-
Proof of Gauge-Invariance of Magnetic Susceptibility of Topologically Trivial Insulators in the Independent Particle Approximation
Authors:
Alistair H. Duff,
J. E. Sipe
Abstract:
We have derived an expression for the magnetic susceptibility of topologically trivial insulators, however an important consideration for any response tensor is whether it is gauge-invariant. By this we refer to the gauge-freedom in choosing the Bloch functions one uses in a computation since multiplication by an arbitrary $\textbf{k}$-dependent complex phase produces equally valid Bloch functions…
▽ More
We have derived an expression for the magnetic susceptibility of topologically trivial insulators, however an important consideration for any response tensor is whether it is gauge-invariant. By this we refer to the gauge-freedom in choosing the Bloch functions one uses in a computation since multiplication by an arbitrary $\textbf{k}$-dependent complex phase produces equally valid Bloch functions. Additionally Wannier functions, which can be constructed by a unitary mixing of the Bloch functions, are a useful basis for computation due to their localized properties, but are strongly non-unique. Therefore, we show that the theoretical expression we derived is independent of the choice of Bloch functions or Wannier functions used, and thus is gauge-invariant in this sense.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2023; v1 submitted 6 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Microscopic Theory of the Magnetic Susceptibility of Insulators
Authors:
Alistair H. Duff,
Aidan Lau,
J. E. Sipe
Abstract:
We present a general theory of the magnetic susceptibility of insulators that can be extended to treat spatially varying and finite frequency fields. While there are existing results in the literature for the zero frequency response that appear to be in disagreement with each other, we show that the apparent differences between them vanish with the use of various sum rules, and that our result is…
▽ More
We present a general theory of the magnetic susceptibility of insulators that can be extended to treat spatially varying and finite frequency fields. While there are existing results in the literature for the zero frequency response that appear to be in disagreement with each other, we show that the apparent differences between them vanish with the use of various sum rules, and that our result is in agreement with them. Although our strategy is based on the use of Wannier functions, we show that our result can be written in a ``gauge invariant" form involving Bloch functions. We can write it as the sum of terms that involve the diagonal elements of the Berry connection, and this decomposition is particularly useful in considering the limit of isolated molecules. But these contributions can be repackaged to give a form independent of those diagonal elements, which is thus generally more suitable for numerical computation. We consider an h-BN model to demonstrate the practical considerations in building a model and making calculations within this formalism.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2023; v1 submitted 6 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Magnetoelectric polarizability and optical activity: spin and frequency dependence
Authors:
Alistair H. Duff,
J. E. Sipe
Abstract:
We extend a microscopic theory of polarization and magnetization to include the spin degree of freedom of the electrons, introducing a general spin orbit coupling and Zeeman interaction term in the Hamiltonian. At finite frequencies and including spin, the magnetoelectric polarizability tensor is replaced by two separate tensors, one that relates the polarization \textbf{P} to the magnetic field \…
▽ More
We extend a microscopic theory of polarization and magnetization to include the spin degree of freedom of the electrons, introducing a general spin orbit coupling and Zeeman interaction term in the Hamiltonian. At finite frequencies and including spin, the magnetoelectric polarizability tensor is replaced by two separate tensors, one that relates the polarization \textbf{P} to the magnetic field \textbf{B} and a separate tensor that relates the magnetization \textbf{M} to the electric field \textbf{E}. When combined with other relevant response tensors a third rank tensor that relates the induced current density to gradients in the electric field can be introduced; it is gauge invariant, in a form suitable for numerical calculations, and describes optical activity -- including spin effects -- even in materials that may lack time reversal symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2023; v1 submitted 16 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
