-
Low-mass planets falling into gaps with cyclonic vortices
Authors:
Raúl O. Chametla,
F. J. Sánchez-Salcedo,
Mauricio Reyes-Ruiz,
Carlos Carrasco-González,
Ondrej Chrenko
Abstract:
We investigate the planetary migration of low-mass planets ($M_p\in[1,15]M_\oplus$, here $M_\oplus$ is the Earth mass) in a gaseous disc containing a previously formed gap. We perform high-resolution 3D simulations with the FARGO3D code. To create the gap in the surface density of the disc, we use a radial viscosity profile with a bump, which is maintained during the entire simulation time. We fin…
▽ More
We investigate the planetary migration of low-mass planets ($M_p\in[1,15]M_\oplus$, here $M_\oplus$ is the Earth mass) in a gaseous disc containing a previously formed gap. We perform high-resolution 3D simulations with the FARGO3D code. To create the gap in the surface density of the disc, we use a radial viscosity profile with a bump, which is maintained during the entire simulation time. We find that when the gap is sufficiently deep, the spiral waves excited by the planet trigger the Rossby wave instability, forming cyclonic (underdense) vortices at the edges of the gap. When the planet approaches the gap, it interacts with the vortices, which produce a complex flow structure around the planet. Remarkably, we find a widening of the horseshoe region of the planet produced by the vortex at the outer edge of the gap, which depending on the mass of the planet differs by at least a factor of two with respect to the standard horseshoe width. This inevitably leads to an increase in the corotation torque on the planet and produces an efficient trap to halt its inward migration. In some cases, the planet becomes locked in corotation with the outer vortex. Under this scenario, our results could explain why low-mass planets do not fall towards the central star within the lifetime of the protoplanetary disc. Lastly, the development of these vortices produces an asymmetric temporal evolution of the gap, which could explain the structures observed in some protoplanetary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
2.5-MHD models of circumstellar discs around FS~CMa post-mergers : II. Stationary accretion stage
Authors:
A. Moranchel-Basurto,
D. Korčáková,
R. O. Chametla
Abstract:
We study the star-disc interaction in the presence of the strong magnetic field ($B_\star=6.2kG$) of a slowly rotating star. This situation describes a post-merger of the spectral type B and has not been previously investigated. We perform a set of resistive and viscosity $2.5D$-magnetohydrodynamical simulations using the PLUTO code. Based on our previous work, we consider the initial gas disc den…
▽ More
We study the star-disc interaction in the presence of the strong magnetic field ($B_\star=6.2kG$) of a slowly rotating star. This situation describes a post-merger of the spectral type B and has not been previously investigated. We perform a set of resistive and viscosity $2.5D$-magnetohydrodynamical simulations using the PLUTO code. Based on our previous work, we consider the initial gas disc density $ρ_{d0}=10^{-13}\mathrm{gcm}^{-3}$ since it describes the conditions around IRAS 17449+2320 well. We find that the fall of gas towards the star occurs in the mid-plane, and remarkably, intermittent backflow takes place in the mid-plane in all of our models for $R\geq10R_\star$. However, we do not rule out that the funnel effect may occur and cause the accretion closer to the poles. Also, when larger values of viscosity ($α_ν=1$) and stellar rotation rate ($δ_\star=0.2$) are considered, we find that the disc exhibits a thickening which is characteristic of FS~CMa-type stellar objects. Additionally, we find that the poloidal magnetic field lines twist over short periods of time, leading to magnetic reconnection causing coronal heating that could explain the presence of the Raman lines found observationally in several FS~CMa stars. Lastly, we find the formation of several knots in the magnetic field lines near and in the mid-plane of the disc which produce perturbations in the density and velocity components, as well as the formation of shallow gaps whose position depends on the inflation of the magnetic field lines.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024; v1 submitted 1 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The inner disk rim of HD 163296: linking radiative hydrostatic models with infrared interferometry
Authors:
Ondřej Chrenko,
Mario Flock,
Takahiro Ueda,
Antoine Mérand,
Myriam Benisty,
Raúl O. Chametla
Abstract:
Previous studies of the protoplanetary disk HD 163296 revealed that the morphology of its sub-au infrared emission encompasses the terminal sublimation front of dust grains, referred to as the inner rim, but also extends into the (supposedly) dust-free region within it. Here, we present a set of radiative hydrostatic simulations of the inner rim in order to assess how much the rim alone can contri…
▽ More
Previous studies of the protoplanetary disk HD 163296 revealed that the morphology of its sub-au infrared emission encompasses the terminal sublimation front of dust grains, referred to as the inner rim, but also extends into the (supposedly) dust-free region within it. Here, we present a set of radiative hydrostatic simulations of the inner rim in order to assess how much the rim alone can contribute to the observed interferometric visibilities $V$, half-light radii $R_{\mathrm{hl}}$, and fractional disk fluxes $\mathcal{F}$ in the wavelength range $1.5$--$13\,μ\mathrm{m}$. In our set of models, we regulate the cooling efficiency of the disk via the boundary condition for radiation diffusion and we also modify the shape of the sublimation front. We find that when the cooling efficiency is reduced, the infrared photosphere at the rim becomes hotter, leading to an increase of $R_{\mathrm{hl}}$ sufficient to match the observations. However, the near-infrared disk flux is typically too low ($\mathcal{F}\simeq0.25$ at $1.5\,μ\mathrm{m}$), resulting in H-band visibility curves located above the observed data. We show that the match to the H-band observations up to moderate baselines can be improved when a wall-shaped rather than curved sublimation front is considered. Nevertheless, our model visibilities always exhibit a bounce at long baselines, which is not observed, confirming the need for additional emission interior to the rim. In summary, our study illustrates how the temperature structure and geometry of the inner rim needs to change in order to boost the rim's infrared emission.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Turbulent stress within dead zones and magnetic field dragging induced by Rossby vortices
Authors:
Raúl O. Chametla,
Ondrej Chrenko,
Mauricio Reyes-Ruiz,
F. J. Sánchez-Salcedo
Abstract:
By means of three dimensional resistive-magnetohydrodynamical models, we study the evolution of the so-called dead zones focused on the magnitude of the Reynolds and Maxwell stresses. We consider two different types of static resistivity radial profiles which give rise to an intermediate dead zone or an intermediate active zone. As we are interested in analyzing the strength of angular momentum tr…
▽ More
By means of three dimensional resistive-magnetohydrodynamical models, we study the evolution of the so-called dead zones focused on the magnitude of the Reynolds and Maxwell stresses. We consider two different types of static resistivity radial profiles which give rise to an intermediate dead zone or an intermediate active zone. As we are interested in analyzing the strength of angular momentum transport in these intermediate regions of the disc, we use as free parameters the radial extent of the intermediate dead ($Δr_\mathrm{idz}$) or active ($Δr_\mathrm{iact}$) zones, and the widths of the inner ($H_{b_1}$) and outer ($H_{b_2}$) transitions. We find that regardless of the width or radial extent of the intermediate zones, Rossby wave instability (RWI) develops at these transition boundaries, leading to the emergence of vortices and spiral waves. In the case of an intermediate dead zone, when $H_{b_1}\,,H_{b_2}\leq0.8$, the vortices are almost completely confined to the dead zone. Remarkably, we find that the formation of vortices at the inner transition can drag magnetic field lines into the dead zone stirring up the region that the vortex covers (reaching an $α\approx10^{-2}$ value similar to that of an active zone). Vortices formed in the outer transition only modify the Reynolds stress tensor. Our results can be important to understanding angular momentum transport in poorly ionized regions within the disc due to magnetized vortices within dead zones.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Accreting luminous low-mass planets escape from migration traps at pressure bumps
Authors:
O. Chrenko,
R. O. Chametla
Abstract:
We investigate the migration of Mars- to super-Earth-sized planets in the vicinity of a pressure bump in a 3D radiative protoplanetary disc while accounting for the effect of accretion heat release. Pressure bumps have often been assumed to act as efficient migration traps, but we show that the situation changes when the thermal forces are taken into account. Our simulations reveal that for planet…
▽ More
We investigate the migration of Mars- to super-Earth-sized planets in the vicinity of a pressure bump in a 3D radiative protoplanetary disc while accounting for the effect of accretion heat release. Pressure bumps have often been assumed to act as efficient migration traps, but we show that the situation changes when the thermal forces are taken into account. Our simulations reveal that for planetary masses $\lesssim$$2\,M_{\oplus}$, once their luminosity exceeds the critical value predicted by linear theory, thermal driving causes their orbits to become eccentric, quenching the positive corotation torque responsible for the migration trap. As a result, planets continue migrating inwards past the pressure bump. Additionally, we find that planets that remain circular and evolve in the super-Keplerian region of the bump exhibit a reversed asymmetry of their thermal lobes, with the heating torque having an opposite (negative) sign compared to the standard circular case, thus leading to inward migration as well. We also demonstrate that the super-critical luminosities of planets in question can be reached through the accretion of pebbles accumulating in the bump. Our findings have implications for planet formation scenarios that rely on the existence of migration traps at pressure bumps, as the bumps may repeatedly spawn inward-migrating low-mass embryos rather than harbouring newborn planets until they become massive.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
On wave interference in planet migration: dead zone torques modified by active zone forcing
Authors:
R. O. Chametla,
O. Chrenko,
W. Lyra,
N. J. Turner
Abstract:
We investigate planetary migration in the dead zone of a protoplanetary disk where there are a set of spiral waves propagating inward due to the turbulence in the active zone and the Rossby wave instability (RWI), which occurs at the transition between the dead and active zones. We perform global 3D unstratified magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) simulations of a gaseous disk with the FARGO3D code, using…
▽ More
We investigate planetary migration in the dead zone of a protoplanetary disk where there are a set of spiral waves propagating inward due to the turbulence in the active zone and the Rossby wave instability (RWI), which occurs at the transition between the dead and active zones. We perform global 3D unstratified magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) simulations of a gaseous disk with the FARGO3D code, using weak gradients in the static resistivity profiles that trigger the formation of a vortex at the outer edge of the dead zone. We find that once the Rossby vortex develops, spiral waves in the dead zone emerge and interact with embedded migrating planets by wave interference, which notably changes their migration. The inward migration becomes faster depending on the mass of the planet, due mostly to the constructive (destructive) interference between the outer (inner) spiral arm of the planet and, the destruction of the dynamics of the horseshoe region by means of the set of background spiral waves propagating inward. The constructive wave interference produces a more negative Lindblad differential torque which inevitably leads to an inward migration. Lastly, for massive planets embedded in the dead zone, we find that the spiral waves can create an asymmetric wider and depeer gap than in the case of $α$-disks, and can prevent the formation of vortices at the outer edge of the gap. The latter could generate a faster or slower migration compared to the standard type-II migration.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
2.5-MHD models of circumstellar discs around FS~CMa post-mergers : I. Non-stationary accretion stage
Authors:
A. Moranchel-Basurto,
D. Korčáková,
R. O. Chametla
Abstract:
We investigate the dynamic evolution of gaseous region around FS~CMa post-mergers. Due to the slow rotation of a central B-type star, the dynamics is driven mainly by the magnetic field of the central star. Recent observations have allowed us to set a realistic initial conditions such as, the magnetic field value ($B_\star\approx6\times10^{3}G$), the mass of the central star ($M_\star=6M_\odot$),…
▽ More
We investigate the dynamic evolution of gaseous region around FS~CMa post-mergers. Due to the slow rotation of a central B-type star, the dynamics is driven mainly by the magnetic field of the central star. Recent observations have allowed us to set a realistic initial conditions such as, the magnetic field value ($B_\star\approx6\times10^{3}G$), the mass of the central star ($M_\star=6M_\odot$), and the initial disc density $ρ_{d0}\in[10^{-13}\mathrm{g\,cm^{-3}},10^{-11}\mathrm{g \, cm^{-3}}] $. We use the PLUTO code to perform 2.5D-MHD simulations of thin and thick discs models. Especially relevant for the interpretation of the observed properties of FS~CMa post-mergers are the results for low-density discs, in which we find formation of a jet emerging from inner edge of the disc, as well as the formation of the so called "hot plasmoid" in the corona region. Jets are probably detected as discrete absorption components in the resonance lines of FS~CMa stars. Moreover, the magnetic field configuration in the low-density plasma region, favors the appearance of magnetocentrifugal winds from the disc. The currents toward the star created by the magnetic field may explain accidentally observed material infall. The disc structure is significantly changed due to the presence of the magnetic field. The magnetic field is also responsible for the formation of a hot corona as observed in several FS~CMa stars through the Raman lines. Our results are valid for all magnetic stars surrounded by a low density plasma, i.e., some of stars showing the B[e] phenomenon.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Evolution of the eccentricity and inclination of low-mass planets subjected to thermal forces: a numerical study
Authors:
S. Cornejo,
F. S. Masset,
R. O. Chametla,
S. Fromenteau
Abstract:
By means of three dimensional, high resolution hydrodynamical simulations we study the orbital evolution of weakly eccentric or inclined low-mass protoplanets embedded in gaseous discs subject to thermal diffusion. We consider both non-luminous planets, and planets that also experience the radiative feedback from their own luminosity. We compare our results to previous analytical work, and find th…
▽ More
By means of three dimensional, high resolution hydrodynamical simulations we study the orbital evolution of weakly eccentric or inclined low-mass protoplanets embedded in gaseous discs subject to thermal diffusion. We consider both non-luminous planets, and planets that also experience the radiative feedback from their own luminosity. We compare our results to previous analytical work, and find that thermal forces (the contribution to the disc's force arising from thermal effects) match those predicted by linear theory within $\sim 20$%. When the planet's luminosity exceeds a threshold found to be within $10$% of that predicted by linear theory, its eccentricity and inclination grow exponentially, whereas these quantities undergo a strong dam** below this threshold. In this regime of low luminosity indeed, thermal diffusion cools the surroundings of the planet and allows gas to accumulate in its vicinity. It is the dynamics of this gas excess that contributes to damp eccentricity and inclination. The dam** rates obtained can be up to $h^{-1}$ times larger than those due to the resonant interaction with the disc, where $h$ is the disc's aspect ratio. This suggests that models that incorporate planet-disc interactions using well-known formulae based on resonant wave-launching to describe the evolution of eccentricity and inclination underestimate the dam** action of the disc on the eccentricity and inclination of low-mass planets by an order of magnitude.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Estimating the depth of gaps opened by planets in eccentric orbit
Authors:
F. J. Sanchez-Salcedo,
R. O. Chametla,
O. Chrenko
Abstract:
Planets can carve gaps in the surface density of protoplanetary discs. The formation of these gaps can reduce the corotation torques acting on the planets. In addition, gaps can halt the accretion of solids onto the planets as dust and pebbles can be trapped at the edge of the gap. This accumulation of dust could explain the origin of the ring-like dust structures observed using high-resolution in…
▽ More
Planets can carve gaps in the surface density of protoplanetary discs. The formation of these gaps can reduce the corotation torques acting on the planets. In addition, gaps can halt the accretion of solids onto the planets as dust and pebbles can be trapped at the edge of the gap. This accumulation of dust could explain the origin of the ring-like dust structures observed using high-resolution interferometry. In this work we provide an empirical scaling relation for the depth of the gap cleared by a planet on an eccentric orbit as a function of the planet-to-star mass ratio $q$, the disc aspect ratio $h$, Shakura-Sunyaev viscosity parameter $α$, and planetary eccentricity $e$. We construct the scaling relation using a heuristic approach: we calibrate a toy model based on the impulse approximation with 2D hydrodynamical simulations. The scaling reproduces the gap depth for moderate eccentricities ($e\leq 4h$) and when the surface density contrast outside and inside the gap is $\leq 10^{2}$. Our framework can be used as the basis of more sophisticated models aiming to predict the radial gap profile for eccentric planets.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Trap** (sub-)Neptunes similar to TOI-216b at the inner disk rim: Implications for the disk viscosity and the Neptunian desert
Authors:
Ondřej Chrenko,
Raúl O. Chametla,
David Nesvorný,
Mario Flock
Abstract:
[Abridged] The occurrence rate of observed sub-Neptunes has a break at 0.1 au, which is often attributed to a migration trap at the inner rim of protoplanetary disks where a positive co-rotation torque prevents inward migration. We argue that conditions in inner disk regions are such that sub-Neptunes are likely to open gaps, lose the support of the co-rotation torque as their co-rotation regions…
▽ More
[Abridged] The occurrence rate of observed sub-Neptunes has a break at 0.1 au, which is often attributed to a migration trap at the inner rim of protoplanetary disks where a positive co-rotation torque prevents inward migration. We argue that conditions in inner disk regions are such that sub-Neptunes are likely to open gaps, lose the support of the co-rotation torque as their co-rotation regions become depleted, and the trap** efficiency then becomes uncertain. We study what it takes to trap such gap-opening planets at the inner disk rim. We performed 2D locally isothermal and non-isothermal hydrodynamic simulations of planet migration. A viscosity transition was introduced in the disk to (i) create a density drop and (ii) mimic the viscosity increase as the planet migrated from a dead zone towards a region with active magneto-rotational instability (MRI). We chose TOI-216b as a Neptune-like upper-limit test case, but we also explored different planetary masses, both on fixed and evolving orbits. For planet-to-star mass ratios $q\simeq(4$-$8)\times10^{-5}$, the density drop at the disk rim becomes reshaped due to a gap opening and is often replaced with a small density bump centered on the planet's corotation. Trap** is possible only if the bump retains enough gas mass and if the co-rotation region becomes azimuthally asymmetric, with an island of librating streamlines that accumulate a gas overdensity ahead of the planet. The overdensity exerts a positive torque that can counteract the negative torque of spiral arms. In our model, efficient trap** depends on the $α$ viscosity and its contrast across the viscosity transition. In order to trap TOI-216b, $α_{\mathrm{DZ}}=10^{-3}$ in the dead zone requires $α_{\mathrm{MRI}}\gtrsim5\times10^{-2}$ in the MRI-active zone. If $α_{\mathrm{DZ}}=5\times10^{-4}$, $α_{\mathrm{MRI}}\gtrsim7.5\times10^{-2}$ is needed.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2022; v1 submitted 22 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Spreading pressure bumps in gas-dust discs can stall planet migration via planet-vortex interactions
Authors:
R. O. Chametla,
O. Chrenko
Abstract:
We investigate the gravitational interaction between low- to intermediate-mass planets ($M_p \in[0.06-210]\,M_{\oplus}$) and two previously formed pressure bumps in a gas-dust protoplanetary disc. We explore how the disc structure changes due to planet-induced perturbations and also how the appearance of vortices affects planet migration. We use multifluid 2D hydrodynamical simulations and the dus…
▽ More
We investigate the gravitational interaction between low- to intermediate-mass planets ($M_p \in[0.06-210]\,M_{\oplus}$) and two previously formed pressure bumps in a gas-dust protoplanetary disc. We explore how the disc structure changes due to planet-induced perturbations and also how the appearance of vortices affects planet migration. We use multifluid 2D hydrodynamical simulations and the dust is treated in the pressureless-fluid approximation, assuming a single grain size of $5\,μ{\mathrm{m}}$. The initial surface density profiles containing two bumps are motivated by recent observations of the protoplanetary disc HD163296. When planets are allowed to migrate, either a single planet from the outer pressure maximum or two planets from each pressure maximum, the initial pressure bumps quickly spread and merge into a single bump which is radially wide and has a very low amplitude. The redistribution of the disc material is accompanied by the Rossby Wave Instability (RWI) and an appearance of mini-vortices that merge in a short period of time to form a large vortex. The large vortex induces perturbations with a spiral wave pattern that propagate away from the vortex as density waves. We found that these vortex-induced spiral waves strongly interact with the spiral waves generated by the planet and we called this mechanism the "\textit{Faraway Interaction}". It facilitates much slower and/or stagnant migration of the planets and it excites their orbital eccentricities in some cases. Our study provides a new explanation for how rocky planets can come to have a slow migration in protoplanetary discs where vortex formation occurs.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
How the planetary eccentricity influences the pebble isolation mass
Authors:
Raúl O. Chametla,
Frédéric S. Masset,
Clément Baruteau,
Bertram Bitsch
Abstract:
We investigate the pebble isolation mass for a planet on a fixed eccentric orbit in its protoplanetary disc by conducting a set of 2D hydrodynamical simulations including dust turbulent diffusion. A range of planet eccentricities up to $e=0.2$ is adopted. Our simulations also cover a range of $α-$turbulent viscosities, and for each pair $\{α,e\}$ the pebble isolation mass is estimated as the minim…
▽ More
We investigate the pebble isolation mass for a planet on a fixed eccentric orbit in its protoplanetary disc by conducting a set of 2D hydrodynamical simulations including dust turbulent diffusion. A range of planet eccentricities up to $e=0.2$ is adopted. Our simulations also cover a range of $α-$turbulent viscosities, and for each pair $\{α,e\}$ the pebble isolation mass is estimated as the minimum planet mass in our simulations such that solids with a Stokes number $\gtrsim 0.05$ do not flow across the planet orbit and remain trapped around a pressure bump outside the planet gap. For $α<10^{-3}$, we find that eccentric planets reach a well-defined pebble isolation mass, which can be smaller than for planets on circular orbits when the eccentricity remains smaller than the disc's aspect ratio. We provide a fitting formula for how the pebble isolation mass depends on planet eccentricity. However, for $α> 10^{-3}$, eccentric planets cannot fully stall the pebbles flow, and thus do not reach a well-defined pebble isolation mass. Our results suggest that the maximum mass reached by rocky cores should exhibit a dichotomy depending on the disc turbulent viscosity. While being limited to ${\cal O}(10\,M_\oplus)$ in low-viscosity discs, this maximum mass could reach much larger values in discs with a high turbulent viscosity in the planet vicinity. Our results further highlight that pebble filtering by growing planets might not be as effective as previously thought, especially in high-viscosity discs, with important implications to protoplanetary discs observations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Supernova Explosions in Accretion Disks in Active Galactic Nuclei: Three-Dimensional Models
Authors:
A. Moranchel-Basurto,
F. J. Sánchez-salcedo,
Raúl O. Chametla,
P. F. Velázquez
Abstract:
Supernova (SN) explosions can potentially affect the structure and evolution of circumnuclear disks in active galactic nuclei (AGN). Some previous studies have suggested that a relatively low rate of SN explosions can provide an effective value of alpha viscosity between 0.1 and 1 in AGN accretion disks within 1 pc scale. In order to test this possibility, we provide some analytic scalings of the…
▽ More
Supernova (SN) explosions can potentially affect the structure and evolution of circumnuclear disks in active galactic nuclei (AGN). Some previous studies have suggested that a relatively low rate of SN explosions can provide an effective value of alpha viscosity between 0.1 and 1 in AGN accretion disks within 1 pc scale. In order to test this possibility, we provide some analytic scalings of the evolution of a SN remnant embedded in a differentially rotating smooth disk. We calibrate our estimates using three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations where the gas is modeled as adiabatic with index $γ$. Our simulations are suited to include the fact that a fraction of the momentum injected by the SN escapes from the disk into the corona. Based on these results, we calculate the contribution of SN explosions to the effective alpha viscosity, denoted by $α_{SNe}$, in a model AGN accretion disk, where accretion is driven by the local viscosity $α$. We find that for AGN galaxies with a central black hole of $~ 10^8M_{\cdot}$ and a disk with viscosity $α=0.1$, the contribution of SN explosions may be as large as $α_{SNe} \simeq 0.02$, provided that $α\gtrsim 1.1$. On the other hand, in the momentum conservation limit, which is valid when the push by the internal pressure of the SN remnant is negligible, we find $α_SNe \lesssim 6\times10^{-4}$.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Numerical study of coorbital thermal torques on cold or hot satellites
Authors:
Raúl O. Chametla,
Frédéric S. Masset
Abstract:
We evaluate the thermal torques exerted on low-mass planets embedded in gaseous protoplanetary discs with thermal diffusion, by means of high-resolution three-dimensional hydrodynamics simulations. We confirm that thermal torques essentially depend on the offset between the planet and its corotation, and find a good agreement with analytic estimates when this offset is small compared to the size o…
▽ More
We evaluate the thermal torques exerted on low-mass planets embedded in gaseous protoplanetary discs with thermal diffusion, by means of high-resolution three-dimensional hydrodynamics simulations. We confirm that thermal torques essentially depend on the offset between the planet and its corotation, and find a good agreement with analytic estimates when this offset is small compared to the size of the thermal disturbance. For larger offsets that may be attained in discs with a large pressure gradient or a small thermal diffusivity, thermal torques tend toward an asymptotic value broadly compatible with results from a dynamical friction calculation in an unsheared medium. We perform a convergence study and find that the thermal disturbance must be resolved over typically 10 zones for a decent agreement with analytic predictions. We find that the luminosity at which the net thermal torque changes sign matches that predicted by linear theory within a few percents. Our study confirms that thermal torques usually supersede Lindblad and corotation torques by almost an order of magnitude for low mass planets. As we increase the planetary mass, we find that the ratio of thermal torques to Lindblad and corotation torques is progressively reduced, and that the thermal disturbance is increasingly distorted by the horseshoe flow. Overall, we find that thermal torques are dominant for masses up to an order of magnitude larger than implemented in recent models of planetary population synthesis. We finally briefly discuss the case of stellar or intermediate-mass objects embedded in discs around AGNs.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Capture and migration of Jupiter and Saturn in mean motion resonance in a gaseous protoplanetary disc
Authors:
Raul O. Chametla,
Gennaro D'Angelo,
Mauricio Reyes-Ruiz,
F. Javier Sanchez-Salcedo
Abstract:
We study the dynamical evolution of Jupiter and Saturn embedded in a gaseous, solar-nebula-type disc by means of hydrodynamics simulations with the FARGO2D1D code. We study the evolution for different initial separations of the planets' orbits, Delta a_SJ , to investigate whether they become captured in mean motion resonance (MMR) and the direction of the subsequent migration of the planet (inward…
▽ More
We study the dynamical evolution of Jupiter and Saturn embedded in a gaseous, solar-nebula-type disc by means of hydrodynamics simulations with the FARGO2D1D code. We study the evolution for different initial separations of the planets' orbits, Delta a_SJ , to investigate whether they become captured in mean motion resonance (MMR) and the direction of the subsequent migration of the planet (inward or outward). We also provide an assessment of the planet's orbital dynamics at different epochs of Saturn's growth. We find that the evolution of initially compact orbital configurations is dependent on the value of Delta a_SJ . This implies that an evolution as that proposed in the Grand Tack model depends on the precise initial orbits of Jupiter and Saturn and on the timescales for their formation. Capture in the 1:2 MMR and inward or (nearly) stalled migration are highly favoured. Within its limits, our work suggests that the reversed migration, associated with the resonance capture of Jupiter and Saturn, may be a low probability evolutionary scenario, so that other planetary systems with giant planets are not expected to have experienced a Grand Tack-like evolutionary path.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Gaseous wakes and dynamical friction: mass-losing and mass-gaining perturbers
Authors:
F. J. Sanchez-Salcedo,
R. O. Chametla
Abstract:
An extended gravitational object embedded in a parent system comprised of gas and collisionless particles may undergo both dynamical friction (DF) and mass loss by tidal forces. If the object is compact enough, it can increase its mass through accretion of material from the surrounding medium. We extend the classical linear analysis of DF on a constant-mass body in a gaseous medium to the case whe…
▽ More
An extended gravitational object embedded in a parent system comprised of gas and collisionless particles may undergo both dynamical friction (DF) and mass loss by tidal forces. If the object is compact enough, it can increase its mass through accretion of material from the surrounding medium. We extend the classical linear analysis of DF on a constant-mass body in a gaseous medium to the case where its mass changes with time. We show that the structure of the wake may differ significantly from the constant-mass case. For instance, the front-back symmetry of density about subsonic constant-mass perturbers is broken down for variable-mass perturbers. The density wake keeps a memory of the past mass history of the perturber. For dissolving perturbers, the density field is more dense than expected using the instantaneous mass of the perturber in the classical formula. As a consequence, the instantaneous-mass approximation underestimates the drag force for mass-losing perturbers and overestimates it for mass-gaining perturbers. We present cases in which the percentage error in the drag force using the instantaneous-mass approximation is greater than 50%.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Torques on low-mass bodies in retrograde orbit in gaseous disks
Authors:
F. J. Sanchez-Salcedo,
R. O. Chametla,
A. Santillan
Abstract:
We evaluate the torque acting on a gravitational perturber on a retrograde circular orbit in the midplane of a gaseous disk. We assume that the mass of this satellite is so low it weakly disturbs the disk (type I migration). The perturber may represent the companion of a binary system with a small mass ratio. We compare the results of hydrodynamical simulations with analytic predictions. Our two-d…
▽ More
We evaluate the torque acting on a gravitational perturber on a retrograde circular orbit in the midplane of a gaseous disk. We assume that the mass of this satellite is so low it weakly disturbs the disk (type I migration). The perturber may represent the companion of a binary system with a small mass ratio. We compare the results of hydrodynamical simulations with analytic predictions. Our two-dimensional (2D) simulations indicate that the torque acting on a perturber with softening radius $R_{\rm soft}$ can be accounted for by a scattering approach if $R_{\rm soft}<0.3H$, where $H$ is defined as the ratio between the sound speed and the angular velocity at the orbital radius of the perturber. For $R_{\rm soft}>0.3H$, the torque may present large and persistent oscillations, but the resultant time-averaged torque decreases rapidly with increasing $R_{\rm soft}/H$, in agreement with previous analytical studies. We then focus on the torque acting on small-size perturbers embedded in full three-dimensional (3D) disks and argue that the density waves propagating at distances $\lesssim H$ from the perturber contribute significantly to the torque because they transport angular momentum. We find a good agreement between the torque found in 3D simulations and analytical estimates based on ballistic orbits. We compare the radial migration timescales of prograde versus retrograde perturbers. For a certain range of the perturber's mass and aspect ratio of the disk, the radial migration timescale in the retrograde case may be appreciably shorter than in the prograde case. We also provide the smoothing length required in 2D simulations in order to account for 3D effects.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Gap formation by inclined massive planets in locally isothermal three-dimensional discs
Authors:
R. O. Chametla,
F. J. Sanchez-Salcedo,
F. S. Masset,
A. M. Hidalgo-Gamez
Abstract:
We study gap formation in gaseous protoplanetary discs by a Jupiter mass planet. The planet's orbit is circular and inclined relative to the midplane of the disc. We use the impulse approximation to estimate the gravitational tidal torque between the planet and the disc, and infer the gap profile. For low-mass discs, we provide a criterion for gap opening when the orbital inclination is…
▽ More
We study gap formation in gaseous protoplanetary discs by a Jupiter mass planet. The planet's orbit is circular and inclined relative to the midplane of the disc. We use the impulse approximation to estimate the gravitational tidal torque between the planet and the disc, and infer the gap profile. For low-mass discs, we provide a criterion for gap opening when the orbital inclination is $\leq 30^{\circ}$. Using the FARGO3D code, we simulate the disc response to an inclined massive planet. The dependence of the depth and width of the gap obtained in the simulations on the inclination of the planet is broadly consistent with the scaling laws derived in the impulse approximation. Although we mainly focus on planets kept on fixed orbits, the formalism permits to infer the temporal evolution of the gap profile in cases where the inclination of the planet changes with time. This study may be useful to understand the migration of massive planets on inclined orbit, because the strength of the interaction with the disc depends on whether a gap is opened or not.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Binaries traveling through a gaseous medium: Dynamical drag forces and internal torques
Authors:
F. J. Sanchez-Salcedo,
Raul O. Chametla
Abstract:
Using time-dependent linear theory, we investigate the morphology of the gravitational wake induced by a binary, whose center of mass moves at velocity Vcm against a uniform background of gas. For simplicity, we assume that the binary's components are on circular orbits about their common center of mass. The consequences of dynamical friction is twofold. First, gas dynamical friction may drag the…
▽ More
Using time-dependent linear theory, we investigate the morphology of the gravitational wake induced by a binary, whose center of mass moves at velocity Vcm against a uniform background of gas. For simplicity, we assume that the binary's components are on circular orbits about their common center of mass. The consequences of dynamical friction is twofold. First, gas dynamical friction may drag the binary's center of mass and cause the binary to migrate. Second, drag forces also induce a braking torque, which causes the orbits of the binary components to shrink. We compute the drag forces acting on one component of the binary due to the gravitational interaction with its own wake. We show that the dynamical friction force responsible to decelerate the binary's center of mass is smaller than it is in the point-mass case because of the loss of gravitational focusing. We show that the braking internal torque depends on the Mach numbers of each binary component about their center of mass, and also on the Mach number of the center of mass of the binary. In general, the internal torque decreases with increasing the velocity of the binary relative to the ambient gas cloud. However, this is not always the case. We also mention the relevance of our results on the period distribution of binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
