-
The Equitable AI Research Roundtable (EARR): Towards Community-Based Decision Making in Responsible AI Development
Authors:
Jamila Smith-Loud,
Andrew Smart,
Darlene Neal,
Amber Ebinama,
Eric Corbett,
Paul Nicholas,
Qazi Rashid,
Anne Peckham,
Sarah Murphy-Gray,
Nicole Morris,
Elisha Smith Arrillaga,
Nicole-Marie Cotton,
Emnet Almedom,
Olivia Araiza,
Eliza McCullough,
Abbie Langston,
Christopher Nellum
Abstract:
This paper reports on our initial evaluation of The Equitable AI Research Roundtable -- a coalition of experts in law, education, community engagement, social justice, and technology. EARR was created in collaboration among a large tech firm, nonprofits, NGO research institutions, and universities to provide critical research based perspectives and feedback on technology's emergent ethical and soc…
▽ More
This paper reports on our initial evaluation of The Equitable AI Research Roundtable -- a coalition of experts in law, education, community engagement, social justice, and technology. EARR was created in collaboration among a large tech firm, nonprofits, NGO research institutions, and universities to provide critical research based perspectives and feedback on technology's emergent ethical and social harms. Through semi-structured workshops and discussions within the large tech firm, EARR has provided critical perspectives and feedback on how to conceptualize equity and vulnerability as they relate to AI technology. We outline three principles in practice of how EARR has operated thus far that are especially relevant to the concerns of the FAccT community: how EARR expands the scope of expertise in AI development, how it fosters opportunities for epistemic curiosity and responsibility, and that it creates a space for mutual learning. This paper serves as both an analysis and translation of lessons learned through this engagement approach, and the possibilities for future research.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
The optical morphology of A3667 re-examined
Authors:
M. Johnston-Hollitt,
R. W. Hunstead,
E. Corbett
Abstract:
The galaxy cluster A3667 was observed using the Two-degree Field (2dF) multifibre spectroscopic system on the Anglo-Australian Telescope in a program designed to examine the velocity structure in the region. Specifically, we sought evidence from the optical data for the putative cluster merger believed to be responsible for the observed radio and X-ray emission. We present 184 new redshifts in t…
▽ More
The galaxy cluster A3667 was observed using the Two-degree Field (2dF) multifibre spectroscopic system on the Anglo-Australian Telescope in a program designed to examine the velocity structure in the region. Specifically, we sought evidence from the optical data for the putative cluster merger believed to be responsible for the observed radio and X-ray emission. We present 184 new redshifts in the region, of which 143 correspond to member galaxies of A3667. We find the cluster velocity distribution to be well modelled by a single Gaussian in agreement with previous results. In addition, new redshift-selected isodensity plots significantly reduce the prominence of the previously reported subgroup to the north-west of the main cluster. Instead, we find the galaxy distribution to be elongated and well mixed, with a high velocity dispersion and no significant evidence for substructure. These results are consistent with the axis of the proposed merger being close to the plane of the sky.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Equatorial scattering and the structure of the broad-line region in Seyfert nuclei: evidence for a rotating disc
Authors:
J. E. Smith,
A. Robinson,
S. Young,
D. J. Axon,
Elizabeth A. Corbett
Abstract:
We present detailed scattering models confirming that distinctive variations in polarization across the broad Halpha line, which are observed in a significant fraction of Seyfert 1 galaxies, can be understood in terms of a rotating line-emitting disc surrounded by a co-planar scattering region (the equatorial scattering region). The predicted polarization properties are: averaged over wavelength…
▽ More
We present detailed scattering models confirming that distinctive variations in polarization across the broad Halpha line, which are observed in a significant fraction of Seyfert 1 galaxies, can be understood in terms of a rotating line-emitting disc surrounded by a co-planar scattering region (the equatorial scattering region). The predicted polarization properties are: averaged over wavelength, the position angle of polarization is aligned with the projected disc rotation axis and hence also with the radio source axis; (ii) the polarization PA rotates across the line profile, reaching equal but opposite (relative to the continuum PA) rotations in the blue and red wings; (iii) the degree of polarization peaks in the line wings and passes through a minimum in the line core. We identify 11 objects which exhibit these features to different degrees. In order to reproduce the large amplitude PA rotations observed in some cases, the scattering region must closely surround the emission disc and the latter must itself be a relatively narrow annulus -- presumably the Halpha-emitting zone of a larger accretion disc. Asymmetries in the polarization spectra may be attributable to several possible causes, including bulk radial infall in the equatorial scattering region, or contamination by polar scattered light. The broad Halpha lines do not, in general, exhibit double-peaked profiles, suggesting that a second Halpha-emitting component of the broad-line region is present, in addition to the disc.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Near Infrared Spectroscopy of High Redshift Active Galactic Nuclei. II. Disappearing Narrow Line Regions and the Role of Accretion
Authors:
H. Netzer,
O. Shemmer,
R. Maiolino,
E. Oliva,
S. Croom,
E. Corbett,
L. di Fabrizio
Abstract:
We present new near infrared spectroscopic measurements for 29 luminous high-z quasars and use the data to discuss the size and other properties of the NLRs in those sources. The high resolution spectra have been used to carefully model the Fe II blends and to provide reliable [O III], Fe II and Hb measurements. We find that about 2/3 of all high luminosity sources show strong [O III] lines whil…
▽ More
We present new near infrared spectroscopic measurements for 29 luminous high-z quasars and use the data to discuss the size and other properties of the NLRs in those sources. The high resolution spectra have been used to carefully model the Fe II blends and to provide reliable [O III], Fe II and Hb measurements. We find that about 2/3 of all high luminosity sources show strong [O III] lines while the remaining objects show no or very weak such line. While weak [O III] emitters are also found among lower luminosity AGN, we argue that the implications for very high luminosity objects are different. In particular, we suggest that the averaging of these two populations in other works gave rise to claims of a Baldwin relationship in [O III] which is not confirmed by our data. We also argue that earlier proposed relations of the type R_NLR \propto L_[O III]^{1/2}, where R_NLR is the NLR radius, are theoretically sound yet they must break down for R_NLR exceeding a few kpc. This suggests that the NLR properties in luminous sources are different from those observed in nearby AGN. In particular, we suggest that some sources lost their very large, dynamically unbound NLR while others are in a phase of violent star-forming events that produce a large quantity of high density gas in the central kpc. This gas is ionized and excited by the central radiation source and its spectroscopic properties may be different from those observed in nearby, lower luminosity NLRs. We also discuss the dependence of EW(Hb) and Fe II/Hb on L, M_BH, and accretion rate for a large sample of AGNs. The strongest dependence of the two quantities is on the accretion rate and the Fe II/Hb correlation is probably due to the EW(Hb) dependence on accretion rate. We show the most extreme values measured so far of Fe II/Hb and address its correlation with EW([O III]).
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
Near Infrared Spectroscopy of High Redshift Active Galactic Nuclei. I. A Metallicity-Accretion Rate Relationship
Authors:
O. Shemmer,
H. Netzer,
R. Maiolino,
E. Oliva,
S. Croom,
E. Corbett,
L. di Fabrizio
Abstract:
We present new near infrared spectroscopic measurements of the H_beta region for a sample of 29 luminous high redshift quasars. We have measured the width of H_beta in those sources, and added archival H_beta width measurements, to create a sample of 92 active galactic nuclei (AGNs) for which H_beta width and rest-frame UV measurements of N V λ1240 and C IV λ1549 emission-lines are available. Ou…
▽ More
We present new near infrared spectroscopic measurements of the H_beta region for a sample of 29 luminous high redshift quasars. We have measured the width of H_beta in those sources, and added archival H_beta width measurements, to create a sample of 92 active galactic nuclei (AGNs) for which H_beta width and rest-frame UV measurements of N V λ1240 and C IV λ1549 emission-lines are available. Our sample spans six orders of magnitude in luminosity and includes 31 radio-loud AGNs. It also includes 10 narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies and one broad absorption-line quasar. We find that metallicity, indicated by the N V/C IV line ratio, is primarily correlated with accretion rate, which is a function of luminosity and H_beta line-width. This may imply an intimate relation between starburst, responsible for the metal enrichment of the nuclear gas, and AGN fueling, represented by the accretion rate. The correlation of metallicity with luminosity, or black hole (BH) mass, is weaker in contrast with recent results which were based on measurements of the width of C IV. We argue that using C IV as a proxy to H_beta in estimating M_BH might be problematic and lead to spurious BH mass and accretion rate estimates in individual sources. We discuss the potential implications of our new result in the framework of the starburst-AGN connection and theories of BH growth.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
Seyferts on the edge: polar scattering and orientation-dependent polarization in Seyfert 1 nuclei
Authors:
J. E. Smith,
A. Robinson,
D. M. Alexander,
S. Young,
D. J. Axon,
Elizabeth A. Corbett
Abstract:
We have identified 12 Seyfert 1 galaxies that exhibit optical polarization spectra similar to those of Seyfert 2 galaxies in which polarized broad-lines are detected. We present new spectropolarimetric observations of 3 of them: Was 45, Mrk 231 and NGC 3227. These objects appear to be polarized as a result of far-field scattering in the polar illumination cones of the circum-nuclear torus. We es…
▽ More
We have identified 12 Seyfert 1 galaxies that exhibit optical polarization spectra similar to those of Seyfert 2 galaxies in which polarized broad-lines are detected. We present new spectropolarimetric observations of 3 of them: Was 45, Mrk 231 and NGC 3227. These objects appear to be polarized as a result of far-field scattering in the polar illumination cones of the circum-nuclear torus. We estimate that they represent between 10 and 30 per cent of the Seyfert 1 population; they are found amongst all the main spectroscopic sub-types, including narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies. We have shown elsewhere that Seyfert 1 nuclei more commonly have polarization characteristics that can be attributed to scattering by a compact 'equatorial' scattering region located inside the torus. We propose that both equatorial and polar scattering regions are present in all Seyfert galaxies and argue that the observed range of polarization properties can be broadly understood as an orientation effect. In this scheme, polar-scattered Seyfert 1 galaxies represent the transition between unobscured (the majority of type 1) and obscured (type 2) Seyferts. They are viewed through the upper layers of the torus and are thus subject to moderate extinction (Av ~1-4 mag) sufficient to suppress polarized light from the equatorial scattering region, but not the broad wings of the Balmer lines. The orientation of the polarization position angle relative to the radio source is broadly consistent with the two-component scattering model. More generally, we find that amongst Seyferts 1 galaxies, parallel, perpendicular and intermediate orientations of the polarization PA relative to the radio axis occur roughly in the proportions 2:1:1.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2004;
originally announced January 2004.
-
Emission line widths and QSO black hole mass estimates from the 2dF QSO Redshift Survey
Authors:
E. A. Corbett,
S. M. Croom,
B. J. Boyle,
H. Netzer,
L. Miller,
P. J. Outram,
T. Shanks,
R. J. Smith,
K. Rhook
Abstract:
We have used composite spectra generated from more than 22000 QSOs observed in the course of the 2dF and 6dF QSO Redshift Surveys to investigate the relationship between the velocity width of emission lines and QSO luminosity. We find that the velocity width of the broad emission lines Hbeta, Hgamma, MgII, CIII] and CIV are correlated with the continuum luminosity, with a significance of more th…
▽ More
We have used composite spectra generated from more than 22000 QSOs observed in the course of the 2dF and 6dF QSO Redshift Surveys to investigate the relationship between the velocity width of emission lines and QSO luminosity. We find that the velocity width of the broad emission lines Hbeta, Hgamma, MgII, CIII] and CIV are correlated with the continuum luminosity, with a significance of more than 99 per cent. Of the major narrow emission lines ([OIII] 5007, [OII] 3727, NeIII 3870 and NeV 3426) only [OIII] exhibits a significant correlation between line width and luminosity. Assuming that the gas is moving in Keplerian orbits and that the radius of the broad line region is related to the QSO continuum luminosity, we use the velocity widths of the broad lines to derive average black hole masses for the QSOs contributing to the composite spectra. The resultant QSO mass-luminosity relationship is consistent with M ~ L^0.97+-0.16. We find that the correlation between line width and redshift, if present, must be weak, and only CIV shows significant evidence of evolution. This enables us to constrain the redshift evolution of the black hole mass-luminosity ratio to be ~(1+z)^beta with beta ~< 1, much less than the ~(1+z)^3 evolution seen in QSO luminosity evolution. Assuming that the motion of the broad line region gas is Keplerian and that its radius depends on the QSO luminosity, our models indicate that the observed weak redshift dependence is too small for the observed QSO luminosity function to be due to the evolution of a single long-lived population of sources.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2003;
originally announced April 2003.
-
COLA II - Radio and Spectroscopic Diagnostics of Nuclear Activity in Galaxies
Authors:
E. A. Corbett,
L. J. Kewley,
P. N. Appleton,
V. Charmandaris,
M. A. Dopita,
C. A. Heisler,
R. P. Norris,
A. Zezas,
A. Marston
Abstract:
We present optical spectroscopic observations of 93 galaxies taken from the infra-red selected COLA (Compact Objects in Low Power AGN) sample. The sample spans the range of far-IR luminosities from normal galaxies to LIRGs. Of the galaxies observed, 78 (84%) exhibit emission lines. Using a theoretically-based optical emission-line scheme we classify 15% of the emission-line galaxies as Seyferts,…
▽ More
We present optical spectroscopic observations of 93 galaxies taken from the infra-red selected COLA (Compact Objects in Low Power AGN) sample. The sample spans the range of far-IR luminosities from normal galaxies to LIRGs. Of the galaxies observed, 78 (84%) exhibit emission lines. Using a theoretically-based optical emission-line scheme we classify 15% of the emission-line galaxies as Seyferts, 77% as starbursts, and the rest are either borderline AGN/starburst or show ambiguous characteristics. We find little evidence for an increase in the fraction of AGN in the sample as a function of far-IR luminosity but our sample covers only a small range in infrared luminosity and thus a weak trend may be masked. As a whole the Seyfert galaxies exhibit a small, but significant, radio excess on the radio-FIR correlation compared to the galaxies classified as starbursts. Compact (<0.05'') radio cores are detected in 55% of the Seyfert galaxies, and these galaxies exhibit a significantly larger radio excess than the Seyfert galaxies in which cores were not detected. Our results indicate that there may be two distinct populations of Seyferts, ``radio-excess'' Seyferts, which exhibit extended radio structures and compact radio cores, and ``radio-quiet'' Seyferts, in which the majority of the radio emission can be attributed to star-formation in the host galaxy. No significant difference is seen between the IR and optical spectroscopic properties of Seyferts with and without radio cores. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2002;
originally announced October 2002.
-
The correlation of line strength with luminosity and redshift from composite QSO spectra
Authors:
S. M. Croom,
K. Rhook,
E. A. Corbett,
B. J. Boyle,
H. Netzer,
N. S. Loaring,
L. Miller,
P. J. Outram,
T. Shanks,
R. J. Smith
Abstract:
We have generated a series of composite QSO spectra using over 22000 individual low resolution (~8A) QSO spectra obtained from the 2dF (18.25<bj<20.85) and 6dF (16<bj<18.25) QSO Redshift Surveys. The large size of the catalogue has enabled us to construct composite spectra in narrow redshift (dz=0.25) and absolute magnitude (dMb=0.5) bins. The median number of QSOs in each composite is ~200, yie…
▽ More
We have generated a series of composite QSO spectra using over 22000 individual low resolution (~8A) QSO spectra obtained from the 2dF (18.25<bj<20.85) and 6dF (16<bj<18.25) QSO Redshift Surveys. The large size of the catalogue has enabled us to construct composite spectra in narrow redshift (dz=0.25) and absolute magnitude (dMb=0.5) bins. The median number of QSOs in each composite is ~200, yielding typical S/N of ~100. For a given redshift interval, the composite spectra cover a factor of over 25 in luminosity. Using the composite spectra we have measured the equivalent widths (EWs) of the major broad and narrow emission lines, and the CaII K absorption feature due to the host galaxy of the AGN. Assuming a fixed host galaxy spectral energy distribution (SED), the correlation between CaII K EW and luminosity implies Lgal proportional to Lqso**{0.42+-0.05}. We find strong anti-correlations with luminosity for the EWs of [OII] and [NeV]. These provide hints to the general fading of the NLR in high luminosity sources which we attribute to the NLR dimensions becoming larger than the host galaxy. If average AGN host galaxies have SEDs similar to average galaxies, then the observed narrow [OII] emission could be solely due to the host galaxy at low luminosities (M_B~-20). We measure highly significant Baldwin effects for most broad emission lines (CIV, CIII], MgII, Hbeta, Hgamma) and show that they are predominantly due to correlations with luminosity, not redshift. We find that the Hbeta and Hgamma Balmer lines show an inverse Baldwin effect and are positively correlated with luminosity, unlike the broad UV lines. We postulate that this previously unknown effect is due to a luminosity dependent change in the the ratio of disk to non-disk continuum components (abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2002;
originally announced July 2002.
-
A Spectropolarimetric Atlas of Seyfert 1 Galaxies
Authors:
J. E. Smith,
S. Young,
A. Robinson,
E. A. Corbett,
M. E. Giannuzzo,
D. J. Axon,
J. H. Hough
Abstract:
We present optical spectropolarimetry of the nuclei of 36 Seyfert 1 galaxies, obtained with the William Herschel and the Anglo-Australian Telescopes from 1996 to 1999. In 20 of these, the optical emission from the active nucleus is intrinsically polarized. We have measured a significant level of polarization in a further 7 objects but these may be heavily contaminated by Galactic interstellar po…
▽ More
We present optical spectropolarimetry of the nuclei of 36 Seyfert 1 galaxies, obtained with the William Herschel and the Anglo-Australian Telescopes from 1996 to 1999. In 20 of these, the optical emission from the active nucleus is intrinsically polarized. We have measured a significant level of polarization in a further 7 objects but these may be heavily contaminated by Galactic interstellar polarization. The intrinsically polarized Seyfert 1s exhibit a variety of characteristics, with the average polarization ranging from < 0.5 to 5 per cent and many showing variations in both the degree and position angle of polarization across the broad H alpha emission line. We identify a small group of Seyfert 1s that exhibit polarization properties similar to those of Seyfert 2 galaxies in which polarized broad-lines have been discovered. These objects represent direct observational evidence that a Seyfert 2-like far-field polar scattering region is also present in Seyfert 1s. Several other objects have features that can be explained in terms of equatorial scattering of line emission from a rotating disk. We propose that much of the diversity in the polarization properties of Seyfert galaxies can be understood in terms of a model involving both equatorial and polar scattering, the relative importance of the two geometries as sources of polarized light being determined principally by the inclination of the system axis to the line-of-sight.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2002;
originally announced May 2002.
-
GRB 011121: A Massive Star Progenitor
Authors:
P. A. Price,
E. Berger,
D. E. Reichart,
S. R. Kulkarni,
R. Subrahmanyan,
R. M. Wark,
M. H. Wieringa,
D. A. Frail,
J. Bailey,
B. Boyle,
E. Corbett,
K. Gunn,
S. D. Ryder,
N. Seymour,
K. Koviak,
P. McCarthy,
M. Phillips,
T. S. Axelrod,
J. S. Bloom,
S. G. Djorgovski,
D. W. Fox,
T. J. Galama,
F. A. Harrison,
K. Hurley,
R. Sari
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Of the cosmological gamma-ray bursts, GRB 011121 has the lowest redshift, z=0.36. More importantly, the multi-color excess in the afterglow detected in the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) light curves is compelling observational evidence for an underlying supernova. Here we present near-infrared and radio observations of the afterglow. We undertake a comprehensive modeling of these observations and…
▽ More
Of the cosmological gamma-ray bursts, GRB 011121 has the lowest redshift, z=0.36. More importantly, the multi-color excess in the afterglow detected in the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) light curves is compelling observational evidence for an underlying supernova. Here we present near-infrared and radio observations of the afterglow. We undertake a comprehensive modeling of these observations and those reported in the literature and find good evidence favoring a wind-fed circumburst medium. In detail, we infer the progenitor had a mass loss rate of Mdot ~ 10^-7 / v_w3 Mo/yr where v_w3 is the speed of the wind from the progenitor in units of 10^3 km/s. This mass loss rate is similar to that inferred for the progenitor of SN 1998bw which has been associated with GRB 980425. Our data, taken in conjunction with the HST results of Bloom et al. (2002), provide a consistent picture: the long duration GRB 011121 had a massive star progenitor which exploded as a supernova at about the same time as the GRB event.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2002;
originally announced March 2002.
-
First Results from the COLA Project- the Radio-FIR Correlation and Compact Radio Cores in Southern COLA Galaxies
Authors:
E. A. Corbett,
R. P. Norris,
C. A. Heisler,
M. A. Dopita,
P. Appleton,
C. Struck,
T. Murphy,
A. Marston
Abstract:
We present the first results from the COLA (Compact Objects in Low-power AGN) project which aims to determine the relationship between one facet of AGN activity, the compact radio core, with star formation in the circumnuclear region of the host galaxy. This will be accomplished by the comparison of the multi-wavelength properties of a sample of AGN with compact radio cores to those of a sample…
▽ More
We present the first results from the COLA (Compact Objects in Low-power AGN) project which aims to determine the relationship between one facet of AGN activity, the compact radio core, with star formation in the circumnuclear region of the host galaxy. This will be accomplished by the comparison of the multi-wavelength properties of a sample of AGN with compact radio cores to those of a sample of AGN without compact cores and a matched sample of galaxies without AGN.
In this paper we discuss the selection criteria for our galaxy samples and present the initial radio observations of the 107 Southern galaxies in our sample. Low-resolution ATCA observations at 4.8, 2.5 and 1.4 GHz and high resolution, single baseline snapshots at 2.3 GHz with the Australian LBA are presented. We find that for the majority of the galaxies in our sample, the radio luminosity is correlated with the FIR luminosity.
Compact radio cores are detected in 9 galaxies. The majority (8/9) of these galaxies exhibit a significant radio excess and 50% (7/14) of the galaxies which lie above the radio-FIR correlation by more than 1 sigma have compact radio cores. The emission from the cores is too weak to account for this radio excess and there is no evidence that the radio luminosity of the compact cores is correlated with the FIR galaxy luminosity.
The galaxies with compact cores tend to be classified optically as AGN, with two thirds (6/9) exhibiting Seyfert-like optical emission line ratios, and the remaining galaxies classified either as composite objects (2/9) or starburst (1/9). (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2001;
originally announced September 2001.
