-
Photonic lantern wavefront reconstruction in a multi-wavefront sensor single-conjugate adaptive optics system
Authors:
Aditya R. Sengupta,
Jordan Diaz,
Benjamin L. Gerard,
Rebecca Jensen-Clem,
Daren Dillon,
Matthew DeMartino,
Kevin Bundy,
Sylvain Cetre,
Vincent Chambouleyron
Abstract:
Exoplanet direct imaging using adaptive optics (AO) is often limited by non-common path aberrations (NCPAs) and aberrations that are invisible to traditional pupil-plane wavefront sensors (WFSs). This can be remedied by focal-plane (FP) WFSs that characterize aberrations directly from a final science image. Photonic lanterns (PLs) can act as low-order FPWFSs with the ability to direct some light t…
▽ More
Exoplanet direct imaging using adaptive optics (AO) is often limited by non-common path aberrations (NCPAs) and aberrations that are invisible to traditional pupil-plane wavefront sensors (WFSs). This can be remedied by focal-plane (FP) WFSs that characterize aberrations directly from a final science image. Photonic lanterns (PLs) can act as low-order FPWFSs with the ability to direct some light to downstream science instruments. Using a PL on the SEAL (Santa Cruz Extreme AO Laboratory) high-contrast imaging testbed, we demonstrate (1) linear ranges and (2) closed-loop control. Additionally, we simulate the use of the PL in a multi-wavefront sensor AO system, in which multiple WFSs feed back to the same common-path deformable mirror. Building on previous multi-WFS AO demonstrations on SEAL, we simulate a modulated pyramid WFS to sense aberrations of high spatial order and large amplitude, and the PL to sense low order aberrations including NCPAs. We assess adaptive optics performance in this setting using three different PL wavefront reconstruction algorithms. We also provide a new method to experimentally identify the propagation matrix of a PL, making advanced model-based algorithms practical. This work demonstrates the role of photonic technologies and multi-stage wavefront sensing in the context of extreme AO and high contrast imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Keck Primary Mirror Closed-Loop Segment Control using a Vector-Zernike Wavefront Sensor
Authors:
Maissa Salama,
Charlotte Guthery,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Rebecca Jensen-Clem,
J. Kent Wallace,
Jacques-Robert Delorme,
Mitchell Troy,
Tobias Wenger,
Daniel Echeverri,
Luke Finnerty,
Nemanja Jovanovic,
Joshua Liberman,
Ronald A. Lopez,
Dimitri Mawet,
Evan C. Morris,
Maaike van Kooten,
Jason J. Wang,
Peter Wizinowich,
Yinzi Xin,
Jerry Xuan
Abstract:
We present the first on-sky segmented primary mirror closed-loop piston control using a Zernike wavefront sensor (ZWFS) installed on the Keck II telescope. Segment co-phasing errors are a primary contributor to contrast limits on Keck and will be necessary to correct for the next generation of space missions and ground-based extremely large telescopes (ELTs), which will all have segmented primary…
▽ More
We present the first on-sky segmented primary mirror closed-loop piston control using a Zernike wavefront sensor (ZWFS) installed on the Keck II telescope. Segment co-phasing errors are a primary contributor to contrast limits on Keck and will be necessary to correct for the next generation of space missions and ground-based extremely large telescopes (ELTs), which will all have segmented primary mirrors. The goal of the ZWFS installed on Keck is to monitor and correct primary mirror co-phasing errors in parallel with science observations. The ZWFS is ideal for measuring phase discontinuities such as segment co-phasing errors and is one of the most sensitive WFS, but has limited dynamic range. The vector-ZWFS at Keck works on the adaptive optics (AO) corrected wavefront and consists of a metasurface focal plane mask which imposes two different phase shifts on the core of the point spread function (PSF) to two orthogonal light polarizations, producing two pupil images. This design extends the dynamic range compared with the scalar ZWFS. The primary mirror segment pistons were controlled in closed-loop using the ZWFS, improving the Strehl ratio on the NIRC2 science camera by up to 10 percentage points. We analyze the performance of the closed-loop tests, the impact on NIRC2 science data, and discuss the ZWFS measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Expected performance of the Pyramid wavefront sensor with a laser guide star for 40 m class telescopes
Authors:
Francisco Oyarzún,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Benoit Neichel,
Thierry Fusco,
Andrés Guesalaga
Abstract:
The use of artificial Laser Guide Stars (LGS) is planned for the new generation of giant segmented mirror telescopes, to extend the sky coverage of their adaptive optics systems. The LGS, being a 3D object at a finite distance will have a large elongation that will affect its use with the Shack-Hartmann (SH) wavefront sensor. In this paper, we compute the expected performance for a Pyramid WaveFro…
▽ More
The use of artificial Laser Guide Stars (LGS) is planned for the new generation of giant segmented mirror telescopes, to extend the sky coverage of their adaptive optics systems. The LGS, being a 3D object at a finite distance will have a large elongation that will affect its use with the Shack-Hartmann (SH) wavefront sensor. In this paper, we compute the expected performance for a Pyramid WaveFront Sensor (PWFS) using a LGS for a 40 m telescope affected by photon noise, and also extend the analysis to a flat 2D object as reference. We developed a new way to discretize the LGS, and a new, faster method of propagating the light for any Fourier Filtering wavefront sensors (FFWFS) when using extended objects. We present the use of a sensitivity model to predict the performance of a closed-loop adaptive optic system. We optimized a point source calibrated interaction matrix to accommodate the signal of an extended object, by means of computing optical gains using a convolutional model. We found that the sensitivity drop, given the size of the extended laser source, is large enough to make the system operate in a low-performance regime given the expected return flux of the LGS. The width of the laser beam, rather than the thickness of the sodium layer was identified as the limiting factor. Even an ideal, flat LGS will have a drop in performance due to the flux of the LGS, and small variations in the return flux will result in large variations in performance. We conclude that knife-edge-like wavefront sensors, such as the PWFS, are not recommended for their use with LGS for a 40 m telescope, as they will operate in a low-performance regime, given the size of the extended object.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Strategy for sensing petal mode in presence of AO residual turbulence with pyramid wavefront sensor
Authors:
Nicolas Levraud,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Jean François Sauvage,
Benoit Neichel,
Mahawa Cisse,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Guido Agapito,
Cédric Plantet,
Anne Laure Cheffot,
Enrico Pinna,
Simone Esposito2,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
With the Extremely Large Telescope-generation telescopes come new challenges. The complexity of these telescopes' pupil creates new problems for Adaptive Optics. In particular, the large spiders necessary to support the massive optics of these telescopes create discontinuities in the wavefront measurement. These discontinuities appear as a new phase error dubbed the `petal mode'. This error is des…
▽ More
With the Extremely Large Telescope-generation telescopes come new challenges. The complexity of these telescopes' pupil creates new problems for Adaptive Optics. In particular, the large spiders necessary to support the massive optics of these telescopes create discontinuities in the wavefront measurement. These discontinuities appear as a new phase error dubbed the `petal mode'. This error is described as a differential piston between the fragment of the pupil separated by the spiders and is responsible for reducing the European Extremely Large Telescope's (ELT) resolution to a 15m telescope resolution. The aim of this paper is to study the measurement of the petal mode by adaptive optics sensors. We want to understand why the Pyramid Wavefront Sensor (PyWFS) cannot measure this petal mode under normal conditions and how to allow this measurement by adapting the Adaptive optics control scheme and the PyWFS. To facilitate our study, we consider a simplified version of the petal mode, featuring a simpler pupil than the ELT. We studied specifically how a system that separates the atmospheric turbulence from the petal measurement would behave. The unmodulated PyWFS (uPyWFS) but the uPyWFS does not make accurate measurements in the presence of atmospheric residuals. Studying the petal mode's power spectral density, we propose a filtering step, consisting of a pinhole around the pyramid tip. This reduces the first path residuals seen by the uPyWFS and restores its accuracy. Finally, we demonstrate our proposed system with end-to-end simulations.To address the petal problem, a two-path adaptive optics with a sensor dedicated to the measurement of the petal mode seems necessary. Through this paper, we demonstrate that an uPyWFS can confuse the petal mode with the residuals from the first path. However, adding a spatial filter on top of said uPyWFS makes it a good petalometer candidate.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
GPI 2.0: Performance Evaluation of the Wavefront Sensor's EMCCD
Authors:
Clarissa R. Do Ó,
Saavidra Perera,
Jérôme Maire,
Jayke S. Nguyen,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Quinn M. Konopacky,
Jeffrey Chilcote,
Joeleff Fitzsimmons,
Randall Hamper,
Dan Kerley,
Bruce Macintosh,
Christian Marois,
Fredrik Rantakyrö,
Dmitry Savranksy,
Jean-Pierre Veran,
Guido Agapito,
S. Mark Ammons,
Marco Bonaglia,
Marc-Andre Boucher,
Jennifer Dunn,
Simone Esposito,
Guillaume Filion,
Jean Thomas Landry,
Olivier Lardiere,
Duan Li
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Gemini Planet Imager (GPI) is a high contrast imaging instrument that aims to detect and characterize extrasolar planets. GPI is being upgraded to GPI 2.0, with several subsystems receiving a re-design to improve the instrument's contrast. To enable observations on fainter targets and increase stability on brighter ones, one of the upgrades is to the adaptive optics system. The current Shack-H…
▽ More
The Gemini Planet Imager (GPI) is a high contrast imaging instrument that aims to detect and characterize extrasolar planets. GPI is being upgraded to GPI 2.0, with several subsystems receiving a re-design to improve the instrument's contrast. To enable observations on fainter targets and increase stability on brighter ones, one of the upgrades is to the adaptive optics system. The current Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor (WFS) is being replaced by a pyramid WFS with an low-noise electron multiplying CCD (EMCCD). EMCCDs are detectors capable of counting single photon events at high speed and high sensitivity. In this work, we characterize the performance of the HNü 240 EMCCD from Nüvü Cameras, which was custom-built for GPI 2.0. The HNü 240 EMCCD's characteristics make it well suited for extreme AO: it has low dark current ($<$ 0.01 e-/pix/fr), low readout noise (0.1 e-/pix/fr at a gain of 5000), high quantum efficiency ( 90% at wavelengths from 600-800 nm; 70% from 800-900 nm), and fast readout (up to 3000 fps full frame). Here we present test results on the EMCCD's noise contributors, such as the readout noise, pixel-to-pixel variability and CCD bias. We also tested the linearity and EM gain calibration of the detector. All camera tests were conducted before its integration into the GPI 2.0 PWFS system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Using the Gerchberg-Saxton algorithm to reconstruct non-modulated pyramid wavefront sensor measurements
Authors:
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Aditya Sengupta,
Maïssa Salama,
Maaike A. M van Kooten,
Benjamin L. Gerard,
Sebastiaan Y. Haffert,
Sylvain Cetre,
Daren Dillon,
Renate Kupke,
Rebecca Jensen-Clem,
Phil Hinz,
Bruce Macintosh
Abstract:
Adaptive optics (AO) is a technique to improve the resolution of ground-based telescopes by correcting, in real-time, optical aberrations due to atmospheric turbulence and the telescope itself. With the rise of Giant Segmented Mirror Telescopes (GSMT), AO is needed more than ever to reach the full potential of these future observatories. One of the main performance drivers of an AO system is the w…
▽ More
Adaptive optics (AO) is a technique to improve the resolution of ground-based telescopes by correcting, in real-time, optical aberrations due to atmospheric turbulence and the telescope itself. With the rise of Giant Segmented Mirror Telescopes (GSMT), AO is needed more than ever to reach the full potential of these future observatories. One of the main performance drivers of an AO system is the wavefront sensing operation, consisting of measuring the shape of the above mentioned optical aberrations. Aims. The non-modulated pyramid wavefront sensor (nPWFS) is a wavefront sensor with high sensitivity, allowing the limits of AO systems to be pushed. The high sensitivity comes at the expense of its dynamic range, which makes it a highly non-linear sensor. We propose here a novel way to invert nPWFS signals by using the principle of reciprocity of light propagation and the Gerchberg-Saxton (GS) algorithm. We test the performance of this reconstructor in two steps: the technique is first implemented in simulations, where some of its basic properties are studied. Then, the GS reconstructor is tested on the Santa Cruz Extreme Adaptive optics Laboratory (SEAL) testbed located at the University of California Santa Cruz. This new way to invert the nPWFS measurements allows us to drastically increase the dynamic range of the reconstruction for the nPWFS, pushing the dynamics close to a modulated PWFS. The reconstructor is an iterative algorithm requiring heavy computational burden, which could be an issue for real-time purposes in its current implementation. However, this new reconstructor could still be helpful in the case of many wavefront control operations. This reconstruction technique has also been successfully tested on the Santa Cruz Extreme AO Laboratory (SEAL) bench where it is now used as the standard way to invert nPWFS signal.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Deformable mirror-based pupil chop** for exoplanet imaging and adaptive optics
Authors:
Javier Perez Soto,
Cesar Laguna,
Benjamin L. Gerard,
Anne Dattilo,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Rebecca Jensen-Clem
Abstract:
Due to turbulence in the atmosphere images taken from ground-based telescopes become distorted. With adaptive optics (AO) images can be given greater clarity allowing for better observations with existing telescopes and are essential for ground-based coronagraphic exoplanet imaging instruments. A disadvantage to many AO systems is that they use sensors that can not correct for non-common path aber…
▽ More
Due to turbulence in the atmosphere images taken from ground-based telescopes become distorted. With adaptive optics (AO) images can be given greater clarity allowing for better observations with existing telescopes and are essential for ground-based coronagraphic exoplanet imaging instruments. A disadvantage to many AO systems is that they use sensors that can not correct for non-common path aberrations. We have developed a new focal plane wavefront sensing technique to address this problem called deformable mirror (DM)-based pupil chop**. The process involves a coronagraphic or non-coronagraphic science image and a deformable mirror, which modulates the phase by applying a local tip/tilt every other frame which enables correcting for leftover aberrations in the wavefront after a conventional AO correction. We validate this technique with both simulations (for coronagraphic and non-coronagraphic images) and testing (for non-coronagraphic images) on UCSC's Santa Cruz Extreme AO Laboratory (SEAL) testbed. We demonstrate that with as low as 250 nm of DM stroke to apply the local tip/tilt this wavefront sensor is linear for low-order Zernike modes and enables real-time control, in principle up to kHz speeds to correct for residual atmospheric turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Modeling noise propagation in Fourier-filtering wavefront sensing, fundamental limits and quantitative comparison
Authors:
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Cédric Plantet,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Nicolas Levraud,
Mahawa Cissé,
Benoît Neichel,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
Adaptive optics (AO) is a technique allowing to drastically improve ground-based telescopes angular resolution. The wavefront sensor (WFS) is one of the key components of such systems, driving the fundamental performance limitations. In this paper, we focus on a specific class of WFS: the Fourier-filtering wavefront sensors (FFWFS). This class is known for its extremely high sensitivity. However,…
▽ More
Adaptive optics (AO) is a technique allowing to drastically improve ground-based telescopes angular resolution. The wavefront sensor (WFS) is one of the key components of such systems, driving the fundamental performance limitations. In this paper, we focus on a specific class of WFS: the Fourier-filtering wavefront sensors (FFWFS). This class is known for its extremely high sensitivity. However, a clear and comprehensive noise propagation model for any kind of FFWFS is lacking. Considering read-out noise and photon noise, we derive a simple and comprehensive model allowing to understand how these noises propagates in the phase reconstruction in the linear framework. This new noise propagation model works for any kind of FFWFS, and allows to revisit the fundamental sensitivity limit of these sensors. Furthermore, a new comparison between widely used FFWFS is held. We focus on the two main used FFWFS classes: the Zernike WFS (ZWFS) and the pyramid WFS (PWFS), bringing new understanding of their behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2023; v1 submitted 27 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Optimizing Fourier-Filtering WFS to reach sensitivity close to the fundamental limit
Authors:
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Cédric Plantet,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Nicolas Levraud,
Mahawa Cissé,
Benoît Neichel,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
To reach the full potential of the new generation of ground based telescopes, an extremely fine adjustment of the phase is required. Wavefront control and correction before detection has therefore become one of the cornerstones of instruments to achieve targeted performance, especially for high-contrast imaging. A crucial feature of accurate wavefront control leans on the wavefront sensor (WFS). W…
▽ More
To reach the full potential of the new generation of ground based telescopes, an extremely fine adjustment of the phase is required. Wavefront control and correction before detection has therefore become one of the cornerstones of instruments to achieve targeted performance, especially for high-contrast imaging. A crucial feature of accurate wavefront control leans on the wavefront sensor (WFS). We present a strategy to design new Fourier-Filtering WFS that encode the phase close from the fundamental photon efficiency limit. This strategy seems promising as it generates highly sensitive sensors suited for different pupil shape configurations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Three-sided pyramid wavefront sensor. II. Preliminary demonstration on the new CACTI testbed
Authors:
Lauren Schatz,
Johanan Codona,
Joseph D. Long,
Jared R. Males,
Weslin Pullen,
Jennifer Lumbres,
Kyle Van Gorkom,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Laird M. Close,
Carlos Correia,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Thierry Fusco,
Olivier Guyon,
Michael Hart,
Pierre Janin-Potiron,
Robert Johnson,
Nemanja Jovanovic,
Mala Mateen,
Jean-Francois Sauvage,
Benoit Neichel
Abstract:
The next generation of giant ground and space telescopes will have the light-collecting power to detect and characterize potentially habitable terrestrial exoplanets using high-contrast imaging for the first time. This will only be achievable if the performance of Giant Segmented Mirror Telescopes (GSMTs) extreme adaptive optics (ExAO) systems are optimized to their full potential. A key component…
▽ More
The next generation of giant ground and space telescopes will have the light-collecting power to detect and characterize potentially habitable terrestrial exoplanets using high-contrast imaging for the first time. This will only be achievable if the performance of Giant Segmented Mirror Telescopes (GSMTs) extreme adaptive optics (ExAO) systems are optimized to their full potential. A key component of an ExAO system is the wavefront sensor (WFS), which measures aberrations from atmospheric turbulence. A common choice in current and next-generation instruments is the pyramid wavefront sensor (PWFS). ExAO systems require high spatial and temporal sampling of wavefronts to optimize performance, and as a result, require large detectors for the WFS. We present a closed-loop testbed demonstration of a three-sided pyramid wavefront sensor (3PWFS) as an alternative to the conventional four-sided pyramid wavefront (4PWFS) sensor for GSMT-ExAO applications on the new Comprehensive Adaptive Optics and Coronagraph Test Instrument (CACTI). The 3PWFS is less sensitive to read noise than the 4PWFS because it uses fewer detector pixels. The 3PWFS has further benefits: a high-quality three-sided pyramid optic is easier to manufacture than a four-sided pyramid. We detail the design of the two components of the CACTI system, the adaptive optics simulator and the PWFS testbed that includes both a 3PWFS and 4PWFS. A preliminary experiment was performed on CACTI to study the performance of the 3PWFS to the 4PWFS in varying strengths of turbulence using both the Raw Intensity and Slopes Map signal processing methods. This experiment was repeated for a modulation radius of 1.6 lambda/D and 3.25 lambda/D. We found that the performance of the two wavefront sensors is comparable if modal loop gains are tuned.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Adapting the pyramid wavefront sensor for pupil fragmentation of the ELT class telescopes
Authors:
Nicolas Levraud,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Mahawa Cissé,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Benoît Neichel,
Charlotte Bond,
Enrico Pinna,
Simone Esposito,
Noah Schwartz,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
The next generation of Extremely Large Telescope (24 to 39m diameter) will suffer from the so-called "pupil fragmentation" problem. Due to their pupil shape complexity (segmentation, large spiders ...), some differential pistons may appear between some isolated part of the full pupil during the observations. Although classical AO system will be able to correct for turbulence effects, they will be…
▽ More
The next generation of Extremely Large Telescope (24 to 39m diameter) will suffer from the so-called "pupil fragmentation" problem. Due to their pupil shape complexity (segmentation, large spiders ...), some differential pistons may appear between some isolated part of the full pupil during the observations. Although classical AO system will be able to correct for turbulence effects, they will be blind to this specific telescope induced perturbations. Hence, such differential piston, a.k.a petal modes, will prevent to reach the diffraction limit of the telescope and ultimately will represent the main limitation of AO-assisted observation with an ELT. In this work we analyse the spatial structure of these petal modes and how it affects the ability of a Pyramid Wavefront sensor to sense them. Then we propose a variation around the classical Pyramid concept for increasing the WFS sensitivity to this particular modes. Nevertheless, We show that one single WFS can not accurately and simultaneously measure turbulence and petal modes. We propose a double path wavefront sensor scheme to solve this problem. We show that such a scheme,associated to a spatial filtering of residual turbulence in the second WFS path dedicated to petal mode sensing, allows to fully measure and correct for both turbulence and fragmentation effects and will eventually restore the full capability and spatial resolution of the future ELT.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
A pyramid-based adaptive optics for the high-resolution echelle spectrograph at SAO RAS 6-m telescope
Authors:
Eduard Muslimov,
Gennadiy Valyavin,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Felipe Pedreros Bustos,
Idir Boudjema
Abstract:
We propose a design of an adaptive optics (AO) system for the high-resolution fiber-fed echelle spectrograph installed at the Nasmyth focus of the 6-m BTA telescope at the Special Astrophysical Observatory (SAO) of the Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS). The system will be based on a pyramid wavefront sensor and benefit from the experience of the Laboratoire d'Astrophysique de Marseille team in the…
▽ More
We propose a design of an adaptive optics (AO) system for the high-resolution fiber-fed echelle spectrograph installed at the Nasmyth focus of the 6-m BTA telescope at the Special Astrophysical Observatory (SAO) of the Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS). The system will be based on a pyramid wavefront sensor and benefit from the experience of the Laboratoire d'Astrophysique de Marseille team in the field of adaptive optics. The AO will operate in the visible domain of 430-680 nm, in an f\30 input beam and provide correction for the on-axis source only. The main challenges in this particular design are insetting inserting the AO into an existing optical system and maintaining the focal and pupil planes configuration, fitting within the instrument's flux budget as well as limitations on the total cost of the AO bench. According to the current design, the AO bench will use an additional relay consisting of 2 spherical mirrors to re-collimate the beam and project the pupil onto a small deformable mirror. A dichroic splitter will be used to longwave component to the pyramid wavefront sensor branch based on refractive optics only. Using off-the-shelf components only we can reach the instrumental wavefront error of 0.016 waves PTV with a 20 nm bandpass filter at 700 nm. Using folding mirrors and refocusing of the fiber's microlens we restore the nominal geometry of the beam feeding the spectrograph. The final goal for the AO system is to increase the energy concentration in spot at the spectrograph's entrance, and our preliminary modelling shows that we can gain by factor of 69.5 with the typical atmospheric conditions at SAO RAS.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Various Wavefront Sensing and Control Developments on the Santa Cruz Extreme AO Laboratory (SEAL) Testbed
Authors:
Benjamin L. Gerard,
Javier Perez-Soto,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Maaike A. M. van Kooten,
Daren Dillon,
Sylvain Cetre,
Rebecca Jensen-Clem,
Qiang Fu,
Hadi Amata,
Wolfgang Heidrich
Abstract:
Ground-based high contrast imaging (HCI) and extreme adaptive optics (AO) technologies have advanced to the point of enabling direct detections of gas-giant exoplanets orbiting beyond the snow lines around nearby young star systems. However, leftover wavefront errors using current HCI and AO technologies, realized as "speckles" in the coronagraphic science image, still limit HCI instrument sensiti…
▽ More
Ground-based high contrast imaging (HCI) and extreme adaptive optics (AO) technologies have advanced to the point of enabling direct detections of gas-giant exoplanets orbiting beyond the snow lines around nearby young star systems. However, leftover wavefront errors using current HCI and AO technologies, realized as "speckles" in the coronagraphic science image, still limit HCI instrument sensitivities to detecting and characterizing lower-mass, closer-in, and/or older/colder exoplanetary systems. Improving the performance of AO wavefront sensors (WFSs) and control techniques is critical to improving such HCI instrument sensitivity. Here we present three different ongoing wavefront sensing and control project developments on the Santa cruz Extreme AO Laboratory (SEAL) testbed: (1) "multi-WFS single congugate AO (SCAO)" using the Fast Atmospheric Self-coherent camera (SCC) Technique (FAST) and a Shack Hartmann WFS, (2) pupil chop** for focal plane wavefront sensing, first with an external amplitude modulator and then with the DM as a phase-only modulator, and (3) a laboratory demonstration of enhanced linearity with the non-modulated bright Pyramid WFS (PWFS) compared to the regular PWFS. All three topics share a common theme of multi-WFS SCAO and/or second stage AO, presenting opportunities and applications to further investigate these techniques in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
The Three-Sided PyramidWavefront Sensor. I. Simulations and Analysis for Astronomical Adaptive Optics
Authors:
Lauren Schatz,
Jared R. Males,
Carlos Correia,
Benoit Neichel,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Johanan Codona,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Thierry Fusco,
Michael Hart,
Pierre Janin-Potiron,
Robert Johnson,
Joseph Long,
Mala Mateen
Abstract:
For ExAO instruments for the Giant Segmented Mirror Telescopes (GSMTs), alternative architectures of WFS are under consideration because there is a tradeoff between detector size, speed, and noise that reduces the performance of GSMT-ExAO wavefront control. One option under consideration for a GSMT-ExAO wavefront sensor is a three-sided PWFS (3PWFS). The 3PWFS creates three copies of the telescope…
▽ More
For ExAO instruments for the Giant Segmented Mirror Telescopes (GSMTs), alternative architectures of WFS are under consideration because there is a tradeoff between detector size, speed, and noise that reduces the performance of GSMT-ExAO wavefront control. One option under consideration for a GSMT-ExAO wavefront sensor is a three-sided PWFS (3PWFS). The 3PWFS creates three copies of the telescope pupil for wavefront sensing, compared to the conventional four-sided PWFS (4PWFS) which uses four pupils. The 3PWFS uses fewer detector pixels than the 4PWFS and should therefore be less sensitive to read noise. Here we develop a mathematical formalism based on the diffraction theory description of the Foucault knife edge test that predicts the intensity pattern after the PWFS. Our formalism allows us to calculate the intensity in the pupil images formed by the PWFS in the presence of phase errors corresponding to arbitrary Fourier modes. We then use the Object Oriented MATLAB Adaptive Optics toolbox (OOMAO) to simulate an end-to-end model of an adaptive optics system using a PWFS with modulation and compare the performance of the 3PWFS to the 4PWFS. In the case of a low read noise detector, the Strehl ratios of the 3PWFS and 4PWFS are within 0.01. When we included higher read noise in the simulation, we found a Strehl ratio gain of 0.036 for the 3PWFS using Raw Intensity over the 4PWFS using Slopes Maps at a stellar magnitude of 10. At the same magnitude, the 4PWFS RI also outperformed the 4PWFS SM, but the gain was only 0.012 Strehl. This is significant because 4PWFS using Slopes Maps is how the PWFS is conventionally used for AO wavefront sensing. We have found that the 3PWFS is a viable wavefront sensor that can fully reconstruct a wavefront and produce a stable closed-loop with correction comparable to that of a 4PWFS, with modestly better performance for high read-noise detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
The Bright Pyramid Wavefront Sensor
Authors:
Benjamin L. Gerard,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Rebecca Jensen-Clem,
Jean-François Sauvage
Abstract:
Extreme adaptive optics (AO) is crucial for enabling the contrasts needed for ground-based high contrast imaging instruments to detect exoplanets. Pushing exoplanet imaging detection sensitivities towards lower mass, closer separations, and older planets will require upgrading AO wavefront sensors (WFSs) to be more efficient. In particular, future WFS designs will aim to improve a WFS's measuremen…
▽ More
Extreme adaptive optics (AO) is crucial for enabling the contrasts needed for ground-based high contrast imaging instruments to detect exoplanets. Pushing exoplanet imaging detection sensitivities towards lower mass, closer separations, and older planets will require upgrading AO wavefront sensors (WFSs) to be more efficient. In particular, future WFS designs will aim to improve a WFS's measurement error (i.e., the wavefront level at which photon noise, detector noise, and/or sky background limits a WFS measurement) and linearity (i.e., the wavefront level, in the absence of photon noise, aliasing, and servo lag, at which an AO loop can close and the corresponding closed-loop residual level). We present one such design here called the bright pyramid WFS (bPWFS), which improves both the linearity and measurement errors as compared to the non-modulated pyramid WFS (PWFS). The bPWFS is a unique design that, unlike other WFSs, doesn't sacrifice measurement error for linearity, potentially enabling this WFS to (a) close the AO loop on open loop turbulence utilising a tip/tilt modulation mirror (i.e., a modulated bPWFS; analogous to the procedure used for the regular modulated PWFS), and (b) reach deeper closed-loop residual wavefront levels (i.e., improving both linearity and measurement error) compared to the regular non-modulated PWFS. The latter approach could be particularly beneficial to enable improved AO performance using the bWFS as a second stage AO WFS. In this paper we will present an AO error budget analysis of the non-modulated bPWFS as well as supporting AO testbed results from the Marseille Astrophysics Laboratory.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Variation on a Zernike wavefront sensor theme: optimal use of photons
Authors:
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Kjetil Dohlen,
Nicolas Levraud,
Arthur Vigan,
Mamadou N'Diaye,
Benoît Neichel,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
The Zernike wavefront sensor (ZWFS) is a concept belonging to the wide class Fourier-filtering wavefront sensor (FFWFS). The ZWFS is known for its extremely high sensitivity while having a low dynamic range, which makes it a unique sensor for second stage adaptive optics (AO) systems or quasi-static aberrations calibration sensor. This sensor is composed of a focal plane mask made of a phase shift…
▽ More
The Zernike wavefront sensor (ZWFS) is a concept belonging to the wide class Fourier-filtering wavefront sensor (FFWFS). The ZWFS is known for its extremely high sensitivity while having a low dynamic range, which makes it a unique sensor for second stage adaptive optics (AO) systems or quasi-static aberrations calibration sensor. This sensor is composed of a focal plane mask made of a phase shifting dot fully described by two parameters: its diameter and depth. In this letter, we aim to improve the performance of this sensor by changing the diameter of its phase shifting dot. We begin with a general theoretical framework providing an analytical description of the FFWFS properties, then we predict the expected ZWFS sensitivity for different configurations of dot diameters and depths. The analytical predictions are then validated with end-to-end simulations. From this, we propose a variation of the classical ZWFS shape which exhibits extremely appealing properties. We show that the ZWFS sensitivity can be optimized by modifying the dot diameter and even reach the optimal theoretical limit, with a trade-off for low spatial frequencies sensitivity. As an example, we show that a ZWFS with a 2λ/D dot diameter (where λ is the sensing wavelength and D the telescope diameter), hereafter called Z2WFS, exhibits a sensitivity twice higher than the classical 1.06λ/D ZWFS for all the phase spatial components except for tip-tilt modes. Furthermore, this gain in sensitivity does not impact the dynamic range of the sensor, and the Z2WFS exhibits a similar dynamical range as the classical 1.06λ/D ZWFS. This study opens the path to the conception of diameter-optimized ZWFS.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
The focal-plane assisted pyramid wavefront sensor: enabling frame-by-frame optical gains tracking
Authors:
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Benoît Neichel,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
With its high sensitivity, the Pyramid wavefront sensor (PyWFS) is becoming an advantageous sensor for astronomical adaptive optics (AO) systems. However, this sensor exhibits significant non-linear behaviours leading to challenging AO control issues. In order to mitigate these effects, we propose to use, in addition to the classical pyramid sensor, a focal plane image combined with a convolutive…
▽ More
With its high sensitivity, the Pyramid wavefront sensor (PyWFS) is becoming an advantageous sensor for astronomical adaptive optics (AO) systems. However, this sensor exhibits significant non-linear behaviours leading to challenging AO control issues. In order to mitigate these effects, we propose to use, in addition to the classical pyramid sensor, a focal plane image combined with a convolutive description of the sensor to perform a fast tracking of the PyWFS non-linearities, the so-called optical gains (OG). We show that this additional focal plane imaging path only requires a small fraction of the total flux, while representing a robust solution to estimate the PyWFS OG. Finally, we demonstrate the gain brought by our method with the specific examples of bootstrap and Non-Common Path Aberrations (NCPA) handling.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Pyramid wavefront sensor optical gains compensation using a convolutional model
Authors:
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Pierre Janin-Potiron,
Carlos Correia,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Noah Schwartz,
Benoît Neichel,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
Extremely Large Telescopes have overwhelmingly opted for the Pyramid wavefront sensor (PyWFS) over the more widely used Shack-Hartmann WaveFront Sensor (SHWFS) to perform their Single Conjugate Adaptive Optics (SCAO) mode. The PyWFS, a sensor based on Fourier filtering, has proven to be highly successful in many astronomy applications. However, it exhibits non-linearity behaviors that lead to a re…
▽ More
Extremely Large Telescopes have overwhelmingly opted for the Pyramid wavefront sensor (PyWFS) over the more widely used Shack-Hartmann WaveFront Sensor (SHWFS) to perform their Single Conjugate Adaptive Optics (SCAO) mode. The PyWFS, a sensor based on Fourier filtering, has proven to be highly successful in many astronomy applications. However, it exhibits non-linearity behaviors that lead to a reduction of its sensitivity when working with non-zero residual wavefronts. This so-called Optical Gains (OG) effect, degrades the close loop performance of SCAO systems and prevents accurate correction of Non-Common Path Aberrations (NCPA). In this paper, we aim at computing the OG using a fast and agile strategy in order to control the PyWFS measurements in adaptive optics closed loop systems. Using a novel theoretical description of the PyFWS, which is based on a convolutional model, we are able to analytically predict the behavior of the PyWFS in closed-loop operation. This model enables us to explore the impact of residual wavefront error on particular aspects such as sensitivity and associated OG. The proposed method relies on the knowledge of the residual wavefront statistics and enables automatic estimation of the current OG. End-to-End numerical simulations are used to validate our predictions and test the relevance of our approach. We demonstrate, using on non-invasive strategy, that our method provides an accurate estimation of the OG. The model itself only requires AO telemetry data to derive statistical information on atmospheric turbulence. Furthermore, we show that by only using an estimation of the current Fried parameter r_0 and the basic system-level characteristics, OGs can be estimated with an accuracy of less than 10%. Finally, we highlight the importance of OG estimation in the case of NCPA compensation. The proposed method is applied to the PyWFS.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2020; v1 submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Design of the HARMONI Pyramid WFS module
Authors:
Noah Schwartz,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Edgard Renault,
Carlos Correia,
Benoit Neichel,
Thierry Fusco,
Kjetil Dohlen,
Kacem El Hadi,
Cyril Petit,
Elodie Choquet,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Jerome Paufique,
Fraser Clarke,
Niranjan Thatte,
Ian Bryson
Abstract:
Current designs for all three extremely large telescopes show the overwhelming adoption of the pyramid wavefront sensor (P-WFS) as the WFS of choice for adaptive optics (AO) systems sensing on natural guide stars (NGS) or extended objects. The key advantages of the P-WFS over the Shack-Hartmann are known and are mainly provided by the improved sensitivity (fainter NGS) and reduced sensitivity to s…
▽ More
Current designs for all three extremely large telescopes show the overwhelming adoption of the pyramid wavefront sensor (P-WFS) as the WFS of choice for adaptive optics (AO) systems sensing on natural guide stars (NGS) or extended objects. The key advantages of the P-WFS over the Shack-Hartmann are known and are mainly provided by the improved sensitivity (fainter NGS) and reduced sensitivity to spatial aliasing. However, robustness and tolerances of the P-WFS for the ELTs are not currently well understood. In this paper, we present simulation results for the single-conjugate AO mode of HARMONI, a visible and near-infrared integral field spectrograph for the European Extremely Large Telescope. We first explore the wavefront sensing issues related to the telescope itself; namely the island effect (i.e. differential piston) and M1 segments phasing errors. We present mitigation strategies to the island effect and their performance. We then focus on some performance optimisation aspects of the AO design to explore the impact of the RTC latency and the optical gain issues, which will in particular affect the high-contrast mode of HARMONI. Finally, we investigate the influence of the quality of glass pyramid prism itself, and of optical aberrations on the final AO performance. By relaxing the tolerances on the fabrication of the prism, we are able to reduce hardware costs and simplify integration. We show the importance of calibration (i.e. updating the control matrix) to capture any displacement of the telescope pupil and rotation of the support structure for M4. We also show the importance of the number of pixels used for wavefront sensing to relax tolerances of the pyramid prism. Finally, we present a detailed optical design of the pyramid prism, central element of the P-WFS.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Performance limits of adaptive-optics/high-contrast imagers with pyramid wave-front sensors
Authors:
Carlos M. Correia,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Charlotte Z. Bond,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Jean-Francois Sauvage,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
Advanced AO systems will likely utilise Pyramid wave-front sensors (PWFS) over the traditional Shack-Hartmann sensor in the quest for increased sensitivity, peak performance and ultimate contrast. Here, we wish to bring knowledge and quantify the PWFS theoretical limits as a means to highlight its properties and use cases.
We explore forward models for the PWFS in the spatial-frequency domain fo…
▽ More
Advanced AO systems will likely utilise Pyramid wave-front sensors (PWFS) over the traditional Shack-Hartmann sensor in the quest for increased sensitivity, peak performance and ultimate contrast. Here, we wish to bring knowledge and quantify the PWFS theoretical limits as a means to highlight its properties and use cases.
We explore forward models for the PWFS in the spatial-frequency domain for they prove quite useful since a) they emanate directly from physical-optics (Fourier) diffraction theory; b) provide a straightforward path to meaningful error breakdowns, c) allow for reconstruction algorithms with $O (n\,log(n))$ complexity for large-scale systems and d) tie in seamlessly with decoupled (distributed) optimal predictive dynamic control for performance and contrast optimisation. All these aspects are dealt with here. We focus on recent analytical PWFS developments and demonstrate the performance using both analytic and end-to-end simulations.
We anchor our estimates with observed on-sky contrast on existing systems and then show very good agreement between analytical and Monte-Carlo estimates for the PWFS. For a potential upgrade of existing high-contrast imagers on 10\,m-class telescopes with visible or near-infrared PWFS, we show under median conditions at Paranal a contrast improvement (limited by chromatic and scintillation effects) of 2x-5x by replacing the wave-front sensor alone at large separations close to the AO control radius where aliasing dominates, and factors in excess of 10x by coupling distributed control with the PWFS over most of the AO control region, from small separations starting with the Inner Working Angle of typically 1-2 $λ/D$ to the AO correction edge (here 20 $λ/D$).
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Adaptive optics with programmable Fourier-based wavefront sensors: a spatial light modulator approach to the LOOPS testbed
Authors:
Pierre Janin-Potiron,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Lauren Schatz,
Olivier Fauvarque,
Charlotte Z. Bond,
Yannick Abautret,
Eduard Muslimov,
Kacem El-Hadi,
Jean-François Sauvage,
Kjetil Dohlen,
Benoît Neichel,
Carlos M. Correia,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
Wavefront sensors encode phase information of an incoming wavefront into an intensity pattern that can be measured on a camera. Several kinds of wavefront sensors (WFS) are used in astronomical adaptive optics. Amongst them, Fourier-based wavefront sensors perform a filtering operation on the wavefront in the focal plane. The most well known example of a WFS of this kind is the Zernike wavefront s…
▽ More
Wavefront sensors encode phase information of an incoming wavefront into an intensity pattern that can be measured on a camera. Several kinds of wavefront sensors (WFS) are used in astronomical adaptive optics. Amongst them, Fourier-based wavefront sensors perform a filtering operation on the wavefront in the focal plane. The most well known example of a WFS of this kind is the Zernike wavefront sensor, and the pyramid wavefront sensor (PWFS) also belongs to this class. Based on this same principle, new WFSs can be proposed such as the n-faced pyramid (which ultimately becomes an axicone) or the flattened pyramid, depending on whether the image formation is incoherent or coherent. In order to test such novel concepts, the LOOPS adaptive optics testbed hosted at the Laboratoire d'Astrophysique de Marseille has been upgraded by adding a Spatial Light Modulator (SLM). This device, placed in a focal plane produces high-definition phase masks that mimic otherwise bulk optic devices. In this paper, we first present the optical design and upgrades made to the experimental setup of the LOOPS bench. Then, we focus on the generation of the phase masks with the SLM and the implications of having such a device in a focal plane. Finally, we present the first closed-loop results in either static or dynamic mode with different WFS applied on the SLM.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Kernel formalism applied to Fourier based wave front sensing in presence of residual phases
Authors:
Olivier Fauvarque,
Pierre Janin-Potiron,
Carlos Correia,
Yoann Brule,
Benoit Neichel,
Vincent Chambouleyron,
Jean-Francois Sauvage,
Thierry Fusco
Abstract:
In this paper, we describe Fourier-based Wave Front Sensors (WFS) as linear integral operators, characterized by their Kernel. In a first part, we derive the dependency of this quantity with respect to the WFS's optical parameters: pupil geometry, filtering mask, tip/tilt modulation. In a second part we focus the study on the special case of convolutional Kernels. The assumptions required to be in…
▽ More
In this paper, we describe Fourier-based Wave Front Sensors (WFS) as linear integral operators, characterized by their Kernel. In a first part, we derive the dependency of this quantity with respect to the WFS's optical parameters: pupil geometry, filtering mask, tip/tilt modulation. In a second part we focus the study on the special case of convolutional Kernels. The assumptions required to be in such a regime are described. We then show that these convolutional kernels allow to drastically simplify the WFS's model by summarizing its behavior in a concise and comprehensive quantity called the WFS's Impulse Response. We explain in particular how it allows to compute the sensor's sensitivity with respect to the spatial frequencies. Such an approach therefore provides a fast diagnostic tool to compare and optimize Fourier-based WFSs. In a third part, we develop the impact of the residual phases on the sensor's impulse response, and show that the convolutional model remains valid. Finally, a section dedicated to the Pyramid WFS concludes this work, and illustrates how the slopes maps are easily handled by the convolutional model.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2019; v1 submitted 14 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
