-
Tidal synchronization trap** in stars and planets with convective envelopes
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry
Abstract:
Tidal torques can alter the spins of tidally interacting stars and planets, usually over shorter timescales than the tidal dam** of orbital separations or eccentricities. Simple tidal models predict that in eccentric binary or planetary systems, rotation periods will evolve toward a "pseudosynchronous" ratio with the orbital period. However, this prediction does not account for "inertial" waves…
▽ More
Tidal torques can alter the spins of tidally interacting stars and planets, usually over shorter timescales than the tidal dam** of orbital separations or eccentricities. Simple tidal models predict that in eccentric binary or planetary systems, rotation periods will evolve toward a "pseudosynchronous" ratio with the orbital period. However, this prediction does not account for "inertial" waves that are present in stars or gaseous planets with (i) convective envelopes, and (ii) even very slow rotation. We demonstrate that tidal driving of inertial oscillations in eccentric systems generically produces a network of stable "synchronization traps" at ratios of orbital to rotation period that are simple to predict, but can deviate significantly from pseudosynchronization. The mechanism underlying spin synchronization trap** is similar to tidal resonance locking, involving a balance between torques that is maintained automatically by the scaling of inertial mode frequencies with the rotation rate. In contrast with many resonance locking scenarios, however, the torque balance required for synchronization trap** need not drive mode amplitudes to nonlinearity. Synchronization traps may provide an explanation for low-mass stars and hot Jupiters with observed rotation rates that deviate from pseudosynchronous or synchronous expectations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2024; v1 submitted 11 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Tidal migration of exoplanets around M-dwarfs: frequency-dependent tidal dissipation
Authors:
Samantha C. Wu,
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Jim Fuller
Abstract:
The orbital architectures of short-period exoplanet systems are shaped by tidal dissipation in their host stars. For low-mass M-dwarfs whose dynamical tidal response comprises a dense spectrum of inertial modes at low frequencies, resolving the frequency dependence of tidal dissipation is crucial to capturing the effect of tides on planetary orbits throughout the evolutionary stages of the host st…
▽ More
The orbital architectures of short-period exoplanet systems are shaped by tidal dissipation in their host stars. For low-mass M-dwarfs whose dynamical tidal response comprises a dense spectrum of inertial modes at low frequencies, resolving the frequency dependence of tidal dissipation is crucial to capturing the effect of tides on planetary orbits throughout the evolutionary stages of the host star. We use non-perturbative spectral methods to calculate the normal mode oscillations of a fully-convective M-dwarf modeled using realistic stellar profiles from MESA. We compute the dissipative tidal response composed of contributions from each mode as well as non-adiabatic coupling between the modes, which we find to be an essential component of the dissipative calculations. Using our results for dissipation, we then compute of the evolution of circular, coplanar planetary orbits under the influence of tides in the host star. We find that orbital migration driven by resonance locking affects the orbits of Earth-mass planets at orbital periods $P_{\rm orb} \lesssim 1.5$ day and of Jupiter-mass planets at $P_{\rm orb} \lesssim 2.5$ day. Due to resonantly-driven orbital decay and outward migration, we predict a dearth of small planets closer than $P_{\rm orb} \sim 1$ day and similarly sparse numbers of more massive planets out to $P_{\rm orb} \sim 3$ day.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024; v1 submitted 6 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
On the dam** of tidally driven oscillations
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Samantha C. Wu
Abstract:
Expansions in the oscillation modes of tidally perturbed bodies provide a useful framework for representing tidally induced flows. However, recent work has demonstrated that such expansions produce inaccurate predictions for secular orbital evolution when mode dam** rates are computed independently. We explore the coupling of collectively driven modes by frictional and viscous dissipation, in ti…
▽ More
Expansions in the oscillation modes of tidally perturbed bodies provide a useful framework for representing tidally induced flows. However, recent work has demonstrated that such expansions produce inaccurate predictions for secular orbital evolution when mode dam** rates are computed independently. We explore the coupling of collectively driven modes by frictional and viscous dissipation, in tidally perturbed bodies that are both non-rotating and rigidly rotating. This exploration leads us to propose an alternative approach to treating the dam** of tidally driven oscillations that accounts for dissipative mode coupling, but which does not require any information beyond the eigenfunctions and eigenfrequencies of adiabatic modes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Linear and nonlinear eccentric mode evolution in unstratified MHD discs
Authors:
Elliot M. Lynch,
Janosz W. Dewberry
Abstract:
In this paper we develop a framework for studying unstratified, magnetised eccentric discs and compute uniformly precessing eccentric modes in a cylindrical annulus which provide convenient initial conditions for numerical simulations. The presence of a magnetic field in an eccentric disc can be described by an effective gas with a modified equation of state. At magnetic field strengths relevant t…
▽ More
In this paper we develop a framework for studying unstratified, magnetised eccentric discs and compute uniformly precessing eccentric modes in a cylindrical annulus which provide convenient initial conditions for numerical simulations. The presence of a magnetic field in an eccentric disc can be described by an effective gas with a modified equation of state. At magnetic field strengths relevant to the magneto-rotational instability the magnetic field has negligible influence on the evolution of the eccentric disc, however the eccentric disc can significantly enhance the magnetic field strength over that in the a circular disc. We verify the suitability of these eccentric disc solutions by carrying out 2D simulations in RAMSES. Our simulated modes (in 2D) follow a similar evolution to the purely hydrodynamical modes, matching theoretical expectations, provided they are adequately resolved. Such solutions will provide equilibrium states for studies of the eccentric magneto-rotational instability and magnetised parametric instability in unstratified discs and are useful for exploring the response of disc turbulence on top of a fluid flow varying on the orbital timescale.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Saturn's Seismic Rotation Revisited
Authors:
Christopher R. Mankovich,
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Jim Fuller
Abstract:
Normal mode seismology is a promising means of measuring rotation in gas giant interiors, and ring seismology presents a singular opportunity to do so at Saturn. We calculate Saturn's normal modes of oscillation and zonal gravity field, using nonperturbative methods for normal modes in the rigidly rotating approximation, and perturbative methods for the shifts that Saturn's deep winds induce in th…
▽ More
Normal mode seismology is a promising means of measuring rotation in gas giant interiors, and ring seismology presents a singular opportunity to do so at Saturn. We calculate Saturn's normal modes of oscillation and zonal gravity field, using nonperturbative methods for normal modes in the rigidly rotating approximation, and perturbative methods for the shifts that Saturn's deep winds induce in the mode frequencies and zonal gravity harmonics. The latter are calculated by solving the thermo-gravitational wind equation in an oblate geometry. Comparing many such models to gravity data and the frequencies of ring patterns excited by Saturn normal modes, we use statistical methods to estimate that Saturn's cloud-level winds extend inward along cylinders before decaying at a depth 0.125-0.138 times Saturn's equatorial radius, or 7,530-8,320 km, consistent with analyses of Cassini gravity and magnetic field data. The seismology is especially useful for pinning down Saturn's poorly constrained deep rotation period, which we estimate at 634.7 min (median) with a 5/95% quantile range 633.8-635.5 min. Outstanding residuals in mode frequencies at low angular degree suggest a more complicated deep interior than has been considered to date. Smaller but still significant residuals at high angular degree also show that our picture for the thermal, composition, and/or rotation profile in Saturn's envelope is not yet complete.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Dynamical tides in Jupiter and other rotationally flattened planets and stars with stable stratification
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry
Abstract:
We develop a numerical method for directly computing the dissipative dynamical tidal response of rapidly rotating, oblate stars and gaseous planets with realistic internal structures. Applying these calculations to neutrally and stably stratified polytropes, we identify the most relevant resonances in models with rotation rates up to nearly the mass-shedding limit. We then compute the dynamical ti…
▽ More
We develop a numerical method for directly computing the dissipative dynamical tidal response of rapidly rotating, oblate stars and gaseous planets with realistic internal structures. Applying these calculations to neutrally and stably stratified polytropes, we identify the most relevant resonances in models with rotation rates up to nearly the mass-shedding limit. We then compute the dynamical tidal response for Jupiter interior models including both stably stratified and convective regions. These calculations show that resonances involving mixed waves with both gravito-inertial and purely inertial character are capable of explaining a discrepancy between observations and hydrostatic calculations of Jupiter's response to tidal forcing by Io. This result contrasts with recent work that excluded Jupiter's rotational flattening, and opens the door to resonances involving a wider range of internal oscillation modes than previously considered.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2023; v1 submitted 17 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Impacts of zonal winds on planetary oscillations and Saturn ring seismology
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Christopher R. Mankovich,
Jim Fuller
Abstract:
The excitation of density and bending waves in Saturn's C ring by planetary oscillation modes presents a unique opportunity to learn about gas giant interiors and rotation. However, theoretical complications related to Saturn's rapid and differential rotation pose a barrier to the full utilization of ring wave detections. We calculate oscillation modes using a complete, non-perturbative treatment…
▽ More
The excitation of density and bending waves in Saturn's C ring by planetary oscillation modes presents a unique opportunity to learn about gas giant interiors and rotation. However, theoretical complications related to Saturn's rapid and differential rotation pose a barrier to the full utilization of ring wave detections. We calculate oscillation modes using a complete, non-perturbative treatment of differential rotation modelled after Saturn's zonal winds in self-consistently computed, polytropic equilibria. We find that previous, approximate treatments of the effects of differential rotation in Saturn overestimate shifts in the frequencies of fundamental modes (f-modes) thought to be responsible for the majority of the waves detected in the C ring, due to an omitted modification of the equilibrium shape and structure of the planet by differential rotation. The bias introduced by these frequency overestimates is small, but significant relative to the uncertainties afforded by Cassini data. We additionally consider the non-perturbative effects of Saturn-like differential rotation on the rotational mixing of f-modes and internal gravity modes (g-modes), which is relevant to detections of multiple density waves with very closely split pattern speeds. We find that higher order rotational effects can produce orders-of-magnitude enhancements in the surface gravitational perturbations of g-modes dominated by large spherical harmonic degrees $\ell$, regardless of frequency separation from the sectoral f-mode. Despite this enhancement, we find that the observed fine-splitting of density waves is unlikely to involve g-modes dominated by $\ell\gtrsim 10$. This restriction may aid in the inference of possible internal structures for Saturn.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2022; v1 submitted 8 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Dynamical tidal Love numbers of rapidly rotating planets and stars
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
Tidal interactions play an important role in many astrophysical systems, but uncertainties regarding the tides of rapidly rotating, centrifugally distorted stars and gaseous planets remain. We have developed a precise method for computing the dynamical, non-dissipative tidal response of rotating planets and stars, based on summation over contributions from normal modes driven by the tidal potentia…
▽ More
Tidal interactions play an important role in many astrophysical systems, but uncertainties regarding the tides of rapidly rotating, centrifugally distorted stars and gaseous planets remain. We have developed a precise method for computing the dynamical, non-dissipative tidal response of rotating planets and stars, based on summation over contributions from normal modes driven by the tidal potential. We calculate the normal modes of isentropic polytropes rotating at up to $\simeq90\%$ of their critical breakup rotation rates, and tabulate fits to mode frequencies and tidal overlap coefficients that can be used to compute the frequency-dependent, non-dissipative tidal response (via potential Love numbers $k_{\ell m}$). Although fundamental modes (f-modes) possess dominant tidal overlap coefficients at (nearly) all rotation rates, we find that the strong coupling of retrograde inertial modes (i-modes) to tesseral ($\ell>|m|$) components of the tidal potential produces resonances that may be relevant to gas giants like Jupiter and Saturn. The coupling of f-modes in rapid rotators to multiple components of both the driving tidal potential and the induced gravitational field also affect the tesseral response, leading to significant deviations from treatments of rotation that neglect centrifugal distortion and high-order corrections. For very rapid rotation rates ($\gtrsim 70\%$ of breakup), mixing between prograde f-modes and i-modes significantly enhances the sectoral ($\ell=|m|$) tidal overlap of the latter. The tidal response of very rapidly rotating, centrifugally distorted planets or stars can also be modified by resonant sectoral f-modes that are secularly unstable via the Chandrasekhar-Friedman-Schutz (CFS) mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2021; v1 submitted 22 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Constraining Saturn's interior with ring seismology: effects of differential rotation and stable stratification
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Christopher R. Mankovich,
Jim Fuller,
Dong Lai,
Wenrui Xu
Abstract:
Normal mode oscillations in Saturn excite density and bending waves in the C Ring, providing a valuable window into the planet's interior. Saturn's fundamental modes (f modes) excite the majority of the observed waves, while gravito-inertial modes (rotationally modified g modes) associated with stable stratification in the deep interior provide a compelling explanation for additional density waves…
▽ More
Normal mode oscillations in Saturn excite density and bending waves in the C Ring, providing a valuable window into the planet's interior. Saturn's fundamental modes (f modes) excite the majority of the observed waves, while gravito-inertial modes (rotationally modified g modes) associated with stable stratification in the deep interior provide a compelling explanation for additional density waves with low azimuthal wavenumbers m. However, multiplets of density waves with nearly degenerate frequencies, including an m=3 triplet, still lack a definitive explanation. We investigate the effects of rapid and differential rotation on Saturn's oscillations, calculating normal modes for independently constrained interior models. We use a non-perturbative treatment of rotation that captures the full effects of the Coriolis and centrifugal forces, and consequently the mixing of sectoral f modes with g modes characterized by very different spherical harmonic degrees. Realistic profiles for differential rotation associated with Saturn's zonal winds can enhance these mode interactions, producing detectable oscillations with frequencies separated by less than 1%. Our calculations demonstrate that a three-mode interaction involving an f mode and two g modes can feasibly explain the finely split m=3 triplet, although the fine-tuning required to produce such an interaction generally worsens agreement with seismological constraints provided by m=2 density waves. Our calculations additionally demonstrate that sectoral f mode frequencies are measurably sensitive to differential rotation in Saturn's convective envelope. Finally, we find that including realistic equatorial antisymmetry in Saturn's differential rotation profile couples modes with even and odd equatorial parity, producing oscillations that could in principle excite both density and bending waves simultaneously.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2021; v1 submitted 14 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
HFQPOs and discoseismic mode excitation in eccentric, relativistic discs. II. Magnetohydrodynamic simulations
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Henrik N. Latter,
Gordon I. Ogilvie,
Sebastien Fromang
Abstract:
Trapped inertial oscillations (r-modes) provide a promising explanation for high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) observed in the emission from black hole X-ray binary systems. An eccentricity (or warp) can excite r-modes to large amplitudes, but concurrently the oscillations are likely damped by magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence driven by the magnetorotational instability (MRI).…
▽ More
Trapped inertial oscillations (r-modes) provide a promising explanation for high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) observed in the emission from black hole X-ray binary systems. An eccentricity (or warp) can excite r-modes to large amplitudes, but concurrently the oscillations are likely damped by magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence driven by the magnetorotational instability (MRI). We force eccentricity in global, unstratified, zero-net flux MHD simulations of relativistic accretion discs, and find that a sufficiently strong disc distortion generates trapped inertial waves despite this dam**. In our simulations, eccentricities above ~ 0.03 in the inner disc excite trapped waves. In addition to the competition between r-mode dam** and driving, we observe that larger amplitude eccentric structures modify and in some cases suppress MRI turbulence. Given the variety of distortions (warps as well as eccentricities) capable of amplifying r-modes, the robustness of trapped inertial wave excitation in the face of MRI turbulence in our simulations provides support for a discoseismic explanation for HFQPOs.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2020; v1 submitted 29 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
HFQPOs and discoseismic mode excitation in eccentric, relativistic discs. I. Hydrodynamic simulations
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Henrik N. Latter,
Gordon I. Ogilvie,
Sebastian Fromang
Abstract:
High-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) observed in the emission of black-hole X-ray binary systems promise insight into strongly curved spacetime. `Discoseismic' oscillations with frequencies set by the intrinsic properties of the central black hole, in particular `trapped inertial waves' (r-modes), offer an attractive explanation for HFQPOs. To produce an observable signature, howeve…
▽ More
High-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) observed in the emission of black-hole X-ray binary systems promise insight into strongly curved spacetime. `Discoseismic' oscillations with frequencies set by the intrinsic properties of the central black hole, in particular `trapped inertial waves' (r-modes), offer an attractive explanation for HFQPOs. To produce an observable signature, however, such oscillations must be excited to sufficiently large amplitudes. Turbulence driven by the magnetorotational instability (MRI) fails to provide the necessary amplification, but r-modes may still be excited via interaction with accretion disc warps or eccentricities. We present 3D global hydrodynamic simulations of relativistic accretion discs, which demonstrate for the first time the excitation of trapped inertial waves by an imposed eccentricity in the flow. While the r-modes' saturated state depends on the vertical boundary conditions used in our unstratified, cylindrical framework, their excitation is unambiguous in all runs with eccentricity >0.005 near the ISCO. These simulations provide a proof of concept, demonstrating the robustness of trapped inertial wave excitation in a non-magnetized context. In a companion paper, we explore the competition between this excitation, and dam** by magnetohydrodynamic turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2020; v1 submitted 23 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Quasi-periodic oscillations, trapped inertial waves and strong toroidal magnetic fields in relativistic accretion discs
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Henrik N. Latter,
Gordon I. Ogilvie
Abstract:
The excitation of trapped inertial waves (r-modes) by warps and eccentricities in the inner regions of a black hole accretion disc may explain the high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) observed in the emission of Galactic X-ray binaries. However, it has been suggested that strong vertical magnetic fields push the oscillations' trap** region toward the innermost stable circular orbi…
▽ More
The excitation of trapped inertial waves (r-modes) by warps and eccentricities in the inner regions of a black hole accretion disc may explain the high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) observed in the emission of Galactic X-ray binaries. However, it has been suggested that strong vertical magnetic fields push the oscillations' trap** region toward the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO), where conditions could be unfavourable for their excitation. This paper explores the effects of large-scale magnetic fields that exhibit \textit{both} toroidal and vertical components, through local and global linear analyses. We find that a strong toroidal magnetic field can reduce the detrimental effects of a vertical field: in fact, the isolation of the trap** region from the ISCO may be restored by toroidal magnetic fields approaching thermal strengths. The toroidal field couples the r-modes to the disc's magneto-acoustic response and inflates the effective pressure within the oscillations. As a consequence, the restoring force associated with the vertical magnetic field's tension is reduced. Given the analytical and numerical evidence that accretion discs threaded by poloidal magnetic field lines develop a strong toroidal component, our result provides further evidence that the detrimental effects of magnetic fields on trapped inertial modes are not as great as previously thought.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Quasi-periodic oscillations and the global modes of relativistic, MHD accretion discs
Authors:
Janosz W. Dewberry,
Henrik N. Latter,
Gordon I. Ogilvie
Abstract:
The high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) that punctuate the light curves of X-ray binary systems present a window onto the intrinsic properties of stellar-mass black holes and hence a testbed for general relativity. One explanation for these features is that relativistic distortion of the accretion disc's differential rotation creates a trap** region in which inertial waves (r-mod…
▽ More
The high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (HFQPOs) that punctuate the light curves of X-ray binary systems present a window onto the intrinsic properties of stellar-mass black holes and hence a testbed for general relativity. One explanation for these features is that relativistic distortion of the accretion disc's differential rotation creates a trap** region in which inertial waves (r-modes) might grow to observable amplitudes. Local analyses, however, predict that large-scale magnetic fields push this trap** region to the inner disc edge, where conditions may be unfavorable for r-mode growth. We revisit this problem from a pseudo-Newtonian but fully global perspective, deriving linearized equations describing a relativistic, magnetized accretion flow, and calculating normal modes with and without vertical density stratification. In an unstratified model, the choice of vertical wavenumber determines the extent to which vertical magnetic fields drive the r-modes toward the inner edge. In a global model fully incorporating density stratification, we confirm that this susceptibility to magnetic fields depends on disc thickness. Our calculations suggest that in thin discs, r-modes may remain independent of the inner disc edge for vertical magnetic fields with plasma betas as low as $β\approx 100-300$. We posit that the appearance of r-modes in observations may be more determined by a competition between excitation and dam** mechanisms near the ISCO than the modification of the trap** region by magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
