Showing 1–50 of 78 results for author: Clifton, T

Emergent Cosmological Expansion in Scalar-Tensor Theories of Gravity

Authors: Chad Briddon, Timothy Clifton, Pierre Fleury

Abstract: We consider the emergence of large-scale cosmological expansion in scalar-tensor theories of gravity. This is achieved by modelling sub-horizon regions of space-time as weak-field expansions around Minkowski space, and then subsequently joining many such regions together to create a statistically homogeneous and isotropic cosmology. We find that when the scalar field can be treated perturbatively,… ▽ More We consider the emergence of large-scale cosmological expansion in scalar-tensor theories of gravity. This is achieved by modelling sub-horizon regions of space-time as weak-field expansions around Minkowski space, and then subsequently joining many such regions together to create a statistically homogeneous and isotropic cosmology. We find that when the scalar field can be treated perturbatively, the cosmological behaviour that emerges is well modelled by the Friedmann solutions of the theory. When non-perturbative screening mechanisms occur this result no longer holds, and in the case of scalar fields subject to the chameleon mechanism we find significant deviations from the expected Friedmann behaviour. In particular, the screened mass no longer contributes to the Klein-Gordon equation, suppressing deviations from general relativistic behaviour. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

Constraining Post-Newtonian Parameters with the Cosmic Microwave Background

Authors: Daniel B. Thomas, Theodore Anton, Timothy Clifton, Philip Bull

Abstract: The Parameterised Post-Newtonian (PPN) approach is the default framework for performing precision tests of gravity in nearby astrophysical systems. In recent works we have extended this approach for cosmological applications, and in this paper we use observations of the anisotropies in the Cosmic Microwave Background to constrain the time variation of the PPN parameters $α$ and $γ$ between last sc… ▽ More The Parameterised Post-Newtonian (PPN) approach is the default framework for performing precision tests of gravity in nearby astrophysical systems. In recent works we have extended this approach for cosmological applications, and in this paper we use observations of the anisotropies in the Cosmic Microwave Background to constrain the time variation of the PPN parameters $α$ and $γ$ between last scattering and the present day. We find their time-averages over cosmological history should be within $\sim 20\%$ of their values in GR, with $\barα=0.89^{+0.08}_{-0.09}$ and $\barγ=0.90^{+0.07}_{-0.08}$ at the $68\%$ confidence level. We also constrain the time derivatives of these parameters, and find that their present-day values should be within a factor of two of the best Solar System constraints. Many of these results have no counter-part from Solar System observations, and are entirely new constraints on the gravitational interaction. In all cases, we find that the data strongly prefer $\barα\simeq \barγ$, meaning that observers would typically find local gravitational physics to be compatible with GR, despite considerable variation of $α$ and $γ$ being allowed over cosmic history. This study lays the groundwork for future precision tests of gravity that combine observations made over all cosmological and astrophysical scales of length and time. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: Comments welcome

A Radical Solution to the Hubble Tension Problem

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Neil Hyatt

Abstract: The Hubble tension has proven to be stubbornly persistent, despite widespread efforts to relax it. As a possible resolution of this problem we propose a radical alternative to the way in which cosmological models are viewed. Specifically, we consider building cosmological models from spaces that exhibit intrinsic symmetries, rather than as space-times with explicit symmetry. This change in perspec… ▽ More The Hubble tension has proven to be stubbornly persistent, despite widespread efforts to relax it. As a possible resolution of this problem we propose a radical alternative to the way in which cosmological models are viewed. Specifically, we consider building cosmological models from spaces that exhibit intrinsic symmetries, rather than as space-times with explicit symmetry. This change in perspective allows statistical homogeneity and isotropy to be maintained, while relaxing some strong mathematical constraints that the standard approach imposes. We show that a Hubble tension arises naturally in our new approach, and that (as a corollary) a prediction can be made for the radial component of the Baryon Acoustic Oscillations. Our prediction appears to be consistent with the DESI first-year data release, which has otherwise been interpreted as evidence for dynamical dark energy. △ Less

Submitted 19 May, 2024; v1 submitted 12 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 figures

Hubble Diagrams in Statistically Homogeneous, Anisotropic Universes

Authors: Theodore Anton, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We consider the form of Hubble diagrams that would be constructed by observers in universes that are homogeneous but anisotropic, when averaged over suitably large length-scales. This is achieved by ray-tracing in different directions on the sky in families of exact inhomogeneous cosmological solutions of Einstein's equations, in order to determine the redshifts and luminosity distances that obser… ▽ More We consider the form of Hubble diagrams that would be constructed by observers in universes that are homogeneous but anisotropic, when averaged over suitably large length-scales. This is achieved by ray-tracing in different directions on the sky in families of exact inhomogeneous cosmological solutions of Einstein's equations, in order to determine the redshifts and luminosity distances that observers in these space-times would infer for distant astrophysical objects. We compare the results of this procedure to the Hubble diagrams that would be obtained by direct use of the large-scale-averaged anisotropic cosmological models, and find that observables calculated in the averaged model closely agree with those obtained from ray-tracing in all cases where a statistical homogeneity scale exists. In contrast, we find that in cosmologies with spaces that contain no statistical homogeneity scale that Hubble diagrams inferred from the averaged cosmological model can differ considerably from those that observers in the space-time would actually construct. We hope that these results will be of use for understanding and interpreting recent observations that suggest that large-scale anisotropy may have developed in the late Universe. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2024; v1 submitted 26 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 35 pages, 17 figures

Journal ref: JCAP 05 (2024) 120

Modelling the emergence of cosmic anisotropy from non-linear structures

Authors: Theodore Anton, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: Astronomical observations suggest that the Universe may be anisotropic on the largest scales. In order to model this situation, we develop a new approach to cosmology that allows for large-scale anisotropy to emerge from the growth of non-linear structure. This is achieved by decomposing all relevant fields with respect to a preferred space-like direction, and then averaging the resulting scalar q… ▽ More Astronomical observations suggest that the Universe may be anisotropic on the largest scales. In order to model this situation, we develop a new approach to cosmology that allows for large-scale anisotropy to emerge from the growth of non-linear structure. This is achieved by decomposing all relevant fields with respect to a preferred space-like direction, and then averaging the resulting scalar quantities over spatial domains. Our approach allows us to derive a set of large-scale effective field equations that govern the dynamics of any emergent large-scale anisotropy, and which (up to back-reaction terms) take the form of the field equations of the locally rotationally symmetric Bianchi cosmologies. We apply our approach to the dust-filled Farnsworth solutions, which are an interesting set of exact cosmological models that allow for both anisotropic expansion and large-scale bulk flow. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2023; v1 submitted 11 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: 33 pages, 8 figures. Typo corrected in Eq. (21)

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 40 145004 (2023)

Scale-Dependent Gravitational Couplings in Parameterised Post-Newtonian Cosmology

Authors: Daniel B. Thomas, Timothy Clifton, Theodore Anton

Abstract: Parameterised Post-Newtonian Cosmology (PPNC) is a theory-agnostic framework for testing gravity in cosmology, which connects gravitational physics on small and large scales in the Universe. It is a direct extension of the Parameterised Post-Newtonian (PPN) approach to testing gravity in isolated astrophysical systems, and therefore allows constraints on gravity from vastly different physical regi… ▽ More Parameterised Post-Newtonian Cosmology (PPNC) is a theory-agnostic framework for testing gravity in cosmology, which connects gravitational physics on small and large scales in the Universe. It is a direct extension of the Parameterised Post-Newtonian (PPN) approach to testing gravity in isolated astrophysical systems, and therefore allows constraints on gravity from vastly different physical regimes to be compared and combined. We investigate the application of this framework to a class of example scalar-tensor theories of gravity in order to verify theoretical predictions, and to investigate for the first time the scale-dependence of the gravitational couplings that appear within its perturbation equations. In doing so, we evaluate the performance of some simple interpolating functions in the transition region between small and large cosmological scales, as well as the uncertainties that using such functions would introduce into the calculation of observables. We find that all theoretical predictions of the PPNC framework are verified to high accuracy in the relevant regimes, and that simple interpolating functions perform well (but not perfectly) between these regimes. This study is an important step towards being able to use the PPNC framework to analyse cosmological datasets, and to thereby test if/how the gravitational interaction has changed as the Universe has evolved. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2023; v1 submitted 29 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 28 pages, 16 figures

Journal ref: JCAP 04 (2023) 016

The 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet Theory of Gravity: A Review

Authors: Pedro G. S. Fernandes, Pedro Carrilho, Timothy Clifton, David J. Mulryne

Abstract: We review the topic of 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity, which has been the subject of considerable interest over the past two years. Our review begins with a general introduction to Lovelock's theorem, and the subject of Gauss-Bonnet terms in the action for gravity. These areas are of fundamental importance for understanding modified theories of gravity, and inform our subsequent discussion of re… ▽ More We review the topic of 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity, which has been the subject of considerable interest over the past two years. Our review begins with a general introduction to Lovelock's theorem, and the subject of Gauss-Bonnet terms in the action for gravity. These areas are of fundamental importance for understanding modified theories of gravity, and inform our subsequent discussion of recent attempts to include the effects of a Gauss-Bonnet term in four space-time dimensions by re-scaling the appropriate coupling parameter. We discuss the mathematical complexities involved in implementing this idea, and review recent attempts at constructing well-defined, self-consistent theories that enact it. We then move on to consider the gravitational physics that results from these theories, in the context of black holes, cosmology, and weak-field gravity. We show that 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity exhibits a number of interesting phenomena in each of these areas. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 57 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 39 (2022) 063001

The momentum constraint equation in Parameterised Post-Newtonian Cosmology

Authors: Theodore Anton, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We derive a theory-independent version of the momentum constraint equation for use in cosmology, as a part of the Parameterised Post-Newtonian Cosmology (PPNC) framework. Our equations are constructed by adapting the corresponding quantities from formalisms devised for testing and constraining gravity in isolated astrophysical systems, thereby extending the domain of applicability of these approac… ▽ More We derive a theory-independent version of the momentum constraint equation for use in cosmology, as a part of the Parameterised Post-Newtonian Cosmology (PPNC) framework. Our equations are constructed by adapting the corresponding quantities from formalisms devised for testing and constraining gravity in isolated astrophysical systems, thereby extending the domain of applicability of these approaches up to cosmological scales. Our parameterised equations include both scalar and divergenceless-vector gravitational potentials, and can be applied to both conservative and non-conservative theories of gravity. They can also be used to describe the gravitational fields of both non-linear structures and super-horizon perturbations. We apply the parameterised equations we propose to quintessence models of dark energy, as well as to scalar-tensor and vector-tensor theories of gravity. We find them to work well in each case. Our equations are highly compact, and are intended to be useful for constraining gravity in a theory-independent fashion in cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2022; v1 submitted 21 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 26 pages, 2 figures, v2. Matches version published in CQG

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 39 (2022) 095005

Black Holes in the Scalar-Tensor Formulation of 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet Gravity: Uniqueness of Solutions, and a New Candidate for Dark Matter

Authors: Pedro G. S. Fernandes, Pedro Carrilho, Timothy Clifton, David J. Mulryne

Abstract: In this work we study static black holes in the regularized 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet theory of gravity; a shift-symmetric scalar-tensor theory that belongs to the Horndeski class. This theory features a simple black hole solution that can be written in closed form, and which we show is the unique static, spherically-symmetric and asymptotically-flat black hole vacuum solution of the theory. We fur… ▽ More In this work we study static black holes in the regularized 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet theory of gravity; a shift-symmetric scalar-tensor theory that belongs to the Horndeski class. This theory features a simple black hole solution that can be written in closed form, and which we show is the unique static, spherically-symmetric and asymptotically-flat black hole vacuum solution of the theory. We further show that no asymptotically-flat, time-dependent, spherically-symmetric perturbations to this geometry are allowed, which suggests that it may be the only spherically-symmetric vacuum solution that this theory admits (a result analogous to Birkhoff's theorem). Finally, we consider the thermodynamic properties of these black holes, and find that their final state after evaporation is a remnant with a size determined by the coupling constant of the theory. We speculate that remnants of this kind from primordial black holes could act as dark matter, and we constrain the parameter space for their formation mass, as well as the coupling constant of the theory. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 104, 044029 (2021)

Multi-Scale Perturbation Theory II: Solutions and Leading-Order Bispectrum in the $Λ$CDM Universe

Authors: Christopher S. Gallagher, Timothy Clifton, Chris Clarkson

Abstract: Two-parameter perturbation theory (2PPT) is a framework designed to include the relativistic gravitational effects of small-scale nonlinear structures on the large-scale properties of the Universe. In this paper we use the 2PPT framework to calculate and study the bispectrum of matter in a spatially-flat $Λ$CDM cosmology. This is achieved by deploying Newtonian perturbation theory to model the gra… ▽ More Two-parameter perturbation theory (2PPT) is a framework designed to include the relativistic gravitational effects of small-scale nonlinear structures on the large-scale properties of the Universe. In this paper we use the 2PPT framework to calculate and study the bispectrum of matter in a spatially-flat $Λ$CDM cosmology. This is achieved by deploying Newtonian perturbation theory to model the gravitational fields of quasi-nonlinear structures, and then subsequently using them as source terms for the large-scale cosmological perturbations. We find that our approach reproduces some of the expected relativistic effects from second-order cosmological perturbation theory, but not all. This work therefore provides a first step in deploying a formalism that can simultaneously model the weak gravitational fields of both linear and nonlinear structures in a realistic model of the Universe. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2021; v1 submitted 9 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 21 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: JCAP 08 (2021) 048

Observational Constraints on the Regularized 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet Theory of Gravity

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Pedro Carrilho, Pedro G. S. Fernandes, David J. Mulryne

Abstract: In this paper we study the observational constraints that can be imposed on the coupling parameter, $\hat α$, of the regularized version of the 4-dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet theory of gravity. We use the scalar-tensor field equations of this theory to perform a thorough investigation of its slow-motion and weak-field limit, and apply our results to observations of a wide array of physical sy… ▽ More In this paper we study the observational constraints that can be imposed on the coupling parameter, $\hat α$, of the regularized version of the 4-dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet theory of gravity. We use the scalar-tensor field equations of this theory to perform a thorough investigation of its slow-motion and weak-field limit, and apply our results to observations of a wide array of physical systems that admit such a description. We find that the LAGEOS satellites are the most constraining, requiring $| \hat α| \lesssim 10^{10} \,{\rm m}^2$. This constraint suggests that the possibility of large deviations from general relativity is small in all systems except the very early universe ($t<10^{-3}\, {\rm s}$), or the immediate vicinity of stellar-mass black holes ($M\lesssim100\, M_{\odot}$). We then consider constraints that can be imposed on this theory from cosmology, black hole systems, and table-top experiments. It is found that early universe inflation prohibits all but the smallest negative values of $\hat α$, while observations of binary black hole systems are likely to offer the tightest constraints on positive values, leading to overall bounds $0 \lesssim \hat α\lesssim 10^8 \, {\rm m}^2$. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2020; v1 submitted 26 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 17 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 102, 084005 (2020)

Derivation of Regularized Field Equations for the Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet Theory in Four Dimensions

Authors: Pedro G. S. Fernandes, Pedro Carrilho, Timothy Clifton, David J. Mulryne

Abstract: We propose a regularization procedure for the novel Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet theory of gravity, which produces a set of field equations that can be written in closed form in four dimensions. Our method consists of introducing a counter term into the action, and does not rely on the embedding or compactification of any higher-dimensional spaces. This counterterm is sufficient to cancel the divergence… ▽ More We propose a regularization procedure for the novel Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet theory of gravity, which produces a set of field equations that can be written in closed form in four dimensions. Our method consists of introducing a counter term into the action, and does not rely on the embedding or compactification of any higher-dimensional spaces. This counterterm is sufficient to cancel the divergence in the action that would otherwise occur, and exactly reproduces the trace of the field equations of the original formulation of the theory. All other field equations display an extra scalar gravitational degree of freedom in the gravitational sector, in kee** with the requirements of Lovelock's theorem. We discuss issues concerning the equivalence between our new regularized theory and the original. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2020; v1 submitted 17 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 6 pages + 2 pages with references; V2: Published in Physical Review D

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 102, 024025 (2020)

Viable Gauge Choices in Cosmologies with Non-Linear Structures

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Christopher S. Gallagher, Sophia Goldberg, Karim A. Malik

Abstract: A variety of gauges are used in cosmological perturbation theory. These are often chosen in order to attribute physical properties to a particular choice of coordinates, or otherwise to simplify the form of the resultant equations. Calculations are then performed with the understanding that they could have been done in any gauge, and that transformations between different gauges can be made at wil… ▽ More A variety of gauges are used in cosmological perturbation theory. These are often chosen in order to attribute physical properties to a particular choice of coordinates, or otherwise to simplify the form of the resultant equations. Calculations are then performed with the understanding that they could have been done in any gauge, and that transformations between different gauges can be made at will. We show that this logic can be extended to the domain of large density contrasts, where different types of perturbative expansion are required, but that the way in which gauges can be chosen in the presence of such structures is severely constrained. In particular, most gauges that are commonly considered in the cosmology literature are found to be unviable in the presence of non-linear structures. This includes spatially flat gauge, synchronous gauge, comoving orthogonal gauge, total matter gauge, N-body gauge, and the uniform density gauge. In contrast, we find that the longitudinal gauge and the Newtonian motion gauge are both viable choices in both standard cosmological perturbation theory, and in the post-Newtonian perturbative expansions that are required in order to model non-linear structures. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2020; v1 submitted 2 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 063530 (2020)

Multi-Scale Perturbation Theory I: Methodology and Leading-Order Bispectrum Corrections in the Matter-Dominated Era

Authors: Christopher Gallagher, Timothy Clifton, Chris Clarkson

Abstract: Two-parameter perturbation theory is a scheme tailor-made to consistently include nonlinear density contrasts on small scales ($<100\; \mathrm{Mpc}$), whilst retaining a traditional approach to cosmological perturbations in the long-wavelength universe. In this paper we study the solutions that arise from this theory in a spatially-flat dust-filled cosmology, and what these imply for the bispectru… ▽ More Two-parameter perturbation theory is a scheme tailor-made to consistently include nonlinear density contrasts on small scales ($<100\; \mathrm{Mpc}$), whilst retaining a traditional approach to cosmological perturbations in the long-wavelength universe. In this paper we study the solutions that arise from this theory in a spatially-flat dust-filled cosmology, and what these imply for the bispectrum of matter. This is achieved by using Newtonian perturbation theory to model the gravitational fields of nonlinear structures in the quasi-linear regime, and then using the resulting solutions as source terms for the cosmological equations. We find that our approach results in the leading-order part of the cosmological gravitational potentials being identical to those that result from standard cosmological perturbation theory at second-order, while the dark matter bispectrum itself yields some differences on Hubble scales. This demonstrates that our approach is sufficient to capture most leading-order relativistic effects, but within a framework that is far easier to generalize. We expect this latter property to be particularly useful for calculating leading-order relativistic corrections to the matter power spectrum, as well as for deriving predictions for relativistic effects in alternative theories of gravity. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2020; v1 submitted 10 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 51 pages, 14 figures

Cosmological Backreaction in Spherical and Plane Symmetric Dust-Filled Space-Times

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Roberto A. Sussman

Abstract: We examine the implementation of Buchert's and Green & Wald's averaging formalisms in exact spherically symmetric and plane symmetric dust-filled cosmological models. We find that, given a cosmological space-time, Buchert's averaging scheme gives a faithful way of interpreting the large-scale expansion of space, and explicit terms that precisely quantify deviations from the behaviour expected from… ▽ More We examine the implementation of Buchert's and Green & Wald's averaging formalisms in exact spherically symmetric and plane symmetric dust-filled cosmological models. We find that, given a cosmological space-time, Buchert's averaging scheme gives a faithful way of interpreting the large-scale expansion of space, and explicit terms that precisely quantify deviations from the behaviour expected from the Friedmann equations of homogeneous and isotropic cosmological models. The Green & Wald formalism, on the other hand, does not appear to yield any information about the large-scale properties of a given inhomogeneous space-time. Instead, this formalism is designed to calculate the back-reaction effects of short-wavelength fluctuations around a given "background" geometry. We find that the inferred expansion of space in this approach is entirely dependent on the choice of this background, which is not uniquely specified for any given inhomogeneous space-time, and that the "back-reaction" from small-scale structures vanishes in every case we study. This would appear to limit the applicability of Green & Wald's formalism to the study of large-scale expansion in the real Universe, which also has no pre-defined background. Further study is required to enhance the evaluation and comparison of these averaging formalisms, and determine whether the same difficulties exist, in less idealized space-time geometries. △ Less

Submitted 19 September, 2019; v1 submitted 4 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 34 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 36 (2019) 205004

Discrete Cosmological Models in the Brans-Dicke Theory of Gravity

Authors: Jessie Durk, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We consider the problem of building inhomogeneous cosmological models in scalar-tensor theories of gravity. This starts by splitting the field equations of these theories into constraint and evolution equations, and then proceeds by identifying exact solutions to the constraints. We find exact, closed form expressions for geometries that correspond to the initial data for cosmological models conta… ▽ More We consider the problem of building inhomogeneous cosmological models in scalar-tensor theories of gravity. This starts by splitting the field equations of these theories into constraint and evolution equations, and then proceeds by identifying exact solutions to the constraints. We find exact, closed form expressions for geometries that correspond to the initial data for cosmological models containing regular arrays of point-like masses. These solutions extend similar methods that have recently been applied to Einstein's equations, and provides sufficient initial conditions to perform numerical integration of the evolution equations. We use our new solutions to study the effects of inhomogeneity in cosmologies governed by scalar-tensor theories of gravity, including the spatial inhomogeneity allowed in Newton's constant. Finally, we compare our solutions to their general relativistic counterparts, and investigate the effect of changing the coupling constant between the scalar and tensor degrees of freedom. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 2019; v1 submitted 7 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 18 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 36 (2019) 185011

Relativistic Euler Equations in cosmologies with non-linear structures

Authors: Christopher S. Gallagher, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We consider a new variant of cosmological perturbation theory that has been designed specifically to include non-linear density contrasts on scales 100 Mpc, while still allowing for linear fluctuations on larger scales. This theory is used to derive the relativistic equations of Eulerian hydrodynamics in realistic cosmological scenarios that contain radiation and a cosmological constant, as well a… ▽ More We consider a new variant of cosmological perturbation theory that has been designed specifically to include non-linear density contrasts on scales 100 Mpc, while still allowing for linear fluctuations on larger scales. This theory is used to derive the relativistic equations of Eulerian hydrodynamics in realistic cosmological scenarios that contain radiation and a cosmological constant, as well as matter that has been allowed to clump into galaxies and clusters of galaxies. These equations can be used to evolve energy densities and velocities in the presences of small-scale non-linear structures, and on scales all the way up to the horizon and beyond. The leading-order part of these equations reproduces the expected Newtonian equations, while subsequent orders prescribe relativistic corrections. We demonstrate that these evolution equations are consistent with maintaining the Einstein constraints, and hence that the system as a whole is mathematically well posed. The relativistic corrections that we derive are found to exhibit non-trivial interactions between perturbations on different scales, as well as the mixing of scalar, vector and tensor modes. They deviate from those that occur in both post-Friedmann and standard cosmological perturbation theory approaches, and point towards new relativistic effects that could be measurable by upcoming ultra-large-scale surveys. △ Less

Submitted 5 April, 2019; v1 submitted 4 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 13 pages, 1 appendix

MSC Class: 83F05

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 103516 (2018)

Parametrizing theories of gravity on large and small scales in cosmology

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Viraj A. A. Sanghai

Abstract: We present a link between parametrizations of alternative theories of gravity on large and small scales in cosmology. This relationship is established using theoretical consistency conditions only. We find that in both limits the "slip" and "effective Newton's constant" can be written in terms of a set of four functions of time, two of which are direct generalizations of the $α$ and $γ$ parameters… ▽ More We present a link between parametrizations of alternative theories of gravity on large and small scales in cosmology. This relationship is established using theoretical consistency conditions only. We find that in both limits the "slip" and "effective Newton's constant" can be written in terms of a set of four functions of time, two of which are direct generalizations of the $α$ and $γ$ parameters from post-Newtonian physics. This generalizes previous work that has constructed frameworks for testing gravity on small scales, and is to the best of our knowledge the first time that a link between parametrizations of gravity on such very different scales has been established. We expect our result to facilitate the imposition of observational constraints, by drastically reducing the number of functional degrees of freedom required to consistently test gravity on multiple scales in cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2019; v1 submitted 3 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 011301 (2019)

Black-Hole Lattices as Cosmological Models

Authors: Eloisa Bentivegna, Timothy Clifton, Jessie Durk, Mikołaj Korzyński, Kjell Rosquist

Abstract: The search for solutions of Einstein's equations representing relativistic cosmological models with a discrete matter content has been remarkably fruitful in the last decade. In this review we discuss the progress made in the study of a specific subclass of discrete cosmologies, Black-Hole Lattice models. In particular, we illustrate the techniques used for the construction of these spacetimes, an… ▽ More The search for solutions of Einstein's equations representing relativistic cosmological models with a discrete matter content has been remarkably fruitful in the last decade. In this review we discuss the progress made in the study of a specific subclass of discrete cosmologies, Black-Hole Lattice models. In particular, we illustrate the techniques used for the construction of these spacetimes, and examine their resulting physical properties. This includes their large-scale dynamics, the dressing of mass due to the interaction between individual black holes, along with features of direct observational interest such as the distance-to-redshift relation. This collection of results provides a novel perspective on the physical effects of averaging in General Relativity, as well as on the emergence of gravitational structures from solutions with isolated objects. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 54 pages, 16 figures, review prepared for the CQG Special Focus Issue "Computational issues in mathematical cosmology"

A Quasi-Static Approach to Structure Formation in Black Hole Universes

Authors: Jessie Durk, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: Motivated by the existence of hierarchies of structure in the Universe, we present four new families of exact initial data for inhomogeneous cosmological models at their maximum of expansion. These data generalise existing black hole lattice models to situations that contain clusters of masses, and hence allow the consequences of cosmological structures to be considered in a well-defined and non-p… ▽ More Motivated by the existence of hierarchies of structure in the Universe, we present four new families of exact initial data for inhomogeneous cosmological models at their maximum of expansion. These data generalise existing black hole lattice models to situations that contain clusters of masses, and hence allow the consequences of cosmological structures to be considered in a well-defined and non-perturbative fashion. The degree of clustering is controlled by a parameter $λ$, in such a way that for $λ\sim 0$ or $1$ we have very tightly clustered masses, whilst for $λ\sim 0.5$ all masses are separated by cosmological distance scales. We study the consequences of structure formation on the total net mass in each of our clusters, as well as calculating the cosmological consequences of the interaction energies both within and between clusters. The locations of the shared horizons that appear around groups of black holes, when they are brought sufficiently close together, are also identified and studied. We find that clustering can have surprisingly large effects on the scale of the cosmology, with models that contain thousands of black holes sometimes being as little as 30% of the size of comparable Friedmann models with the same total proper mass. This deficit is comparable to what might be expected to occur from neglecting gravitational interaction energies in Friedmann cosmology, and suggests that these quantities may have a significant influence on the properties of the large-scale cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2017; v1 submitted 25 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 33 pages, 10 figures, v2: matches published version, typos corrected

Journal ref: JCAP 10 (2017) 012

Perturbation theory for cosmologies with non-linear structure

Authors: Sophia R. Goldberg, Christopher Gallagher, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: The next generation of cosmological surveys will operate over unprecedented scales, and will therefore provide exciting new opportunities for testing general relativity. The standard method for modelling the structures that these surveys will observe is to use cosmological perturbation theory for linear structures on horizon-sized scales, and Newtonian gravity for non-linear structures on much sma… ▽ More The next generation of cosmological surveys will operate over unprecedented scales, and will therefore provide exciting new opportunities for testing general relativity. The standard method for modelling the structures that these surveys will observe is to use cosmological perturbation theory for linear structures on horizon-sized scales, and Newtonian gravity for non-linear structures on much smaller scales. We propose a two-parameter formalism that generalizes this approach, thereby allowing interactions between large and small scales to be studied in a self-consistent and well-defined way. This uses both post-Newtonian gravity and cosmological perturbation theory, and can be used to model realistic cosmological scenarios including matter, radiation and a cosmological constant. We find that the resulting field equations can be written as a hierarchical set of perturbation equations. At leading-order, these equations allow us to recover a standard set of Friedmann equations, as well as a Newton-Poisson equation for the inhomogeneous part of the Newtonian energy density in an expanding background. For the perturbations in the large-scale cosmology, however, we find that the field equations are sourced by both non-linear and mode-mixing terms, due to the existence of small-scale structures. These extra terms should be expected to give rise to new gravitational effects, through the mixing of gravitational modes on small and large scales - effects that are beyond the scope of standard linear cosmological perturbation theory. We expect our formalism to be useful for accurately modelling gravitational physics in universes that contain non-linear structures, and for investigating the effects of non-linear gravity in the era of ultra-large-scale surveys. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2018; v1 submitted 4 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: "21 pages, 2 appendices. Equations (29) and (80) have been corrected from the published version."

MSC Class: 83F05

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 96, 103508 (2017)

Ray tracing and Hubble diagrams in post-Newtonian cosmology

Authors: Viraj A. A. Sanghai, Pierre Fleury, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: On small scales the observable Universe is highly inhomogeneous, with galaxies and clusters forming a complex web of voids and filaments. The optical properties of such configurations can be quite different from the perfectly smooth Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) solutions that are frequently used in cosmology, and must be well understood if we are to make precise inferences about fund… ▽ More On small scales the observable Universe is highly inhomogeneous, with galaxies and clusters forming a complex web of voids and filaments. The optical properties of such configurations can be quite different from the perfectly smooth Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) solutions that are frequently used in cosmology, and must be well understood if we are to make precise inferences about fundamental physics from cosmological observations. We investigate this problem by calculating redshifts and luminosity distances within a class of cosmological models that are constructed explicitly in order to allow for large density contrasts on small scales. Our study of optics is then achieved by propagating one hundred thousand null geodesics through such space-times, with matter arranged in either compact opaque objects or diffuse transparent haloes. We find that in the absence of opaque objects, the mean of our ray tracing results faithfully reproduces the expectations from FLRW cosmology. When opaque objects with sizes similar to those of galactic bulges are introduced, however, we find that the mean of distance measures can be shifted up from FLRW predictions by as much as $10\%$. This bias is due to the viable photon trajectories being restricted by the presence of the opaque objects, which means that they cannot probe the regions of space-time with the highest curvature. It corresponds to a positive bias of order $10\%$ in the estimation of $Ω_Λ$ and highlights the important consequences that astronomical selection effects can have on cosmological observables. △ Less

Submitted 18 July, 2017; v1 submitted 5 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: 37 pages, 15 figures, 1 table, v2: matches published version

Journal ref: JCAP 07 (2017) 028

Cosmological Solutions with Charged Black Holes

Authors: Rashida Bibi, Timothy Clifton, Jessie Durk

Abstract: We consider the problem of constructing cosmological solutions of the Einstein-Maxwell equations that contain multiple charged black holes. By considering the field equations as a set of constraint and evolution equations, we construct exact initial data for N charged black holes on a hypersphere. This corresponds to the maximum of expansion of a cosmological solution, and provides sufficient info… ▽ More We consider the problem of constructing cosmological solutions of the Einstein-Maxwell equations that contain multiple charged black holes. By considering the field equations as a set of constraint and evolution equations, we construct exact initial data for N charged black holes on a hypersphere. This corresponds to the maximum of expansion of a cosmological solution, and provides sufficient information for a unique evolution. We then consider the specific example of a universe that contains eight charged black holes, and show that the existence of non-zero electric charge reduces the scale of the cosmological region of the space. These solutions generalize the Majumdar-Papapetrou solutions away from the extremal limit of charged black holes, and provide what we believe to be some of the first relativistic calculations of the effects of electric charge on cosmological backreaction. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2017; v1 submitted 4 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: 14 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Gen. Rel. Grav. 49 (2017) 98

Black holes as echoes of previous cosmic cycles

Authors: Bernard Carr, Timothy Clifton, Alan Coley

Abstract: The existence of exact solutions which represent a lattice of black holes at a scalar-field-dominated cosmological bounce suggests that black holes could persist through successive eras of a cyclic cosmology. Here we explore some remarkable cosmological consequences of this proposal. In different mass ranges pre-big-bang black holes could explain the dark matter, provide seeds for galaxies, genera… ▽ More The existence of exact solutions which represent a lattice of black holes at a scalar-field-dominated cosmological bounce suggests that black holes could persist through successive eras of a cyclic cosmology. Here we explore some remarkable cosmological consequences of this proposal. In different mass ranges pre-big-bang black holes could explain the dark matter, provide seeds for galaxies, generate entropy and even drive the bounce itself. The cycles end naturally when the filling factor of the black holes reaches unity and this could entail a dimensional transition. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 5 pages. Essay written for the Gravity Research Foundation 2017 Awards for Essays on Gravitation

Persistent Black Holes in Bouncing Cosmologies

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Bernard Carr, Alan Coley

Abstract: In this paper we explore the idea that black holes can persist in a universe that collapses to a big crunch and then bounces into a new phase of expansion. We use a scalar field to model the matter content of such a universe {near the time} of the bounce, and look for solutions that represent a network of black holes within a dynamical cosmology. We find exact solutions to Einstein's constraint eq… ▽ More In this paper we explore the idea that black holes can persist in a universe that collapses to a big crunch and then bounces into a new phase of expansion. We use a scalar field to model the matter content of such a universe {near the time} of the bounce, and look for solutions that represent a network of black holes within a dynamical cosmology. We find exact solutions to Einstein's constraint equations that provide the geometry of space at the minimum of expansion and that can be used as initial data for the evolution of hyperspherical cosmologies. These solutions illustrate that there exist models in which multiple distinct black holes can persist through a bounce, and allow for concrete computations of quantities such as the black hole filling factor. We then consider solutions in flat cosmologies, as well as in higher-dimensional spaces (with up to nine spatial dimensions). We derive conditions for the black holes to remain distinct (i.e. avoid merging) and hence persist into the new expansion phase. Some potentially interesting consequences of these models are also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2017; v1 submitted 20 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 37 pages, 16 figures

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 34 (2017) 135005

Cosmology on all scales: a two-parameter perturbation expansion

Authors: Sophia R. Goldberg, Timothy Clifton, Karim A. Malik

Abstract: We propose and construct a two-parameter perturbative expansion around a Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker geometry that can be used to model high-order gravitational effects in the presence of non-linear structure. This framework reduces to the weak-field and slow-motion post-Newtonian treatment of gravity in the appropriate limits, but also includes the low-amplitude large-scale fluctuations t… ▽ More We propose and construct a two-parameter perturbative expansion around a Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker geometry that can be used to model high-order gravitational effects in the presence of non-linear structure. This framework reduces to the weak-field and slow-motion post-Newtonian treatment of gravity in the appropriate limits, but also includes the low-amplitude large-scale fluctuations that are important for cosmological modelling. We derive a set of field equations that can be applied to the late Universe, where non-linear structure exists on supercluster scales, and perform a detailed investigation of the associated gauge problem. This allows us to identify a consistent set of perturbed quantities in both the gravitational and matter sectors, and to construct a set of gauge-invariant quantities that correspond to each of them. The field equations, written in terms of these quantities, take on a relatively simple form, and allow the effects of small-scale structure on the large-scale properties of the Universe to be clearly identified. We find that inhomogeneous structures source the global expansion, that there exist new field equations at new orders, and that there is vector gravitational potential that is a hundred times larger than one might naively expect from cosmological perturbation theory. Finally, we expect our formalism to be of use for calculating relativistic effects in upcoming ultra-large-scale surveys, as the form of the gravitational coupling between small and large scales depends on the non-linearity of Einstein's equations, and occurs at what is normally thought of as first order in cosmological perturbations. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2016; v1 submitted 27 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 34 pages, 2 figures, typos corrected, references added

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 95, 043503 (2017)

Parameterized Post-Newtonian Cosmology

Authors: Viraj A. A. Sanghai, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: Einstein's theory of gravity has been extensively tested on solar system scales, and for isolated astrophysical systems, using the perturbative framework known as the parameterized post-Newtonian (PPN) formalism. This framework is designed for use in the weak-field and slow-motion limit of gravity, and can be used to constrain a large class of metric theories of gravity with data collected from th… ▽ More Einstein's theory of gravity has been extensively tested on solar system scales, and for isolated astrophysical systems, using the perturbative framework known as the parameterized post-Newtonian (PPN) formalism. This framework is designed for use in the weak-field and slow-motion limit of gravity, and can be used to constrain a large class of metric theories of gravity with data collected from the aforementioned systems. Given the potential of future surveys to probe cosmological scales to high precision, it is a topic of much contemporary interest to construct a similar framework to link Einstein's theory of gravity and its alternatives to observations on cosmological scales. Our approach to this problem is to adapt and extend the existing PPN formalism for use in cosmology. We derive a set of equations that use the same parameters to consistently model both weak fields and cosmology. This allows us to parameterize a large class of modified theories of gravity and dark energy models on cosmological scales, using just four functions of time. These four functions can be directly linked to the background expansion of the universe, first-order cosmological perturbations, and the weak-field limit of the theory. They also reduce to the standard PPN parameters on solar system scales. We illustrate how dark energy models and scalar-tensor and vector-tensor theories of gravity fit into this framework, which we refer to as "parameterized post-Newtonian cosmology" (PPNC). △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2017; v1 submitted 25 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 30 pages, no figures, v2: matches published version

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 34 (2017) 065003

Exact Initial Data for Black Hole Universes with a Cosmological Constant

Authors: Jessie Durk, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We construct exact initial data for closed cosmological models filled with regularly arranged black holes in the presence of $Λ$. The intrinsic geometry of the 3-dimensional space described by this data is a sum of simple closed-form expressions, while the extrinsic curvature is just proportional to $Λ$. We determine the mass of each of the black holes in this space by performing a limiting proced… ▽ More We construct exact initial data for closed cosmological models filled with regularly arranged black holes in the presence of $Λ$. The intrinsic geometry of the 3-dimensional space described by this data is a sum of simple closed-form expressions, while the extrinsic curvature is just proportional to $Λ$. We determine the mass of each of the black holes in this space by performing a limiting procedure around the location of each of the black holes, and then compare the result to an appropriate slice through the Schwarzschild-de Sitter spacetime. The consequences of the inhomogeneity of this model for the large-scale expansion of space are then found by comparing the lengths of curves in the cosmological region to similar curves in a suitably chosen Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) solution. Finally, we locate the positions of the apparent horizons of the black holes, and determine the extremal values of their mass, for every possible regular arrangement of masses. We find that as the number of black holes is increased, the large-scale expansion of space approaches that of an FLRW model filled with dust and $Λ$, and that the extremal values of the black hole masses approaches that of the Schwarzschild-de Sitter solution. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2017; v1 submitted 18 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 19 pages, 5 figures, v2: matches published version

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 34 (2017) 065009

The Magnetic Part of the Weyl Tensor, and the Expansion of Discrete Universes

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Daniele Gregoris, Kjell Rosquist

Abstract: We examine the effect that the magnetic part of the Weyl tensor has on the large-scale expansion of space. This is done within the context of a class of cosmological models that contain regularly arranged discrete masses, rather than a continuous perfect fluid. The natural set of geodesic curves that one should use to consider the cosmological expansion of these models requires the existence of a… ▽ More We examine the effect that the magnetic part of the Weyl tensor has on the large-scale expansion of space. This is done within the context of a class of cosmological models that contain regularly arranged discrete masses, rather than a continuous perfect fluid. The natural set of geodesic curves that one should use to consider the cosmological expansion of these models requires the existence of a non-zero magnetic part of the Weyl tensor. We include this object in the evolution equations of these models by performing a Taylor series expansion about a hypersurface where it initially vanishes. At the same cosmological time, measured as a fraction of the age of the universe, we find that the influence of the magnetic part of the Weyl tensor increases as the number of masses in the universe is increased. We also find that the influence of the magnetic part of the Weyl tensor increases with time, relative to the leading-order electric part, so that its contribution to the scale of the universe can reach values of ~1%, before the Taylor series approximation starts to break down. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2017; v1 submitted 4 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 42 pages, 27 figures

Journal ref: Gen Rel Grav 49(2), 1-40 (2017)

Cosmological backreaction in the presence of radiation and a cosmological constant

Authors: Viraj A. A. Sanghai, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We construct high-precision models of the Universe that contain radiation, a cosmological constant, and periodically distributed inhomogeneous matter. The density contrasts in these models are allowed to be highly non-linear, and the cosmological expansion is treated as an emergent phenomenon. This is achieved by employing a generalised version of the post-Newtonian formalism, and by joining toget… ▽ More We construct high-precision models of the Universe that contain radiation, a cosmological constant, and periodically distributed inhomogeneous matter. The density contrasts in these models are allowed to be highly non-linear, and the cosmological expansion is treated as an emergent phenomenon. This is achieved by employing a generalised version of the post-Newtonian formalism, and by joining together inhomogeneous regions of space-time at reflection symmetric junctions. Using these models, we find general expressions that precisely and unambiguously quantify the effect of small-scale inhomogeneity on the large-scale expansion of space (an effect referred to as "back-reaction", in the literature). We then proceed to specialize our models to the case where the matter fields are given by a regular array of point-like particles. This allows us to derive extremely simple expressions for the emergent Friedmann-like equations that govern the large-scale expansion of space. It is found that the presence of radiation tends to reduce the magnitude of back-reaction effects, while the existence of a cosmological constant has only a negligible effect. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2017; v1 submitted 21 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: 14 pages, 12 figures, v2: matches published version, v3: typo corrected in Eq. (59)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 94, 023505 (2016)

What's the Matter in Cosmology?

Authors: Timothy Clifton

Abstract: Almost all models of the universe start by assuming that matter fields can be modelled as dust. In the real universe, however, matter is clumped into dense objects that are separated by regions of space that are almost empty. If we are to treat such a distribution of matter as being modelled as a fluid, in some average or coarse-grained sense, then there a number of questions that must be answered… ▽ More Almost all models of the universe start by assuming that matter fields can be modelled as dust. In the real universe, however, matter is clumped into dense objects that are separated by regions of space that are almost empty. If we are to treat such a distribution of matter as being modelled as a fluid, in some average or coarse-grained sense, then there a number of questions that must be answered. One of the most fundamental of these is whether or not the interaction energy between masses should gravitate. If it does, then a dust-like description may not be sufficient. We would then need to ask how interaction energies should be calculated in cosmology, and how they should appear in the Friedmann-like equations that govern the large-scale behaviour of the universe. I will discuss some recent results that may shed light on these questions. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 6 pages. Contribution to the proceedings of MG14

Embedding Non-Linear Structures in f(R) Cosmologies

Authors: Timothy Clifton

Abstract: When using Einstein's equations, there exist a number of techniques for embedding non-linear structures in cosmological backgrounds. These include Swiss cheese models, in which spherically symmetric vacua are patched onto Friedmann solutions, and lattice models, in which weak-field regions are joined together directly. In this talk we will consider how these methods work in f(R) theories of gravit… ▽ More When using Einstein's equations, there exist a number of techniques for embedding non-linear structures in cosmological backgrounds. These include Swiss cheese models, in which spherically symmetric vacua are patched onto Friedmann solutions, and lattice models, in which weak-field regions are joined together directly. In this talk we will consider how these methods work in f(R) theories of gravity. We will show that their existence places constraints on the large-scale expansion of the universe, and that it may not always be possible to consider the Friedmann solutions and weak-field solutions of a theory independently from each other. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 6 pages. Contribution to the proceedings of MG14

Post-Newtonian Cosmological Modelling

Authors: Viraj A. A. Sanghai, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We develop a new approach to building cosmological models, in which small pieces of perturbed Minkowski space are joined together at reflection-symmetric boundaries in order to form a global, dynamical space-time. Each piece of this patchwork universe is described using post-Newtonian gravitational physics, with the large-scale expansion of the universe being an emergent phenomenon. This approach… ▽ More We develop a new approach to building cosmological models, in which small pieces of perturbed Minkowski space are joined together at reflection-symmetric boundaries in order to form a global, dynamical space-time. Each piece of this patchwork universe is described using post-Newtonian gravitational physics, with the large-scale expansion of the universe being an emergent phenomenon. This approach to cosmology does not require any assumptions about non-local averaging processes. Our framework clarifies the relation between the weak-field limit of general relativity, and the cosmological solutions that result from solving Einstein's equations with a set of symmetry assumptions. It also allows the effects of structure formation on the large-scale expansion of the universe to be investigated in an unambiguous way. As an explicit example, we use this formalism to investigate the cosmological behaviour of a large number of regularly arranged point-like masses. In this case we find that the large-scale expansion is well modelled by a Friedmann-like equation that contains terms that take the form of dust, radiation, and spatial curvature. The radiation term, while small compared to the dust term, is purely a result of the non-linearity of Einstein's equations. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2016; v1 submitted 30 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 22 pages, 5 figures, v2: Published version, v4: Corrections to published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 103532 (2015) (erratum: Phys. Rev. D 93, 089903 (2016))

On the Emergence of Accelerating Cosmic Expansion in f(R) Theories of Gravity

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Peter K. S. Dunsby

Abstract: We consider cosmological modelling in $f(R)$ theories of gravity, using both top-down and bottom-up constructions. The top-down models are based on Robertson-Walker geometries, and the bottom-up constructions are built by patching together sub-horizon-sized regions of perturbed Minkowski space. Our results suggest that these theories do not provide a theoretically attractive alternative to the sta… ▽ More We consider cosmological modelling in $f(R)$ theories of gravity, using both top-down and bottom-up constructions. The top-down models are based on Robertson-Walker geometries, and the bottom-up constructions are built by patching together sub-horizon-sized regions of perturbed Minkowski space. Our results suggest that these theories do not provide a theoretically attractive alternative to the standard general relativistic cosmology. We find that the only $f(R)$ theories that can admit an observationally viable weak-field limit have large-scale expansions that are observationally indistinguishable from the Friedmann solutions of General Relativity with $Λ$. Such theories do not alleviate any of the difficulties associated with $Λ$, and cannot produce any new behaviour in the cosmological expansion without simultaneously destroying the Newtonian approximation to gravity on small scales. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2015; v1 submitted 9 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 103528 (2015)

Decay of the Cosmic Vacuum Energy

Authors: Timothy Clifton, John D. Barrow

Abstract: In his 2005 review, Gravity and the Thermodynamics of Horizons, Paddy suggested that a vacuum in thermal equilibrium with a bath of radiation should have a gradually diminishing energy. We work through the consequences of this scenario, and find that a coupling between the vacuum and a bath of black-body radiation at the temperature of the horizon requires the Hubble rate, $H$, to approach the sam… ▽ More In his 2005 review, Gravity and the Thermodynamics of Horizons, Paddy suggested that a vacuum in thermal equilibrium with a bath of radiation should have a gradually diminishing energy. We work through the consequences of this scenario, and find that a coupling between the vacuum and a bath of black-body radiation at the temperature of the horizon requires the Hubble rate, $H$, to approach the same type of evolution as in the "intermediate inflation" scenario, with $H\propto t^{-1/3}$, rather than as a constant. We show that such behaviour does not conflict with observations when the vacuum energy is described by a slowly-rolling scalar field, and when the fluctuations in the scalar field are treated as in the "warm inflation" scenario. It does, however, change the asymptotic states of the universe. We find that the existence of the radiation introduces a curvature singularity at early times, where the energy densities in both the radiation and the vacuum diverge. Furthermore, we show that the introduction of an additional non-interacting perfect fluid into the space-time reveals that radiation can dominate over dust at late times, in contrast to what occurs in the standard cosmological model. Such a coupling can also lead to a negative vacuum energy becoming positive. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2016; v1 submitted 17 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 12 pages, 3 figures. Final version accepted for Padmanabhan birthday volume

Journal ref: Gravity and the Quantum, Festschrift for T. Padmanabhan, eds. J Singh Bagla and S. Engineer, series Fundamental Theories of Physics 187, (Springer, New York), pp. 61-71 (2017)

The Method of Images in Cosmology

Authors: Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We apply the method of images to the exact initial data for cosmological models that contain a number of regularly arranged discrete masses. This allows us to join cosmological regions together by throats, and to construct wormholes in the initial data. These wormholes allow for the removal of the asymptotically flat "flange" regions that would otherwise exist on the far side of black holes. The m… ▽ More We apply the method of images to the exact initial data for cosmological models that contain a number of regularly arranged discrete masses. This allows us to join cosmological regions together by throats, and to construct wormholes in the initial data. These wormholes allow for the removal of the asymptotically flat "flange" regions that would otherwise exist on the far side of black holes. The method of images also provides us with a way to investigate the definition of mass is cosmology, and the cosmological consequences of the gravitational interaction energies between massive objects. We find evidence that the interaction energies within clusters of massive objects do indeed appear to contribute to the total energy budget in the cosmological regions of the space-time. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2014; v1 submitted 13 May, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: 31 pages, 18 figures

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 31 (2014) 175010

Piecewise Silence in Discrete Cosmological Models

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Daniele Gregoris, Kjell Rosquist

Abstract: We consider a family of cosmological models in which all mass is confined to a regular lattice of identical black holes. By exploiting the reflection symmetry about planes that bisect these lattices into identical halves, we are able to consider the evolution of a number of geometrically distinguished surfaces that exist within each of them. We find that the evolution equations for the reflection… ▽ More We consider a family of cosmological models in which all mass is confined to a regular lattice of identical black holes. By exploiting the reflection symmetry about planes that bisect these lattices into identical halves, we are able to consider the evolution of a number of geometrically distinguished surfaces that exist within each of them. We find that the evolution equations for the reflection symmetric surfaces can be written as a simple set of Friedmann-like equations, with source terms that behave like a set of interacting effective fluids. We then show that gravitational waves are effectively trapped within small chambers for all time, and are not free to propagate throughout the space-time. Each chamber therefore evolves as if it were in isolation from the rest of the universe. We call this phenomenon "piecewise silence". △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2014; v1 submitted 13 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: 20 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 31 (2014) 105012

Exact Evolution of Discrete Relativistic Cosmological Models

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Daniele Gregoris, Kjell Rosquist, Reza Tavakol

Abstract: We study the effects of inhomogeneities on the evolution of the Universe, by considering a range of cosmological models with discretized matter content. This is done using exact and fully relativistic methods that exploit the symmetries in and about submanifolds of spacetimes that themselves possess no continuous global symmetries. These methods allow us to follow the evolution of our models throu… ▽ More We study the effects of inhomogeneities on the evolution of the Universe, by considering a range of cosmological models with discretized matter content. This is done using exact and fully relativistic methods that exploit the symmetries in and about submanifolds of spacetimes that themselves possess no continuous global symmetries. These methods allow us to follow the evolution of our models throughout their entire history, far beyond what has previously been possible. We find that while some space-like curves collapse to anisotropic singularities in finite time, others remain non-singular forever. The resulting picture is of a cosmological spacetime in which some behaviour remains close to Friedmann-like, while other behaviours deviate radically. In particular, we find that large-scale acceleration is possible without any violation of the energy conditions. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2013; v1 submitted 11 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 46 pages, 23 figures

Journal ref: JCAP 11(2013)010

A Gravitational Entropy Proposal

Authors: Timothy Clifton, George F R Ellis, Reza Tavakol

Abstract: We propose a thermodynamically motivated measure of gravitational entropy based on the Bel-Robinson tensor, which has a natural interpretation as the effective super-energy-momentum tensor of free gravitational fields. The specific form of this measure differs depending on whether the gravitational field is Coulomb-like or wave-like, and reduces to the Bekenstein-Hawking value when integrated over… ▽ More We propose a thermodynamically motivated measure of gravitational entropy based on the Bel-Robinson tensor, which has a natural interpretation as the effective super-energy-momentum tensor of free gravitational fields. The specific form of this measure differs depending on whether the gravitational field is Coulomb-like or wave-like, and reduces to the Bekenstein-Hawking value when integrated over the interior of a Schwarzschild black hole. For scalar perturbations of a Robertson-Walker geometry we find that the entropy goes like the Hubble weighted anisotropy of the gravitational field, and therefore increases as structure formation occurs. This is in kee** with our expectations for the behaviour of gravitational entropy in cosmology, and provides a thermodynamically motivated arrow of time for cosmological solutions of Einstein's field equations. It is also in kee** with Penrose's Weyl curvature hypothesis. △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 2013; v1 submitted 22 March, 2013; originally announced March 2013.

Comments: 17 pages

Journal ref: Class. Quant. Grav. 30 (2013) 125009

Back-Reaction in Relativistic Cosmology

Authors: Timothy Clifton

Abstract: We introduce the concept of back-reaction in relativistic cosmological modeling. Roughly speaking, this can be thought of as the difference between the large-scale behaviour of an inhomogeneous cosmological solution of Einstein's equations, and a homogeneous and isotropic solution that is a best-fit to either the average of observables or dynamics in the inhomogeneous solution. This is sometimes p… ▽ More We introduce the concept of back-reaction in relativistic cosmological modeling. Roughly speaking, this can be thought of as the difference between the large-scale behaviour of an inhomogeneous cosmological solution of Einstein's equations, and a homogeneous and isotropic solution that is a best-fit to either the average of observables or dynamics in the inhomogeneous solution. This is sometimes paraphrased as `the effect that structure has of the large-scale evolution of the universe'. Various different approaches have been taken in the literature in order to try and understand back-reaction in cosmology. We provide a brief and critical summary of some of them, highlighting recent progress that has been made in each case. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: 13 pages, 2 figures. Based on a talk given at the 13th Marcel Grossmann meeting

Journal ref: IJMPD 22 (2013) 133004

On the absence of the usual weak-field limit, and the impossibility of embedding some known solutions for isolated masses in cosmologies with f(R) dark energy

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Peter Dunsby, Rituparno Goswami, Anne Marie Nzioki

Abstract: The problem of matching different regions of spacetime in order to construct inhomogeneous cosmological models is investigated in the context of Lagrangian theories of gravity constructed from general analytic functions f(R), and from non-analytic theories with f(R)=R^n. In all of the cases studied, we find that it is impossible to satisfy the required junction conditions without the large-scale b… ▽ More The problem of matching different regions of spacetime in order to construct inhomogeneous cosmological models is investigated in the context of Lagrangian theories of gravity constructed from general analytic functions f(R), and from non-analytic theories with f(R)=R^n. In all of the cases studied, we find that it is impossible to satisfy the required junction conditions without the large-scale behaviour reducing to that expected from Einstein's equations with a cosmological constant. For theories with analytic f(R) this suggests that the usual treatment of weak-field systems as perturbations about Minkowski space may not be compatible with late-time acceleration driven by anything other than a constant term of the form f(0), which acts like a cosmological constant. In the absence of Minkowski space as a suitable background for weak-field systems, one must then choose and justify some other solution to perform perturbative analyses around. For theories with f(R)=R^n we find that no known spherically symmetric vacuum solutions can be matched to an expanding FLRW background. This includes the absence of any Einstein-Straus-like embeddings of the Schwarzschild exterior solution in FLRW spacetimes. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2013; v1 submitted 2 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 12 pages. Corrections made in Eqs. (6)-(9)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 87, 063517 (2013)

Observational Cosmology in Macroscopic Gravity

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Alan Coley, Robert van den Hoogen

Abstract: We discuss the construction of cosmological models within the framework of Macroscopic Gravity (MG), which is a theory that models the effects of averaging the geometry of space-time on large scales. We find new exact spatially homogeneous and isotropic FLRW solutions to the MG field equations, and investigate large-scale perturbations around them. We find that any inhomogeneous perturbations to t… ▽ More We discuss the construction of cosmological models within the framework of Macroscopic Gravity (MG), which is a theory that models the effects of averaging the geometry of space-time on large scales. We find new exact spatially homogeneous and isotropic FLRW solutions to the MG field equations, and investigate large-scale perturbations around them. We find that any inhomogeneous perturbations to the averaged geometry are severely restricted, but that possible anisotropies in the correlation tensor can have dramatic consequences for the measurement of distances. These calculations are a first step within the MG approach toward develo** averaged cosmological models to a point where they can be used to interpret real cosmological data, and hence to provide a working alternative to the "concordance" LCDM model. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2012; v1 submitted 5 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: 22 pages

Journal ref: JCAP 10(2012)044

An exact quantification of backreaction in relativistic cosmology

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Kjell Rosquist, Reza Tavakol

Abstract: An important open question in cosmology is the degree to which the Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) solutions of Einstein's equations are able to model the large-scale behaviour of the locally inhomogeneous observable universe. We investigate this problem by considering a range of exact n-body solutions of Einstein's constraint equations. These solutions contain discrete masses, and so a… ▽ More An important open question in cosmology is the degree to which the Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) solutions of Einstein's equations are able to model the large-scale behaviour of the locally inhomogeneous observable universe. We investigate this problem by considering a range of exact n-body solutions of Einstein's constraint equations. These solutions contain discrete masses, and so allow arbitrarily large density contrasts to be modelled. We restrict our study to regularly arranged distributions of masses in topological 3-spheres. This has the benefit of allowing straightforward comparisons to be made with FLRW solutions, as both spacetimes admit a discrete group of symmetries. It also provides a time-symmetric hypersurface at the moment of maximum expansion that allows the constraint equations to be solved exactly. We find that when all the mass in the universe is condensed into a small number of objects (<10) then the amount of backreaction in dust models can be large, with O(1) deviations from the predictions of the corresponding FLRW solutions. When the number of masses is large (>100), however, then our measures of backreaction become small (<1%). This result does not rely on any averaging procedures, which are notoriously hard to define uniquely in general relativity, and so provides (to the best of our knowledge) the first exact and unambiguous demonstration of backreaction in general relativistic cosmological modelling. Discrete models such as these can therefore be used as laboratories to test ideas about backreaction that could be applied in more complicated and realistic settings. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2013; v1 submitted 29 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 13 pages, 9 figures. Corrections made to Tables IV and V

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 86, 043506 (2012)

Local and non-local measures of acceleration in cosmology

Authors: Philip Bull, Timothy Clifton

Abstract: Current cosmological observations, when interpreted within the framework of a homogeneous and isotropic Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) model, strongly suggest that the Universe is entering a period of accelerating expansion. This is often taken to mean that the expansion of space itself is accelerating. In a general spacetime, however, this is not necessarily true. We attempt to clarif… ▽ More Current cosmological observations, when interpreted within the framework of a homogeneous and isotropic Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) model, strongly suggest that the Universe is entering a period of accelerating expansion. This is often taken to mean that the expansion of space itself is accelerating. In a general spacetime, however, this is not necessarily true. We attempt to clarify this point by considering a handful of local and non-local measures of acceleration in a variety of inhomogeneous cosmological models. Each of the chosen measures corresponds to a theoretical or observational procedure that has previously been used to study acceleration in cosmology, and all measures reduce to the same quantity in the limit of exact spatial homogeneity and isotropy. In statistically homogeneous and isotropic spacetimes, we find that the acceleration inferred from observations of the distance-redshift relation is closely related to the acceleration of the spatially averaged universe, but does not necessarily bear any resemblance to the average of the local acceleration of spacetime itself. For inhomogeneous spacetimes that do not display statistical homogeneity and isotropy, however, we find little correlation between acceleration inferred from observations and the acceleration of the averaged spacetime. This shows that observations made in an inhomogeneous universe can imply acceleration without the existence of dark energy. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2012; v1 submitted 20 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 19 pages, 10 figures. Several references added or amended, some minor clarifications made in the text

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 85, 103512 (2012)

The isotropic blackbody CMB as evidence for a homogeneous universe

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Chris Clarkson, Philip Bull

Abstract: The question of whether the Universe is spatially homogeneous and isotropic on the largest scales is of fundamental importance to cosmology, but has not yet been answered decisively. Surprisingly, neither an isotropic primary CMB nor combined observations of luminosity distances and galaxy number counts are sufficient to establish such a result. The inclusion of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect in CM… ▽ More The question of whether the Universe is spatially homogeneous and isotropic on the largest scales is of fundamental importance to cosmology, but has not yet been answered decisively. Surprisingly, neither an isotropic primary CMB nor combined observations of luminosity distances and galaxy number counts are sufficient to establish such a result. The inclusion of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect in CMB observations, however, dramatically improves this situation. We show that even a solitary observer who sees an isotropic blackbody CMB can conclude that the universe is homogeneous and isotropic in their causal past when the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect is present. Critically, however, the CMB must either be viewed for an extended period of time, or CMB photons that have scattered more than once must be detected. This result provides a theoretical underpinning for testing the Cosmological Principle with observations of the CMB alone. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2012; v1 submitted 16 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 051303 (2012)

Observational Constraints on the Averaged Universe

Authors: Chris Clarkson, Timothy Clifton, Alan Coley, Rockhee Sung

Abstract: Averaging in general relativity is a complicated operation, due to the general covariance of the theory and the non-linearity of Einstein's equations. The latter of these ensures that smoothing spacetime over cosmological scales does not yield the same result as solving Einstein's equations with a smooth matter distribution, and that the smooth models we fit to observations need not be simply rela… ▽ More Averaging in general relativity is a complicated operation, due to the general covariance of the theory and the non-linearity of Einstein's equations. The latter of these ensures that smoothing spacetime over cosmological scales does not yield the same result as solving Einstein's equations with a smooth matter distribution, and that the smooth models we fit to observations need not be simply related to the actual geometry of spacetime. One specific consequence of this is a decoupling of the geometrical spatial curvature term in the metric from the dynamical spatial curvature in the Friedmann equation. Here we investigate the consequences of this decoupling by fitting to a combination of HST, CMB, SNIa and BAO data sets. We find that only the geometrical spatial curvature is tightly constrained, and that our ability to constrain dark energy dynamics will be severely impaired until we gain a thorough understanding of the averaging problem in cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2014; v1 submitted 9 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

An Improved Treatment of Optics in the Lindquist-Wheeler Models

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Pedro G. Ferreira, Kane O'Donnell

Abstract: We consider the optical properties of Lindquist-Wheeler (LW) models of the Universe. These models consist of lattices constructed from regularly arranged discrete masses. They are akin to the Wigner-Seitz construction of solid state physics, and result in a dynamical description of the large-scale Universe in which the global expansion is given by a Friedmann-like equation. We show that if these m… ▽ More We consider the optical properties of Lindquist-Wheeler (LW) models of the Universe. These models consist of lattices constructed from regularly arranged discrete masses. They are akin to the Wigner-Seitz construction of solid state physics, and result in a dynamical description of the large-scale Universe in which the global expansion is given by a Friedmann-like equation. We show that if these models are constructed in a particular way then the redshifts of distant objects, as well as the dynamics of the global space-time, can be made to be in good agreement with the homogeneous and isotropic Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) solutions of Einstein's equations, at the level of <3% out to z~2. Angular diameter and luminosity distances, on the other hand, differ from those found in the corresponding FLRW models, while being consistent with the 'empty beam' approximation, together with the shearing effects due to the nearest masses. This can be compared with the large deviations found from the corresponding FLRW values obtained in a previous study that considered LW models constructed in a different way. We therefore advocate the improved LW models we consider here as useful constructions that appear to faithfully reproduce both the dynamical and observational properties of space-times containing discrete masses. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2012; v1 submitted 14 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 85, 023502 (2012)

The kSZ effect as a test of general radial inhomogeneity in LTB cosmology

Authors: Philip Bull, Timothy Clifton, Pedro G. Ferreira

Abstract: The apparent accelerating expansion of the Universe, determined from observations of distant supernovae, and often taken to imply the existence of dark energy, may alternatively be explained by the effects of a giant underdense void if we relax the assumption of homogeneity on large scales. Recent studies have made use of the spherically-symmetric, radially-inhomogeneous Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB… ▽ More The apparent accelerating expansion of the Universe, determined from observations of distant supernovae, and often taken to imply the existence of dark energy, may alternatively be explained by the effects of a giant underdense void if we relax the assumption of homogeneity on large scales. Recent studies have made use of the spherically-symmetric, radially-inhomogeneous Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) models to derive strong constraints on this scenario, particularly from observations of the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (kSZ) effect which is sensitive to large scale inhomogeneity. However, most of these previous studies explicitly set the LTB 'bang time' function to be constant, neglecting an important freedom of the general solutions. Here we examine these models in full generality by relaxing this assumption. We find that although the extra freedom allowed by varying the bang time is sufficient to account for some observables individually, it is not enough to simultaneously explain the supernovae observations, the small-angle CMB, the local Hubble rate, and the kSZ effect. This set of observables is strongly constraining, and effectively rules out simple LTB models as an explanation of dark energy. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2012; v1 submitted 10 August, 2011; originally announced August 2011.

Comments: 14 pages, 9 figures. Minor update to match the published version (includes typo correction in Eq. 16)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 85, 024002 (2012)

Modified Gravity and Cosmology

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Pedro G. Ferreira, Antonio Padilla, Constantinos Skordis

Abstract: In this review we present a thoroughly comprehensive survey of recent work on modified theories of gravity and their cosmological consequences. Amongst other things, we cover General Relativity, Scalar-Tensor, Einstein-Aether, and Bimetric theories, as well as TeVeS, f(R), general higher-order theories, Horava-Lifschitz gravity, Galileons, Ghost Condensates, and models of extra dimensions includin… ▽ More In this review we present a thoroughly comprehensive survey of recent work on modified theories of gravity and their cosmological consequences. Amongst other things, we cover General Relativity, Scalar-Tensor, Einstein-Aether, and Bimetric theories, as well as TeVeS, f(R), general higher-order theories, Horava-Lifschitz gravity, Galileons, Ghost Condensates, and models of extra dimensions including Kaluza-Klein, Randall-Sundrum, DGP, and higher co-dimension braneworlds. We also review attempts to construct a Parameterised Post-Friedmannian formalism, that can be used to constrain deviations from General Relativity in cosmology, and that is suitable for comparison with data on the largest scales. These subjects have been intensively studied over the past decade, largely motivated by rapid progress in the field of observational cosmology that now allows, for the first time, precision tests of fundamental physics on the scale of the observable Universe. The purpose of this review is to provide a reference tool for researchers and students in cosmology and gravitational physics, as well as a self-contained, comprehensive and up-to-date introduction to the subject as a whole. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2012; v1 submitted 13 June, 2011; originally announced June 2011.

Comments: 312 pages, 15 figures

Journal ref: Physics Reports 513, 1 (2012), 1-189

The Parameterised Post-Newtonian Limit of Bimetric Theories of Gravity

Authors: Timothy Clifton, Máximo Bañados, Constantinos Skordis

Abstract: We consider the post-Newtonian limit of a general class of bimetric theories of gravity, in which both metrics are dynamical. The established parameterised post-Newtonian approach is followed as closely as possible, although new potentials are found that do not exist within the standard frame-work. It is found that these theories can evade solar system tests of post-Newtonian gravity remarkably we… ▽ More We consider the post-Newtonian limit of a general class of bimetric theories of gravity, in which both metrics are dynamical. The established parameterised post-Newtonian approach is followed as closely as possible, although new potentials are found that do not exist within the standard frame-work. It is found that these theories can evade solar system tests of post-Newtonian gravity remarkably well. We show that perturbations about Minkowski space in these theories contain both massless and massive degrees of freedom, and that in general there are two different types of massive mode, each with a different mass parameter. If both of these masses are sufficiently large then the predictions of the most general class of theories we consider are indistinguishable from those of general relativity, up to post-Newtonian order in a weak field, low velocity expansion. In the limit that the massive modes become massless, we find that these general theories do not exhibit a van Dam-Veltman-Zakharov-like discontinuity in their gamma parameter, although there are discontinuities in other post-Newtonian parameters as the massless limit is approached. This smooth behaviour in gamma is due to the discontinuities from each of the two different massive modes cancelling each other out. Such cancellations cannot occur in special cases with only one massive mode, such as the Isham-Salam-Strathdee theory. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2010; v1 submitted 29 June, 2010; originally announced June 2010.

Comments: 36 pages

Journal ref: Class.Quant.Grav.27:235020,2010