-
Radiative cooling effects on reverse shocks formed by magnetised supersonic plasma flows
Authors:
S. Merlini,
J. D. Hare,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. W. D. Halliday,
A. Ciardi,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
A. J. Crilly,
S. J. Eardley,
K. E. Marrow,
D. R. Russell,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart,
L. G. Suttle,
E. R. Tubman,
V. Valenzuela-Villaseca,
T. W. O. Varnish,
S. V. Lebedev
Abstract:
We study the structure of reverse shocks formed by the collision of supersonic, magnetised plasma flows driven by an inverse (or exploding) wire array with a planar conducting obstacle. We observe that the structure of these reverse shocks varies dramatically with wire material, despite the similar upstream flow velocities and mass densities. For aluminium wire arrays, the shock is sharp and well…
▽ More
We study the structure of reverse shocks formed by the collision of supersonic, magnetised plasma flows driven by an inverse (or exploding) wire array with a planar conducting obstacle. We observe that the structure of these reverse shocks varies dramatically with wire material, despite the similar upstream flow velocities and mass densities. For aluminium wire arrays, the shock is sharp and well defined, consistent with magneto-hydrodynamic theory. In contrast, we do not observe a well-defined shock using tungsten wires, instead, we see a broad region dominated by density fluctuations on a wide range of spatial scales. We diagnose these two very different interactions using interferometry, Thomson scattering, shadowgraphy, and a newly developed imaging refractometer which is sensitive to small deflections of the probing laser corresponding to small-scale density perturbations. We conclude that the differences in shock structure are most likely due to radiative cooling instabilities which create small-scale density perturbations elongated along magnetic field lines in the tungsten plasma. These instabilities grow more slowly and are smoothed by thermal conduction in the aluminium plasma.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2023; v1 submitted 2 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The structure of 3D collisional magnetized bow shocks in pulsed-power-driven plasma flow
Authors:
Rishabh Datta,
Danny R. Russell,
Iek Tang,
Thomas Clayson,
Lee G. Suttle,
Jeremy P. Chittenden,
Sergey V. Lebedev,
Jack D. Hare
Abstract:
We investigate 3D bow shocks in a highly collisional magnetized aluminum plasma, generated during the ablation phase of an exploding wire array on the MAGPIE facility (1.4 MA, 240 ns). Ablation of plasma from the wire array generates radially diverging, supersonic ($M_S \sim 7$), super-Alfvénic ($M_A > 1$) magnetized flows with frozen-in magnetic flux ($R_M \gg 1$). These flows collide with an ind…
▽ More
We investigate 3D bow shocks in a highly collisional magnetized aluminum plasma, generated during the ablation phase of an exploding wire array on the MAGPIE facility (1.4 MA, 240 ns). Ablation of plasma from the wire array generates radially diverging, supersonic ($M_S \sim 7$), super-Alfvénic ($M_A > 1$) magnetized flows with frozen-in magnetic flux ($R_M \gg 1$). These flows collide with an inductive probe placed in the flow, which serves both as the obstacle that generates the magnetized bow shock, and as a diagnostic of the advected magnetic field. Laser interferometry along two orthogonal lines of sight is used to measure the line-integrated electron density. A detached bow shock forms ahead of the probe, with a larger opening angle in the plane parallel to the magnetic field than in the plane normal to it. Since the resistive diffusion length of the plasma is comparable to the probe size, the magnetic field decouples from the ion fluid at the shock front and generates a hydrodynamic shock, whose structure is determined by the sonic Mach number, rather than the magnetosonic Mach number of the flow. 3D simulations performed using the resistive magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) code GORGON confirm this picture, but under-predict the anisotropy observed in the shape of the experimental bow shock, suggesting that non-MHD mechanisms may be important for modifying the shock structure.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Time-resolved velocity and ion sound speed measurements from simultaneous bow shock imaging and inductive probe measurements
Authors:
R. Datta,
D. R. Russell,
T. Clayson,
J. P. Chittenden,
S. V. Lebedev,
J. D. Hare
Abstract:
We present a technique to measure the time-resolved velocity and ion sound speed in magnetized, supersonic high-energy-density plasmas. We place an inductive (`b-dot') probe in a supersonic pulsed-power-driven plasma flow and measure the magnetic field advected by the plasma. As the magnetic Reynolds number is large ($R_M > 10$), the plasma flow advects a magnetic field proportional to the current…
▽ More
We present a technique to measure the time-resolved velocity and ion sound speed in magnetized, supersonic high-energy-density plasmas. We place an inductive (`b-dot') probe in a supersonic pulsed-power-driven plasma flow and measure the magnetic field advected by the plasma. As the magnetic Reynolds number is large ($R_M > 10$), the plasma flow advects a magnetic field proportional to the current at the load. This enables us to estimate the plasma flow velocity as a function of time from the delay between the current at the load and the signal at the probe. The supersonic flow also generates a detached hydrodynamic bow shock around the probe, the structure of which depends on the upstream sonic Mach number. By imaging the shock around the probe with a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, we determine the upstream Mach number from the shock Mach angle, which we then use to determine the ion sound speed from the known upstream velocity. We use the measured sound speed to infer the value of $\bar{Z}T_e$, where $\bar{Z}$ is the average ionization, and $T_e$ is the electron temperature. We use this diagnostic to measure the time-resolved velocity and sound speed of a supersonic $(M_S \sim 8)$, super-Alfvénic $(M_A \sim 2)$ aluminum plasma generated during the ablation stage of an exploding wire array on the MAGPIE generator (1.4 MA, 250 ns). Velocity and $\bar{Z}T_e$ measured using this technique agree well with optical Thompson scattering measurements reported in literature, and with 3D resistive MHD simulations in GORGON.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Experimental study of the interaction of two laser-driven radiative shocks at the PALS laser
Authors:
R. L. Singh,
C. Stehle,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
M. Kozlova,
J. Larour,
U. Chaulagain,
T. Clayson,
R. Rodriguez,
J. M. Gil,
J. Nejdl,
M. Krus,
J. Dostal,
R. Dudzak,
P. Barroso,
O. Acef,
M. Cotelo,
P. Velarde
Abstract:
Radiative shocks (RS) are complex phenomena which are ubiquitous in astrophysical environments. The study of such hypersonic shocks in the laboratory, under controlled conditions, is of primary interest to understand the physics at play and also to check the ability of numerical simulations to reproduce the experimental results. In this context, we conducted, at the Prague Asterix Laser System fac…
▽ More
Radiative shocks (RS) are complex phenomena which are ubiquitous in astrophysical environments. The study of such hypersonic shocks in the laboratory, under controlled conditions, is of primary interest to understand the physics at play and also to check the ability of numerical simulations to reproduce the experimental results. In this context, we conducted, at the Prague Asterix Laser System facility (PALS), the first experiments dedicated to the study of two counter-propagating radiative shocks propagating at non-equal speeds up to 25-50 km/s in noble gases at pressures ranging between 0.1 and 0.6 bar. These experiments highlighted the interaction between the two radiative precursors. This interaction is qualitatively but not quantitatively described by 1D simulations. Preliminary results obtained with XUV spectroscopy leading to the estimation of shock temperature and ion charge of the plasma are also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
First radiative shock experiments on the SG-II laser
Authors:
Francisco Suzuki-Vidal,
Thomas Clayson,
Chantal Stehlé,
Uddhab Chaulagain,
Jack W. D. Halliday,
Mingying Sun,
Lei Ren,
Ning Kang,
Huiya Liu,
Baoqiang Zhu,
Jianqiang Zhu,
Carolina de Almeida Rossi,
Teodora Mihailescu,
Pedro Velarde,
Manuel Cotelo,
John M. Foster,
Colin N. Danson,
Christopher Spindloe,
Jeremy P. Chittenden,
Carolyn Kuranz
Abstract:
We report on the design and first results from experiments looking at the formation of radiative shocks on the Shenguang-II (SG-II) laser at the Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics in China. Laser-heating of a two-layer CH/CH-Br foil drives a $\sim$40 km/s shock inside a gas-cell filled with argon at an initial pressure of 1 bar. The use of gas-cell targets with large (several mm) late…
▽ More
We report on the design and first results from experiments looking at the formation of radiative shocks on the Shenguang-II (SG-II) laser at the Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics in China. Laser-heating of a two-layer CH/CH-Br foil drives a $\sim$40 km/s shock inside a gas-cell filled with argon at an initial pressure of 1 bar. The use of gas-cell targets with large (several mm) lateral and axial extent allows the shock to propagate freely without any wall interactions, and permits a large field of view to image single and colliding counter-propagating shocks with time resolved, point-projection X-ray backlighting ($\sim20$ $μ$m source size, 4.3 keV photon energy). Single shocks were imaged up to 100 ns after the onset of the laser drive allowing to probe the growth of spatial non-uniformities in the shock apex. These results are compared with experiments looking at counter-propagating shocks, showing a symmetric drive which leads to a collision and stagnation from $\sim$40 ns onward. We present a preliminary comparison with numerical simulations with the radiation hydrodynamics code ARWEN, which provides expected plasma parameters for the design of future experiments in this facility.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
An Imaging Refractometer for Density Fluctuation Measurements in High Energy Density Plasmas
Authors:
J. D. Hare,
G. C. Burdiak,
S. Merlini,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
A. J. Crilly,
J. W. D. Halliday,
D. R. Russell,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart,
L. G. Suttle,
S. V. Lebedev
Abstract:
We report on a recently developed laser-probing diagnostic which allows direct measurements of ray-deflection angles in one axis, whilst retaining imaging capabilities in the other axis. This allows us to measure the spectrum of angular deflections from a laser beam which passes though a turbulent high-energy-density plasma. This spectrum contains information about the density fluctuations within…
▽ More
We report on a recently developed laser-probing diagnostic which allows direct measurements of ray-deflection angles in one axis, whilst retaining imaging capabilities in the other axis. This allows us to measure the spectrum of angular deflections from a laser beam which passes though a turbulent high-energy-density plasma. This spectrum contains information about the density fluctuations within the plasma, which deflect the probing laser over a range of angles. %The principle of this diagnostic is described, along with our specific experimental realisation. We create synthetic diagnostics using ray-tracing to compare this new diagnostic with standard shadowgraphy and schlieren imaging approaches, which demonstrates the enhanced sensitivity of this new diagnostic over standard techniques. We present experimental data from turbulence behind a reverse shock in a plasma and demonstrate that this technique can measure angular deflections between 0.06 and 34 mrad, corresponding to a dynamic range of over 500.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2021; v1 submitted 9 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Interactions of magnetized plasma flows in pulsed-power driven experiments
Authors:
L G Suttle,
G C Burdiak,
C L Cheung,
T Clayson,
J W D Halliday,
J D Hare,
S Rusli,
D Russell,
E Tubman,
A Ciardi,
N F Loureiro,
J Li,
A Frank,
S V Lebedev
Abstract:
A supersonic flow of magnetized plasma is produced by the application of a 1 MA-peak, 500 ns current pulse to a cylindrical arrangement of parallel wires, known as an inverse wire array. The plasma flow is produced by the JxB acceleration of the ablated wire material, and a magnetic field of several Tesla is embedded at source by the driving current. This setup has been used for a variety of exper…
▽ More
A supersonic flow of magnetized plasma is produced by the application of a 1 MA-peak, 500 ns current pulse to a cylindrical arrangement of parallel wires, known as an inverse wire array. The plasma flow is produced by the JxB acceleration of the ablated wire material, and a magnetic field of several Tesla is embedded at source by the driving current. This setup has been used for a variety of experiments investigating the interactions of magnetized plasma flows. In experiments designed to investigate magnetic reconnection, the collision of counter-streaming flows, carrying oppositely directed magnetic fields, leads to the formation of a reconnection layer in which we observe ions reaching temperatures much greater than predicted by classical heating mechanisms. The breakup of this layer under the plasmoid instability is dependent on the properties of the inflowing plasma, which can be controlled by the choice of the wire array material. In other experiments, magnetized shocks were formed by placing obstacles in the path of the magnetized plasma flow. The pile-up of magnetic flux in front of a conducting obstacle produces a magnetic precursor acting on upstream electrons at the distance of the ion inertial length. This precursor subsequently develops into a steep density transition via ion-electron fluid decoupling. Obstacles which possess a strong private magnetic field affect the upstream flow over a much greater distance, providing an extended bow shock structure. In the region surrounding the obstacle the magnetic pressure holds off the flow, forming a void of plasma material, analogous to the magnetopause around planetary bodies with self-generated magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Ion heating and magnetic flux pile-up in a magnetic reconnection experiment with super-Alfvenic plasma inflows
Authors:
L. G. Suttle,
J. D. Hare,
S. V. Lebedev,
A. Ciardi,
N. F. Loureiro,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
J. W. D. Halliday,
N. Niasse,
D. Russell,
F. Suzuki Vidal,
E. Tubman,
T. Lane,
J. Ma,
T. Robinson,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart
Abstract:
This work presents a magnetic reconnection experiment in which the kinetic, magnetic and thermal properties of the plasma each play an important role in the overall energy balance and structure of the generated reconnection layer. Magnetic reconnection occurs during the interaction of continuous and steady flows of super-Alfvenic, magnetized, aluminum plasma, which collide in a geometry with two-d…
▽ More
This work presents a magnetic reconnection experiment in which the kinetic, magnetic and thermal properties of the plasma each play an important role in the overall energy balance and structure of the generated reconnection layer. Magnetic reconnection occurs during the interaction of continuous and steady flows of super-Alfvenic, magnetized, aluminum plasma, which collide in a geometry with two-dimensional symmetry, producing a stable and long-lasting reconnection layer. Optical Thomson scattering measurements show that when the layer forms, ions inside the layer are more strongly heated than electrons, reaching temperatures of Ti~ZTe>300 eV - much greater than can be expected from strong shock and viscous heating alone. Later in time, as the plasma density in the layer increases, the electron and ion temperatures are found to equilibrate, and a constant plasma temperature is achieved through a balance of the heating mechanisms and radiative losses of the plasma. Measurements from Faraday rotation polarimetry also indicate the presence of significant magnetic field pile-up occurring at the boundary of the reconnection region, which is consistent with the super-Alfvenic velocity of the inflows.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
An Experimental Platform for Pulsed-Power Driven Magnetic Reconnection
Authors:
J. D. Hare,
L. G. Suttle,
S. V. Lebedev,
N. F. Loureiro,
A. Ciardi,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
S. J. Eardley,
C. Garcia,
J. W. D. Halliday,
T. Robinson,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
E. R. Tubman
Abstract:
We describe a versatile pulsed-power driven platform for magnetic reconnection experiments, based on exploding wire arrays driven in parallel [Suttle, L. G. et al. PRL, 116, 225001]. This platform produces inherently magnetised plasma flows for the duration of the generator current pulse (250 ns), resulting in a long-lasting reconnection layer. The layer exists for long enough to allow evolution o…
▽ More
We describe a versatile pulsed-power driven platform for magnetic reconnection experiments, based on exploding wire arrays driven in parallel [Suttle, L. G. et al. PRL, 116, 225001]. This platform produces inherently magnetised plasma flows for the duration of the generator current pulse (250 ns), resulting in a long-lasting reconnection layer. The layer exists for long enough to allow evolution of complex processes such as plasmoid formation and movement to be diagnosed by a suite of high spatial and temporal resolution laser-based diagnostics. We can access a wide range of magnetic reconnection regimes by changing the wire material or moving the electrodes inside the wire arrays. We present results with aluminium and carbon wires, in which the parameters of the inflows and the layer which forms are significantly different. By moving the electrodes inside the wire arrays, we change how strongly the inflows are driven. This enables us to study both symmetric reconnection in a range of different regimes, and asymmetric reconnection.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2018; v1 submitted 17 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Counter-propagating radiative shock experiments on the Orion laser
Authors:
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
T. Clayson,
G. F. Swadling,
S. V. Lebedev,
G. C. Burdiak,
C. Stehlé,
U. Chaulagain,
R. L. Singh,
J. M. Foster,
J. Skidmore,
E. T. Gumbrell,
P. Graham,
S. Patankar,
C. Danson,
C. Spindloe,
J. Larour,
M. Kozlova,
R. Rodriguez,
J. M. Gil,
G. Espinosa,
P. Velarde
Abstract:
We present new experiments to study the formation of radiative shocks and the interaction between two counter-propagating radiative shocks. The experiments were performed at the Orion laser facility which was used to drive shocks in xenon inside large aspect ratio gas-cells. The collision between the two shocks and their respective radiative precursors, combined with the formation of inherently 3-…
▽ More
We present new experiments to study the formation of radiative shocks and the interaction between two counter-propagating radiative shocks. The experiments were performed at the Orion laser facility which was used to drive shocks in xenon inside large aspect ratio gas-cells. The collision between the two shocks and their respective radiative precursors, combined with the formation of inherently 3-dimensional shocks, provides a novel platform particularly suited for benchmarking of numerical codes. The dynamics of the shocks before and after the collision were investigated using point-projection X-ray backlighting while, simultaneously, the electron density in the radiative precursor was measured via optical laser interferometry. Modelling of the experiments using the 2-D radiation hydrodynamic codes NYM/PETRA show a very good agreement with the experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Formation and Structure of a Current Sheet in Pulsed-Power Driven Magnetic Reconnection Experiments
Authors:
J. D. Hare,
S. V. Lebedev,
L. G. Suttle,
N. F. Loureiro,
A. Ciardi,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
S. J. Eardley,
C. Garcia,
J. W. D. Halliday,
N. Niasse,
T. Robinson,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
G. F. Swadling,
J. Ma,
J. Wu
Abstract:
We describe magnetic reconnection experiments using a new, pulsed-power driven experimental platform in which the inflows are super-sonic but sub-Alfvénic.The intrinsically magnetised plasma flows are long lasting, producing a well-defined reconnection layer that persists over many hydrodynamic time scales.The layer is diagnosed using a suite of high resolution laser based diagnostics which provid…
▽ More
We describe magnetic reconnection experiments using a new, pulsed-power driven experimental platform in which the inflows are super-sonic but sub-Alfvénic.The intrinsically magnetised plasma flows are long lasting, producing a well-defined reconnection layer that persists over many hydrodynamic time scales.The layer is diagnosed using a suite of high resolution laser based diagnostics which provide measurements of the electron density, reconnecting magnetic field, inflow and outflow velocities and the electron and ion temperatures.Using these measurements we observe a balance between the power flow into and out of the layer, and we find that the heating rates for the electrons and ions are significantly in excess of the classical predictions. The formation of plasmoids is observed in laser interferometry and optical self-emission, and the magnetic O-point structure of these plasmoids is confirmed using magnetic probes.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2017; v1 submitted 30 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Counter-propagating radiative shock experiments on the Orion laser and the formation of radiative precursors
Authors:
T. Clayson,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
S. V. Lebedev,
G. F. Swadling,
C. Stehle,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. M. Foster,
J. Skidmore,
P. Graham,
E. Gumbrell,
S. Patankar,
C. Spindloe,
U. Chaulagain,
M. Kozlova,
J. Larour,
R. L. Singh,
R. Rodriguez,
J. M. Gil,
G. Espinosa,
P. Velarde,
C. Danson
Abstract:
We present results from new experiments to study the dynamics of radiative shocks, reverse shocks and radiative precursors. Laser ablation of a solid piston by the Orion high-power laser at AWE Aldermaston UK was used to drive radiative shocks into a gas cell initially pressurised between $0.1$ and $1.0 \ bar$ with different noble gases. Shocks propagated at {$80 \pm 10 \ km/s$} and experienced st…
▽ More
We present results from new experiments to study the dynamics of radiative shocks, reverse shocks and radiative precursors. Laser ablation of a solid piston by the Orion high-power laser at AWE Aldermaston UK was used to drive radiative shocks into a gas cell initially pressurised between $0.1$ and $1.0 \ bar$ with different noble gases. Shocks propagated at {$80 \pm 10 \ km/s$} and experienced strong radiative cooling resulting in post-shock compressions of { $\times 25 \pm 2$}. A combination of X-ray backlighting, optical self-emission streak imaging and interferometry (multi-frame and streak imaging) were used to simultaneously study both the shock front and the radiative precursor. These experiments present a new configuration to produce counter-propagating radiative shocks, allowing for the study of reverse shocks and providing a unique platform for numerical validation. In addition, the radiative shocks were able to expand freely into a large gas volume without being confined by the walls of the gas cell. This allows for 3-D effects of the shocks to be studied which, in principle, could lead to a more direct comparison to astrophysical phenomena. By maintaining a constant mass density between different gas fills the shocks evolved with similar hydrodynamics but the radiative precursor was found to extend significantly further in higher atomic number gases ($\sim$$4$ times further in xenon than neon). Finally, 1-D and 2-D radiative-hydrodynamic simulations are presented showing good agreement with the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Anomalous Heating and Plasmoid Formation in a Driven Magnetic Reconnection Experiment
Authors:
J. D. Hare,
L. Suttle,
S. V. Lebedev,
N. F. Loureiro,
A. Ciardi,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
C. Garcia,
N. Niasse,
T. Robinson,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
G. F. Swadling,
J. Ma,
J. Wu,
Q. Yang
Abstract:
We present a detailed study of magnetic reconnection in a quasi-two-dimensional pulsed-power driven laboratory experiment. Oppositely directed magnetic fields $(B=3$ T), advected by supersonic, sub-Alfvénic carbon plasma flows $(V_{in}=50$ km/s), are brought together and mutually annihilate inside a thin current layer ($δ=0.6$ mm). Temporally and spatially resolved optical diagnostics, including i…
▽ More
We present a detailed study of magnetic reconnection in a quasi-two-dimensional pulsed-power driven laboratory experiment. Oppositely directed magnetic fields $(B=3$ T), advected by supersonic, sub-Alfvénic carbon plasma flows $(V_{in}=50$ km/s), are brought together and mutually annihilate inside a thin current layer ($δ=0.6$ mm). Temporally and spatially resolved optical diagnostics, including interferometry, Faraday rotation imaging and Thomson scattering, allow us to determine the structure and dynamics of this layer, the nature of the inflows and outflows and the detailed energy partition during the reconnection process. We measure high electron and ion temperatures $(T_e=100$ eV, $T_i=600$ eV), far in excess of what can be attributed to classical (Spitzer) resistive and viscous dissipation. We observe the repeated formation and ejection of plasmoids, which we interpret as evidence of two-fluid effects in our experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2017; v1 submitted 29 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
