-
GN-z11: witnessing the formation of second generation stars and an accreting massive black hole in a massive star cluster
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
E. Vesperini,
F. Calura,
P. Ventura,
A. D'Ercole,
V. Caloi,
A. F. Marino,
A. P. Milone,
F. Dell'Agli,
M. Tailo
Abstract:
We explore the possibility that the N-rich young proto-galaxy GN-z11 recently observed at z=10.6 by the James Webb Space Telescope is the result of the formation of second generation stars from pristine gas and Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) ejecta in a massive globular cluster or nuclear star cluster. We show that a second generation forming out of gas polluted by the ejecta of massive AGB stars a…
▽ More
We explore the possibility that the N-rich young proto-galaxy GN-z11 recently observed at z=10.6 by the James Webb Space Telescope is the result of the formation of second generation stars from pristine gas and Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) ejecta in a massive globular cluster or nuclear star cluster. We show that a second generation forming out of gas polluted by the ejecta of massive AGB stars and mixed with gas having a standard composition accounts for the unusually large N/O in the GN-z11 spectrum. The timing of the evolution of massive (4-7.5M$_{\odot}$) AGBs also provides a favourable environment for the growth of a central stellar mass black hole to the Active Galactic Nucleus stage observed in GN-z11. According to our model the progenitor system was born at an age of the Universe of $\simeq 260 - 380$Myr, well within the pre-reionization epoch.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
HST observations of the globular cluster NGC 6402 (M14) and its peculiar multiple populations
Authors:
Francesca D'Antona,
Antonino P. Milone,
Christian I. Johnson,
Marco Tailo,
Enrico Vesperini,
Vittoria Caloi,
Paolo Ventura,
Anna Fabiola Marino,
Flavia Dell'Agli
Abstract:
We present Hubble Space Telescope (HST) photometric results for NGC 6402, a highly reddened very luminous Galactic globular cluster (GC). Recent spectroscopic observations of its red giant stars have shown a quite peculiar behavior in the chemistry of its multiple populations. These results have prompted UV and optical HST observations aimed at obtaining the cluster's "Chromosome map" (ChM), an ef…
▽ More
We present Hubble Space Telescope (HST) photometric results for NGC 6402, a highly reddened very luminous Galactic globular cluster (GC). Recent spectroscopic observations of its red giant stars have shown a quite peculiar behavior in the chemistry of its multiple populations. These results have prompted UV and optical HST observations aimed at obtaining the cluster's "Chromosome map" (ChM), an efficient tool to classify GCs and characterize their multiple populations. We find that the discontinuity in the abundance distributions of O, Mg, Al and Na inferred from spectroscopy is more nuanced in the ChM, which is mostly sensitive to nitrogen. Nevertheless, photometry in optical bands reveals a double main sequence, indicating a discontinuity in the helium content of the populations. The population with the largest chemical anomalies (extreme) peaks at a helium mass fraction Y~0.31. This helium content is consistent with results from the analysis of the distribution of horizontal-branch stars and the spectrophotometry of the red giants. The ChM and the color magnitude diagrams are compared with those in NGC 2808, a prototype GC with helium abundances up to Y > 0.35, and both confirm that NGC 6402 does not host stellar populations with such extreme helium content. Further, the ChM reveals the presence of a group of stars with larger metallicity, thus indicating that NGC 6402 is a Type II cluster. The modalities of formation of the multiple populations in NGC 6402 are briefly surveyed, with main attention on the Asymptotic Giant Branch and Supermassive star models, and on possible clusters' merging.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Mass loss law for red giant stars in simple population globular clusters
Authors:
M. Tailo,
A. P. Milone,
E. P. Lagioia,
F. D'Antona,
S. Jang,
E. Vesperini,
A. F. Marino,
P. Ventura,
V. Caloi,
M. Carlos,
G. Cordoni,
E. Dondoglio,
A. Mohandasan,
J. E. Nastasio,
M. V. Legnardi
Abstract:
The amount of mass lost by stars during the red-giant branch (RGB) phase is one of the main parameters to understand and correctly model the late stages of stellar evolution. Nevertheless, a fully-comprehensive knowledge of the RGB mass loss is still missing.
Galactic Globular Clusters (GCs) are ideal targets to derive empirical formulations of mass loss, but the presence of multiple populations…
▽ More
The amount of mass lost by stars during the red-giant branch (RGB) phase is one of the main parameters to understand and correctly model the late stages of stellar evolution. Nevertheless, a fully-comprehensive knowledge of the RGB mass loss is still missing.
Galactic Globular Clusters (GCs) are ideal targets to derive empirical formulations of mass loss, but the presence of multiple populations with different chemical compositions has been a major challenge to constrain stellar masses and RGB mass losses. Recent work has disentangled the distinct stellar populations along the RGB and the horizontal branch (HB) of 46 GCs, thus providing the possibility to estimate the RGB mass loss of each stellar population. The mass losses inferred for the stellar populations with pristine chemical composition (called first-generation or 1G stars) tightly correlate with cluster metallicity. This finding allows us to derive an empirical RGB mass-loss law for 1G stars.
In this paper we investigate seven GCs with no evidence of multiple populations and derive the RGB mass loss by means of high-precision {\it Hubble-Space Telescope} photometry and accurate synthetic photometry.
We find a cluster-to-cluster variation in the mass loss ranging from $\sim$0.1 to $\sim$0.3 $M_{\odot}$.
The RGB mass loss of simple-population GCs correlates with the metallicity of the host cluster. The discovery that simple-population GCs and 1G stars of multiple population GCs follow similar mass-loss vs. metallicity relations suggests that the resulting mass-loss law is a standard outcome of stellar evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Mass loss along the red giant branch in 46 Globular Clusters and their multiple populations
Authors:
M. Tailo,
A. P. Milone,
E. P. Lagioia,
F. D'Antona,
A. F. Marino,
E. Vesperini,
V. Caloi,
P. Ventura,
E. Dondoglio,
G. Cordoni
Abstract:
The location of Galactic Globular Clusters' (GC) stars on the horizontal branch (HB) should mainly depend on GC metallicity, the "first parameter", but it is actually the result of complex interactions between the red giant branch (RGB) mass loss, the coexistence of multiple stellar populations with different helium content, and the presence of a "second parameter" which produces dramatic differen…
▽ More
The location of Galactic Globular Clusters' (GC) stars on the horizontal branch (HB) should mainly depend on GC metallicity, the "first parameter", but it is actually the result of complex interactions between the red giant branch (RGB) mass loss, the coexistence of multiple stellar populations with different helium content, and the presence of a "second parameter" which produces dramatic differences in HB morphology of GCs of similar metallicity and ages (like the pair M3--M13). In this work, we combine the entire dataset from the Hubble Space Telescope Treasury survey and stellar evolutionary models, to analyse the HBs of 46 GCs. For the first time in a large sample of GCs, we generate population synthesis models, where the helium abundances for the first and the "extreme" second generations are constrained using independent measurements based on RGB stars. The main results are: 1) the mass loss of first generation stars is tightly correlated to cluster metallicity. 2) the location of helium enriched stars on the HB is reproduced only by adopting a higher RGB mass loss than for the first generation. The difference in mass loss correlates with helium enhancement and cluster mass. 3) A model of "pre-main sequence disc early loss", previously developed by the authors, explains such a mass loss increase and is consistent with the findings of multiple-population formation models predicting that populations more enhanced in helium tend to form with higher stellar densities and concentrations. 4) Helium-enhancement and mass-loss both contribute to the second parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Is helium the key parameter in the extended color spread of the first generation stars in M3?
Authors:
M. Tailo,
F. D'Antona,
V. Caloi,
A. P. Milone,
A. F. Marino,
E. Lagioia,
G. Cordoni
Abstract:
The study of the "chromosome maps" of Galactic Globular Clusters has shown that the stars identified as `first generation' often define an extended sequence in the $m_{F275W}-m_{F814W}$ colour, whose straightforward interpretation, by comparison with synthetic spectra, is that they are inhomogeneous in helium content.
The cluster M 3 (NGC 5272) is one of the most prominent example of this phenom…
▽ More
The study of the "chromosome maps" of Galactic Globular Clusters has shown that the stars identified as `first generation' often define an extended sequence in the $m_{F275W}-m_{F814W}$ colour, whose straightforward interpretation, by comparison with synthetic spectra, is that they are inhomogeneous in helium content.
The cluster M 3 (NGC 5272) is one of the most prominent example of this phenomenon, since its first generation is distributed on an extended colour range, formally corresponding to a large helium enhancement ($ \sim 0.1$). It is necessary to ask whether the bulk of photometric observations available for this cluster supports or falsifies this interpretation. For this purpose, we examine the horizontal branch morphology, the period and magnitude distributions of the RR Lyrae variables, and the main sequence colour distribution. Simulating the first generation stars with such internal variation of helium content we can not meet all the observational constraints at the same time, concluding that the origin of the first generation colour spread is still without a straightforward explanation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
The mosaic multiple stellar populations in $ω$ Centauri : the Horizontal Branch and the Main Sequence
Authors:
Marco Tailo,
Marcella Di Criscienzo,
Francesca D'Antona,
Vittoria Caloi,
Paolo Ventura
Abstract:
We interpret the stellar population of $ω$ Centauri by means of a population synthesis analysis, following the most recent observational guidelines for input metallicities, helium and [(C+N+O)/Fe] contents. We deal at the same time with the main sequences, sub-giant and horizontal branch data. The reproduction of the observed colour magnitude features is very satisfying and bears interesting hints…
▽ More
We interpret the stellar population of $ω$ Centauri by means of a population synthesis analysis, following the most recent observational guidelines for input metallicities, helium and [(C+N+O)/Fe] contents. We deal at the same time with the main sequences, sub-giant and horizontal branch data. The reproduction of the observed colour magnitude features is very satisfying and bears interesting hints concerning the evolutionary history of this peculiar stellar ensemble. Our main results are: 1) no significant spread in age is required to fit the colour-magnitude diagram. Indeed we can use coeval isochrones for the synthetic populations, and we estimate that the ages fall within a $\sim 0.5$ Gyr time interval; in particular the most metal rich population can be coeval (in the above meaning) with the others, if its stars are very helium--rich (Y$\sim$0.37) and with the observed CNO enhancement ([(C+N+O)/Fe] = + 0.7); 2) a satisfactory fit of the whole HB is obtained, consistent with the choice of the populations providing a good reproduction of the main sequence and sub giant data. 3) the split in magnitude observed in the red HB is well reproduced assuming the presence of two stellar populations in the two different sequences observed: a metal poor population made of stars evolving from the blue side (luminous branch) and a metal richer one whose stars are in a stage closer to the zero age HB (dimmer branch). This modelization also fits satisfactorily the period and the [Fe/H] distribution of the RR Lyrae stars.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Rapidly rotating second-generation progenitors for the blue hook stars of ω Cen
Authors:
Marco Tailo,
Francesca D'Antona,
Enrico Vesperini,
Marcella Di Criscienzo,
Paolo Ventura,
Antonino Milone,
Andrea Bellini,
Aaron Dotter,
Thibaut Decressin,
Annibale D'Ercole,
Vittoria Caloi,
Roberto Capuzzo Dolcetta
Abstract:
Horizontal Branch stars belong to an advanced stage in the evolution of the oldest stellar galactic population, occurring either as field halo stars or grouped in globular clusters. The discovery of multiple populations in these clusters, that were previously believed to have single populations gave rise to the currently accepted theory that the hottest horizontal branch members (the blue hook sta…
▽ More
Horizontal Branch stars belong to an advanced stage in the evolution of the oldest stellar galactic population, occurring either as field halo stars or grouped in globular clusters. The discovery of multiple populations in these clusters, that were previously believed to have single populations gave rise to the currently accepted theory that the hottest horizontal branch members (the blue hook stars, which had late helium-core flash ignition, followed by deep mixing) are the progeny of a helium-rich "second generation" of stars. It is not known why such a supposedly rare event (a late flash followed by mixing) is so common that the blue hook of ω Cen contains \sim 30% of horizontal branch stars 10 , or why the blue hook luminosity range in this massive cluster cannot be reproduced by models. Here we report that the presence of helium core masses up to \sim 0.04 solar masses larger than the core mass resulting from evolution is required to solve the luminosity range problem. We model this by taking into account the dispersion in rotation rates achieved by the progenitors, whose premain sequence accretion disc suffered an early disruption in the dense environment of the cluster's central regions where second-generation stars form. Rotation may also account for frequent late-flash-mixing events in massive globular clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
The puzzle of metallicity and multiple stellar populations in the Globular Clusters in Fornax
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
V. Caloi,
A. D'Ercole,
M. Tailo,
E. Vesperini,
P. Ventura,
M. Di Criscienzo
Abstract:
We examine the photometric data for Fornax clusters, focussing our attention on their horizontal branch color distribution and, when available, on the RR Lyr variables fraction and period distribution. Based on our understanding of the HB morphology in terms of varying helium content in the context of multiple stellar generations, we show that clusters F2, F3 and F5 must contain substantial fracti…
▽ More
We examine the photometric data for Fornax clusters, focussing our attention on their horizontal branch color distribution and, when available, on the RR Lyr variables fraction and period distribution. Based on our understanding of the HB morphology in terms of varying helium content in the context of multiple stellar generations, we show that clusters F2, F3 and F5 must contain substantial fractions of second generation stars (~54-65%). On the basis of a simple chemical evolution model we show that the helium distribution in these clusters can be reproduced by models with cluster initial masses ranging from values equal to ~4 to ~10 times larger than the current masses. Models with a very short second generation star formation episode can also reproduce the observed helium distribution but require larger initial masses up to about twenty times the current mass. While the lower limit of this range of possible initial GC masses is consistent with those suggested by the observations of the low metallicity field stars, we also discuss the possibility that the metallicity scale of field stars (based on CaII triplet spectroscopy) and the metallicities derived for the clusters in Fornax may not be consistent with each other. The reproduction of the HB morphology in F2,F3,F5 requires two interesting hypotheses: 1) the first generation HB stars lie all at "red" colours. According to this interpretation, the low metallicity stars in the field of Fornax, populating the HB at colours bluer than the blue side ((V-I)o<=0.3 or (B-V)o<=0.2) of the RR Lyrs, should be second generation stars born in the clusters;a preliminary analysis of available colour surveys of Fornax field provides a fraction ~20% of blue HB stars, in the low metallicity range; 2) the mass loss from individual second generation red giants is a few percent of a solar mass larger than the mass loss from first generation stars.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2013; v1 submitted 14 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
In search of massive single-population Globular Clusters
Authors:
V. Caloi,
F. D'Antona
Abstract:
Most Globular Clusters so far examined host (at least) two stellar populations. This feature requires a two--step process, in which the nuclearly processed matter from a first generation (FG) of stars gives birth to a second generation (SG) bearing the fingerprint of a fully CNO-cycled matter. Since the present population of most globular clusters is made up largely of SG stars, a substantial frac…
▽ More
Most Globular Clusters so far examined host (at least) two stellar populations. This feature requires a two--step process, in which the nuclearly processed matter from a first generation (FG) of stars gives birth to a second generation (SG) bearing the fingerprint of a fully CNO-cycled matter. Since the present population of most globular clusters is made up largely of SG stars, a substantial fraction of the FG (>~90%) must be lost. Nevertheless, two types of clusters dominated by a simple stellar population (FG clusters) should exist: either clusters initially too small to be able to retain a cooling flow and form a SG (FG-only clusters), or massive clusters that could retain the CNO processed ejecta and form a SG, but were unable to lose a significant fraction of their FG (mainly-FG clusters). We attempt a classification of FG clusters, based on the morphology of their horizontal branches (HBs), as displayed in photomectric catalogues for 106 clusters. FG candidates are the clusters in which the HB can be reproduced by the evolution of an almost unique mass. <20% of clusters with [Fe/H]<-0.8 appear to be FG, but only ~10% probably had a mass sufficient to form at all an SG. This small percentage confirms on a wider database that the SG is a dominant constituent of today's clusters, suggesting that its formation is an ingredient necessary for the survival of globular clusters during their dynamical evolution in the Galactic tidal field. Pal3 turns out to be a good example of FG-only cluster. HB simulations and space distribution of its components, indicate that M 53 is a "mainly-FG" cluster. Mainly-FG candidates may be also NGC5634, NGC5694 and NGC6101. In contrast, NGC 2419 contains >30% of SG stars, and its present dynamical status bears less information on its formation process than the analysis of the chemical abundances of its stars and of its HB morphology.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
NGC 2419: a large and extreme second generation in a currently undisturbed cluster
Authors:
M. Di Criscienzo,
F. D'Antona,
A. P. Milone,
P. Ventura,
V. Caloi,
R. Carini,
D'Ercole,
E. Vesperini,
G. Piotto
Abstract:
We analyse complementary HST and SUBARU data for the globular cluster NGC 2419. We make a detailed analysis of the horizontal branch (HB), that appears composed by two main groups of stars: the luminous blue HB stars ---that extend by evolution into the RR Lyrae and red HB region--- and a fainter, extremely blue population. We examine the possible models for this latter group and conclude that a p…
▽ More
We analyse complementary HST and SUBARU data for the globular cluster NGC 2419. We make a detailed analysis of the horizontal branch (HB), that appears composed by two main groups of stars: the luminous blue HB stars ---that extend by evolution into the RR Lyrae and red HB region--- and a fainter, extremely blue population. We examine the possible models for this latter group and conclude that a plausible explanation is that they correspond to a significant (~30 %) extreme second generation with a strong helium enhancement (Y~0.4). We also show that the color dispersion of the red giant branch is consistent with this hypothesis, while the main sequence data are compatible with it, although the large observational error blurs the possible underlying splitting. While it is common to find an even larger (50 -- 80) percentage of second generation in a globular cluster, the presence of a substantial and extreme fraction of these stars in NGC 2419 might be surprising, as the cluster is at present well inside the radius beyond which the galactic tidal field would be dominant. If a similar situation had been present in the first stages of the cluster life, the cluster would have retained its initial mass, and the percentage of second generation stars should have been quite small (up to ~10 %). Such a large fraction of extreme second generation stars implies that the system must have been initially much more massive and in different dynamical conditions than today. We discuss this issue in the light of existing models of the formation of multiple populations in globular clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Terzan 5: an alternative interpretation for the split horizontal branch
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
P. Ventura,
V. Caloi,
A. D'Ercole,
E. Vesperini,
R. Carini,
M. Di Criscienzo
Abstract:
We consider the horizontal branch (HB) of the Globular Cluster Terzan 5, recently shown to be split into two parts, the fainter one (delta M_K ~ 0.3mag) having a lower metallicity than the more luminous. Both features show that it contains at least two stellar populations. The separation in magnitude has been ascribed to an age difference of ~6 Gyr and interpreted as the result of an atypical…
▽ More
We consider the horizontal branch (HB) of the Globular Cluster Terzan 5, recently shown to be split into two parts, the fainter one (delta M_K ~ 0.3mag) having a lower metallicity than the more luminous. Both features show that it contains at least two stellar populations. The separation in magnitude has been ascribed to an age difference of ~6 Gyr and interpreted as the result of an atypical evolutionary history for this cluster. We show that the observed HB morphology is also consistent with a model in which the bright HB is composed of second generation stars that are metal enriched and with a helium mass fraction larger (by delta Y ~ 0.07) than that of first generation stars populating the fainter part of the HB. Terzan 5 would therefore be anomalous, compared to most "normal" clusters hosting multiple populations, only because its second generation is strongly contaminated by supernova ejecta; the previously proposed prolonged period of star formation, however, is not required. The iron enrichment of the bright HB can be ascribed either to contamination from Type Ia supernova ejecta of the low-iron, helium rich, ejecta of the massive asympotic giant branch stars of the cluster, or to its mixing with gas, accreting on the cluster from the environment, that has been subject to fast metal enrichment due to its proximity with the galactic bulge. The model here proposed requires only a small age difference, of ~100Myr.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
The evolutionary status of the blue hook stars in Omega Centauri
Authors:
Francesca D'Antona,
Vittoria Caloi,
Paolo Ventura
Abstract:
Core helium burning is the dominant source of energy of extreme horizontal branch stars, as the hydrogen envelope is too small to contribute to the nuclear energy output. The evolution of each mass in the HR diagram occurs along vertical tracks that, when the core helium is consumed, evolve to higher Teff and then to the white dwarf stage. The larger is the mass, the smaller is the Teff of the…
▽ More
Core helium burning is the dominant source of energy of extreme horizontal branch stars, as the hydrogen envelope is too small to contribute to the nuclear energy output. The evolution of each mass in the HR diagram occurs along vertical tracks that, when the core helium is consumed, evolve to higher Teff and then to the white dwarf stage. The larger is the mass, the smaller is the Teff of the models, so that the zero age horizontal branch (ZAHB) is "horizontal". In this paper we show that, if the helium mass fraction (Y) of the envelope is larger than Y~0.5, the shape of the tracks changes completely: the hydrogen burning becomes efficient again also for very small envelope masses, thanks to the higher molecular weight and to the higher temperatures of the hydrogen shell. The larger is Y, the smaller is the envelope mass that provides strong H-shell burning. These tracks have a curled shape, are located at a Teff following the approximate relation Teff=8090+ 32900xY, and become more luminous for larger envelope masses. Consequently, the ZAHB of the very high helium models is "vertical" in the HR diagram. Synthetic models based on these tracks nicely reproduce the location and shape of the "blue hook" in the globular cluster wCen, best fit by a very high Teff (bluer) sequence with Y=0.80 and a cooler (redder) one with Y=0.65. Although these precise values of Y may depend on the color-Teff conversions, we know that the helium content of the progenitors of the blue hook stars can not be larger than Y~0.38-0.40, if they are descendants of the cluster blue main sequence. Consequently, this interpretation implies that all these objects must in fact be progeny of the blue main sequence, but they have all suffered further deep mixing, that has largely and uniformly increased their surface helium abundance, during the red giant branch evolution. A late helium flash can not be the cause of this deep mixing, as the models we propose have hydrogen rich envelopes much more massive than those required for a late flash. We discuss different models of deep mixing proposed in the literature, and conclude that our interpretation of the blue hook can not be ruled out, but requires a much deeper investigation before it can be accepted.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
The influence of the C+N+O abundances on the determination of the relative ages of Globular Clusters: the case of NGC 1851 and NGC 6121 (M4)
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
P. B. Stetson,
P. Ventura,
A. Milone,
G. P. Piotto,
V. Caloi
Abstract:
The color magnitude diagram (CMD) of NGC 1851 presents two subgiant branches (SGB), probably due the presence of two populations differing in total CNO content. We test the idea that a difference in total CNO may simulate an age difference when comparing the CMD of clusters to derive relative ages. We compare NGC 1851 with NGC 6121 (M4), a cluster of very similar [Fe/H]. We find that, with a sui…
▽ More
The color magnitude diagram (CMD) of NGC 1851 presents two subgiant branches (SGB), probably due the presence of two populations differing in total CNO content. We test the idea that a difference in total CNO may simulate an age difference when comparing the CMD of clusters to derive relative ages. We compare NGC 1851 with NGC 6121 (M4), a cluster of very similar [Fe/H]. We find that, with a suitable shift of the CMDs that brings the two red horizontal branches at the same magnitude level, the unevolved main sequence and red giant branch match, but the SGB of NGC 6121 and its red giant branch "bump" are fainter than in NGC 1851. In particular, the SGB of NGC 6121 is even slightly fainter than the the faint SGB in NGC 1851. Both these features can be explained if the total CNO in NGC 6121 is larger than that in NGC 1851, even if the two clusters are coeval. We conclude by warning that different initial C+N+O abundances between two clusters, otherwise similar in metallicity and age, may lead to differences in the turnoff morphology that can be easily attributed to an age difference.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
The C+N+O abundances and the splitting of the subgiant branch in the Globular Cluster NGC 1851
Authors:
P. Ventura,
V. Caloi,
F. D'Antona,
J. Ferguson,
A. Milone,
G. Piotto
Abstract:
Among the newly discovered features of multiple stellar populations in Globular Clusters, the cluster NGC 1851 harbours a double subgiant branch, that can be explained in terms of two stellar generations, only slightly differing in age, the younger one having an increased total C+N+O abundance. Thanks to this difference in the chemistry, a fit can be made to the subgiant branches, roughly consis…
▽ More
Among the newly discovered features of multiple stellar populations in Globular Clusters, the cluster NGC 1851 harbours a double subgiant branch, that can be explained in terms of two stellar generations, only slightly differing in age, the younger one having an increased total C+N+O abundance. Thanks to this difference in the chemistry, a fit can be made to the subgiant branches, roughly consistent with the C+N+O abundance variations already discovered two decades ago, and confirmed by recent spectroscopic data. We compute theoretical isochrones for the main sequence turnoff, by adopting four chemical mixtures for the opacities and nuclear reaction rates. The standard mixture has Z=10$^{-3}$ and [$α$/Fe]=0.4, the others have C+N+O respectively equal to 2, 3 and 5 times the standard mixture, according to the element abundance distribution described in the text. We compare tracks and isochrones, and show how the results depend on the total CNO abundance. We notice that different initial CNO abundances between two clusters, otherwise similar in metallicity and age, may lead to differences in the turnoff morphology that can be easily attributed to an age difference. We simulate the main sequence and subgiant branch data for NGC 1851 and show that an increase of C+N+O by a factor $\sim$3 best reproduces the shift between the subgiant branches. We compare the main sequence width in the color m$_{F336W}$-m$_{F814W}$ with models, and find that the maximum helium abundance compatible with the data is Y$\simeq$0.29. We consider the result in the framework of the formation of the second stellar generation in globular clusters, for the bulk of which we estimate a helium abundance of Y$\simlt 0.26$.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
The fraction of second generation stars in Globular Clusters from the analysis of the Horizontal Branch
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
V. Caloi
Abstract:
Most Globular Clusters (GC) show chemical inhomogeneities in the composition of their stars, apparently due to a second stellar generation (SG) in which the forming gas is enriched by hot-CNO cycled material processed in stars belonging to a first stellar generation (FG). We propose to use the horizontal branch (HB) to infer which is today the relative number fraction of ''normal" and anomalous…
▽ More
Most Globular Clusters (GC) show chemical inhomogeneities in the composition of their stars, apparently due to a second stellar generation (SG) in which the forming gas is enriched by hot-CNO cycled material processed in stars belonging to a first stellar generation (FG). We propose to use the horizontal branch (HB) to infer which is today the relative number fraction of ''normal" and anomalous stars in clusters. We assume that the anomalies also include enhanced helium abundance. Helium variations have been recognized to be able to explain several puzzling peculiarities (gaps, RR Lyr periods and period distribution, ratio of blue to red stars, blue tails) in HBs. We extend the analysis to as many clusters as possible. We show that, with few exceptions, 50% or more of the stars belong to the SG. In other cases, where one would think of a simple stellar population, we suggest that the stars might all belong to the SG. We fit the optical and UV data of NGC2808, including a reproduction of the main sequence splittings and an exam of the problem of "blue hook" stars. We also show a detailed fit of the totally blue HB of M13, one among the clusters that are possibly fully made up by SG stars. We conclude that the formation of the SG is a crucial event in the life of GCs. A high fraction of SG stars can be achieved only if the initial cluster was much more massive than the present one and most of the FG low mass stars have been lost. As shown by D'Ercole et al., the mass loss due to type II supernovae of the FG may be the process responsible for triggering the expansion of the cluster, the strip** of its outer layers and the loss of most of the FG low-mass stars.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
Multiple stellar populations in Globular Clusters: collection of information from the Horizontal Branch
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
V. Caloi
Abstract:
The majority of the inhomogeneities in the chemical composition of Globular Cluster (GC) stars appear due to primordial enrichment by hot-CNO cycled material processed in stars belonging to a first stellar generation. Either massive AGB envelopes subject to hot bottom burning, or the envelopes of massive fastly rotating stars could be the progenitors. In both cases, the stars showing chemical an…
▽ More
The majority of the inhomogeneities in the chemical composition of Globular Cluster (GC) stars appear due to primordial enrichment by hot-CNO cycled material processed in stars belonging to a first stellar generation. Either massive AGB envelopes subject to hot bottom burning, or the envelopes of massive fastly rotating stars could be the progenitors. In both cases, the stars showing chemical anomalies must have also enhanced helium abundance, and we have proposed that this higher helium could be at the basis of the many different morphologies of GC horizontal branches (HB) for similar ages and metallicities. The helium variations have been beautifully confirmed by the splitting of the main sequence in the clusters omega Cen and NGC 2808, but this effect can show up only for somewhat extreme helium abundances. Therefore it is important to go on using the HB morphology to infer the number ratio of the first to the second generation in as many clusters as possible. We exemplify how it is possible to infer the presence of a He-rich stellar component in different clusters thanks to different HB features (gaps, RR Lyr periods and period distribution, ratio of blue to red stars, blue tails). In many clusters at least 50% of the stars belong to the second stellar generation, and in some cases we suspect that the stars might all belong to the second generation. We shortly examine the problem of the initial mass function required to achieve the observed number ratios and conclude that: 1) the initial cluster must have been much more massive than today's cluster, and 2) formation of the second stellar generation mainly in the central regions of the cluster may help in obtaining the desired values.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
Is mass loss along the red giant branch of globular clusters sharply peaked? The case of M3
Authors:
Vittoria Caloi,
Francesca D'Antona
Abstract:
There is a growing evidence that several globular clusters must contain multiple stellar generations, differing in helium content. This hypothesis has helped to interpret peculiar unexplained features in their horizontal branches. In this framework we model the peaked distribution of the RR Lyr periods in M3, that has defied explanation until now. At the same time, we try to reproduce the colour…
▽ More
There is a growing evidence that several globular clusters must contain multiple stellar generations, differing in helium content. This hypothesis has helped to interpret peculiar unexplained features in their horizontal branches. In this framework we model the peaked distribution of the RR Lyr periods in M3, that has defied explanation until now. At the same time, we try to reproduce the colour distribution of M3 horizontal branch stars. We find that only a very small dispersion in mass loss along the red giant branch reproduces with good accuracy the observational data. The enhanced and variable helium content among cluster stars is at the origin of the extension in colour of the horizontal branch, while the sharply peaked mass loss is necessary to reproduce the sharply peaked period distribution of RR Lyr variables. The dispersion in mass loss has to be <~ 0.003 Msun, to be compared with the usually assumed values of ~0.02 Msun. This requirement represents a substantial change in the interpretation of the physical mechanisms regulating the evolution of globular cluster stars.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
Na-O Anticorrelation and Horizontal Branches. V. The Na-O anticorrelation in NGC 6441 from Giraffe spectra
Authors:
R. G. Gratton,
S. Lucatello,
A. Bragaglia,
E. Carretta,
S. Cassisi,
Y. Momany,
E. Pancino,
E. Valenti,
V. Caloi,
R. Claudi,
F. D'Antona,
S. Desidera,
P. François,
G. James,
S. Moehler,
S. Ortolani,
L. Pasquini,
G. Piotto,
A. Recio-Blanco
Abstract:
We present an analysis of FLAMES-Giraffe spectra for several bright giants in NGC 6441, to investigate the presence and extent of the Na-O anticorrelation in this anomalous globular cluster. The field of NGC 6441 is very crowded, with severe contamination by foreground (mainly bulge) field stars. Appropriate membership criteria were devised to identify a group of 25 likely cluster members among…
▽ More
We present an analysis of FLAMES-Giraffe spectra for several bright giants in NGC 6441, to investigate the presence and extent of the Na-O anticorrelation in this anomalous globular cluster. The field of NGC 6441 is very crowded, with severe contamination by foreground (mainly bulge) field stars. Appropriate membership criteria were devised to identify a group of 25 likely cluster members among the about 130 stars observed. Combined with the UVES data obtained with the same observations, high dispersion abundance analyses are now available for a total of 30 stars in NGC 6441, 29 of them having data for both O and Na. The spectra were analyzed by a standard line analysis procedure; care was taken to minimize the impact of the differential interstellar reddening throughout the cluster, and to extract reliable information from crowded, and moderately high S/N (30-70), moderately high resolution (R ~ 23,000) spectra. NGC 6441 is very metal-rich ([Fe/H]=$-0.34\pm 0.02\pm0.04$ dex). There is no clear sign of star-to-star scatter in the Fe-peak elements. The alpha-elements Mg, Si, Ca, and Ti are overabundant by rather large factors, suggesting that the cluster formed from material enriched by massive core collapse SNe. The O-Na anticorrelation is well defined, with about 1/4 of the stars being Na-rich and O-poor. One of the stars is a Ba-rich and moderately C-rich star. The distribution of [Na/O] ratios among RGB stars in NGC 6441 appears similar to the distribution of colors of stars along the horizontal branch. The fraction of Na-poor, O-rich stars found in NGC 6441 agrees well with that of stars on the red horizontal branch of this cluster (in both cases about 80%), with a slo** distribution toward lower values of [O/Na] (among RGB stars and bluer colors (among HB stars).
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
The first stages of the evolution of Globular Clusters
Authors:
Francesca D'Antona,
Paolo Ventura,
Vittoria Caloi
Abstract:
The majority of the inhomogeneities in the chemical composition of Globular Cluster (GC) stars appear due to primordial enrichment. The most studied model today claims that the ejecta of Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars of high mass -those evolving during the first ~100Myr of the Clusters life- directly form a second generation of stars with abundance anomalies. In this talk, we review the st…
▽ More
The majority of the inhomogeneities in the chemical composition of Globular Cluster (GC) stars appear due to primordial enrichment. The most studied model today claims that the ejecta of Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars of high mass -those evolving during the first ~100Myr of the Clusters life- directly form a second generation of stars with abundance anomalies. In this talk, we review the status of the art with regard to this model, whose major problems are i) the modelling of the chemical anomalies is still not fully complete, and ii) it requires an IMF peculiarly enhanced in the intermediate mass stars. The model predicts enhanced helium abundance in the stars showing chemical anomalies, and the helium abundance distribution can be roughly derived from the morphology of the horizontal branch. Such distribution may possibly help to falsify the model for the first phases of evolution of GCs. As an illustration, we compare the results of the analysis of the HB morphology of some clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
NGC 6441: another indication for a very high helium content in Globular Cluster stars
Authors:
V. Caloi,
F. D'Antona
Abstract:
The metal-rich bulge globular cluster NGC 6441 shows a well developed blue horizontal branch (Rich et al.), together with a strong slope upward from the red clump to the blue of the RR Lyrae region. Both features, the former corresponding to the well-known second parameter problem, are not explained by conventional evolutionary models. Helium self-enrichment is proposed as a possible solution to…
▽ More
The metal-rich bulge globular cluster NGC 6441 shows a well developed blue horizontal branch (Rich et al.), together with a strong slope upward from the red clump to the blue of the RR Lyrae region. Both features, the former corresponding to the well-known second parameter problem, are not explained by conventional evolutionary models. Helium self-enrichment is proposed as a possible solution to both questions, a mechanism already invoked for the interpretation of the peculiarities in NGC 2808 and M13. We make use of horizontal branch simulations, covering a wide range in main sequence helium abundance, to investigate whether the main features of NGC 6441 horizontal branch population, including the RR Lyrae variables period, can be reproduced. To describe the horizontal branch of NGC 6441, the helium content Y in the red clump must reach at least 0.35; values up to Y~0.37 are necessary to populate the RR Lyr region, reproducing also the observed mean long periods; depending on the dispersion in mass loss assumed in the simulations, values up to Y~0.38--0.40 are necessary to populate the blue HB. The total self--enriched population amounts to ~60% of the whole stellar content. Self-enrichment and multiple star formation episodes in the early evolution of globular clusters appear more and more able to account for many of the chemical and population peculiarities observed in these systems. The very large helium abundances (Y>0.35) required for ~14% of the horizontal branch population pose some problem on the enrichment mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Multiple helium abundances in Globular Clusters stars: Consequences for the Horizontal Branch and RR Lyrae
Authors:
Francesca D'Antona,
Paolo Ventura,
Vittoria Caloi
Abstract:
Most inhomogeneities in the chemical composition of GC stars are due to primordial enrichment. The model today most credited is that the winds lost by high mass Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars, evolving during the first $\simlt$200Myr of the Clusters life, directly form a second generation of stars with abundance anomalies. The best indirect hint towards this suggestion is the recognition th…
▽ More
Most inhomogeneities in the chemical composition of GC stars are due to primordial enrichment. The model today most credited is that the winds lost by high mass Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars, evolving during the first $\simlt$200Myr of the Clusters life, directly form a second generation of stars with abundance anomalies. The best indirect hint towards this suggestion is the recognition that some peculiarities in the Horizontal Branch (HB) stars distribution (blue tails, gaps, anomalous luminosity slope of the flat part of the HB) can be attributed to the larger helium abundance in the matter, processed through Hot Bottom Burning, from which these stars are born. The model has been reinforced by finding a peculiar main sequence distribution in the cluster NGC 2808, which also has a bimodal HB distribution and an extended blue tail: the excess of blue objects on the main sequence has been interpreted as stars with very high helium. We remark that the RR Lyr distribution may be affected by the helium spread, and this can be at the basis of the very long periods of the RRab variables of the metal rich clusters NGC 6388 and NGC 6441, longer than for the very metal poor Oosterhoff II clusters. These periods imply that the RR Lyr are brighter than expected for their metallicities, consistent with a larger helium abundance.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
A helium spread among the main sequence stars in NGC 2808
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
M. Bellazzini,
V. Caloi,
F. Fusi Pecci,
S. Galleti,
R. T. Rood
Abstract:
We studied the color distribution of the main sequence of the Globular Cluster NGC 2808, based on new deep HST-WFPC2 photometry of a field in the uncrowded outskirts of the cluster. The color distribution of main sequence stars is wider than expected for a single stellar population, given our (carefully determined) measurement errors. About 20% of the sample stars are much bluer than expected an…
▽ More
We studied the color distribution of the main sequence of the Globular Cluster NGC 2808, based on new deep HST-WFPC2 photometry of a field in the uncrowded outskirts of the cluster. The color distribution of main sequence stars is wider than expected for a single stellar population, given our (carefully determined) measurement errors. About 20% of the sample stars are much bluer than expected and are most plausibly explained as a population having a much larger helium abundance than the bulk of the main sequence. We estimate that the helium mass fraction of these stars is Y ~ 0.4. NGC 2808 may have suffered self-enrichment, with different stellar populations born from the ejecta of the intermediate mass asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars of the first generation. In addition to the Y=0.40 stars, roughly 30% of the stars should have Y distributed between 0.26-0.29 while 50% have primordial Y, to explain also the peculiar horizontal branch morphology. Three main stages of star formation are identified, the first with primordial helium content Y ~ 0.24, the second one born from the winds of the most massive AGBs of the first stellar generation (6-7msun), having Y ~ 0.4, and a third one born from the matter ejected from less massive AGBs (~ 3.5-4.5msun) with Y ~ 0.26-0.29. For a long hiatus of time (several 10^7yr) between the second and third generation, star formation might have been inhibited by the explosion of late Supernovae II deriving from binary evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2005;
originally announced May 2005.
-
Helium self--enrichment and the second parameter problem in M3 and M13
Authors:
V. Caloi,
F. D'Antona
Abstract:
Inspection of the CM diagrams of globular clusters having similar heavy element content shows that the luminosity of the red giant bump relative to the turnoff (Delta V_{TO}^{bump}) differs by more than 0.1 mag between clusters with different horizontal branch morphology. Unfortunately, careful consideration of the data leaves us with only one pair (M3 and M13) of clusters good for a quantitativ…
▽ More
Inspection of the CM diagrams of globular clusters having similar heavy element content shows that the luminosity of the red giant bump relative to the turnoff (Delta V_{TO}^{bump}) differs by more than 0.1 mag between clusters with different horizontal branch morphology. Unfortunately, careful consideration of the data leaves us with only one pair (M3 and M13) of clusters good for a quantitative discussion. For this pair we consider differences in age and helium content as possible causes for the difference in Delta V_{TO}^{bump}, and find more convincing support for the latter. A larger helium content in M13 stars (Y~0.28 vs. Y~0.24) accounts for various CM diagram features, such as the difference in the luminosity level of RR Lyr variables and of the red giant bump with respect to the turnoff luminosity, and the horizontal branch morphology. This enhanced helium can be tentatively understood in the framework of self--enrichment by massive asymptotic giant branch stars in the first ~100 Myr of the cluster life. A modest self--enrichment can be present also in M3 and can be the reason for the still unexplained presence of a not negligible number of luminous, Oosterhoff II type RR Lyr variables. The hypothesis that a larger helium content is the second parameter for clusters with very blue horizontal branch morphology could be checked by an accurate set of data for more clusters giving turnoff, RR Lyrs and bump magnitudes within a unique photometry.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
The early evolution of Globular Clusters: the case of NGC 2808
Authors:
Francesca D'Antona,
Vittoria Caloi
Abstract:
Enhancement and spread of helium among globular cluster stars have been recently suggested as a way to explain the horizontal branch blue tails, in those clusters which show a primordial spread in the abundances of CNO and other elements involved in advanced CNO burning (D'Antona et al. 2002). In this paper we examine the implications of the hypothesis that, in many globular clusters, stars were…
▽ More
Enhancement and spread of helium among globular cluster stars have been recently suggested as a way to explain the horizontal branch blue tails, in those clusters which show a primordial spread in the abundances of CNO and other elements involved in advanced CNO burning (D'Antona et al. 2002). In this paper we examine the implications of the hypothesis that, in many globular clusters, stars were born in two separate events: an initial burst (first generation), which gives origin to probably all high and intermediate mass stars and to a fraction of the cluster stars observed today, and a second, prolonged star formation phase (second generation) in which stars form directly from the ejecta of the intermediate mass stars of the first generation. In particular, we consider in detail the morphology of the horizontal branch in NGC 2808 and argue that it unveils the early cluster evolution, from the birth of the first star generation to the end of the second phase of star formation. This framework provides a feasible interpretation for the still unexplained dichotomy of NGC 2808 horizontal branch, attributing the lack of stars in the RR Lyr region to the gap in the helium content between the red clump, whose stars are considered to belong to the first stellar generation and have primordial helium, and the blue side of the horizontal branch, whose minimum helium content reflects the helium abundance in the smallest mass (~4Msun)contributing to the second stellar generation. This scenario provides constraints on the required Initial Mass Function, in a way that a great deal of remnant neutron stars and stellar mass black holes might have been produced.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2004;
originally announced May 2004.
-
Helium variation due to self-pollution among Globular Cluster stars: consequences on the horizontal branch morphology
Authors:
F. D'Antona,
V. Caloi,
J. Montalban,
P. Ventura,
R. Gratton
Abstract:
It is becoming clear that `self--pollution' by the ejecta of massive asymptotic giant branch stars has an important role in the early chemical evolution of globular cluster stars, producing CNO abundance spreads which are observed also at the surface of unevolved stars. Considering that the ejecta which are CNO processed must also be helium enriched, we have modelled stellar evolution of globula…
▽ More
It is becoming clear that `self--pollution' by the ejecta of massive asymptotic giant branch stars has an important role in the early chemical evolution of globular cluster stars, producing CNO abundance spreads which are observed also at the surface of unevolved stars. Considering that the ejecta which are CNO processed must also be helium enriched, we have modelled stellar evolution of globular cluster stars by taking into account this possible helium enhancement with respect to the primordial value. We show that the differences between the main evolutionary phases (main sequence, turn--off and red giants) are small enough that it would be very difficult to detect them observationally. However, the difference in the evolving mass may play a role in the morphology of the horizontal branch, and in particular in the formation of blue tails, in those globular clusters which show strong CNO abundance variations, such as M13 and NGC 6752.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2002;
originally announced September 2002.
-
Mixing, Enhanced Helium and Blue Tails in Globular Clusters
Authors:
V. Caloi
Abstract:
We investigate the consequences of an increase in the envelope helium abundance of pre-helium flash red giants in globular clusters. Comparing predictions with the CM diagrams of a few crucial GC, one finds no evidence for a substantial increase in the surface helium content of HB members of these clusters, at least for objects in the RR Lyrae region or close to it. The possibility that the most…
▽ More
We investigate the consequences of an increase in the envelope helium abundance of pre-helium flash red giants in globular clusters. Comparing predictions with the CM diagrams of a few crucial GC, one finds no evidence for a substantial increase in the surface helium content of HB members of these clusters, at least for objects in the RR Lyrae region or close to it. The possibility that the most peculiar giants belong to the asymptotic giant branch is discussed. The consequences of a delay in the helium flash are briefly examined.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2000;
originally announced December 2000.
-
Kinematics and age of stellar populations in the solar neighbourhood from Hipparcos data
Authors:
V. Caloi,
D. Cardini,
F. D'Antona,
M. Badiali,
A. Emanuele,
I. Mazzitelli
Abstract:
The large sample of main sequence stars with Hipparcos parallaxes and estimates of the radial velocity has been used to study the relations among kinematics, age and heavy element content for the solar neighbourhood. The samples with V> -30 km $\rm s^{-1}$, although including stars as old as 10^10 yr, have a very young component (age $\simgt$ 10^7 yr), and have a metallicity close to the solar o…
▽ More
The large sample of main sequence stars with Hipparcos parallaxes and estimates of the radial velocity has been used to study the relations among kinematics, age and heavy element content for the solar neighbourhood. The samples with V> -30 km $\rm s^{-1}$, although including stars as old as 10^10 yr, have a very young component (age $\simgt$ 10^7 yr), and have a metallicity close to the solar one. Most of the stars with space velocity component V < -40 km $\rm s^{-1}$ have a minimum age of about 2 10^9 yr. Stars with V \simlt -80 km $\rm s^{-1}$ share a common age \simgt $10^{10}$ yr. The distribution in \Feh of these latter objects suggests a decrease in metal content with increasing $| V |$ till \Feh < -2. For V < -180 km $\rm s^{-1}$ only the metal poor component ([Fe/H] < -0.7) is found. The common age for large space velocity suggests that no substantial age spread exists in the inner halo, at least in the local sample.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 1999;
originally announced October 1999.
