-
Controlling noisy herds
Authors:
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
Saad Bhamla
Abstract:
The wisdom of the crowd breaks down in small groups. While large flocks exhibit swarm intelligence to evade predators, small groups display erratic behavior, oscillating between unity and discord. We investigate these dynamics using small groups of sheep controlled by shepherd dogs in century-old sheepdog trials, proposing a two-parameter stochastic dynamic framework. Our model employs pressure (s…
▽ More
The wisdom of the crowd breaks down in small groups. While large flocks exhibit swarm intelligence to evade predators, small groups display erratic behavior, oscillating between unity and discord. We investigate these dynamics using small groups of sheep controlled by shepherd dogs in century-old sheepdog trials, proposing a two-parameter stochastic dynamic framework. Our model employs pressure (stimulus intensity) and lightness (response isotropy) to simulate herding and shedding behaviors. Light sheep rapidly achieve a stable herding state, while heavy sheep exhibit intermittent herding and orthogonal alignment to the dog. High response isotropy enhances group cohesion but complicates group splitting. We construct a unified phase diagram for sheep behavior, identifying three regimes (fleeing, flocking, and grazing) based on group size and stimulus specificity. Increasing stimulus specificity shifts small group behavior from grazing to fleeing, while larger groups exhibit flocking. This transition underscores the challenge of controlling small indecisive collectives. Introducing the Indecisive Collective Algorithm (ICA), we show that deliberate indecisiveness and stochasticity improve control efficiency. ICA outperforms traditional averaging-based algorithms in high-noise settings and excels in tasks requiring group splitting. Our study offers a foundational framework for controlling small, indecisive groups, applicable to biochemical reactions, cell populations, and opinion dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Ultrafast reversible self-assembly of living tangled matter
Authors:
Vishal P. Patil,
Harry Tuazon,
Emily Kaufman,
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
David Qin,
Jörn Dunkel,
M. Saad Bhamla
Abstract:
Tangled active filaments are ubiquitous in nature, from chromosomal DNA and cilia carpets to root networks and worm blobs. How activity and elasticity facilitate collective topological transformations in living tangled matter is not well understood. Here, we report an experimental and theoretical study of California blackworms (Lumbriculus variegatus), which slowly form tangles over minutes but ca…
▽ More
Tangled active filaments are ubiquitous in nature, from chromosomal DNA and cilia carpets to root networks and worm blobs. How activity and elasticity facilitate collective topological transformations in living tangled matter is not well understood. Here, we report an experimental and theoretical study of California blackworms (Lumbriculus variegatus), which slowly form tangles over minutes but can untangle in milliseconds. Combining ultrasound imaging, theoretical analysis and simulations, we develop and validate a mechanistic model that explains how the kinematics of individual active filaments determines their emergent collective topological dynamics. The model reveals that resonantly alternating helical waves enable both tangle formation and ultrafast untangling. By identifying generic dynamical principles of topological self-transformations, our results can provide guidance for designing new classes of topologically tunable active materials.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Fundamental limits of accuracy and precision in single molecule biosensors
Authors:
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
Manoj M Varma
Abstract:
Physical limit of molecular sensing has been extensively studied in biological systems. Biosensors are engineered equivalents of molecular sensors in living systems and play critical role in disease diagnosis and management. Investigation into the physical limits of biosensors could have major beneficial impact on early disease diagnosis. Here, we present an extension of the classical works on mol…
▽ More
Physical limit of molecular sensing has been extensively studied in biological systems. Biosensors are engineered equivalents of molecular sensors in living systems and play critical role in disease diagnosis and management. Investigation into the physical limits of biosensors could have major beneficial impact on early disease diagnosis. Here, we present an extension of the classical works on molecular sensing limits of living systems to the realm of biosensors. Two approaches are proposed to estimate concentration with noisy biosensors. We find a trade-off between precision and accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Equilibrium Probability Distribution for Number of Bound Receptor-Ligand Complexes
Authors:
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
Manoj M Varma
Abstract:
The phenomenon of molecular binding, where two molecules, referred to as a receptor and a ligand, bind together to form a ligand-receptor complex, is ubiquitous in biology and essential for the accurate functioning of all life-sustaining processes. The probability of a single receptor forming a complex with any one of L surrounding ligand molecules at thermal equilibrium can be derived from a part…
▽ More
The phenomenon of molecular binding, where two molecules, referred to as a receptor and a ligand, bind together to form a ligand-receptor complex, is ubiquitous in biology and essential for the accurate functioning of all life-sustaining processes. The probability of a single receptor forming a complex with any one of L surrounding ligand molecules at thermal equilibrium can be derived from a partition function obtained from the Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution. We extend this approach to a system consisting of R receptors and L ligands to derive the probability density function p(r;R,L) to find r bound receptor-ligand complexes at thermal equilibrium. This extension allows us to illustrate two aspects of this problem which are not apparent in the single receptor problem, namely, a) a symmetry to be expected in the equilibrium distribution of the number of bound complexes under exchange of R and L and b) the number of bound complexes obtained from chemical kinetic equations has an exact correspondence to the maximum probable value of r from the expression for p(r;R,L). We derive the number fluctuations of r and present a practically relevant molecular sensing application that benefits from the knowledge of p(r;R,L).
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020; v1 submitted 21 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Theoretical Limit Of Concentration Sensing of Single Receptor Artificial Biosensors
Authors:
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
Manoj M Varma
Abstract:
Artificially engineered biosensors are highly inefficient in accurately measuring the concentration of biomarkers, particularly, during early diagnosis of diseases. On the other hand, single cellular systems such as chemotactic bacteria can sense their environment with extraordinary precision. Therefore, one would expect that implementing the optimal cellular sensing strategies in state-of-the-art…
▽ More
Artificially engineered biosensors are highly inefficient in accurately measuring the concentration of biomarkers, particularly, during early diagnosis of diseases. On the other hand, single cellular systems such as chemotactic bacteria can sense their environment with extraordinary precision. Therefore, one would expect that implementing the optimal cellular sensing strategies in state-of-the-art artificial sensors can produce optimally precise biosensors. However because of the presence of measurement noise, strategies that are optimal in biological systems may not be optimal in artificial systems. Therefore, mimicking biological strategies may not be the optimal path in case of artificial sensing systems because of the presence of inherent measurement noise.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Fundamental Limitations in Biomarker Based Early Disease Diagnosis
Authors:
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
Chandra R. Murthy,
Manoj Varma
Abstract:
Clinical biosensors with low detection limit hold significant promise in the early diagnosis of debilitating diseases. Recent progress in sensor development has led to the demonstration of detection capable of detecting target molecules even down to single-molecule level. One crucial performance parameter which is not adequately discussed is the issue of measurement fidelity in such sensors. We de…
▽ More
Clinical biosensors with low detection limit hold significant promise in the early diagnosis of debilitating diseases. Recent progress in sensor development has led to the demonstration of detection capable of detecting target molecules even down to single-molecule level. One crucial performance parameter which is not adequately discussed is the issue of measurement fidelity in such sensors. We define measurement fidelity based on the false positive rate of the system as we expect systems with higher sensitivity to concomitantly respond more to interfering molecules thus increasing the false-positive rates. We present a model which allows us to estimate the limit of detection of a biosensor system constrained by a specified false-positive rate. Two major results emerging from our model is that a) there is a lower bound to the detection limit for a target molecule determined by the variation in the concentration of background molecules interfering with the molecular recognition process and b) systems which use a secondary label, such as a fluorophore, can achieve lower detection limits for a given false positive rate. We also present data collected from literature to support our model. The insights from our model will be useful in the systematic design of future clinical biosensors to achieve relevant detection limits with assured fidelity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2019; v1 submitted 11 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Error reduction in biosensors using secondary labeling
Authors:
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
Manoj M Varma
Abstract:
In this article, we derive the limit of detection for a two-step molecular recognition process and show that in-spite of all the recognition reactions being in equilibrium the overall error rates can be reduced exactly as much as possible in non-equilibrium methods such as kinetic proofreading.
In this article, we derive the limit of detection for a two-step molecular recognition process and show that in-spite of all the recognition reactions being in equilibrium the overall error rates can be reduced exactly as much as possible in non-equilibrium methods such as kinetic proofreading.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
A Null-model Exhibiting Synchronized Dynamics in Uncoupled Oscillators
Authors:
Tuhin Chakrabortty,
Akash Suman,
Anjali Gupta,
Varsha Singh,
Manoj Varma
Abstract:
The phenomenon of phase synchronization of oscillatory systems arising out of feedback coupling is ubiquitous across physics and biology. In noisy, complex systems, one generally observes transient epochs of synchronization followed by non-synchronous dynamics. How does one guarantee that the observed transient epochs of synchronization are arising from an underlying feedback mechanism and not fro…
▽ More
The phenomenon of phase synchronization of oscillatory systems arising out of feedback coupling is ubiquitous across physics and biology. In noisy, complex systems, one generally observes transient epochs of synchronization followed by non-synchronous dynamics. How does one guarantee that the observed transient epochs of synchronization are arising from an underlying feedback mechanism and not from some peculiar statistical properties of the system? This question is particularly important for complex biological systems where the search for a non-existent feedback mechanism may turn out be an enormous waste of resources. In this article, we propose a null model for synchronization motivated by expectations on the dynamical behaviour of biological systems to provide a quantitative measure of the confidence with which one can infer the existence of a feedback mechanism based on observation of transient synchronized behaviour. We demonstrate the application of our null model to the phenomenon of gait synchronization in free-swimming nematodes, C. elegans.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2018; v1 submitted 9 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
