-
Multistability of elasto-inertial two-dimensional channel flow
Authors:
Miguel Beneitez,
Jacob Page,
Yves Dubief,
Rich R. Kerswell
Abstract:
Elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT) is a recently discovered two-dimensional chaotic flow state observed in dilute polymer solutions. It has been hypothesised that the dynamical origins of EIT are linked to a center-mode instability, whose nonlinear evolution leads to a travelling wave with an 'arrowhead' structure in the polymer conformation, a structure also observed instantaneously in simulations…
▽ More
Elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT) is a recently discovered two-dimensional chaotic flow state observed in dilute polymer solutions. It has been hypothesised that the dynamical origins of EIT are linked to a center-mode instability, whose nonlinear evolution leads to a travelling wave with an 'arrowhead' structure in the polymer conformation, a structure also observed instantaneously in simulations of EIT. In this work we conduct a suite of two-dimensional direct numerical simulations spanning a wide range of polymeric flow parameters to examine the possible dynamical connection between the arrowhead and EIT. Our calculations reveal (up to) four co-existent attractors: the laminar state and a steady arrowhead, along with EIT and a 'chaotic arrowhead'. The steady arrowhead is stable for all parameters considered here, while the final pair of (chaotic) flow states are visually very similar and can be distinguished only by the presence of a weak polymer arrowhead structure in the 'chaotic arrowhead' regime. Analysis of energy transfers between the flow and the polymer indicates that both chaotic regimes are maintained by an identical near-wall mechanism and that the weak arrowhead does not play a role. Our results suggest that the arrowhead is a benign flow structure that is disconnected from the self-sustaining mechanics of EIT.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Exact travelling wave solutions in viscoelastic channel flow
Authors:
Jacob Page,
Yves Dubief,
Rich R. Kerswell
Abstract:
Elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT) is a new, two-dimensional chaotic flow state observed in polymer solutions with possible connections to inertialess elastic turbulence and drag-reduced Newtonian turbulence. In this Letter, we argue that the origins of EIT are fundamentally different from Newtonian turbulence by finding a dynamical connection between EIT and an elasto-inertial linear instability re…
▽ More
Elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT) is a new, two-dimensional chaotic flow state observed in polymer solutions with possible connections to inertialess elastic turbulence and drag-reduced Newtonian turbulence. In this Letter, we argue that the origins of EIT are fundamentally different from Newtonian turbulence by finding a dynamical connection between EIT and an elasto-inertial linear instability recently found at high Weissenberg numbers (Garg et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 024502, 2018). This link is established by isolating the first known exact coherent structures in viscoelastic parallel flows - nonlinear elasto-inertial travelling waves (TWs) - borne at the linear instability and tracking them down to substantially lower Weissenberg numbers where EIT exists. These TWs have a distinctive ``arrowhead'' structure in the polymer stretch field and can be clearly recognised, albeit transiently, in EIT, as well as being attractors for EIT dynamics if the Weissenberg number is sufficiently large. Our findings suggest that the dynamical systems picture in which Newtonian turbulence is built around the co-existence of many (unstable) simple invariant solutions populating phase space carries over to EIT, though these solutions rely on elasticity to exist.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A first coherent structure in elasto-inertial turbulence
Authors:
Yves Dubief,
Jacob Page,
Rich R. Kerswell,
Vincent E. Terrapon,
Victor Steinberg
Abstract:
Two dimensional channel flow simulations of FENE-P fluid in the elasto-inertial turbulence regime reveal distinct regimes ranging from chaos to a steady travelling wave which takes the form of an arrowhead structure. This coherent structure provides new insights in the polymer/flow interactions driving EIT, which are observed in a set of controlled numerical experiments and the study of transfer b…
▽ More
Two dimensional channel flow simulations of FENE-P fluid in the elasto-inertial turbulence regime reveal distinct regimes ranging from chaos to a steady travelling wave which takes the form of an arrowhead structure. This coherent structure provides new insights in the polymer/flow interactions driving EIT, which are observed in a set of controlled numerical experiments and the study of transfer between elastic and turbulent kinetic energy.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2021; v1 submitted 11 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Two-dimensional dynamics of elasto-inertial turbulence and its role in polymer drag reduction
Authors:
S. Sid,
Y. Dubief,
V. E. Terrapon
Abstract:
The goal of the present study is: (i) to demonstrate the two-dimensional nature of the elasto-inertial instability in elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT), (ii) to identify the role of the bi-dimensional instability in three-dimensional EIT flows and (iii) to establish the role of the small elastic scales in the mechanism of self-sustained EIT. Direct numerical simulations of FENE-P fluid flows are pe…
▽ More
The goal of the present study is: (i) to demonstrate the two-dimensional nature of the elasto-inertial instability in elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT), (ii) to identify the role of the bi-dimensional instability in three-dimensional EIT flows and (iii) to establish the role of the small elastic scales in the mechanism of self-sustained EIT. Direct numerical simulations of FENE-P fluid flows are performed in two- and three-dimensional channels. The Reynolds number is set to $\mathrm{Re}_τ= 85$ which is sub-critical for 2D flows but beyond transition for 3D ones. The polymer properties correspond to those of typical dilute polymer solutions and two moderate Weissenberg numbers, $\mathrm{Wi}_τ= 40, 100$, are considered. The simulation results show that sustained turbulence can be observed in 2D sub-critical flows, confirming the existence of a bi-dimensional elasto-inertial instability. The same type of instability is also observed in 3D simulations where both Newtonian and elasto-inertial turbulent structures co-exist. Depending on the Wi number, one type of structure can dominate and drive the flow. For large Wi values, the elasto-inertial instability tends to prevail over the Newtonian turbulence. This statement is supported by (i) the absence of the typical Newtonian near-wall vortices and (ii) strong similarities between two- and three-dimensional flows when considering larger Wi numbers. The role of the small elastic scales is investigated by introducing global artificial diffusion in the hyperbolic transport equation for polymers. The study results show that the introduction of large polymer diffusion in the system strongly damps a significant part of the elastic scales that are necessary to feed turbulence, eventually leading to the flow laminarization. A sufficiently high Schmidt number is necessary to allow self-sustained turbulence to settle.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Predicting Flow Reversals in a Computational Fluid Dynamics Simulated Thermosyphon using Data Assimilation
Authors:
Andrew J. Reagan,
Yves Dubief,
Peter Sheridan Dodds,
Christopher M. Danforth
Abstract:
A thermal convection loop is a annular chamber filled with water, heated on the bottom half and cooled on the top half. With sufficiently large forcing of heat, the direction of fluid flow in the loop oscillates chaotically, dynamics analogous to the Earth's weather. As is the case for state-of-the-art weather models, we only observe the statistics over a small region of state space, making predic…
▽ More
A thermal convection loop is a annular chamber filled with water, heated on the bottom half and cooled on the top half. With sufficiently large forcing of heat, the direction of fluid flow in the loop oscillates chaotically, dynamics analogous to the Earth's weather. As is the case for state-of-the-art weather models, we only observe the statistics over a small region of state space, making prediction difficult. To overcome this challenge, data assimilation (DA) methods, and specifically ensemble methods, use the computational model itself to estimate the uncertainty of the model to optimally combine these observations into an initial condition for predicting the future state. Here, we build and verify four distinct DA methods, and then, we perform a twin model experiment with the computational fluid dynamics simulation of the loop using the Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter (ETKF) to assimilate observations and predict flow reversals. We show that using adaptively shaped localized covariance outperforms static localized covariance with the ETKF, and allows for the use of less observations in predicting flow reversals. We also show that a Dynamic Mode Decomposition (DMD) of the temperature and velocity fields recovers the low dimensional system underlying reversals, finding specific modes which together are predictive of reversal direction.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2016; v1 submitted 12 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
A Second Order Thermal and Momentum Immersed Boundary Method for Conjugate Heat Transfer in a Cartesian Finite Volume Solver
Authors:
Ryan Crocker,
Yves Dubief,
Olivier Desjardins
Abstract:
A conjugate heat transfer (CHT) immersed boundary (IB and CHTIB) method is developed for use with laminar and turbulent flows with low to moderate Reynolds numbers. The method is validated with the canonical flow of two co-annular rotating cylinders at $Re=50$ which shows second order accuracy of the $L_{2}$ and $L_{\infty}$ error norms of the temperature field over a wide rage of solid to fluid t…
▽ More
A conjugate heat transfer (CHT) immersed boundary (IB and CHTIB) method is developed for use with laminar and turbulent flows with low to moderate Reynolds numbers. The method is validated with the canonical flow of two co-annular rotating cylinders at $Re=50$ which shows second order accuracy of the $L_{2}$ and $L_{\infty}$ error norms of the temperature field over a wide rage of solid to fluid thermal conductivities, $κ_{s}/κ_{f} = \left(9-100\right)$. To evaluate the CHTIBM with turbulent flow a fully developed, heated, turbulent channel $\left(Re_{u_τ}=150\text{ and } κ_{s}/κ_{f}=4 \right)$ is used which shows near perfect correlation to previous direct numerical simulation (DNS) results. The CHTIB method is paired with a momentum IB method (IBM), both of which use a level set field to define the wetted boundaries of the fluid/solid interfaces and are applied to the flow solver implicitly with rescaling of the difference operators of the finite volume (FV) method (FVM).
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2014; v1 submitted 4 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
On the mechanism of elasto-inertial turbulence
Authors:
Yves Dubief,
Vincent E. Terrapon,
Julio Soria
Abstract:
Elasto-inertial turbulence is a new state of turbulence found in flows with polymer additives . The dynamics of turbulence generated and controlled by such additives is investigated from the perspective of the coupling between polymer dynamics and flow structures. Direct numerical simulations of channel flow with Reynolds numbers ranging from 1000 to 6000 (based on the bulk and the channel height)…
▽ More
Elasto-inertial turbulence is a new state of turbulence found in flows with polymer additives . The dynamics of turbulence generated and controlled by such additives is investigated from the perspective of the coupling between polymer dynamics and flow structures. Direct numerical simulations of channel flow with Reynolds numbers ranging from 1000 to 6000 (based on the bulk and the channel height) are used to study the formation and dynamics of elastic instabilities and their effects on the flow. The resulting mechanism of interactions between polymer dynamics and the flow helps resolve a long-standing controversy in the understanding of polymer drag reduction and explains the phenomenon of early turbulence, or onset of turbulence at lower Reynolds numbers than for Newtonian flows, previously observed in polymeric flows. Polymers also point out an interesting analogy with the forward and backward energy cascade in two-dimensional turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Elasto-inertial turbulence
Authors:
Devranjan Samanta,
Yves Dubief,
Markus Holzner,
Christof Schäfer,
Alexander Morozov,
Christian Wagner,
Björn Hof
Abstract:
Turbulence is ubiquitous in nature yet even for the case of ordinary Newtonian fluids like water our understanding of this phenomenon is limited. Many liquids of practical importance however are more complicated (e.g. blood, polymer melts or paints), they exhibit elastic as well as viscous characteristics and the relation between stress and strain is nonlinear. We here demonstrate for a model syst…
▽ More
Turbulence is ubiquitous in nature yet even for the case of ordinary Newtonian fluids like water our understanding of this phenomenon is limited. Many liquids of practical importance however are more complicated (e.g. blood, polymer melts or paints), they exhibit elastic as well as viscous characteristics and the relation between stress and strain is nonlinear. We here demonstrate for a model system of such complex fluids that at high shear rates turbulence is not simply modified as previously believed but it is suppressed and replaced by a new type of disordered motion, elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT). EIT is found to occur at much lower Reynolds numbers than Newtonian turbulence and the dynamical properties differ significantly. In particular the drag is strongly reduced and the observed friction scaling resolves a longstanding puzzle in non-Newtonian fluid mechanics regarding the nature of the so-called maximum drag reduction asymptote. Theoretical considerations imply that EIT will arise in complex fluids if the extensional viscosity is sufficiently large.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Dynamics of Elastic-Inertial Turbulence
Authors:
Y. Dubief,
V. E. Terrapon,
J. Soria
Abstract:
This movie illustrates the recent numerical and experimental discovery of a new state of turbulence in dilute polymer solutions, Elasto-Inertial Turbulence. Elasto-inertial turbulence is characterized by a chaotic flow state in which both inertial and elastic effects, whose relative contributions vary with the Reynolds number, control the flow dynamics.
This movie illustrates the recent numerical and experimental discovery of a new state of turbulence in dilute polymer solutions, Elasto-Inertial Turbulence. Elasto-inertial turbulence is characterized by a chaotic flow state in which both inertial and elastic effects, whose relative contributions vary with the Reynolds number, control the flow dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2012; v1 submitted 15 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Polymer Maximum Drag Reduction: A Unique Transitional State
Authors:
Yves Dubief,
Christopher M. White,
Eric S. G. Shaqfeh,
Vincent E. Terrapon
Abstract:
The upper bound of polymer drag reduction is identified as a unique transitional state between laminar and turbulent flow corresponding to the onset of the nonlinear breakdown of flow instabilities.
The upper bound of polymer drag reduction is identified as a unique transitional state between laminar and turbulent flow corresponding to the onset of the nonlinear breakdown of flow instabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Heat transfer enhancement and reduction by poylmer additives in turbulent Rayleigh Benard convection
Authors:
Yves Dubief
Abstract:
This letter confirms the existence of heat transfer enhancement (HTE) and reduction (HTR) in turbulent natural convection with polymer additives. HTE and HTR were numerically predicted by Benzi et al.(PRL, 104, 024502, 2010) in homogenous turbulent convection, but experiments by Ahlers & Nikolaenko(PRL, 104, 034503, 2010) in turbulent natural convection observed HTR only. Using direct numerical si…
▽ More
This letter confirms the existence of heat transfer enhancement (HTE) and reduction (HTR) in turbulent natural convection with polymer additives. HTE and HTR were numerically predicted by Benzi et al.(PRL, 104, 024502, 2010) in homogenous turbulent convection, but experiments by Ahlers & Nikolaenko(PRL, 104, 034503, 2010) in turbulent natural convection observed HTR only. Using direct numerical simulation of natural convection, the present study reconciles earlier numerical and experimental work on the basis of the dominant role of polymer length in the polymer dynamics in extensional flows.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Variation on the Kolmogorov Forcing: Asymptotic Dissipation Rate Driven by Harmonic Forcing
Authors:
B. Rollin,
Y. Dubief,
C. R. Doering
Abstract:
The relation between the shape of the force driving a turbulent flow and the upper bound on the dimensionless dissipation factor $β$ is presented. We are interested in non-trivial (more than two wave numbers) forcing functions in a three dimensional domain periodic in all directions. A comparative analysis between results given by the optimization problem and the results of Direct Numerical Simu…
▽ More
The relation between the shape of the force driving a turbulent flow and the upper bound on the dimensionless dissipation factor $β$ is presented. We are interested in non-trivial (more than two wave numbers) forcing functions in a three dimensional domain periodic in all directions. A comparative analysis between results given by the optimization problem and the results of Direct Numerical Simulations is performed. We report that the bound on the dissipation factor in the case of infinite Reynolds numbers have the same qualitative behavior as for the dissipation factor at finite Reynolds number. As predicted by the analysis, the dissipation factor depends strongly on the force shape. However, the optimization problem does not predict accurately the quantitative behavior. We complete our study by analyzing the mean flow profile in relation to the Stokes flow profile and the optimal multiplier profile shape for different force-shapes. We observe that in our 3D-periodic domain, the mean velocity profile and the Stokes flow profile reproduce all the characteristic features of the force-shape. The optimal multiplier proves to be linked to the intensity of the wave numbers of the forcing function.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
