-Berkowitz-Skyum-Rackoff depth-reduction theorem for low-degree arithmetic circuits [Val83].
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Robust Quantum Entanglement at (nearly) Room Temperature
Authors:
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
We formulate a mixed-state analog of the NLTS conjecture [FH14] by asking whether there exist topologically-ordered systems for which the thermal Gibbs state for constant temperature is globally-entangled in the sense that it cannot even be approximated by shallow quantum circuits. We then prove this conjecture holds for nearly optimal parameters: when the "inverse temperature" is almost a constan…
▽ More
We formulate a mixed-state analog of the NLTS conjecture [FH14] by asking whether there exist topologically-ordered systems for which the thermal Gibbs state for constant temperature is globally-entangled in the sense that it cannot even be approximated by shallow quantum circuits. We then prove this conjecture holds for nearly optimal parameters: when the "inverse temperature" is almost a constant (temperature decays as 1/loglog(n))) and the Hamiltonian is nearly local (log(n)-local). The construction and proof combine quantum codes that arise from high-dimensional manifolds [Has17, LLZ19], the local-decoding approach to quantum codes [LTZ15, FGL18] and quantum locally-testable codes [AE15].
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2020; v1 submitted 11 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Approximating the Permanent of a Random Matrix with Vanishing Mean
Authors:
Lior Eldar,
Saeed Mehraban
Abstract:
We show an algorithm for computing the permanent of a random matrix with vanishing mean in quasi-polynomial time. Among special cases are the Gaussian, and biased-Bernoulli random matrices with mean 1/lnln(n)^{1/8}. In addition, we can compute the permanent of a random matrix with mean 1/poly(ln(n)) in time 2^{O(n^{\eps})} for any small constant \eps>0. Our algorithm counters the intuition that th…
▽ More
We show an algorithm for computing the permanent of a random matrix with vanishing mean in quasi-polynomial time. Among special cases are the Gaussian, and biased-Bernoulli random matrices with mean 1/lnln(n)^{1/8}. In addition, we can compute the permanent of a random matrix with mean 1/poly(ln(n)) in time 2^{O(n^{\eps})} for any small constant \eps>0. Our algorithm counters the intuition that the permanent is hard because of the "sign problem" - namely the interference between entries of a matrix with different signs. A major open question then remains whether one can provide an efficient algorithm for random matrices of mean 1/poly(n), whose conjectured #P-hardness is one of the baseline assumptions of the BosonSampling paradigm.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2018; v1 submitted 26 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
A Discrete Fourier Transform on Lattices with Quantum Applications
Authors:
Lior Eldar,
Peter Shor
Abstract:
In this work, we introduce a definition of the Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) on Euclidean lattices in $\R^n$, that generalizes the $n$-th fold DFT of the integer lattice $\Z^n$ to arbitrary lattices. This definition is not applicable for every lattice, but can be defined on lattices known as Systematic Normal Form (SysNF) introduced in \cite{ES16}. Systematic Normal Form lattices are sets of in…
▽ More
In this work, we introduce a definition of the Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) on Euclidean lattices in $\R^n$, that generalizes the $n$-th fold DFT of the integer lattice $\Z^n$ to arbitrary lattices. This definition is not applicable for every lattice, but can be defined on lattices known as Systematic Normal Form (SysNF) introduced in \cite{ES16}. Systematic Normal Form lattices are sets of integer vectors that satisfy a single homogeneous modular equation, which itself satisfies a certain number-theoretic property. Such lattices form a dense set in the space of $n$-dimensional lattices, and can be used to approximate efficiently any lattice. This implies that for every lattice $L$ a DFT can be computed efficiently on a lattice near $L$.
Our proof of the statement above uses arguments from quantum computing, and as an application of our definition we show a quantum algorithm for sampling from discrete distributions on lattices, that extends our ability to sample efficiently from the discrete Gaussian distribution \cite{GPV08} to any distribution that is sufficiently "smooth". We conjecture that studying the eigenvectors of the newly-defined lattice DFT may provide new insights into the structure of lattices, especially regarding hard computational problems, like the shortest vector problem.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2017; v1 submitted 7 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
An Efficient Quantum Algorithm for a Variant of the Closest Lattice-Vector Problem
Authors:
Lior Eldar,
Peter W. Shor
Abstract:
The Systematic Normal Form (SysNF) is a canonical form of lattices introduced in [Eldar,Shor '16], in which the basis entries satisfy a certain co-primality condition. Using a "smooth" analysis of lattices by SysNF lattices we design a quantum algorithm that can efficiently solve the following variant of the bounded-distance-decoding problem: given a lattice L, a vector v, and numbers b = λ_1(L)/n…
▽ More
The Systematic Normal Form (SysNF) is a canonical form of lattices introduced in [Eldar,Shor '16], in which the basis entries satisfy a certain co-primality condition. Using a "smooth" analysis of lattices by SysNF lattices we design a quantum algorithm that can efficiently solve the following variant of the bounded-distance-decoding problem: given a lattice L, a vector v, and numbers b = λ_1(L)/n^{17}, a = λ_1(L)/n^{13} decide if v's distance from L is in the range [a/2, a] or at most b, where λ_1(L) is the length of L's shortest non-zero vector. Improving these parameters to a = b = λ_1(L)/\sqrt{n} would invalidate one of the security assumptions of the Learning-with-Errors (LWE) cryptosystem against quantum attacks.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2016; v1 submitted 21 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
The Need for Structure in Quantum LDPC Codes
Authors:
Lior Eldar,
Maris Ozols,
Kevin F. Thompson
Abstract:
Existence of quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes whose minimal distance scales linearly with the number of qubits is a major open problem in quantum information. Its practical interest stems from the need to protect information in a future quantum computer, and its theoretical appeal relates to a deep "global-to-local" notion in quantum mechanics: whether we can constrain long-range enta…
▽ More
Existence of quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes whose minimal distance scales linearly with the number of qubits is a major open problem in quantum information. Its practical interest stems from the need to protect information in a future quantum computer, and its theoretical appeal relates to a deep "global-to-local" notion in quantum mechanics: whether we can constrain long-range entanglement using local checks. Given the inability of lattice-based quantum LDPC codes to achieve linear distance, research has recently shifted to the other extreme end of topologies, so called high-dimensional expanders. In this work we show that trying to leverage the mere "random-like" property of these expanders to find good quantum codes may be futile: quantum CSS codes of $n$ quits built from $d$-complexes that are $\varepsilon$-far from perfectly random, in a well-known sense called discrepancy, have a small minimal distance. Quantum codes aside, our work places a first upper-bound on the systole of high-dimensional expanders with small discrepancy, and a lower-bound on the discrepancy of skeletons of Ramanujan complexes due to Lubotzky.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2017; v1 submitted 24 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
The Systematic Normal Form of Lattices
Authors:
Lior Eldar,
Peter W. Shor
Abstract:
We introduce a new canonical form of lattices called the systematic normal form (SNF). We show that for every lattice there is an efficiently computable "nearby" SNF lattice, such that for any lattice one can solve lattice problems on its "nearby" SNF lattice, and translate the solutions back efficiently to the original lattice. The SNF provides direct connections between arbitrary lattices, and v…
▽ More
We introduce a new canonical form of lattices called the systematic normal form (SNF). We show that for every lattice there is an efficiently computable "nearby" SNF lattice, such that for any lattice one can solve lattice problems on its "nearby" SNF lattice, and translate the solutions back efficiently to the original lattice. The SNF provides direct connections between arbitrary lattices, and various lattice related problems like the Shortest-Integer-Solution, Approximate Greatest Common Divisor. As our main application of SNF we derive a new set of worst-to-average case lattice reductions that deviate significantly from the template of Ajtai and improve upon previous reductions in terms of simplicity.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Local Hamiltonians Whose Ground States are Hard to Approximate
Authors:
Lior Eldar,
Aram W. Harrow
Abstract:
Ground states of local Hamiltonians can be generally highly entangled: any quantum circuit that generates them (even approximately) must be sufficiently deep to allow coupling (entanglement) between any pair of qubits. Until now this property was not known to be "robust" - the marginals of such states to a subset of the qubits containing all but a small constant fraction of them may be only locall…
▽ More
Ground states of local Hamiltonians can be generally highly entangled: any quantum circuit that generates them (even approximately) must be sufficiently deep to allow coupling (entanglement) between any pair of qubits. Until now this property was not known to be "robust" - the marginals of such states to a subset of the qubits containing all but a small constant fraction of them may be only locally entangled, and hence approximable by shallow quantum circuits. In this work we construct a family of 16-local Hamiltonians for which any 1-10^{-9} fraction of qubits of any ground state must be highly entangled.
This provides evidence that quantum entanglement is not very fragile, and perhaps our intuition about its instability is an artifact of considering local Hamiltonians which are not only local but spatially local. Formally, it provides positive evidence for two wide-open conjectures in condensed-matter physics and quantum complexity theory which are the qLDPC conjecture, positing the existence of "good" quantum LDPC codes, and the NLTS conjecture due to Freedman and Hastings positing the existence of local Hamiltonians in which any low-energy state is highly-entangled.
Our Hamiltonian is based on applying the hypergraph product by Tillich and Zemor to a classical locally testable code. A key tool in our proof is a new lower bound on the vertex expansion of the output of low-depth quantum circuits, which may be of independent interest.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2016; v1 submitted 7 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
A Quasi-Random Approach to Matrix Spectral Analysis
Authors:
Michael Ben-Or,
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
Inspired by the quantum computing algorithms for Linear Algebra problems [HHL,TaShma] we study how the simulation on a classical computer of this type of "Phase Estimation algorithms" performs when we apply it to solve the Eigen-Problem of Hermitian matrices. The result is a completely new, efficient and stable, parallel algorithm to compute an approximate spectral decomposition of any Hermitian m…
▽ More
Inspired by the quantum computing algorithms for Linear Algebra problems [HHL,TaShma] we study how the simulation on a classical computer of this type of "Phase Estimation algorithms" performs when we apply it to solve the Eigen-Problem of Hermitian matrices. The result is a completely new, efficient and stable, parallel algorithm to compute an approximate spectral decomposition of any Hermitian matrix. The algorithm can be implemented by Boolean circuits in $O(\log^2 n)$ parallel time with a total cost of $O(n^{ω+1})$ Boolean operations. This Boolean complexity matches the best known rigorous $O(\log^2 n)$ parallel time algorithms, but unlike those algorithms our algorithm is (logarithmically) stable, so further improvements may lead to practical implementations.
All previous efficient and rigorous approaches to solve the Eigen-Problem use randomization to avoid bad condition as we do too. Our algorithm makes further use of randomization in a completely new way, taking random powers of a unitary matrix to randomize the phases of its eigenvalues. Proving that a tiny Gaussian perturbation and a random polynomial power are sufficient to ensure almost pairwise independence of the phases $(\mod (2π))$ is the main technical contribution of this work. This randomization enables us, given a Hermitian matrix with well separated eigenvalues, to sample a random eigenvalue and produce an approximate eigenvector in $O(\log^2 n)$ parallel time and $O(n^ω)$ Boolean complexity. We conjecture that further improvements of our method can provide a stable solution to the full approximate spectral decomposition problem with complexity similar to the complexity (up to a logarithmic factor) of sampling a single eigenvector.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2017; v1 submitted 29 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Local Hamiltonians with Approximation-Robust Entanglement
Authors:
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
Quantum entanglement is considered, by and large, to be a very delicate and non-robust phenomenon that is very hard to maintain in the presence of noise, or non-zero temperatures. In recent years however, and motivated, in part, by a quest for a quantum analog of the PCP theorem researches have tried to establish whether or not we can preserve quantum entanglement at "constant" temperatures that a…
▽ More
Quantum entanglement is considered, by and large, to be a very delicate and non-robust phenomenon that is very hard to maintain in the presence of noise, or non-zero temperatures. In recent years however, and motivated, in part, by a quest for a quantum analog of the PCP theorem researches have tried to establish whether or not we can preserve quantum entanglement at "constant" temperatures that are independent of system size. This would imply that any quantum state with energy at most, say 0.05 of the total available energy of the Hamiltonian, would be highly-entangled. To this date, no such systems were found, and moreover, it became evident that even embedding local Hamiltonians on robust, albeit "non-physical" topologies, namely expanders, does not guarantee entanglement robustness. In this study, we indicate that such robustness may be possible after all: We construct an infinite family of O(1)-local Hamiltonians, corresponding to check terms of a quantum error-correcting code with the following property of inapproximability: any quantum state with energy at most 0.05 w.r.t. the total available energy cannot be even approximately simulated by classical circuits of bounded (sub-logarithmic) depth. In a sense, this implies that even providing a "witness" to the fact that the local Hamiltonian can be "almost" satisfied, already requires some measure of long-range entanglement. Our construction is but a first step in what, we believe, is a whole range of possible entanglement - robust local Hamiltonians. A natural next step, we believe, is to devise such local Hamiltonians that resist approximation in terms of bounded-depth quantum circuits (e.g. NLTS), and even find such robust forms of entanglement that are useful for some computation.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2017; v1 submitted 8 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Optimal algorithms for linear algebra by quantum inspiration
Authors:
Michael Ben-Or,
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
Recent results by Harrow et. al. and by Ta-Shma, suggest that quantum computers may have an exponential advantage in solving a wealth of linear algebraic problems, over classical algorithms. Building on the quantum intuition of these results, we step back into the classical domain, and explore its usefulness in designing classical algorithms. We achieve an algorithm for solving the major linear-al…
▽ More
Recent results by Harrow et. al. and by Ta-Shma, suggest that quantum computers may have an exponential advantage in solving a wealth of linear algebraic problems, over classical algorithms. Building on the quantum intuition of these results, we step back into the classical domain, and explore its usefulness in designing classical algorithms. We achieve an algorithm for solving the major linear-algebraic problems in time $O(n^{ω+ν})$ for any $ν>0$, where $ω$ is the optimal matrix-product constant. Thus our algorithm is optimal w.r.t. matrix multiplication, and comparable to the state-of-the-art algorithm for these problems due to Demmel et. al. Being derived from quantum intuition, our proposed algorithm is completely disjoint from all previous classical algorithms, and builds on a combination of low-discrepancy sequences and perturbation analysis. As such, we hope it motivates further exploration of quantum techniques in this respect, hopefully leading to improvements in our understanding of space complexity and numerical stability of these problems.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2017; v1 submitted 13 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
The commuting local Hamiltonian on locally-expanding graphs is in NP
Authors:
Dorit Aharonov,
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
The local Hamiltonian problem is famously complete for the class QMA, the quantum analogue of NP. The complexity of its semi-classical version, in which the terms of the Hamiltonian are required to commute (the CLH problem), has attracted considerable attention recently due to its intriguing nature, as well as in relation to growing interest in the qPCP conjecture. We show here that if the underly…
▽ More
The local Hamiltonian problem is famously complete for the class QMA, the quantum analogue of NP. The complexity of its semi-classical version, in which the terms of the Hamiltonian are required to commute (the CLH problem), has attracted considerable attention recently due to its intriguing nature, as well as in relation to growing interest in the qPCP conjecture. We show here that if the underlying bipartite interaction graph of the CLH instance is a good locally-expanding graph, namely, the expansion of any constant-size set is e-close to optimal, then approximating its ground energy to within additive factor O(e) lies in NP. The proof holds for k- local Hamiltonians for any constant k and any constant dimensionality of particles d. We also show that the approximation problem of CLH on such good local expanders is NP-hard. This implies that too good local expansion of the interaction graph constitutes an obstacle against quantum hardness of the approximation problem, though it retains its classical hardness. The result highlights new difficulties in trying to mimic classical proofs (in particular Dinur's PCP proof) in an attempt to prove the quantum PCP conjecture. A related result was discovered recently independently by Brandao and Harrow, for 2-local general Hamiltonians, bounding the quantum hardness of the approximation problem on good expanders, though no NP-hardness is known in that case.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Quantum Locally Testable Codes
Authors:
Dorit Aharonov,
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
We initiate the study of quantum Locally Testable Codes (qLTCs). We provide a definition together with a simplification, denoted sLTCs, for the special case of stabilizer codes, together with some basic results using those definitions. The most crucial parameter of such codes is their soundness, $R(δ)$, namely, the probability that a randomly chosen constraint is violated as a function of the dist…
▽ More
We initiate the study of quantum Locally Testable Codes (qLTCs). We provide a definition together with a simplification, denoted sLTCs, for the special case of stabilizer codes, together with some basic results using those definitions. The most crucial parameter of such codes is their soundness, $R(δ)$, namely, the probability that a randomly chosen constraint is violated as a function of the distance of a word from the code ($δ$, the relative distance from the code, is called the proximity). We then proceed to study limitations on qLTCs. In our first main result we prove a surprising, inherently quantum, property of sLTCs: for small values of proximity, the better the small-set expansion of the interaction graph of the constraints, the less sound the qLTC becomes. This phenomenon, which can be attributed to monogamy of entanglement, stands in sharp contrast to the classical setting. The complementary, more intuitive, result also holds: an upper bound on the soundness when the code is defined on poor small-set expanders (a bound which turns out to be far more difficult to show in the quantum case). Together we arrive at a quantum upper-bound on the soundness of stabilizer qLTCs set on any graph, which does not hold in the classical case. Many open questions are raised regarding what possible parameters are achievable for qLTCs. In the appendix we also define a quantum analogue of PCPs of proximity (PCPPs) and point out that the result of Ben-Sasson et. al. by which PCPPs imply LTCs with related parameters, carries over to the sLTCs. This creates a first link between qLTCs and quantum PCPs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Commuting Local Hamiltonians on Expanders, Locally Testable Quantum codes, and the qPCP conjecture
Authors:
Dorit Aharonov,
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
Understanding commuting local Hamiltonians (CLHs) is at the heart of many questions in quantum computational complexity and quantum physics: quantum error correcting codes, quantum NP, the PCP conjecture, topological order and more.
Understanding commuting local Hamiltonians (CLHs) is at the heart of many questions in quantum computational complexity and quantum physics: quantum error correcting codes, quantum NP, the PCP conjecture, topological order and more.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
On the complexity of Commuting Local Hamiltonians, and tight conditions for Topological Order in such systems
Authors:
Dorit Aharonov,
Lior Eldar
Abstract:
The local Hamiltonian problem plays the equivalent role of SAT in quantum complexity theory. Understanding the complexity of the intermediate case in which the constraints are quantum but all local terms in the Hamiltonian commute, is of importance for conceptual, physical and computational complexity reasons. Bravyi and Vyalyi showed in 2003, using a clever application of the representation theor…
▽ More
The local Hamiltonian problem plays the equivalent role of SAT in quantum complexity theory. Understanding the complexity of the intermediate case in which the constraints are quantum but all local terms in the Hamiltonian commute, is of importance for conceptual, physical and computational complexity reasons. Bravyi and Vyalyi showed in 2003, using a clever application of the representation theory of C*-algebras, that if the terms in the Hamiltonian are all two-local, the problem is in NP, and the entanglement in the ground states is local. The general case remained open since then. In this paper we extend the results of Bravyi and Vyalyi beyond the two-local case, to the case of three-qubit interactions. We then extend our results even further, and show that NP verification is possible for three-wise interaction between qutrits as well, as long as the interaction graph is embedded on a planar lattice, or more generally, "Nearly Euclidean" (NE). The proofs imply that in all such systems, the entanglement in the ground states is local. These extensions imply an intriguing sharp transition phenomenon in commuting Hamiltonian systems: 3-local NE systems based on qubits and qutrits cannot be used to construct Topological order, as their entanglement is local, whereas for higher dimensional qudits, or for interactions of at least 4 qudits, Topological Order is already possible, via Kitaev's Toric Code construction. We thus conclude that Kitaev's Toric Code construction is optimal for deriving topological order based on commuting Hamiltonians.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2011; v1 submitted 3 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
