-
A new 700 GeV scalar in the LHC data?
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
George Rupp
Abstract:
As an alternative to the metastability of the electroweak vacuum, resulting from perturbative calculations, one can consider a non-perturbative effective potential which, as at the beginning of the Standard Model, is restricted to the pure $Φ^4$ sector yet consistent with the known analytical and numerical studies. In this approach, where the electroweak vacuum is now the lowest-energy state, besi…
▽ More
As an alternative to the metastability of the electroweak vacuum, resulting from perturbative calculations, one can consider a non-perturbative effective potential which, as at the beginning of the Standard Model, is restricted to the pure $Φ^4$ sector yet consistent with the known analytical and numerical studies. In this approach, where the electroweak vacuum is now the lowest-energy state, besides the resonance of mass $m_h=$ 125 GeV defined by the quadratic shape of the potential at its minimum, the Higgs field should exhibit a second resonance with mass $(M_H)^{\rm Theor}=690\,(30)$ GeV associated with the zero-point energy determining the potential depth. In spite of its large mass, this resonance would couple to longitudinal $W$s with the same typical strength as the low-mass state at 125 GeV and represent a relatively narrow resonance, mainly produced at LHC by gluon-gluon fusion.
In this Letter, we review LHC data suggesting a new resonance of mass $(M_H)^{\rm EXP} \sim 682\,(10)$ GeV, with a statistical significance that is far from negligible.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
SU(3) altermagnetism: Lattice models, chiral magnons, and flavor-split bands
Authors:
Pedro M. Cônsoli,
Matthias Vojta
Abstract:
Altermagnetism, a type of magnetic order that combines properties of ferromagnets and antiferromagnets, has generated significant interest recently, in particular due to its potential spintronics applications. Here, we show that altermagnetic states, which typically involve collinear magnetic order of SU(2) spins, can be generalized to higher SU($N$) symmetry groups. We construct a two-dimensional…
▽ More
Altermagnetism, a type of magnetic order that combines properties of ferromagnets and antiferromagnets, has generated significant interest recently, in particular due to its potential spintronics applications. Here, we show that altermagnetic states, which typically involve collinear magnetic order of SU(2) spins, can be generalized to higher SU($N$) symmetry groups. We construct a two-dimensional Heisenberg model for a three-sublattice SU(3) altermagnet and analyze its excitation spectrum via flavor-wave theory. By deriving a general formula for the chirality of the excitations, we show that the SU(3) altermagnet harbors chiral magnons that are split in energy. We also compute the electronic band structure for a metallic system of the same symmetry and map out the polarization of the resulting flavor-split bands. We conclude by discussing further generalizations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Michelson-Morley Experiments: at the crossroads of Relativity, Cosmology and Quantum Physics
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
Alessandro Pluchino
Abstract:
Quantum nonlocality would naturally fit into a version of relativity with a preferred reference system. However, acceptance of this idea has traditionally required experimental evidence. Namely, detecting in laboratory a small angular dependence of the velocity of light correlated to the cosmic motion of the Earth. Here, we summarize a new theoretical framework where the tiny, irregular residuals…
▽ More
Quantum nonlocality would naturally fit into a version of relativity with a preferred reference system. However, acceptance of this idea has traditionally required experimental evidence. Namely, detecting in laboratory a small angular dependence of the velocity of light correlated to the cosmic motion of the Earth. Here, we summarize a new theoretical framework where the tiny, irregular residuals observed so far, from Michelson-Morley to current experiments of laser interferometry, can indeed be understood in terms of the Earth motion in the Cosmic Microwave Background observed directly with satellites in space. Our results, challenging the usual null interpretation, emphasize the central role of 'ether-drift' experiments for Relativity, Cosmology and Quantum Physics.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Disorder effects in spiral spin liquids: Long-range spin textures, Friedel-like oscillations, and spiral spin glasses
Authors:
Pedro M. Cônsoli,
Matthias Vojta
Abstract:
Spiral spin liquids are correlated states of matter in which a frustrated magnetic system evades order by fluctuating between a set of (nearly) degenerate spin spirals. Here, we investigate the response of spiral spin liquids to quenched disorder in a $J_1$-$J_2$ honeycomb-lattice Heisenberg model. At the single-impurity level, we identify different order-by-quenched-disorder phenomena and analyze…
▽ More
Spiral spin liquids are correlated states of matter in which a frustrated magnetic system evades order by fluctuating between a set of (nearly) degenerate spin spirals. Here, we investigate the response of spiral spin liquids to quenched disorder in a $J_1$-$J_2$ honeycomb-lattice Heisenberg model. At the single-impurity level, we identify different order-by-quenched-disorder phenomena and analyze the ensuing spin textures. In particular, we show that the latter generally display Friedel-like oscillations, which encode direct information about the spiral contour, i.e., the classical ground-state manifold. At finite defect concentrations, we perform extensive numerical simulations and characterize the resulting phases at zero temperature. As a result, we find that the competition between incompatible order-by-quenched-disorder mechanisms can lead to spiral spin glass states already at low to moderate disorder. Finally, we discuss extensions of our conclusions to nonzero temperatures and higher-dimensional systems, as well as their applications to experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2024; v1 submitted 24 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Second resonance of the Higgs field: motivations, experimental signals, unitarity constraints
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
George Rupp
Abstract:
Perturbative calculations predict that the Standard Model (SM) effective potential should have a new minimum, well beyond the Planck scale, much deeper than the electroweak vacuum. As it is not obvious that gravitational effects can get so strong to stabilize the potential, most authors have accepted the metastability scenario in a cosmological perspective. This perspective is needed to explain wh…
▽ More
Perturbative calculations predict that the Standard Model (SM) effective potential should have a new minimum, well beyond the Planck scale, much deeper than the electroweak vacuum. As it is not obvious that gravitational effects can get so strong to stabilize the potential, most authors have accepted the metastability scenario in a cosmological perspective. This perspective is needed to explain why the theory remains trapped into our electroweak vacuum, but requires to control the properties of matter in the extreme conditions of the early universe. Alternatively, one can consider the completely different idea of a non-perturbative effective potential which, as at the beginning of the SM, is restricted to the pure $Φ^4$ sector yet consistent with the now existing analytical and numerical studies. In this approach, where the electroweak vacuum is the lowest-energy state, besides the resonance of mass $m_h=125$ GeV defined by the quadratic shape of the potential at its minimum, the Higgs field should exhibit a second resonance with mass $690\pm10({\rm stat})\pm20({\rm sys})$ GeV associated with the zero-point energy determining the potential depth. Despite its large mass, this would couple to longitudinal $W$s with the same typical strength as the low-mass state at 125 GeV and represent a relatively narrow resonance of width $Γ_H=30÷38$ GeV, mainly produced at LHC by gluon-gluon fusion. So it is interesting that, in the LHC data, one can find various indications for a new resonance in the expected mass range with a non-negligible statistical significance. As this could become an important new discovery by just adding two missing samples of RUN2 data, we outline further refinements of the theoretical predictions that could be obtained by implementing unitarity constraints, in the presence of fermion and gauge fields, with coupled-channel calculations used for meson spectroscopy.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2023; v1 submitted 2 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Quantum Non-Locality and the CMB: what Experiments say
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
Alessandro Pluchino,
Paola Zizzi
Abstract:
"Non-Locality is most naturally incorporated into a theory in which there is a special frame of reference. One possible candidate for this special frame of reference is the one in which the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is isotropic. However, other than the fact that a realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics requires a preferred frame and the CMB provides us with one, there is no readily…
▽ More
"Non-Locality is most naturally incorporated into a theory in which there is a special frame of reference. One possible candidate for this special frame of reference is the one in which the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is isotropic. However, other than the fact that a realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics requires a preferred frame and the CMB provides us with one, there is no readily apparent reason why the two should be linked" (L. Hardy). Starting from this remark we first argue that, given the present view of the vacuum, the basic tenets of Quantum Field Theory cannot guarantee that Einstein Special Relativity, with no preferred frame, is the physically realized version of relativity. Then, to try to understand the nature of the hypothetical preferred $Σ-$frame, we consider the so called ether-drift experiments, those precise optical measurements that try to detect in laboratory a small angular dependence of the two-way velocity of light and then to correlate this angular dependence with the direct CMB observations with satellites in space. By considering all experiments performed so far, from Michelson-Morley to the present experiments with optical resonators, and analyzing the small observed residuals in a modern theoretical framework, the long sought $Σ-$ frame tight to the CMB naturally emerges. Finally, if quantum non-locality reflects some effect propagating at vastly superluminal speed $v_{QI} \to \infty $, its ultimate origin could be hidden somewhere in the infinitely large speed $c_s \to \infty$ of the vacuum density fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Kondo breakdown transitions and phase-separation tendencies in valence-fluctuating heavy-fermion materials
Authors:
Pedro M. Cônsoli,
Matthias Vojta
Abstract:
The breakdown of the lattice Kondo effect in local-moment metals can lead to non-trivial forms of quantum criticality and a variety of non-Fermi-liquid phases. Given indications that Kondo-breakdown transitions involve criticality not only in the spin but also in the charge sector, we investigate the interplay of Kondo breakdown and strong valence fluctuations in generalized Anderson lattice model…
▽ More
The breakdown of the lattice Kondo effect in local-moment metals can lead to non-trivial forms of quantum criticality and a variety of non-Fermi-liquid phases. Given indications that Kondo-breakdown transitions involve criticality not only in the spin but also in the charge sector, we investigate the interplay of Kondo breakdown and strong valence fluctuations in generalized Anderson lattice models. We employ a parton mean-field theory to describe the transitions between deconfined fractionalized Fermi liquids and various confined phases. We find that rapid valence changes near Kondo breakdown can render the quantum transition first order. This leads to phase-separation tendencies which, upon inclusion of longer-range Coulomb interactions, will produce intrinsically inhomogeneous states near Kondo-breakdown transitions. We connect our findings to unsolved aspects of experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2022; v1 submitted 26 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Second resonance of the Higgs field: more signals from the LHC experiments
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
Leonardo Cosmai,
Fabrizio Fabbri
Abstract:
Theoretical arguments and lattice simulations suggest that, beside the known resonance of mass $m_h=$ 125 GeV, the Higgs field might exhibit a second resonance with a larger mass $(M_H)^{\rm theor} = 690 \pm 10 ~({\rm stat}) \pm 20 ~({\rm sys})~ {\rm GeV}$ which, however, would couple to longitudinal W's with the same typical strength as the low-mass state at 125 GeV and thus represent a relativel…
▽ More
Theoretical arguments and lattice simulations suggest that, beside the known resonance of mass $m_h=$ 125 GeV, the Higgs field might exhibit a second resonance with a larger mass $(M_H)^{\rm theor} = 690 \pm 10 ~({\rm stat}) \pm 20 ~({\rm sys})~ {\rm GeV}$ which, however, would couple to longitudinal W's with the same typical strength as the low-mass state at 125 GeV and thus represent a relatively narrow resonance mainly produced at LHC by gluon-gluon fusion. By looking for some evidence in the LHC data, we argue that the existence of a new resonance in the predicted mass region finds support in two analyses by ATLAS (searching for heavy resonances decaying into final states with 4 charged leptons or $γγ$ pairs) and in more recent CMS results (searching for heavy resonances decaying into a pair of $h(125)$ bosons or looking for $γγ$ pairs produced in $pp$ double-diffractive scattering). Since the correlation of these measurements is very small and since, having some definite theoretical prediction, local deviations from the pure background are not downgraded by the look-elsewhere effect, we emphasize the instability of the present situation that could probably be resolved by just adding two crucial, missing samples of RUN2 data.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2022; v1 submitted 1 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Stability of ordered and disordered phases in the Heisenberg-Kitaev model in a magnetic field
Authors:
Pedro M. Cônsoli,
Eric C. Andrade
Abstract:
The $S=1/2$ Kitaev honeycomb model has attracted significant attention as an exactly solvable example with a quantum spin liquid ground state. In a properly oriented external magnetic field, chiral Majorana edge modes associated with a quantized thermal Hall conductance emerge, and a distinct spin-disordered phase appears at intermediate field strengths, below the polarized phase. However, since m…
▽ More
The $S=1/2$ Kitaev honeycomb model has attracted significant attention as an exactly solvable example with a quantum spin liquid ground state. In a properly oriented external magnetic field, chiral Majorana edge modes associated with a quantized thermal Hall conductance emerge, and a distinct spin-disordered phase appears at intermediate field strengths, below the polarized phase. However, since material realizations of Kitaev magnetism invariably display competing exchange interactions, the stability of these exotic phases with respect to additional couplings is a key issue. Here, we report a 24-site exact diagonalization study of the Heisenberg-Kitaev model in a magnetic field applied in the [001] and [111] directions. By map** the full phase diagram of the model and contrasting the results to recent nonlinear spin-wave calculations, we show that both methods agree well, thus establishing that quantum corrections substantially modify the classical phase diagram. Furthermore, we find that, in a [111] field, the intermediate-field spin-disordered phase is remarkably stable to Heisenberg interactions and may potentially end in a novel quantum tricritical point.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Experimental signals for a second resonance of the Higgs field
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
Leonardo Cosmai
Abstract:
In the region of invariant mass 620$÷$740 GeV, we have analyzed the ATLAS sample of 4-lepton events that could indicate a new scalar resonance produced mainly via gluon-gluon fusion. These data suggest the existence of a new heavy state $H$ whose mass $660÷680$ GeV would fit well with the theoretical range $M_H = 690 \pm 10 ~({\rm stat}) \pm 20 ~({\rm sys})~ {\rm GeV}$ for the hypothetical second…
▽ More
In the region of invariant mass 620$÷$740 GeV, we have analyzed the ATLAS sample of 4-lepton events that could indicate a new scalar resonance produced mainly via gluon-gluon fusion. These data suggest the existence of a new heavy state $H$ whose mass $660÷680$ GeV would fit well with the theoretical range $M_H = 690 \pm 10 ~({\rm stat}) \pm 20 ~({\rm sys})~ {\rm GeV}$ for the hypothetical second resonance of the Higgs field that has been recently proposed and which would couple to longitudinal W's with the same typical strength of the low-mass state at $125$ GeV. Since the total width $Γ_H$ is very poorly determined, to sharpen the analysis of the precious ATLAS data, we have considered a particular correlation between resonating peak cross section $σ_R(pp\to H \to 4l)$ and the ratio $γ_H=Γ_H/M_H$. This correlation should be nearly insensitive to the precise value of $Γ_H$ and mainly determined by the lower mass $m_h=$ 125 GeV. Equivalently, if this correlation holds true, one could also fit $m_h$ from the 4-lepton data in the high-mass range 620$÷$740 GeV. The result $(m_h)^{\rm fit} \sim (125 \pm 13)$ GeV reproduces the direct measurement of the Higgs particle mass and thus supports the idea that $m_h$ and $M_H$ are the masses of two different excitations of the same field. Therefore, if we combine with the excess at 680 GeV in the ATLAS $γγ$ distribution, there are now two signals for a new resonance in the same mass region. Even though, quantitatively, the global statistical significance of each effect is modest, still the sharp correlation $γ_H-σ_R$ in the 4-lepton channel should induce to consider seriously these indications.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2022; v1 submitted 17 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The CMB, preferred reference system and dragging of light in the earth frame
Authors:
M. Consoli,
A. Pluchino
Abstract:
The dominant CMB dipole anisotropy is a Doppler effect due to a particular motion of the solar system with velocity of 370 km/s. Since this derives from peculiar motions and local inhomogeneities, one could meaningfully consider a fundamental frame of rest $Σ$ associated with the Universe as a whole. From the group properties of Lorentz transformations, two observers, individually moving within…
▽ More
The dominant CMB dipole anisotropy is a Doppler effect due to a particular motion of the solar system with velocity of 370 km/s. Since this derives from peculiar motions and local inhomogeneities, one could meaningfully consider a fundamental frame of rest $Σ$ associated with the Universe as a whole. From the group properties of Lorentz transformations, two observers, individually moving within $Σ$, would still be connected by the relativistic composition rules. But ultimate implications could be substantial. Physical interpretation is thus traditionally demanded to correlating some dragging of light observed in laboratory with the direct CMB observations. Today the small residuals, from Michelson-Morley to present experiments with optical resonators, are just considered instrumental artifacts. However, if the velocity of light in the interferometers is not the same parameter "c" of Lorentz transformations, nothing would prevent a non-zero dragging. Furthermore, observable effects would be much smaller than classically expected and most likely of irregular nature. We review an alternative reading of experiments which leads to remarkable correlations with the CMB observations. Notably, we explain the irregular $10^{-15}$ fractional frequency shift presently measured with optical resonators operating in vacuum and solid dielectrics. For integration times of about 1 second, and typical Central-Europe latitude, we also predict daily variations of the Allan variance in the range $(5\div12) \cdot 10^{-16}$.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
A hidden, heavier resonance of the Higgs field
Authors:
M. Consoli
Abstract:
In Veltman's original view, the Standard Model with a large Higgs particle mass of about 1 TeV was the natural completion of non-renormalizable Glashow model. This mass was thus a second threshold for weak interactions, as the W mass was for the non-renormalizable 4-fermion V-A theory. Today, after the observation of the narrow scalar resonance at 125 GeV, Veltman's large-mass idea seems to be rul…
▽ More
In Veltman's original view, the Standard Model with a large Higgs particle mass of about 1 TeV was the natural completion of non-renormalizable Glashow model. This mass was thus a second threshold for weak interactions, as the W mass was for the non-renormalizable 4-fermion V-A theory. Today, after the observation of the narrow scalar resonance at 125 GeV, Veltman's large-mass idea seems to be ruled out. Yet, this is not necessarily true. Depending on the description of SSB in $Φ^4$ theory, and by combining analytic calculations and lattice simulations, besides the known particle at 125 GeV, a new resonance of the Higgs field may also show up around 700 GeV. The peculiarity, though, is that this heavier state would couple to longitudinal vector bosons with the same typical strength of the low-mass state and thus represent a relatively narrow resonance. In this way, such hypothetical new resonance would naturally fit with some excess of 4-lepton events observed by ATLAS around 680 GeV. Analogous data from CMS are needed to confirm or disprove this interpretation. Implications of a two-mass structure for radiative corrections are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Fluctuation-induced ferrimagnetism in sublattice-imbalanced antiferromagnets with application to SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$ under pressure
Authors:
Pedro M. Cônsoli,
Max Fornoville,
Matthias Vojta
Abstract:
We show that a collinear Heisenberg antiferromagnet, whose sublattice symmetry is broken at the Hamiltonian level, becomes a fluctuation-induced ferrimagnet at any finite temperature $T$ below the Néel temperature $T_{\rm N}$. We demonstrate this using a layered variant of a square-lattice $J_1$-$J_2$ model. Linear spin-wave theory is used to determine the low-temperature behavior of the uniform m…
▽ More
We show that a collinear Heisenberg antiferromagnet, whose sublattice symmetry is broken at the Hamiltonian level, becomes a fluctuation-induced ferrimagnet at any finite temperature $T$ below the Néel temperature $T_{\rm N}$. We demonstrate this using a layered variant of a square-lattice $J_1$-$J_2$ model. Linear spin-wave theory is used to determine the low-temperature behavior of the uniform magnetization, and non-linear corrections are argued to yield a temperature-induced qualitative change of the magnon spectrum. We then consider a layered Shastry-Sutherland model, describing a frustrated arrangement of orthogonal dimers. This model displays an antiferromagnetic phase for large intra-dimer couplings. A lattice distortion which breaks the glide symmetry between the two types of dimers corresponds to broken sublattice symmetry and hence gives rise to ferrimagnetism. Given indications that such a distortion is present in the material SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$ under hydrostatic pressure, we suggest the existence of a fluctuation-induced ferrimagnetic phase in pressurized SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$. We predict a non-monotonic behavior of the uniform magnetization as function of temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2021; v1 submitted 17 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
A resonance of the Higgs field at 700 GeV and a new phenomenology
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
Leonardo Cosmai
Abstract:
It has been recently proposed that, besides the known resonance with mass $m_h\sim$ 125 GeV, the Higgs field could exhibit a new excitation with a larger mass $M_h$ related by $M^2_h\sim m^2_h \ln (Λ_s/M_h)$, where $Λ_s$ is the ultraviolet cutoff of the scalar sector. Lattice simulations of the propagator performed in the 4D Ising limit of the theory are consistent with this two-mass picture and l…
▽ More
It has been recently proposed that, besides the known resonance with mass $m_h\sim$ 125 GeV, the Higgs field could exhibit a new excitation with a larger mass $M_h$ related by $M^2_h\sim m^2_h \ln (Λ_s/M_h)$, where $Λ_s$ is the ultraviolet cutoff of the scalar sector. Lattice simulations of the propagator performed in the 4D Ising limit of the theory are consistent with this two-mass picture and lead to the estimate $M_h\sim 700$ GeV. In spite of its large mass, however, this heavier state would couple to longitudinal vector bosons with the same typical strength of the low-mass state and would thus represent a relatively narrow resonance. In this Letter we argue that this hypothetical new resonance would naturally fit with some excess of 4-lepton events which is observed by ATLAS around 680 GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2020; v1 submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Heisenberg-Kitaev model in a magnetic field: $1/S$ expansion
Authors:
Pedro M. Cônsoli,
Lukas Janssen,
Matthias Vojta,
Eric C. Andrade
Abstract:
The exact solution of Kitaev's spin-$1/2$ honeycomb spin-liquid model has sparked an intense search for Mott insulators hosting bond-dependent Kitaev interactions, of which $\mathrm{Na}_{2}\mathrm{IrO}_{3}$ and $α-\mathrm{RuCl}_{3}$ are prime examples. Subsequently, it has been proposed that also spin-$1$ and spin-$3/2$ analogs of Kitaev interactions may occur in materials with strong spin-orbit c…
▽ More
The exact solution of Kitaev's spin-$1/2$ honeycomb spin-liquid model has sparked an intense search for Mott insulators hosting bond-dependent Kitaev interactions, of which $\mathrm{Na}_{2}\mathrm{IrO}_{3}$ and $α-\mathrm{RuCl}_{3}$ are prime examples. Subsequently, it has been proposed that also spin-$1$ and spin-$3/2$ analogs of Kitaev interactions may occur in materials with strong spin-orbit coupling. As a minimal model to describe these Kitaev materials, we study the Heisenberg-Kitaev Hamiltonian in a consistent $1/S$ expansion, with $S$ being the spin size. We present a comprehensive study of this model in the presence of an external magnetic field applied along two different directions, [001] and [111], for which an intricate classical phase diagram has been reported. In both settings, we employ spin-wave theory in a number of ordered phases to compute phase boundaries at the next-to-leading order in $1/S$ and show that quantum corrections substantially modify the classical phase diagram. More broadly, our work presents a consistent route to investigate the leading quantum corrections in spin models that break spin-rotational symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2020; v1 submitted 7 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
The mass scales of the Higgs field
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli,
Leonardo Cosmai
Abstract:
In the first version of the theory, with a classical scalar potential, the sector inducing SSB was distinct from the Higgs field interactions induced through its gauge and Yukawa couplings. We have adopted a similar perspective but, following most recent lattice simulations, described SSB in $λΦ^4$ theory as a weak first-order phase transition. In this case, the resulting effective potential has t…
▽ More
In the first version of the theory, with a classical scalar potential, the sector inducing SSB was distinct from the Higgs field interactions induced through its gauge and Yukawa couplings. We have adopted a similar perspective but, following most recent lattice simulations, described SSB in $λΦ^4$ theory as a weak first-order phase transition. In this case, the resulting effective potential has two mass scales: i) a lower mass $m_h$, defined by its quadratic shape at the minima, ~and~ ii) a larger mass $M_h$, defined by the zero-point energy. These refer to different momentum scales in the propagator and are related by $M^2_h\sim m^2_h \ln (Λ_s/M_h)$, where $Λ_s$ is the ultraviolet cutoff of the scalar sector. We have checked this two-scale structure with lattice simulations of the propagator and of the susceptibility in the 4D Ising limit of the theory. These indicate that, in a cutoff theory where both $m_h$ and $M_h$ are finite, by increasing the energy, there could be a transition from a relatively low value, e.g. $m_h$=125 GeV, to a much larger $M_h$. The same lattice data give a final estimate $M_h= 720 \pm 30 $ GeV which induces to re-consider the experimental situation at LHC. In particular an independent analysis of the ATLAS + CMS data indicating an excess in the 4-lepton channel as if there were a new scalar resonance around 700 GeV. Finally, the presence of two vastly different mass scales, requiring an interpolating form for the Higgs field propagator also in loop corrections, could reduce the discrepancy with those precise measurements which still favor large values of the Higgs particle mass.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Field-induced phase transitions of the Kitaev material $α$-RuCl$_3$ probed by thermal expansion and magnetostriction
Authors:
S. Gass,
P. M. Cônsoli,
V. Kocsis,
L. T. Corredor,
P. Lampen-Kelley,
D. G. Mandrus,
S. E. Nagler,
L. Janssen,
M. Vojta,
B. Büchner,
A. U. B. Wolter
Abstract:
High-resolution thermal expansion and magnetostriction measurements were performed on single crystals of $α$-RuCl$_3$ in magnetic fields applied parallel to the Ru-Ru bonds. The length changes were measured in the direction perpendicular to the honeycomb planes. Our data show clear thermodynamic characteristics for the field-induced phase transition at the critical field $μ_0H_{c1} = 7.8(2)$ T whe…
▽ More
High-resolution thermal expansion and magnetostriction measurements were performed on single crystals of $α$-RuCl$_3$ in magnetic fields applied parallel to the Ru-Ru bonds. The length changes were measured in the direction perpendicular to the honeycomb planes. Our data show clear thermodynamic characteristics for the field-induced phase transition at the critical field $μ_0H_{c1} = 7.8(2)$ T where the antiferromagnetic zigzag order is suppressed. At higher fields, a kink in the magnetostriction coefficient signals an additional phase transition around $μ_0H_{c2} \approx 11$ T. The extracted Grüneisen parameter shows typical hallmarks for quantum criticality near $H_{c1}$, but also displays anomalous behavior above $H_{c1}$. We compare our experimental data with linear spin-wave calculations employing a minimal Kitaev-Heisenberg model in the semiclassical limit. Most of the salient features are in agreement with each other, however, the peculiar features in the high-field region above $H_{c1}$ cannot be accounted for in our modelling and hence suggest a genuine quantum nature. We construct a phase diagram for $α$-RuCl$_3$ showing two low-temperature transitions induced by an in-plane field along the Ru-Ru bonds.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2020; v1 submitted 16 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Two mass scales for the Higgs field?
Authors:
Paolo Cea,
Maurizio Consoli,
Leonardo Cosmai
Abstract:
In the original version of the theory, the driving mechanism for spontaneous symmetry breaking was identified in the pure scalar sector. However, this old idea requires a heavy Higgs particle that, after the discovery of the 125 GeV resonance, seems to be ruled out. We argue that this is not necessarily true. If the phase transition is weakly first order, as indicated by most recent lattice simula…
▽ More
In the original version of the theory, the driving mechanism for spontaneous symmetry breaking was identified in the pure scalar sector. However, this old idea requires a heavy Higgs particle that, after the discovery of the 125 GeV resonance, seems to be ruled out. We argue that this is not necessarily true. If the phase transition is weakly first order, as indicated by most recent lattice simulations, one should consider those approximation schemes that are in agreement with this scenario. Then, even in a simple one-component theory, it becomes natural to introduce two mass scales, say $M_h$ and $m_h$ with $m_h \ll M_h$. This resembles the coexistence of phonons and rotons in superfluid helium-4, which is the non-relativistic analogue of the scalar condensate, and is potentially relevant for the Standard Model. In fact, vacuum stability would depend on $M_h$ and not on $m_h$ and be nearly insensitive to the other parameters of the theory (e.g. the top quark mass). By identifying $m_h=125$ GeV, and with our previous estimate from lattice simulations $M_h= 754 \pm 20 ~\rm{(stat)} \pm 20 ~\rm{(syst)}$ GeV, we thus get in touch with a recent, independent analysis of the ATLAS + CMS data which claims experimental evidence for a scalar resonance around $700$ GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Cosmic Microwave Background and the issue of a fundamental preferred frame
Authors:
M. Consoli,
A. Pluchino
Abstract:
Correlating ether-drift measurements in laboratory and CMB observations in space would confirm the existence of a preferred reference frame. To this end, however, the velocity of light in the interferometers cannot be the same parameter 'c' of Lorentz transformations. Thus, for the earth velocity of 370 km/s, a fundamental 10^(-15) light anisotropy, as presently observed in vacuum and in solid die…
▽ More
Correlating ether-drift measurements in laboratory and CMB observations in space would confirm the existence of a preferred reference frame. To this end, however, the velocity of light in the interferometers cannot be the same parameter 'c' of Lorentz transformations. Thus, for the earth velocity of 370 km/s, a fundamental 10^(-15) light anisotropy, as presently observed in vacuum and in solid dielectrics, could reveal a 10^(-9) difference in the vacuum refractivity between an ideal freely-falling frame and an apparatus on the earth surface. In this perspective, the stochastic nature of the vacuum could explain the irregular character of the signal and the substantial reduction of its statistical average (10^(-18) or smaller). For the same v=370 km/s the different refractivity, about 10^(-4) and 10^(-5) for air or helium at atmospheric pressure, could also explain the observed anisotropy, respectively about 10^(-10) and 10^(-11). The mechanism enhancing the signal in gaseous matter, but ineffective in solid dielectrics, is naturally identified in a non-local, temperature gradient of a fraction of millikelvin. This is found in all classical experiments and might ultimately reflect the CMB temperature dipole or the fundamental energy flow in a Lorentz-non-invariant vacuum. Clarification requires dedicated experiments and improvements in the data analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2018; v1 submitted 9 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Cosmic Background Radiation and `ether-drift' experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
A. Pluchino,
A. Rapisarda
Abstract:
`Ether-drift' experiments have played a crucial role for the origin of relativity. Though, a recent re-analysis shows that those original measurements where light was still propagating in gaseous systems, differently from the modern experiments in vacuum and in solid dielectrics, indicate a small universal anisotropy which is naturally interpreted in terms of a non-local thermal gradient. We argue…
▽ More
`Ether-drift' experiments have played a crucial role for the origin of relativity. Though, a recent re-analysis shows that those original measurements where light was still propagating in gaseous systems, differently from the modern experiments in vacuum and in solid dielectrics, indicate a small universal anisotropy which is naturally interpreted in terms of a non-local thermal gradient. We argue that this could possibly be the effect, on weakly bound gaseous matter, of the temperature gradient due to the Earth's motion within the Cosmic Background Radiation (CBR). Therefore, a check with modern laser interferometers is needed to reproduce the conditions of those early measurements with today's much greater accuracy. We emphasize that an unambiguous confirmation of our interpretation would have far reaching consequences. For instance, it would also imply that all physical systems on the moving Earth are exposed to a tiny energy flow, an effect that, in principle, could induce forms of self-organization in matter.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Gravity as an emergent phenomenon: experimental signatures
Authors:
M. Consoli,
A. Pluchino
Abstract:
According to some authors, gravity might be an emergent phenomenon in a fundamentally flat space-time. In this case the speed of light in the vacuum would not coincide exactly with the basic parameter "c" entering Lorentz transformations and, for an apparatus placed on the Earth's surface, light should exhibit a tiny fractional anisotropy at the level 10^{-15}. We argue that, most probably, this e…
▽ More
According to some authors, gravity might be an emergent phenomenon in a fundamentally flat space-time. In this case the speed of light in the vacuum would not coincide exactly with the basic parameter "c" entering Lorentz transformations and, for an apparatus placed on the Earth's surface, light should exhibit a tiny fractional anisotropy at the level 10^{-15}. We argue that, most probably, this effect is now observed in many room-temperature ether-drift experiments and, in particular, in a very precise cryogenic experiment where this level of signal is about 100 times larger than the designed short-term stability. To fully appreciate what is going on, however, one should consider the vacuum as a true physical medium whose fundamental quantum nature gives rise to the irregular, non-deterministic pattern which characterizes the observed signal.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
The classical ether-drift experiments: a modern re-interpretation
Authors:
M. Consoli,
C. Matheson,
A. Pluchino
Abstract:
The condensation of elementary quanta and their macroscopic occupation of the same quantum state, say k=0 in some reference frame Sigma, is the essential ingredient of the degenerate vacuum of present-day elementary particle physics. This represents a sort of `quantum ether' which characterizes the physically realized form of relativity and could play the role of preferred reference frame in a mod…
▽ More
The condensation of elementary quanta and their macroscopic occupation of the same quantum state, say k=0 in some reference frame Sigma, is the essential ingredient of the degenerate vacuum of present-day elementary particle physics. This represents a sort of `quantum ether' which characterizes the physically realized form of relativity and could play the role of preferred reference frame in a modern re-formulation of the Lorentzian approach. In spite of this, the so called `null results' of the classical ether-drift experiments, traditionally interpreted as confirmations of Special Relativity, have so deeply influenced scientific thought as to prevent a critical discussion on the real reasons underlying its alleged supremacy. In this paper, we argue that this traditional null interpretation is far from obvious. In fact, by using Lorentz transformations to connect the Earth's frame to Sigma, the small observed effects point to an average Earth's velocity of about 300 km/s, as in most cosmic motions. A common feature is the irregular behaviour of the data. While this has motivated, so far, their standard interpretation as instrumental artifacts, our new re-analysis of the very accurate Joos experiment gives clear indications for the type of Earth's motion associated with the CMB anisotropy and leaves little space for this traditional interpretation. The new explanation requires instead a view of the vacuum as a stochastic medium, similar to a fluid in a turbulent state of motion, in agreement with basic foundational aspects of both quantum physics and relativity. The overall consistency of this picture with the present experiments with vacuum optical resonators and the need for a new generation of dedicated ether-drift experiments are also emphasized.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2013; v1 submitted 12 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
The vacuum as a form of turbulent fluid: motivations, experiments, implications
Authors:
M. Consoli,
A. Pluchino,
A. Rapisarda,
S. Tudisco
Abstract:
Basic foundational aspects of both quantum theory and relativity might induce to represent the physical vacuum as an underlying highly turbulent fluid. By explicit numerical simulations, we show that a form of statistically isotropic and homogeneous vacuum turbulence is entirely consistent with the present ether-drift experiments. In particular, after subtracting known forms of disturbances, the o…
▽ More
Basic foundational aspects of both quantum theory and relativity might induce to represent the physical vacuum as an underlying highly turbulent fluid. By explicit numerical simulations, we show that a form of statistically isotropic and homogeneous vacuum turbulence is entirely consistent with the present ether-drift experiments. In particular, after subtracting known forms of disturbances, the observed stochastic signal requires velocity fluctuations whose absolute scale is well described by the average Earth's motion with respect to the Cosmic Microwave Background. We emphasize that the existence of a genuine stochastic ether drift could be crucial for the emergence of forms of self-organization in matter and thus for the whole approach to complexity.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2013; v1 submitted 27 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Basic randomness of nature and ether-drift experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
A. Pluchino,
A. Rapisarda
Abstract:
We re-consider the idea that quantum fluctuations might reflect the existence of an 'objective randomness', i.e. a basic property of the vacuum state which is independent of any experimental accuracy of the observations or limited knowledge of initial conditions. Besides being responsible for the observed quantum behaviour, this might introduce a weak, residual form of `noise' which is intrinsic t…
▽ More
We re-consider the idea that quantum fluctuations might reflect the existence of an 'objective randomness', i.e. a basic property of the vacuum state which is independent of any experimental accuracy of the observations or limited knowledge of initial conditions. Besides being responsible for the observed quantum behaviour, this might introduce a weak, residual form of `noise' which is intrinsic to natural phenomena and could be important for the emergence of complexity at higher physical levels. By adopting Stochastic Electro Dynamics as a heuristic model, we are driven to a picture of the vacuum as a form of highly turbulent ether, which is deep-rooted into the basic foundational aspects of both quantum physics and relativity, and to search for experimental tests of this scenario. An analysis of the most precise ether-drift experiments, operating both at room temperature and in the cryogenic regime, shows that, at present, there is some ambiguity in the interpretation of the data. In fact the average amplitude of the signal has precisely the magnitude expected, in a 'Lorentzian' form of relativity, from an underlying stochastic ether and, as such, might not be a spurious instrumental effect. This puzzle, however, should be solved in a next future with the use of new cryogenically cooled optical resonators whose stability should improve by about two orders of magnitude. In these new experimental conditions, the persistence of the present amplitude would represent a clean evidence for the type of random vacuum we are envisaging.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2011; v1 submitted 7 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
On the low-energy spectrum of spontaneously broken Φ^4 theories
Authors:
Maurizio Consoli
Abstract:
The low-energy spectrum of a one-component, spontaneously broken Φ^4 theory is generally believed to have the same simple massive form \sqrt{{\bf p}^2 + m^2_h} as in the symmetric phase where < Φ>=0. However, in lattice simulations of the 4D Ising limit of the theory, the two-point connected correlator and the connected scalar propagator show deviations from a standard massive behaviour that do no…
▽ More
The low-energy spectrum of a one-component, spontaneously broken Φ^4 theory is generally believed to have the same simple massive form \sqrt{{\bf p}^2 + m^2_h} as in the symmetric phase where < Φ>=0. However, in lattice simulations of the 4D Ising limit of the theory, the two-point connected correlator and the connected scalar propagator show deviations from a standard massive behaviour that do not exist in the symmetric phase. As a support for this observed discrepancy, I present a variational, analytic calculation of the energy spectrum E_1({\bf p}) in the broken phase. This analytic result, while providing the trend E_1({\bf p})\sim \sqrt{{\bf p}^2 + m^2_h} at large |{\bf p}|, gives an energy gap E_1(0)< m_h, even when approaching the infinite-cutoff limit Λ\to \infty with that infinitesimal coupling λ\sim 1/\ln Λsuggested by the standard interpretation of "triviality" within leading-order perturbation theory. I also compare with other approaches and discuss the more general implications of the result.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Emergent gravity and ether-drift experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
L. Pappalardo
Abstract:
According to several authors, gravity might be a long-wavelength phenomenon emerging in some 'hydrodynamic limit' from the same physical, flat-space vacuum viewed as a form of superfluid medium. In this framework, light might propagate in an effective acoustic geometry and exhibit a tiny anisotropy that could be measurable in the present ether-drift experiments. By accepting this view of the vacuu…
▽ More
According to several authors, gravity might be a long-wavelength phenomenon emerging in some 'hydrodynamic limit' from the same physical, flat-space vacuum viewed as a form of superfluid medium. In this framework, light might propagate in an effective acoustic geometry and exhibit a tiny anisotropy that could be measurable in the present ether-drift experiments. By accepting this view of the vacuum, one should also consider the possibility of sizeable random fluctuations of the signal that reflect the stochastic nature of the underlying `quantum ether' and could be erroneously interpreted as instrumental noise. To test the present interpretation, we have extracted the mean amplitude of the signal from various experiments with different systematics, operating both at room temperature and in the cryogenic regime. They all give the same consistent value < A > = O (10^{-15}) which is precisely the magnitude expected in an emergent-gravity approach, for an apparatus placed on the Earth's surface. Since physical implications could be substantial, it would be important to obtain more direct checks from the instantaneous raw data and, possibly, with new experimental set-ups operating in gravity-free environments.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2010; v1 submitted 1 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Vacuum structure and ether-drift experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
L. Pappalardo
Abstract:
In the data of the ether-drift experiments there might be sizable fluctuations superposed on the smooth sinusoidal modulations due to the Earth's rotation and orbital revolution. These fluctuations might reflect the stochastic nature of the underlying "quantum ether" and produce vanishing averages for all vectorial quantities extracted from a naive Fourier analysis of the data. By comparing the…
▽ More
In the data of the ether-drift experiments there might be sizable fluctuations superposed on the smooth sinusoidal modulations due to the Earth's rotation and orbital revolution. These fluctuations might reflect the stochastic nature of the underlying "quantum ether" and produce vanishing averages for all vectorial quantities extracted from a naive Fourier analysis of the data. By comparing the typical stability limits of the individual optical resonators with the amplitude of their relative frequency shift, the presently observed signal, rather than being spurious experimental noise, might also express fundamental properties of a physical vacuum similar to a superfluid in a turbulent state of motion. In this sense, the situation might be similar to the discovery of the CMBR that was first interpreted as mere instrumental noise.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
Ultraweak excitations of the quantum vacuum as physical models of gravity
Authors:
M. Consoli
Abstract:
It has been argued by several authors that the space-time curvature observed in gravitational fields, and the same idea of forms of physical equivalence different from the Lorentz group, might emerge from the dynamical properties of the physical flat-space vacuum in a suitable hydrodynamic limit. To explore this idea, one could start by representing the physical vacuum as a Bose condensate of el…
▽ More
It has been argued by several authors that the space-time curvature observed in gravitational fields, and the same idea of forms of physical equivalence different from the Lorentz group, might emerge from the dynamical properties of the physical flat-space vacuum in a suitable hydrodynamic limit. To explore this idea, one could start by representing the physical vacuum as a Bose condensate of elementary quanta and look for vacuum excitations that, on a coarse grained scale, resemble the Newtonian potential. In this way, it is relatively easy to match the weak-field limit of classical General Relativity or of some of its possible variants. The idea that Bose condensates can provide various forms of gravitational dynamics is not new. Here, I want to emphasize some genuine quantum field theoretical aspects that can help to understand i) why infinitesimally weak, 1/r interactions can indeed arise from the same physical vacuum of electroweak and strong interactions and ii) why, on a coarse-grained scale, their dynamical effects can be re-absorbed into an effective curved metric structure.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2009; v1 submitted 8 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Do 1/r potentials require massless particles ?
Authors:
M. Consoli
Abstract:
Long-range 1/r potentials play a fundamental role in physics. Their ultimate origin is usually traced back to the existence of genuine massless particles as photons or gravitons related to fundamental properties of continuum quantum field theories such as gauge invariance. In this Letter, it is argued that, in principle, an asymptotic, infinitesimally weak 1/r potential might also occur in the c…
▽ More
Long-range 1/r potentials play a fundamental role in physics. Their ultimate origin is usually traced back to the existence of genuine massless particles as photons or gravitons related to fundamental properties of continuum quantum field theories such as gauge invariance. In this Letter, it is argued that, in principle, an asymptotic, infinitesimally weak 1/r potential might also occur in the cutoff version of a simple, one-component spontaneously broken Φ^4 theory, after taking into account the peculiar nature of the zero-momentum limit of the connected scalar propagator. Physical interpretation, phenomenological implications and proposals for a new generation of lattice simulations are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Precision tests with a new class of dedicated ether-drift experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
In principle, by accepting the idea of a non-zero vacuum energy, the physical vacuum of present particle physics might represent a preferred reference frame. By treating this quantum vacuum as a relativistic medium, the non-zero energy-momentum flow expected in a moving frame should effectively behave as a small thermal gradient and could, in principle, induce a measurable anisotropy of the spee…
▽ More
In principle, by accepting the idea of a non-zero vacuum energy, the physical vacuum of present particle physics might represent a preferred reference frame. By treating this quantum vacuum as a relativistic medium, the non-zero energy-momentum flow expected in a moving frame should effectively behave as a small thermal gradient and could, in principle, induce a measurable anisotropy of the speed of light in a loosely bound system as a gas. We explore the phenomenological implications of this scenario by considering a new class of dedicated ether-drift experiments where arbitrary gaseous media fill the resonating optical cavities. Our predictions cover most experimental set up and should motivate precise experimental tests of these fundamental issues.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Flat-space picture of gravity vs. General Relativity: a precision test for present ether-drift experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
Modern ether-drift experiments in vacuum could in principle detect the tiny refractive index that, in a flat-space picture of gravity, is appropriate for an apparatus placed on the Earth's surface. In this picture, in fact, if there were a preferred reference frame, light on the Earth would exhibit a slight anisotropy with definite quantitative differences from General Relativity. By re-analyzin…
▽ More
Modern ether-drift experiments in vacuum could in principle detect the tiny refractive index that, in a flat-space picture of gravity, is appropriate for an apparatus placed on the Earth's surface. In this picture, in fact, if there were a preferred reference frame, light on the Earth would exhibit a slight anisotropy with definite quantitative differences from General Relativity. By re-analyzing the data published by two modern experiments with rotating optical resonators, and concentrating on the part of the signal that should be free of spurious systematic effects, we have found evidences that would support the flat-space scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
An alternative heavy Higgs mass limit
Authors:
P. Castorina,
M. Consoli,
D. Zappalá
Abstract:
After commenting on the present value of the Higgs particle mass from radiative corrections, we explore the phenomenological implications of an alternative, non-perturbative renormalization of the scalar sector where the mass of the Higgs particle does not represent a measure of observable interactions at the Higgs mass scale. In this approach the Higgs particle could be very heavy, even heavier…
▽ More
After commenting on the present value of the Higgs particle mass from radiative corrections, we explore the phenomenological implications of an alternative, non-perturbative renormalization of the scalar sector where the mass of the Higgs particle does not represent a measure of observable interactions at the Higgs mass scale. In this approach the Higgs particle could be very heavy, even heavier than 1 TeV, and remain nevertheless a relatively narrow resonance.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2008; v1 submitted 2 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Is the physical vacuum a preferred frame ?
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
It is generally assumed that the physical vacuum of particle physics should be characterized by an energy momentum tensor in such a way to preserve exact Lorentz invariance. On the other hand, if the ground state were characterized by its energy-momentum vector, with zero spatial momentum and a non-zero energy, the vacuum would represent a preferred frame. Since both theoretical approaches have…
▽ More
It is generally assumed that the physical vacuum of particle physics should be characterized by an energy momentum tensor in such a way to preserve exact Lorentz invariance. On the other hand, if the ground state were characterized by its energy-momentum vector, with zero spatial momentum and a non-zero energy, the vacuum would represent a preferred frame. Since both theoretical approaches have their own good motivations, we propose an experimental test to decide between the two scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
An easy reading of modern ether-drift experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
Modern ether-drift experiments look for a preferred reference frame searching for modulations of the beat note of two optical resonators that might be induced by the Earth's rotation. We present a compact formalism to evaluate the signal for most experiments where two arbitrary gaseous media fill the resonating cavities. Our predictions can provide useful hints to optimize the experimental set u…
▽ More
Modern ether-drift experiments look for a preferred reference frame searching for modulations of the beat note of two optical resonators that might be induced by the Earth's rotation. We present a compact formalism to evaluate the signal for most experiments where two arbitrary gaseous media fill the resonating cavities. Our predictions can provide useful hints to optimize the experimental set up and the data taking.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Is the standard singlet Higgs a true massive field ?
Authors:
M. Consoli
Abstract:
The phenomenon of spontaneous symmetry breaking admits a physical interpretation in terms of the Bose-condensation process of elementary spinless quanta. In a cutoff theory, this leads to a picture of the vacuum as a condensed medium whose excitations might deviate from exact Lorentz covariance in both the ultraviolet and infrared regions. For this reason, the conventional singlet Higgs boson, t…
▽ More
The phenomenon of spontaneous symmetry breaking admits a physical interpretation in terms of the Bose-condensation process of elementary spinless quanta. In a cutoff theory, this leads to a picture of the vacuum as a condensed medium whose excitations might deviate from exact Lorentz covariance in both the ultraviolet and infrared regions. For this reason, the conventional singlet Higgs boson, the shifted field of spontaneous symmetry breaking, rather than being a purely massive field, might possess a gapless branch describing the long-wavelength fluctuations of the scalar condensate. To test this idea, that might have substantial phenomenological implications, I compare with a detailed lattice simulation of the broken phase in the 4D Ising limit of the theory. The results are the following: i) differently from the symmetric phase, the single-particle energy spectrum is not reproduced by the standard massive form ii) for the value of the hop** parameter κ=0.076, increasing the lattice size from 20^4 to 32^4, the mass gap is found to decrease from the value 0.392(1) reported by Balog et al. (see Nucl. Phys. B714 (2005) 256) to the value 0.366(5). Both results confirm that, in the infrared region, the standard singlet Higgs cannot be considered as a simple massive field. Several arguments indicate that, approaching the continuum limit of the lattice theory, the observed volume dependence of the mass gap might require larger and larger lattice sizes before to show up.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
Renormalization-Group flow for the field strength in scalar self-interacting theories
Authors:
M. Consoli,
D. Zappalá
Abstract:
We consider the Renormalization-Group coupled equations for the effective potential V(φ) and the field strength Z(φ) in the spontaneously broken phase as a function of the infrared cutoff momentum k. In the k \to 0 limit, the numerical solution of the coupled equations, while consistent with the expected convexity property of V(φ), indicates a sharp peaking of Z(φ) close to the end points of the…
▽ More
We consider the Renormalization-Group coupled equations for the effective potential V(φ) and the field strength Z(φ) in the spontaneously broken phase as a function of the infrared cutoff momentum k. In the k \to 0 limit, the numerical solution of the coupled equations, while consistent with the expected convexity property of V(φ), indicates a sharp peaking of Z(φ) close to the end points of the flatness region that define the physical realization of the broken phase. This might represent further evidence in favor of the non-trivial vacuum field renormalization effect already discovered with variational methods.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2006; v1 submitted 1 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
An effective vacuum refractive index from gravity and the present ether-drift experiments
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
Re-analyzing the data published by the Berlin and Duesseldorf ether-drift experiments, we have found a clean non-zero daily average for the amplitude of the signal. The two experimental values, A_0\sim (10.5 \pm 1.3) 10^{-16} and A_0\sim (12.1\pm 2.2) 10^{-16}$ respectively, are entirely consistent with the theoretical prediction (9.7\pm 3.5) 10^{-16} that is obtained once the Robertson-Mansouri…
▽ More
Re-analyzing the data published by the Berlin and Duesseldorf ether-drift experiments, we have found a clean non-zero daily average for the amplitude of the signal. The two experimental values, A_0\sim (10.5 \pm 1.3) 10^{-16} and A_0\sim (12.1\pm 2.2) 10^{-16}$ respectively, are entirely consistent with the theoretical prediction (9.7\pm 3.5) 10^{-16} that is obtained once the Robertson-Mansouri-Sexl anisotropy parameter is expressed in terms of N_{vacuum}, the effective vacuum refractive index that one would get, for an apparatus placed on the Earth's surface, in a flat-space picture of gravity .
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
-
Motion toward the Great Attractor from an ether-drift experiment
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo,
V. Palmisano
Abstract:
Since the end of 80's, the region of sky of galactic coordinates (l\sim 309^o, b\sim 18^o), corresponding to a declination γ\sim -44^o and right ascension α\sim 202^o, usually denoted as the "Great Attractor", is known to control the overall galaxy flow in our local Universe. In this sense, this direction might represent a natural candidate to characterize a hypothetical Earth's "absolute motion…
▽ More
Since the end of 80's, the region of sky of galactic coordinates (l\sim 309^o, b\sim 18^o), corresponding to a declination γ\sim -44^o and right ascension α\sim 202^o, usually denoted as the "Great Attractor", is known to control the overall galaxy flow in our local Universe. In this sense, this direction might represent a natural candidate to characterize a hypothetical Earth's "absolute motion". Our analysis of the extensive ether-drift observations recently reported by an experimental group in Berlin provides values of αand γthat coincide almost exactly with those of the Great Attractor and not with the values γ\sim -6^o and α\sim 168^o obtained from a dipole fit to the anisotropy of the CMB. This supports in a new fashion the existence of a discrepancy between the observed motion of the Local Group and the direction obtained from the CMB dipole.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2006; v1 submitted 19 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
-
Indications for a preferred reference frame from an ether-drift experiment
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
We present a fully model-independent analysis of the extensive observations reported by a recent ether-drift experiment in Berlin. No a priori assumption is made on the nature of a hypothetical preferred frame. We find a remarkable consistency with an Earth's cosmic motion exhibiting an average declination angle |γ|\sim 43^o and with values of the RMS anisotropy parameter (1/2-β+δ) that are one…
▽ More
We present a fully model-independent analysis of the extensive observations reported by a recent ether-drift experiment in Berlin. No a priori assumption is made on the nature of a hypothetical preferred frame. We find a remarkable consistency with an Earth's cosmic motion exhibiting an average declination angle |γ|\sim 43^o and with values of the RMS anisotropy parameter (1/2-β+δ) that are one order of magnitude larger than the presently quoted ones. This might represent the first modern indication for a preferred frame and for a non-zero anisotropy of the speed of light.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
-
Evidence for an anisotropy of the speed of light
Authors:
C. M. L. de Aragao,
M. Consoli,
A. Grillo
Abstract:
By comparing with the most recent experimental results, we point out the model dependence of the present bounds on the anisotropy of the speed of light. In fact, by replacing the CMB with a class of preferred frames that can better account for the experimental data, one obtains values of the RMS anisotropy parameter (1/2 -beta + delta) that are one order of magnitude larger than the presently qu…
▽ More
By comparing with the most recent experimental results, we point out the model dependence of the present bounds on the anisotropy of the speed of light. In fact, by replacing the CMB with a class of preferred frames that can better account for the experimental data, one obtains values of the RMS anisotropy parameter (1/2 -beta + delta) that are one order of magnitude larger than the presently quoted ones. The resulting non-zero anisotropy can be understood starting from the observation that the speed of light in the Earth's gravitational field is not the basic parameter c=1 entering Lorentz transformations. In this sense, light can propagate isotropically only in one `preferred' frame.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2005;
originally announced September 2005.
-
Extra dimensions, preferred frames and ether-drift experiments
Authors:
C. M. L. de Aragao,
M. Consoli,
A. Grillo
Abstract:
Models with extra space-time dimensions produce, tipically, a 4D effective theory whose vacuum is not exactly Lorentz invariant but can be considered a physical medium whose refractive index is determined by the gravitational field. This leads to a version of relativity with a preferred frame and to look for experimental tests with the new generation of ether-drift experiments using rotating cry…
▽ More
Models with extra space-time dimensions produce, tipically, a 4D effective theory whose vacuum is not exactly Lorentz invariant but can be considered a physical medium whose refractive index is determined by the gravitational field. This leads to a version of relativity with a preferred frame and to look for experimental tests with the new generation of ether-drift experiments using rotating cryogenic optical resonators. Considering various types of cosmic motion, we formulate precise predictions for the modulations of the signal induced by the Earth's rotation and its orbital revolution around the Sun. We also compare with recent experimental results that might represent the first modern experimental evidence for a preferred frame.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.
-
Precision test for the new Michelson-Morley experiments with rotating cryogenic cavities
Authors:
M. Consoli
Abstract:
A new ether-drift experiment in Düsseldorf is currently measuring the relative frequency shift of two cryogenic optical resonators upon active rotations of the apparatus. I point out that the observed fractional amplitude of the sidereal variations of the signal in February, C_sid \sim (11 \pm 2) 10^{-16}, is entirely consistent with the expectations based on Miller's observations in the same ep…
▽ More
A new ether-drift experiment in Düsseldorf is currently measuring the relative frequency shift of two cryogenic optical resonators upon active rotations of the apparatus. I point out that the observed fractional amplitude of the sidereal variations of the signal in February, C_sid \sim (11 \pm 2) 10^{-16}, is entirely consistent with the expectations based on Miller's observations in the same epoch of the year. This leads to predict that, with future data collected in August-September, the observed sidereal variations should increase by \sim + 70 %, i.e. up to C_sid \sim (19\pm 2) 10^{-16} retaining the present normalization. This would represent clean experimental evidence for the existence of a preferred frame.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
Large logarithmic rescaling of the scalar condensate: a subtlety with substantial phenomenological implications
Authors:
P. Cea,
M. Consoli,
L. Cosmai
Abstract:
Lattice data, taken since 1998 near the critical line of a 4D Ising model, have been supporting the large logarithmic rescaling of the scalar condensate predicted in the alternative description of symmetry breaking proposed by Consoli and Stevenson. This conclusion has been challenged in a recent paper by Balog et al. In this paper we respond to the criticism of these authors, recapitulate the t…
▽ More
Lattice data, taken since 1998 near the critical line of a 4D Ising model, have been supporting the large logarithmic rescaling of the scalar condensate predicted in the alternative description of symmetry breaking proposed by Consoli and Stevenson. This conclusion has been challenged in a recent paper by Balog et al. In this paper we respond to the criticism of these authors, recapitulate the theoretical and numerical evidences in favour of the alternative interpretation of `triviality' and reiterate our conclusion: `triviality', by itself, cannot be used to place upper bounds on the Higgs boson mass.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
From classical to modern ether-drift experiments: the narrow window for a preferred frame
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
Modern ether-drift experiments look for a preferred frame by measuring the difference Δνin the relative frequencies of two cavity-stabilized lasers, upon local rotations of the apparatus or under the Earth's rotation. If the small deviations observed in the classical ether-drift experiments were not mere instrumental artifacts, by replacing the high vacuum in the resonating cavities with a diele…
▽ More
Modern ether-drift experiments look for a preferred frame by measuring the difference Δνin the relative frequencies of two cavity-stabilized lasers, upon local rotations of the apparatus or under the Earth's rotation. If the small deviations observed in the classical ether-drift experiments were not mere instrumental artifacts, by replacing the high vacuum in the resonating cavities with a dielectric gaseous medium (e.g. air), the typical measured Δν\sim 1 Hz should increase by orders of magnitude. This prediction is consistent with the characteristic modulation of a few kHz observed in the original experiment with He-Ne masers. However, if such enhancement would not be confirmed by new and more precise data, the existence of a preferred frame can be definitely ruled out.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2004;
originally announced October 2004.
-
Large logarithmic rescaling of the scalar condensate: new lattice evidences
Authors:
P. Cea,
M. Consoli,
L. Cosmai
Abstract:
Using two different methods, we have determined the rescaling of the scalar condensate $Z\equiv Z_φ$ near the critical line of a 4D Ising model. Our lattice data, in agreement with previous numerical indications, support the behavior $Z_φ\sim \ln (Λ)$, $Λ$ being the ultraviolet cutoff. This result is predicted in an alternative description of symmetry breaking where there are no upper bounds on…
▽ More
Using two different methods, we have determined the rescaling of the scalar condensate $Z\equiv Z_φ$ near the critical line of a 4D Ising model. Our lattice data, in agreement with previous numerical indications, support the behavior $Z_φ\sim \ln (Λ)$, $Λ$ being the ultraviolet cutoff. This result is predicted in an alternative description of symmetry breaking where there are no upper bounds on the Higgs boson mass from `triviality'.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
Old and new ether-drift experiments: a sharp test for a preferred frame
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
Motivated by the critical remarks of several authors, we have re-analyzed the classical ether-drift experiments with the conclusion that the small observed deviations should not be neglected. In fact, within the framework of Lorentzian Relativity, they might indicate the existence of a preferred frame relatively to which the Earth is moving with a velocity v_earth\sim 200$ km/s (value projected…
▽ More
Motivated by the critical remarks of several authors, we have re-analyzed the classical ether-drift experiments with the conclusion that the small observed deviations should not be neglected. In fact, within the framework of Lorentzian Relativity, they might indicate the existence of a preferred frame relatively to which the Earth is moving with a velocity v_earth\sim 200$ km/s (value projected in the plane of the interferometer). We have checked this idea by comparing with the modern ether-drift experiments, those where the observation of the fringe shifts is replaced by the difference Δνin the relative frequencies of two cavity-stabilized lasers, upon local rotations of the apparatus or under the Earth's rotation. It turns out that, even in this case, the most recent data are consistent with the same value of the Earth's velocity, once the vacuum within the cavities is considered a physical medium whose refractive index is fixed by General Relativity. We thus propose a sharp experimental test that can definitely resolve the issue. If the small deviations observed in the classical ether-drift experiments were not mere instrumental artifacts, by replacing the high vacuum in the resonating cavities with a dielectric gaseous medium (e.g. air), the typical measured Δν\sim 1 Hz should increase by orders of magnitude. This expectation is consistent with the characteristic modulation of a few kHz observed in the original experiment with He-Ne masers. However, if such enhancement would not be confirmed by new and more precise data, the existence of a preferred frame can be definitely ruled out.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
The Michelson-Morley experiment and the cosmic velocity of the Earth
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
The Michelson-Morley experiment was designed to detect the relative motion of the Earth with respect to a preferred reference frame, the ether, by measuring the fringe shifts in an optical interferometer. These shifts, that should have been proportional to the square of the Earth's velocity, were found to be much smaller than expected. As a consequence, that experiment was taken as an evidence t…
▽ More
The Michelson-Morley experiment was designed to detect the relative motion of the Earth with respect to a preferred reference frame, the ether, by measuring the fringe shifts in an optical interferometer. These shifts, that should have been proportional to the square of the Earth's velocity, were found to be much smaller than expected. As a consequence, that experiment was taken as an evidence that there is no ether and, as such, played a crucial role for deciding between Lorentzian Relativity and Einstein's Special Relativity. However, according to some authors, the observed Earth's velocity was not negligibly small. To provide an independent check, we have re-analyzed the fringe shifts observed in each of the six different sessions of the Michelson-Morley experiment. They are consistent with a non-zero observable Earth's velocity $v_{\rm obs} = 8.4 \pm 0.5 km/s$. Assuming the existence of a preferred reference frame and using Lorentz transformations, this $v_{\rm obs}$ corresponds to a real velocity, in the plane of the interferometer, $v_{\rm earth} = 201 \pm 12 km/s$. This value, which is remarkably consistent with 1932 Miller's cosmic solution, suggests that the magnitude of the fringe shifts is determined by the typical velocity of the solar system within our galaxy. This conclusion is consistent with the results of all classical experiments (Morley-Miller, Illingworth, Joos, Michelson-Pease-Pearson,...) and with the existing data from present-day experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
-
Quantum-hydrodynamical picture of the massive Higgs boson
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
The phenomenon of spontaneous symmetry breaking admits a physical interpretation in terms of the Bose-condensation process of elementary spinless quanta. In this picture, the broken-symmetry phase emerges as a real physical medium, endowed with a hierarchical pattern of scales, supporting two types of elementary excitations for k \to 0: a massive energy branch E_a(k) \to M_H, corresponding to th…
▽ More
The phenomenon of spontaneous symmetry breaking admits a physical interpretation in terms of the Bose-condensation process of elementary spinless quanta. In this picture, the broken-symmetry phase emerges as a real physical medium, endowed with a hierarchical pattern of scales, supporting two types of elementary excitations for k \to 0: a massive energy branch E_a(k) \to M_H, corresponding to the usual Higgs boson field, and a collective gap-less branch E_b(k) \to 0. This is similar to the coexistence of phonons and rotons in superfluid He-4 that, in fact, is usually considered the condensed-matter analog of the Higgs condensate.
After previous work dedicated to the properties of the gap-less, phonon branch, in this paper we use quantum hydrodynamics to propose a physical interpretation of the massive branch. On the base of our results, M_H coincides with the energy-gap for vortex formation and a massive Higgs boson is like a roton in superfluid He-4. Within this interpretation of the Higgs particle, there is no "naturalness" problem since M_H remains a naturally intermediate, fixed energy scale, even for an ultimate ultraviolet cutoff Lambda \to \infty.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
-
Lattice measurement of the rescaling of the scalar condensate
Authors:
P. Cea,
M. Consoli,
L. Cosmai
Abstract:
We have determined the rescaling of the scalar condensate $Z\equiv Z_φ$ near the critical line of a 4D Ising model. Our lattice data, supporting previous numerical indications, confirm the behaviour $Z_φ\sim \ln ({\rm cutoff})$. This result is predicted in an alternative description of symmetry breaking where there are no upper bounds on the Higgs boson mass from `triviality'.
We have determined the rescaling of the scalar condensate $Z\equiv Z_φ$ near the critical line of a 4D Ising model. Our lattice data, supporting previous numerical indications, confirm the behaviour $Z_φ\sim \ln ({\rm cutoff})$. This result is predicted in an alternative description of symmetry breaking where there are no upper bounds on the Higgs boson mass from `triviality'.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
-
The motion of the Solar System and the Michelson-Morley experiment
Authors:
M. Consoli,
E. Costanzo
Abstract:
Historically, the Michelson-Morley experiment has played a crucial role for abandoning the idea of a preferred reference frame, the ether, and for replacing Lorentzian Relativity with Einstein's Special Relativity. However, our re-analysis of the Michelson-Morley original data, consistently with the point of view already expressed by other authors, shows that the experimental observations have b…
▽ More
Historically, the Michelson-Morley experiment has played a crucial role for abandoning the idea of a preferred reference frame, the ether, and for replacing Lorentzian Relativity with Einstein's Special Relativity. However, our re-analysis of the Michelson-Morley original data, consistently with the point of view already expressed by other authors, shows that the experimental observations have been misinterpreted. Namely, the fringe shifts point to a non-zero observable Earth's velocity v_obs = 8.4 +/- 0.5 km/s. Assuming the existence of a preferred reference frame, and using Lorentz transformations to extract the kinematical Earth's velocity that corresponds to this v_obs, we obtain a real velocity, in the plane of the interferometer, v_earth = 201 +/- 12 km/s. This value is in excellent agreement with Miller's calculated value v_earth = 203 +/- 8 km/s and suggests that the magnitude of the fringe shifts is determined by the typical velocity of the Solar System within our galaxy. This conclusion, which is also consistent with the results of all other classical experiments, leads to an alternative interpretation of the Michelson-Morley type of experiments. Contrary to the generally accepted ideas of last century, they provide experimental evidence for the existence of a preferred reference frame. This point of view is also consistent with the most recent data for the anisotropy of the two-way speed of light in the vacuum.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
