-
Spin-Hall effect in topological materials: Evaluating the proper spin current in systems with arbitrary degeneracies
Authors:
Hongyang Ma,
James H. Cullen,
Serajum Monir,
Rajib Rahman,
Dimitrie Culcer
Abstract:
The spin-Hall effect underpins some of the most active topics in modern physics, including spin torques and the inverse spin-Hall effect, yet it lacks a proper theoretical description. This makes it difficult to differentiate the SHE from other mechanisms, as well as differentiate band structure and disorder contributions. Here, by exploiting recent analytical breakthroughs in the understanding of…
▽ More
The spin-Hall effect underpins some of the most active topics in modern physics, including spin torques and the inverse spin-Hall effect, yet it lacks a proper theoretical description. This makes it difficult to differentiate the SHE from other mechanisms, as well as differentiate band structure and disorder contributions. Here, by exploiting recent analytical breakthroughs in the understanding of the intrinsic spin-Hall effect, we devise a density functional theory method for evaluating the conserved (proper) spin current in a generic system. Spin non-conservation makes the conventional spin current physically meaningless, while the conserved spin current has been challenging to evaluate since it involves the position operator between Bloch bands. The novel method we introduce here can handle band structures with arbitrary degeneracies and incorporates all matrix elements of the position operator, including the notoriously challenging diagonal elements, which are associated with Fermi surface, group velocity, and dipolar effects but often diverge if not treated correctly. We apply this method to the most important classes of spin-Hall materials: topological insulators, 2D quantum spin-Hall insulators, non-collinear antiferromagnets, and strongly spin-orbit coupled metals. We demonstrate that the torque dipole systematically suppresses contributions to the conventional spin current such that, the proper spin current is generally smaller in magnitude and often has a different sign. Remarkably, its energy-dependence is relatively flat and featureless, and its magnitude is comparable in all classes of materials studied. These findings will guide the experiment in characterizing charge-to-spin interconversion in spintronic and orbitronic devices. We also discuss briefly a potential generalisation of the method to calculate extrinsic spin currents generated by disorder scattering.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Spin-Hall effect due to the bulk states of topological insulators: Extrinsic contribution to the conserved spin current
Authors:
James H. Cullen,
Dimitrie Culcer
Abstract:
The substantial amount of recent research into spin torques has been accompanied by a revival of interest in the spin-Hall effect. This effect contributes to the spin torque in many materials, including topological insulator/ferromagnet devices, Weyl semimetals, and van der Waals heterostructures. In general the relative sizes of competing spin torque mechanisms remain poorly understood. Whereas a…
▽ More
The substantial amount of recent research into spin torques has been accompanied by a revival of interest in the spin-Hall effect. This effect contributes to the spin torque in many materials, including topological insulator/ferromagnet devices, Weyl semimetals, and van der Waals heterostructures. In general the relative sizes of competing spin torque mechanisms remain poorly understood. Whereas a consensus is beginning to emerge on the evaluation of a conserved spin current, the role of extrinsic disorder mechanisms in the spin-Hall effect has not been clarified. In this work we present a comprehensive calculation of the extrinsic spin Hall effect while focussing on the bulk states of topological insulators as a prototype system and employing a fully quantum mechanical formalism to calculate the proper spin current. Our calculation of the proper spin current employs a 4x4 k.p Hamiltonian describing the bulk states of topological insulators. At the same time, we provide a qualitative explanation of the proper spin currents calculated based on an effective $2\times2$ Hamiltonian obtained via a Schrieffer-Wolf transformation. We find that the extrinsic contribution to the proper spin current, driven by side jump, skew scattering and related mechanisms, is of a comparable magnitude to the intrinsic contribution, making it vital to take such disorder effects into account when seeking to understand experiments. Among the scattering effects considered, side jump scattering is the primary contributor to the extrinsic spin Hall effect. The total spin susceptibility calculated here is too small to explain experimentally measured spin torques, hence we expect the spin Hall effect to make a negligible contribution to the spin torque in topological insulator structures.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Spin-orbit torques due to topological insulator surface states: an in-plane magnetization as a probe of extrinsic spin-orbit scattering
Authors:
Mohsen Farokhnezhad,
James H. Cullen,
Dimitrie Culcer
Abstract:
Topological insulator (TI) surface states exert strong spin-orbit torques. When the magnetization is in the plane its interaction with the TI conduction electrons is non-trivial, and is influenced by extrinsic spin-orbit scattering. This is expected to be strong in TIs but is difficult to calculate and to measure unambiguously. Here we show that extrinsic spin-orbit scattering sizably renormalizes…
▽ More
Topological insulator (TI) surface states exert strong spin-orbit torques. When the magnetization is in the plane its interaction with the TI conduction electrons is non-trivial, and is influenced by extrinsic spin-orbit scattering. This is expected to be strong in TIs but is difficult to calculate and to measure unambiguously. Here we show that extrinsic spin-orbit scattering sizably renormalizes the surface state spin-orbit torque resulting in a strong density dependence. The magnitude of the renormalization of the spin torque and the effect of spin-orbit scattering on the relative sizes of the in-plane and out-of-plane field-like torques have strong implications for experiment: We propose two separate experimental signatures for the measurement of its presence.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2024; v1 submitted 21 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Topological nature of the proper spin current and the spin-Hall torque
Authors:
Hong Liu,
James H. Cullen,
Dimitrie Culcer
Abstract:
Spin currents are key to spin torque devices, but determining the proper spin current is non-trivial. Here we derive a general quantum-mechanical formula for the intrinsic proper spin current showing that it is topological and can be finite in the gap. For topological insulators with an out of plane magnetization and the chemical potential in the surface state gap, the net spin torque is determine…
▽ More
Spin currents are key to spin torque devices, but determining the proper spin current is non-trivial. Here we derive a general quantum-mechanical formula for the intrinsic proper spin current showing that it is topological and can be finite in the gap. For topological insulators with an out of plane magnetization and the chemical potential in the surface state gap, the net spin torque is determined by the competition between the topological spin-Hall torque due to the bulk and the topological Edelstein effect due to the surface states. We also discuss spin-3/2 hole quantum wells.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2023; v1 submitted 23 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Spin transfer torques due to the bulk states of topological insulators
Authors:
James H. Cullen,
Rhonald Burgos Atencia,
Dimitrie Culcer
Abstract:
Spin torques at topological insulator (TI)/ferromagnet interfaces have received considerable attention in recent years with a view towards achieving full electrical manipulation of magnetic degrees of freedom. The most important question in this field concerns the relative contributions of bulk and surface states to the spin torque, a matter that remains incompletely understood. Whereas the surfac…
▽ More
Spin torques at topological insulator (TI)/ferromagnet interfaces have received considerable attention in recent years with a view towards achieving full electrical manipulation of magnetic degrees of freedom. The most important question in this field concerns the relative contributions of bulk and surface states to the spin torque, a matter that remains incompletely understood. Whereas the surface state contribution has been extensively studied, the contribution due to the bulk states has received comparatively little attention. Here we study spin torques due to TI bulk states and show that: (i) There is no spin-orbit torque due to the bulk states on a homogeneous magnetisation, in contrast to the surface states, which give rise to a spin-orbit torque via the well-known Edelstein effect. (ii) The bulk states give rise to a spin transfer torque (STT) due to the inhomogeneity of the magnetisation in the vicinity of the interface. This spin transfer torque, which has not been considered in TIs in the past, is somewhat unconventional since it arises from the interplay of the bulk TI spin-orbit coupling and the gradient of the monotonically decaying magnetisation inside the TI. Whereas we consider an idealised model in which the magnetisation gradient is small and the spin transfer torque is correspondingly small, we argue that in real samples the spin transfer torque should be sizable and may provide the dominant contribution due to the bulk states. We show that an experimental smoking gun for identifying the bulk states is the fact that the field-like component of the spin transfer torque generates a spin density with the same size but opposite sign for in-plane and out-of-plane magnetisations. This distinguishes them from the surface states, which are expected to give a spin density of a similar size and the same sign for both an in-plane and out-of-plane magnetisations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2023; v1 submitted 20 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Generating a topological anomalous Hall effect in a non-magnetic conductor
Authors:
James H. Cullen,
Pankaj Bhalla,
Elizabeth Marcellina,
Alexander R. Hamilton,
Dimitrie Culcer
Abstract:
The ordinary Hall effect is driven by the Lorentz force, while its anomalous counterpart occurs in ferromagnets. Here we show that the Berry curvature monopole of non-magnetic 2D spin-3/2 holes leads to a novel Hall effect linear in an applied in-plane magnetic field B_x. There is no Lorentz force hence no ordinary Hall effect, while all disorder contributions vanish to leading order in B_x. This…
▽ More
The ordinary Hall effect is driven by the Lorentz force, while its anomalous counterpart occurs in ferromagnets. Here we show that the Berry curvature monopole of non-magnetic 2D spin-3/2 holes leads to a novel Hall effect linear in an applied in-plane magnetic field B_x. There is no Lorentz force hence no ordinary Hall effect, while all disorder contributions vanish to leading order in B_x. This intrinsic phenomenon, which we term the anomalous planar Hall effect (APHE), provides a non-quantized footprint of topological transport directly accessible in p-type semiconductors.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Optimal operation points for ultrafast, highly coherent Ge hole spin-orbit qubits
Authors:
Zhanning Wang,
Elizabeth Marcellina,
A. R. Hamilton,
James H. Cullen,
Sven Rogge,
Joe Salfi,
Dimitrie Culcer
Abstract:
Strong spin-orbit interactions make hole quantum dots central to the quest for electrical spin qubit manipulation enabling fast, low-power, scalable quantum computation. Yet it is important to establish to what extent spin-orbit coupling exposes qubits to electrical noise, facilitating decoherence. Here, taking Ge as an example, we show that group IV gate-defined hole spin qubits generically exhib…
▽ More
Strong spin-orbit interactions make hole quantum dots central to the quest for electrical spin qubit manipulation enabling fast, low-power, scalable quantum computation. Yet it is important to establish to what extent spin-orbit coupling exposes qubits to electrical noise, facilitating decoherence. Here, taking Ge as an example, we show that group IV gate-defined hole spin qubits generically exhibit optimal operation points, defined by the top gate electric field, at which they are both fast and long-lived: the dephasing rate vanishes to first order in electric field noise along all directions in space, the electron dipole spin resonance strength is maximised, while relaxation is drastically reduced at small magnetic fields. The existence of optimal operation points is traced to group IV crystal symmetry and properties of the Rashba spin-orbit interaction unique to spin-3/2 systems. Our results overturn the conventional wisdom that fast operation implies reduced lifetimes, and suggest group IV hole spin qubits as ideal platforms for ultra-fast, highly coherent scalable quantum computing.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2021; v1 submitted 25 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.