-
Direct in-situ observations of wave-induced floe collisions in the deeper Marginal Ice Zone
Authors:
Lars Willas Dreyer,
Jean Rabault,
Atle Jensen,
Ingrid Dæhlen,
Øyvind Breivik,
Gaute Hope,
Yngve Kristoffersen
Abstract:
Ocean waves propagating through the Marginal Ice Zone (MIZ) and the pack ice are strongly attenuated. This attenuation is critical for protecting sea ice from energetic wave events that could otherwise lead to sea ice break-up and dislocation over large areas. Despite the importance of waves-in-ice attenuation, the exact physical mechanisms involved, and their relative importance, are still uncert…
▽ More
Ocean waves propagating through the Marginal Ice Zone (MIZ) and the pack ice are strongly attenuated. This attenuation is critical for protecting sea ice from energetic wave events that could otherwise lead to sea ice break-up and dislocation over large areas. Despite the importance of waves-in-ice attenuation, the exact physical mechanisms involved, and their relative importance, are still uncertain. Here we present for the first time direct in situ measurements of floe-floe interactions under the influence of waves, including collisions between adjacent floes. The collision events we report are aligned with the incoming wave direction, and phase-locked to the wave signal, which indicates that the individual collisions we detect are wave-induced. The observations demonstrate that wave attenuation by wave-induced floe-floe collisions, which have been studied in idealized laboratory and field experiments in the outer MIZ, are indeed a likely source of wave energy dissipation deep inside the MIZ as well.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024; v1 submitted 3 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
In-situ observations of strong waves in ice amplitude modulation with a 12-hour period: a likely signature of complex physics governing waves in ice attenuation?
Authors:
J. Rabault,
T. Halsne,
A. Carrasco,
A. Korosov,
J. Voermans,
P. Bohlinger,
J. B. Debernard,
M. Müller,
Ø. Breivik,
T. Nose,
G. Hope,
F. Collard,
S. Herlédan,
T. Kodaira,
N. Hughes,
Q. Zhang,
K. H. Christensen,
A. Babanin,
L. W. Dreyer,
C. Palerme,
L. Aouf,
K. Christakos,
A. Jensen,
J. Röhrs,
A. Marchenko
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Marginal Ice Zone (MIZ) forms a critical transition region between the ocean and sea ice cover as it protects the close ice further in from the effect of the steepest and most energetic open ocean waves. As waves propagate through the MIZ, they get exponentially attenuated. Unfortunately, the associated attenuation coefficient is difficult to accurately estimate and model, and there are still…
▽ More
The Marginal Ice Zone (MIZ) forms a critical transition region between the ocean and sea ice cover as it protects the close ice further in from the effect of the steepest and most energetic open ocean waves. As waves propagate through the MIZ, they get exponentially attenuated. Unfortunately, the associated attenuation coefficient is difficult to accurately estimate and model, and there are still large uncertainties around which attenuation mechanisms dominate depending on the conditions. This makes it challenging to predict waves in ice attenuation, as well as the effective impact of open ocean waves propagating into the MIZ on sea ice breakup and dynamics. Here, we report in-situ observations of strongly modulated waves-in-ice amplitude, with a modulation period of around 12 hours. We show that simple explanations, such as changes in the incoming open water waves, or the effect of tides and currents and bathymetry, cannot explain for the observed modulation. Therefore, the significant wave height modulation observed in the ice most likely comes from a modulation of the waves-in-ice attenuation coefficient. To explain this, we conjecture that one or several waves-in-ice attenuation mechanisms are periodically modulated and switched on and off in the area of interest. We gather evidence that sea ice convergence and divergence may be the factor driving this change in the waves in ice attenuation mechanisms and attenuation coefficient, for example by modulating the intensity of floe-floe interaction mechanisms. Since this conclusion is obtained, at least partially, by elimination, we acknowledge that additional measurements will be needed to provide a positive proof of our conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
SFY -- A lightweight, high-frequency and phase-resolving wave-buoy for coastal waters
Authors:
Gaute Hope,
Torunn Irene Seldal,
Jean Rabault,
Helge Thomas Bryhni,
Patrik Bohlinger,
Jan-Victor Björkqvist,
Tor Nordam,
Atle Kleven,
Arsalan Mostaani,
Birgitte Rugaard Furevik,
Lars Robert Hole,
Roger Storvik,
Øyvind Breivik
Abstract:
Small lightweight wave buoys, SFYs, designed to operate near the coast, have been developed. The buoys are designed to record and transmit the full time series of surface acceleration at $52$ Hz. The buoy uses the cellular network to transfer data and position (up to $80$ km from the base station). This reduces costs and increases band-width. The low cost and low weight permits the buoys to be dep…
▽ More
Small lightweight wave buoys, SFYs, designed to operate near the coast, have been developed. The buoys are designed to record and transmit the full time series of surface acceleration at $52$ Hz. The buoy uses the cellular network to transfer data and position (up to $80$ km from the base station). This reduces costs and increases band-width. The low cost and low weight permits the buoys to be deployed easily, and in arrays in areas where satellite and wave models struggle to resolve wave and current interaction. The buoys are tested in a wave-flume, the open water and in the breaking waves of the surf. The conditions range from calm to significant wave heights exceeding $7$ m and crashing breakers with accelerations exceeding $10$ g. The high sample rate captures the impulse of breaking waves, and allows them to be studied in detail. Breaking waves are measured and quantified in the open water. We measure breaking waves in the surf and recover the trajectory of waves breaking in the field to a higher degree than previously done. The time series of surface elevation, and accurate positioning, permits the signal of adjacent buoys to be correlated in a coherent phase-resolved way. Finally, we offer an explanation and solution for the ubiquitous low-frequency noise in IMU-based buoys and discuss necessary sampling and design to measure in areas of breaking waves.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2024; v1 submitted 4 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
NORA-Surge: A storm surge hindcast for the Norwegian Sea, the North Sea and the Barents Sea
Authors:
Nils Melsom Kristensen,
Paulina Tedesco,
Jean Rabault,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Øyvind Saetra,
Øyvind Breivik
Abstract:
Knowledge about statistics for water level variations along the coast due to storm surge is important for the utilization of the coastal zone. An open and freely available storm surge hindcast archive covering the coast of Norway and adjacent sea areas spanning the time period 1979-2022 is presented. The storm surge model is forced by wind stress and mean sea level pressure taken from the non-hydr…
▽ More
Knowledge about statistics for water level variations along the coast due to storm surge is important for the utilization of the coastal zone. An open and freely available storm surge hindcast archive covering the coast of Norway and adjacent sea areas spanning the time period 1979-2022 is presented. The storm surge model is forced by wind stress and mean sea level pressure taken from the non-hydrostatic NORA3 atmospheric hindcast. A dataset consisting of observations of water level from more than 90 water level gauges along the coasts of the North Sea and the Norwegian Sea is compiled and quality controlled, and used to assess the performance of the hindcast. The observational dataset is distributed in both time and space, and when considering all the available quality controlled data, the comparison with modelled water levels yield a mean absolute error (MAE) of 9.7 cm and a root mean square error (RMSE) of 12.4 cm. Values for MAE and RMSE scaled by the standard deviation of the observed storm surge for each station are 0.42 and 0.54 standard deviations, repsectively. When considering the geographical differences in characteristics of storm surge for different countries/regions, the values of MAE and RMSE are in the range 5.7-13.9 cm and 7.6-17.8 cm respectively, and 0.33-0.46 and 0.42-0.59 standard deviations for the scaled values. The minimum and maximum values for water level in the hindcast are -2.60 m and 3.92 m. In addition, 100-year return level estimates are calculated from the hindcast, with minimum and maximum values of, respectively, -2.75 m and 3.98 m. All minimum and maximum values are found in the southern North Sea area.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Wave Measurements using Open Source Ship Mounted Ultrasonic Altimeter and Motion Correction System during the One Ocean Expedition
Authors:
Judith Thu Ølberg,
Patrik Bohlinger,
Øyvind Breivik,
Kai H. Christensen,
Birgitte R. Furevik,
Lars R. Hole,
Gaute Hope,
Atle Jensen,
Fabian Knoblauch,
Ngoc-Thanh Nguyen,
Jean Rabault
Abstract:
This study reviews the design and signal processing of ship borne ultrasonic altimeter wave measurements. The system combines a downward facing ultrasonic altimeter to capture the sea surface elevation as a time series, and an inertial measurement unit to compensate for the ship's motion. The methodology is cost-effective, open source, and adaptable to various ships and platforms. The system was i…
▽ More
This study reviews the design and signal processing of ship borne ultrasonic altimeter wave measurements. The system combines a downward facing ultrasonic altimeter to capture the sea surface elevation as a time series, and an inertial measurement unit to compensate for the ship's motion. The methodology is cost-effective, open source, and adaptable to various ships and platforms. The system was installed on the barque Statsraad Lehmkuhl and recorded data continuously during the 20-month One Ocean Expedition. Results from 1-month crossing of the Tropical Atlantic are presented here. The one-dimensional wave spectrum and associated wave parameters are obtained from the sea surface elevation time series. The observed significant wave height agrees well with satellite altimetry and a spectral wave model. The agreement between observations and the spectral wave model is better for the mean wave period than the peak period. We perform Doppler shift corrections to improve wave period estimates by accounting for the speed of the ship relative to the waves. This correction enhances the accuracy of the mean period, but not the peak period. We suggest that the Doppler correction could be improved by complementing the data sources with directional wave measurements from a marine X-band radar.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Bias Correction of Operational Storm Surge Forecasts Using Neural Networks
Authors:
Paulina Tedesco,
Jean Rabault,
Martin Lilleeng Sætra,
Nils Melsom Kristensen,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Øyvind Breivik,
Cecilie Mauritzen,
Øyvind Sætra
Abstract:
Storm surges can give rise to extreme floods in coastal areas. The Norwegian Meteorological Institute produces 120-hour regional operational storm surge forecasts along the coast of Norway based on the Regional Ocean Modeling System (ROMS), using a model setup called Nordic4-SS. Despite advances in the development of models and computational capabilities, forecast errors remain large enough to imp…
▽ More
Storm surges can give rise to extreme floods in coastal areas. The Norwegian Meteorological Institute produces 120-hour regional operational storm surge forecasts along the coast of Norway based on the Regional Ocean Modeling System (ROMS), using a model setup called Nordic4-SS. Despite advances in the development of models and computational capabilities, forecast errors remain large enough to impact response measures and issued alerts, in particular, during the strongest events. Reducing these errors will positively impact the efficiency of the warning systems while minimizing efforts and resources spent on mitigation. Here, we investigate how forecasts can be improved with residual learning, i.e., training data-driven models to predict the residuals in forecasts from Nordic4-SS. A simple error map** technique and a more sophisticated Neural Network (NN) method are tested. Using the NN residual correction method, the Root Mean Square Error in the Oslo Fjord is reduced by 36% for lead times of one hour and 9% for 24 hours. Therefore, the residual NN method is a promising direction for correcting storm surge forecasts, especially on short timescales. Moreover, it is well adapted to being deployed operationally, as i) the correction is applied on top of the existing model and requires no changes to it, ii) all predictors used for NN inference are already available operationally, iii) prediction by the NNs is very fast, typically a few seconds per station, and iv) the NN correction can be provided to a human expert who may inspect it, compare it with the model output, and see how much correction is brought by the NN, allowing to capitalize on human expertise as a quality validation of the NN output. While no changes to the hydrodynamic model are necessary to calibrate the neural networks, they are specific to a given model and must be recalibrated when the numerical models are updated.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2023; v1 submitted 2 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
A dataset of direct observations of sea ice drift and waves in ice
Authors:
Jean Rabault,
Malte Müller,
Joey Voermans,
Dmitry Brazhnikov,
Ian Turnbull,
Aleksey Marchenko,
Martin Biuw,
Takehiko Nose,
Takuji Waseda,
Malin Johansson,
Øyvind Breivik,
Graig Sutherland,
Lars Robert Hole,
Mark Johnson,
Atle Jensen,
Olav Gundersen,
Yngve Kristoffersen,
Alexander Babanin,
Paulina Tedesco,
Kai Haakon Christensen,
Martin Kristiansen,
Gaute Hope,
Tsubasa Kodaira,
Victor de Aguiar,
Catherine Taelman
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Variability in sea ice conditions, combined with strong couplings to the atmosphere and the ocean, lead to a broad range of complex sea ice dynamics. More in-situ measurements are needed to better identify the phenomena and mechanisms that govern sea ice growth, drift, and breakup. To this end, we have gathered a dataset of in-situ observations of sea ice drift and waves in ice. A total of 15 depl…
▽ More
Variability in sea ice conditions, combined with strong couplings to the atmosphere and the ocean, lead to a broad range of complex sea ice dynamics. More in-situ measurements are needed to better identify the phenomena and mechanisms that govern sea ice growth, drift, and breakup. To this end, we have gathered a dataset of in-situ observations of sea ice drift and waves in ice. A total of 15 deployments were performed over a period of 5 years in both the Arctic and Antarctic, involving 72 instruments. These provide both GPS drift tracks, and measurements of waves in ice. The data can, in turn, be used for tuning sea ice drift models, investigating waves dam** by sea ice, and hel** calibrate other sea ice measurement techniques, such as satellite based observations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The Impact of a Reduced High-wind Charnock Parameter on Wave Growth With Application to the North Sea, the Norwegian Sea and the Arctic Ocean
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Ana Carrasco,
Hilde Haakenstad,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Arno Behrens,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot,
Jan-Victor Björkqvist,
Patrik Bohlinger,
Birgitte R Furevik,
Joanna Staneva,
Magnar Reistad
Abstract:
As atmospheric models move to higher resolution and resolve smaller scales, the maximum modeled wind speed also tends to increase. Wave models tuned to coarser wind fields tend to overestimate the wave growth under strong winds. A recently developed semi-empirical parameterization of the Charnock parameter, which controls the roughness length over surface waves, substantially reduces the aerodynam…
▽ More
As atmospheric models move to higher resolution and resolve smaller scales, the maximum modeled wind speed also tends to increase. Wave models tuned to coarser wind fields tend to overestimate the wave growth under strong winds. A recently developed semi-empirical parameterization of the Charnock parameter, which controls the roughness length over surface waves, substantially reduces the aerodynamic drag of waves in high winds (above a threshold of 30 m/s). Here we apply the formulation in a recent version of the wave model WAM (Cycle 4.7), which uses a modified version of the physics parameterizations by Ardhuin et al (2010) as well as subgrid obstructions for better performance around complex topography. The new Charnock formulation is tested with wind forcing from NORA3, a recently completed non-hydrostatic atmospheric downscaling of the global reanalysis ERA5 for the North Sea, the Norwegian Sea and the Barents Sea. Such high-resolution atmospheric model integrations tend to have stronger (and more realistic) upper-percentile winds than what is typically found in coarser atmospheric models. A two-year comparison (2011-2012) of a control run against the run with the modified Charnock parameter shows a dramatic reduction of the wave height bias in high-wind cases. The added computational cost of the new physics and the reduction of the Charnock parameter compared to the earlier WAM physics is modest (14%). A longer (1998-2020) hindcast integration with the new Charnock parameter is found to compare well against in situ and altimeter wave measurements both for intermediate and high sea states.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
OpenMetBuoy-V2021: an easy-to-build, affordable, customizable, open source instrument for oceanographic measurements of drift and waves in sea ice and the open ocean
Authors:
Jean Rabault,
Takehiko Nose,
Gaute Hope,
Malte Muller,
Oyvind Breivik,
Joey Voermans,
Lars Robert Hole,
Patrik Bohlinger,
Takuji Waseda,
Tsubasa Kodaira,
Tomotaka Katsuno,
Mark Johnson,
Graig Sutherland,
Malin Johanson,
Kai Haakon Christensen,
Adam Garbo,
Atle Jensen,
Olav Gundersen,
Aleksey Marchenko,
Alexander Babanin
Abstract:
There is a wide consensus within the polar science, meteorology, and oceanography communities that more in-situ observations of the ocean, atmosphere, and sea ice, are required to further improve operational forecasting model skills. Traditionally, the volume of such measurements has been limited by the high cost of commercially available instruments. An increasingly attractive solution to this co…
▽ More
There is a wide consensus within the polar science, meteorology, and oceanography communities that more in-situ observations of the ocean, atmosphere, and sea ice, are required to further improve operational forecasting model skills. Traditionally, the volume of such measurements has been limited by the high cost of commercially available instruments. An increasingly attractive solution to this cost issue is to use instruments produced in-house from open source hardware, firmware, and post processing building blocks. In the present work, we release the next iteration of the open source drifter and waves monitoring instruments. The new design is both significantly less expensive, much easier to build and assemble for people without specific microelectronics and programming competence, more easily extendable and customizable, and two orders of magnitude more power efficient. Improving performance and reducing noise levels and costs compared with our previous generation of instruments is possible in large part thanks to progress from the electronics component industry. As a result, we believe that this will allow scientists in geosciences to increase by an order of magnitude the amount of in-situ data they can collect under a constant instrumentation budget. In the following, we offer 1) detailed overview of our hardware and software solution, 2) in-situ validation and benchmarking of our instrument, 3) full open source release of both hardware and software blueprints. We hope that this work, and the associated open source release, may be a milestone that will allow our scientific fields to transition towards open source, community driven instrumentation. We believe that this could have a considerable impact on many fields, by making in-situ instrumentation at least an order of magnitude less expensive and more customizable than it has been for the last 50 years.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Evaluating the leeway coefficient for different ocean drifters using operational models
Authors:
Graig Sutherland,
Nancy Soontiens,
Fraser Davidson,
Gregory C. Smith,
Natacha Bernier,
Hauke Blanken,
Douglas Schillinger,
Guillaume Marcotte,
Johannes Röhrs,
Knut-Frode Dagestad,
Kai H. Christensen,
Oyvind Breivik
Abstract:
The water following characteristics of six different drifter types are investigated using two different operational marine environmental prediction systems: one produced by Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) and the other produced by the Norwegian Meteorological Institute (METNO). These marine prediction systems include ocean circulation models, atmospheric models, and surface wave model…
▽ More
The water following characteristics of six different drifter types are investigated using two different operational marine environmental prediction systems: one produced by Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) and the other produced by the Norwegian Meteorological Institute (METNO). These marine prediction systems include ocean circulation models, atmospheric models, and surface wave models. Two leeway models are tested for use in drift object prediction: an implicit leeway model where the Stokes drift is implicit in the leeway coefficient, and an explicit leeway model where the Stokes drift is provided by the wave model. Both leeway coefficients are allowed to vary in direction and time in order to perfectly reproduce the observed drifter trajectory. This creates a time series of the leeway coefficients which exactly reproduce the observed drifter trajectories. Mean values for the leeway coefficients are consistent with previous studies which utilized direct observations of the leeway. For all drifters and models, the largest source of variance in the leeway coefficient occurs at the inertial frequency and the evidence suggests it is related to uncertainties in the ocean inertial currents.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
An Open Source, Versatile, Affordable Waves in Ice Instrument for Scientific Measurements in the Polar Regions
Authors:
Jean Rabault,
Graig Sutherland,
Olav Gundersen,
Atle Jensen,
Aleksey Marchenko,
Øyvind Breivik
Abstract:
Sea ice is a major feature of the polar environments. Recent changes in the climate and extent of the sea ice, together with increased economic activity and research interest in these regions, are driving factors for new measurements of sea ice dynamics. Waves in ice are important as they participate in the coupling between the open ocean and the ice-covered regions. Measurements are challenging t…
▽ More
Sea ice is a major feature of the polar environments. Recent changes in the climate and extent of the sea ice, together with increased economic activity and research interest in these regions, are driving factors for new measurements of sea ice dynamics. Waves in ice are important as they participate in the coupling between the open ocean and the ice-covered regions. Measurements are challenging to perform due to remoteness and harsh environmental conditions. While progress has been made in observing wave propagtion in sea ice using remote methods, these are still relatively new measurements and would benefit from more in situ data for validation. In this article, we present an open source instrument that was developed for performing such measurements. The versatile design includes an ultra-low power unit, a microcontroller-based logger, a small microcomputer for on-board data processing, and an Iridium modem for satellite communications. Virtually any sensor can be used with this design. In the present case, we use an Inertial Motion Unit to record wave motion. High quality results were obtained, which opens new possibilities for in situ measurements in the polar regions. Our instrument can be easily customized to fit many in situ measurement tasks, and we hope that our work will provide a framework for future developments of a variety of such open source instruments.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2019; v1 submitted 8 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Shear and depth-averaged Stokes drift under a Phillips-type spectrum
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik
Abstract:
The transport and shear under a Phillips-type spectrum are presented. A combined profile for monochromatic swell and a Phillips-type wind sea spectrum which can be used to investigate the shear under crossing seas is then presented.
The transport and shear under a Phillips-type spectrum are presented. A combined profile for monochromatic swell and a Phillips-type wind sea spectrum which can be used to investigate the shear under crossing seas is then presented.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2016; v1 submitted 21 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
A Stokes drift approximation based on the Phillips spectrum
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot,
Peter A. E. M. Janssen
Abstract:
A new approximation to the Stokes drift velocity profile based on the exact solution for the Phillips spectrum is explored. The profile is compared with the monochromatic profile and the recently proposed exponential integral profile. ERA-Interim spectra and spectra from a wave buoy in the central North Sea are used to investigate the behaviour of the profile. It is found that the new profile has…
▽ More
A new approximation to the Stokes drift velocity profile based on the exact solution for the Phillips spectrum is explored. The profile is compared with the monochromatic profile and the recently proposed exponential integral profile. ERA-Interim spectra and spectra from a wave buoy in the central North Sea are used to investigate the behaviour of the profile. It is found that the new profile has a much stronger gradient near the surface and lower normalized deviation from the profile computed from the spectra. Based on estimates from two open-ocean locations, an average value has been estimated for a key parameter of the profile. Given this parameter, the profile can be computed from the same two parameters as the monochromatic profile, namely the transport and the surface Stokes drift velocity.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2016; v1 submitted 29 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Surface Wave Effects in the NEMO Ocean Model: Forced and Coupled Experiments
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Kristian Mogensen,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot,
Magdalena Alonso Balmaseda,
Peter A. E. M. Janssen
Abstract:
The NEMO general circulation ocean model is extended to incorporate three physical processes related to ocean surface waves, namely the surface stress (modified by growth and dissipation of the oceanic wave field), the turbulent kinetic energy flux from breaking waves, and the Stokes-Coriolis force. Experiments are done with NEMO in ocean-only (forced) mode and coupled to the ECMWF atmospheric and…
▽ More
The NEMO general circulation ocean model is extended to incorporate three physical processes related to ocean surface waves, namely the surface stress (modified by growth and dissipation of the oceanic wave field), the turbulent kinetic energy flux from breaking waves, and the Stokes-Coriolis force. Experiments are done with NEMO in ocean-only (forced) mode and coupled to the ECMWF atmospheric and wave models. Ocean-only integrations are forced with fields from the ERA-Interim reanalysis. All three effects are noticeable in the extra-tropics, but the sea-state dependent turbulent kinetic energy flux yields by far the largest difference. This is partly because the control run has too vigorous deep mixing due to an empirical mixing term in NEMO. We investigate the relation between this ad hoc mixing and Langmuir turbulence and find that it is much more effective than the Langmuir parameterization used in NEMO. The biases in sea surface temperature as well as subsurface temperature are reduced, and the total ocean heat content exhibits a trend closer to that observed in a recent ocean reanalysis (ORAS4) when wave effects are included. Seasonal integrations of the coupled atmosphere-wave-ocean model consisting of NEMO, the wave model ECWAM and the atmospheric model of ECMWF similarly show that the sea surface temperature biases are greatly reduced when the mixing is controlled by the sea state and properly weighted by the thickness of the uppermost level of the ocean model. These wave-related physical processes were recently implemented in the operational coupled ensemble forecast system of ECMWF.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2015; v1 submitted 26 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
The International Workshop on Wave Hindcasting and Forecasting and the Coastal Hazards Symposium
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Val Swail,
Alexander Babanin,
Kevin Horsburgh
Abstract:
Following the 13th International Workshop on Wave Hindcasting and Forecasting and 4th Coastal Hazards Symposium in October 2013 in Banff, Canada, a topical collection has appeared in recent issues of Ocean Dynamics. Here we give a brief overview of the history of the conference since its inception in 1986 and of the progress made in the fields of wind-generated ocean waves and the modelling of coa…
▽ More
Following the 13th International Workshop on Wave Hindcasting and Forecasting and 4th Coastal Hazards Symposium in October 2013 in Banff, Canada, a topical collection has appeared in recent issues of Ocean Dynamics. Here we give a brief overview of the history of the conference since its inception in 1986 and of the progress made in the fields of wind-generated ocean waves and the modelling of coastal hazards before we summarize the main results of the papers that have appeared in the topical collection.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Wind and Wave Extremes over the World Oceans from Very Large Ensembles
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Saleh Abdalla,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot,
Peter A. E. M. Janssen
Abstract:
Global return values of marine wind speed and significant wave height are estimated from very large aggregates of archived ensemble forecasts at +240-h lead time. Long lead time ensures that the forecasts represent independent draws from the model climate. Compared with ERA-Interim, a reanalysis, the ensemble yields higher return estimates for both wind speed and significant wave height. Confidenc…
▽ More
Global return values of marine wind speed and significant wave height are estimated from very large aggregates of archived ensemble forecasts at +240-h lead time. Long lead time ensures that the forecasts represent independent draws from the model climate. Compared with ERA-Interim, a reanalysis, the ensemble yields higher return estimates for both wind speed and significant wave height. Confidence intervals are much tighter due to the large size of the dataset. The period (9 yrs) is short enough to be considered stationary even with climate change. Furthermore, the ensemble is large enough for non-parametric 100-yr return estimates to be made from order statistics. These direct return estimates compare well with extreme value estimates outside areas with tropical cyclones. Like any method employing modeled fields, it is sensitive to tail biases in the numerical model, but we find that the biases are moderate outside areas with tropical cyclones.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Approximate Stokes Drift Profiles in Deep Water
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Peter A E M Janssen,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot
Abstract:
A deep-water approximation to the Stokes drift velocity profile is explored as an alternative to the monochromatic profile. The alternative profile investigated relies on the same two quantities required for the monochromatic profile, viz the Stokes transport and the surface Stokes drift velocity. Comparisons with parametric spectra and profiles under wave spectra from the ERA-Interim reanalysis a…
▽ More
A deep-water approximation to the Stokes drift velocity profile is explored as an alternative to the monochromatic profile. The alternative profile investigated relies on the same two quantities required for the monochromatic profile, viz the Stokes transport and the surface Stokes drift velocity. Comparisons with parametric spectra and profiles under wave spectra from the ERA-Interim reanalysis and buoy observations reveal much better agreement than the monochromatic profile even for complex sea states. That the profile gives a closer match and a more correct shear has implications for ocean circulation models since the Coriolis-Stokes force depends on the magnitude and direction of the Stokes drift profile and Langmuir turbulence parameterizations depend sensitively on the shear of the profile. The alternative profile comes at no added numerical cost compared to the monochromatic profile.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Wind and Wave Extremes over the World Oceans From Very Large Forecast Ensembles
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Saleh Abdalla,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot
Abstract:
Global return value estimates of significant wave height and 10-m neutral wind speed are estimated from very large aggregations of archived ECMWF ensemble forecasts at +240-h lead time from the period 2003-2012. The upper percentiles are found to match ENVISAT wind speed better than ERA-Interim (ERA-I), which tends to be biased low. The return estimates are significantly higher for both wind speed…
▽ More
Global return value estimates of significant wave height and 10-m neutral wind speed are estimated from very large aggregations of archived ECMWF ensemble forecasts at +240-h lead time from the period 2003-2012. The upper percentiles are found to match ENVISAT wind speed better than ERA-Interim (ERA-I), which tends to be biased low. The return estimates are significantly higher for both wind speed and wave height in the extratropics and the subtropics than what is found from ERA-I, but lower than what is reported by Caires and Sterl (2005) and Vinoth and Young (2011). The highest discrepancies between ERA-I and ENS240 are found in the hurricane-prone areas, suggesting that the ensemble comes closer than ERA-I in capturing the intensity of tropical cyclones. The width of the confidence intervals are typically reduced by 70% due to the size of the data sets. Finally, non-parametric estimates of return values were computed from the tail of the distribution. These direct return estimates compare very well with Generalized Pareto estimates.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Wave Extremes in the North East Atlantic from Ensemble Forecasts
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot,
Ana Carrasco,
Øyvind Saetra
Abstract:
A method for estimating return values from ensembles of forecasts at advanced lead times is presented. Return values of significant wave height in the North-East Atlantic, the Norwegian Sea and the North Sea are computed from archived +240-h forecasts of the ECMWF ensemble prediction system (EPS) from 1999 to 2009.
We make three assumptions: First, each forecast is representative of a six-hour i…
▽ More
A method for estimating return values from ensembles of forecasts at advanced lead times is presented. Return values of significant wave height in the North-East Atlantic, the Norwegian Sea and the North Sea are computed from archived +240-h forecasts of the ECMWF ensemble prediction system (EPS) from 1999 to 2009.
We make three assumptions: First, each forecast is representative of a six-hour interval and collectively the data set is then comparable to a time period of 226 years. Second, the model climate matches the observed distribution, which we confirm by comparing with buoy data. Third, the ensemble members are sufficiently uncorrelated to be considered independent realizations of the model climate. We find anomaly correlations of 0.20, but peak events (>P97) are entirely uncorrelated. By comparing return values from individual members with return values of subsamples of the data set we also find that the estimates follow the same distribution and appear unaffected by correlations in the ensemble. The annual mean and variance over the 11-year archived period exhibit no significant departures from stationarity compared with a recent reforecast, i.e., there is no spurious trend due to model upgrades.
EPS yields significantly higher return values than ERA-40 and ERA-Interim and is in good agreement with the high-resolution hindcast NORA10, except in the lee of unresolved islands where EPS overestimates and in enclosed seas where it is biased low. Confidence intervals are half the width of those found for ERA-Interim due to the magnitude of the data set.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Advances in Search and Rescue at Sea
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Arthur Addoms Allen,
Christophe Maisondieu,
Michel Olagnon
Abstract:
A topical collection on "Advances in Search and Rescue at Sea" has appeared in recent issues of Ocean Dynamics following the latest in a series of workshops on "Technologies for Search and Rescue and other Emergency Marine Operations" (2004, 2006, 2008 and 2011), hosted by IFREMER in Brest, France.
Here we give a brief overview of the history of search and rescue at sea before we summarize the m…
▽ More
A topical collection on "Advances in Search and Rescue at Sea" has appeared in recent issues of Ocean Dynamics following the latest in a series of workshops on "Technologies for Search and Rescue and other Emergency Marine Operations" (2004, 2006, 2008 and 2011), hosted by IFREMER in Brest, France.
Here we give a brief overview of the history of search and rescue at sea before we summarize the main results of the papers that have appeared in the topical collection.
Keywords: Search and rescue (SAR), Trajectory modelling, Stochastic Lagrangian ocean models, Lagrangian measurement methods, ocean surface currents.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Real time assimilation of HF radar currents into a coastal ocean model
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Øyvind Saetra
Abstract:
A real time assimilation and forecasting system for coastal currents is presented. The purpose of the system is to deliver current analyses and forecasts based on assimilation of high frequency radar surface current measurements. The local Vessel Traffic Service monitoring the ship traffic to two oil terminals on the coast of Norway received the analyses and forecasts in real time.
A new assimil…
▽ More
A real time assimilation and forecasting system for coastal currents is presented. The purpose of the system is to deliver current analyses and forecasts based on assimilation of high frequency radar surface current measurements. The local Vessel Traffic Service monitoring the ship traffic to two oil terminals on the coast of Norway received the analyses and forecasts in real time.
A new assimilation method based on optimal interpolation is presented where spatial covariances derived from an ocean model are used instead of simplified mathematical formulations. An array of high frequency radar antennae provide the current measurements. A suite of nested ocean models comprise the model system. The observing system is found to yield good analyses and short range forecasts that are significantly improved compared to a model twin without assimilation. The system is fast; analysis and six hour forecasts are ready at the Vessel Traffic Service 45 minutes after acquisition of radar measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Nearshore wave forecasting and hindcasting by dynamical and statistical downscaling
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Yvonne Gusdal,
Birgitte R. Furevik,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Magnar Reistad
Abstract:
A high-resolution nested WAM/SWAN wave model suite aimed at rapidly establishing nearshore wave forecasts as well as a climatology and return values of the local wave conditions with Rapid Enviromental Assessment (REA) in mind is described. The system is targeted at regions where local wave growth and partial exposure to complex open-ocean wave conditions makes diagnostic wave modelling difficult.…
▽ More
A high-resolution nested WAM/SWAN wave model suite aimed at rapidly establishing nearshore wave forecasts as well as a climatology and return values of the local wave conditions with Rapid Enviromental Assessment (REA) in mind is described. The system is targeted at regions where local wave growth and partial exposure to complex open-ocean wave conditions makes diagnostic wave modelling difficult.
SWAN is set up on 500 m resolution and is nested in a 10 km version of WAM. A model integration of more than one year is carried out to map the spatial distribution of the wave field. The model correlates well with wave buoy observations (0.96) but overestimates the wave height somewhat (18%, bias 0.29 m).
To estimate wave height return values a much longer time series is required and running SWAN for such a period is unrealistic in a REA setting. Instead we establish a direction-dependent transfer function between an already existing coarse open-ocean hindcast dataset and the high-resolution nested SWAN model. Return values are estimated using ensemble estimates of two different extreme-value distributions based on the full 52 years of statistically downscaled hindcast data. We find good agreement between downscaled wave height and wave buoy observations. The cost of generating the statistically downscaled hindcast time series is negligible and can be redone for arbitrary locations within the SWAN domain, although the sectors must be carefully chosen for each new location.
The method is found to be well suited to rapidly providing detailed wave forecasts as well as hindcasts and return values estimates of partly sheltered coastal regions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
The Leeway of Ship** Containers at Different Immersion Levels
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Arthur A. Allen,
Christophe Maisondieu,
Jens-Christian Roth,
Bertrand Forest
Abstract:
The leeway of 20-foot containers in typical distress conditions is established through field experiments in a Norwegian fjord and in open-ocean conditions off the coast of France with wind speed ranging from calm to 14 m/s. The experimental setup is described in detail and certain recommendations given for experiments on objects of this size. The results are compared with the leeway of a scaled-do…
▽ More
The leeway of 20-foot containers in typical distress conditions is established through field experiments in a Norwegian fjord and in open-ocean conditions off the coast of France with wind speed ranging from calm to 14 m/s. The experimental setup is described in detail and certain recommendations given for experiments on objects of this size. The results are compared with the leeway of a scaled-down container before the full set of measured leeway characteristics are compared with a semi-analytical model of immersed containers. Our results are broadly consistent with the semi-analytical model, but the model is found to be sensitive to choice of drag coefficient and makes no estimate of the cross-wind leeway of containers. We extend the results from the semi-analytical immersion model by extrapolating the observed leeway divergence and estimates of the experimental uncertainty to various realistic immersion levels. The sensitivity of these leeway estimates at different immersion levels are tested using a stochastic trajectory model. Search areas are found to be sensitive to the exact immersion levels, the choice of drag coefficient and somewhat less sensitive to the inclusion of leeway divergence. We further compare the search areas thus found with a range of trajectories estimated using the semi-analytical model with only perturbations to the immersion level. We find that the search areas calculated without estimates of crosswind leeway and its uncertainty will grossly underestimate the rate of expansion of the search areas. We recommend that stochastic trajectory models of container drift should account for these uncertainties by generating search areas for different immersion levels and with the uncertainties in crosswind and downwind leeway reported from our field experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
An Operational Search and Rescue Model for the Norwegian Sea and the North Sea
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Arthur A Allen
Abstract:
A new operational, ensemble-based search and rescue model for the Norwegian Sea and the North Sea is presented. The stochastic trajectory model computes the net motion of a range of search and rescue objects. A new, robust formulation for the relation between the wind and the motion of the drifting object (termed the leeway of the object) is employed. Empirically derived coefficients for 63 catego…
▽ More
A new operational, ensemble-based search and rescue model for the Norwegian Sea and the North Sea is presented. The stochastic trajectory model computes the net motion of a range of search and rescue objects. A new, robust formulation for the relation between the wind and the motion of the drifting object (termed the leeway of the object) is employed. Empirically derived coefficients for 63 categories of search objects compiled by the US Coast Guard are ingested to estimate the leeway of the drifting objects. A Monte Carlo technique is employed to generate an ensemble that accounts for the uncertainties in forcing fields (wind and current), leeway drift properties, and the initial position of the search object. The ensemble yields an estimate of the time-evolving probability density function of the location of the search object, and its envelope defines the search area. Forcing fields from the operational oceanic and atmospheric forecast system of The Norwegian Meteorological Institute are used as input to the trajectory model. This allows for the first time high-resolution wind and current fields to be used to forecast search areas up to 60 hours into the future. A limited set of field exercises show good agreement between model trajectories, search areas, and observed trajectories for liferafts and other search objects. Comparison with older methods shows that search areas expand much more slowly using the new ensemble method with high resolution forcing fields and the new leeway formulation. It is found that going to higher-order stochastic trajectory models will not significantly improve the forecast skill and the rate of expansion of search areas.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
A high-resolution hindcast of wind and waves for The North Sea, The Norwegian Sea and The Barents Sea
Authors:
Magnar Reistad,
Øyvind Breivik,
Hilde Haakenstad,
Ole Johan Aarnes,
Birgitte R. Furevik,
Jean-Raymond Bidlot
Abstract:
A combined high-resolution atmospheric downscaling and wave hindcast based on the ERA-40 reanalysis covering the Norwegian Sea, the North Sea and the Barents Sea is presented. The period covered is from September 1957 to August 2002. The dynamic atmospheric downscaling is performed as a series of short prognostic runs initialized from a blend of ERA-40 and the previous prognostic run to preserve t…
▽ More
A combined high-resolution atmospheric downscaling and wave hindcast based on the ERA-40 reanalysis covering the Norwegian Sea, the North Sea and the Barents Sea is presented. The period covered is from September 1957 to August 2002. The dynamic atmospheric downscaling is performed as a series of short prognostic runs initialized from a blend of ERA-40 and the previous prognostic run to preserve the fine-scale surface features from the high-resolution model while maintaining the large-scale synoptic field from ERA-40. The nested WAM wave model hindcast consists of a coarse 50 km model covering the North Atlantic forced with ERA-40 winds and a nested 10-11 km resolution model forced with downscaled winds.
A comparison against in situ and satellite observations of wind and sea state reveals significant improvement in mean values and upper percentiles of wind vectors and the significant wave height over ERA-40. Improvement is also found in the mean wave period. ERA-40 is biased low in wind speed and significant wave height, a bias which is not reproduced by the downscaling. The atmospheric downscaling also reproduces polar lows, which can not be resolved by ERA-40, but the lows are too weak and short-lived as the downscaling is not capable of capturing their full life cycle.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
BAKTRAK: Backtracking drifting objects using an iterative algorithm with a forward trajectory model
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Tor Christian Bekkvik,
Atle Ommundsen,
Cecilie Wettre
Abstract:
The task of determining the origin of a drifting object after it has been located is highly complex due to the uncertainties in drift properties and environmental forcing (wind, waves and surface currents). Usually the origin is inferred by running a trajectory model (stochastic or deterministic) in reverse. However, this approach has some severe drawbacks, most notably the fact that many drifting…
▽ More
The task of determining the origin of a drifting object after it has been located is highly complex due to the uncertainties in drift properties and environmental forcing (wind, waves and surface currents). Usually the origin is inferred by running a trajectory model (stochastic or deterministic) in reverse. However, this approach has some severe drawbacks, most notably the fact that many drifting objects go through nonlinear state changes underway (e.g., evaporating oil or a capsizing lifeboat). This makes it difficult to naively construct a reverse-time trajectory model which realistically predicts the earliest possible time the object may have started drifting. We propose instead a different approach where the original (forward) trajectory model is kept unaltered while an iterative seeding and selection process allows us to retain only those particles that end up within a certain time-space radius of the observation. An iterative refinement process named BAKTRAK is employed where those trajectories that do not make it to the goal are rejected and new trajectories are spawned from successful trajectories. This allows the model to be run in the forward direction to determine the point of origin of a drifting object. The method is demonstrated using the Leeway stochastic trajectory model for drifting objects due to its relative simplicity and the practical importance of being able to identify the origin of drifting objects. However, the methodology is general and even more applicable to oil drift trajectories, drifting ships and hazardous material that exhibit non-linear state changes such as evaporation, chemical weathering, capsizing or swam**. The backtracking method is tested against the drift trajectory of a life raft and is shown to predict closely the initial release position of the raft and its subsequent trajectory.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Wind-induced drift of objects at sea: the leeway field method
Authors:
Øyvind Breivik,
Arthur A Allen,
Christophe Maisondieu,
Jens Christian Roth
Abstract:
A method for conducting leeway field experiments to establish the drift properties of small objects (0.1-25 m) is described. The objective is to define a standardized and unambiguous procedure for condensing the drift properties down to a set of coefficients that may be incorporated into existing stochastic trajectory forecast models for drifting objects of concern to search and rescue operations…
▽ More
A method for conducting leeway field experiments to establish the drift properties of small objects (0.1-25 m) is described. The objective is to define a standardized and unambiguous procedure for condensing the drift properties down to a set of coefficients that may be incorporated into existing stochastic trajectory forecast models for drifting objects of concern to search and rescue operations and other activities involving vessels lost at sea such as containers with hazardous material.
An operational definition of the slip or wind and wave-induced motion of a drifting object relative to the ambient current is proposed. This definition taken together with a strict adherence to 10 m wind speed allows us to refer unambiguously to the leeway of a drifting object. We recommend that all objects if possible be studied using what we term the direct method, where the object's leeway is studied directly using an attached current meter.
We divide drifting objects into four categories, depending on their size. For the smaller objects (less than 0.5 m), an indirect method of measuring the object's motion relative to the ambient current must be used. For larger objects, direct measurement of the motion through the near-surface water masses is strongly recommended. Larger objects are categorized according to the ability to attach current meters and wind monitoring systems to them.
The leeway field method proposed here is illustrated with results from field work where three objects were studied in their distress configuration; a 1:3.3 sized model of a 40-ft Ship** container, a World War II mine and a 220 l (55-gallon) oil drum.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
