Showing 1–26 of 26 results for author: Cats, O

COVID-19 risk-perception in long-distance travel

Authors: Nejc Geržinič, Maurizio van Dalen, Oded Cats

Abstract: Long-distance travel has seen little attention in the past, largely due its sporadic nature. A single long-distance trip can amount to a distance equivalent to a year's worth of commute trips, resulting in a similar, if not worse, environmental footprint. Understanding travellers' behaviour is thus just as relevant for such trips. As international travel is slowly picking up from the COVID-19 pand… ▽ More Long-distance travel has seen little attention in the past, largely due its sporadic nature. A single long-distance trip can amount to a distance equivalent to a year's worth of commute trips, resulting in a similar, if not worse, environmental footprint. Understanding travellers' behaviour is thus just as relevant for such trips. As international travel is slowly picking up from the COVID-19 pandemic, it has been marred by an abundance of national and regional pandemic-related safety measures. While their primary goal is to protect the local population from infection, these safety may also make travellers feel safer while travelling. This perceived safety can - and likely does - differ from the true efficacy of the measures. In this research, we investigate people's perception of eight COVID-19-related safety measures related to long-distance trips and how subjective perception of safety impacts their mode choice among car, train and aircraft. We employ a Hierarchical Information Integration (HII) approach to capture subjective perceptions and then model the obtained data by means of a Latent Class Choice Model, resulting in four distinct segments. To extrapolate the segments onto the rating experiment of HII, we apply a weighted least squares (WLS) regression, to obtain segment-specific safety perception. Two segments show a relatively high value-of-time (72EUR/h and 50EUR/h), tend to be more mode-agnostic and prefer determining the level of risk by themselves (relying primarily on infection and vaccination rate). The remaining two segments have a lower value-of-time (38EUR / h and 15EUR/h) and have strong mode affinity, for the train and car respectively. Future research could look into a way that segments the sample based on both the mode choice and rating experiment, providing additional insights into the heterogeneity of individuals in their perceptions. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

An instance-based learning approach for evaluating the perception of ride-hailing waiting time variability

Authors: Nejc Geržinič, Oded Cats, Niels van Oort, Sascha Hoogendoorn-Lanser, Michel Bierlaire, Serge Hoogendoorn

Abstract: Understanding user's perception of service variability is essential to discern their overall perception of any type of (transport) service. We study the perception of waiting time variability for ride-hailing services. We carried out a stated preference survey in August 2021, yielding 936 valid responses. The respondents were faced with static pre-trip information on the expected waiting time, fol… ▽ More Understanding user's perception of service variability is essential to discern their overall perception of any type of (transport) service. We study the perception of waiting time variability for ride-hailing services. We carried out a stated preference survey in August 2021, yielding 936 valid responses. The respondents were faced with static pre-trip information on the expected waiting time, followed by the actually experienced waiting time for their selected alternative. We analyse this data by means of an instance-based learning (IBL) approach to evaluate how individuals respond to service performance variation and how this impacts their future decisions. Different novel specifications of memory fading, captured by the IBL approach, are tested to uncover which describes the user behaviour best. Additionally, existing and new specification of inertia (habit) are tested. Our model outcomes reveal that the perception of unexpected waiting time is within the expected range of 2-3 times the value-of-time. Travellers seem to place a higher reward on an early departure compared to a penalty for a late departure of equal magnitude. A cancelled service, after having made a booking, results in significant disutility for the passenger and a strong motivation to shift to a different provider. Considering memory decay, our results show that the most recent experience is by far the most relevant for the next decision, with memories fading quickly in importance. The role of inertia seems to gain importance with each additional consecutive choice for the same option, but then resetting back to zero following a shift in behaviour. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

An adaptive route choice model for integrated fixed and flexible transit systems

Authors: David Leffler, Wilco Burghout, Oded Cats, Erik Jenelius

Abstract: Over the past decade, there has been a surge of interest in the transport community in the application of agent-based simulation models to evaluate flexible transit solutions characterized by different degrees of short-term flexibility in routing and scheduling. A central modeling decision in the development of an agent-based simulation model for the evaluation of flexible transit is how one choos… ▽ More Over the past decade, there has been a surge of interest in the transport community in the application of agent-based simulation models to evaluate flexible transit solutions characterized by different degrees of short-term flexibility in routing and scheduling. A central modeling decision in the development of an agent-based simulation model for the evaluation of flexible transit is how one chooses to represent the mode- and route-choices of travelers. The real-time adaptive behavior of travelers is intuitively important to model in the presence of a flexible transit service, where the routing and scheduling of vehicles is highly dependent on supply-demand dynamics at a closer to real-time temporal resolution. We propose a utility-based transit route-choice model with representation of within-day adaptive travel behavior and between-day learning where station-based fixed-transit, flexible-transit, and active-mode alternatives may be dynamically combined in a single path. To enable experimentation, this route-choice model is implemented within an agent-based dynamic public transit simulation framework. Model properties are first explored in a choice between fixed- and flexible-transit modes for a toy network. The framework is then applied to illustrate level-of-service trade-offs and analyze traveler mode choices within a mixed fixed- and flexible transit system in a case study based on a real-life branched transit service in Stockholm, Sweden. △ Less

Submitted 19 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 33 pages, 9 figures, preprint

Multi-purpose Pickup and Delivery Problem for Combined Passenger and Freight Transport

Authors: Jonas Hatzenbühler, Erik Jenelius, Győző Gidófalvi, Oded Cats

Abstract: Recent developments in modular transport vehicles allow deploying multi-purpose vehicles which can alternately transport different kinds of flows. In this study, we propose a novel variant of the pickup and delivery problem, the multi-purpose pickup and delivery problem, where multi-purpose vehicles are assigned to serve a multi-commodity flow. We solve a series of use case scenarios using an exac… ▽ More Recent developments in modular transport vehicles allow deploying multi-purpose vehicles which can alternately transport different kinds of flows. In this study, we propose a novel variant of the pickup and delivery problem, the multi-purpose pickup and delivery problem, where multi-purpose vehicles are assigned to serve a multi-commodity flow. We solve a series of use case scenarios using an exact optimization algorithm and an adaptive large neighborhood search algorithm. We compare the performance of a multi-purpose vehicle fleet to a mixed single-use vehicle fleet. Our findings suggest that total costs can be reduced by an average of 13% when multi-purpose vehicles are deployed, while at the same time reducing the total vehicle trip duration and total distance travelled by an average of 33% and 16%, respectively. The size of the fleet can be reduced by an average of 35%. The results can be used by practitioners and policymakers to decide on whether the combination of passenger and freight demand flows with multi-purpose vehicles in a given system will yield benefits compared to existing fleet configurations. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Analysis and Prediction of Ridership Impacts during Planned Public Transport Disruptions

Authors: Menno Yap, Oded Cats

Abstract: Urban metro and tram networks are regularly subject to planned disruptions, including closures, resulting from the need to maintain and renew infrastructure. In this study, we first empirically analyse the passenger demand response to planned public transport disruptions based on individual passenger travel behaviour, based on which we infer generalised journey time and cost elasticities for diffe… ▽ More Urban metro and tram networks are regularly subject to planned disruptions, including closures, resulting from the need to maintain and renew infrastructure. In this study, we first empirically analyse the passenger demand response to planned public transport disruptions based on individual passenger travel behaviour, based on which we infer generalised journey time and cost elasticities for different passenger groups and time periods of the day. Second, we develop a model which enables predicting public transport demand for individual origin-destination pairs affected by a closure. The model is trained based on the empirically observed travel behaviour. The proposed method is applied to a case study closure in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, based on which we empirically derive generalised journey time and generalised journey cost elasticities. Our results suggest that passengers demand response is lower for frequent users of the public transport network, as well as during weekdays, especially during the peak periods. Arguably, this stems from a higher share of captive passengers with a mandatory journey purpose in these segments, who will continue making their journey nevertheless. During weekends, with typically higher shares of leisure related journeys, a much more pronounced demand response is found. The estimated neural network regression model is able to predict passenger demand during public transport closures with a high level of accuracy. This provides public transport agencies more precise insights into the impact of closures on their revenue losses and on the potential need for resources reallocation. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Modular Vehicle Routing for Combined Passenger and Freight Transport

Authors: Jonas Hatzenbühler, Erik Jenelius, Győző Gidófalvi, Oded Cats

Abstract: The continuous increase in urban deliveries and the ongoing urbanization of large cities require the development of efficient and sustainable transportation solutions. This study investigates the impact of modular vehicle concepts and the consolidation of different demand types in the route planning on the efficiency of the urban freight and passenger transportation system. Modularity is achieved… ▽ More The continuous increase in urban deliveries and the ongoing urbanization of large cities require the development of efficient and sustainable transportation solutions. This study investigates the impact of modular vehicle concepts and the consolidation of different demand types in the route planning on the efficiency of the urban freight and passenger transportation system. Modularity is achieved by connecting multiple vehicles together to form a platoon. The consolidation of different demand types is realized by simultaneously consider passenger and freight demand in the optimization algorithm. The considered vehicles are specific for each demand type by can be connected freely, hence it is possible to transport different demand types in the same platoon. The cost terms in the problem formulation are comprised of travel time costs, travel distance costs, fleet size costs, and cost considering unserved requests. The modular vehicle operations are modeled in a novel pickup and delivery problem which is solved using CPLEX and Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search. In an extensive scenario study and case study in Stockholm, the potentials of the new modular vehicle type are explored for different spatial and temporal demand distributions. A parameter study on vehicle capacity, vehicle range and cost saving assumptions is performed to study their influence on the efficiency. The experiments carried out indicate a general cost savings of 48% due to modularity and an additional 9% due to consolidation. The reduction mainly stems from reduced operating costs and reduced trip duration, while the same number of requests can be served in all cases. Empty vehicle kilometers are reduced by more than 60% by consolidation and modularity. The proposed model and optimization framework can be used by companies and policy makers to identify required fleet sizes, optimal vehicle routes and cost savings. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Report number: 103688

Journal ref: Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice Volume 173, July 2023

Identifying Human Mobility Patterns using Smart Card Data

Authors: Oded Cats

Abstract: Human mobility is subject to collective dynamics that are the outcome of numerous individual choices. Smart card data which originated as a means of facilitating automated fare collections has emerged as an invaluable source for analyzing human mobility patterns. A variety of clustering and segmentation techniques has been adopted and adapted for applications ranging from passenger demand market s… ▽ More Human mobility is subject to collective dynamics that are the outcome of numerous individual choices. Smart card data which originated as a means of facilitating automated fare collections has emerged as an invaluable source for analyzing human mobility patterns. A variety of clustering and segmentation techniques has been adopted and adapted for applications ranging from passenger demand market segmentation to the analysis of urban activity locations. In this paper we provide a systematic review of the state-of-the-art on clustering public transport users based on their temporal or spatial-temporal characteristics as well as studies that use the patter to characterize individual stations, lines or urban areas. Furthermore, a critical review of the literature reveals an important distinction between studies focusing on the intra-personal variability of travel patterns versus those concerned with the inter-personal variability of travel patterns. We synthesize the key analysis approaches and based on which identify and outline the following directions for further research: (i) predictions of passenger travel patterns; (ii) decision support for service planning and policy evaluation; (iii) enhanced geographical characterization of users' travel patterns; (iv) from demand analytics towards behavioral analytics. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: Keywords: Public transport; Smart card data; Market segmentation; Clustering; Urban analytics

On the Relocation Behaviour of Ride-sourcing Drivers

Authors: Peyman Ashkrof, Gonçalo Homem de Almeida Correia, Oded Cats, Bart van Arem

Abstract: Ride-sourcing drivers as individual service suppliers can freely adopt their own relocation strategies including waiting, cruising freely, or following the platform recommendations. These decisions substantially impact the balance between supply and demand, and consequently affect system performance. We conducted a stated choice experiment to study the searching behaviour of ride-sourcing drivers… ▽ More Ride-sourcing drivers as individual service suppliers can freely adopt their own relocation strategies including waiting, cruising freely, or following the platform recommendations. These decisions substantially impact the balance between supply and demand, and consequently affect system performance. We conducted a stated choice experiment to study the searching behaviour of ride-sourcing drivers and examine novel policies. A unique dataset of 576 ride-sourcing drivers working in the US was collected and a choice modelling approach was used to estimate the effects of multiple existing and hypothetical attributes. The results suggest that relocation strategies of ride-sourcing drivers considerably vary between different groups of drivers. Surge pricing significantly stimulates drivers to head towards the designated areas. However, the distance between the location of drivers and surge or high-demand areas demotivates them to follow the platform repositioning recommendations. We discuss the implications of our findings for various platform policies on real-time information sharing and platform repositioning guidance. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Hyper-pool: pooling private trips into high-occupancy transit-like attractive shared rides

Authors: Rafal Kucharski, Oded Cats

Abstract: We propose Hyper-pool, an analytical, offline, utility-driven ride-pooling algorithm to aggregate individual trip requests into attractive shared rides of high-occupancy. We depart from our ride-pooling ExMAS algorithm where single rides are pooled into attractive door-to-door rides and propose two novel demand-side algorithms for further aggregating individual demand towards more compact pooling.… ▽ More We propose Hyper-pool, an analytical, offline, utility-driven ride-pooling algorithm to aggregate individual trip requests into attractive shared rides of high-occupancy. We depart from our ride-pooling ExMAS algorithm where single rides are pooled into attractive door-to-door rides and propose two novel demand-side algorithms for further aggregating individual demand towards more compact pooling. First, we generate stop-to-stop rides, with a single pick up and drop off points optimal for all the travellers. Second, we bundle such rides again, resulting with hyper-pooled rides compact enough to resemble public transport operations. We propose a bottom-up framework where the pooling degree of identified rides is gradually increased, thereby ensuring attractiveness at subsequent aggregation levels. Our Hyper-pool method outputs the set of attractive pooled rides per service variant for a given travel demand. The algorithms are publicly available and reproducible. It is applicable for real-size demand datasets and opens new opportunities for exploiting the limits of ride-pooling potential. In our Amsterdam case-study we managed to pool over 220 travellers into 40 hyper-pooled rides of average occupancy 5.8 pax/veh. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

A General Framework to Forecast the Adoption of Novel Products: A Case of Autonomous Vehicles

Authors: Subodh Dubey, Ishant Sharma, Sabyasachee Mishra, Oded Cats, Prateek Bansal

Abstract: Due to the unavailability of prototypes, the early adopters of novel products actively seek information from multiple sources (e.g., media and social networks) to minimize the potential risk. The existing behavior models not only fail to capture the information propagation within the individual's social network, but also they do not incorporate the impact of such word-of-mouth (WOM) dissemination… ▽ More Due to the unavailability of prototypes, the early adopters of novel products actively seek information from multiple sources (e.g., media and social networks) to minimize the potential risk. The existing behavior models not only fail to capture the information propagation within the individual's social network, but also they do not incorporate the impact of such word-of-mouth (WOM) dissemination on the consumer's risk preferences. Moreover, even cutting-edge forecasting models rely on crude/synthetic consumer behavior models. We propose a general framework to forecast the adoption of novel products by develo** a new consumer behavior model and integrating it into a population-level agent-based model. Specifically, we extend the hybrid choice model to estimate consumer behavior, which incorporates social network effects and interplay between WOM and risk aversion. The calibrated consumer behavior model and synthetic population are passed through the agent-based model for forecasting the product market share. We apply the proposed framework to forecast the adoption of autonomous vehicles (AVs) in Nashville, USA. The consumer behavior model is calibrated with a stated preference survey data of 1,495 Nashville residents. The output of the agent-based model provides the effect of the purchase price, post-purchase satisfaction, and safety measures/regulations on the forecasted AV market share. With an annual AV price reduction of 5% at the initial purchase price of $40,000 and 90% of satisfied adopters, AVs are forecasted to attain around 85% market share in thirty years. These findings are crucial for policymakers to develop infrastructure plans and manufacturers to conduct an after-sales cost-benefit analysis. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Day-to-day and seasonal regularity of network passenger delay for metro networks

Authors: Panchamy Krishnakumari, Oded Cats, Hans van Lint

Abstract: In an effort to improve user satisfaction and transit image, transit service providers worldwide offer delay compensations. Smart card data enables the estimation of passenger delays throughout the network and aid in monitoring service performance. Notwithstanding, in order to prioritize measures for improving service reliability and hence reducing passenger delays, it is paramount to identify the… ▽ More In an effort to improve user satisfaction and transit image, transit service providers worldwide offer delay compensations. Smart card data enables the estimation of passenger delays throughout the network and aid in monitoring service performance. Notwithstanding, in order to prioritize measures for improving service reliability and hence reducing passenger delays, it is paramount to identify the system components - stations and track segments - where most passenger delay occurs. To this end, we propose a novel method for estimating network passenger delay from individual trajectories. We decompose the delay along a passenger trajectory into its corresponding track segment delay, initial waiting time and transfer delay. We distinguish between two different types of passenger delay in relation to the public transit network: average passenger delay and total passenger delay. We employ temporal clustering on these two quantities to reveal daily and seasonal regularity in delay patterns of the transit network. The estimation and clustering methods are demonstrated on one year of data from Washington metro network. The data consists of schedule information and smart card data which includes passenger-train assignment of the metro network for the months of August 2017 to August 2018. Our findings show that the average passenger delay is relatively stable throughout the day. The temporal clustering reveals pronounced and recurrent and thus predictable daily and weekly patterns with distinct characteristics for certain months. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: Transportation Research Board Annual Meeting 2020

Ride Acceptance Behaviour of Ride-sourcing Drivers

Authors: Peyman Ashkrof, Gonçalo Homem de Almeida Correia, Oded Cats, Bart van Arem

Abstract: The performance of ride-sourcing services such as Uber and Lyft is determined by the collective choices of individual drivers who are not only chauffeurs but private fleet providers. In such a context, ride-sourcing drivers are free to decide whether to accept or decline ride requests assigned by the ride-hailing platform. Drivers' ride acceptance behaviour can significantly influence system perfo… ▽ More The performance of ride-sourcing services such as Uber and Lyft is determined by the collective choices of individual drivers who are not only chauffeurs but private fleet providers. In such a context, ride-sourcing drivers are free to decide whether to accept or decline ride requests assigned by the ride-hailing platform. Drivers' ride acceptance behaviour can significantly influence system performance in terms of riders' waiting time (associated with the level of service), drivers' occupation rate and idle time (related to drivers' income), and platform revenue and reputation. Hence, it is of great importance to identify the underlying determinants of the ride acceptance behaviour of drivers. To this end, we collected a unique dataset from ride-sourcing drivers working in the United States and the Netherlands through a cross-sectional stated preference experiment designed based upon disparate information conveyed to the respondents. Using a choice modelling approach, we estimated the effects of various existing and hypothetical attributes influencing the ride acceptance choice. Employment status, experience level with the platform, and working shift are found to be the key individual-specific determinants. Part-time and beginning drivers who work on midweek days (Monday-Thursday) have a higher tendency to accept ride offers. Results also reveal that pickup time, which is the travel time between the driver's location and the rider's waiting spot, has a negative impact on ride acceptance. Moreover, the findings suggest that a guaranteed tip (i.e., the minimum amount of tip that is indicated upfront by the prospective rider, a feature that is currently not available) and an additional income due to surge pricing are valued noticeably higher than trip fare. The provided insights can be used to develop customised matching and pricing strategies to improve system efficiency. △ Less

Submitted 16 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 25 pages, 4 figures

Ride-Pooling Matching with a Compensatory Cost Function: Implications for Adoption, Efficiency and Level of Service

Authors: Arjan de Ruijter, Oded Cats, Javier Alonso-Mora, Serge Hoogendoorn

Abstract: By utilising vehicle capacity more efficiently, ride-pooling platforms can potentially lead to reduced congestion levels without adversely prolonging travel times. While previous studies concluded that shared rides can offer substantial benefits, initial evidence suggests low adoption levels. We postulate that previous studies that investigated the potential of ride-pooling failed to account for t… ▽ More By utilising vehicle capacity more efficiently, ride-pooling platforms can potentially lead to reduced congestion levels without adversely prolonging travel times. While previous studies concluded that shared rides can offer substantial benefits, initial evidence suggests low adoption levels. We postulate that previous studies that investigated the potential of ride-pooling failed to account for the trade-off that users are likely to make when considering a shared ride. We address this shortcoming by formulating user net benefit stemming from sharing as a compensatory function where the additional travel time and on-board discomfort need to be compensated by the price discount for a traveller to choose a shared ride over a private ride. The proposed formulation is embedded in a method for matching travel requests and vehicles. We conduct a series of experiments investigating how the potential of ride-pooling services depends on travel demand characteristics, user preferences and the pricing policy adopted by the service provider. In particular, the impact of various behavioural settings in terms of users' willingness to share their ride and delay aversion on service adoption and its operational efficiency is assessed. Our results suggest that the total vehicle mileage savings found by previous studies is only attainable when users are very willing to share their ride (i.e. attach low premium to private rides) and are offered a 50% discount for doing so. We find ride-pooling transportation distance savings as low as 15% in less favourable behavioural scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 24 pages, 5 figures, Submitted to International Journal of Transportation Science and Technology

Evolution of Labour Supply in Ridesourcing

Authors: Arjan de Ruijter, Oded Cats, Rafal Kucharski, Hans van Lint

Abstract: Contrary to traditional transit services, supply in ridesourcing systems emerges from individual labour decisions of gig workers. The effect of decentralisation in supply on the evolution of on-demand transit services is largely unknown. To this end, we propose a dynamic model comprising of the subsequent supply-side processes: (i) initial exposure to information about the platform, (ii) a long-te… ▽ More Contrary to traditional transit services, supply in ridesourcing systems emerges from individual labour decisions of gig workers. The effect of decentralisation in supply on the evolution of on-demand transit services is largely unknown. To this end, we propose a dynamic model comprising of the subsequent supply-side processes: (i) initial exposure to information about the platform, (ii) a long-term registration decision, and (iii) daily participation decisions, subject to day-to-day learning based on within-day matching outcomes. We construct a series of experiments to study the effect of supply market properties and pricing strategies. We find that labour supply in ridesourcing may be non-linear and undergo several transitions, inducing significant variations in income levels and level of service over time. Our results provide indications that the ridesourcing market may benefit from a cap in supply and regulation of the commission fee. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2022; v1 submitted 14 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 33 pages, 11 figures, Replacement of version submitted to Transportmetrica B: Transport Dynamics (2022) prior to revisions

What is the market potential for on-demand services as a train station access mode?

Authors: N. Geržinič, O. Cats, N. van Oort, S. Hoogendoorn-Lanser, S. Hoogendoorn

Abstract: On-demand mobility services (FLEX) are often proposed as a solution for the first/last mile problem. We study the potential of using FLEX to improve train station access by means of a three-step sequential stated preference survey. We compare FLEX with the bicycle, car and public transport for accessing two alternative train stations. We estimate a joint access mode and train station choice model.… ▽ More On-demand mobility services (FLEX) are often proposed as a solution for the first/last mile problem. We study the potential of using FLEX to improve train station access by means of a three-step sequential stated preference survey. We compare FLEX with the bicycle, car and public transport for accessing two alternative train stations. We estimate a joint access mode and train station choice model. Estimating a latent class choice model with different nesting structures, we uncover four distinct segments in the population. Two segments (~50%) with a lower Willingness-to-Pay seem to be more likely to take-up FLEX. Ex-urban car drivers seem to be the most likely segment to adopt FLEX, showing great, since members of this segment are currently frequent users of the private car. Our case study also shows that while FLEX competes primarily with public transport when accessing local stations, it competes primarily with car for reaching distant stations. △ Less

Submitted 17 April, 2023; v1 submitted 2 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Journal ref: Nejc Geržinič, Oded Cats, Niels van Oort, Sascha Hoogendoorn-Lanser & Serge Hoogendoorn (2023) What is the market potential for on-demand services as a train station access mode?, Transportmetrica A: Transport Science

Potential of on-demand services for urban travel

Authors: N. Geržinič, N. van Oort, S. Hoogendoorn-Lanser, O. Cats, S. Hoogendoorn

Abstract: On-demand mobility services are promising to revolutionise urban travel, but preliminary studies are showing they may actually increase total vehicle miles travelled, worsening road congestion in cities. In this study, we assess the demand for on-demand mobility services in urban areas, using a stated preference survey, to understand the potential impact of introducing on-demand services on the cu… ▽ More On-demand mobility services are promising to revolutionise urban travel, but preliminary studies are showing they may actually increase total vehicle miles travelled, worsening road congestion in cities. In this study, we assess the demand for on-demand mobility services in urban areas, using a stated preference survey, to understand the potential impact of introducing on-demand services on the current modal split. The survey was carried out in the Netherlands and offered respondents a choice between bike, car, public transport and ondemand services. 1,063 valid responses are analysed with a multinomial logit and a latent class choice model. By means of the latter, we uncover four distinctive groups of travellers based on the observed choice behaviour. The majority of the sample, the Sharing-ready cyclists (55%), are avid cyclists and do not see on-demand mobility as an alternative for making urban trips. Two classes, Tech-ready individuals (27%) and Flex-ready individuals (9%) would potentially use on-demand services: the former is fairly time-sensitive and would thus use on-demand service if they were sufficiently fast. The latter is highly costsensitive, and would therefore use the service primarily if it is cheap. The fourth class, Flex-sceptic individuals (9%) shows very limited potential for using on-demand services. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2023; v1 submitted 2 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: Transportation (2022)

Unravelling the Spatial Properties of Individual Mobility Patterns using Longitudinal Travel Data

Authors: Oded Cats, Francesco Ferranti

Abstract: The analysis of longitudinal travel data enables investigating how mobility patterns vary across the population and identify the spatial properties thereof. The objective of this study is to identify the extent to which users explore different parts of the network as well as identify distinctive user groups in terms of the spatial extent of their mobility patterns. To this end, we propose two mean… ▽ More The analysis of longitudinal travel data enables investigating how mobility patterns vary across the population and identify the spatial properties thereof. The objective of this study is to identify the extent to which users explore different parts of the network as well as identify distinctive user groups in terms of the spatial extent of their mobility patterns. To this end, we propose two means for representing spatial mobility profiles and clustering travellers accordingly. We represent users patterns in terms of zonal visiting frequency profiles and grid-cells spatial extent heatmaps. We apply the proposed analysis to a large-scale multi-modal mobility data set from the public transport system in Stockholm, Sweden. We unravel three clusters - locals, commuters and explorers - that best describe the zonal visiting frequency and show that their composition varies considerably across users' place of residence and related demographics. We also identify 18 clusters of visiting spatial extent which form four groups that follow similar shapes of travel extent yet oriented in different directions. The approach proposed and applied in this study could be applied for any longitudinal individual travel demand data. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

A Multinomial Probit Model with Choquet Integral and Attribute Cut-offs

Authors: Subodh Dubey, Oded Cats, Serge Hoogendoorn, Prateek Bansal

Abstract: Several non-linear functions and machine learning methods have been developed for flexible specification of the systematic utility in discrete choice models. However, they lack interpretability, do not ensure monotonicity conditions, and restrict substitution patterns. We address the first two challenges by modelling the systematic utility using the Choquet Integral (CI) function and the last one… ▽ More Several non-linear functions and machine learning methods have been developed for flexible specification of the systematic utility in discrete choice models. However, they lack interpretability, do not ensure monotonicity conditions, and restrict substitution patterns. We address the first two challenges by modelling the systematic utility using the Choquet Integral (CI) function and the last one by embedding CI into the multinomial probit (MNP) choice probability kernel. We also extend the MNP-CI model to account for attribute cut-offs that enable a modeller to approximately mimic the semi-compensatory behaviour using the traditional choice experiment data. The MNP-CI model is estimated using a constrained maximum likelihood approach, and its statistical properties are validated through a comprehensive Monte Carlo study. The CI-based choice model is empirically advantageous as it captures interaction effects while maintaining monotonicity. It also provides information on the complementarity between pairs of attributes coupled with their importance ranking as a by-product of the estimation. These insights could potentially assist policymakers in making policies to improve the preference level for an alternative. These advantages of the MNP-CI model with attribute cut-offs are illustrated in an empirical application to understand New Yorkers' preferences towards mobility-on-demand services. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2021; v1 submitted 7 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

How to split the costs among travellers sharing a ride? Aligning system's optimum with users' equilibrium

Authors: Andres Fielbaum, Rafal Kucharski, Oded Cats, Javier Alonso-Mora

Abstract: How to form groups in a mobility system that offers shared rides, and how to split the costs within the travellers of a group, are non-trivial tasks, as two objectives conflict: 1) minimising the total costs of the system, and 2) making each user content with her assignment. Aligning both objectives is challenging, as users are not aware of the externalities induced to the rest of the system. In… ▽ More How to form groups in a mobility system that offers shared rides, and how to split the costs within the travellers of a group, are non-trivial tasks, as two objectives conflict: 1) minimising the total costs of the system, and 2) making each user content with her assignment. Aligning both objectives is challenging, as users are not aware of the externalities induced to the rest of the system. In this paper, we propose protocols to share the costs within a ride so that optimal solutions can also constitute equilibria. To do this, we model the situation as a game. We show that the traditional notions of equilibrium in game theory (Nash and Strong) are not useful here, and prove that determining whether a Strong Equilibrium exists is an NP-Complete problem. Hence, we propose three alternative equilibrium notions (stronger than Nash and weaker than Strong), depending on how users can coordinate, that effectively represent stable ways to match the users. We then propose three cost-sharing protocols, for which the optimal solutions are an equilibrium for each of the mentioned intermediate notions of equilibrium. The game we study can be seen as a game-version of the well-known \textit{set cover problem}. Numerical simulations for Amsterdam reveal that our protocols can achieve stable solutions that are always close to the optimum, that there exists a trade-off between total users' costs and how equal do they distribute among them, and that having a central coordinator can have a large impact. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Traveller behaviour in public transport in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic in the Netherlands

Authors: Sanmay Shelat, Oded Cats, Sander van Cranenburgh

Abstract: Public transport ridership around the world has been hit hard by the COVID-19 pandemic. Travellers are likely to adapt their behaviour to avoid the risk of transmission and these changes may even be sustained after the pandemic. To evaluate travellers' behaviour in public transport networks during these times and assess how they will respond to future changes in the pandemic, we conduct a stated c… ▽ More Public transport ridership around the world has been hit hard by the COVID-19 pandemic. Travellers are likely to adapt their behaviour to avoid the risk of transmission and these changes may even be sustained after the pandemic. To evaluate travellers' behaviour in public transport networks during these times and assess how they will respond to future changes in the pandemic, we conduct a stated choice experiment with train travellers in the Netherlands. We specifically assess behaviour related to three criteria affecting the risk of COVID-19 transmission: (i) crowding, (ii) exposure duration, and (iii) prevalent infection rate. Observed choices are analysed using a latent class choice model which reveals two, nearly equally sized traveller segments: 'COVID Conscious' and 'Infection Indifferent'. The former has a significantly higher valuation of crowding, accepting, on average 8.75 minutes extra waiting time to reduce one person on-board. Moreover, they demonstrate a strong desire to sit without anybody in their neighbouring seat and are quite sensitive to changes in the prevalent infection rate. By contrast, Infection Indifferent travellers' value of crowding (1.04 waiting time minutes/person) is only slightly higher than pre-pandemic estimates and they are relatively unaffected by infection rates. We find that older and female travellers are more likely to be COVD Conscious while those reporting to use the trains more frequently during the pandemic tend to be Infection Indifferent. Further analysis also reveals differences between the two segments in attitudes towards the pandemic and self-reported rule-following behaviour. The behavioural insights from this study will not only contribute to better demand forecasting for service planning but will also inform public transport policy decisions aimed at curbing the shift to private modes. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2022; v1 submitted 22 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Journal ref: Transp. Res. A: Policy Pract. 159 (2022) 357-371

Ride-pooling potential under alternative spatial demand patterns

Authors: Jaime Soza-Parra, Rafał Kucharski, Oded Cats

Abstract: Shared rides are often considered to be a promising travel alternative that could efficiently pool people together while offering a door-to-door service. Notwithstanding, even though demand distribution patterns are expected to greatly affect the potential for ride-pooling, their impact remains unknown. In this study we explore the shareability of various demand patterns. We devise a set of experi… ▽ More Shared rides are often considered to be a promising travel alternative that could efficiently pool people together while offering a door-to-door service. Notwithstanding, even though demand distribution patterns are expected to greatly affect the potential for ride-pooling, their impact remains unknown. In this study we explore the shareability of various demand patterns. We devise a set of experiments tailored to identify the most promising demand patterns for introducing ride-pooling services by varying the number of centers, the dispersion of destinations around each of these centers and the trip length distribution. When matching trips into rides, we do not only ensure their mutual compatibility in time and space but also that shared rides are only composed by travellers who find the ride-pooling offer to be more attractive than the private ride-hailing alternative given the trade-offs between travel time, fare and discomfort. We measure the shareability potential using a series of metrics related to the extent to which passenger demand can be assigned to shared rides. Our findings indicate that introducing a ride-pooling service can reduce vehicle-hours by 18-59% under a fixed demand level and depending on the concentration of travel destinations around the center and the trip length distribution. System efficiency correlates positively with the former and negatively with the latter. A shift from a monocentric to a polycentric demand pattern is found to have a limited impact on the prospects of shared rides. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Beyond the Dichotomy: How Ride-hailing Competes with and Complements Public Transport

Authors: Oded Cats, Rafał Kucharski, Santosh Rao Danda, Menno Yap

Abstract: Since ride-hailing has become an important travel alternative in many cities worldwide, a fervent debate is underway on whether it competes with or complements public transport services. We use Uber trip data in six cities in the United States and Europe to identify the most attractive public transport alternative for each ride. We then address the following questions: (i) How does ride-hailing tr… ▽ More Since ride-hailing has become an important travel alternative in many cities worldwide, a fervent debate is underway on whether it competes with or complements public transport services. We use Uber trip data in six cities in the United States and Europe to identify the most attractive public transport alternative for each ride. We then address the following questions: (i) How does ride-hailing travel time and cost compare to the fastest public transport alternative? (ii) What proportion of ride-hailing trips that do not have a viable public transport alternative? (iii) How does ride-hailing change overall service accessibility? (iv) What is the relation between demand share and relative competition between the two alternatives? Our findings suggest that the dichotomy - competing with or complementing - is false. Though the vast majority of ride-hailing trips have a viable public transport alternative, between 20% and 40% of them have no viable public transport alternative. The increased service accessibility attributed to the inclusion of ride-hailing is greater in our US cities than in their European counterparts. Demand split is directly related to the relative competitiveness of travel times i.e. when public transport travel times are competitive ride-hailing demand share is low and vice-versa. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

MaaSSim -- agent-based two-sided mobility platform simulator

Authors: Rafał Kucharski, Oded Cats

Abstract: Two-sided mobility platforms, such as Uber and Lyft, widely emerged in the urban mobility landscape, bringing disruptive changes to transportation systems worldwide. This calls for a simulation framework where researchers from various and across disciplines may introduce models aimed at representing the dynamics of platform-driven urban mobility systems. In this work, we present MaaSSim, an agent-… ▽ More Two-sided mobility platforms, such as Uber and Lyft, widely emerged in the urban mobility landscape, bringing disruptive changes to transportation systems worldwide. This calls for a simulation framework where researchers from various and across disciplines may introduce models aimed at representing the dynamics of platform-driven urban mobility systems. In this work, we present MaaSSim, an agent-based simulator reproducing the transport system used by two kind of agents: (i) travellers, requesting to travel from their origin to destination at a given time, and (ii) drivers supplying their travel needs by offering them rides. An intermediate agent, the platform, allows demand to be matched with supply. Agents are decision makers, specifically, travellers may decide which mode they use or reject an incoming offer. Similarly, drivers may opt-out from the system or reject incoming requests. All of the above behaviours are modelled through user-defined modules, representing agents' taste variations (heterogeneity), their previous experiences (learning) and available information (system control). MaaSSim is an open-source library available at a public repository github.com/RafalKucharskiPK/MaaSSim, along with a set of tutorials and reproducible use-case scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Modelling virus spreading in ride-pooling networks

Authors: Rafał Kucharski, Oded Cats, Julian Sienkiewicz

Abstract: Urban mobility needs alternative sustainable travel modes to keep our pandemic cities in motion. Ride-pooling, where a single vehicle is shared by more than one traveller, is not only appealing for mobility platforms and their travellers, but also for promoting the sustainability of urban mobility systems. Yet, the potential of ride-pooling rides to serve as a safe and effective alternative given… ▽ More Urban mobility needs alternative sustainable travel modes to keep our pandemic cities in motion. Ride-pooling, where a single vehicle is shared by more than one traveller, is not only appealing for mobility platforms and their travellers, but also for promoting the sustainability of urban mobility systems. Yet, the potential of ride-pooling rides to serve as a safe and effective alternative given the personal and public health risks considerations associated with the COVID-19 pandemic is hitherto unknown. To answer this, we combine epidemiological and behavioural shareability models to examine spreading among ride-pooling travellers, with an application for Amsterdam. Findings are at first sight devastating, with only few initially infected travellers needed to spread the virus to hundreds of ride-pooling users. Without intervention, ride-pooling system may substantially contribute to virus spreading. Notwithstanding, we identify an effective control measure allowing to halt the spreading before the outbreaks (at 50 instead of 800 infections) without sacrificing the efficiency achieved by pooling. Fixed matches among co-travellers disconnect the otherwise dense contact network, encapsulating the virus in small communities and preventing the outbreaks. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2021; v1 submitted 25 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Journal ref: Scientific Reports 11 (1), 1-11, 2021

Mobility operator service capacity sharing contract design to risk-pool against network disruptions

Authors: Theodoros P. Pantelidis, Joseph Y. J. Chow, Oded Cats

Abstract: We propose a new mechanism to design risk-pooling contracts between operators to facilitate horizontal cooperation to mitigate those costs and improve service resilience during disruptions. We formulate a novel two-stage stochastic multicommodity flow model to determine the cost savings of a coalition under different disruption scenarios and solve it using L-shaped method along with sample average… ▽ More We propose a new mechanism to design risk-pooling contracts between operators to facilitate horizontal cooperation to mitigate those costs and improve service resilience during disruptions. We formulate a novel two-stage stochastic multicommodity flow model to determine the cost savings of a coalition under different disruption scenarios and solve it using L-shaped method along with sample average approximation. Computational tests of the L-shaped method against deterministic equivalent method with sample average approximation are conducted for network instances with up to 64 nodes, 10 OD pairs, and 1024 scenarios. The results demonstrate that the solution algorithm only becomes computationally effective for larger size instances (above 128 nodes) and that SAA maintains a close approximation. The proposed model is applied to a regional multi-operator network in the Randstad area of the Netherlands, for four operators, 40 origin-destination pairs, and over 1400 links where disruption data is available. Using the proposed method, we identify stable cost allocations among four operating agencies that could yield a 66% improvement in overall network performance over not having any risk-pooling contract in place. Furthermore, the model allows policymakers to evaluate the sensitivity of any one operator's bargaining power to different network structures and disruption scenario distributions, as we illustrate for the HTM operator in Randstad. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2023; v1 submitted 25 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Optimal frequency setting of metro services in the age of COVID-19 distancing measures

Authors: Konstantinos Gkiotsalitis, Oded Cats

Abstract: Public transport is one of the most disrupted sectors of the COVID-19 pandemic with reported ridership drops up to 90% in majorly affected countries. As many government authorities strive to partially resume activities, public transport operators are in an urgent need for models that can evaluate the impact of different social distancing policies on operational and passenger-related costs. In this… ▽ More Public transport is one of the most disrupted sectors of the COVID-19 pandemic with reported ridership drops up to 90% in majorly affected countries. As many government authorities strive to partially resume activities, public transport operators are in an urgent need for models that can evaluate the impact of different social distancing policies on operational and passenger-related costs. In this study, we introduce a mixed-integer quadratic programming model for the redesign of public transport services considering the operational, passenger, and revenue loss-related costs by evaluating the effects of different social distancing policies. Our model is applied at the metro network of Washington D.C. and provides optimal redistribution of vehicles across lines for different social distancing scenarios. This model can be used as a decision support tool by other policymakers and public transport operators that are in need of evaluating the costs related to the implementation of different social distancing policies. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.