-
Resource Adequacy and Capacity Procurement: Metrics and Decision Support Analysis
Authors:
Chris J. Dent,
Nestor Sanchez,
Aditi Shevni,
Jim Q. Smith,
Amy L. Wilson,
Xuewen Yu
Abstract:
Resource adequacy studies typically use standard metrics such as Loss of Load Expectation and Expected Energy Unserved to quantify the risk of supply shortfalls. This paper critiques present approaches to adequacy assessment and capacity procurement in terms of their relevance to decision maker interests, before demonstrating alternatives including risk-averse metrics and visualisations of wider r…
▽ More
Resource adequacy studies typically use standard metrics such as Loss of Load Expectation and Expected Energy Unserved to quantify the risk of supply shortfalls. This paper critiques present approaches to adequacy assessment and capacity procurement in terms of their relevance to decision maker interests, before demonstrating alternatives including risk-averse metrics and visualisations of wider risk profile. This is illustrated with results for a Great Britain example, in which the risk profile varies substantially with the installed capacity of wind generation. This paper goes beyond previous literature through its critical discussion of how current practices reflect decision maker interests; and how decision making can be improved using a broader range of outputs available from standard models.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Overcoming the disconnect between energy system and climate modeling
Authors:
Michael T. Craig,
Jan Wohland,
Laurens P. Stoop,
Alexander Kies,
Bryn Pickering,
Hannah C. Bloomfield,
Jethro Browell,
Matteo De Felice,
Chris J. Dent,
Adrien Deroubaix,
Felix Frischmuth,
Paula L. M. Gonzalez,
Aleksander Grochowicz,
Katharina Gruber,
Philipp Härtel,
Martin Kittel,
Leander Kotzur,
Inga Labuhn,
Julie K. Lundquist,
Noah Pflugradt,
Karin van der Wiel,
Marianne Zeyringer,
David J. Brayshaw
Abstract:
Energy system models underpin decisions by energy system planners and operators. Energy system modelling faces a transformation: accounting for changing meteorological conditions imposed by climate change. To enable that transformation, a community of practice in energy-climate modelling has started to form that aims to better integrate energy system models with weather and climate models. Here, w…
▽ More
Energy system models underpin decisions by energy system planners and operators. Energy system modelling faces a transformation: accounting for changing meteorological conditions imposed by climate change. To enable that transformation, a community of practice in energy-climate modelling has started to form that aims to better integrate energy system models with weather and climate models. Here, we evaluate the disconnects between the energy system and climate modelling communities, then lay out a research agenda to bridge those disconnects. In the near-term, we propose interdisciplinary activities for expediting uptake of future climate data in energy system modelling. In the long-term, we propose a transdisciplinary approach to enable development of (1) energy-system-tailored climate datasets for historical and future meteorological conditions and (2) energy system models that can effectively leverage those datasets. This agenda increases the odds of meeting ambitious climate mitigation goals by systematically capturing and mitigating climate risk in energy sector decision making.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2023; v1 submitted 31 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Propagating uncertainty in a network of energy models
Authors:
Victoria Volodina,
Nikki Sonenberg,
Jim Q. Smith,
Peter G. Challenor,
Chris J. Dent,
Henry P. Wynn
Abstract:
Computer models are widely used in decision support for energy systems operation, planning and policy. A system of models is often employed, where model inputs themselves arise from other computer models, with each model being developed by different teams of experts. Gaussian Process emulators can be used to approximate the behaviour of complex, computationally intensive models and used to generat…
▽ More
Computer models are widely used in decision support for energy systems operation, planning and policy. A system of models is often employed, where model inputs themselves arise from other computer models, with each model being developed by different teams of experts. Gaussian Process emulators can be used to approximate the behaviour of complex, computationally intensive models and used to generate predictions together with a measure of uncertainty about the predicted model output. This paper presents a computationally efficient framework for propagating uncertainty within a network of models with high-dimensional outputs used for energy planning. We present a case study from a UK county council considering low carbon technologies to transform its infrastructure to reach a net-zero carbon target. The system model considered for this case study is simple, however the framework can be applied to larger networks of more complex models.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2022; v1 submitted 24 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
The use of multiple models within an organisation
Authors:
Chris J Dent,
Michael Goldstein,
Andrew Wright,
Henry P. Wynn
Abstract:
Organisations, whether in government, industry or commerce, are required to make decisions in a complex and uncertain environment. The way models are used is intimately connected to the way organisations make decisions and the context in which they make them. Typically, in a complex organisation, multiple related models will often be used in support of a decision. For example, engineering models m…
▽ More
Organisations, whether in government, industry or commerce, are required to make decisions in a complex and uncertain environment. The way models are used is intimately connected to the way organisations make decisions and the context in which they make them. Typically, in a complex organisation, multiple related models will often be used in support of a decision. For example, engineering models might be combined with financial models and macro-economic models in order to decide whether to invest in new production capability. Different parts of a complex organisation might operate their own related models which might then be presented to a central decision maker. Yet in practice, there is little awareness of the practical challenges of using models in a robust way to support decision making. There is significant scope to improve decision making though an enhanced understanding of the role and limitations of modelling and through the application of cutting edge methodologies and organisational best practice. This report is in the form of a 'white paper', whose purpose is to identify key issues for consideration whist postulating tentative approaches to these issues that might be worthy of further exploration, focussing on both technical and organisational aspects. It begins with a framework for consideration of how model-based decisions are made in organisations. It then looks more closely at the questions of uncertainty and multiple models. It then postulates some technical statistical and organisational approaches for managing some of these issues. Finally, it considers the way forward, and the possible focus for further work.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Capacity Value of Solar Power and Other Variable Generation
Authors:
S. Awara,
M. Lynch,
S. Pfenninger,
K. Schell,
R. Sioshansi,
I. Staffell,
N. Samaan,
S. H. Tindemans,
A. L. Wilson,
S. Zachary,
H. Zareipour,
C. J. Dent
Abstract:
This paper reviews methods that are used for adequacy risk assessment considering solar power and for assessment of the capacity value of solar power. The properties of solar power are described as seen from the perspective of the power-system operator, comparing differences in energy availability and capacity factors with those of wind power. Methodologies for risk calculations considering variab…
▽ More
This paper reviews methods that are used for adequacy risk assessment considering solar power and for assessment of the capacity value of solar power. The properties of solar power are described as seen from the perspective of the power-system operator, comparing differences in energy availability and capacity factors with those of wind power. Methodologies for risk calculations considering variable generation are surveyed, including the probability background, statistical-estimation approaches, and capacity-value metrics. Issues in incorporating variable generation in capacity markets are described, followed by a review of applied studies considering solar power. Finally, recommendations for further research are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Bayesian estimates of transmission line outage rates that consider line dependencies
Authors:
Kai Zhou,
James R. Cruise,
Chris J. Dent,
Ian Dobson,
Louis Wehenkel,
Zhaoyu Wang,
Amy L. Wilson
Abstract:
Transmission line outage rates are fundamental to power system reliability analysis. Line outages are infrequent, occurring only about once a year, so outage data are limited. We propose a Bayesian hierarchical model that leverages line dependencies to better estimate outage rates of individual transmission lines from limited outage data. The Bayesian estimates have a lower standard deviation than…
▽ More
Transmission line outage rates are fundamental to power system reliability analysis. Line outages are infrequent, occurring only about once a year, so outage data are limited. We propose a Bayesian hierarchical model that leverages line dependencies to better estimate outage rates of individual transmission lines from limited outage data. The Bayesian estimates have a lower standard deviation than estimating the outage rates simply by dividing the number of outages by the number of years of data, especially when the number of outages is small. The Bayesian model produces more accurate individual line outage rates, as well as estimates of the uncertainty of these rates. Better estimates of line outage rates can improve system risk assessment, outage prediction, and maintenance scheduling.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The Scenario Culture
Authors:
Edward Wheatcroft,
Henry Wynn,
Chris J. Dent,
Jim Q. Smith,
Claire L. Copeland,
Daniel Ralph,
Stan Zachary
Abstract:
Scenario Analysis is a risk assessment tool that aims to evaluate the impact of a small number of distinct plausible future scenarios. In this paper, we provide an overview of important aspects of Scenario Analysis including when it is appropriate, the design of scenarios, uncertainty and encouraging creativity. Each of these issues is discussed in the context of climate, energy and legal scenario…
▽ More
Scenario Analysis is a risk assessment tool that aims to evaluate the impact of a small number of distinct plausible future scenarios. In this paper, we provide an overview of important aspects of Scenario Analysis including when it is appropriate, the design of scenarios, uncertainty and encouraging creativity. Each of these issues is discussed in the context of climate, energy and legal scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
An Integrated Optimization + Learning Approach to Optimal Dynamic Pricing for the Retailer with Multi-type Customers in Smart Grids
Authors:
Fanlin Meng,
Xiao-Jun Zeng,
Yan Zhang,
Chris J. Dent,
Dunwei Gong
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider a realistic and meaningful scenario in the context of smart grids where an electricity retailer serves three different types of customers, i.e., customers with an optimal home energy management system embedded in their smart meters (C-HEMS), customers with only smart meters (C-SM), and customers without smart meters (C-NONE). The main objective of this paper is to suppor…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider a realistic and meaningful scenario in the context of smart grids where an electricity retailer serves three different types of customers, i.e., customers with an optimal home energy management system embedded in their smart meters (C-HEMS), customers with only smart meters (C-SM), and customers without smart meters (C-NONE). The main objective of this paper is to support the retailer to make optimal day-ahead dynamic pricing decisions in such a mixed customer pool. To this end, we propose a two-level decision-making framework where the retailer acting as upper-level agent firstly announces its electricity prices of next 24 hours and customers acting as lower-level agents subsequently schedule their energy usages accordingly. For the lower level problem, we model the price responsiveness of different customers according to their unique characteristics. For the upper level problem, we optimize the dynamic prices for the retailer to maximize its profit subject to realistic market constraints. The above two-level model is tackled by genetic algorithms (GA) based distributed optimization methods while its feasibility and effectiveness are confirmed via simulation results.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2018; v1 submitted 18 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Quasiparticle lifetimes in the charged Bose gas and the cuprates
Authors:
A. S. Alexandrov,
C. J. Dent
Abstract:
The scattering cross section of a Coulomb potential screened by a charged Bose gas (CBG) is calculated both above and below the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature, using the variable phase method. In contrast with the BCS superconductor, the screened scattering potential and quasiparticle lifetime are found to be very different in the superconducting and normal states. We apply the result to…
▽ More
The scattering cross section of a Coulomb potential screened by a charged Bose gas (CBG) is calculated both above and below the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature, using the variable phase method. In contrast with the BCS superconductor, the screened scattering potential and quasiparticle lifetime are found to be very different in the superconducting and normal states. We apply the result to explain the appearence of a sharp peak in the ARPES spectra in some cuprates below the superconducting transition.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2000;
originally announced December 2000.
-
Angle-resolved photoemission in doped charge-transfer Mott insulators
Authors:
A. S. Alexandrov,
C. J. Dent
Abstract:
A theory of angle-resolved photoemission (ARPES) in doped cuprates and other charge-transfer Mott insulators is developed taking into account the realistic (LDA+U) band structure, (bi)polaron formation due to the strong electron-phonon interaction, and a random field potential. In most of these materials the first band to be doped is the oxygen band inside the Mott-Hubbard gap. We derive the coh…
▽ More
A theory of angle-resolved photoemission (ARPES) in doped cuprates and other charge-transfer Mott insulators is developed taking into account the realistic (LDA+U) band structure, (bi)polaron formation due to the strong electron-phonon interaction, and a random field potential. In most of these materials the first band to be doped is the oxygen band inside the Mott-Hubbard gap. We derive the coherent part of the ARPES spectra with the oxygen hole spectral function calculated in the non-crossing (ladder) approximation and with the exact spectral function of a one-dimensional hole in a random potential. Some unusual features of ARPES including the polarisation dependence and spectral shape in YBa2Cu3O7 and YBa2Cu4O8 are described without any Fermi-surface, large or small. The theory is compatible with the do** dependence of kinetic and thermodynamic properties of cuprates as well as with the d-wave symmetry of the superconducting order parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 1999;
originally announced May 1999.
