-
Stable Boundary Layers with Subsidence: Scaling and Similarity of the Truly Steady State
Authors:
Thijs Bon,
Raúl Bayoán Cal,
Johan Meyers
Abstract:
The stable boundary layer (SBL) subjected to large-scale subsidence is studied through large-eddy simulations (LESs) with fixed surface temperature and a linear subsidence velocity profile. These boundary layers reach a truly steady state, where thermal equilibrium is established by a balance between surface cooling and subsidence-induced heating. We identify three governing dimensionless groups b…
▽ More
The stable boundary layer (SBL) subjected to large-scale subsidence is studied through large-eddy simulations (LESs) with fixed surface temperature and a linear subsidence velocity profile. These boundary layers reach a truly steady state, where thermal equilibrium is established by a balance between surface cooling and subsidence-induced heating. We identify three governing dimensionless groups by scaling the governing equations with the geostrophic wind and Coriolis frequency, and systematically investigate the impact of these external parameters on global flow properties and mean profiles in the steady state. The SBL depth, low-level jet, and the magnitude of the turbulent momentum flux are reduced when the subsidence rate or Buoyancy number increases, while surface heat flux is enhanced. The shape of normalized mean profiles of temperature and heat flux is mainly determined by the subsidence rate, while they collapse for varying buoyancy and surface Rossby numbers. We develop empirical correlations for the stability parameter $h_θ/L_O$ and a thermal shape factor, and propose a new unidirectional geostrophic drag law, to form a closed set of equations that estimates relevant flow properties from external parameters. The estimation errors compared to the LES data are less than 5% for friction velocity and surface heat flux, and at most 10% for the SBL depth $h_θ$. Within the surface layer, dimensionless velocity and temperature gradients in the steady SBL with subsidence show acceptable agreement to Monin-Obukhov similarity theory, while the collapse is improved when a recently proposed mixed scaling parameter, that includes $h_θ/L_O$, is used.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
A Moving Surface Drag Model for LES of Wind over Waves
Authors:
Manuel Ayala,
Zein Sadek,
Ondřej Ferčák,
Raúl Bayoán Cal,
Dennice Gayme,
Charles Meneveau
Abstract:
Numerical prediction of the interactions between wind and ocean waves is essential for climate modeling and a wide range of offshore operations. Large Eddy Simulation (LES) of the marine atmospheric boundary layer is a practical numerical predictive tool but requires parameterization of surface fluxes at the air-water interface. Current momentum flux parameterizations primarily use wave-phase adap…
▽ More
Numerical prediction of the interactions between wind and ocean waves is essential for climate modeling and a wide range of offshore operations. Large Eddy Simulation (LES) of the marine atmospheric boundary layer is a practical numerical predictive tool but requires parameterization of surface fluxes at the air-water interface. Current momentum flux parameterizations primarily use wave-phase adapting computational grids, incurring high computational costs, or use an equilibrium model based on Monin-Obukhov similarity theory for rough surfaces that cannot resolve wave phase information. To include wave phase-resolving physics at a cost similar to the equilibrium model, the Moving Surface Drag (MOSD) model is introduced. It assumes ideal airflow over locally piece-wise planar representations of moving water wave surfaces. Horizontally unresolved interactions are still modeled using the equilibrium model. Validation against experimental and numerical datasets with known monochromatic waves demonstrates the robustness and accuracy of the model in representing wave-induced impacts on mean velocity and Reynolds stress profiles. The model is formulated to be applicable to a broad range of wave fields and its ability to represent cross-swell and multiple wavelength cases is illustrated. Additionally, the model is applied to LES of a laboratory-scale fixed-bottom offshore wind turbine model, and the results are compared with wind tunnel experimental data. The LES with the MOSD model shows good agreement in wind-wave-wake interactions and phase-dependent physics at a low computational cost. The model's simplicity and minimal computational needs make it valuable for studying turbulent atmospheric-scale flows over the sea, particularly in offshore wind energy research.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024; v1 submitted 22 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Lagrangian modeling of a non-homogeneous turbulent shear flow: Molding homogeneous and isotropic trajectories into a jet
Authors:
Bianca Viggiano,
Thomas Basset,
Mickaël Bourgoin,
Raúl Bayoán Cal,
Laurent Chevillard,
Charles Meneveau,
Romain Volk
Abstract:
Turbulence is prevalent in nature and industry, from large-scale wave dynamics to small-scale combustion nozzle sprays. In addition to the multi-scale nonlinear complexity and both randomness and coherent structures in its dynamics, practical turbulence is often non-homogeneous and anisotropic, leading to great modeling challenges. In this letter, an efficient model is proposed to predict turbulen…
▽ More
Turbulence is prevalent in nature and industry, from large-scale wave dynamics to small-scale combustion nozzle sprays. In addition to the multi-scale nonlinear complexity and both randomness and coherent structures in its dynamics, practical turbulence is often non-homogeneous and anisotropic, leading to great modeling challenges. In this letter, an efficient model is proposed to predict turbulent jet statistics with high accuracy. The model leverages detailed knowledge of readily available velocity signals from idealized homogeneous turbulence and transforms them into Lagrangian trajectories of a turbulent jet. The resulting spatio-temporal statistics are compared against experimental jet data showing remarkable agreement at all scales. In particular the intermittency phenomenon is accurately mapped by the model to this inhomogeneous situation, as observed by higher-order moments and velocity increment probability density functions. Crucial to the advancement of turbulence modeling, the transformation is simple to implement, with possible extensions to other inhomogeneous flows such as wind turbine wakes and canopy flows, to name a few.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Coriolis force deflects wind plant wakes left in the Northern Hemisphere
Authors:
Natalie Violetta Frank,
Maria Eletta Negretti,
Joel Sommeria,
Martín Obligado,
Raúl Bayoán Cal
Abstract:
The physical growth of wind energy over several decades, caused a re-investigation mesoscale effects on wind plant dynamics. At a large scale operation, understanding the interactions between atmospheric phenomena and wind plant wakes is crucial to improving models. Within a wind plant, wakes are generated by individual turbines and the summation of individual wakes is the global plant wake. In bo…
▽ More
The physical growth of wind energy over several decades, caused a re-investigation mesoscale effects on wind plant dynamics. At a large scale operation, understanding the interactions between atmospheric phenomena and wind plant wakes is crucial to improving models. Within a wind plant, wakes are generated by individual turbines and the summation of individual wakes is the global plant wake. In both cases, the dynamics are sensitive to atmospheric conditions; one of interest to wind and atmospheric scientists is the Coriolis force. Current research noted spatial and temporal influences on the global plant wakes caused by the Coriolis force. Due to the presence of wind veer in the atmospheric boundary layer, field research is notoriously difficult. As a result, investigations have been lead by numerical simulations. This proved helpful for initial queries, established the significance of the Coriolis force as a non trivial parameter of wind plant dynamics. This works presents a novel experimental study of the impact of the Coriolis force on the dynamics of a scaled wind plant. The experiments show that for a single turbine the wake deflection is insignificant. Additionally, the results show that the global plant wake deflects in the anti-clockwise direction in the Northern hemisphere. The outcomes of this work yield unique experimental methods for research in wind energy, and provide a new basis for the fundamental dynamics of a wind plant under influence of the Coriolis force for future wind plant models causing influence on the global expansion of wind energy.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Effects of wavelength on vortex structure and turbulence kinetic energy transfer of flow over undulated cylinders
Authors:
Kathleen Lyons,
Raúl Bayoán Cal,
Jennifer A. Franck
Abstract:
Passive flow control research is commonly utilized to provide desirable drag and oscillating lift reduction across a range of engineering applications. This research explores the spanwise undulated cylinder inspired by seal whiskers, shown to reduce lift and drag forces when compared to smooth cylinders. Although the fluid flow over this unique complex geometry has been documented experimentally a…
▽ More
Passive flow control research is commonly utilized to provide desirable drag and oscillating lift reduction across a range of engineering applications. This research explores the spanwise undulated cylinder inspired by seal whiskers, shown to reduce lift and drag forces when compared to smooth cylinders. Although the fluid flow over this unique complex geometry has been documented experimentally and computationally, investigations surrounding geometric modifications to the undulation topography have been limited, and fluid mechanisms by which force reduction is induced have not been fully examined. Five undulation wavelength variations of the undulated cylinder model are simulated at Reynolds number $\Rey=250$ and compared with results from a smooth elliptical cylinder. Vortex structures and turbulence kinetic energy (TKE) transfer in the wake are analyzed to explain how undulation wavelength affects force reduction. Modifications to the undulation wavelength generate a variety of flow patterns including alternating vortex rollers and hairpin vortices. Maximum force reduction is observed at wavelengths that are large enough to allow hairpin vortices to develop without intersecting each other and small enough to prevent the generation of additional alternating flow structures. The differences in flow structures modify the magnitude and location of TKE production and dissipation due to changes in mean and fluctuating strain. Decreased TKE production and increased dissipation in the near wake result in overall lower TKE and reduced body forces. Understanding the flow physics linking geometry to force reduction will guide appropriate parameter selection in bio-inspired design applications.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2023; v1 submitted 6 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Entrainment, diffusion and effective compressibility in a self-similar turbulent jet
Authors:
Thomas Basset,
Bianca Viggiano,
Thomas Barois,
Mathieu Gibert,
Nicolas Mordant,
Raúl Bayoán Cal,
Romain Volk,
Mickaël Bourgoin
Abstract:
An experimental Lagrangian study based on particle tracking velocimetry has been completed in an incompressible turbulent round water jet freely spreading into water. The jet is seeded with tracers only through the nozzle: inhomogeneous seeding called nozzle seeding. The Lagrangian flow tagged by these tracers therefore does not contain any contribution from particles entrained into the jet from t…
▽ More
An experimental Lagrangian study based on particle tracking velocimetry has been completed in an incompressible turbulent round water jet freely spreading into water. The jet is seeded with tracers only through the nozzle: inhomogeneous seeding called nozzle seeding. The Lagrangian flow tagged by these tracers therefore does not contain any contribution from particles entrained into the jet from the quiescent surrounding fluid. The mean velocity field of the nozzle seeded flow, $\langle \boldsymbol{U_\varphi} \rangle$, is found to be essentially indistinguishable from the global mean velocity field of the jet, $\langle \boldsymbol{U} \rangle$, for the axial velocity while significant deviations are found for the radial velocity. This results in an effective compressibility of the nozzle seeded flow for which $\boldsymbol{\nabla \cdot} \langle \boldsymbol{U_\varphi} \rangle \neq 0$ even though the global background flow is fully incompressible. By using mass conservation and self-similarity, we quantitatively explain the modified radial velocity profile and analytically express the missing contribution associated to entrained fluid particles. By considering a classical advection-diffusion description, we explicitly connect turbulent diffusion of mass (through the turbulent diffusivity $K_T$) and momentum (through the turbulent viscosity $ν_T$) to entrainment. This results in new practical relations to experimentally determine the non-uniform spatial profiles of $K_T$ and $ν_T$ (and hence of the turbulent Prandtl number $σ_T = ν_T/K_T$) from simple measurements of the mean tracer concentration and axial velocity profiles. Overall, the proposed approach based on nozzle seeded flow gives new experimental and theoretical elements for a better comprehension of turbulent diffusion and entrainment in turbulent jets.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Single inertial particle statistics in turbulent flows from Lagrangian velocity models
Authors:
J. Friedrich,
B. Viggiano,
M. Bourgoin,
R. B. Cal,
L. Chevillard
Abstract:
We present the extension of a modeling technique for Lagrangian tracer particles [B. Viggiano et al., J. Fluid Mech.(2020), vol. 900, A27] which accounts for the effects of particle inertia. Thereby, the particle velocity for several Stokes numbers is modeled directly by a multi-layered Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process and a comparison of key statistical quantities (second-order velocity structure funct…
▽ More
We present the extension of a modeling technique for Lagrangian tracer particles [B. Viggiano et al., J. Fluid Mech.(2020), vol. 900, A27] which accounts for the effects of particle inertia. Thereby, the particle velocity for several Stokes numbers is modeled directly by a multi-layered Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process and a comparison of key statistical quantities (second-order velocity structure function, acceleration correlation function, and root mean square acceleration) to expressions derived from Batchelor's model as well as to direct numerical simulations (DNS) is performed. In both approaches, Stokes' drag is treated by an approximate ``linear filter'' which replaces the particle position entering the fluid velocity field by the corresponding ideal tracer position. Effects of preferential concentration of inertial particles are taken into account in terms of an effective Stokes number that is determined from the zero crossing of the acceleration correlation function from DNS. This approximation thus allows the modeling of inertial particle statistics through stochastic methods and models for the Lagrangian velocity; the particle velocity is effectively decoupled from the particle position. In contrast to the ordinary filtering technique [Cencini et al., J. Turbul. (2006), 7, N36], our method captures the effects of preferential concentration of particles at low Stokes numbers which manifest themselves for instance by a sharp decrease of the acceleration variance for increasing Stokes numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Lagrangian diffusion properties of a free shear turbulent jet
Authors:
Bianca Viggiano,
Thomas Basset,
Stephen Solovitz,
Thomas Barois,
Mathieu Gibert,
Nicolas Mordant,
Laurent Chevillard,
Romain Volk,
Mickael Bourgoin,
Raul Bayoan Cal
Abstract:
A Lagrangian experimental study of an axisymmetric turbulent water jet is performed to investigate the highly anisotropic and inhomogeneous flow field. The measurements were conducted within a Lagrangian exploration module, an icosahedron apparatus, to facilitate optical access of three cameras. The stereoscopic particle tracking velocimetry results in three component tracks of position, velocity…
▽ More
A Lagrangian experimental study of an axisymmetric turbulent water jet is performed to investigate the highly anisotropic and inhomogeneous flow field. The measurements were conducted within a Lagrangian exploration module, an icosahedron apparatus, to facilitate optical access of three cameras. The stereoscopic particle tracking velocimetry results in three component tracks of position, velocity and acceleration of the tracer particles within the vertically-oriented jet with a Taylor-based Reynolds number $\mathcal R_λ\simeq 230$. Analysis is performed at seven locations from 15 diameters up to 45 diameters downstream. Eulerian analysis is first carried out to obtain critical parameters of the jet and relevant scales, namely the Kolmogorov and large turnover (integral) scales as well as the energy dissipation rate. Lagrangian statistical analysis is then performed on velocity components stationarised following methods inspired by Batchelor (\textit{J. Fluid Mech.}, vol. 3, 1957, pp. 67-80) which aim to extend stationary Lagrangian theory of turbulent diffusion by Taylor to the case of self-similar flows. The evolution of typical Lagrangian scaling parameters as a function of the develo** jet is explored and results show validation of the proposed stationarisation. The universal scaling constant $C_0$ (for the Lagrangian second-order structure function), as well as Eulerian and Lagrangian integral time scales are discussed in this context. $C_0$ is found to converge to a constant value (of the order of $C_0 = 3$) within 30 diameters downstream of the nozzle. Finally, the existence of finite particle size effects are investigated through consideration of acceleration dependent quantities.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Dynamic stall of an airfoil under tailored three-dimensional inflow conditions
Authors:
Dominik Traphan,
Tom T. B. Wester,
Matthew Melius,
Joachim Peinke,
Gerd Gülker,
Raúl Bayoán Cal
Abstract:
Rotor blades of wind turbines in the atmospheric boundary layer regularly experience the aerodynamic phenomenon of dynamic stall consisting of a temporary overshoot of lift and detrimental fatigue loads. Particularly the formation of dynamic stall under three-dimensional inflow conditions raises open questions. Aerodynamic behavior of a DU 91-W2-250 wind profile undergoing light dynamic stall is t…
▽ More
Rotor blades of wind turbines in the atmospheric boundary layer regularly experience the aerodynamic phenomenon of dynamic stall consisting of a temporary overshoot of lift and detrimental fatigue loads. Particularly the formation of dynamic stall under three-dimensional inflow conditions raises open questions. Aerodynamic behavior of a DU 91-W2-250 wind profile undergoing light dynamic stall is thus analyzed in a wind tunnel. Effects of a gust with streamwise and spanwise periodic variation are investigated by comparing total and local lift generation with flow formation above the airfoil. The observed stall cycle is divided into five stages of which one reveals lift overshoot of up to $16~\%$. The aerodynamic response of the airfoil shows a delay of about $1/8$ period between evolution of local angle of attack and lift giving a counterclockwise dynamic polar. A proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) analysis of the flow field contributes to understand aerodynamic consequences of the three-dimensional gust. Local inflow, total lift as well as certain lift events are captured by one POD eigenmode, respectively. Obtained results lead to the conclusion that the flow and particularly the stalled wake of an airfoil facing a three-dimensional gust are strongly coupled in the spanwise direction. This yields to flow stabilization, inhibition of stall, and in turn, counterclockwise dynamic polar along with augmented total lift.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Modelling Lagrangian velocity and acceleration in turbulent flows as infinitely differentiable stochastic processes
Authors:
Bianca Viggiano,
Jan Friedrich,
Romain Volk,
Mickael Bourgoin,
Raul Bayoan Cal,
Laurent Chevillard
Abstract:
We develop a stochastic model for Lagrangian velocity as it is observed in experimental and numerical fully developed turbulent flows. We define it as the unique statistically stationary solution of a causal dynamics, given by a stochastic differential equation. In comparison to previously proposed stochastic models, the obtained process is infinitely differentiable at a given finite Reynolds numb…
▽ More
We develop a stochastic model for Lagrangian velocity as it is observed in experimental and numerical fully developed turbulent flows. We define it as the unique statistically stationary solution of a causal dynamics, given by a stochastic differential equation. In comparison to previously proposed stochastic models, the obtained process is infinitely differentiable at a given finite Reynolds number, and its second-order statistical properties converge to those of an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process in the infinite Reynolds number limit. In this limit, it exhibits furthermore intermittent scaling properties, as they can be quantified using higher-order statistics. To achieve this, we begin with generalizing the two-layered embedded stochastic process of Sawford (1991) by considering an infinite number of layers. We then study, both theoretically and numerically, the convergence towards a smooth (i.e. infinitely differentiable) Gaussian process. To include intermittent corrections, we follow similar considerations as for the multifractal random walk of Bacry et al. (2001). We derive in an exact manner the statistical properties of this process, and compare them to those estimated from Lagrangian trajectories extracted from numerically simulated turbulent flows. Key predictions of the multifractal formalism regarding acceleration correlation function and high-order structure functions are also derived. Through these predictions, we understand phenomenologically peculiar behaviours of the fluctuations in the dissipative range, that are not reproduced by our stochastic process. The proposed theoretical method regarding the modelling of infinitely differentiability opens the route to the full stochastic modelling of velocity, including the peculiar action of viscosity on the very fine scales.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2020; v1 submitted 20 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
On the decay of dispersive motions in the outer region of rough-wall boundary layers
Authors:
Johan Meyers,
Bharathram Ganapathisubramani,
Raúl Bayoán Cal
Abstract:
In rough-wall boundary layers, wall-parallel non-homogeneous mean-flow solutions exist that lead to so-called dispersive velocity components and dispersive stresses. They play a significant role in the mean-flow momentum balance near the wall, but typically disappear in the outer layer. A theoretical framework is presented to study the decay of dispersive motions in the outer layer. To this end, t…
▽ More
In rough-wall boundary layers, wall-parallel non-homogeneous mean-flow solutions exist that lead to so-called dispersive velocity components and dispersive stresses. They play a significant role in the mean-flow momentum balance near the wall, but typically disappear in the outer layer. A theoretical framework is presented to study the decay of dispersive motions in the outer layer. To this end, the problem is formulated in Fourier space, and a set of governing ordinary differential equations per mode in wavenumber space is derived by linearizing the Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations around a constant background velocity. With further simplifications, analytically tractable solutions are found consisting of linear combinations of $\exp(-kz)$ and $\exp(-Kz)$, with $z$ the wall distance, $k$ the magnitude of the horizontal wavevector $\mathbf{k}$, and where $K(\mathbf{k},\textit{Re})$ is a function of $\mathbf{k}$ and the Reynolds number $\textit{Re}$. Moreover, for $k\rightarrow \infty$ or $k_1\rightarrow 0$, $K\rightarrow k$ is found, in which case solutions consist of a linear combination of $\exp(-kz)$ and $z\exp(-kz)$, and are Reynolds number independent. These analytical relations are verified in the limit of $k_1=0$ using the rough boundary layer experiments by Vanderwel and Ganapathisubramani (J. Fluid Mech. 774, R2, 2015) and are in good agreement for $\ell_k/δ\leq 0.5$, with $δ$ the boundary-layer thickness and $\ell_k = 2π/k$.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Turbulent Boundary Layer Features via Lagrangian Coherent Structures, Proper Orthogonal Decomposition and Dynamic Mode Decomposition
Authors:
Naseem Ali,
Murat Tutkun,
Raúl Bayoán Cal
Abstract:
High-speed stereo PIV-measurements have been performed in a turbulent boundary layer at Re$_θ$ of 9800 in order to elucidate the coherent structures. Snapshot proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) are used to visualize the flow structure depending on the turbulent kinetic energy and frequency content. The first six POD and DMD modes show the largest and the low…
▽ More
High-speed stereo PIV-measurements have been performed in a turbulent boundary layer at Re$_θ$ of 9800 in order to elucidate the coherent structures. Snapshot proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) are used to visualize the flow structure depending on the turbulent kinetic energy and frequency content. The first six POD and DMD modes show the largest and the lowest amount of energy and frequency, respectively. Lagrangian coherent structure (LCS) based on the algorithm developed using the variational theory is also applied to track the flow via attracting and repelling trajectories. The shapes and the length of the trajectories show variation with increasing advection time. LCS trajectories are overlayed with the individual POD and DMD modes. Repelling and attracting lines cover the structure of these modes. Reconstructed flow fields from individual POD modes are also used to generate new LCS trajectories. The energy and frequency content have a direct impact on the length of the trajectories, where the longest reconstructed trajectories associate with the higher energy and lower frequency modes, and vise verse. The multiple intersection points between the repelling and attracting lines marked the low momentum regions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
