-
Designing metainterfaces with specified friction laws
Authors:
Antoine Aymard,
Emilie Delplanque,
Davy Dalmas,
Julien Scheibert
Abstract:
Many devices, including touchscreens and robotic hands, involve frictional contacts. Optimizing these devices requires fine control of the interface's friction law. We lack systematic methods to create dry contact interfaces whose frictional behavior satisfies preset specifications. We propose a generic surface design strategy to prepare dry rough interfaces that have predefined relationships betw…
▽ More
Many devices, including touchscreens and robotic hands, involve frictional contacts. Optimizing these devices requires fine control of the interface's friction law. We lack systematic methods to create dry contact interfaces whose frictional behavior satisfies preset specifications. We propose a generic surface design strategy to prepare dry rough interfaces that have predefined relationships between normal and friction forces. Such metainterfaces circumvent the usual multiscale challenge of tribology by considering simplified surface topographies as assemblies of spherical asperities. Optimizing the individual asperities' heights enables specific friction laws to be targeted. Through various centimeter-scaled elastomer-glass metainterfaces, we illustrate three types of achievable friction laws, including linear laws with a specified friction coefficient and unusual nonlinear laws. This design strategy represents a scale- and material-independent, chemical-free pathway toward energy-saving and adaptable smart interfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Adhesion in soft contacts is minimum beyond a critical shear displacement
Authors:
C. Oliver,
D. Dalmas,
J. Scheibert
Abstract:
The most direct measurement of adhesion is the pull-off force, i.e. the tensile force necessary to separate two solids in contact. For a given interface, it depends on various experimental parameters, including separation speed, contact age and maximum loading force. Here, using smooth contacts between elastomer spheres and rigid plates, we show that the pull-off force also varies if the contact i…
▽ More
The most direct measurement of adhesion is the pull-off force, i.e. the tensile force necessary to separate two solids in contact. For a given interface, it depends on various experimental parameters, including separation speed, contact age and maximum loading force. Here, using smooth contacts between elastomer spheres and rigid plates, we show that the pull-off force also varies if the contact is sheared prior to separation. For shear displacements below a critical valueabout 10% of that necessary to yield gross sliding, the pull-off force steadily decreases as shear increases. For larger shear, the pull-off force remains constant, at a residual value 10%--15% of its initial value. Combining force measurements and in situ imaging, we show how the unloading path leading to contact separation is modified by the initial shear. In particular, we find that the residual pull-off force prevails if the contact reaches full sliding during unloading. Based on those observations, a first modeling attempt of the critical shear displacement is proposed,involving a competition between jump instability and transition to sliding. Overall, those results offer new insights into the interplay between adhesion and friction, provide new constraints on adhesion measurements and challenge existing adhesive models. They will be useful wherever soft contacts undergo both normal and shear stresses, including tire grip, soft robotics, haptics and animal locomotion.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A versatile flexure-based 6-axes force/torque sensor and its application to tribology
Authors:
M Guibert,
C Oliver,
T Durand,
T Le Mogne,
A Le Bot,
D Dalmas,
J Scheibert,
J Fontaine
Abstract:
Six-axes force/torque sensors are increasingly needed in mechanical engineering. Here, we introduce a flexure-based design for such sensors, which solves some of the drawbacks of the existing designs. In particular, it is backlash-free, it can be wirelessly monitored, it exactly enforces 90 degrees angles between axes, and it enables visual inspection of the monitored system thanks to its hollow s…
▽ More
Six-axes force/torque sensors are increasingly needed in mechanical engineering. Here, we introduce a flexure-based design for such sensors, which solves some of the drawbacks of the existing designs. In particular, it is backlash-free, it can be wirelessly monitored, it exactly enforces 90 degrees angles between axes, and it enables visual inspection of the monitored system thanks to its hollow structure. We first describe the generic design, implementation and calibration procedure. We then demonstrate its capabilities through three illustration examples relevant to the field of tribology: low friction measurements under ultra-high vacuum, multi-directional friction measurements of elastomer contacts, and force/torque-based contact position monitoring.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Finite deformations govern the anisotropic shear-induced area reduction of soft elastic contacts
Authors:
J. Lengiewicz,
M. de Souza,
M. Lahmar,
C. Courbon,
D. Dalmas,
S. Stupkiewicz,
J. Scheibert
Abstract:
Solid contacts involving soft materials are important in mechanical engineering or biomechanics. Experimentally, such contacts have been shown to shrink significantly under shear, an effect which is usually explained using adhesion models. Here we show that quantitative agreement with recent high-load experiments can be obtained, with no adjustable parameter, using a non-adhesive model, provided t…
▽ More
Solid contacts involving soft materials are important in mechanical engineering or biomechanics. Experimentally, such contacts have been shown to shrink significantly under shear, an effect which is usually explained using adhesion models. Here we show that quantitative agreement with recent high-load experiments can be obtained, with no adjustable parameter, using a non-adhesive model, provided that finite deformations are taken into account. Analysis of the model uncovers the basic mechanisms underlying shear-induced area reduction, local contact lifting being the dominant one. We confirm experimentally the relevance of all those mechanisms, by tracking the shear-induced evolution of tracers inserted close to the surface of a smooth elastomer sphere in contact with a smooth glass plate. Our results suggest that finite deformations are an alternative to adhesion, when interpreting a variety of sheared contact experiments involving soft materials.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2020; v1 submitted 5 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Aftershock sequences and seismic-like organization of acoustic events produced by a single propagating crack
Authors:
Jonathan Barés,
Alizée Dubois,
Lamine Hattali,
Davy Dalmas,
Daniel Bonamy
Abstract:
Brittle fractures of inhomogeneous materials like rocks, concrete, or ceramics are of two types: Nominally brittle and driven by the propagation of a single dominant crack or quasi-brittle and resulting from the accumulation of many microcracks. The latter goes along with acoustic noise, whose analysis has revealed that events form aftershock sequences obeying characteristic laws reminiscent of th…
▽ More
Brittle fractures of inhomogeneous materials like rocks, concrete, or ceramics are of two types: Nominally brittle and driven by the propagation of a single dominant crack or quasi-brittle and resulting from the accumulation of many microcracks. The latter goes along with acoustic noise, whose analysis has revealed that events form aftershock sequences obeying characteristic laws reminiscent of those in seismology. Yet, their origin lacks explanation. Here we show that such a statistical organization is not only specific to the multi-cracking situations of quasi-brittle failure and seismology, but also rules the acoustic events produced by a propagating crack. This simpler situation has permitted us to relate these laws to the overall scale-free distribution of inter-event time and energy and to uncover their selection by the crack speed. These results provide a comprehensive picture of how acoustic events are organized upon material failure in the most fundamental of fracture states: single propagating cracks.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Finite size effects on crack front pinning at heterogeneous planar interfaces: Experimental, finite elements and perturbation approaches
Authors:
Sylvain Patinet,
L Alzate,
E Barthel,
D Dalmas,
D Vandembroucq,
V Lazarus
Abstract:
Understanding the role played by the microstructure of materials on their macroscopic failure properties is an important challenge in solid mechanics. Indeed, when a crack propagates at a heterogeneous brittle interface, the front is trapped by tougher regions and deforms. This pinning induces non-linearities in the crack propagation problem, even within Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics theory, a…
▽ More
Understanding the role played by the microstructure of materials on their macroscopic failure properties is an important challenge in solid mechanics. Indeed, when a crack propagates at a heterogeneous brittle interface, the front is trapped by tougher regions and deforms. This pinning induces non-linearities in the crack propagation problem, even within Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics theory, and modifies the overall failure properties of the material. For example crack front pinning by tougher places could increase the fracture resistance of multilayer structures, with interesting technological applications. Analytical perturbation approaches, based on Bueckner-Rice elastic line models, focus on the crack front perturbations, hence allow for a description of these phenomena. Here, they are applied to experiments investigating the propagation of a purely interfacial crack in a simple toughness pattern: a single defect strip surrounded by homogeneous interface. We show that by taking into account the finite size of the body, quantitative agreement with experimental and finite elements results is achieved. In particular this method allows to predict the toughness contrast, i.e. the toughness difference between the single defect strip and its homogeneous surrounding medium. This opens the way to a more accurate use of the perturbation method to study more disordered heterogeneous materials, where the finite elements method is less adequate. From our results, we also propose a simple method to determine the adhesion energy of tough interfaces by measuring the crack front deformation induced by known interface patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Hydrodynamic coarsening in phase-separated silicate melts
Authors:
David Bouttes,
Océane Lambert,
Corinne Claireaux,
William Woelffel,
Davy Dalmas,
Emmanuelle Gouillart,
Pierre Lhuissier,
Luc Salvo,
Elodie Boller,
Damien Vandembroucq
Abstract:
Using in-situ synchrotron tomography, we investigate the coarsening dynamics of barium borosilicate melts during phase separation. The 3-D geometry of the two interconnected phases is determined thanks to image processing. We observe a linear growth of the size of domains with time, at odds with the sublinear diffusive growth usually observed in phase-separating glasses or alloys. Such linear coar…
▽ More
Using in-situ synchrotron tomography, we investigate the coarsening dynamics of barium borosilicate melts during phase separation. The 3-D geometry of the two interconnected phases is determined thanks to image processing. We observe a linear growth of the size of domains with time, at odds with the sublinear diffusive growth usually observed in phase-separating glasses or alloys. Such linear coarsening is attributed to viscous flow inside the bicontinuous phases, and quantitative measurements show that the growth rate is well explained by the ratio of surface tension over viscosity. The geometry of the domains is shown to be statistically similar at different times, provided that the microstructure is rescaled by the average domain size. Complementary experiments on melts with a droplet morphology demonstrate that viscous flow prevails over diffusion in the large range of domain sizes measured in our experiments (1 - 80 microns).
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Fluctuations of global energy release and crackling in nominally brittle heterogeneous fracture
Authors:
Jonathan Barés,
Lamine Hattali,
Davy Dalmas,
Daniel Bonamy
Abstract:
The temporal evolution of mechanical energy and spatially-averaged crack speed are both monitored in slowly fracturing artificial rocks. Both signals display an irregular burst-like dynamics, with power-law distributed fluctuations spanning a broad range of scales. Yet, the elastic power released at each time step is proportional to the global velocity all along the process, which enables defining…
▽ More
The temporal evolution of mechanical energy and spatially-averaged crack speed are both monitored in slowly fracturing artificial rocks. Both signals display an irregular burst-like dynamics, with power-law distributed fluctuations spanning a broad range of scales. Yet, the elastic power released at each time step is proportional to the global velocity all along the process, which enables defining a material-constant fracture energy. We characterize the intermittent dynamics by computing the burst statistics. This latter displays the scale-free features signature of crackling dynamics, in qualitative but not quantitative agreement with the depinning interface models derived for fracture problems. The possible sources of discrepancies are pointed out and discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Self-replicating cracks: a collaborative fracture mode in thin films
Authors:
Joel Marthelot,
Benoit Roman,
Jose Bico,
Jeremie Teisseire,
Davy Dalmas,
Francisco Melo
Abstract:
Straight cracks are observed in thin coatings under residual tensile stress, resulting into the classical network pattern observed in china crockery, old paintings or dry mud. Here, we present a novel fracture mechanism where delamination and propagation occur simultaneously, leading to the spontaneous self-replication of an initial template. Surprisingly, this mechanism is active below the standa…
▽ More
Straight cracks are observed in thin coatings under residual tensile stress, resulting into the classical network pattern observed in china crockery, old paintings or dry mud. Here, we present a novel fracture mechanism where delamination and propagation occur simultaneously, leading to the spontaneous self-replication of an initial template. Surprisingly, this mechanism is active below the standard critical tensile load for channel cracks and selects a robust interaction length scale on the order of 30 times the film thickness. Depending on triggering mechanisms, crescent alleys, spirals or long bands are generated over a wide range of experimental parameters. We describe with a simple physical model the selection of the fracture path and provide a configuration diagram displaying the different failure modes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Fragmentation and Limits to Dynamical Scaling in Viscous Coarsening: An Interrupted in situ X-Ray Tomographic Study
Authors:
David Bouttes,
Emmanuelle Gouillart,
Elodie Boller,
Davy Dalmas,
Damien Vandembroucq
Abstract:
X-Ray microtomography was used to follow the coarsening of the structure of a ternary silicate glass experiencing phase separation in the liquid state. The volumes, surfaces, mean and Gaussian curvatures of the domains of minority phase were measured after reconstruction of the 3D images and segmentation. A linear growth law of the characteristic length scale $\ell \sim t$ was observed. A detailed…
▽ More
X-Ray microtomography was used to follow the coarsening of the structure of a ternary silicate glass experiencing phase separation in the liquid state. The volumes, surfaces, mean and Gaussian curvatures of the domains of minority phase were measured after reconstruction of the 3D images and segmentation. A linear growth law of the characteristic length scale $\ell \sim t$ was observed. A detailed morphological study was performed. While dynamical scaling holds for most of the geometrical observables under study, a progressive departure from scaling invariance of the distributions of local curvatures was evidenced. The latter results from a gradual fragmentation of the structure in the less viscous phase that also leads to a power-law size distribution of isolated domains.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2014; v1 submitted 6 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Damage mechanisms in the dynamic fracture of nominally brittle polymers
Authors:
Davy Dalmas,
Claudia Guerra,
Julien Scheibert,
Daniel Bonamy
Abstract:
Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics (LEFM) provides a consistent framework to evaluate quantitatively the energy flux released to the tip of a growing crack. Still, the way in which the crack selects its velocity in response to this energy flux remains far from completely understood. To uncover the underlying mechanisms, we experimentally studied damage and dissipation processes that develop during…
▽ More
Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics (LEFM) provides a consistent framework to evaluate quantitatively the energy flux released to the tip of a growing crack. Still, the way in which the crack selects its velocity in response to this energy flux remains far from completely understood. To uncover the underlying mechanisms, we experimentally studied damage and dissipation processes that develop during the dynamic failure of polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA), classically considered as the archetype of brittle amorphous materials. We evidenced a well-defined critical velocity along which failure switches from nominally-brittle to quasi-brittle, where crack propagation goes hand in hand with the nucleation and growth of microcracks. Via post-mortem analysis of the fracture surfaces, we were able to reconstruct the complete spatiotemporal microcracking dynamics with micrometer/nanosecond resolution. We demonstrated that the true local propagation speed of individual crack fronts is limited to a fairly low value, which can be much smaller than the apparent speed measured at the continuum-level scale. By coalescing with the main front, microcracks boost the macroscale velocity through an acceleration factor of geometrical origin. We discuss the key role of damage-related internal variables in the selection of macroscale fracture dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Understanding fast macroscale fracture from microcrack post mortem patterns
Authors:
Claudia Guerra,
Julien Scheibert,
Daniel Bonamy,
Davy Dalmas
Abstract:
Dynamic crack propagation drives catastrophic solid failures. In many amorphous brittle materials, sufficiently fast crack growth involves small-scale, high-frequency microcracking damage localized near the crack tip. The ultra-fast dynamics of microcrack nucleation, growth and coalescence is inaccessible experimentally and fast crack propagation was therefore studied only as a macroscale average.…
▽ More
Dynamic crack propagation drives catastrophic solid failures. In many amorphous brittle materials, sufficiently fast crack growth involves small-scale, high-frequency microcracking damage localized near the crack tip. The ultra-fast dynamics of microcrack nucleation, growth and coalescence is inaccessible experimentally and fast crack propagation was therefore studied only as a macroscale average. Here, we overcome this limitation in polymethylmethacrylate, the archetype of brittle amorphous materials: We reconstruct the complete spatio-temporal microcracking dynamics, with micrometer / nanosecond resolution, through post mortem analysis of the fracture surfaces. We find that all individual microcracks propagate at the same low, load-independent, velocity. Collectively, the main effect of microcracks is not to slow down fracture by increasing the energy required for crack propagation, as commonly believed, but on the contrary to boost the macroscale velocity through an acceleration factor selected on geometric grounds. Our results emphasize the key role of damage-related internal variables in the selection of macroscale fracture dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2012; v1 submitted 10 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Brittle/quasi-brittle transition in dynamic fracture: An energetic signature
Authors:
Julien Scheibert,
Claudia Guerra,
Fabrice Célarié,
Davy Dalmas,
Daniel Bonamy
Abstract:
Dynamic fracture experiments were performed in PMMA over a wide range of velocities and reveal that the fracture energy exhibits an abrupt 3-folds increase from its value at crack initiation at a well-defined critical velocity, below the one associated to the onset of micro-branching instability. This transition is associated with the appearance of conics patterns on fracture surfaces that, in m…
▽ More
Dynamic fracture experiments were performed in PMMA over a wide range of velocities and reveal that the fracture energy exhibits an abrupt 3-folds increase from its value at crack initiation at a well-defined critical velocity, below the one associated to the onset of micro-branching instability. This transition is associated with the appearance of conics patterns on fracture surfaces that, in many materials, are the signature of damage spreading through the nucleation and growth of microcracks. A simple model allows to relate both the energetic and fractographic measurements. These results suggest that dynamic fracture at low velocities in amorphous materials is controlled by the brittle/quasi-brittle transition studied here.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2010; v1 submitted 16 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Crack propagation through phase separated glasses: effect of the characteristic size of disorder
Authors:
Davy Dalmas,
Anne Lelarge,
Damien Vandembroucq
Abstract:
We perform fracture experiments on nanoscale phase separated glasses and measure crack surface roughness by atomic force microscopy. The ability of tuning the phase domain size by thermal treatment allows us to test thoroughly the predictions of crack font depinning models about the scaling properties of crack surface roughness. It appears that in the range of validity of these depinning models…
▽ More
We perform fracture experiments on nanoscale phase separated glasses and measure crack surface roughness by atomic force microscopy. The ability of tuning the phase domain size by thermal treatment allows us to test thoroughly the predictions of crack font depinning models about the scaling properties of crack surface roughness. It appears that in the range of validity of these depinning models developed for the fracture of brittle materials, our experimental results show a quantitative agreement with theoretical predictions: beyond the characteristic size of disorder, the roughness of crack surfaces obeys the logarithmic scaling early predicted by Ramanathan, Ertas and Fisher (PRL97)
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2009; v1 submitted 27 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
-
Quantitative AFM analysis of phase separated borosilicate glass surfaces
Authors:
Davy Dalmas,
Anne Lelarge,
Damien Vandembroucq
Abstract:
Phase separated borosilicate glass samples were prepared by applying various heat treatments. Using selective chemical etching we performed AFM measurement on the phase separated glass surfaces. A quantitative roughness analysis allowed us to measure precisely the dependence of the characteristic size of the phase domains on heating time and temperature. The experimental measurements are very we…
▽ More
Phase separated borosilicate glass samples were prepared by applying various heat treatments. Using selective chemical etching we performed AFM measurement on the phase separated glass surfaces. A quantitative roughness analysis allowed us to measure precisely the dependence of the characteristic size of the phase domains on heating time and temperature. The experimental measurements are very well described by the theoretically expected scaling laws. Interdiffusion coefficients and activation energy are estimated from this analysis and are consistent with literature data.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Nanoscale damage during fracture in silica glass
Authors:
Daniel Bonamy,
Silke Prades,
Cindy Rountree,
Laurent Ponson,
Davy Dalmas,
Elisabeth Bouchaud,
K. Ravi-Chandar,
Claude Guillot
Abstract:
We report here atomic force microscopy experiments designed to uncover the nature of failure mechanisms occuring within the process zone at the tip of a crack propagating into a silica glass specimen under stress corrosion. The crack propagates through the growth and coalescence of nanoscale damage spots. This cavitation process is shown to be the key mechanism responsible for damage spreading w…
▽ More
We report here atomic force microscopy experiments designed to uncover the nature of failure mechanisms occuring within the process zone at the tip of a crack propagating into a silica glass specimen under stress corrosion. The crack propagates through the growth and coalescence of nanoscale damage spots. This cavitation process is shown to be the key mechanism responsible for damage spreading within the process zone. The possible origin of the nucleation of cavities, as well as the implications on the selection of both the cavity size at coalescence and the process zone extension are finally discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
-
The mechanics of glass and functionalised glass surfaces
Authors:
E. Barthel,
M. Beauvais,
R. Briard,
N. Chemin,
D. Dalmas,
C. Heitz,
M. Klotz,
P. Nael,
A. Perriot,
A. Pinquier,
S. Roux,
L. Serreau,
E. Sondergard,
D. Vandembroucq
Abstract:
Glass is highly sensitive to surface flaws generated by contact. Surface cracks threaten both its mechanical strength and visual aspect. Recent trends in glass functionalisation by grafting or coating lend an even more prominent role to the surface. For these reasons, the glass surface mechanics, which couples surface physico-chemistry with mechanical response, must be considered in details to o…
▽ More
Glass is highly sensitive to surface flaws generated by contact. Surface cracks threaten both its mechanical strength and visual aspect. Recent trends in glass functionalisation by grafting or coating lend an even more prominent role to the surface. For these reasons, the glass surface mechanics, which couples surface physico-chemistry with mechanical response, must be considered in details to optimize glass processing and products. We review a few recent advances in the field of glass surface mechanics, with special emphasis on the local ductility of silicate glasses and the mechanical stability of films and coatings.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Crack fronts and damage in glass at the nanometer scale
Authors:
C. Marliere,
S. Prades,
F. Celarie,
D. Dalmas,
D. Bonamy,
C. Guillot,
E. Bouchaud
Abstract:
We have studied the low speed fracture regime for different glassy materials with variable but controlled length scales of heterogeneity in a carefully mastered surrounding atmosphere. By using optical and atomic force microscopy (AFM) techniques we tracked in real-time the crack tip propagation at the nanometer scale on a wide velocity range (mm/s - pm/s and below). The influence of the heterog…
▽ More
We have studied the low speed fracture regime for different glassy materials with variable but controlled length scales of heterogeneity in a carefully mastered surrounding atmosphere. By using optical and atomic force microscopy (AFM) techniques we tracked in real-time the crack tip propagation at the nanometer scale on a wide velocity range (mm/s - pm/s and below). The influence of the heterogeneities on this velocity is presented and discussed. Our experiments reveal also -for the first time- that the crack progresses through nucleation, growth and coalescence of nanometric damage cavities within the amorphous phase. This may explain the large fluctuations observed in the crack tip velocities for the smallest values. This behaviour is very similar to what is involved, at the micrometric scale, in ductile fracture. The only difference is very likely due to the related length scales (nanometric instead of micrometric). Consequences of such a nano-ductile fracture mode observed at a temperature far below the glass transition temperature in glass is finally discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2003; v1 submitted 28 February, 2003;
originally announced February 2003.
