-
Inefficient star formation in high Mach number environments. II. Numerical simulations and comparison with analytical models
Authors:
Noé Brucy,
Patrick Hennebelle,
Tine Colman,
Ralf S. Klessen,
Corentin Le Yhuelic
Abstract:
Predicting the star formation rate (SFR) in galaxies is crucial to understand their evolution and morphology. To do so requires a fine understanding of how dense structures of gas are created and collapse. In that, turbulence and gravity play a major role. Within the gravo-turbulent framework, we assume that turbulence shapes the ISM, creating density fluctuations that, if gravitationally unstable…
▽ More
Predicting the star formation rate (SFR) in galaxies is crucial to understand their evolution and morphology. To do so requires a fine understanding of how dense structures of gas are created and collapse. In that, turbulence and gravity play a major role. Within the gravo-turbulent framework, we assume that turbulence shapes the ISM, creating density fluctuations that, if gravitationally unstable, will collapse and form stars. The goal of this work is to quantify how different regimes of turbulence, characterized by the strength and compressibility of the driving, shape the density field. We are interested in the outcome in terms of SFR and how it compares with existing analytical models for the SFR. We run a series of hydrodynamical simulations of turbulent gas. The simulations are first conducted without gravity, so that the density and velocity are shaped by the turbulence driving. Gravity is then switched on, and the SFR is measured and compared with analytical models. The physics included in these simulations is very close to the one assumed in the classical gravo-turbulent SFR analytical models, which makes the comparison straightforward. We found that the existing analytical models convincingly agree with simulations at low Mach number, but we measure a much lower SFR in the simulation with a high Mach number. We develop, in a companion paper, an updated physically-motivated SFR model that reproduces well the inefficient high Mach regime of the simulations. Our work demonstrates that accurate estimations of the turbulent-driven replenishment time of dense structures and the dense gas spatial distribution are necessary to correctly predict the SFR in the high Mach regime. The inefficient high-Mach regime is a possible explanation for the low SFR found in dense and turbulent environments such as the centers of our Milky Way and other galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Inefficient star formation in high Mach number environments I. The turbulent support analytical model
Authors:
Patrick Hennebelle,
Noé Brucy,
Tine Colman
Abstract:
The star formation rate (SFR), the number of stars formed per unit of time, is a fundamental quantity in the evolution of the Universe. While turbulence is believed to play a crucial role in setting the SFR, the exact mechanism remains unclear. Turbulence promotes star formation by compressing the gas, but also slows it down by stabilizing the gas against gravity. Most widely-used analytical model…
▽ More
The star formation rate (SFR), the number of stars formed per unit of time, is a fundamental quantity in the evolution of the Universe. While turbulence is believed to play a crucial role in setting the SFR, the exact mechanism remains unclear. Turbulence promotes star formation by compressing the gas, but also slows it down by stabilizing the gas against gravity. Most widely-used analytical models rely on questionable assumptions, including: $i)$ integrating over the density PDF, a one-point statistical description that ignores spatial correlation, $ii)$ selecting self-gravitating gas based on a density threshold that often ignores turbulent dispersion, $iii)$ assuming the freefall time as the timescale for estimating SFR without considering the need to rejuvenate the density PDF, $iv)$ assuming the density PDF to be lognormal. Improving upon the only existing model that incorporates the spatial correlation of the density field, we present a new analytical model. We calculate the time needed to rejuvenate density fluctuations of a given density and spatial scale, revealing that it is generally much longer than the freefall time, rendering the latter inappropriate for use. We make specific predictions regarding the role of the Mach number, $ M $, and the driving scale of turbulence divided by the mean Jeans length. At low to moderate Mach numbers, turbulence does not reduce and may even slightly promote star formation by broadening the PDF. However, at higher Mach numbers, most density fluctuations are stabilized by turbulent dispersion, leading to a steep drop in the SFR as the Mach number increases.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Testing kinematic distances under a realistic Galactic potential
Authors:
Glen H. Hunter,
Mattia C. Sormani,
Jan P. Beckmann,
Eugene Vasiliev,
Simon C. O. Glover,
Ralf S. Klessen,
Juan D. Soler,
Noé Brucy,
Philipp Girichidis,
Junia Göller,
Loke Ohlin,
Robin Tress,
Sergio Molinari,
Ortwin Gerhard,
Milena Benedettini,
Rowan Smith,
Patrick Hennebelle,
Leonardo Testi
Abstract:
Obtaining reliable distance estimates to gas clouds within the Milky Way is challenging in the absence of certain tracers. The kinematic distance approach has been used as an alternative, derived from the assumption of circular trajectories around the Galactic centre. Consequently, significant errors are expected in regions where gas flow deviates from purely circular motions. We aim to quantify t…
▽ More
Obtaining reliable distance estimates to gas clouds within the Milky Way is challenging in the absence of certain tracers. The kinematic distance approach has been used as an alternative, derived from the assumption of circular trajectories around the Galactic centre. Consequently, significant errors are expected in regions where gas flow deviates from purely circular motions. We aim to quantify the systematic errors that arise from the kinematic distance method in the presence of a Galactic potential that is non-axisymmetric. We investigate how these errors differ in certain regions of the Galaxy and how they relate to the underlying dynamics. We perform 2D isothermal hydrodynamical simulation of the gas disk with the moving-mesh code Arepo, adding the capability of using an external potential provided by the Agama library for galactic dynamics. We introduce a new analytic potential of the Milky Way, taking elements from existing models and adjusting parameters to match recent observational constraints. We find significant errors in the kinematic distance estimate for gas close to the Sun, along sight lines towards the Galactic centre and anti-centre, and significant deviations associated with the Galactic bar. Kinematic distance errors are low within the spiral arms as gas resides close to local potential minima and the resulting line-of-sight velocity is close to what is expected for an axisymmetric potential. Interarm regions exhibit large deviations at any given Galactic radius. This is caused by the gas being sped up or slowed down as it travels into or out of the spiral arm. We are able to define 'zones of avoidance' in the lv-diagram, where the kinematic distance method is particularly unreliable and should only be used with caution. We report a power law relation between the kinematic distance error and the deviation of the project line-of-sight velocity from circular motion.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Magnetic field morphology and evolution in the Central Molecular Zone and its effect on gas dynamics
Authors:
R. G. Tress,
M. C. Sormani,
P. Girichidis,
S. C. O. Glover,
R. S. Klessen,
R. J. Smith,
E. Sobacchi,
L. Armillotta,
A. T. Barnes,
C. Battersby,
K. R. J. Bogue,
N. Brucy,
L. Colzi,
C. Federrath,
P. García,
A. Ginsburg,
J. Göller,
H P. Hatchfield,
C. Henkel,
P. Hennebelle,
J. D. Henshaw,
M. Hirschmann,
Y. Hu,
J. Kauffmann,
J. M. D. Kruijssen
, et al. (12 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The interstellar medium in the Milky Way's Central Molecular Zone (CMZ) is known to be strongly magnetised, but its large-scale morphology and impact on the gas dynamics are not well understood. We explore the impact and properties of magnetic fields in the CMZ using three-dimensional non-self gravitating magnetohydrodynamical simulations of gas flow in an external Milky Way barred potential. We f…
▽ More
The interstellar medium in the Milky Way's Central Molecular Zone (CMZ) is known to be strongly magnetised, but its large-scale morphology and impact on the gas dynamics are not well understood. We explore the impact and properties of magnetic fields in the CMZ using three-dimensional non-self gravitating magnetohydrodynamical simulations of gas flow in an external Milky Way barred potential. We find that: (1) The magnetic field is conveniently decomposed into a regular time-averaged component and an irregular turbulent component. The regular component aligns well with the velocity vectors of the gas everywhere, including within the bar lanes. (2) The field geometry transitions from parallel to the Galactic plane near $z=0$ to poloidal away from the plane. (3) The magneto-rotational instability (MRI) causes an in-plane inflow of matter from the CMZ gas ring towards the central few parsecs of $0.01-0.1$ M$_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$ that is absent in the unmagnetised simulations. However, the magnetic fields have no significant effect on the larger-scale bar-driven inflow that brings the gas from the Galactic disc into the CMZ. (4) A combination of bar inflow and MRI-driven turbulence can sustain a turbulent vertical velocity dispersion of $σ_z \simeq 5$ km s$^{-1}$ on scales of $20$ pc in the CMZ ring. The MRI alone sustains a velocity dispersion of $σ_z \simeq 3$ km s$^{-1}$. Both these numbers are lower than the observed velocity dispersion of gas in the CMZ, suggesting that other processes such as stellar feedback are necessary to explain the observations. (5) Dynamo action driven by differential rotation and the MRI amplifies the magnetic fields in the CMZ ring until they saturate at a value that scales with the average local density as $B \simeq 102 (n/10^3 cm^{-3})^{0.33}$ $μ$G. Finally, we discuss the implications of our results within the observational context in the CMZ.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Cloud properties across spatial scales in simulations of the interstellar medium
Authors:
Tine Colman,
Noé Brucy,
Philipp Girichidis,
Simon C. O Glover,
Milena Benedettini,
Juan D. Soler,
Robin G. Tress,
Alessio Traficante,
Patrick Hennebelle,
Ralf S. Klessen,
Sergio Molinari,
Marc-Antoine Miville-Deschênes
Abstract:
Molecular clouds (MC) are structures of dense gas in the interstellar medium (ISM), that extend from ten to a few hundred parsecs and form the main gas reservoir available for star formation. Hydrodynamical simulations of varying complexity are a promising way to investigate MC evolution and their properties. However, each simulation typically has a limited range in resolution and different cloud…
▽ More
Molecular clouds (MC) are structures of dense gas in the interstellar medium (ISM), that extend from ten to a few hundred parsecs and form the main gas reservoir available for star formation. Hydrodynamical simulations of varying complexity are a promising way to investigate MC evolution and their properties. However, each simulation typically has a limited range in resolution and different cloud extraction algorithms are used, which complicates the comparison between simulations. In this work, we aim to extract clouds from different simulations covering a wide range of spatial scales. We compare their properties, such as size, shape, mass, internal velocity dispersion and virial state. We apply the Hop cloud detection algorithm on (M)HD numerical simulations of stratified ISM boxes and isolated galactic disk simulations that were produced using Flash Ramses and Arepo We find that the extracted clouds are complex in shape ranging from round objects to complex filamentary networks in all setups. Despite the wide range of scales, resolution, and sub-grid physics, we observe surprisingly robust trends in the investigated metrics. The mass spectrum matches in the overlap between simulations without rescaling and with a high-mass slope of $\mathrm{d} N/\mathrm{d}\ln M\propto-1$ in accordance with theoretical predictions. The internal velocity dispersion scales with the size of the cloud as $σ\propto R^{0.75}$ for large clouds ($R\gtrsim3\,\mathrm{pc}$). For small clouds we find larger sigma compared to the power-law scaling, as seen in observations, which is due to supernova-driven turbulence. Almost all clouds are gravitationally unbound with the virial parameter scaling as $α_\mathrm{vir}\propto M^{-0.4}$, which is slightly flatter compared to observed scaling, but in agreement given the large scatter.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Large-scale turbulent driving regulates star formation in high-redshift gas-rich galaxies II: Influence of the magnetic field and the turbulent compressive fraction
Authors:
Noé Brucy,
Patrick Hennebelle,
Tine Colman,
Simon Iteanu
Abstract:
The observed star formation rate (SFR) in galaxies is well below what it should be if gravitational collapse alone were at play. It has recently been shown that one candidate that might regulate star formation, the feedback from massive stars, is suitable only if the mean column density at the kiloparsec scale is lower than $\approx 20 M_\odot\cdot\mathrm{pc}^{-2}$. On the other hand, intense larg…
▽ More
The observed star formation rate (SFR) in galaxies is well below what it should be if gravitational collapse alone were at play. It has recently been shown that one candidate that might regulate star formation, the feedback from massive stars, is suitable only if the mean column density at the kiloparsec scale is lower than $\approx 20 M_\odot\cdot\mathrm{pc}^{-2}$. On the other hand, intense large-scale turbulent driving might slow down star formation in high-density environments to values that are compatible with observations. In this work, we explore the effect of the nature and strength of the turbulent driving, as well as the effect of the magnetic field. We performed a large series of feedback-regulated numerical simulations of the interstellar medium in which bidimensional large-scale turbulent driving was also applied. We determined the driving intensity needed to reproduce the Schmidt-Kennicutt relation for several gas column densities, magnetization, and driving compressibility. We confirm that in the absence of turbulent forcing and even with a substantial magnetic field, the SFR is too high, particularly at a high column density, compared to the Schmidt-Kennicutt relation. We find that the SFR outcome strongly depends on the initial magnetic field and on the compressibility of the turbulent driving. As a consequence, a higher magnetic field in high column density environment may lower the energy necessary to sustain a turbulence that is sufficiently intense to regulate star formation. Stellar feedback does not seem to be sufficient to regulate star formation in gas-rich galaxies where large-scale turbulent driving may be needed. The sources of this large-scale turbulence as well as its characteristics, such as its intensity, compressibility, and anisotropy, need to be understood and quantified.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2023; v1 submitted 29 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Universal gravity-driven isothermal turbulence cascade in disk galaxies
Authors:
Jérémy Fensch,
Frédéric Bournaud,
Noé Brucy,
Yohan Dubois,
Patrick Hennebelle,
Joakim Rosdahl
Abstract:
While interstellar gas is known to be supersonically turbulent, the injection processes of this turbulence are still unclear. Many studies suggest a dominant role of gravitational instabilities. However, their effect on galaxy morphology and large-scale dynamics vary across cosmic times, in particular due to the evolution of the gas fraction of galaxies. In this paper, we propose numerical simulat…
▽ More
While interstellar gas is known to be supersonically turbulent, the injection processes of this turbulence are still unclear. Many studies suggest a dominant role of gravitational instabilities. However, their effect on galaxy morphology and large-scale dynamics vary across cosmic times, in particular due to the evolution of the gas fraction of galaxies. In this paper, we propose numerical simulations to follow the isothermal turbulent cascade of purely gravitationally-driven turbulence from its injection scale down to 0.095 pc for a gas-poor spiral disk and a gas-rich clumpy disk. To this purpose, and to lift the memory-footprint technical lock of sufficiently resolving the interstellar medium of a galaxy, we developed an encapsulated zoom method that allows us to probe self-consistently the self-generated turbulence cascade over three orders of magnitude on spatial scales. We follow this cascade for 10 Myrs. We find that the turbulent cascade follows the same scaling laws in both setups. Namely, in both cases the turbulence is close to equipartition between its compressive and solenoidal modes, the velocity power spectrum follows the Burgers' scaling and the density power spectrum is rather shallow, with a power-law slope of -0.7. Last, gravitationally-bound substructures follow a mass distribution with a -1.8 slope, similar to that of CO clumps. These simulations thus suggest a universality of gravity-driven isothermal turbulent cascade in disk galaxies across cosmic time.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
The signature of large scale turbulence driving on the structure of the interstellar medium
Authors:
Tine Colman,
Jean-François Robitaille,
Patrick Hennebelle,
Marc-Antoine Miville-Deschênes,
Noé Brucy,
Ralf S. Klessen,
Simon C. O. Glover,
Juan D. Soler,
Davide Elia,
Alessio Traficante,
Sergio Molinari,
Leonardo Testi
Abstract:
The mechanisms that maintain turbulence in the interstellar medium (ISM) are still not identified. This work investigates how we can distinguish between two fundamental driving mechanisms: the accumulated effect of stellar feedback versus the energy injection from Galactic scales. We perform a series of numerical simulations describing a stratified star forming ISM subject to self-consistent stell…
▽ More
The mechanisms that maintain turbulence in the interstellar medium (ISM) are still not identified. This work investigates how we can distinguish between two fundamental driving mechanisms: the accumulated effect of stellar feedback versus the energy injection from Galactic scales. We perform a series of numerical simulations describing a stratified star forming ISM subject to self-consistent stellar feedback. Large scale external turbulent driving of various intensities is added to mimic galactic driving mechanisms. We analyse the resulting column density maps with a technique called Multi-scale non-Gaussian segmentation that separates the coherent structures and the Gaussian background. This effectively discriminates between the various simulations and is a promising method to understand the ISM structure. In particular the power spectrum of the coherent structures flattens above 60 pc when turbulence is driven only by stellar feedback. When large-scale driving is applied, the turn-over shifts to larger scales. A systematic comparison with the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) is then performed. Only 1 out of 25 regions has a coherent power spectrum which is consistent with the feedback-only simulation. A detailed study of the turn-over scale leads us to conclude that regular stellar feedback is not enough to explain the observed ISM structure on scales larger than 60 pc. Extreme feedback in the form of supergiant shells likely plays an important role but cannot explain all the regions of the LMC. If we assume ISM structure is generated by turbulence, another large scale driving mechanism is needed to explain the entirety of the observations.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
A two-step gravitational cascade for the fragmentation of self-gravitating discs
Authors:
Noé Brucy,
Patrick Hennebelle
Abstract:
Self-gravitating discs are believed to play an important role in astrophysics in particular regarding the star and planet formation process. In this context, discs subject to an idealized cooling process, characterized by a cooling timescale $β$ expressed in unit of orbital timescale, have been extensively studied. We take advantage of the Riemann solver and the 3D Godunov scheme implemented in th…
▽ More
Self-gravitating discs are believed to play an important role in astrophysics in particular regarding the star and planet formation process. In this context, discs subject to an idealized cooling process, characterized by a cooling timescale $β$ expressed in unit of orbital timescale, have been extensively studied. We take advantage of the Riemann solver and the 3D Godunov scheme implemented in the code Ramses to perform high resolution simulations, complementing previous studies that have used smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) or 2D grid codes. We observe that the critical value of $β$ for which the disc fragments is consistent with most previous results, and is not well converged with resolution. By studying the probability density function of the fluctuations of the column density ($Σ$-PDF), we argue that there is no strict separation between the fragmented and the unfragmented regimes but rather a smooth transition with the probability of apparition of fragments steadily diminishing as the cooling becames less effective. We find that the high column density part of the $Σ$-PDF follows a simple power law whose slope turns out to be proportional to $β$ and we propose an explanation based on the balance between cooling and heating through gravitational stress. Our explanation suggests that a more efficient cooling requires more heating implying a larger fraction of dense material which, in the absence of characteristic scales, results in a shallower scale-free power law. We propose that the gravitational cascade proceeds in two steps, first the formation of a dense filamentary spiral pattern through a sequence of quasi-static equilibrium triggered by the viscous transport of angular momentum, and second the collapse alongside these filaments that eventually results in the formation of bounded fragments.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2021; v1 submitted 9 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Large-scale turbulent driving regulates star formation in high-redshift gas-rich galaxies
Authors:
Noé Brucy,
Patrick Hennebelle,
Frédéric Bournaud,
Cédric Colling
Abstract:
The question of what regulates star formation is a long standing issue. To investigate this issue, we run simulations of a kiloparsec cube section of a galaxy with three kinds of stellar feedback: the formation of HII regions, the explosion of supernovae, and the UV heating. We show that stellar feedback is sufficient to reduce the averaged star formation rate (SFR) to the level of the Schmidt- Ke…
▽ More
The question of what regulates star formation is a long standing issue. To investigate this issue, we run simulations of a kiloparsec cube section of a galaxy with three kinds of stellar feedback: the formation of HII regions, the explosion of supernovae, and the UV heating. We show that stellar feedback is sufficient to reduce the averaged star formation rate (SFR) to the level of the Schmidt- Kennicutt law in Milky-Way like galaxies but not in high-redshift gas rich galaxies suggesting that another type of support should be added. We investigate whether an external driving of the turbulence such as the one created by the large galactic scales could diminish the SFR at the observed level. Assuming that the Toomre parameter is close to 1 as suggested by the observations, we infer a typical turbulent forcing that we argue should be applied parallel to the plane of the galactic disc. When this forcing is applied in our simulations, the SFR within our simulations closely follows the Schmidt- Kennicutt relation. We found that the velocity dispersion is strongly anisotropic with the velocity dispersion alongside the galactic plane being up to 10 times larger than the perpendicular velocity.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2020; v1 submitted 3 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
