-
Why every observatory needs a disco ball
Authors:
Robert J. Cumming,
Alexander G. M. Pietrow,
Livia Pietrow,
Maria Cavallius,
Dominique Petit dit de la Roche,
Casper Pietrow,
Ilane Schroetter,
Moa Skan
Abstract:
Commercial disco balls provide a safe, effective and instructive way of observing the Sun. We explore the optics of solar projections with disco balls, and find that while sunspot observations are challenging, the solar disk and its changes during eclipses are easy and fun to observe. We explore the disco ball's potential for observing the moon and other bright astronomical phenomena.
Commercial disco balls provide a safe, effective and instructive way of observing the Sun. We explore the optics of solar projections with disco balls, and find that while sunspot observations are challenging, the solar disk and its changes during eclipses are easy and fun to observe. We explore the disco ball's potential for observing the moon and other bright astronomical phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2023; v1 submitted 25 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The molecular gas reservoir of 6 low-metallicity galaxies from the Herschel Dwarf Galaxy Survey: A ground-based follow-up survey of CO(1-0), CO(2-1), and CO(3-2)
Authors:
D. Cormier,
S. C. Madden,
V. Lebouteiller,
S. Hony,
S. Aalto,
F. Costagliola,
A. Hughes,
A. Rémy-Ruyer,
N. Abel,
E. Bayet,
F. Bigiel,
J. M. Cannon,
R. J. Cumming,
M. Galametz,
F. Galliano,
S. Viti,
R. Wu
Abstract:
We aim to quantify the molecular gas reservoir in a subset of 6 low-metallicity galaxies from the Herschel Dwarf Galaxy Survey with newly acquired CO data, and link this reservoir to the observed star formation activity. We present CO(1-0), CO(2-1), and CO(3-2) observations obtained at the ATNF Mopra 22-m, APEX, and IRAM 30-m telescopes, as well as [CII] 157um and [OI] 63um observations obtained w…
▽ More
We aim to quantify the molecular gas reservoir in a subset of 6 low-metallicity galaxies from the Herschel Dwarf Galaxy Survey with newly acquired CO data, and link this reservoir to the observed star formation activity. We present CO(1-0), CO(2-1), and CO(3-2) observations obtained at the ATNF Mopra 22-m, APEX, and IRAM 30-m telescopes, as well as [CII] 157um and [OI] 63um observations obtained with the Herschel/PACS spectrometer in the 6 galaxies: Haro11, Mrk1089, Mrk930, NGC4861, NGC625, and UM311. We derive molecular gas mass from several methods including the use of the CO-to-H2 conversion factor Xco (both Galactic and metallicity-scaled values) and of dust measurements. The molecular and atomic gas reservoirs are compared to the star formation activity. We also constrain the physical conditions of the molecular clouds using the non-LTE code RADEX and the spectral synthesis code Cloudy. We detect CO in 5 of the 6 galaxies, including first detections in Haro11 (Z~0.4 Zsun), Mrk930 (0.2 Zsun), and UM311 (0.5 Zsun), but CO remains undetected in NGC4861 (0.2 Zsun). The CO luminosities are low while [CII] is bright in these galaxies, resulting in [CII]/CO(1-0)>10000. Our dwarf galaxies are in relatively good agreement with the Schmidt-Kennicutt relation for total gas. They show short molecular depletion time scales, even when considering metallicity-scaled Xco factors. Those galaxies are dominated by their HI gas, except Haro11 which has high star formation efficiency and is dominated by ionized and molecular gas. We determine the mass of each ISM phase in Haro11 using Cloudy and estimate an equivalent Xco factor which is 10 times higher than the Galactic value. Overall, our results confirm the emerging picture that CO suffers from significant selective photodissociation in low-metallicity dwarf galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
SN 2009kn - the twin of the Type IIn supernova 1994W
Authors:
E. Kankare,
M. Ergon,
F. Bufano,
J. Spyromilio,
S. Mattila,
N. N. Chugai,
P. Lundqvist,
A. Pastorello,
R. Kotak,
S. Benetti,
M. -T. Botticella,
R. J. Cumming,
C. Fransson,
M. Fraser,
G. Leloudas,
M. Miluzio,
J. Sollerman,
M. Stritzinger,
M. Turatto,
S. Valenti
Abstract:
We present an optical and near-infrared photometric and spectroscopic study of supernova (SN) 2009kn spanning ~1.5 yr from the discovery. The optical spectra are dominated by the narrow (full width at half-maximum ~1000 km s^-1) Balmer lines distinctive of a Type IIn SN with P Cygni profiles. Contrarily, the photometric evolution resembles more that of a Type IIP SN with a large drop in luminosity…
▽ More
We present an optical and near-infrared photometric and spectroscopic study of supernova (SN) 2009kn spanning ~1.5 yr from the discovery. The optical spectra are dominated by the narrow (full width at half-maximum ~1000 km s^-1) Balmer lines distinctive of a Type IIn SN with P Cygni profiles. Contrarily, the photometric evolution resembles more that of a Type IIP SN with a large drop in luminosity at the end of the plateau phase. These characteristics are similar to those of SN 1994W, whose nature has been explained with two different models with different approaches. The well-sampled data set on SN 2009kn offers the possibility to test these models, in the case of both SN 2009kn and SN 1994W. We associate the narrow P Cygni lines with a swept-up shell composed of circumstellar matter and SN ejecta. The broad emission line wings, seen during the plateau phase, arise from internal electron scattering in this shell. The slope of the light curve after the post-plateau drop is fairly consistent with that expected from the radioactive decay of 56Co, suggesting an SN origin for SN 2009kn. Assuming radioactivity to be the main source powering the light curve of SN 2009kn in the tail phase, we infer an upper limit for 56Ni mass of 0.023 M_sun. This is significantly higher than that estimated for SN 1994W, which also showed a much steeper decline of the light curve after the post-plateau drop. We also observe late-time near-infrared emission which most likely arises from newly formed dust produced by SN 2009kn. As with SN 1994W, no broad lines are observed in the spectra of SN 2009kn, not even in the late-time tail phase.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2012; v1 submitted 2 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Stellar kinematics in blue compact galaxies
Authors:
Robert J. Cumming,
Göran Östlin,
Thomas Marquart,
Kambiz Fathi,
Nils Bergvall,
Angela Adamo
Abstract:
In a programme of observations of local luminous blue compact galaxies (BCGs), we are investigating kinematics by using tracers of both stars and ionized gas. Here we summarise our program and present new data on the local Lyman break galaxy analogue Haro 11. From spatially-resolved spectroscopy around the near-infrared Ca II triplet, we find that its stars and ionized gas have similar velocity…
▽ More
In a programme of observations of local luminous blue compact galaxies (BCGs), we are investigating kinematics by using tracers of both stars and ionized gas. Here we summarise our program and present new data on the local Lyman break galaxy analogue Haro 11. From spatially-resolved spectroscopy around the near-infrared Ca II triplet, we find that its stars and ionized gas have similar velocity fields. Our programme so far indicates however that emission line velocities can differ locally by a few tens of km/s from the Ca II values. Comparing our data to simple stellar population models, we assess which stellar population the Ca II triplet traces and its potential beyond the local universe.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Stellar dynamics of blue compact galaxies. II. Further indications of a merger in ESO 338-IG04
Authors:
Robert J. Cumming,
Kambiz Fathi,
Göran Östlin,
Thomas Marquart,
Isabel Marquez,
Josefa Masegosa,
Nils Bergvall,
Philippe Amram
Abstract:
Luminous blue compact galaxies, common at z~1 but now relatively rare, show disturbed kinematics in emission lines. As part of a programme to understand their formation and evolution, we have investigated the stellar dynamics of a number of nearby objects in this class. We obtained long-slit spectra with VLT/FORS2 in the spectral region covering the near-infrared calcium triplet. In this paper w…
▽ More
Luminous blue compact galaxies, common at z~1 but now relatively rare, show disturbed kinematics in emission lines. As part of a programme to understand their formation and evolution, we have investigated the stellar dynamics of a number of nearby objects in this class. We obtained long-slit spectra with VLT/FORS2 in the spectral region covering the near-infrared calcium triplet. In this paper we focus on the well-known luminous blue compact galaxy ESO 338-IG04 (Tololo 1924-416). A previous investigation, using Fabry-Perot interferometry, showed that this galaxy has a chaotic H-alpha velocity field, indicating that either the galaxy is not in dynamical equilibrium or that H-alpha does not trace the gravitational potential due to feedback from star formation. Along the apparent major axis, the stellar and ionised gas velocities for the most part follow each other. The chaotic velocity field must therefore be a sign that the young stellar population in ESO 338-IG04 is not in dynamical equilibrium. The most likely explanation, which is also supported by its morphology, is that the galaxy has experienced a merger and that this has triggered the current starburst. Summarising the results of our programme so far, we note that emission-line velocity fields are not always reliable tracers of stellar motions, and go on to assess the implications for kinematic studies of similar galaxies at intermediate redshift.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2007; v1 submitted 24 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Star-gas decoupling and a non-rotating stellar core in He 2-10: Integral field spectroscopy with FLAMES/ARGUS
Authors:
T. Marquart,
K. Fathi,
G. Östlin,
N. Bergvall,
R. J. Cumming,
P. Amram
Abstract:
We study the two-dimensional distribution and kinematics of the stellar and gaseous components in the centre of the blue compact dwarf galaxy, He 2-10. The aim is to compare the kinematics of gas and stars in order to determine whether they are consistent with one another, or if stars and gas can be decoupled due to gravitational perturbations and feedback from star formation. We have used the i…
▽ More
We study the two-dimensional distribution and kinematics of the stellar and gaseous components in the centre of the blue compact dwarf galaxy, He 2-10. The aim is to compare the kinematics of gas and stars in order to determine whether they are consistent with one another, or if stars and gas can be decoupled due to gravitational perturbations and feedback from star formation. We have used the integral field unit ARGUS, part of FLAMES on the European Southern Observatory's Very Large Telescope, to target the near-infrared Ca-triplet in the central 300 times 480 parsecs of He 2-10. The selected wavelength regime includes several prominent spectral features, including the Paschen series and an [SIII] emission-line, which we have used to derive the kinematics of the ionised interstellar medium. We find no systematic trend in the velocities of the stars over the observed field of view and conclude that the stellar kinematics is governed by random motions. This is in contrast to the motions the ionised interstellar medium, where we find spatial velocity variations up to 60 km/s. Our gas velocity field is consistent with previous studies of both the molecular gas and the feedback-driven outflow in He 2-10. We interpret the kinematic decoupling between the stars and the gas as He 2-10 being in the process of transformation to a dwarf elliptical galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Dynamical masses of two young globular clusters in the blue compact galaxy ESO 338-IG04
Authors:
Goran Ostlin,
Robert J. Cumming,
Nils Bergvall
Abstract:
We present high-resolution echelle spectroscopy, obtained with the UVES spectrograph on ESO/VLT, of two luminous star clusters in the metal-poor blue compact galaxy ESO 338-IG04 at a distance of 37.5 Mpc. Cross-correlating with template stars, we obtain line-of-sight velocity dispersions of 33 and 17 km/s. By combining with size estimates from Hubble Space Telescope images we infer dynamical mas…
▽ More
We present high-resolution echelle spectroscopy, obtained with the UVES spectrograph on ESO/VLT, of two luminous star clusters in the metal-poor blue compact galaxy ESO 338-IG04 at a distance of 37.5 Mpc. Cross-correlating with template stars, we obtain line-of-sight velocity dispersions of 33 and 17 km/s. By combining with size estimates from Hubble Space Telescope images we infer dynamical masses of 1.3x10^7 and 4.0x10^6 solar masses for the two clusters, making them among the most massive known. The less massive cluster is the faintest cluster for which a dynamical mass has yet been obtained. In both clusters we detect Balmer absorption lines which we use to estimate their ages.
From the younger (~6 Myr) and more massive cluster, we detect He II 4686 emission of intermediate width, indicating the presence of very massive O-stars. Moreover, analysis of the [O III] 5007 and H-alpha emission lines from the region near the younger cluster indicates that it is associated with a bubble expanding at ~40 km/s. We also see from the Na I D absorption lines indications of neutral gas flows towards the younger cluster. We compare the dynamical masses with those derived from photometry and discuss implications for the stellar initial mass function (IMF) in each cluster. Both clusters are compatible with rather normal IMFs which will favour their long-term survival and evolution into massive bona fide globular clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
The type IIn supernova 1994W: evidence for the explosive ejection of a circumstellar envelope
Authors:
Nikolai N. Chugai,
Sergei I. Blinnikov,
Robert J. Cumming,
Peter Lundqvist,
Angela Bragaglia,
Alexei V. Filippenko,
Douglas C. Leonard,
Thomas Matheson,
Jesper Sollerman
Abstract:
We present and analyse spectra of the Type IIn supernova 1994W obtained between 18 and 203 days after explosion. During the luminous phase (first 100 d) the line profiles are composed of three major components: (i) narrow P-Cygni lines with the absorption minima at -700 km/s; (ii) broad emission lines with BVZI ~4000 km/s; and (iii) broad, smooth wings, most apparent in H-alpha. These components…
▽ More
We present and analyse spectra of the Type IIn supernova 1994W obtained between 18 and 203 days after explosion. During the luminous phase (first 100 d) the line profiles are composed of three major components: (i) narrow P-Cygni lines with the absorption minima at -700 km/s; (ii) broad emission lines with BVZI ~4000 km/s; and (iii) broad, smooth wings, most apparent in H-alpha. These components are identified with an expanding circumstellar (CS) envelope, shocked cool gas in the forward post-shock region, and multiple Thomson scattering in the CS envelope, respectively. The absence of broad P-Cygni lines from the supernova is the result of the formation of an optically thick, cool, dense shell at the interface of the ejecta and the CS envelope. We model the supernova deceleration and Thomson scattering wings to recover the density, radial extent and Thomson optical depth of the CS envelope during the first month. We reproduce the light curve with a hydrodynamical model and find it to be powered by a combination of internal energy leakage after the explosion of an extended pre-supernova (~10^15 cm) and luminosity from circumstellar interaction. We recover the pre-explosion kinematics of the CS envelope: it is close to homologous expansion with outer velocity ~1100 km/s and a kinematic age of ~1.5 yr. The CS envelope's high mass and kinetic energy, combined with its small age, strongly suggest that the CS envelope was explosively ejected about 1.5 yr before the supernova explosion.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2004;
originally announced May 2004.
-
Stellar dynamics of blue compact galaxies: I. Decoupled star-gas kinematics in ESO 400-G43
Authors:
G. Ostlin,
R. J. Cumming,
P. Amram,
N. Bergvall,
D. Kunth,
I. Marquez,
J. Masegosa,
E. Zackrisson
Abstract:
In this letter we present the first results from a program aimed at measuring the stellar kinematics of blue compact galaxies by observing the near-infrared Calcium triplet. We show the first results for ESO 400-G43 based on deep VLT/FORS2 spectroscopy. The instabilities found in the central gaseous velocity field are not seen in the solid body stellar rotation curve, indicating that stars and g…
▽ More
In this letter we present the first results from a program aimed at measuring the stellar kinematics of blue compact galaxies by observing the near-infrared Calcium triplet. We show the first results for ESO 400-G43 based on deep VLT/FORS2 spectroscopy. The instabilities found in the central gaseous velocity field are not seen in the solid body stellar rotation curve, indicating that stars and gas are kinematically decoupled in this galaxy. Even if this galaxy has a perturbed gaseous velocity field, the stellar velocity dispersion on average agrees well with that derived from the nebular lines.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
SN 1994W: evidence of explosive mass ejection a few years before explosion
Authors:
Nikolai N. Chugai,
Robert J. Cumming,
Sergei I. Blinnikov,
Peter Lundqvist,
Alexei V. Filippenko,
Aaron J. Barth,
Angela Bragaglia,
Douglas C. Leonard,
Thomas Matheson,
Jesper Sollerman
Abstract:
We present and analyse spectra of the Type IIn supernova 1994W obtained between 18 and 202 days after explosion. During the first 100 days the line profiles are composed of three major components: (i) narrow P Cygni lines with absorption minima at -700 km/s; (ii) broad emission lines with BVZI ~4000 km/s; (iii) broad wings most apparent in H-alpha. These components are identified with the expand…
▽ More
We present and analyse spectra of the Type IIn supernova 1994W obtained between 18 and 202 days after explosion. During the first 100 days the line profiles are composed of three major components: (i) narrow P Cygni lines with absorption minima at -700 km/s; (ii) broad emission lines with BVZI ~4000 km/s; (iii) broad wings most apparent in H-alpha. These components are identified with the expanding circumstellar (CS) envelope (Sollerman, Cumming & Lundqvist 1998), shocked cool gas in the forward postshock region, and multiple Thomson scattering in the CS envelope, respectively. The absence of broad P Cygni lines from the supernova (SN) is the result of the formation of an optically thick, cool, dense shell at the interface of the ejecta and the CS envelope. Models of the SN deceleration and Thomson scattering wings are used to recover the Thomson optical depth of the CS envelope and its radial extent, 4E15 cm. The light curve, which we reproduce by a hydrodynamical model, is powered by a combination of internal energy leakage after the explosion of an extended presupernova (~1E15 cm) and luminosity from circumstellar interaction. We recover the pre-explosion kinematics of the CS envelope and find it to be close to homologous expansion with outmost velocity ~1100 km/s and a kinematic age of \~1.5 yr. The high mass and kinetic energy of the CS envelope strongly suggest that the CS envelope was explosively ejected only a few years before explosion.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.
-
A very low mass of Ni-56 in the ejecta of SN 1994W
Authors:
Jesper Sollerman,
Robert J. Cumming,
Peter Lundqvist
Abstract:
We present spectroscopic and photometric observations of the luminous narrow- line Type IIP (plateau) supernova 1994W. After the plateau phase (t >120 days), the light curve dropped by 3.5 mag in V in only 12 days. Between 125 and 197 days after explosion the supernova faded substantially faster than the decay rate of Co-56, and by day 197 it was 3.6 magnitudes less luminous in R compared to SN…
▽ More
We present spectroscopic and photometric observations of the luminous narrow- line Type IIP (plateau) supernova 1994W. After the plateau phase (t >120 days), the light curve dropped by 3.5 mag in V in only 12 days. Between 125 and 197 days after explosion the supernova faded substantially faster than the decay rate of Co-56, and by day 197 it was 3.6 magnitudes less luminous in R compared to SN 1987A. The low R-luminosity could indicate less than 0.0026 {+0.0017}/ {-0.0011} Msun of Ni-56 ejected at the explosion, but the emission between 125 and 197 days must then have been dominated by an additional power source, pre- sumably circumstellar interaction. Alternatively, the late light curve was dominated by Co-56 decay. In this case, the mass of the ejected Ni-56 was 0.015 {+0.012}/{-0.008} Msun, and the rapid fading between 125 and 197 days was most likely due to dust formation. Though this value of the mass is higher than in the case with the additional power source, it is still lower than estimated for any previous Type II supernova. Only progenitors with M(ZAMS) = 8-10 Msun and M(ZAMS) > 25 Msun are expected to eject such low masses of Ni-56. If M(ZAMS) = 8-10 Msun, the plateau phase indicates a low explosion energy, while for a progenitor with M(ZAMS) > 25 Msun the energy can be the canonical 1.0E{51} ergs. As SN 1994W was unusually luminous, the low-mass explosion may require an uncomfortably high efficiency in converting explosion energy into radiation. This favors a M(ZAMS) > 25 Msun progenitor. The supernova's narrow (roughly 1000 km s^{-1}) emission lines were excited by the hot supernova spectrum, rather than a circumstellar shock. The thin shell from which the lines origi- nated was most likely accelerated by the radiation from the supernova.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 1997;
originally announced September 1997.
-
Supernova progenitor constraints from circumstellar interaction: Type II
Authors:
Robert J. Cumming,
Peter Lundqvist
Abstract:
All types of supernovae (SNe), except Type Ia, have been observed to interact with their immediate circumstellar medium (CSM). This interaction can reveal their progenitor's histories, and constrain our ideas about the evolution of massive stars. As examples of the latest progress in this areas, we present some new results on two SNe: a 3D picture of the triple-ring nebula around SN 1987A, and o…
▽ More
All types of supernovae (SNe), except Type Ia, have been observed to interact with their immediate circumstellar medium (CSM). This interaction can reveal their progenitor's histories, and constrain our ideas about the evolution of massive stars. As examples of the latest progress in this areas, we present some new results on two SNe: a 3D picture of the triple-ring nebula around SN 1987A, and observations of the less well-known but rather intriguing SN 1994W. In the process we introduce Type IIn supernovae (SN IIn; Schlegel 1990) as an important new probe of massive star evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
Supernova progenitor constraints from circumstellar interaction: Type Ia
Authors:
Peter Lundqvist,
Robert J. Cumming
Abstract:
Searching for the presence of a circumstellar medium is a direct observational way to discriminate between different types of progenitor systems for Type Ia supernovae. We have modeled whether such gas may give rise to detectable emission, especially in H-alpha, and compare the models with observations of SN 1994D. We obtain a mass loss rate less than about 2.5 10^{-5} solar masses per year for…
▽ More
Searching for the presence of a circumstellar medium is a direct observational way to discriminate between different types of progenitor systems for Type Ia supernovae. We have modeled whether such gas may give rise to detectable emission, especially in H-alpha, and compare the models with observations of SN 1994D. We obtain a mass loss rate less than about 2.5 10^{-5} solar masses per year for a wind speed of 10 km/s. We find that X-ray observations in the range 5-10 keV, e.g., with AXAF, provide the most useful limits on the mass loss, while high-resolution optical spectroscopy offers the only direct way of identifying circumstellar hydrogen.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
Circumstellar H-alpha from SN 1994D and future Type Ia supernovae: an observational test of progenitor models
Authors:
R. J. Cumming,
P. Lundqvist,
L. J. Smith,
M. Pettini,
D. L. King
Abstract:
Searching for the presence of circumstellar material is currently the only direct way to discriminate between the different types of possible progenitor systems for Type Ia supernovae. We have therefore looked for narrow H-alpha in a high-resolution spectrum of the normal Type Ia supernova 1994D taken 10 days before maximum and only 6.5 days after explosion. We derive an upper limit of 2.0E-16 e…
▽ More
Searching for the presence of circumstellar material is currently the only direct way to discriminate between the different types of possible progenitor systems for Type Ia supernovae. We have therefore looked for narrow H-alpha in a high-resolution spectrum of the normal Type Ia supernova 1994D taken 10 days before maximum and only 6.5 days after explosion. We derive an upper limit of 2.0E-16 erg cm^{-2} s^{-1} for an unresolved emission line at the local H II region velocity. To estimate the limit this puts on wind density, we have made time-dependent photoionization calculations. Assuming spherical symmetry we find an upper limit of the mass loss rate which is roughly 1.5E-5 solar masses per year for a wind speed of 10 km s^{-1}. This limit can exclude only the highest-mass-loss-rate symbiotic systems as progenitors. We discuss the effect of asymmetry and assess the relative merits of early optical, radio and X-ray limits in constraining mass loss from Type Ia progenitors. We find that X-ray observations can probably provide the most useful limits on the progenitor mass loss, while high-resolution optical spectroscopy offers our only chance of actually identifying circumstellar hydrogen.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
An Observational Limit on Circumstellar H-Alpha from Supernova 1994D
Authors:
R. J. Cumming,
P. Lundqvist,
L. J. Smith,
M. Pettini,
D. L. King
Abstract:
We searched for narrow H$α$ in a high-resolution spectrum of SN 1994D taken 10 days before maximum, and found none. We estimate the limit this places on the progenitor mass loss, and find that it is competitive with recent radio limits, and excludes the highest-mass-loss-rate symbiotic systems as possible progenitors of the normal Type Ia SN 1994D.
We searched for narrow H$α$ in a high-resolution spectrum of SN 1994D taken 10 days before maximum, and found none. We estimate the limit this places on the progenitor mass loss, and find that it is competitive with recent radio limits, and excludes the highest-mass-loss-rate symbiotic systems as possible progenitors of the normal Type Ia SN 1994D.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 1995;
originally announced December 1995.
