-
Interpreting the Value of Flexibility in AC Security-Constrained Transmission Expansion Planning via a Cooperative Game Framework
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Wangwei Kong,
Mohammad Iman Alizadeh,
Florin Capitanescu,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Eduardo A. Martínez Ceseña
Abstract:
Security-constrained transmission expansion planning (SCTEP) is an inherently complex problem that requires simultaneously solving multiple contingency states of the system (usually corresponding to N-1 security criterion). Existing studies focus on effectively finding optimal solutions; however, single optimal solutions are not sufficient to interpret the value of flexibility (e.g., from energy s…
▽ More
Security-constrained transmission expansion planning (SCTEP) is an inherently complex problem that requires simultaneously solving multiple contingency states of the system (usually corresponding to N-1 security criterion). Existing studies focus on effectively finding optimal solutions; however, single optimal solutions are not sufficient to interpret the value of flexibility (e.g., from energy storage systems) and support system planners in well-informed decision making. In view of planning uncertainties, it is necessary to estimate the contributions of flexibility to various objectives and prioritise the most effective investments. In this regard, this work introduces a SCTEP tool that enables interpreting the value of flexibility in terms of contributions to avoided load curtailment and total expected system cost reduction. Inspired by cooperative game theory, the tool ranks the contributions of flexibility providers and compares them against traditional line reinforcements. This information can be used by system planners to prioritise investments with higher contributions and synergistic capabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2024; v1 submitted 5 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Impacts of Distribution Network Reconfiguration on Aggregated DER Flexibility
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Miguel Sanchez-Lopez,
Mohammad Iman Alizadeh,
Florin Capitanescu,
Eduardo A. Martínez Ceseña,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
The ongoing integration of controllable distributed energy resources (DER) makes distribution networks capable of aggregating flexible power and providing flexibility services at both transmission and distribution levels. The aggregated flexibility of an active distribution network (ADN) can be represented as its feasible operating area in the P-Q space. The limits of this area are pivotal for arr…
▽ More
The ongoing integration of controllable distributed energy resources (DER) makes distribution networks capable of aggregating flexible power and providing flexibility services at both transmission and distribution levels. The aggregated flexibility of an active distribution network (ADN) can be represented as its feasible operating area in the P-Q space. The limits of this area are pivotal for arranging flexibility markets and coordinating transmission and distribution system operators (TSOs and DSOs). However, motivated by the current technical limitations of distribution networks (e.g., protection schemes), existing literature on ADN flexibility and TSO-DSO coordination mostly focuses on radial networks, overlooking the potential benefits of network reconfiguration. This paper, using a realistic meshed distribution system from the UK and the exact ACOPF model for flexibility estimation, demonstrates that network reconfiguration can increase the limits of ADN aggregated flexibility and improve the economic efficiency of flexibility markets.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Tracing, Ranking and Valuation of Aggregated DER Flexibility in Active Distribution Networks
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Wangwei Kong,
Jose N. Melchor Gutierrez,
Eduardo A. Martínez Ceseña,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
The integration of distributed energy resources (DER) makes active distribution networks (ADNs) natural providers of flexibility services. However, the optimal operation of flexible units in ADNs is highly complex, which poses challenges for distribution system operators (DSOs) in aggregating DER flexibility. For example, to maximise the provision of services, flexible units must be strongly coord…
▽ More
The integration of distributed energy resources (DER) makes active distribution networks (ADNs) natural providers of flexibility services. However, the optimal operation of flexible units in ADNs is highly complex, which poses challenges for distribution system operators (DSOs) in aggregating DER flexibility. For example, to maximise the provision of services, flexible units must be strongly coordinated to manage network constraints, e.g., perform power swaps. Furthermore, due to the nonlinearities of aggregated DER flexibility provision, some units may need to rapidly change their outputs to enable the services. To address these challenges, this paper brings together exact AC optimal power flow (OPF) models and a cooperative game formulation and presents a new framework for tracing, ranking, and valuation of aggregated DER flexibility in ADNs. Extensive tests and simulations performed for the 33-bus radial distribution network demonstrate that the framework enables translating complex DER interactions into useful information for DSOs by ranking the criticality of flexible units and performing flexibility valuation based on its cost or economic surplus. Additionally, the framework proposes no-swap constraints and a nonlinearity metric which can be used by DSOs to identify unreliable operating regions with power swaps or rapid changes in flexible unit dispatch.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2023; v1 submitted 7 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Assessing Active Distribution Network Flexibility: On the Effects of Nonlinearities and Nonconvexities
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Eduardo A. Martinez Cesena
Abstract:
A widespread approach to characterise the aggregated flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) is to estimate the boundary of the feasible network operating areas using convex polygons in the P-Q space. However, such approximations can be inaccurate under realistic conditions where, for example, the nonlinear nature of the network is captured, and the behaviour of flexible units is constr…
▽ More
A widespread approach to characterise the aggregated flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) is to estimate the boundary of the feasible network operating areas using convex polygons in the P-Q space. However, such approximations can be inaccurate under realistic conditions where, for example, the nonlinear nature of the network is captured, and the behaviour of flexible units is constrained. This letter demonstrates, using a small ADN example with four flexible units and considering only nonlinearities from the network, that reaching the full P-Q flexibility areas would require perfect coordination of units and high ram** rates. Without these requirements, the P-Q areas become nonconvex. Thus, if the effects of nonlinearities and nonconvexities are ignored, existing approaches in the literature can result in overestimation of ADN flexibility and give rise to impractical solutions, hampering coordination between transmission and distribution system operators.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Assessing Distribution Network Flexibility via Reliability-based P-Q Area Segmentation
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Wangwei Kong,
Jose N. Melchor Gutierrez,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Eduardo A. Martinez Cesena
Abstract:
This paper proposes a framework to assess the flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) via P-Q area segmentation, considering the reliability of flexible units (FUs). A mixed-integer quadratically constrained programming (MIQCP) model is formulated to analyse flexible active and reactive power support at the interface with transmission networks, explicitly capturing the contributions and…
▽ More
This paper proposes a framework to assess the flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) via P-Q area segmentation, considering the reliability of flexible units (FUs). A mixed-integer quadratically constrained programming (MIQCP) model is formulated to analyse flexible active and reactive power support at the interface with transmission networks, explicitly capturing the contributions and reliability of FUs that provide flexibility services within an ADN. The numerical simulations performed for a real 124-bus UK distribution network demonstrate the optimal flexibility provision by different FUs, as well as the corresponding reliability and the impact of network reconfiguration. Distribution system operators (DSOs) can use the proposed framework to identify critical units, select an adequate combination of flexibility volumes, and manage its reliability.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2023; v1 submitted 3 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Anomalous low-energy properties in amorphous solids and the interplay of electric and elastic interactions of tunneling two-level systems
Authors:
Alexander Churkin,
Shlomi Matityahu,
Andrii O. Maksymov,
Alexander L. Burin,
Moshe Schechter
Abstract:
Tunneling two-level systems (TLSs), generic to amorphous solids, dictate the low-temperature properties of amorphous solids and dominate noise and decoherence in quantum nano-devices. The properties of the TLSs are generally described by the phenomenological standard tunneling model. Yet, significant deviations from the predictions of this model found experimentally suggest the need for a more pre…
▽ More
Tunneling two-level systems (TLSs), generic to amorphous solids, dictate the low-temperature properties of amorphous solids and dominate noise and decoherence in quantum nano-devices. The properties of the TLSs are generally described by the phenomenological standard tunneling model. Yet, significant deviations from the predictions of this model found experimentally suggest the need for a more precise model in describing TLSs. Here we show that the temperature dependence of the sound velocity, dielectric constant, specific heat, and thermal conductivity, can be explained using an energy-dependent TLS density of states reduced at low energies due to TLS-TLS interactions. This reduction is determined by the ratio between the strengths of the TLS-TLS interactions and the random potential, which is enhanced in systems with dominant electric dipolar interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2021; v1 submitted 7 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Non-homogeneity of the density of states of tunneling two-level systems at low energies
Authors:
A. Churkin,
D. Barash,
M. Schechter
Abstract:
Amorphous solids, and many disordered lattices, exhibit a remarkable qualitative and quantitative universality in their acoustic properties at temperature $\lesssim 3$K. This phenomenon is attributed to the existence of tunneling two level systems (TTLSs), characterized by a homogenous density of states (DOS) at energies much lower than the disorder energy ($\approx 0.1$eV). Here we calculate nume…
▽ More
Amorphous solids, and many disordered lattices, exhibit a remarkable qualitative and quantitative universality in their acoustic properties at temperature $\lesssim 3$K. This phenomenon is attributed to the existence of tunneling two level systems (TTLSs), characterized by a homogenous density of states (DOS) at energies much lower than the disorder energy ($\approx 0.1$eV). Here we calculate numerically, from first principles, the DOS of KBr:CN glass, the archetypal disordered lattice showing universality. In contrast to the standard tunneling model, we find that the DOS diminishes abruptly at $\approx 3$ K, and that tunneling states differ essentially by their symmetry under inversion. This structure of the TTLSs dictates the low temperature below which universality is observed, and the quantitative universality of the acoustic properties in glasses. Consequences to the properties of glasses at intermediate temperatures, as well as to the microscopic structure of amorphous solids, are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2014; v1 submitted 10 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
The strain gap in a system of weakly and strongly interacting two-level systems
Authors:
A. Churkin,
I. Gabdank,
A. Burin,
M. Schechter
Abstract:
Many disordered lattices exhibit remarkable universality in their low temperature properties, similar to that found in amorphous solids. Recently a two-TLS (two-level system) model was derived based on the microscopic characteristics of disordered lattices. Within the two-TLS model the quantitative universality of phonon attenuation, and the energy scale of $1-3$ K below which universality is obse…
▽ More
Many disordered lattices exhibit remarkable universality in their low temperature properties, similar to that found in amorphous solids. Recently a two-TLS (two-level system) model was derived based on the microscopic characteristics of disordered lattices. Within the two-TLS model the quantitative universality of phonon attenuation, and the energy scale of $1-3$ K below which universality is observed, are derived as a consequence of the existence of two types of TLSs, differing by their interaction with the phonon field. In this paper we calculate analytically and numerically the densities of states (DOS) of the weakly and strongly interacting TLSs. We find that the DOS of the former can be well described by a Gaussian function, whereas the DOS of the latter have a power law correlation gap at low energies, with an intriguing dependence of the power on the short distance cutoff of the interaction. Both behaviors are markedly different from the logarithmic gap exhibited by a single species of interacting TLSs. Our results support the notion that it is the weakly interacting $τ$-TLSs that dictate the standard low temperature glassy physics. Yet, the power-law DOS we find for the $S$-TLSs enables the prediction of a number of deviations from the universal glassy behavior that can be tested experimentally. Our results carry through to the analogous system of electronic and nuclear spins, implying that electronic spin flip rate is significantly reduced at temperatures smaller than the magnitude of the hyperfine interaction.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2024; v1 submitted 2 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Acoustic interactions between inversion symmetric and asymmetric two-level systems
Authors:
A. Churkin,
D. Barash,
M. Schechter
Abstract:
Amorphous solids, as well as many disordered lattices, display remarkable universality in their low temperature acoustic properties. This universality is attributed to the attenuation of phonons by tunneling two-level systems (TLSs), facilitated by the interaction of the TLSs with the phonon field. TLS-phonon interaction also mediates effective TLS-TLS interactions, which dictates the existence of…
▽ More
Amorphous solids, as well as many disordered lattices, display remarkable universality in their low temperature acoustic properties. This universality is attributed to the attenuation of phonons by tunneling two-level systems (TLSs), facilitated by the interaction of the TLSs with the phonon field. TLS-phonon interaction also mediates effective TLS-TLS interactions, which dictates the existence of a glassy phase and its low energy properties. Here we consider KBr:CN, the archetypal disordered lattice showing universality. We calculate numerically, using conjugate gradients method, the effective TLS-TLS interactions for inversion symmetric (CN flips) and asymmetric (CN rotations) TLSs, in the absence and presence of disorder, in two and three dimensions. The observed dependence of the magnitude and spatial power law of the interaction on TLS symmetry, and its change with disorder, characterizes TLS-TLS interactions in disordered lattices in both extreme and moderate dilutions. Our results are in good agreement with the two-TLS model, recently introduced to explain long-standing questions regarding the quantitative universality of phonon attenuation and the energy scale of $\approx 1-3$ K below which universality is observed.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2014; v1 submitted 12 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
