-
On the Principles behind Opinion Dynamics in Multi-Agent Systems of Large Language Models
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde
Abstract:
We study the evolution of opinions inside a population of interacting large language models (LLMs). Every LLM needs to decide how much funding to allocate to an item with three initial possibilities: full, partial, or no funding. We identify biases that drive the exchange of opinions based on the LLM's tendency to (i) find consensus with the other LLM's opinion, (ii) display caution when specifyin…
▽ More
We study the evolution of opinions inside a population of interacting large language models (LLMs). Every LLM needs to decide how much funding to allocate to an item with three initial possibilities: full, partial, or no funding. We identify biases that drive the exchange of opinions based on the LLM's tendency to (i) find consensus with the other LLM's opinion, (ii) display caution when specifying funding, and (iii) consider ethical concerns in its opinion. We find these biases are affected by the perceived absence of compelling reasons for opinion change, the perceived willingness to engage in discussion, and the distribution of allocation values. Moreover, tensions among biases can lead to the survival of funding for items with negative connotations. We also find that the final distribution of full, partial, and no funding opinions is more diverse when an LLM freely forms its opinion after an interaction than when its opinion is a multiple-choice selection among the three allocation options. In the latter case, consensus or polarization is generally attained. When agents are aware of past opinions, they seek to maintain consistency with them, and more diverse updating rules emerge. Our study is performed using a Llama 3 LLM.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Finite-sample Guarantees for Nash Q-learning with Linear Function Approximation
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Sanmi Koyejo
Abstract:
Nash Q-learning may be considered one of the first and most known algorithms in multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) for learning policies that constitute a Nash equilibrium of an underlying general-sum Markov game. Its original proof provided asymptotic guarantees and was for the tabular case. Recently, finite-sample guarantees have been provided using more modern RL techniques for the tabul…
▽ More
Nash Q-learning may be considered one of the first and most known algorithms in multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) for learning policies that constitute a Nash equilibrium of an underlying general-sum Markov game. Its original proof provided asymptotic guarantees and was for the tabular case. Recently, finite-sample guarantees have been provided using more modern RL techniques for the tabular case. Our work analyzes Nash Q-learning using linear function approximation -- a representation regime introduced when the state space is large or continuous -- and provides finite-sample guarantees that indicate its sample efficiency. We find that the obtained performance nearly matches an existing efficient result for single-agent RL under the same representation and has a polynomial gap when compared to the best-known result for the tabular case.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Restricted Strong Convexity of Deep Learning Models with Smooth Activations
Authors:
Arindam Banerjee,
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Libin Zhu,
Mikhail Belkin
Abstract:
We consider the problem of optimization of deep learning models with smooth activation functions. While there exist influential results on the problem from the ``near initialization'' perspective, we shed considerable new light on the problem. In particular, we make two key technical contributions for such models with $L$ layers, $m$ width, and $σ_0^2$ initialization variance. First, for suitable…
▽ More
We consider the problem of optimization of deep learning models with smooth activation functions. While there exist influential results on the problem from the ``near initialization'' perspective, we shed considerable new light on the problem. In particular, we make two key technical contributions for such models with $L$ layers, $m$ width, and $σ_0^2$ initialization variance. First, for suitable $σ_0^2$, we establish a $O(\frac{\text{poly}(L)}{\sqrt{m}})$ upper bound on the spectral norm of the Hessian of such models, considerably sharpening prior results. Second, we introduce a new analysis of optimization based on Restricted Strong Convexity (RSC) which holds as long as the squared norm of the average gradient of predictors is $Ω(\frac{\text{poly}(L)}{\sqrt{m}})$ for the square loss. We also present results for more general losses. The RSC based analysis does not need the ``near initialization" perspective and guarantees geometric convergence for gradient descent (GD). To the best of our knowledge, ours is the first result on establishing geometric convergence of GD based on RSC for deep learning models, thus becoming an alternative sufficient condition for convergence that does not depend on the widely-used Neural Tangent Kernel (NTK). We share preliminary experimental results supporting our theoretical advances.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Discrete State-Action Abstraction via the Successor Representation
Authors:
Amnon Attali,
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Marco Morales,
Nancy M. Amato
Abstract:
While the difficulty of reinforcement learning problems is typically related to the complexity of their state spaces, Abstraction proposes that solutions often lie in simpler underlying latent spaces. Prior works have focused on learning either a continuous or dense abstraction, or require a human to provide one. Information-dense representations capture features irrelevant for solving tasks, and…
▽ More
While the difficulty of reinforcement learning problems is typically related to the complexity of their state spaces, Abstraction proposes that solutions often lie in simpler underlying latent spaces. Prior works have focused on learning either a continuous or dense abstraction, or require a human to provide one. Information-dense representations capture features irrelevant for solving tasks, and continuous spaces can struggle to represent discrete objects. In this work we automatically learn a sparse discrete abstraction of the underlying environment. We do so using a simple end-to-end trainable model based on the successor representation and max-entropy regularization. We describe an algorithm to apply our model, named Discrete State-Action Abstraction (DSAA), which computes an action abstraction in the form of temporally extended actions, i.e., Options, to transition between discrete abstract states. Empirically, we demonstrate the effects of different exploration schemes on our resulting abstraction, and show that it is efficient for solving downstream tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2022; v1 submitted 7 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
One Policy is Enough: Parallel Exploration with a Single Policy is Near-Optimal for Reward-Free Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Boxiang Lyu,
Sanmi Koyejo,
Mladen Kolar
Abstract:
Although parallelism has been extensively used in reinforcement learning (RL), the quantitative effects of parallel exploration are not well understood theoretically. We study the benefits of simple parallel exploration for reward-free RL in linear Markov decision processes (MDPs) and two-player zero-sum Markov games (MGs). In contrast to the existing literature, which focuses on approaches that e…
▽ More
Although parallelism has been extensively used in reinforcement learning (RL), the quantitative effects of parallel exploration are not well understood theoretically. We study the benefits of simple parallel exploration for reward-free RL in linear Markov decision processes (MDPs) and two-player zero-sum Markov games (MGs). In contrast to the existing literature, which focuses on approaches that encourage agents to explore a diverse set of policies, we show that using a single policy to guide exploration across all agents is sufficient to obtain an almost-linear speedup in all cases compared to their fully sequential counterpart. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this simple procedure is near-minimax optimal in the reward-free setting for linear MDPs. From a practical perspective, our paper shows that a single policy is sufficient and provably near-optimal for incorporating parallelism during the exploration phase.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2023; v1 submitted 31 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Family-wise error rate control in Gaussian graphical model selection via Distributionally Robust Optimization
Authors:
Chau Tran,
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Sang-Yun Oh,
Alexander Petersen
Abstract:
Recently, a special case of precision matrix estimation based on a distributionally robust optimization (DRO) framework has been shown to be equivalent to the graphical lasso. From this formulation, a method for choosing the regularization term, i.e., for graphical model selection, was proposed. In this work, we establish a theoretical connection between the confidence level of graphical model sel…
▽ More
Recently, a special case of precision matrix estimation based on a distributionally robust optimization (DRO) framework has been shown to be equivalent to the graphical lasso. From this formulation, a method for choosing the regularization term, i.e., for graphical model selection, was proposed. In this work, we establish a theoretical connection between the confidence level of graphical model selection via the DRO formulation and the asymptotic family-wise error rate of estimating false edges. Simulation experiments and real data analyses illustrate the utility of the asymptotic family-wise error rate control behavior even in finite samples.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
From Contraction Theory to Fixed Point Algorithms on Riemannian and Non-Euclidean Spaces
Authors:
Francesco Bullo,
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Alexander Davydov,
Saber Jafarpour
Abstract:
The design of fixed point algorithms is at the heart of monotone operator theory, convex analysis, and of many modern optimization problems arising in machine learning and control. This tutorial reviews recent advances in understanding the relationship between Demidovich conditions, one-sided Lipschitz conditions, and contractivity theorems. We review the standard contraction theory on Euclidean s…
▽ More
The design of fixed point algorithms is at the heart of monotone operator theory, convex analysis, and of many modern optimization problems arising in machine learning and control. This tutorial reviews recent advances in understanding the relationship between Demidovich conditions, one-sided Lipschitz conditions, and contractivity theorems. We review the standard contraction theory on Euclidean spaces as well as little-known results for Riemannian manifolds. Special emphasis is placed on the setting of non-Euclidean norms and the recently introduced weak pairings for the $\ell_1$ and $\ell_\infty$ norms. We highlight recent results on explicit and implicit fixed point schemes for non-Euclidean contracting systems.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
A Contraction Theory Approach to Optimization Algorithms from Acceleration Flows
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
Much recent interest has focused on the design of optimization algorithms from the discretization of an associated optimization flow, i.e., a system of differential equations (ODEs) whose trajectories solve an associated optimization problem. Such a design approach poses an important problem: how to find a principled methodology to design and discretize appropriate ODEs. This paper aims to provide…
▽ More
Much recent interest has focused on the design of optimization algorithms from the discretization of an associated optimization flow, i.e., a system of differential equations (ODEs) whose trajectories solve an associated optimization problem. Such a design approach poses an important problem: how to find a principled methodology to design and discretize appropriate ODEs. This paper aims to provide a solution to this problem through the use of contraction theory. We first introduce general mathematical results that explain how contraction theory guarantees the stability of the implicit and explicit Euler integration methods. Then, we propose a novel system of ODEs, namely the Accelerated-Contracting-Nesterov flow, and use contraction theory to establish it is an optimization flow with exponential convergence rate, from which the linear convergence rate of its associated optimization algorithm is immediately established. Remarkably, a simple explicit Euler discretization of this flow corresponds to the Nesterov acceleration method. Finally, we present how our approach leads to performance guarantees in the design of optimization algorithms for time-varying optimization problems.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2022; v1 submitted 18 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Distributed Wasserstein Barycenters via Displacement Interpolation
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
Consider a multi-agent system whereby each agent has an initial probability measure. In this paper, we propose a distributed algorithm based upon stochastic, asynchronous and pairwise exchange of information and displacement interpolation in the Wasserstein space. We characterize the evolution of this algorithm and prove it computes the Wasserstein barycenter of the initial measures under various…
▽ More
Consider a multi-agent system whereby each agent has an initial probability measure. In this paper, we propose a distributed algorithm based upon stochastic, asynchronous and pairwise exchange of information and displacement interpolation in the Wasserstein space. We characterize the evolution of this algorithm and prove it computes the Wasserstein barycenter of the initial measures under various conditions. One version of the algorithm computes a standard Wasserstein barycenter, i.e., a barycenter based upon equal weights; and the other version computes a randomized Wasserstein barycenter, i.e., a barycenter based upon random weights for the initial measures. Finally, we specialize our algorithm to Gaussian distributions and draw a connection with the modeling of opinion dynamics in mathematical sociology.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2022; v1 submitted 15 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Contraction Theory for Dynamical Systems on Hilbert Spaces
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Saber Jafarpour,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
Contraction theory for dynamical systems on Euclidean spaces is well-established. For contractive (resp. semi-contractive) systems, the distance (resp. semi-distance) between any two trajectories decreases exponentially fast. For partially contractive systems, each trajectory converges exponentially fast to an invariant subspace.
In this note, we develop contraction theory on Hilbert spaces. Fir…
▽ More
Contraction theory for dynamical systems on Euclidean spaces is well-established. For contractive (resp. semi-contractive) systems, the distance (resp. semi-distance) between any two trajectories decreases exponentially fast. For partially contractive systems, each trajectory converges exponentially fast to an invariant subspace.
In this note, we develop contraction theory on Hilbert spaces. First, we provide a novel integral condition for contractivity, and for time-invariant systems, we establish the existence of a unique globally exponentially stable equilibrium. Second, we introduce the notions of partial and semi-contraction and we provide various sufficient conditions for time-varying and time-invariant systems. Finally, we apply the theory on a classic reaction-diffusion system.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2021; v1 submitted 2 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Multi-group SIS Epidemics with Simplicial and Higher-Order Interactions
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
This paper analyzes a Susceptible-Infected-Susceptible (SIS) model of epidemic propagation over hypergraphs and, motivated by an important special case, we refer to the model as to the simplicial SIS model. Classically, the multi-group SIS model has assumed pairwise interactions of contagion across groups and thus has been vastly studied in the literature. It is only recently that a renewed specia…
▽ More
This paper analyzes a Susceptible-Infected-Susceptible (SIS) model of epidemic propagation over hypergraphs and, motivated by an important special case, we refer to the model as to the simplicial SIS model. Classically, the multi-group SIS model has assumed pairwise interactions of contagion across groups and thus has been vastly studied in the literature. It is only recently that a renewed special attention has been drawn to the study of contagion dynamics over higher-order interactions and over more general graph structures, like simplexes. Previous work on mean-field approximation scalar models of the simplicial SIS model has indicated that a new dynamical behavior domain, compared to the classical SIS model, appears due to the newly introduced higher order interaction terms: both a disease-free equilibrium and an endemic equilibrium co-exist and are both locally asymptotically stable. This paper formally establishes that bistability (as a new epidemiological behavior) also appears in the multi-group simplicial SIS model. We give sufficient conditions over the model's parameters for the appearance of this and the other behavioral domains present in the classical multi-group SIS model. We additionally provide an algorithm to compute the value of the endemic equilibrium and report numerical analysis of the transition from the disease-free domain to the bistable domain.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2021; v1 submitted 22 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Weak and Semi-Contraction for Network Systems and Diffusively-Coupled Oscillators
Authors:
Saber Jafarpour,
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
We develop two generalizations of contraction theory, namely, semi-contraction and weak-contraction theory. First, using the notion of semi-norm, we propose a geometric framework for semi-contraction theory. We introduce matrix semi-measures and characterize their properties. We show that the spectral abscissa of a matrix is the infimum over weighted semi-measures. For dynamical systems, we use th…
▽ More
We develop two generalizations of contraction theory, namely, semi-contraction and weak-contraction theory. First, using the notion of semi-norm, we propose a geometric framework for semi-contraction theory. We introduce matrix semi-measures and characterize their properties. We show that the spectral abscissa of a matrix is the infimum over weighted semi-measures. For dynamical systems, we use the semi-measure of their Jacobian to characterize the contractivity properties of their trajectories. Second, for weakly contracting systems, we prove a dichotomy for the asymptotic behavior of their trajectories and novel sufficient conditions for convergence to an equilibrium. Third, we show that every trajectory of a doubly-contracting system, i.e., a system that is both weakly and semi-contracting, converges to an equilibrium point. Finally, we apply our results to various important network systems including affine averaging and affine flow systems, continuous-time distributed primal-dual algorithms, and networks of diffusively-coupled dynamical systems. For diffusively-coupled systems, the semi-contraction theory leads to a sufficient condition for synchronization that is sharper, in general, than previously-known tests.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2020; v1 submitted 19 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Distributed and time-varying primal-dual dynamics via contraction analysis
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Saber Jafarpour,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
In this note, we provide an overarching analysis of primal-dual dynamics associated to linear equality-constrained optimization problems using contraction analysis. For the well-known standard version of the problem: we establish convergence under convexity and the contracting rate under strong convexity. Then, for a canonical distributed optimization problem, we use partial contractivity to estab…
▽ More
In this note, we provide an overarching analysis of primal-dual dynamics associated to linear equality-constrained optimization problems using contraction analysis. For the well-known standard version of the problem: we establish convergence under convexity and the contracting rate under strong convexity. Then, for a canonical distributed optimization problem, we use partial contractivity to establish global exponential convergence of its primal-dual dynamics. As an application, we propose a new distributed solver for the least-squares problem with the same convergence guarantees. Finally, for time-varying versions of both centralized and distributed primal-dual dynamics, we exploit their contractive nature to establish bounds on their tracking error. To support our analyses, we introduce novel results on contraction theory.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2021; v1 submitted 27 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
A Network Formation Game for the Emergence of Hierarchies
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
We propose a novel network formation game that explains the emergence of various hierarchical structures in groups where self-interested or utility-maximizing individuals decide to establish or severe relationships of authority or collaboration among themselves. We consider two settings: we first consider individuals who do not seek the other party's consent when establishing a relationship and th…
▽ More
We propose a novel network formation game that explains the emergence of various hierarchical structures in groups where self-interested or utility-maximizing individuals decide to establish or severe relationships of authority or collaboration among themselves. We consider two settings: we first consider individuals who do not seek the other party's consent when establishing a relationship and then individuals who do. For both settings, we formally relate the emerged hierarchical structures with the novel inclusion of well-motivated hierarchy promoting terms in the individuals' utility functions. We first analyze the game via a static analysis and characterize all the hierarchical structures that can be formed as its solutions. We then consider the game played dynamically under stochastic interactions among individuals implementing better-response dynamics and analyze the nature of the converged networks.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2020; v1 submitted 14 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Structural Balance via Gradient Flows over Signed Graphs
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Noah E. Friedkin,
Anton V. Proskurnikov,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
Structural balance is a classic property of signed graphs satisfying Heider's seminal axioms. Mathematical sociologists have studied balance theory since its inception in the 1040s. Recent research has focused on the development of dynamic models explaining the emergence of structural balance. In this paper, we introduce a novel class of parsimonious dynamic models for structural balance based on…
▽ More
Structural balance is a classic property of signed graphs satisfying Heider's seminal axioms. Mathematical sociologists have studied balance theory since its inception in the 1040s. Recent research has focused on the development of dynamic models explaining the emergence of structural balance. In this paper, we introduce a novel class of parsimonious dynamic models for structural balance based on an interpersonal influence process. Our proposed models are gradient flows of an energy function, called the dissonance function, which captures the cognitive dissonance arising from violations of Heider's axioms. Thus, we build a new connection with the literature on energy landscape minimization. This gradient flow characterization allows us to study the transient and asymptotic behaviors of our model. We provide mathematical and numerical results describing the critical points of the dissonance function.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Distributionally Robust Formulation and Model Selection for the Graphical Lasso
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Sang-Yun Oh,
Alexander Petersen
Abstract:
Building on a recent framework for distributionally robust optimization, we consider estimation of the inverse covariance matrix for multivariate data. We provide a novel notion of a Wasserstein ambiguity set specifically tailored to this estimation problem, leading to a tractable class of regularized estimators. Special cases include penalized likelihood estimators for Gaussian data, specifically…
▽ More
Building on a recent framework for distributionally robust optimization, we consider estimation of the inverse covariance matrix for multivariate data. We provide a novel notion of a Wasserstein ambiguity set specifically tailored to this estimation problem, leading to a tractable class of regularized estimators. Special cases include penalized likelihood estimators for Gaussian data, specifically the graphical lasso estimator. As a consequence of this formulation, the radius of the Wasserstein ambiguity set is directly related to the regularization parameter in the estimation problem. Using this relationship, the level of robustness of the estimation procedure can be shown to correspond to the level of confidence with which the ambiguity set contains a distribution with the population covariance. Furthermore, a unique feature of our formulation is that the radius can be expressed in closed-form as a function of the ordinary sample covariance matrix. Taking advantage of this finding, we develop a simple algorithm to determine a regularization parameter for graphical lasso, using only the bootstrapped sample covariance matrices, meaning that computationally expensive repeated evaluation of the graphical lasso algorithm is not necessary. Alternatively, the distributionally robust formulation can also quantify the robustness of the corresponding estimator if one uses an off-the-shelf method such as cross-validation. Finally, we numerically study the obtained regularization criterion and analyze the robustness of other automated tuning procedures used in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2019; v1 submitted 22 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Signed Network Formation Games and Clustering Balance
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
We propose a signed network formation game, in which pairs of individuals strategically change the signs of the edges in a complete network. These individuals are members of a social network who strategically reduce cognitive dissonances by changing their interpersonal appraisals. We characterize the best-response dynamics for this game and prove that its implementation \pc{can} dynamically drive…
▽ More
We propose a signed network formation game, in which pairs of individuals strategically change the signs of the edges in a complete network. These individuals are members of a social network who strategically reduce cognitive dissonances by changing their interpersonal appraisals. We characterize the best-response dynamics for this game and prove that its implementation \pc{can} dynamically drive the network to a sociologically meaningful sign configuration called clustering balance. In this configuration, agents in the social network form one or more clusters that have positive relationships among their members but negative relationships among members of other clusters. In the past, various researchers in the fields of psycho-sociology, political science, and physics have looked at models that explain the generation of up to two clusters. Our work contributes to these fields by proposing a simple model that generates a broader class of signed networks.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2019; v1 submitted 5 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Polarization and Fluctuations in Signed Social Networks
Authors:
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Kevin S. Chan,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
Much recent research on social networks has focused on the modeling and analysis of how opinions evolve as a function of interpersonal relationships. It is also of great interest to model and understand the implications of friendly and antagonistic relationships. In this paper, we propose a new, simple and intuitive model that incorporates the socio-psychological phenomenon of the boomerang effect…
▽ More
Much recent research on social networks has focused on the modeling and analysis of how opinions evolve as a function of interpersonal relationships. It is also of great interest to model and understand the implications of friendly and antagonistic relationships. In this paper, we propose a new, simple and intuitive model that incorporates the socio-psychological phenomenon of the boomerang effect in opinion dynamics. We establish that, under certain conditions on the structure of the signed network that corresponds to the so-called structural balance property, the opinions in the network polarize. Compared to other models in the literature, our model displays a richer and perhaps more intuitive behavior of the opinions when the social network does not satisfy structural balance. In particular, we analyze signed networks in which the opinions show persistent fluctuations (including the case of the so-called clustering balance).
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2019; v1 submitted 2 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Dynamic Social Balance and Convergent Appraisals via Homophily and Influence Mechanisms
Authors:
Wenjun Mei,
Pedro Cisneros-Velarde,
Ge Chen,
Noah E. Friedkin,
Francesco Bullo
Abstract:
Social balance theory describes allowable and forbidden configurations of the topologies of signed directed social appraisal networks. In this paper, we propose two discrete-time dynamical systems that explain how an appraisal network \textcolor{blue}{converges to} social balance from an initially unbalanced configuration. These two models are based on two different socio-psychological mechanisms…
▽ More
Social balance theory describes allowable and forbidden configurations of the topologies of signed directed social appraisal networks. In this paper, we propose two discrete-time dynamical systems that explain how an appraisal network \textcolor{blue}{converges to} social balance from an initially unbalanced configuration. These two models are based on two different socio-psychological mechanisms respectively: the homophily mechanism and the influence mechanism. Our main theoretical contribution is a comprehensive analysis for both models in three steps. First, we establish the well-posedness and bounded evolution of the interpersonal appraisals. Second, we fully characterize the set of equilibrium points; for both models, each equilibrium network is composed by an arbitrary number of complete subgraphs satisfying structural balance. Third, we establish the equivalence among three distinct properties: non-vanishing appraisals, convergence to all-to-all appraisal networks, and finite-time achievement of social balance. In addition to theoretical analysis, Monte Carlo validations illustrates how the non-vanishing appraisal condition holds for generic initial conditions in both models. Moreover, numerical comparison between the two models indicate that the homophily-based model might be a more universal explanation for the formation of social balance. Finally, adopting the homophily-based model, we present numerical results on the mediation and globalization of local conflicts, the competition for allies, and the asymptotic formation of a single versus two factions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2019; v1 submitted 25 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
