Showing 1–50 of 62 results for author: Carballo-Rubio, R

Black hole horizons must be veiled by photon spheres

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Astrid Eichhorn

Abstract: Horizons and bound photon orbits are defining features of black holes that translate into key features of black hole images. We present a purely geometric proof that spherically symmetric, isolated objects with horizons in gravity theories with null-geodesic propagation of light must display bound photon orbits forming a photon sphere. Identifying the key elements of the proof, we articulate a sim… ▽ More Horizons and bound photon orbits are defining features of black holes that translate into key features of black hole images. We present a purely geometric proof that spherically symmetric, isolated objects with horizons in gravity theories with null-geodesic propagation of light must display bound photon orbits forming a photon sphere. Identifying the key elements of the proof, we articulate a simpler argument that carries over to more general situations with modified light propagation and implies the existence of equatorial spherical photon orbits in axisymmetric spacetimes with reflection symmetry. We conclude that the \emph{non-}observation of photon rings with very-large-baseline interferometry would be a very strong indication against a horizon, irrespective of whether or not the image shows a central brightness depression. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures, Honorable Mention in the Gravity Research Foundation 2024 Awards for Essays on Gravitation

Geodesically complete universes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Stefano Liberati, Vania Vellucci

Abstract: Singularity theorems demonstrate the inevitable breakdown of the concept of continuous, classical spacetime under highly general conditions. Quantum gravity is expected to intervene to avoid singularities and models so far hint towards several regularized geometries, in which limited spacetime regions requiring full quantum gravitational description can be safely covered by an extension of some su… ▽ More Singularity theorems demonstrate the inevitable breakdown of the concept of continuous, classical spacetime under highly general conditions. Quantum gravity is expected to intervene to avoid singularities and models so far hint towards several regularized geometries, in which limited spacetime regions requiring full quantum gravitational description can be safely covered by an extension of some suitable spacetime geometry. Motivated by these premises, in recent years, a systematic, quantum gravity agnostic, study has been carried out to catalogue all the conceivable non-singular, continuous, and globally hyperbolic geometries arising from evading Penrose's focusing theorem in gravitational collapse. In this study, we extend this inquiry by systematically examining all potential non-singular, continuous, and globally hyperbolic extensions into the past of Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) metrics. As in the black hole case, our investigation reveals a remarkably limited set of alternative scenarios. The stringent requisites of homogeneity and isotropy drastically restrict the viable singularity-free geometries to merely three discernible non-singular cosmological spacetimes: a bouncing universe (where the scale factor reaches a minimum in the past before re-expanding), an emergent universe (where the scale factor reaches and maintains a constant value in the past), and an asymptotically emergent universe (where the scale factor diminishes continually, asymptotically approaching a constant value in the past). We also discuss the implications of these findings for the initial conditions of our universe, and the arrow of time. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Mass inflation without Cauchy horizons

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: Mass inflation is a well established instability, conventionally associated to Cauchy horizons (which are also inner trap** horizons) of stationary geometries, leading to a divergent exponential buildup of energy. We show here that finite (but often large) exponential buildups of energy are generically present for dynamical geometries endowed with slowly-evolving inner trap** horizons, even in… ▽ More Mass inflation is a well established instability, conventionally associated to Cauchy horizons (which are also inner trap** horizons) of stationary geometries, leading to a divergent exponential buildup of energy. We show here that finite (but often large) exponential buildups of energy are generically present for dynamical geometries endowed with slowly-evolving inner trap** horizons, even in the absence of Cauchy horizons. This provides a more general definition of mass inflation based on quasi-local concepts. We also show that various known results in the literature are recovered in the limit in which the inner trap** horizon asymptotically approaches a Cauchy horizon. Our results imply that black hole geometries with non-extremal inner horizons, including the Kerr geometry in general relativity, and non-extremal regular black holes in theories beyond general relativity, can describe dynamical transients but not the long-lived endpoint of gravitational collapse. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

Disentangling photon rings beyond General Relativity with future radio-telescope arrays

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Héloïse Delaporte, Astrid Eichhorn, Aaron Held

Abstract: New physics beyond General Relativity can modify image features of black holes and horizonless spacetimes and increase the separation between photon rings. This motivates us to explore synthetic images consisting of two thin rings. Our synthetic images are parameterized by the separation as well as the relative flux density of the two rings. We perform fits to the visibility amplitude and analyze… ▽ More New physics beyond General Relativity can modify image features of black holes and horizonless spacetimes and increase the separation between photon rings. This motivates us to explore synthetic images consisting of two thin rings. Our synthetic images are parameterized by the separation as well as the relative flux density of the two rings. We perform fits to the visibility amplitude and analyze closure quantities. The current Event Horizon Telescope array cannot detect the presence of a second ring in the region of parameters motivated by particular new-physics cases. We show that this can be improved in three ways: first, if the array is upgraded with Earth-based telescopes with sufficiently high sensitivity, second, if the array is upgraded with a space-based station and third, if super-resolution techniques are used for the data obtained by the array. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: v2: 39 pages with references, 15 figures, accepted for publication in JCAP v1: 38 pages with references, 18 figures, comments welcome

Fundamental Physics Opportunities with the Next-Generation Event Horizon Telescope

Authors: Dimitry Ayzenberg, Lindy Blackburn, Richard Brito, Silke Britzen, Avery E. Broderick, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Vitor Cardoso, Andrew Chael, Koushik Chatterjee, Yifan Chen, Pedro V. P. Cunha, Hooman Davoudiasl, Peter B. Denton, Sheperd S. Doeleman, Astrid Eichhorn, Marshall Eubanks, Yun Fang, Arianna Foschi, Christian M. Fromm, Peter Galison, Sushant G. Ghosh, Roman Gold, Leonid I. Gurvits, Shahar Hadar, Aaron Held , et al. (23 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) Collaboration recently published the first images of the supermassive black holes in the cores of the Messier 87 and Milky Way galaxies. These observations have provided a new means to study supermassive black holes and probe physical processes occurring in the strong-field regime. We review the prospects of future observations and theoretical studies of supermass… ▽ More The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) Collaboration recently published the first images of the supermassive black holes in the cores of the Messier 87 and Milky Way galaxies. These observations have provided a new means to study supermassive black holes and probe physical processes occurring in the strong-field regime. We review the prospects of future observations and theoretical studies of supermassive black hole systems with the next-generation Event Horizon Telescope (ngEHT), which will greatly enhance the capabilities of the existing EHT array. These enhancements will open up several previously inaccessible avenues of investigation, thereby providing important new insights into the properties of supermassive black holes and their environments. This review describes the current state of knowledge for five key science cases, summarising the unique challenges and opportunities for fundamental physics investigations that the ngEHT will enable. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: To be submitted to journal. Comments are welcome

Ultracompact horizonless objects in order-reduced semiclassical gravity

Authors: Julio Arrechea, Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: The backreaction of quantum fields in their vacuum state results in equilibrium structures that surpass the Buchdahl compactness limit. Such backreaction is encapsulated in the vacuum expectation value of the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET). In previous works we presented analytic approximations to the RSET, obtained by dimensional reduction, available in spherical symmetry, and showed th… ▽ More The backreaction of quantum fields in their vacuum state results in equilibrium structures that surpass the Buchdahl compactness limit. Such backreaction is encapsulated in the vacuum expectation value of the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET). In previous works we presented analytic approximations to the RSET, obtained by dimensional reduction, available in spherical symmetry, and showed that the backreaction-generated solutions described ultracompact fluid spheres with a negative mass interior. Here, we derive a novel approximation to the RSET that does not rely on dimensional reduction, but rather on a reduction of the differential order. This approximation also leads to regular stars surpassing the Buchdahl limit. We conclude that this is a consequence of the negative energies associated with the Boulware vacuum which, for sufficiently compact fluid spheres, make the Misner-Sharp mass negative near the centre of spherical symmetry. Our analysis provides further cumulative evidence that quantum vacuum polarization is capable of producing new forms of stellar equilibrium with robust properties accross different analytical approximations to the RSET. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2024; v1 submitted 19 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures. Added a new figure, an appendix, and improved the main text. To appear in Phys. Rev. D

Constraints on thermalizing surfaces from infrared observations of supermassive black holes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: Infrared observations of Sgr A$^*$ and M87$^*$ are incompatible with the assumption that these sources have physical surfaces in thermal equilibrium with their accreting environments. In this paper we discuss a general parametrization of the energy balance in a horizonless object, which permits to quantify how close a horizonless object is in its behavior to a black hole, and analyze the timescale… ▽ More Infrared observations of Sgr A$^*$ and M87$^*$ are incompatible with the assumption that these sources have physical surfaces in thermal equilibrium with their accreting environments. In this paper we discuss a general parametrization of the energy balance in a horizonless object, which permits to quantify how close a horizonless object is in its behavior to a black hole, and analyze the timescale in which its surface can thermalize. We show that the thermalization timescale is unbounded, growing large for objects that mimic closely the behavior of a black hole (and being infinite for the latter). In particular, the thermalization timescale is proportional to the time that energy spends inside the horizonless object due to propagation and interactions with the bulk. Hence, these observations can be used to quantitatively restrict the dynamical behavior of horizonless objects, without being able to discard the existence of a physical surface. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 17 pages, 2 figures

Report number: YITP-22-84

Singularity-free gravitational collapse: From regular black holes to horizonless objects

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: Penrose's singularity theorem implies that if a trapped region forms in a gravitational collapse, then a singularity must form as well within such region. However, it is widely expected that singularities should be generically avoided by quantum gravitational effects. Here we shall explore both the minimum requirements to avoid singularities in a gravitational collapse as well as discuss, without… ▽ More Penrose's singularity theorem implies that if a trapped region forms in a gravitational collapse, then a singularity must form as well within such region. However, it is widely expected that singularities should be generically avoided by quantum gravitational effects. Here we shall explore both the minimum requirements to avoid singularities in a gravitational collapse as well as discuss, without relying on a specific quantum gravity model, the possible regular spacetimes associated to such regularization of the spacetime fabric. In particular, we shall expose the intimate and quite subtle relationship between regular black holes, black bounces and their corresponding horizonless object limits. In doing so, we shall devote specific attention to those critical (extremal) black hole configurations lying at the boundary between horizonful and horizonless geometries. While these studies are carried out in stationary configurations, the presence of generic instabilities strongly suggest the need for considering more realistic time-dependent dynamical spacetimes. Missing specific dynamical models, much less rigorous statements can be made for evolving geometries. We shall nonetheless summarize here their present understanding and discuss their implications for future phenomenological studies. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: 36 pages, 11 figures; invited chapter to appear in the book ''Regular Black Holes: Towards a New Paradigm of the Gravitational Collapse''

Asymptotically flat vacuum solutions in order-reduced semiclassical gravity

Authors: Julio Arrechea, Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: We investigate the effects of quantum backreaction on the Schwarzschild geometry in the semiclassical approximation. The renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a scalar field is modelled via an order reduction of the analytical approximation derived by Anderson, Hiscock and Samuel (AHS). As the resulting AHS semiclassical Einstein equations are of fourth-derivative order in the metric, we fol… ▽ More We investigate the effects of quantum backreaction on the Schwarzschild geometry in the semiclassical approximation. The renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a scalar field is modelled via an order reduction of the analytical approximation derived by Anderson, Hiscock and Samuel (AHS). As the resulting AHS semiclassical Einstein equations are of fourth-derivative order in the metric, we follow a reduction of order prescription to shrink the space of solutions. Motivated by this prescription, we develop a method that allows to obtain a novel analytic approximation for the RSET that exhibits all the desired properties for a well-posed RSET: conservation, regularity, and correct estimation of vacuum-state contributions. We derive a set of semiclassical equations sourced by the order-reduced AHS-RSET in the Boulware state. We classify the self-consistent solutions to this set of field equations, discuss their main features and address how well they resemble the solutions of the higher-order semiclassical theory. Finally, we establish a comparison with previous results in the literature obtained through the Polyakov approximation for minimally coupled scalar fields. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2023; v1 submitted 19 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 20 pages, 4 figures. v2: Added minor comments and corrected typos to match published version

Comment on "Regular evaporating black holes with stable cores"

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Costantino Pacilio, Matt Visser

Abstract: Regular black holes are generically unstable because of the classical phenomenon that goes by the name of "mass inflation" which destabilizes the inner horizon. In a recent article, [Phys.Rev.D~107~(2023)~2,~024005], it is argued that semiclassical effects due to Hawking radiation can cure this instability, and some concerns are raised against the validity of previous analyses showing its existenc… ▽ More Regular black holes are generically unstable because of the classical phenomenon that goes by the name of "mass inflation" which destabilizes the inner horizon. In a recent article, [Phys.Rev.D~107~(2023)~2,~024005], it is argued that semiclassical effects due to Hawking radiation can cure this instability, and some concerns are raised against the validity of previous analyses showing its existence in the first place. In this short comment, we explain our reservations regarding these recent claims, and reiterate the relevance of the mass inflation instability for regular black holes of astrophysical interest. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2024; v1 submitted 14 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: v2: 8 pages, as published in Physical Review D

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D 108 (2023) 12, 128501

A connection between regular black holes and horizonless ultracompact stars

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: We illustrate that regular black holes and horizonless stars, typically considered as quite distinct families of black hole mimickers, are intimately intertwined. We show that any spherically symmetric regular black hole can be continuously deformed into a horizonless star under the mild conditions of non-negativity of gravitational energy (Misner--Sharp quasi-local mass), and an assumed linear re… ▽ More We illustrate that regular black holes and horizonless stars, typically considered as quite distinct families of black hole mimickers, are intimately intertwined. We show that any spherically symmetric regular black hole can be continuously deformed into a horizonless star under the mild conditions of non-negativity of gravitational energy (Misner--Sharp quasi-local mass), and an assumed linear relation between the latter and the Arnowitt--Deser--Misner (ADM) mass. We illustrate this general result by considering the family of geometries proposed by Hayward as the description of regular black holes, and we also describe the properties of the corresponding horizonless stars. The form of the associated effective stress-energy tensor shows that these horizonless stars can be identified as anisotropic gravastars with a soft surface and inner/outer light rings. We also construct dynamical geometries that could describe the evolution of regular black holes towards horizonless stars, and show that semiclassical physics contains the necessary ingredients to trigger the early stages of such dynamical evolution. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 29 pages with references, 6 figures

Towards VLBI Observations of Black Hole Structure

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Vitor Cardoso, Ziri Younsi

Abstract: Black holes hold a tremendous discovery potential. In this paper the extent to which the Event Horizon Telescope and its next generation upgrade can resolve their structure is quantified. Black holes are characterized by a perfectly absorptive boundary, with a specific area determined by intrinsic parameters of the black hole. We use a general parametrization of spherically symmetric spacetimes de… ▽ More Black holes hold a tremendous discovery potential. In this paper the extent to which the Event Horizon Telescope and its next generation upgrade can resolve their structure is quantified. Black holes are characterized by a perfectly absorptive boundary, with a specific area determined by intrinsic parameters of the black hole. We use a general parametrization of spherically symmetric spacetimes describing deviations from this behavior, with parameters controlling the size of the central object and its interaction with light, in particular through a specular reflection coefficient $Γ$ and an intrinsic luminosity measured as a fraction $η$ of that of the accretion disc. This enables us to study exotic compact objects and compare them with black holes in a model-independent manner. We determine the image features associated with the existence of a surface in the presence of a geometrically thin and optically thick accretion disc, identifying requirements for VLBI observations to be able to cast meaningful constraints on these parameters, in particular regarding angular resolution and image dynamic range. For face-on observations, constraints of order $η\lesssim 10^{-4}, Γ\lesssim 10^{-1}$ are possible with an enhanced EHT array, imposing strong constraints on the nature of the central object. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 10 figures

Unimodular Gravity vs General Relativity: A status report

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay, Gerardo García-Moreno

Abstract: Unimodular Gravity is an alternative to General Relativity (GR) which, however, is so closely related to the latter that one can wonder to what extent they are different. The different behavior of the cosmological constant in the semiclassical regimes of both frameworks suggests the possible existence of additional contrasting features. UG and GR are based on two different gauge symmetries: UG is… ▽ More Unimodular Gravity is an alternative to General Relativity (GR) which, however, is so closely related to the latter that one can wonder to what extent they are different. The different behavior of the cosmological constant in the semiclassical regimes of both frameworks suggests the possible existence of additional contrasting features. UG and GR are based on two different gauge symmetries: UG is based on transverse diffeomorphisms and Weyl rescalings (WTDiff transformations), whereas GR is based on the full group of diffeomorphisms. This difference is related to the existence of a fiduciary background structure, a fixed volume form, in UG theories. In this work we present an overview as complete as possible of situations and regimes in which one might suspect that some differences between these two theories might arise. This overview contains analyses in the classical, semiclassical, and quantum regimes. When a particular situation is well known we make just a brief description of its status. For situations less analyzed in the literature we provide here more complete analyses. Whereas some of these analyses are sparse through the literature, many of them are new. Apart from the completely different treatment they provide for the cosmological constant problem, our results uncover no further differences between them. We conclude that, to the extent that the technical naturalness of the cosmological constant is regarded as a fundamental open issue in modern physics, UG is preferred over GR since the cosmological constant is technically natural in the former. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2022; v1 submitted 18 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 58 pages, no figures; v2: Matches the published version. Some discussions are expanded and references added

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 2022, 39, 243001

Regular black holes without mass inflation instability

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Costantino Pacilio, Matt Visser

Abstract: Generic models of regular black holes have separate outer and inner horizons, both with nonzero surface gravity. It has been shown that a nonzero inner horizon surface gravity results in exponential instability at the inner horizon controlled by this parameter. This phenomenon takes the name of "mass inflation instability", and its presence has put in question the physical viability of regular bla… ▽ More Generic models of regular black holes have separate outer and inner horizons, both with nonzero surface gravity. It has been shown that a nonzero inner horizon surface gravity results in exponential instability at the inner horizon controlled by this parameter. This phenomenon takes the name of "mass inflation instability", and its presence has put in question the physical viability of regular black holes as alternatives to their (singular) general relativity counterparts. In this paper, we show that it is possible to make the inner horizon surface gravity vanish, while maintaining the separation between horizons, and a non-zero outer horizon surface gravity. We construct specific geometries satisfying these requirements, and analyze their behavior under different kinds of perturbations, showing that the exponential growth characteristic of mass inflation instability is not present for these geometries. These "inner-extremal" regular black holes are thereby better behaved than singular black holes and generic regular black holes, thus providing a well-motivated alternative of interest for fundamental and phenomenological studies. △ Less

Submitted 26 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 figures

Report number: YITP-22-53

Constraints on horizonless objects after the EHT observation of Sagittarius A*

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: The images of Sagittarius A$^*$ recently released by the Event Horizon Telescope collaboration have been accompanied [Ap.J.Lett.\,{\bf 930\,\#2}\,(2022)\,L17] by an analysis of the constraints on the possible absence of a trap** horizon, i.e.~on the possibility that the object at the center of our galaxy is an ultra-compact object with a surface re-emitting incident radiation. Indeed, using the… ▽ More The images of Sagittarius A$^*$ recently released by the Event Horizon Telescope collaboration have been accompanied [Ap.J.Lett.\,{\bf 930\,\#2}\,(2022)\,L17] by an analysis of the constraints on the possible absence of a trap** horizon, i.e.~on the possibility that the object at the center of our galaxy is an ultra-compact object with a surface re-emitting incident radiation. Indeed, using the observed image size and the broadband spectrum of Sgr A$^*$, it is claimed that the radius of any such thermal surface is strongly bounded from above by these latest observations. Herein, we discuss how the reported constraint relies on the extremely strong assumption of perfect balance in the energy exchange between the accretion disk and the central object, and show that this is violated whenever the surface is endowed with any non-zero absorption coefficient. We discuss in detail the upper-bound constraints that can be cast on the radius and dimensionless absorption coefficient of the surface. We show that the conclusions of the analysis presented by the EHT collaboration hold only for unnaturally small values of the absorption coefficient (i.e. much lower than $10^{-14}$), and thus have to be significantly revised in scenarios with physical significance. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2022; v1 submitted 26 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 13 pages, 4 figures. Minor changes. Matches published version

Report number: YITP-22-54

Journal ref: JCAP 08 (2022) 08, 055

On the inner horizon instability of non-singular black holes

Authors: Francesco Di Filippo, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Stefano Liberati, Costantino Pacilio, Matt Visser

Abstract: Regular black holes represent a conservative model in which the classical singularity is replaced by a non-singular core without necessarily modifying the spacetime outside the trap** horizon. Given the possible lack of phenomenological signatures, it is crucial to study the consistency of the model. In this short work, we review the physical mechanism leading to the instability of the central c… ▽ More Regular black holes represent a conservative model in which the classical singularity is replaced by a non-singular core without necessarily modifying the spacetime outside the trap** horizon. Given the possible lack of phenomenological signatures, it is crucial to study the consistency of the model. In this short work, we review the physical mechanism leading to the instability of the central core, arguing that non-perturbative backreaction is non-negligible and must be taken into account to provide a meaningful description of physical black holes. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Invited talk at the conference "The Quantum & The Gravity 2021"

Report number: YITP-22-22

Classical mass inflation vs semiclassical inner horizon inflation

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Valentin Boyanov, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: We analyse the geometry of a spherically symmetric black hole with an inner and outer apparent horizon which is perturbed by spherical null shells of matter. On a classical level we observe that the mass inflation instability is triggered, resulting in a growth of curvature and an inward displacement of the inner horizon. We study in detail the inner structure of the mass-inflated region and compa… ▽ More We analyse the geometry of a spherically symmetric black hole with an inner and outer apparent horizon which is perturbed by spherical null shells of matter. On a classical level we observe that the mass inflation instability is triggered, resulting in a growth of curvature and an inward displacement of the inner horizon. We study in detail the inner structure of the mass-inflated region and compare it with previous results obtained for the case in which the perturbing matter content has a continuous distribution. We then perform an approximate calculation of the renormalised stress-energy tensor of a quantum field in the vicinity of the inner horizon, and analyse the semiclassical backreaction on this region of the geometry. We find that the classical tendency for this horizon to move inward due to mass inflation is challenged and potentially overcome by a semiclassical tendency for it to inflate outward. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures

Geodesically complete black holes in Lorentz-violating gravity

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: We present a systematic study of the geometric structure of non-singular spacetimes describing black holes in Lorentz-violating gravity. We start with a review of the definition of trap** horizons, and the associated notions of trapped and marginally trapped surfaces, and then study their significance in frameworks with modified dispersion relations. This leads us to introduce the notion of univ… ▽ More We present a systematic study of the geometric structure of non-singular spacetimes describing black holes in Lorentz-violating gravity. We start with a review of the definition of trap** horizons, and the associated notions of trapped and marginally trapped surfaces, and then study their significance in frameworks with modified dispersion relations. This leads us to introduce the notion of universally marginally trapped surfaces, as the direct generalization of marginally trapped surfaces for frameworks with infinite signal velocities (Hořava-like frameworks), which then allows us to define universal trap** horizons. We find that trapped surfaces cannot be generalized in the same way, and discuss in detail why this does not prevent using universal trap** horizons to define black holes in Hořava-like frameworks. We then explore the interplay between the kinematical part of Penrose's singularity theorem, which implies the existence of incomplete null geodesics in the presence of a focusing point, and the existence of multiple different metrics. This allows us to present a complete classification of all possible geometries that neither display incomplete physical trajectories nor curvature singularities. Our main result is that not all classes that exist in frameworks in which all signal velocities are realized in Hořava-like frameworks. However, the taxonomy of geodesically complete black holes in Ho\v rava-like frameworks includes diverse scenarios such as evaporating regular black holes, regular black holes bouncing into regular white holes, and hidden wormholes. △ Less

Submitted 4 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 28 pages, 8 figures

Semiclassical relativistic stars

Authors: Julio Arrechea, Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: We present strong evidence that semiclassical gravity can give place to self-consistent ultracompact stars beyond the Buchdahl limit. We integrate the semiclassical equations of (spherically symmetric) stellar equilibrium for a constant-density classical fluid. The semiclassical contribution is modelled by a quantum massless scalar field in the only static vacuum state compatible with asymptotic f… ▽ More We present strong evidence that semiclassical gravity can give place to self-consistent ultracompact stars beyond the Buchdahl limit. We integrate the semiclassical equations of (spherically symmetric) stellar equilibrium for a constant-density classical fluid. The semiclassical contribution is modelled by a quantum massless scalar field in the only static vacuum state compatible with asymptotic flatness (Boulware vacuum). The Renormalized Stress-Energy Tensor (RSET) is firstly approximated by the analytic Polyakov approximation. This already reveals a crucial difference with respect to purely classical solutions: stars with compactness close to that of a black hole exhibit bounded pressures and curvatures up to a very small central core compared with the star radius. This suggests that a more refined approximation to the RSET at the core may give rise to strictly regular configurations. Following this suggestion, we prove that a minimal deformation of the Polyakov approximation inside the central core is sufficient to produce regular ultracompact stellar configurations. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2022; v1 submitted 29 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 5 figures. Expanded main text significantly with extra details and explanations. Added a new Figure (Fig. 4), Figs. 2 and 3 replaced. Version to appear in Scientific Reports Gravitational Waves guest edited collection

Breaking Buchdahl: ultracompact stars in semiclassical gravity

Authors: Julio Arrechea, Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: The semiclassical approximation takes into account the gravitational contribution of zero-point energies. We model this contribution via the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a massless scalar field, which we compute in a cutoff-regularized version of the Polyakov approximation. When the field is in the Boulware vacuum state (the natural vacuum for stellar geometries), the RSET works in… ▽ More The semiclassical approximation takes into account the gravitational contribution of zero-point energies. We model this contribution via the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a massless scalar field, which we compute in a cutoff-regularized version of the Polyakov approximation. When the field is in the Boulware vacuum state (the natural vacuum for stellar geometries), the RSET works in favor of violating the Buchdahl compactness limit. We review the family of classical constant-density stellar solutions, paying particular attention to the notion of criticality -- the presence of offsets in the mass function -- and use it as a warm up for the analysis of the semiclassical set of solutions. For stars that surpass Buchdahl limit by far, the critical solution has an irregular pressure. This divergence in pressure moves inward by introducing a negative offset in the mass. In the semiclassical theory we find something rather different, namely that the critical configuration already displays a pressure that diverges exactly at the center of the structure. This drastic difference between the classical and semiclassical space of solutions suggests that semiclassical gravity could potentially allow for the existence of ultracompact stellar objects. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures. Contribution to the proceedings of the 16th Marcel Grossmann meeting (5-10 July 2021)

Search for fast radio transients using Arecibo drift-scan observations at 1.4 GHz

Authors: B. B. P. Perera, A. J. Smith, S. Vaddi, R. Carballo-Rubio, A. McGilvray, A. Venkataraman, D. Anish Roshi, P. K. Manoharan, P. Perillat, E. Lieb, D. R. Lorimer, M. A. McLaughlin, D. Agarwal, K. Aggarwal, S. M. Ransom

Abstract: We conducted a drift-scan observation campaign using the 305-m Arecibo telescope in January and March 2020 when the observatory was temporarily closed during the intense earthquakes and the initial outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic, respectively. The primary objective of the survey was to search for fast radio transients, including Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) and Rotating Radio Transients (RRATs). We… ▽ More We conducted a drift-scan observation campaign using the 305-m Arecibo telescope in January and March 2020 when the observatory was temporarily closed during the intense earthquakes and the initial outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic, respectively. The primary objective of the survey was to search for fast radio transients, including Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) and Rotating Radio Transients (RRATs). We used the 7-beam ALFA receiver to observe different sections of the sky within the declination region $\sim$(10$-$20) deg on 23 nights and collected 160 hours of data in total. We searched our data for single-pulse transients, covering up to a maximum dispersion measure of 11 000 pc cm$^{-3}$ at which the dispersion delay across the entire bandwidth is equal to the 13 s transit length of our observations. The analysis produced more than 18 million candidates. Machine learning techniques sorted the radio frequency interference and possibly astrophysical candidates, allowing us to visually inspect and confirm the candidate transients. We found no evidence for new astrophysical transients in our data. We also searched for emission from repeated transient signals, but found no evidence for such sources. We detected single pulses from two known pulsars in our observations and their measured flux densities are consistent with the expected values. Based on our observations and sensitivity, we estimated the upper limit for the FRB rate to be $<$2.8$\times10^5$ sky$^{-1}$ day$^{-1}$ above a fluence of 0.16 Jy ms at 1.4 GHz, which is consistent with the rates from other telescopes and surveys. △ Less

Submitted 27 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures. Accepted 2021 October 27 for publication in MNRAS

Toward a mechanism for the emergence of gravity

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay, Gerardo García-Moreno

Abstract: One of the main problems that emergent-gravity approaches face is explaining how a system that does not contain gauge symmetries ab initio might develop them effectively in some regime. We review a mechanism introduced by some of the authors for the emergence of gauge symmetries in [JHEP 10 (2016) 084] and discuss how it works for interacting Lorentz-invariant vector field theories as a warm-up ex… ▽ More One of the main problems that emergent-gravity approaches face is explaining how a system that does not contain gauge symmetries ab initio might develop them effectively in some regime. We review a mechanism introduced by some of the authors for the emergence of gauge symmetries in [JHEP 10 (2016) 084] and discuss how it works for interacting Lorentz-invariant vector field theories as a warm-up exercise for the more convoluted problem of gravity. Then, we apply this mechanism to the emergence of linear diffeomorphisms for the most general Lorentz-invariant linear theory of a two-index symmetric tensor field, which constitutes a generalization of the Fierz-Pauli theory describing linearized gravity. Finally we discuss two results, the well-known Weinberg-Witten theorem and a more recent theorem by Marolf, that are often invoked as no-go theorems for emergent gravity. Our analysis illustrates that, although these results pinpoint some of the particularities of gravity with respect to other gauge theories, they do not constitute an impediment for the emergent gravity program if gauge symmetries (diffeomorphisms) are emergent in the sense discussed in this paper. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2021; v1 submitted 14 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 35 pages, 1 figure; Contribution to the Special Issue Analogue Gravitational Dynamics; v2: Minor changes introduced in the text to match the published version

Journal ref: Appl. Sci. 2021, 11(18), 8763

Hearts of Darkness: the inside out probing of black holes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati

Abstract: Classical black holes shield us from the singularities that inevitably appear in general relativity. Being singularity regularization one of the main landmarks for a successful theory of quantum gravity, quantum black holes are not obliged to hide their inner core from the outside world. Notwithstanding the aforesaid, it is often implicitly assumed that quantum gravity effects must remain confined… ▽ More Classical black holes shield us from the singularities that inevitably appear in general relativity. Being singularity regularization one of the main landmarks for a successful theory of quantum gravity, quantum black holes are not obliged to hide their inner core from the outside world. Notwithstanding the aforesaid, it is often implicitly assumed that quantum gravity effects must remain confined to black hole interiors. In this essay we argue in the opposite direction, discussing theoretical evidence for the existence of strong correlations between the physics inside and outside non-singular black holes. We conclude that astronomical tests of the surroundings of black holes can provide invaluable information about their so-far unexplored interiors. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 7 pages, 2 figure,Awarded an Honorable Mention in the 2021 Gravity Research Foundation Essays Competition

Report number: YITP-21-46

Semiclassical constant-density spheres in a regularized Polyakov approximation

Authors: Julio Arrechea, Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: We provide an exhaustive analysis of the complete set of solutions of the equations of stellar equilibrium under semiclassical effects. As classical matter we use a perfect fluid of constant density; as the semiclassical source we use the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a minimally coupled massless scalar field in the Boulware vacuum (the only vacuum consistent with asymptotic flatness… ▽ More We provide an exhaustive analysis of the complete set of solutions of the equations of stellar equilibrium under semiclassical effects. As classical matter we use a perfect fluid of constant density; as the semiclassical source we use the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a minimally coupled massless scalar field in the Boulware vacuum (the only vacuum consistent with asymptotic flatness and staticity). For the RSET we use a regularized version of the Polyakov approximation. We present a complete catalogue of the semiclassical self-consistent solutions which incorporates regular as well as singular solutions, showing that the semiclassical corrections are highly relevant in scenarios of high compactness. Semiclassical corrections allow the existence of ultra-compact equilibrium configurations which have bounded pressures and masses up to a central core of Planckian radius, precisely where the regularized Polyakov approximation is not accurate. Our analysis strongly suggests the absence of a Buchdahl limit in semiclasical gravity, while indicating that the regularized Polyakov approximation used here must be improved to describe equilibrium configurations of arbitrary compactness that remain regular at the center of spherical symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2021; v1 submitted 24 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 35 pages, 20 figures. There is a new figure containing numerical integrations for every solution in the catalogue. We included a Mathematica notebook to reproduce such plots. A typo in Eq. (59) has been fixed. References added

Reissner-Nordström geometry counterpart in semiclassical gravity

Authors: Julio Arrechea, Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: We compute the Renormalized Stress-Energy Tensor (RSET) of a massless minimally coupled scalar field in the Regularized Polyakov approximation, as well as its backreaction, on the classical Reissner-Nordström spacetime. The complete set of solutions of the semiclassical self-consistent equations is obtained and compared with the classical counterparts. The semiclassical Reissner-Nordström family i… ▽ More We compute the Renormalized Stress-Energy Tensor (RSET) of a massless minimally coupled scalar field in the Regularized Polyakov approximation, as well as its backreaction, on the classical Reissner-Nordström spacetime. The complete set of solutions of the semiclassical self-consistent equations is obtained and compared with the classical counterparts. The semiclassical Reissner-Nordström family involves three kinds of geometries that depend on the charge-to-mass ratio of the spacetime. In the under-charged regime, the geometry has its external horizon replaced by a wormhole neck that leads to a singular asymptotic region at finite proper distance. The over-charged regime reveals a naked singularity coated by a cloud of (infinite) mass coming from the quantized field. In between both behaviours there is a separatrix solution reminiscent of the extremal black hole classical geometry. As the RSET over an extremal horizon is finite, the semiclassical backreaction does not get rid of the horizon. Nonetheless, we show that the resulting horizon is singular. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 36 pages, 7 figures

Emergent gauge symmetries: Yang-Mills theory

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay, Gerardo García-Moreno

Abstract: Gauge symmetries remove unphysical states and guarantee that field theories are free from the pathologies associated with these states. In this work we find a set of general conditions that guarantee the removal of unphysical states in field theories describing interacting vector fields. These conditions are obtained through the extension of a mechanism for the emergence of gauge symmetries propos… ▽ More Gauge symmetries remove unphysical states and guarantee that field theories are free from the pathologies associated with these states. In this work we find a set of general conditions that guarantee the removal of unphysical states in field theories describing interacting vector fields. These conditions are obtained through the extension of a mechanism for the emergence of gauge symmetries proposed in a previous article [C. Barceló et al. JHEP 10 (2016) 084] in order to account for non-Abelian gauge symmetries, and are the following: low-energy Lorentz invariance, emergence of massless vector fields describable by an action quadratic in those fields and their derivatives, and self-coupling to a conserved current associated with specific rigid symmetries. Using a bootstrap** procedure, we prove that these conditions are equivalent to the emergence of gauge symmetries and, therefore, guarantee that any theory satisfying them must be equivalent to a Yang-Mills theory at low energies. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2021; v1 submitted 28 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 15 pages, no figures; v2: Added minor changes in text to match published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 104, 025017 (2021)

Inner horizon instability and the unstable cores of regular black holes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Costantino Pacilio, Matt Visser

Abstract: Regular black holes with nonsingular cores have been considered in several approaches to quantum gravity, and as agnostic frameworks to address the singularity problem and Hawking's information paradox. While in a recent work we argued that the inner core is destabilized by linear perturbations, opposite claims were raised that regular black holes have in fact stable cores. To reconcile these argu… ▽ More Regular black holes with nonsingular cores have been considered in several approaches to quantum gravity, and as agnostic frameworks to address the singularity problem and Hawking's information paradox. While in a recent work we argued that the inner core is destabilized by linear perturbations, opposite claims were raised that regular black holes have in fact stable cores. To reconcile these arguments, we discuss a generalization of the geometrical framework, originally applied to Reissner--Nordtsröm black holes by Ori, and show that regular black holes have an exponentially growing Misner--Sharp mass at the inner horizon. This result can be taken as an indication that stable nonsingular black hole spacetimes are not the definitive endpoint of a quantum gravity regularization mechanism, and that nonperturbative backreaction effects must be taken into account in order to provide a consistent description of the quantum-gravitational endpoint of gravitational stellar collapse. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2021; v1 submitted 13 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 5 figures. Major changes in the presentation to improve clarity, physical conclusions unchanged, matches the version accepted on JHEP

Report number: YITP-21-02

Black hole inner horizon evaporation in semiclassical gravity

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Valentin Boyanov, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: In this work we analyse the backreaction of a quantum field on a spherically symmetric black hole geometry with an inner horizon, i.e. an internal boundary of the trapped region. We start with a black hole background with an inner horizon which remains static after its formation. We quantise a massless scalar field on it and calculate its renormalised stress-energy tensor in the Polyakov approxima… ▽ More In this work we analyse the backreaction of a quantum field on a spherically symmetric black hole geometry with an inner horizon, i.e. an internal boundary of the trapped region. We start with a black hole background with an inner horizon which remains static after its formation. We quantise a massless scalar field on it and calculate its renormalised stress-energy tensor in the Polyakov approximation. We use this tensor as a source of perturbation on top of the background spacetime. We find that the inner horizon has a tendency to evaporate outward much more quickly than the outer one evaporates inward through the Hawking effect. This suggests a revised picture of a semiclassically self-consistent evaporation in which the dominant dynamical effect comes from the inner horizon. We also look at backreaction on backgrounds which resemble gravitational collapse, where the inner horizon moves toward the origin. There we find that, depending on the nature of the background dynamics, horizon-related semiclassical effects can become dominant and invert the collapse. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2021; v1 submitted 14 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 33 pages, 9 figures; v2 generalises the formalism in sections 3 and 4 and fixes a minor mistake (conclusions remain unchanged)

Causal hierarchy in modified gravity

Authors: Raul Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: We investigate the causal hierarchy in various modified theories of gravity. In general relativity the standard causal hierarchy, (key elements of which are chronology, causality, strong causality, stable causality, and global hyperbolicity), is well-established. In modified theories of gravity there is typically considerable extra structure, (such as: multiple metrics, aether fields, modified dis… ▽ More We investigate the causal hierarchy in various modified theories of gravity. In general relativity the standard causal hierarchy, (key elements of which are chronology, causality, strong causality, stable causality, and global hyperbolicity), is well-established. In modified theories of gravity there is typically considerable extra structure, (such as: multiple metrics, aether fields, modified dispersion relations, Horava-like gravity, parabolic propagation, etcetera), requiring a reassessment and rephrasing of the usual causal hierarchy. We shall show that in this extended framework suitable causal hierarchies can indeed be established, and discuss the implications for the interplay between "superluminal" propagation and causality. The key distinguishing feature is whether the signal velocity is finite or infinite. Preserving even minimal notions of causality in the presence of infinite signal velocity requires the aether field to be both unique and hypersurface orthogonal, leading us to introduce the notion of global parabolicity. △ Less

Submitted 18 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 30 pages

Electromagnetic tests of horizonless rotating black hole mimickers

Authors: Anna Zulianello, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Stefano Liberati, Stefano Ansoldi

Abstract: The interest in the implications that astrophysical observations have for the understanding of the structure of black holes has grown since the first detection of gravitational waves. Many arguments that are put forward in order to constraint alternative black hole models rely on substantial assumptions such as perfect spherical symmetry, which implies absence of rotation. However, given that astr… ▽ More The interest in the implications that astrophysical observations have for the understanding of the structure of black holes has grown since the first detection of gravitational waves. Many arguments that are put forward in order to constraint alternative black hole models rely on substantial assumptions such as perfect spherical symmetry, which implies absence of rotation. However, given that astrophysical black holes will generally exhibit nonzero angular momentum, realistic constraints must take into account the effects of rotation. In this work we analyze the gravitational effect that rotation has on the emission from the surface of ultracompact objects, by studying how angular momentum affects the propagation of light rays. This allows us to evaluate the reliability of the constraints derived for supermassive black holes (more specifically, Sagittarius A* and M87*) assuming lack of rotation, as presented in [Astrophys. J. 701, 1357 (2009); Astrophys. J. 805, 179 (2015)]. We find that for rapidly spinning objects rotation can significantly affect the esca** probability of photon emitted from the surface of the object, with a significant increase at the equatorial regions and a decrease at the poles with respect to the non-rotating case. For not so rapidly spinning black hole candidates like Sagittarius A*, such modifications do not affect significantly the present constraints, which are nevertheless weaker than originally supposed due to the relativistic lensing here considered and additional phenomenological parameters that describe basic processes such as absorption. However, taking into account the angular dependence of the superficial emission of rapidly spinning black hole mimickers will be necessary for future studies of objects like e.g. M87*. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2021; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: V2: 25 pages, 14 figures, 8 tables. Additional discussions included following suggestions by referees, no physics changes. This version accepted for publication. V1: 23 pages, 13 figures, 8 tables

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 103, 064071 (2021)

Asymptotic horizon formation, spacetime stretching and causality

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Valentin Boyanov, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: In this work we analyse asymptotically flat, spherically symmetric spacetimes in which an event horizon is present without any trapped surfaces. We identify two types of such spacetimes, each related to the asymptotic behaviour (in time) of one of the two degrees of freedom of the metric. We study the causal structure of both types, showing that one almost always has a Cauchy horizon beyond which… ▽ More In this work we analyse asymptotically flat, spherically symmetric spacetimes in which an event horizon is present without any trapped surfaces. We identify two types of such spacetimes, each related to the asymptotic behaviour (in time) of one of the two degrees of freedom of the metric. We study the causal structure of both types, showing that one almost always has a Cauchy horizon beyond which it is extendable, while the other is inextendable but has two separate future null infinity regions on either side of the horizon. We also study what energy conditions can be satisfied by the matter around the horizon. Some of these spacetimes were first introduced in an earlier work in which semiclassical effects near black-hole horizons were analysed. Here we generalise this analysis to a larger family of geometries. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2020; v1 submitted 23 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 12 pages, 5 figures; v2: minor changes to match published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 102, 045001 (2020)

Geodesically complete black holes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: The 1965 Penrose singularity theorem demonstrates the utterly inevitable and unavoidable formation of spacetime singularities under physically reasonable assumptions, and it remains one of the main results in our understanding of black holes. It is standard lore that quantum gravitational effects will always tame these singularities in black hole interiors. However, the Penrose's theorem provides… ▽ More The 1965 Penrose singularity theorem demonstrates the utterly inevitable and unavoidable formation of spacetime singularities under physically reasonable assumptions, and it remains one of the main results in our understanding of black holes. It is standard lore that quantum gravitational effects will always tame these singularities in black hole interiors. However, the Penrose's theorem provides no clue as to the possible (non-singular) geometries that may be realized in theories beyond general relativity as the result of singularity regularization. In this paper we analyze this problem in spherically symmetric situations, being completely general otherwise, in particular regarding the dynamics of the gravitational and matter fields. Our main result is that, contrary to what one might expect, the set of regular geometries that arises is remarkably limited. We rederive geometries that have been analyzed before, but also uncover some new possibilities. Moreover, the complete catalogue of possibilities that we obtain allows us to draw the novel conclusion that there is a clear tradeoff between internal and external consistency: One has to choose between models that display internal inconsistencies, or models that include significant deviations with respect to general relativity, which should therefore be amenable to observational tests via multi-messenger astrophysics. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 22 pages, 16 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 084047 (2020)

Schwarzschild geometry counterpart in semiclassical gravity

Authors: Julio Arrechea, Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: We investigate the effects of vacuum polarization on vacuum static spherically-symmetric spacetimes. We start from the Polyakov approximation to the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a minimally coupled massless scalar field. This RSET is not regular at $r=0$, so we define a regularized version of the Polyakov RSET. Using this Regularized RSET, and under the previous symmetry assumptions… ▽ More We investigate the effects of vacuum polarization on vacuum static spherically-symmetric spacetimes. We start from the Polyakov approximation to the renormalized stress-energy tensor (RSET) of a minimally coupled massless scalar field. This RSET is not regular at $r=0$, so we define a regularized version of the Polyakov RSET. Using this Regularized RSET, and under the previous symmetry assumptions, we find all the solutions to the semiclassical field equations in vacuum. The resulting counterpart to the Schwarzschild classical geometry substitutes the presence of an event horizon by a wormhole throat that connects an external asymptotically flat region with an internal asymptotic region possessing a naked singularity: there are no semiclassical vacuum solutions with well-defined Cauchy surfaces. We also show that the Regularized Polyakov RSET allows for wormhole geometries of arbitrarily small throat radius. This analysis paves the way to future investigations of proper stellar configurations with an internal non-vacuum region. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2020; v1 submitted 8 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 22 pages, 4 figures, v2: references and minor changes added to match published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 064059 (2020)

Opening the Pandora's box at the core of black holes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: Unless the reality of spacetime singularities is assumed, astrophysical black holes cannot be identical to their mathematical counterparts obtained as solutions of the Einstein field equations. Mechanisms for singularity regularization would spark deviations with respect to the predictions of general relativity, although these deviations are generally presumed to be negligible for all practical pu… ▽ More Unless the reality of spacetime singularities is assumed, astrophysical black holes cannot be identical to their mathematical counterparts obtained as solutions of the Einstein field equations. Mechanisms for singularity regularization would spark deviations with respect to the predictions of general relativity, although these deviations are generally presumed to be negligible for all practical purposes. Nonetheless, the strength and nature of these deviations remain open questions, given the present uncertainties about the dynamics of quantum gravity. We present here a geometric classification of all spherically symmetric spacetimes that could result from singularity regularization, using a kinematic construction that is both exhaustive and oblivious to the dynamics of the fields involved. Due to the minimal geometric assumptions behind it, this classification encompasses virtually all modified gravity theories, and any theory of quantum gravity in which an effective description in terms of an effective metric is available. The first noteworthy conclusion of our analysis is that the number of independent classes of geometries that can be constructed is remarkably limited, with no more than a handful of qualitatively different possibilities. But our most surprising result is that this catalogue of possibilities clearly demonstrates that the degree of internal consistency and the strength of deviations with respect to general relativity are strongly, and positively, correlated. Hence, either quantum fluctuations of spacetime come to the rescue and solve these internal consistency issues, or singularity regularization will percolate to macroscopic (near-horizon) scales, radically changing our understanding of black holes and opening new opportunities to test quantum gravity. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Class. Quant. Grav. 37 (2020) 14, 145005

Amplitudes, Gravity and Classical Discontinuities

Authors: Daniel J. Burger, Raul Carballo-Rubio, Nathan Moynihan, Jeff Murugan, Amanda Weltman

Abstract: On-shell methods have revitalized interest in scattering amplitudes which have, in turn, shed some much needed light on the structure of quantum field theories. These developments have been warmly embraced by the particle physics community. Less so in the astrophyical and cosmological contexts. As part of an effort to address this imbalance, we illustrate these methods by revisiting two classic pr… ▽ More On-shell methods have revitalized interest in scattering amplitudes which have, in turn, shed some much needed light on the structure of quantum field theories. These developments have been warmly embraced by the particle physics community. Less so in the astrophyical and cosmological contexts. As part of an effort to address this imbalance, we illustrate these methods by revisiting two classic problems in gravity: gravitational light-bending and the vDVZ discontinuity of massive gravity. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 3 pages

Semiclassical gravity effects near horizon formation

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Valentin Boyanov, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: We study the magnitude of semiclassical gravity effects near the formation of a black-hole horizon in spherically-symmetric spacetimes. As a probe for these effects we use a quantised massless scalar field. Specifically, we calculate two quantities derived from it: the renormalised stress-energy tensor (a measure of how the field vacuum state affects the spacetime) and the effective temperature fu… ▽ More We study the magnitude of semiclassical gravity effects near the formation of a black-hole horizon in spherically-symmetric spacetimes. As a probe for these effects we use a quantised massless scalar field. Specifically, we calculate two quantities derived from it: the renormalised stress-energy tensor (a measure of how the field vacuum state affects the spacetime) and the effective temperature function (a generalisation of Hawking temperature related to the energy flux of the field vacuum). The subject of our study are spacetimes which contain a spherical distribution of matter and an empty exterior Schwarzschild region, separated by a surface which is moving in proximity to the Schwarzschild radius $r_{\rm s}=2M$, with $M$ the total mass. In particular, we analyse the consequences of three types of surface movement: an oscillation just above $r_{\rm s}$, a monotonous approach towards $r_{\rm s}$ in infinite time and a crossing of $r_{\rm s}$ at different velocities. For a collapsing matter distribution which follows the expected dynamical evolution in general relativity, we recover the standard picture of black-hole formation and its tenuous semiclassical effects. In more general dynamical regimes, allowing deviations from the standard classical evolution, we obtain a variety of different effects: from the emission of Hawking-like radiation without the formation of a horizon, to large values of the renormalised stress-energy tensor, related to the Boulware vacuum divergence in static spacetimes. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2019; v1 submitted 13 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 41 pages, 19 figures, v2: added one new figure and minor changes in text to match published version

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav., vol. 36, no. 16, 2019

Generalized no-hair theorems without horizons

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Stefano Liberati

Abstract: The simplicity of black holes, as characterized by no-hair theorems, is one of the most important mathematical results in the framework of general relativity. Are these theorems unique to black hole spacetimes, or do they also constrain the geometry around regions of spacetime with arbitrarily large (although finite) redshift? This paper presents a systematic study of this question and illustrates… ▽ More The simplicity of black holes, as characterized by no-hair theorems, is one of the most important mathematical results in the framework of general relativity. Are these theorems unique to black hole spacetimes, or do they also constrain the geometry around regions of spacetime with arbitrarily large (although finite) redshift? This paper presents a systematic study of this question and illustrates that no-hair theorems are not restricted to spacetimes with event horizons but are instead characteristic of spacetimes with deep enough gravitational wells, extending Israel's theorem to static spacetimes without event horizons that contain small deviations from spherical symmetry. Instead of a uniqueness result, we obtain a theorem that constrains the allowed deviations from the Schwarzschild metric and guarantees that these deviations decrease with the maximum redshift of the gravitational well in the external vacuum region. Israel's theorem is recovered continuously in the limit of infinite redshift. This result provides a first extension of no-hair theorems to ultracompact stars, wormholes, and other exotic objects, and paves the way for the construction of similar results for stationary spacetimes describing rotating objects. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2019; v1 submitted 18 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: v2: 18 pages, 1 figure, a couple of minor changes and typos fixed, as accepted for publication; v1: 17 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Class.Quant.Grav. 36 (2019) no.13, 13LT01

Taming higher-derivative interactions and bootstrap** gravity with soft theorems

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Nathan Moynihan

Abstract: On-shell constructibility is redefining our understanding of perturbative quantum field theory. The tree-level S-matrix of constructible theories is completely determined by a set of recurrence relations and a reduced number of scattering amplitudes. In this paper, we revisit the on-shell constructibility of gravitational theories making use of new results on soft theorems and recurrence relations… ▽ More On-shell constructibility is redefining our understanding of perturbative quantum field theory. The tree-level S-matrix of constructible theories is completely determined by a set of recurrence relations and a reduced number of scattering amplitudes. In this paper, we revisit the on-shell constructibility of gravitational theories making use of new results on soft theorems and recurrence relations. We show that using a double complex shift and an all-line soft deformation allows us to relax the technical conditions for constructibility, in order to include more general propagators and higher-derivative interactions that prevent using conventional Britto-Cachazo-Feng-Witten (BCFW) shifts. From this result we extract a set of criteria that guarantee that a given gravitational action has the same tree-level S-matrix in Minkowski spacetime as general relativity, which implies the equivalence at all orders in perturbation theory between these classical field theories on asymptotically flat spacetimes. As a corollary we deduce that the scattering amplitudes of general relativity and unimodular gravity are the same for an arbitrary number of external particles (as long as the S-matrix of the latter is unitary), thus extending previous works that were able to deal only with $n=4$ and $n=5$ amplitudes. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2019; v1 submitted 20 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: v2: published version in REVTeX style, minor changes and additional references after peer review, 29 pages (including references); v1: 26 pages (including references), REVTeX style

Journal ref: JCAP 10 (2019) 030

Topological Features of the Quantum Vacuum

Authors: Stephon Alexander, Raúl Carballo-Rubio

Abstract: A central aspect of the cosmological constant problem is to understand why vacuum energy does not gravitate. In order to account for this observation, while allowing for nontrivial dynamics of the quantum vacuum, we motivate a novel background independent theory of gravity. The theory is an extension of unimodular gravity that is described in geometric terms by means of a conformal (light-cone) st… ▽ More A central aspect of the cosmological constant problem is to understand why vacuum energy does not gravitate. In order to account for this observation, while allowing for nontrivial dynamics of the quantum vacuum, we motivate a novel background independent theory of gravity. The theory is an extension of unimodular gravity that is described in geometric terms by means of a conformal (light-cone) structure and differential forms of degree one and two. We show that the subset of the classical field equations describing the dynamics of matter degrees of freedom and the conformal structure of spacetime are equivalent to that of unimodular gravity. The sector with vanishing matter fields and flat conformal structure is governed by the field equations of BF theory and contains topological invariants that are influenced by quantum vacuum fluctuations. Perturbative deviations from this sector lead to classical solutions that necessarily display relatively small values of the cosmological constant with respect to the would-be contribution of quantum vacuum fluctuations. This feature that goes beyond general relativity (and unimodular gravity) offers an interpretation of the smallness of the currently observed cosmological constant. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 7 double-column pages + references, no figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 024058 (2020)

Phenomenological aspects of black holes beyond general relativity

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Matt Visser

Abstract: While singularities are inevitable in the classical theory of general relativity, it is commonly believed that they will not be present when quantum gravity effects are taken into account in a consistent framework. In particular, the structure of black holes should be modified in frameworks beyond general relativity that aim at regularizing singularities. Being agnostic on the nature of such theor… ▽ More While singularities are inevitable in the classical theory of general relativity, it is commonly believed that they will not be present when quantum gravity effects are taken into account in a consistent framework. In particular, the structure of black holes should be modified in frameworks beyond general relativity that aim at regularizing singularities. Being agnostic on the nature of such theory, in this paper we classify the possible alternatives to classical black holes and provide a minimal set of phenomenological parameters that describe their characteristic features. The introduction of these parameters allows us to study, in a largely model-independent manner and taking into account all the relevant physics, the phenomenology associated with these quantum-modified black holes. We perform an extensive analysis of different observational channels and obtain the most accurate characterization of the viable constraints that can be placed using current data. Aside from facilitating a critical revision of previous work, this analysis also allows us to highlight how different channels are capable of probing certain features but are oblivious to others, and pinpoint the theoretical aspects that should be addressed in order to strengthen these tests. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2018; v1 submitted 21 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: 21 double-column pages + references, 4 figures; V2: 21 double-column pages + updated references, some minor changes, 4 figures; V3: references added, matches published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 124009 (2018)

On the viability of regular black holes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati, Costantino Pacilio, Matt Visser

Abstract: The evaporation of black holes raises a number of conceptual issues, most of them related to the final stages of evaporation, where the interplay between the central singularity and Hawking radiation cannot be ignored. Regular models of black holes replace the central singularity with a nonsingular spacetime region, in which an effective classical geometric description is available. It has been ar… ▽ More The evaporation of black holes raises a number of conceptual issues, most of them related to the final stages of evaporation, where the interplay between the central singularity and Hawking radiation cannot be ignored. Regular models of black holes replace the central singularity with a nonsingular spacetime region, in which an effective classical geometric description is available. It has been argued that these models provide an effective, but complete, description of the evaporation of black holes at all times up to their eventual disappearance. However, here we point out that known models fail to be self-consistent: the regular core is exponentially unstable against perturbations with a finite timescale, while the evaporation time is infinite, therefore making the instability impossible to prevent. We also discuss how to overcome these difficulties, highlighting that this can be done only at the price of accepting that these models cannot be fully predictive regarding the final stages of evaporation. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 14 pages + refs. 3 figures

Journal ref: JHEP 2018 (2018) 23

The Unruh effect without thermality

Authors: Raul Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay, Eduardo Martin-Martinez, Jose de Ramon

Abstract: We show that uniformly accelerated detectors can display genuinely thermal features even if the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger (KMS) condition fails to hold. These features include satisfying thermal detailed balance and having a Planckian response identical to cases in which the KMS condition is satisfied. In this context, we discuss that satisfying the KMS condition for accelerated trajectories is just s… ▽ More We show that uniformly accelerated detectors can display genuinely thermal features even if the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger (KMS) condition fails to hold. These features include satisfying thermal detailed balance and having a Planckian response identical to cases in which the KMS condition is satisfied. In this context, we discuss that satisfying the KMS condition for accelerated trajectories is just sufficient but not necessary for the Unruh effect to be present in a given quantum field theory. Furthermore, we extract the necessary and sufficient conditions for the response function of an accelerated detector to be thermal in the infinitely adiabatic limit. This analysis provides new insights about the interplay between the KMS condition and the Unruh effect, and a solid framework in which the robustness of the Unruh effect against deformations of quantum field theories (perhaps Lorentz-violating) can be answered unambiguously. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: 6 pages. no figures. RevTeX 4.1

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 041601 (2019)

Observational evidence for the formation of trap** horizons in astrophysical black holes

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Pawan Kumar, Wenbin Lu

Abstract: Black holes in general relativity are characterized by their trap** horizon, a one-way membrane that can be crossed only inwards. The existence of trap** horizons in astrophysical black holes can be tested observationally using a reductio ad absurdum argument, replacing black holes by horizonless configurations with a physical surface and looking for inconsistencies with electromagnetic and gr… ▽ More Black holes in general relativity are characterized by their trap** horizon, a one-way membrane that can be crossed only inwards. The existence of trap** horizons in astrophysical black holes can be tested observationally using a reductio ad absurdum argument, replacing black holes by horizonless configurations with a physical surface and looking for inconsistencies with electromagnetic and gravitational wave observations. In this approach, the radius of the horizonless object is always larger than but arbitrarily close to the position where the horizon of a black hole of the same mass would be located. Upper bounds on the radius of these alternatives have been provided using electromagnetic observations (in optical/IR band) of astronomical sources at the center of galaxies, but lower bounds were lacking, leaving unconstrained huge regions of parameter space. We show here that lower bounds on the radius of horizonless objects that do not develop trap** horizons can be placed using observations of accreting systems. This result is model-independent and relies only on the local notion of causality dictated by the spacetime geometry around the horizonless object. These observational bounds reduce considerably the previously allowed parameter space, boosting the prospects of establishing the existence of trap** horizons using electromagnetic observations. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: 12 pages, 2 figures, 1 table

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 123012 (2018)

Minimally modified theories of gravity: a playground for testing the uniqueness of general relativity

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Stefano Liberati

Abstract: In a recent paper [1], it was introduced a new class of gravitational theories with two local degrees of freedom. The existence of these theories apparently challenges the distinctive role of general relativity as the unique non-linear theory of massless spin-2 particles. Here we perform a comprehensive analysis of these theories with the aim of (i) understanding whether or not these are actually… ▽ More In a recent paper [1], it was introduced a new class of gravitational theories with two local degrees of freedom. The existence of these theories apparently challenges the distinctive role of general relativity as the unique non-linear theory of massless spin-2 particles. Here we perform a comprehensive analysis of these theories with the aim of (i) understanding whether or not these are actually equivalent to general relativity, and (ii) finding the root of the variance in case these are not. We have found that a broad set of seemingly different theories actually pass all the possible tests of equivalence to general relativity (in vacuum) that we were able to devise, including the analysis of scattering amplitudes using on-shell techniques. These results are complemented with the observation that the only examples which are manifestly not equivalent to general relativity either do not contain gravitons in their spectrum, or are not guaranteed to include only two local degrees of freedom once radiative corrections are taken into account. Coupling to matter is also considered: we show that coupling these theories to matter in a consistent way is not as straightforward as one could expect. Minimal coupling, as well as the most straightforward non-minimal couplings, cannot be used. Therefore, before being able to address any issues in the presence of matter, it would be necessary to find a consistent (and in any case rather peculiar) coupling scheme. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2018; v1 submitted 7 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 34 pages, 5 figures. Changes in section 3.5 following the submission of an erratum. Main physical conclusions unchanged

Journal ref: JCAP 06(2018):026

Stellar equilibrium in semiclassical gravity

Authors: Raúl Carballo-Rubio

Abstract: The phenomenon of quantum vacuum polarization in the presence of a gravitational field is well understood and is expected to have a physical reality, but studies of its back-reaction on the dynamics of spacetime are practically non-existent outside the specific context of homogeneous cosmologies. Building on previous results of quantum field theory in curved spacetimes, in this letter we first der… ▽ More The phenomenon of quantum vacuum polarization in the presence of a gravitational field is well understood and is expected to have a physical reality, but studies of its back-reaction on the dynamics of spacetime are practically non-existent outside the specific context of homogeneous cosmologies. Building on previous results of quantum field theory in curved spacetimes, in this letter we first derive the semiclassical equations of stellar equilibrium in the s-wave Polyakov approximation. It is highlighted that incorporating the polarization of the quantum vacuum leads to a generalization of the classical Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff equation. Despite the complexity of the resulting field equations, it is possible to find exact solutions. Aside from being the first known exact solutions that describe relativistic stars including the non-perturbative backreaction of semiclassical effects, these are identified as a non-trivial combination of the black star and gravastar proposals. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2018; v1 submitted 16 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: V3: 14 pages, 1 figure. Some discussions and clarifications added in response to the referee's comments. No physics changes. This version accepted for publication in Physical Review Letters

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 061102 (2018)

Amplitudes for Astrophysicists: Known Knowns

Authors: Daniel J. Burger, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Nathan Moynihan, Jeff Murugan, Amanda Weltman

Abstract: The use of quantum field theory to understand astrophysical phenomena is not new. However, for the most part, the methods used are those that have been developed decades ago. The intervening years have seen some remarkable developments in computational quantum field theoretic tools. In particle physics, this technology has facilitated calculations that, even ten years ago would have seemed laughab… ▽ More The use of quantum field theory to understand astrophysical phenomena is not new. However, for the most part, the methods used are those that have been developed decades ago. The intervening years have seen some remarkable developments in computational quantum field theoretic tools. In particle physics, this technology has facilitated calculations that, even ten years ago would have seemed laughably difficult. It is remarkable, then, that most of these new techniques have remained firmly within the domain of high energy physics. We would like to change this. As alluded to in the title, this is the first in a series of papers aimed at showcasing the use of modern on-shell methods in the context of astrophysics and cosmology. In this first article, we use the old problem of the bending of light by a compact object as an anchor to pedagogically develop these new computational tools. Once developed, we then illustrate their power and utility with an application to the scattering of gravitational waves. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2019; v1 submitted 17 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 50 pages (sorry!) but lots of figures, some worked examples and a glossary. v2: now with feynman diagrams and added references v3: updated to match published version

Journal ref: General Relativity and Gravitation (2018) 50:156

Weyl relativity: A novel approach to Weyl's ideas

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: In this paper we revisit the motivation and construction of a unified theory of gravity and electromagnetism, following Weyl's insights regarding the appealing potential connection between the gauge invariance of electromagnetism and the conformal invariance of the gravitational field. We highlight that changing the local symmetry group of spacetime permits to construct a theory in which these two… ▽ More In this paper we revisit the motivation and construction of a unified theory of gravity and electromagnetism, following Weyl's insights regarding the appealing potential connection between the gauge invariance of electromagnetism and the conformal invariance of the gravitational field. We highlight that changing the local symmetry group of spacetime permits to construct a theory in which these two symmetries are combined into a putative gauge symmetry but with second-order field equations and non-trivial mass scales, unlike the original higher-order construction by Weyl. We prove that the gravitational field equations are equivalent to the (trace-free) Einstein field equations, ensuring their compatibility with known tests of general relativity. As a corollary, the effective cosmological constant is rendered radiatively stable due to Weyl invariance. A novel phenomenological consequence characteristic of this construction, potentially relevant for cosmological observations, is the existence of an energy scale below which effects associated with the non-integrability of spacetime distances, and an effective mass for the electromagnetic field, appear simultaneously (as dual manifestations of the use of Weyl connections). We explain how former criticisms against Weyl's ideas lose most of their power in its present reincarnation, which we refer to as Weyl relativity, as it represents a Weyl-invariant, unified description of both the Einstein and Maxwell field equations. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 34 pages, no figures

Journal ref: JCAP 1706 (2017) no.06, 014

Gravitational echoes from macroscopic quantum gravity effects

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: New theoretical approaches developed in the last years predict that macroscopic quantum gravity effects in black holes should lead to modifications of the gravitational wave signals expected in the framework of classical general relativity, with these modifications being characterized by the existence of dampened repetitions of the primary signal. Here we use the fact that non-perturbative correct… ▽ More New theoretical approaches developed in the last years predict that macroscopic quantum gravity effects in black holes should lead to modifications of the gravitational wave signals expected in the framework of classical general relativity, with these modifications being characterized by the existence of dampened repetitions of the primary signal. Here we use the fact that non-perturbative corrections to the near-horizon external geometry of black holes are necessary for these modifications to exist, in order to classify different proposals and paradigms with respect to this criterion and study in a neat and systematic way their phenomenology. Proposals that lead naturally to the existence of echoes in the late-time ringdown of gravitational wave signals from black hole mergers must share the replacement of black holes by horizonless configurations with a physical surface showing reflective properties in the relevant range of frequencies. On the other hand, proposals or paradigms that restrict quantum gravity effects on the external geometry to be perturbative, such as black hole complementarity or the closely related firewall proposal, do not display echoes. For the sake of completeness we exploit the interplay between the timescales associated with the formation of firewalls and the mechanism behind the existence of echoes in order to conclude that even unconventional distortions of the firewall concept (such as naked firewalls) do not lead to this phenomenon. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2017; v1 submitted 31 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: V1: 21 pages + references, 1 figure. V2: updated references

Journal ref: JHEP 1705 (2017) 054

From physical symmetries to emergent gauge symmetries

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Francesco Di Filippo, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: Gauge symmetries indicate redundancies in the description of the relevant degrees of freedom of a given field theory and restrict the nature of observable quantities. One of the problems faced by emergent theories of relativistic fields is to understand how gauge symmetries can show up in systems that contain no trace of these symmetries at a more fundamental level. In this paper we start a system… ▽ More Gauge symmetries indicate redundancies in the description of the relevant degrees of freedom of a given field theory and restrict the nature of observable quantities. One of the problems faced by emergent theories of relativistic fields is to understand how gauge symmetries can show up in systems that contain no trace of these symmetries at a more fundamental level. In this paper we start a systematic study aimed to establish a satisfactory mathematical and physical picture of this issue, dealing first with abelian field theories. We discuss how the trivialization, due to the decoupling and lack of excitation of some degrees of freedom, of the Noether currents associated with physical symmetries leads to emergent gauge symmetries in specific situations. An example of a relativistic field theory of a vector field is worked out in detail in order to make explicit how this mechanism works and to clarify the physics behind it. The interplay of these ideas with well-known results of importance to the emergent gravity program, such as the Weinberg-Witten theorem, are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Journal ref: JHEP 1610 (2016) 084

Exponential fading to white of black holes in quantum gravity

Authors: Carlos Barceló, Raúl Carballo-Rubio, Luis J. Garay

Abstract: Quantization of the gravitational field may allow the existence of a decay channel of black holes into white holes with an explicit time-reversal symmetry. The definition of a meaningful decay probability for this channel is studied in spherically symmetric situations. As a first nontrivial calculation, we present the functional integration over a set of geometries using a single-variable function… ▽ More Quantization of the gravitational field may allow the existence of a decay channel of black holes into white holes with an explicit time-reversal symmetry. The definition of a meaningful decay probability for this channel is studied in spherically symmetric situations. As a first nontrivial calculation, we present the functional integration over a set of geometries using a single-variable function to interpolate between black-hole and white-hole geometries in a bounded region of spacetime. This computation gives a finite result which depends only on the Schwarzschild mass and a parameter measuring the width of the interpolating region. The associated probability distribution displays an exponential decay law on the latter parameter, with a mean lifetime inversely proportional to the Schwarzschild mass. In physical terms this would imply that matter collapsing to a black hole from a finite radius bounces back elastically and instantaneously, with negligible time delay as measured by external observers. These results invite to reconsider the ultimate nature of astrophysical black holes, providing a possible mechanism for the formation of black stars instead of proper general relativistic black holes. The existence of both this decay channel and black stars can be tested in future observations of gravitational waves. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2017; v1 submitted 12 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: V1: 16 pages. V2: 18 pages. Discussion improved, no physics changes. References added. V3: 19 pages. Much more general treatment regarding the shape of boundaries, which strengthens our results (that otherwise remain the same). References added. V4: minor changes to match published version

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 34 105007 (2017)