Demystifying amortized causal discovery with transformers
Authors:
Francesco Montagna,
Max Cairney-Leeming,
Dhanya Sridhar,
Francesco Locatello
Abstract:
Supervised learning approaches for causal discovery from observational data often achieve competitive performance despite seemingly avoiding explicit assumptions that traditional methods make for identifiability. In this work, we investigate CSIvA (Ke et al., 2023), a transformer-based model promising to train on synthetic data and transfer to real data. First, we bridge the gap with existing iden…
▽ More
Supervised learning approaches for causal discovery from observational data often achieve competitive performance despite seemingly avoiding explicit assumptions that traditional methods make for identifiability. In this work, we investigate CSIvA (Ke et al., 2023), a transformer-based model promising to train on synthetic data and transfer to real data. First, we bridge the gap with existing identifiability theory and show that constraints on the training data distribution implicitly define a prior on the test observations. Consistent with classical approaches, good performance is achieved when we have a good prior on the test data, and the underlying model is identifiable. At the same time, we find new trade-offs. Training on datasets generated from different classes of causal models, unambiguously identifiable in isolation, improves the test generalization. Performance is still guaranteed, as the ambiguous cases resulting from the mixture of identifiable causal models are unlikely to occur (which we formally prove). Overall, our study finds that amortized causal discovery still needs to obey identifiability theory, but it also differs from classical methods in how the assumptions are formulated, trading more reliance on assumptions on the noise type for fewer hypotheses on the mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
PriorCVAE: scalable MCMC parameter inference with Bayesian deep generative modelling
Authors:
Elizaveta Semenova,
Prakhar Verma,
Max Cairney-Leeming,
Arno Solin,
Samir Bhatt,
Seth Flaxman
Abstract:
Recent advances have shown that GP priors, or their finite realisations, can be encoded using deep generative models such as variational autoencoders (VAEs). These learned generators can serve as drop-in replacements for the original priors during MCMC inference. While this approach enables efficient inference, it loses information about the hyperparameters of the original models, and consequently…
▽ More
Recent advances have shown that GP priors, or their finite realisations, can be encoded using deep generative models such as variational autoencoders (VAEs). These learned generators can serve as drop-in replacements for the original priors during MCMC inference. While this approach enables efficient inference, it loses information about the hyperparameters of the original models, and consequently makes inference over hyperparameters impossible and the learned priors indistinct. To overcome this limitation, we condition the VAE on stochastic process hyperparameters. This allows the joint encoding of hyperparameters with GP realizations and their subsequent estimation during inference. Further, we demonstrate that our proposed method, PriorCVAE, is agnostic to the nature of the models which it approximates, and can be used, for instance, to encode solutions of ODEs. It provides a practical tool for approximate inference and shows potential in real-life spatial and spatiotemporal applications.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2023; v1 submitted 9 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
