-
Effect of Equation of State and Cutoff Density in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Simulations of the Moon-Forming Giant Impact
Authors:
Scott D. Hull,
Miki Nakajima,
Natsuki Hosono,
Robin M. Canup,
Rene Gassmöller
Abstract:
The amount of vapor in the impact-generated protolunar disk carries implications for the dynamics, devolatilization, and moderately volatile element (MVE) isotope fractionation during lunar formation. The equation of state (EoS) used in simulations of the giant impact is required to calculate the vapor mass fraction (VMF) of the modeled protolunar disk. Recently, a new version of M-ANEOS ("Stewart…
▽ More
The amount of vapor in the impact-generated protolunar disk carries implications for the dynamics, devolatilization, and moderately volatile element (MVE) isotope fractionation during lunar formation. The equation of state (EoS) used in simulations of the giant impact is required to calculate the vapor mass fraction (VMF) of the modeled protolunar disk. Recently, a new version of M-ANEOS ("Stewart M-ANEOS") was released with an improved treatment of heat capacity and expanded experimental Hugoniot. Here, we compare this new M-ANEOS version with a previous version ("N-SPH M-ANEOS") and assess the resulting differences in smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations. We find that Stewart M-ANEOS results in cooler disks with smaller values of VMF and results in differences in disk mass that are dependent on the initial impact angle. We also assess the implications of the minimum "cutoff" density ($ρ_{c}$), similar to a maximum smoothing length, that is set as a fast-computing alternative to an iteratively calculated smoothing length. We find that the low particle resolution of the disk typically results in $>40\%$ of disk particles falling to $ρ_c$, influencing the dynamical evolution and VMF of the disk. Our results show that choice of EoS, $ρ_{c}$, and particle resolution can cause the VMF and disk mass to vary by tens of percent. Moreover, small values of $ρ_{c}$ produce disks that are prone to numerical instability and artificial shocks. We recommend that future giant impact SPH studies review smoothing methods and ensure the thermodynamic stability of the disk over simulated time.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Orbits and Masses of the Small Satellites of Pluto
Authors:
Simon B. Porter,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
We present a new orbit and mass solution for the four small satellites of Pluto: Styx, Nix, Kerberos, and Hydra. We have reanalyzed all available observations of the Pluto system obtained by the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) from 2005 to 2019 with the ACS, WFPC2, and WFC3 instruments, as well as the New Horizons LORRI images taken on approach to Pluto in 2015. We have used this high precision astro…
▽ More
We present a new orbit and mass solution for the four small satellites of Pluto: Styx, Nix, Kerberos, and Hydra. We have reanalyzed all available observations of the Pluto system obtained by the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) from 2005 to 2019 with the ACS, WFPC2, and WFC3 instruments, as well as the New Horizons LORRI images taken on approach to Pluto in 2015. We have used this high precision astrometry to produce updated orbits and mass estimates with uncertainties for all four of the small satellites. We find that the masses of Nix and Hydra are smaller than previously published estimates, with a dynamical mass of 1.8$\pm$0.4$\times$10$^{-3}$ km$^3$/s$^2$ (2.7$\pm$0.6$\times$10$^{16}$ kg) for Nix and 2.0$\pm$0.2$\times$10$^{-3}$ km$^3$/s$^2$ (3.0$\pm$0.3$\times$10$^{16}$ kg) for Hydra. These masses are 60% and 63% of the mean estimates by Brozovic et al. (2015), although still consistent with their 1-sigma uncertainties, and correspond to densities of 1.0$\pm$0.2 g/cm$^3$ for Nix and 1.2$\pm$0.2 g/cm$^3$ for Hydra given the moon volume estimates from Porter et al (2021). Although these densities are consistent with a range of ice-rock compositions, depending on the unknown bulk porosity in the moon interiors, the moons' high albedos and predominantly icy surfaces are most easily explained if their interiors are ice-rich. The tiny masses of Kerberos and Sytx remain very poorly constrained; we find 1-$σ$ upper limits for the dynamical mass of Styx to be 3$\times$10$^{-5}$ km$^3$/s$^2$ (5$\times$10$^{14}$ kg) and for Kerberos 5$\times$10$^{-5}$ km$^3$/s$^2$ (8$\times$10$^{14}$ kg), consistent with densities of $<$2.1 g/cm$^3$ for both bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Co-accretion + giant impact origin of the Uranus system: Tilting Impact
Authors:
Raluca Rufu,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
The origin of the Uranian satellite system remains uncertain. The four major satellites have nearly circular, co-planar orbits and the ratio of the satellite system and planetary mass resembles Jupiter's satellite system, suggesting the Uranian system was similarly formed within a disk produced by gas co-accretion. However, Uranus is a retrograde rotator with a high obliquity. The satellites orbit…
▽ More
The origin of the Uranian satellite system remains uncertain. The four major satellites have nearly circular, co-planar orbits and the ratio of the satellite system and planetary mass resembles Jupiter's satellite system, suggesting the Uranian system was similarly formed within a disk produced by gas co-accretion. However, Uranus is a retrograde rotator with a high obliquity. The satellites orbit in its highly tilted equatorial plane in the same sense as the planet's retrograde rotation, a configuration that cannot be explained by co-accretion alone. In this work we investigate the first stages of the co-accretion + giant impact scenario proposed by Morbidelli et al. (2012) for the origin of the Uranian system. In this model, a satellite system formed by co-accretion is destabilized by a giant impact that tilts the planet. The primordial satellites collide and disrupt, creating an outer debris disk that can re-orient to the planet's new equatorial plane and accrete into Uranus' 4 major satellites. The needed reorientation out to distances comparable to outermost Oberon requires that the impact creates an inner disk with $\ge 1\%$ of Uranus' mass. We here simulate giant impacts that appropriately tilt the planet and leave the system with an angular momentum comparable to that of the current system. We find that such impacts do not produce inner debris disks massive enough to realign the outer debris disk to the post-impact equatorial plane. Although our results are inconsistent with the apparent requirements of a co-accretion + giant impact model, we suggest alternatives that merit further exploration.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
On the Origin of the Pluto System
Authors:
Robin M. Canup,
Kaitlin M. Kratter,
Marc Neveu
Abstract:
The goal of this chapter is to review hypotheses for the origin of the Pluto system in light of observational constraints that have been considerably refined over the 85-year interval between the discovery of Pluto and its exploration by spacecraft. We focus on the giant impact hypothesis currently understood as the likeliest origin for the Pluto-Charon binary, and devote particular attention to n…
▽ More
The goal of this chapter is to review hypotheses for the origin of the Pluto system in light of observational constraints that have been considerably refined over the 85-year interval between the discovery of Pluto and its exploration by spacecraft. We focus on the giant impact hypothesis currently understood as the likeliest origin for the Pluto-Charon binary, and devote particular attention to new models of planet formation and migration in the outer solar system. We discuss the origins conundrum posed by the system's four small moons. We also elaborate on the implications of these scenarios for the dynamical environment of the early transneptunian disk, the likelihood of finding a Pluto collisional family, and the origin of other binary systems in the Kuiper belt. Finally, we highlight outstanding open issues regarding the origins of the Pluto system and suggest areas of future progress.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Origin of the Moon
Authors:
Robin M. Canup,
Kevin Righter,
Nicolas Dauphas,
Kaveh Pahlevan,
Matija Ćuk,
Simon J. Lock,
Sarah T. Stewart,
Julien Salmon,
Raluca Rufu,
Miki Nakajima,
Tomáš Magna
Abstract:
The Earth-Moon system is unusual in several respects. The Moon is roughly 1/4 the radius of the Earth - a larger satellite-to-planet size ratio than all known satellites other than Pluto's Charon. The Moon has a tiny core, perhaps with only ~1% of its mass, in contrast to Earth whose core contains nearly 30% of its mass. The Earth-Moon system has a high total angular momentum, implying a rapidly s…
▽ More
The Earth-Moon system is unusual in several respects. The Moon is roughly 1/4 the radius of the Earth - a larger satellite-to-planet size ratio than all known satellites other than Pluto's Charon. The Moon has a tiny core, perhaps with only ~1% of its mass, in contrast to Earth whose core contains nearly 30% of its mass. The Earth-Moon system has a high total angular momentum, implying a rapidly spinning Earth when the Moon formed. In addition, the early Moon was hot and at least partially molten with a deep magma ocean. Identification of a model for lunar origin that can satisfactorily explain all of these features has been the focus of decades of research.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Tidal Evolution of the Evection Resonance/Quasi-Resonance and the Angular Momentum of the Earth-Moon System
Authors:
Raluca Rufu,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
Forming the Moon by a high-angular momentum impact may explain the Earth-Moon isotopic similarities, however, the post-impact angular momentum needs to be reduced by a factor of 2 or more to the current value (1 L_EM) after the Moon forms. Capture into the evection resonance, occurring when the lunar perigee precession period equals one year, could remove the angular momentum excess. However the a…
▽ More
Forming the Moon by a high-angular momentum impact may explain the Earth-Moon isotopic similarities, however, the post-impact angular momentum needs to be reduced by a factor of 2 or more to the current value (1 L_EM) after the Moon forms. Capture into the evection resonance, occurring when the lunar perigee precession period equals one year, could remove the angular momentum excess. However the appropriate angular momentum removal appears sensitive to the tidal model and chosen tidal parameters. In this work, we use a constant-time delay tidal model to explore the Moon's orbital evolution through evection. We find that exit from formal evection occurs early and that subsequently, the Moon enters a quasi-resonance regime, in which evection still regulates the lunar eccentricity even though the resonance angle is no longer librating. Although not in resonance proper, during quasi-resonance angular momentum is continuously removed from the Earth-Moon system and transferred to Earth's heliocentric orbit. The final angular momentum, set by the timing of quasi-resonance escape, is a function of the ratio of tidal strength in the Moon and Earth and the absolute rate of tidal dissipation in the Earth. We consider a physically-motivated model for tidal dissipation in the Earth as the mantle cools from a molten to a partially molten state. We find that as the mantle solidifies, increased terrestrial dissipation drives the Moon out of quasi-resonance. For post-impact systems that contain >2 L_EM, final angular momentum values after quasi-resonance escape remain significantly higher than the current Earth-Moon value.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Analytical Model for the Tidal Evolution of the Evection Resonance and the Timing of Resonance Escape
Authors:
William R. Ward,
Robin M. Canup,
Raluca Rufu
Abstract:
A high-angular momentum giant impact with the Earth can produce a Moon with a silicate isotopic composition nearly identical to that of Earth's mantle, consistent with observations of terrestrial and lunar rocks. However, such an event requires subsequent angular momentum removal for consistency with the current Earth-Moon system. The early Moon may have been captured into the evection resonance,…
▽ More
A high-angular momentum giant impact with the Earth can produce a Moon with a silicate isotopic composition nearly identical to that of Earth's mantle, consistent with observations of terrestrial and lunar rocks. However, such an event requires subsequent angular momentum removal for consistency with the current Earth-Moon system. The early Moon may have been captured into the evection resonance, occurring when the lunar perigee precession period equals one year. It has been proposed that after a high-angular momentum giant impact, evection removed the angular momentum excess from the Earth-Moon pair and transferred it to Earth's orbit about the Sun. However, prior N-body integrations suggest this result depends on the tidal model and chosen tidal parameters. Here we examine the Moon's encounter with evection using a complementary analytic description and the Mignard tidal model. While the Moon is in resonance the lunar longitude of perigee librates, and if tidal evolution excites the libration amplitude sufficiently, escape from resonance occurs. The angular momentum drain produced by formal evection depends on how long the resonance is maintained. We estimate that resonant escape occurs early, leading to only a small reduction (~few to 10%) in the Earth-Moon system angular momentum. Moon formation from a high-angular momentum impact would then require other angular momentum removal mechanisms beyond standard libration in evection, as have been suggested previously.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
HydroSyMBA: a 1D hydrocode coupled with an N-body symplectic integrator
Authors:
Julien Salmon,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
The numerical modeling of co-existing circumplanetary disks/rings and satellites is particularly challenging because each part of the system requires a very different approach. Disks are generally well represented by a fluid-like dense medium, whose evolution can be calculated by a hydrocode. On the other hand, the orbital evolution of satellites is generally performed using N-body integrators. We…
▽ More
The numerical modeling of co-existing circumplanetary disks/rings and satellites is particularly challenging because each part of the system requires a very different approach. Disks are generally well represented by a fluid-like dense medium, whose evolution can be calculated by a hydrocode. On the other hand, the orbital evolution of satellites is generally performed using N-body integrators. We have developed a new numerical model that combines a 1-dimensional hydrocode with the N-body integrator SyMBA. The disk evolves due to its viscosity, and resonant torques from satellites. The latter is applied to the satellites as an additional "kick" to their accelerations. The integrator also includes the ability to spawn new moonlets at the disk's outer edge if the latter expands beyond a material-dependent Roche limit, as well as the effects of tidal dissipation in the planet and/or the satellite on the satellite orbits. The resulting integrator allows one to accurately model the evolution of an inner circumplanetary disk, and the formation of satellites by accumulation of disk material, all within a single self-consistent framework. Potential applications include the formation of Earth's Moon, the evolution of the inner Saturn system, the martian and uranian moons, and compact exoplanetary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Triton's Evolution with a Primordial Neptunian Satellite System
Authors:
Raluca Rufu,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
The Neptunian satellite system is unusual. The major satellites of Jupiter, Saturn, and Uranus are all in prograde, low-inclination orbits. Neptune on the other hand, has the fewest satellites, and most of the system's mass is within one irregular satellite, Triton. Triton was most likely captured by Neptune and destroyed the primordial regular satellite system. We investigate the interactions bet…
▽ More
The Neptunian satellite system is unusual. The major satellites of Jupiter, Saturn, and Uranus are all in prograde, low-inclination orbits. Neptune on the other hand, has the fewest satellites, and most of the system's mass is within one irregular satellite, Triton. Triton was most likely captured by Neptune and destroyed the primordial regular satellite system. We investigate the interactions between a newly captured Triton and a prior Neptunian satellite system. We find that a prior satellite system with a mass ratio similar to the Uranian system or smaller has a substantial likelihood of reproducing the current Neptunian system, while a more massive system has a low probability of leading to the current configuration. Moreover, Triton's interaction with a prior satellite system may offer a mechanism to decrease its high initial semimajor axis fast enough to preserve small irregular satellites (Nereid-like) that might otherwise be lost during a prolonged Triton circularization via tides alone.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
The Origin of Planetary Ring Systems
Authors:
S. Charnoz,
R. M. Canup,
A. Crida,
L. Dones
Abstract:
This chapter of the book Planetary Ring Systems addresses the origin of planetary rings, one of the least understood processes related to planet formation and evolution. Whereas rings seem ubiquitous around giant planets, their great diversity of mass, structure and composition is a challenge for any formation scenario. Recent advances in our understanding of ring and satellite formation and destr…
▽ More
This chapter of the book Planetary Ring Systems addresses the origin of planetary rings, one of the least understood processes related to planet formation and evolution. Whereas rings seem ubiquitous around giant planets, their great diversity of mass, structure and composition is a challenge for any formation scenario. Recent advances in our understanding of ring and satellite formation and destruction suggest that these processes are interconnected, so that rings and satellites may be two aspects of the same geological system. However, no single theory seems able to explain the origin of the different planetary rings known in our Solar System, and it now seems evident that rings may result from a variety of processes like giant collisions, tidal strip** of comets or satellites, as well as planet formation itself.
In order to build any theory of ring formation it is important to specify physical processes that affect the long-term evolution of rings, as well as to describe the different observations that any ring formation model should explain. This is the topic of section 2. In section 3, we focus our attention on Saturn's rings and their main properties, and then discuss the pros and cons of a series of ring formation models. We also discuss the link between rings and satellites. In section 4, we extend the discussion to the other giant planets (Jupiter, Uranus, and Neptune). Section 5 is devoted to new types of rings -- the recent discovery of rings orbiting small outer Solar System bodies (Centaurs), and the possible rings around extrasolar planets. In section 6, we conclude and try to identify critical observations and theoretical advances needed to better understand the origin of rings and their significance in the global evolution of planets.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Accretion of Saturn's Inner Mid-sized Moons from a Massive Primordial Ice Ring
Authors:
Julien Salmon,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
Saturn's rings are rock-poor, containing 90%-95% ice by mass. As a group, Saturn's moons interior to and including Tethys are also about 90% ice. Tethys itself contains <6% rock by mass, in contrast to its similar-mass outer neighbor Dione, which contains >40% rock. Here we simulate the evolution of a massive primordial ice-rich ring and the production of satellites as ring material spreads beyond…
▽ More
Saturn's rings are rock-poor, containing 90%-95% ice by mass. As a group, Saturn's moons interior to and including Tethys are also about 90% ice. Tethys itself contains <6% rock by mass, in contrast to its similar-mass outer neighbor Dione, which contains >40% rock. Here we simulate the evolution of a massive primordial ice-rich ring and the production of satellites as ring material spreads beyond the Roche limit. We describe the Roche-interior ring with an analytic model, and use an N-body code to describe material beyond the Roche limit. We track the accretion and interactions of spawned satellites, including tidal interaction with the planet, assuming a tidal dissipation factor for Saturn of $Q~10^4$. We find that ring torques and capture of moons into mutual resonances produce a system of ice-rich inner moons that extends outward to approximately Tethys's orbit in $10^9$ years, even with relatively slow orbital expansion due to tides. The resulting mass and semimajor axis distribution of spawned moons resembles that of Mimas, Enceladus, and Tethys. We estimate the mass of rock delivered to the moons by external cometary impactors during a late heavy bombardment. We find that the inner moons receive a mass in rock comparable to their current total rock content, while Dione and Rhea receive an order-of-magnitude less rock than their current rock content. This suggests that external ontamination may have been the primary source of rock in the inner moons, and that Dione and Rhea formed from much more rock-rich source material. Reproducing the distribution of rock among the current inner moons is challenging, and appears to require large impactors stochasticity and/or the presence of some rock in the initial ring.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Accretion of the Moon from non-canonical disks
Authors:
Julien Salmon,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
Impacts that leave the Earth-Moon system with a large excess in angular momentum have recently been advocated as a means of generating a protolunar disc with a composition that is nearly identical to that of the Earth's mantle. We here investigate the accretion of the Moon from discs generated by such "non-canonical" impacts, which are typically more compact than discs produced by canonical impact…
▽ More
Impacts that leave the Earth-Moon system with a large excess in angular momentum have recently been advocated as a means of generating a protolunar disc with a composition that is nearly identical to that of the Earth's mantle. We here investigate the accretion of the Moon from discs generated by such "non-canonical" impacts, which are typically more compact than discs produced by canonical impacts and have a higher fraction of their mass initially located inside the Roche limit. Our model predicts a similar overall accretional history for both canonical and non-canonical discs, with the Moon forming in three consecutive steps over hundreds of years. However, we find that, to yield a lunar-mass Moon, the more compact non-canonical discs must initially be more massive than implied by prior estimates, and only a few of the discs produced by impact simulations to date appear to meet this condition. Non-canonical impacts require that capture of the Moon into the evection resonance with the Sun reduced the Earth-Moon angular momentum by a factor of 2 or more. We find that the Moon's semimajor axis at the end of its accretion is approximately $7R_\oplus$, which is comparable to the location of the evection resonance for a post-impact Earth with a 2.5 h rotation period in the absence of a disc. Thus, the dynamics of the Moon's assembly may directly affect its ability to be captured into the resonance.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Lunar accretion from a Roche-interior fluid disk
Authors:
Julien Salmon,
Robin M. Canup
Abstract:
We use a hybrid numerical approach to simulate the formation of the Moon from an impact-generated disk, consisting of a fluid model for the disk inside the Roche limit and an N-body code to describe accretion outside the Roche limit. As the inner disk spreads due to a thermally regulated viscosity, material is delivered across the Roche limit and accretes into moonlets that are added to the N-body…
▽ More
We use a hybrid numerical approach to simulate the formation of the Moon from an impact-generated disk, consisting of a fluid model for the disk inside the Roche limit and an N-body code to describe accretion outside the Roche limit. As the inner disk spreads due to a thermally regulated viscosity, material is delivered across the Roche limit and accretes into moonlets that are added to the N-body simulation. Contrary to an accretion timescale of a few months obtained with prior pure N-body codes, here the final stage of the Moon's growth is controlled by the slow spreading of the inner disk, resulting in a total lunar accretion timescale of ~10^2 years. It has been proposed that the inner disk may compositionally equilibrate with the Earth through diffusive mixing, which offers a potential explanation for the identical oxygen isotope compositions of the Earth and Moon. However, the mass fraction of the final Moon that is derived from the inner disk is limited by resonant torques between the disk and exterior growing moons. For initial disks containing < 2.5 lunar masses (ML), we find that a final Moon with mass > 0.8ML contains < 60% material derived from the inner disk, with this material preferentially delivered to the Moon at the end of its accretion.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Origin of Europa and the Galilean Satellites
Authors:
Robin M. Canup,
William R. Ward
Abstract:
Europa is believed to have formed near the very end of Jupiter's own accretion, within a circumplanetary disk of gas and solid particles. We review the formation of the Galilean satellites in the context of current constraints and understanding of giant planet formation, focusing on recent models of satellite growth within a circumjovian accretion disk produced during the final stages of gas inf…
▽ More
Europa is believed to have formed near the very end of Jupiter's own accretion, within a circumplanetary disk of gas and solid particles. We review the formation of the Galilean satellites in the context of current constraints and understanding of giant planet formation, focusing on recent models of satellite growth within a circumjovian accretion disk produced during the final stages of gas inflow to Jupiter. In such a disk, the Galilean satellites would have accreted slowly, in more than 10^5 yr, and in a low pressure, low gas density environment. Gravitational interactions between the satellites and the gas disk lead to inward orbital migration and loss of satellites to Jupiter. Such effects tend to select for a maximum satellite mass and a common total satellite system mass compared to the planet's mass. One implication is that multiple satellite systems may have formed and been lost during the final stages of Jupiter's growth, with the Galilean satellites being the last generation that survived as gas inflow to Jupiter ended. We conclude by discussing open issues and implications for Europa's conditions of formation.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
