Showing 1–50 of 329 results for author: Bouchaud, J

Emergent Inequalities in a Primitive Agent-Based Good-Exchange Model

Authors: Nirbhay Patil, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Rising inequalities around the globe bring into question our economic systems and the origin of such inequalities. Here we propose a toy agent-based model where each entity is simultaneously producing and consuming indivisible goods. We find that the system exhibits a non-trivial phase transition beyond which a market clearing equilibrium exists but becomes dynamically unreachable. When production… ▽ More Rising inequalities around the globe bring into question our economic systems and the origin of such inequalities. Here we propose a toy agent-based model where each entity is simultaneously producing and consuming indivisible goods. We find that the system exhibits a non-trivial phase transition beyond which a market clearing equilibrium exists but becomes dynamically unreachable. When production capacity exceeds a threshold and adapts too slowly, some agents cannot sell all their goods. This leads to global price deflation and induces strong wealth inequalities, with the spontaneous separation of the population into a rich class and a poor class. We explore ways to alleviate poverty in this model and whether they have real life significance. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 14 pages, 10 figures, 1 table

Ponzi Funds

Authors: Philippe van der Beck, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Dario Villamaina

Abstract: Many active funds hold concentrated portfolios. Flow-driven trading in these securities causes price pressure, which pushes up the funds' existing positions resulting in realized returns. We decompose fund returns into a price pressure (self-inflated) and a fundamental component and show that when allocating capital across funds, investors are unable to identify whether realized returns are self-i… ▽ More Many active funds hold concentrated portfolios. Flow-driven trading in these securities causes price pressure, which pushes up the funds' existing positions resulting in realized returns. We decompose fund returns into a price pressure (self-inflated) and a fundamental component and show that when allocating capital across funds, investors are unable to identify whether realized returns are self-inflated or fundamental. Because investors chase self-inflated fund returns at a high frequency, even short-lived impact meaningfully affects fund flows at longer time scales. The combination of price impact and return chasing causes an endogenous feedback loop and a reallocation of wealth to early fund investors, which unravels once the price pressure reverts. We find that flows chasing self-inflated returns predict bubbles in ETFs and their subsequent crashes, and lead to a daily wealth reallocation of 500 Million from ETFs alone. We provide a simple regulatory reporting measure -- fund illiquidity -- which captures a fund's potential for self-inflated returns. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 30 Pages, 9 figures, 3 appendices

"Microstructure Modes" -- Disentangling the Joint Dynamics of Prices & Order Flow

Authors: Salma Elomari-Kessab, Guillaume Maitrier, Julius Bonart, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Understanding the micro-dynamics of asset prices in modern electronic order books is crucial for investors and regulators. In this paper, we use an order by order Eurostoxx database spanning over 3 years to analyze the joint dynamics of prices and order flow. In order to alleviate various problems caused by high-frequency noise, we propose a double coarse-graining procedure that allows us to extra… ▽ More Understanding the micro-dynamics of asset prices in modern electronic order books is crucial for investors and regulators. In this paper, we use an order by order Eurostoxx database spanning over 3 years to analyze the joint dynamics of prices and order flow. In order to alleviate various problems caused by high-frequency noise, we propose a double coarse-graining procedure that allows us to extract meaningful information at the minute time scale. We use Principal Component Analysis to construct "microstructure modes" that describe the most common flow/return patterns and allow one to separate them into bid-ask symmetric and bid-ask anti-symmetric. We define and calibrate a Vector Auto-Regressive (VAR) model that encodes the dynamical evolution of these modes. The parameters of the VAR model are found to be extremely stable in time, and lead to relatively high $R^2$ prediction scores, especially for symmetric liquidity modes. The VAR model becomes marginally unstable as more lags are included, reflecting the long-memory nature of flows and giving some further credence to the possibility of "endogenous liquidity crises". Although very satisfactory on several counts, we show that our VAR framework does not account for the well known square-root law of price impact. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Riding Wavelets: A Method to Discover New Classes of Price Jumps

Authors: Cecilia Aubrun, Rudy Morel, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Cascades of events and extreme occurrences have garnered significant attention across diverse domains such as financial markets, seismology, and social physics. Such events can stem either from the internal dynamics inherent to the system (endogenous), or from external shocks (exogenous). The possibility of separating these two classes of events has critical implications for professionals in those… ▽ More Cascades of events and extreme occurrences have garnered significant attention across diverse domains such as financial markets, seismology, and social physics. Such events can stem either from the internal dynamics inherent to the system (endogenous), or from external shocks (exogenous). The possibility of separating these two classes of events has critical implications for professionals in those fields. We introduce an unsupervised framework leveraging a representation of jump time-series based on wavelet coefficients and apply it to stock price jumps. In line with previous work, we recover the fact that the time-asymmetry of volatility is a major feature. Mean-reversion and trend are found to be two additional key features, allowing us to identify new classes of jumps. Furthermore, thanks to our wavelet-based representation, we investigate the reflexive properties of co-jumps, which occur when multiple stocks experience price jumps within the same minute. We argue that a significant fraction of co-jumps results from an endogenous contagion mechanism. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 12 pages and 11 pages of appendices, 26 figures

Revisiting Granular Models of Firm Growth

Authors: José Moran, Angelo Secchi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We revisit granular models that represent the size of a firm as the sum of the sizes of multiple constituents or sub-units. Originally developed to address the unexpectedly slow reduction in volatility as firm size increases, these models also explain the shape of the distribution of firm growth rates. We introduce new theoretical insights regarding the relationship between firm size and growth… ▽ More We revisit granular models that represent the size of a firm as the sum of the sizes of multiple constituents or sub-units. Originally developed to address the unexpectedly slow reduction in volatility as firm size increases, these models also explain the shape of the distribution of firm growth rates. We introduce new theoretical insights regarding the relationship between firm size and growth rate statistics within this framework, directly linking the growth statistics of a firm to how diversified it is. The non-intuitive nature of our results arises from the fat-tailed distributions of the size and the number of sub-units, which suggest the categorization of firms into three distinct diversification types: well-diversified firms with sizes evenly distributed across many sub-units, firms with many sub-units but concentrated size in just a few, and poorly diversified firms consisting of only a small number of sub-units. Inspired by our theoretical findings, we identify new empirical patterns in firm growth. Our findings show that growth volatility, when adjusted by average size-conditioned volatility, has a size-independent distribution, but with a tail that is much too thin to be in agreement with the predictions of granular models. Furthermore, the predicted Gaussian distribution of growth rates, even when rescaled for firm-specific volatility, remains fat-tailed across all sizes. Such discrepancies not only challenge the granularity hypothesis but also underscore the need for deeper exploration into the mechanisms driving firm growth. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2024; v1 submitted 23 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Revisiting Elastic String Models of Forward Interest Rates

Authors: Victor Le Coz, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Twenty five years ago, several authors proposed to model the forward interest rate curve (FRC) as an elastic string along which idiosyncratic shocks propagate, accounting for the peculiar structure of the return correlation across different maturities. In this paper, we revisit the specific "stiff'' elastic string field theory of Baaquie and Bouchaud (2004) in a way that makes its micro-foundation… ▽ More Twenty five years ago, several authors proposed to model the forward interest rate curve (FRC) as an elastic string along which idiosyncratic shocks propagate, accounting for the peculiar structure of the return correlation across different maturities. In this paper, we revisit the specific "stiff'' elastic string field theory of Baaquie and Bouchaud (2004) in a way that makes its micro-foundation more transparent. Our model can be interpreted as capturing the effect of market forces that set the rates of nearby tenors in a self-referential fashion. The model is parsimonious and accurately reproduces the whole correlation structure of the FRC over the time period 1994-2023, with an error below 2%. We need only two parameters, the values of which being very stable except perhaps during the Quantitative Easing period 2009-2014. The dependence of correlation on time resolution (also called the Epps effect) is also faithfully reproduced within the model and leads to a cross-tenor information propagation time of 10 minutes. Finally, we confirm that the perceived time in interest rate markets is a strongly sub-linear function of real time, as surmised by Baaquie and Bouchaud (2004). In fact, our results are fully compatible with hyperbolic discounting, in line with the recent behavioural literature (Farmer and Geanakoplos, 2009). △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 19 pages, 16 figures

Why is the Dynamics of Glasses Super-Arrhenius?

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: The steep increase of the relaxation time of glass forming liquids upon cooling is traditionally ascribed to an impending entropy crisis: since the system has "nowhere to go", dynamics must come to a halt. This classic argument, due to Adam \& Gibbs, has been bolstered and refined by the development of the Random First Order Transition (RFOT) theory, which fares remarkably well at reproducing most… ▽ More The steep increase of the relaxation time of glass forming liquids upon cooling is traditionally ascribed to an impending entropy crisis: since the system has "nowhere to go", dynamics must come to a halt. This classic argument, due to Adam \& Gibbs, has been bolstered and refined by the development of the Random First Order Transition (RFOT) theory, which fares remarkably well at reproducing most salient experimental facts of super-cooled liquids. All static predictions of RFOT, including the existence of a point-to-set length and the role of pinning sites, have been vindicated by detailed numerical simulations. Yet, there is no consensus that the basic mechanism explaining the glass transition is the one captured by RFOT. Strong doubts have emerged following the observation that adding or removing kinetic constraints can change the relaxation time by orders of magnitude, while leaving thermodynamics unchanged. This is at odds with the idea of a one-to-one map** between excess entropy and relaxation time. In the following discussion paper presented at the Solvay conference in October 2023, we review areas of consensus and dissent of RFOT with other competing theoretical proposals, and propose possible paths for (partial) reconciliation. We further argue that extensive numerical simulations of the non-linear susceptibility of glasses, in particular in the aging regime, should shed important light on the mechanism at the origin of the super-Arrhenius behaviour of the relaxation time. In any case, more imagination is still needed to come up with experimental, theoretical or numerical ideas that would allow to finally settle the question of why glasses do not flow. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2024; v1 submitted 2 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: Proceedings of the Solvay Conference "The Structure and Dynamics of Disordered Systems". Two references added

Unlearnable Games and "Satisficing'' Decisions: A Simple Model for a Complex World

Authors: Jerome Garnier-Brun, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: As a schematic model of the complexity economic agents are confronted with, we introduce the ``SK-game'', a discrete time binary choice model inspired from mean-field spin-glasses. We show that even in a completely static environment, agents are unable to learn collectively-optimal strategies. This is either because the learning process gets trapped in a sub-optimal fixed point, or because learnin… ▽ More As a schematic model of the complexity economic agents are confronted with, we introduce the ``SK-game'', a discrete time binary choice model inspired from mean-field spin-glasses. We show that even in a completely static environment, agents are unable to learn collectively-optimal strategies. This is either because the learning process gets trapped in a sub-optimal fixed point, or because learning never converges and leads to a never ending evolution of agents intentions. Contrarily to the hope that learning might save the standard ``rational expectation'' framework in economics, we argue that complex situations are generically unlearnable and agents must do with satisficing solutions, as argued long ago by Herbert Simon (Simon 1955). Only a centralized, omniscient agent endowed with enormous computing power could qualify to determine the optimal strategy of all agents. Using a mix of analytical arguments and numerical simulations, we find that (i) long memory of past rewards is beneficial to learning whereas over-reaction to recent past is detrimental and leads to cycles or chaos; (ii) increased competition destabilizes fixed points and leads first to chaos and, in the high competition limit, to quasi-cycles; (iii) some amount of randomness in the learning process, perhaps paradoxically, allows the system to reach better collective decisions; (iv) non-stationary, ``aging'' behaviour spontaneously emerge in a large swath of parameter space of our complex but static world. On the positive side, we find that the learning process allows cooperative systems to coordinate around satisficing solutions with rather high (but markedly sub-optimal) average reward. However, hyper-sensitivity to the game parameters makes it impossible to predict ex ante who will be better or worse off in our stylized economy. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2024; v1 submitted 19 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 35 pages, 19 figures

The Spectral Boundary of Block Structured Random Matrices

Authors: Nirbhay Patil, Fabian Aguirre-Lopez, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Economic and ecological models can be extremely complex, with a large number of agents/species each featuring multiple interacting dynamical quantities. In an attempt to understand the generic stability properties of such systems, we define and study an interesting new matrix ensemble with extensive correlations, generalising the elliptic ensemble. We determine analytically the boundary of its eig… ▽ More Economic and ecological models can be extremely complex, with a large number of agents/species each featuring multiple interacting dynamical quantities. In an attempt to understand the generic stability properties of such systems, we define and study an interesting new matrix ensemble with extensive correlations, generalising the elliptic ensemble. We determine analytically the boundary of its eigenvalue spectrum in the complex plane, as a function of the correlations determined by the model at hand. We solve numerically our equations in several cases of interest, and show that the resulting spectra can take a surprisingly wide variety of shapes. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 19 pages, 6 figures

Wrap** and unwrap** multifractal fields

Authors: Samy Lakhal, Laurent Ponson, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We develop a powerful yet simple method that generates multifractal fields with fully controlled scaling properties. Adopting the Multifractal Random Walk (MRW) model of Bacry et al. (2001), synthetic multifractal fields are obtained from the fractional integration of non-Gaussian fluctuations, built by a non-linear transformation of log-correlated Gaussian fields. The resulting fields are paramet… ▽ More We develop a powerful yet simple method that generates multifractal fields with fully controlled scaling properties. Adopting the Multifractal Random Walk (MRW) model of Bacry et al. (2001), synthetic multifractal fields are obtained from the fractional integration of non-Gaussian fluctuations, built by a non-linear transformation of log-correlated Gaussian fields. The resulting fields are parameterized by their roughness exponent $H$, intermittency $λ$ and multifractal range $ξ_ω$. We retrieve all the salient features of the MRW, namely a quadratic scaling exponent spectrum $ζ_q$, fat-tail statistics of fluctuations, and spatial correlations of local volatility. Such features can be finely tuned, allowing for the generation of ideal multifractals mimicking real multi-affine fields. The construction procedure is then used the other way around to unwrap experimental data -- here the roughness map of a fractured metallic alloy. Our analysis evidences subtle differences with synthetic fields, namely anisotropic filamental clusters reminiscent of dissipation structures found in fluid turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 5 October, 2023; v1 submitted 3 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 9 pages, 8 figures

Timeliness criticality in complex systems

Authors: José Moran, Matthijs Romeijnders, Pierre Le Doussal, Frank P. Pijpers, Utz Weitzel, Debabrata Panja, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: In complex systems, external parameters often determine the phase in which the system operates, i.e., its macroscopic behavior. For nearly a century, statistical physics has extensively studied systems' transitions across phases, (universal) critical exponents, and related dynamical properties. Here we consider the functionality of systems, notably operations in socio-technical ones, production in… ▽ More In complex systems, external parameters often determine the phase in which the system operates, i.e., its macroscopic behavior. For nearly a century, statistical physics has extensively studied systems' transitions across phases, (universal) critical exponents, and related dynamical properties. Here we consider the functionality of systems, notably operations in socio-technical ones, production in economic ones and, more generally, any schedule-based system, where timing is of crucial importance. We introduce a stylized model of delay propagation on temporal networks, where the magnitude of delay-mitigating buffer acts as a control parameter. The model exhibits {\it timeliness criticality}, a novel form of critical behavior. We characterize fluctuations near criticality, commonly referred to as ``avalanches'', and identify the corresponding critical exponents. The model exhibits timeliness criticality also when run on real-world temporal systems such as production networks. Additionally, we explore potential connections with the Mode-Coupling Theory of glasses, the depinning transition and the directed polymer problem. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2024; v1 submitted 26 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 12 pages of main paper, 12 figures, 9 pages of supplementary information

Journal ref: Nature Physics 2024, advanced online publication

From Statistical Physics to Social Sciences: The Pitfalls of Multi-disciplinarity

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: This is the English version of my inaugural lecture at Collège de France in 2021, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxktplKMhKU. I reflect on the difficulty of multi-disciplinary research, which often hinges of unexpected epistemological and methodological differences, for example about the scientific status of models. What is the purpose of a model? What are we ultimately trying to est… ▽ More This is the English version of my inaugural lecture at Collège de France in 2021, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxktplKMhKU. I reflect on the difficulty of multi-disciplinary research, which often hinges of unexpected epistemological and methodological differences, for example about the scientific status of models. What is the purpose of a model? What are we ultimately trying to establish: rigorous theorems or ad-hoc calculation recipes; absolute truth, or heuristic representations of the world? I argue that the main contribution of statistical physics to social and economic sciences is to make us realise that unexpected behaviour can emerge at the aggregate level, that isolated individuals would never experience. Crises, panics, opinion reversals, the spread of rumours or beliefs, fashion effects and the zeitgeist, but also the existence of money, lasting institutions, social norms and stable societies, must be understood in terms of collective belief and/or trust, self-sustained by interactions, or on the contrary, the rapid collapse of this belief or trust. The Appendix contains my opening remarks to the workshop ``More is Different'', as a tribute to Phil Anderson. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: French version published as a book by Fayard (2021)

Path Shadowing Monte-Carlo

Authors: Rudy Morel, Stéphane Mallat, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We introduce a Path Shadowing Monte-Carlo method, which provides prediction of future paths, given any generative model. At any given date, it averages future quantities over generated price paths whose past history matches, or `shadows', the actual (observed) history. We test our approach using paths generated from a maximum entropy model of financial prices, based on a recently proposed multi-sc… ▽ More We introduce a Path Shadowing Monte-Carlo method, which provides prediction of future paths, given any generative model. At any given date, it averages future quantities over generated price paths whose past history matches, or `shadows', the actual (observed) history. We test our approach using paths generated from a maximum entropy model of financial prices, based on a recently proposed multi-scale analogue of the standard skewness and kurtosis called `Scattering Spectra'. This model promotes diversity of generated paths while reproducing the main statistical properties of financial prices, including stylized facts on volatility roughness. Our method yields state-of-the-art predictions for future realized volatility and allows one to determine conditional option smiles for the S\&P500 that outperform both the current version of the Path-Dependent Volatility model and the option market itself. △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Temporal criticality in socio-technical systems

Authors: José Moran, Frank P. Pijpers, Utz Weitzel, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Debabrata Panja

Abstract: Socio-technical systems, where technological and human elements interact in a goal-oriented manner, provide important, functional support to our societies. We draw specific attention to the concept of timeliness that has been ubiquitously and integrally adopted as a quality standard in the {\it modus operandi\/} of socio-technical systems, but remains an underappreciated aspect. We point out that… ▽ More Socio-technical systems, where technological and human elements interact in a goal-oriented manner, provide important, functional support to our societies. We draw specific attention to the concept of timeliness that has been ubiquitously and integrally adopted as a quality standard in the {\it modus operandi\/} of socio-technical systems, but remains an underappreciated aspect. We point out that a variety of incentives, often reinforced by competitive pressures, prompt system operators to myopically optimize for cost- and time-efficiencies, running the risk of inadvertently pushing the systems towards the proverbial `edge of a cliff'. Invoking a stylized model for operational delays, we argue that this cliff edge is a true critical point -- identified as {\it temporal criticality\/} -- implying that system efficiency and robustness to perturbation are in tension with each other. Specifically for firm-to-firm production networks, we suggest that the proximity to temporal criticality is a possible route for solving the fundamental ``excess volatility puzzle'' in economics. Further, in generality for optimizing socio-technical systems, we propose that system operators incorporate a measure of resilience in their welfare functions. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2023; v1 submitted 7 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 9 pages, 3 figures, perspective paper, corrected copy-paste error in the abstract

Application of spin glass ideas in social sciences, economics and finance

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Matteo Marsili, Jean-Pierre Nadal

Abstract: Classical economics has developed an arsenal of methods, based on the idea of representative agents, to come up with precise numbers for next year's GDP, inflation and exchange rates, among (many) other things. Few, however, will disagree with the fact that the economy is a complex system, with a large number of strongly heterogeneous, interacting units of different types (firms, banks, households… ▽ More Classical economics has developed an arsenal of methods, based on the idea of representative agents, to come up with precise numbers for next year's GDP, inflation and exchange rates, among (many) other things. Few, however, will disagree with the fact that the economy is a complex system, with a large number of strongly heterogeneous, interacting units of different types (firms, banks, households, public institutions) and different sizes. Now, the main issue in economics is precisely the emergent organization, cooperation and coordination of such a motley crowd of micro-units. Treating them as a unique ``representative'' firm or household clearly risks throwing the baby with the bathwater. As we have learnt from statistical physics, understanding and characterizing such emergent properties can be difficult. Because of feedback loops of different signs, heterogeneities and non-linearities, the macro-properties are often hard to anticipate. In particular, these situations generically lead to a very large number of possible equilibria, or even the lack thereof. Spin-glasses and other disordered systems give a concrete example of such difficulties. In order to tackle these complex situations, new theoretical and numerical tools have been invented in the last 50 years, including of course the replica method and replica symmetry breaking, and the cavity method, both static and dynamic. In this chapter we review the application of such ideas and methods in economics and social sciences. Of particular interest are the proliferation (and fragility) of equilibria, the analogue of satisfiability phase transitions in games and random economies, and condensation (or concentration) effects in opinion, wealth, etc △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Contribution to the edited volume "Spin Glass Theory & Far Beyond - Replica Symmetry Breaking after 40 Years", World Scientific, 2023

Post-COVID Inflation & the Monetary Policy Dilemma: An Agent-Based Scenario Analysis

Authors: Max Sina Knicker, Karl Naumann-Woleske, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: The economic shocks that followed the COVID-19 pandemic have brought to light the difficulty, both for academics and policy makers, of describing and predicting the dynamics of inflation. This paper offers an alternative modelling approach. We study the 2020-2023 period within the well-studied Mark-0 Agent-Based Model, in which economic agents act and react according to plausible behavioural rules… ▽ More The economic shocks that followed the COVID-19 pandemic have brought to light the difficulty, both for academics and policy makers, of describing and predicting the dynamics of inflation. This paper offers an alternative modelling approach. We study the 2020-2023 period within the well-studied Mark-0 Agent-Based Model, in which economic agents act and react according to plausible behavioural rules. We include a mechanism through which trust of economic agents in the Central Bank can de-anchor. We investigate the influence of regulatory policies on inflationary dynamics resulting from three exogenous shocks, calibrated on those that followed the COVID-19 pandemic: a production/consumption shock due to COVID-related lockdowns, a supply-chain shock, and an energy price shock exacerbated by the Russian invasion of Ukraine. By exploring the impact of these shocks under different assumptions about monetary policy efficacy and transmission channels, we review various explanations for the resurgence of inflation in the United States, including demand-pull, cost-push, and profit-driven factors. Our main results are four-fold: (i) without appropriate fiscal policy, the shocked economy can take years to recover, or even tip over into a deep recession; {(ii) the success of monetary policy in curbing inflation is primarily due to expectation anchoring, rather than to the direct economic impact of interest rate hikes; (iii) however, strong inflation anchoring is detrimental to consumption and unemployment, leading to a narrow window of ``optimal'' policy responses due to the trade-off between inflation and unemployment;} (iv) the two most sensitive model parameters are those describing wage and price indexation. The results of our study have implications for Central Bank decision-making, and offers an easy-to-use tool that may help anticipate the consequences of different monetary and fiscal policies. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2024; v1 submitted 2 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 57 pages, 35 figures

Journal ref: Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination (2024)

The Cost of Misspecifying Price Impact

Authors: Natascha Hey, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Iacopo Mastromatteo, Johannes Muhle-Karbe, Kevin Webster

Abstract: Portfolio managers' orders trade off return and trading cost predictions. Return predictions rely on alpha models, whereas price impact models quantify trading costs. This paper studies what happens when trades are based on an incorrect price impact model, so that the portfolio either over- or under-trades its alpha signal. We derive tractable formulas for these misspecification costs and illustra… ▽ More Portfolio managers' orders trade off return and trading cost predictions. Return predictions rely on alpha models, whereas price impact models quantify trading costs. This paper studies what happens when trades are based on an incorrect price impact model, so that the portfolio either over- or under-trades its alpha signal. We derive tractable formulas for these misspecification costs and illustrate them on proprietary trading data. The misspecification costs are naturally asymmetric: underestimating impact concavity or impact decay shrinks profits, but overestimating concavity or impact decay can even turn profits into losses. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 14 pages, 5 figures

Income Inequalities Increase with City Size: Evidence from French Data

Authors: Nirbhay Patil, Jean-Pierre Nadal, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We analyse the income distributions of cities in France and the scaling of the income of different deciles as a function of the population. We find a significant difference in the scaling exponents for the richer and poorer parts of the population, implying an unequivocal rise in inequalities in larger cities, made worse by living costs that are disproportionately higher for the poor. We find that… ▽ More We analyse the income distributions of cities in France and the scaling of the income of different deciles as a function of the population. We find a significant difference in the scaling exponents for the richer and poorer parts of the population, implying an unequivocal rise in inequalities in larger cities, made worse by living costs that are disproportionately higher for the poor. We find that the distribution of revenues of cities in France has a universal, Gumbel-like form, with mean and variance growing with the logarithm of population. We show how this result directly implies different income scaling exponents as a function of decile. We also study the spatial correlations of income and population, which decay exponentially with distance. We find that large cities are not more income-segregated than small cities. Finally, we search for couplings between social and economic factors, like age and income, and propose a toy model that reproduces some of our observations. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2023; v1 submitted 22 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 11 pages, 11 figures

The RFOT Theory of Glasses: Recent Progress and Open Issues

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: The Random First Order Transition (RFOT) theory started with the pioneering work of Kirkpatrick, Thirumalai and Wolynes. It leverages the methods and advances of the theory of disordered systems. It fares remarkably well at reproducing the salient experimental facts of super-cooled liquids. Yet, direct and indisputable experimental validations are missing. In this short survey, we will review rece… ▽ More The Random First Order Transition (RFOT) theory started with the pioneering work of Kirkpatrick, Thirumalai and Wolynes. It leverages the methods and advances of the theory of disordered systems. It fares remarkably well at reproducing the salient experimental facts of super-cooled liquids. Yet, direct and indisputable experimental validations are missing. In this short survey, we will review recent investigations that broadly support all static aspects of RFOT, but also those for which the standard dynamical extension of the theory appears to be struggling, in particular in relation with facilitation effects. We discuss possible solutions and open issues. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Multivariate Quadratic Hawkes Processes -- Part I: Theoretical Analysis

Authors: Cécilia Aubrun, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Quadratic Hawkes (QHawkes) processes have proved effective at reproducing the statistics of price changes, capturing many of the stylised facts of financial markets. Motivated by the recently reported strong occurrence of endogenous co-jumps (simultaneous price jumps of several assets) we extend QHawkes to a multivariate framework (MQHawkes), that is considering several financial assets and their… ▽ More Quadratic Hawkes (QHawkes) processes have proved effective at reproducing the statistics of price changes, capturing many of the stylised facts of financial markets. Motivated by the recently reported strong occurrence of endogenous co-jumps (simultaneous price jumps of several assets) we extend QHawkes to a multivariate framework (MQHawkes), that is considering several financial assets and their interactions. Assuming that quadratic kernels write as the sum of a time-diagonal component and a rank one (trend) contribution, we investigate endogeneity ratios and the resulting stationarity conditions. We then derive the so-called Yule-Walker equations relating covariances and feedback kernels, which are essential to calibrate the MQHawkes process on empirical data. Finally, we investigate the volatility distribution of the process and find that, as in the univariate case, it exhibits power-law behavior, with an exponent that can be exactly computed in some limiting cases. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2023; v1 submitted 21 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 23 pages, 5 figures

Bounded Rationality and Animal Spirits: A Fluctuation-Response Approach to Slutsky Matrices

Authors: Jerome Garnier-Brun, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: The Slutsky equation, central in consumer choice theory, is derived from the usual hypotheses underlying most standard models in Economics, such as full rationality, homogeneity, and absence of interactions. We present a statistical physics framework that allows us to relax such assumptions. We first derive a general fluctuation-response formula that relates the Slutsky matrix to spontaneous fluct… ▽ More The Slutsky equation, central in consumer choice theory, is derived from the usual hypotheses underlying most standard models in Economics, such as full rationality, homogeneity, and absence of interactions. We present a statistical physics framework that allows us to relax such assumptions. We first derive a general fluctuation-response formula that relates the Slutsky matrix to spontaneous fluctuations of consumption rather than to response to changing prices and budget. We then show that, within our hypotheses, the symmetry of the Slutsky matrix remains valid even when agents are only boundedly rational but non-interacting. We then propose a model where agents are influenced by the choice of others, leading to a phase transition beyond which consumption is dominated by herding (or `"fashion") effects. In this case, the individual Slutsky matrix is no longer symmetric, even for fully rational agents. The vicinity of the transition features a peak in asymmetry. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 25 pages, 5 figures

Excess Out-of-Sample Risk and Fleeting Modes

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Iacopo Mastromatteo, Marc Potters, Konstantin Tikhonov

Abstract: Using Random Matrix Theory, we propose a universal and versatile tool to reveal the existence of "fleeting modes", i.e. portfolios that carry statistically significant excess risk, signalling ex-post a change in the correlation structure in the underlying asset space. Our proposed test is furthermore independent of the "true" (but unknown) underlying correlation structure. We show empirically that… ▽ More Using Random Matrix Theory, we propose a universal and versatile tool to reveal the existence of "fleeting modes", i.e. portfolios that carry statistically significant excess risk, signalling ex-post a change in the correlation structure in the underlying asset space. Our proposed test is furthermore independent of the "true" (but unknown) underlying correlation structure. We show empirically that such fleeting modes exist both in futures markets and in equity markets. We proposed a metric to quantify the alignment between known factors and fleeting modes and identify momentum as a source of excess risk in the equity space. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures

Occupation time of a renewal process coupled to a discrete Markov chain

Authors: Théo Dessertaine, Claude Godrèche, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: A semi-Markov process is one that changes states in accordance with a Markov chain but takes a random amount of time between changes. We consider the generalisation to semi-Markov processes of the classical Lamperti law for the occupation time of a two-state Markov process. We provide an explicit expression in Laplace space for the distribution of an arbitrary linear combination of the occupation… ▽ More A semi-Markov process is one that changes states in accordance with a Markov chain but takes a random amount of time between changes. We consider the generalisation to semi-Markov processes of the classical Lamperti law for the occupation time of a two-state Markov process. We provide an explicit expression in Laplace space for the distribution of an arbitrary linear combination of the occupation times in the various states of the process. We discuss several consequences of this result. In particular, we infer the limiting distribution of this quantity rescaled by time in the long-time scaling regime, as well as the finite-time corrections to its moments. △ Less

Submitted 26 May, 2022; v1 submitted 24 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 4 figures

Scale Dependencies and Self-Similar Models with Wavelet Scattering Spectra

Authors: Rudy Morel, Gaspar Rochette, Roberto Leonarduzzi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Stéphane Mallat

Abstract: We introduce the wavelet scattering spectra which provide non-Gaussian models of time-series having stationary increments. A complex wavelet transform computes signal variations at each scale. Dependencies across scales are captured by the joint correlation across time and scales of wavelet coefficients and their modulus. This correlation matrix is nearly diagonalized by a second wavelet transform… ▽ More We introduce the wavelet scattering spectra which provide non-Gaussian models of time-series having stationary increments. A complex wavelet transform computes signal variations at each scale. Dependencies across scales are captured by the joint correlation across time and scales of wavelet coefficients and their modulus. This correlation matrix is nearly diagonalized by a second wavelet transform, which defines the scattering spectra. We show that this vector of moments characterizes a wide range of non-Gaussian properties of multi-scale processes. We prove that self-similar processes have scattering spectra which are scale invariant. This property can be tested statistically on a single realization and defines a class of wide-sense self-similar processes. We build maximum entropy models conditioned by scattering spectra coefficients, and generate new time-series with a microcanonical sampling algorithm. Applications are shown for highly non-Gaussian financial and turbulence time-series. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2023; v1 submitted 19 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Will Random Cone-wise Linear Systems Be Stable?

Authors: Théo Dessertaine, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We consider a simple model for multidimensional cone-wise linear dynamics around cusp-like equilibria. We assume that the local linear evolution is either $\mathbf{v}^\prime=\mathbb{A}\mathbf{v}$ or $\mathbb{B}\mathbf{v}$ (with $\mathbb{A}$, $\mathbb{B}$ independently drawn a rotationally invariant ensemble of $N \times N$ matrices) depending on the sign of the first component of $\mathbf{v}$. We… ▽ More We consider a simple model for multidimensional cone-wise linear dynamics around cusp-like equilibria. We assume that the local linear evolution is either $\mathbf{v}^\prime=\mathbb{A}\mathbf{v}$ or $\mathbb{B}\mathbf{v}$ (with $\mathbb{A}$, $\mathbb{B}$ independently drawn a rotationally invariant ensemble of $N \times N$ matrices) depending on the sign of the first component of $\mathbf{v}$. We establish strong connections with the random diffusion persistence problem. When $N \to \infty$, we find that the Lyapounov exponent is non self-averaging, i.e. one can observe apparent stability and apparent instability for the same system, depending on time and initial conditions. Finite $N$ effects are also discussed, and lead to cone trap** phenomena. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2022; v1 submitted 4 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures

On Hawkes Processes with Infinite Mean Intensity

Authors: Cecilia Aubrun, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: The stability condition for Hawkes processes and their non-linear extensions usually relies on the condition that the mean intensity is a finite constant. It follows that the total endogeneity ratio needs to be strictly smaller than unity. In the present note we argue that it is possible to have a total endogeneity ratio greater than unity without rendering the process unstable. In particular, we… ▽ More The stability condition for Hawkes processes and their non-linear extensions usually relies on the condition that the mean intensity is a finite constant. It follows that the total endogeneity ratio needs to be strictly smaller than unity. In the present note we argue that it is possible to have a total endogeneity ratio greater than unity without rendering the process unstable. In particular, we show that, provided the endogeneity ratio of the linear Hawkes component is smaller than unity, Quadratic Hawkes processes are always stationary, although with infinite mean intensity when the total endogenity ratio exceeds one. This results from a subtle compensation between the inhibiting realisations (mean-reversion) and their exciting counterparts (trends). △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2023; v1 submitted 28 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures

Exploration of the Parameter Space in Macroeconomic Agent-Based Models

Authors: Karl Naumann-Woleske, Max Sina Knicker, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Agent-Based Models (ABM) are computational scenario-generators, which can be used to predict the possible future outcomes of the complex system they represent. To better understand the robustness of these predictions, it is necessary to understand the full scope of the possible phenomena the model can generate. Most often, due to high-dimensional parameter spaces, this is a computationally expensi… ▽ More Agent-Based Models (ABM) are computational scenario-generators, which can be used to predict the possible future outcomes of the complex system they represent. To better understand the robustness of these predictions, it is necessary to understand the full scope of the possible phenomena the model can generate. Most often, due to high-dimensional parameter spaces, this is a computationally expensive task. Inspired by ideas coming from systems biology, we show that for multiple macroeconomic models, including an agent-based model and several Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium (DSGE) models, there are only a few stiff parameter combinations that have strong effects, while the other sloppy directions are irrelevant. This suggest an algorithm that efficiently explores the space of parameters by primarily moving along the stiff directions. We apply our algorithm to a medium-sized agent-based model, and show that it recovers all possible dynamics of the unemployment rate. The application of this method to Agent-based Models may lead to a more thorough and robust understanding of their features, and provide enhanced parameter sensitivity analyses. Several promising paths for future research are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2022; v1 submitted 16 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 20 pages, 7 figures

Economic Crises in a Model with Capital Scarcity and Self-Reflexive Confidence

Authors: Federico Guglielmo Morelli, Karl Naumann-Woleske, Michael Benzaquen, Marco Tarzia, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: In the General Theory, Keynes remarked that the economy's state depends on expectations, and that these expectations can be subject to sudden swings. In this work, we develop a multiple equilibria behavioural business cycle model that can account for demand or supply collapses due to abrupt drops in consumer confidence, which affect both consumption propensity and investment. We show that, dependi… ▽ More In the General Theory, Keynes remarked that the economy's state depends on expectations, and that these expectations can be subject to sudden swings. In this work, we develop a multiple equilibria behavioural business cycle model that can account for demand or supply collapses due to abrupt drops in consumer confidence, which affect both consumption propensity and investment. We show that, depending on the model parameters, four qualitatively different outcomes can emerge, characterised by the frequency of capital scarcity and/or demand crises. In the absence of policy measures, the duration of such crises can increase by orders of magnitude when parameters are varied, as a result of the "paradox of thrift". Our model suggests policy recommendations that prevent the economy from getting trapped in extended stretches of low output, low investment and high unemployment. △ Less

Submitted 20 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 6 figures

The Inelastic Market Hypothesis: A Microstructural Interpretation

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We attempt to reconcile Gabaix and Koijen's (GK) recent Inelastic Market Hypothesis (IMH) with the order-driven view of markets that emerged within the microstructure literature in the past 20 years. We review the most salient empirical facts and arguments that give credence to the idea that market price fluctuations are mostly due to order flow, whether informed or non-informed. We show that the… ▽ More We attempt to reconcile Gabaix and Koijen's (GK) recent Inelastic Market Hypothesis (IMH) with the order-driven view of markets that emerged within the microstructure literature in the past 20 years. We review the most salient empirical facts and arguments that give credence to the idea that market price fluctuations are mostly due to order flow, whether informed or non-informed. We show that the Latent Liquidity Theory of price impact makes a precise prediction for GK's multiplier $M$, which measures by how many dollars, on average, the market value of a company goes up if one buys one dollar worth of its stocks. Our central result is that $M$ is of order unity, as found by GK, and increases with the volatility of the stock and decreases with the fraction of the market cap. traded daily. We discuss several empirical results suggesting that the lion's share of volatility is due to trading activity. We argue that the IMH holds for all asset classes, beyond the case of stock markets considered by GK. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2022; v1 submitted 31 July, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: Version to appear in Quantitative Finance

Exogenous and Endogenous Price Jumps Belong to Different Dynamical Classes

Authors: Riccardo Marcaccioli, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: Synchronising a database of stock specific news with 5 years worth of order book data on 300 stocks, we show that abnormal price movements following news releases (exogenous) exhibit markedly different dynamical features from those arising spontaneously (endogenous). On average, large volatility fluctuations induced by exogenous events occur abruptly and are followed by a decaying power-law relaxa… ▽ More Synchronising a database of stock specific news with 5 years worth of order book data on 300 stocks, we show that abnormal price movements following news releases (exogenous) exhibit markedly different dynamical features from those arising spontaneously (endogenous). On average, large volatility fluctuations induced by exogenous events occur abruptly and are followed by a decaying power-law relaxation, while endogenous price jumps are characterized by progressively accelerating growth of volatility, also followed by a power-law relaxation, but slower than for exogenous jumps. Remarkably, our results are reminiscent of what is observed in different contexts, namely Amazon book sales and YouTube views. Finally, we show that fitting power-laws to {\it individual} volatility profiles allows one to classify large events into endogenous and exogenous dynamical classes, without relying on the news feed. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

A new spin on optimal portfolios and ecological equilibria

Authors: Jerome Garnier-Brun, Michael Benzaquen, Stefano Ciliberti, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We consider the classical problem of optimal portfolio construction with the constraint that no short position is allowed, or equivalently the valid equilibria of multispecies Lotka-Volterra equations with self-regulation in the special case where the interaction matrix is of unit rank, corresponding to species competing for a common resource. We compute the average number of solutions and show th… ▽ More We consider the classical problem of optimal portfolio construction with the constraint that no short position is allowed, or equivalently the valid equilibria of multispecies Lotka-Volterra equations with self-regulation in the special case where the interaction matrix is of unit rank, corresponding to species competing for a common resource. We compute the average number of solutions and show that its logarithm grows as $N^α$, where $N$ is the number of assets or species and $α\leq 2/3$ depends on the interaction matrix distribution. We conjecture that the most likely number of solutions is much smaller and related to the typical sparsity $m(N)$ of the solutions, which we compute explicitly. We also find that the solution landscape is similar to that of spin-glasses, i.e. very different configurations are quasi-degenerate. Correspondingly, "disorder chaos" is also present in our problem. We discuss the consequence of such a property for portfolio construction and ecologies, and question the meaning of rational decisions when there is a very large number "satisficing" solutions. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2021; v1 submitted 1 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 37 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: J. Stat. Mech. (2021) 093408

Radical Complexity

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: This is an informal and sketchy review of six topical, somewhat unrelated subjects in quantitative finance: rough volatility models; random covariance matrix theory; copulas; crowded trades; high-frequency trading & market stability; and "radical complexity" & scenario based (macro)economics. Some open questions and research directions are briefly discussed. This is an informal and sketchy review of six topical, somewhat unrelated subjects in quantitative finance: rough volatility models; random covariance matrix theory; copulas; crowded trades; high-frequency trading & market stability; and "radical complexity" & scenario based (macro)economics. Some open questions and research directions are briefly discussed. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 10 pages, edited columns published in Risk.net

Matrix Kesten Recursion, Inverse-Wishart Ensemble and Fermions in a Morse Potential

Authors: Tristan Gautié, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Pierre Le Doussal

Abstract: The random variable $1+z_1+z_1z_2+\dots$ appears in many contexts and was shown by Kesten to exhibit a heavy tail distribution. We consider natural extensions of this variable and its associated recursion to $N \times N$ matrices either real symmetric $β=1$ or complex Hermitian $β=2$. In the continuum limit of this recursion, we show that the matrix distribution converges to the inverse-Wishart en… ▽ More The random variable $1+z_1+z_1z_2+\dots$ appears in many contexts and was shown by Kesten to exhibit a heavy tail distribution. We consider natural extensions of this variable and its associated recursion to $N \times N$ matrices either real symmetric $β=1$ or complex Hermitian $β=2$. In the continuum limit of this recursion, we show that the matrix distribution converges to the inverse-Wishart ensemble of random matrices. The full dynamics is solved using a map** to $N$ fermions in a Morse potential, which are non-interacting for $β=2$. At finite $N$ the distribution of eigenvalues exhibits heavy tails, generalizing Kesten's results in the scalar case. The density of fermions in this potential is studied for large $N$, and the power-law tail of the eigenvalue distribution is related to the properties of the so-called determinantal Bessel process which describes the hard edge universality of random matrices. For the discrete matrix recursion, using free probability in the large $N$ limit, we obtain a self-consistent equation for the stationary distribution. The relation of our results to recent works of Rider and Valkó, Grabsch and Texier, as well as Ossipov, is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2021; v1 submitted 20 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 44 pages, 5 figures, 6 appendices

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 54 255201 (2021)

Crisis Propagation in a Heterogeneous Self-Reflexive DSGE Model

Authors: Federico Guglielmo Morelli, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marco Tarzia

Abstract: We study a self-reflexive DSGE model with heterogeneous households, aimed at characterising the impact of economic recessions on the different strata of the society. Our framework allows to analyse the combined effect of income inequalities and confidence feedback mediated by heterogeneous social networks. By varying the parameters of the model, we find different crisis typologies: loss of confide… ▽ More We study a self-reflexive DSGE model with heterogeneous households, aimed at characterising the impact of economic recessions on the different strata of the society. Our framework allows to analyse the combined effect of income inequalities and confidence feedback mediated by heterogeneous social networks. By varying the parameters of the model, we find different crisis typologies: loss of confidence may propagate mostly within high income households, or mostly within low income households, with a rather sharp crossover between the two. We find that crises are more severe for segregated networks (where confidence feedback is essentially mediated between agents of the same social class), for which cascading contagion effects are stronger. For the same reason, larger income inequalities tend to reduce, in our model, the probability of global crises. Finally, we are able to reproduce a perhaps counter-intuitive empirical finding: in countries with higher Gini coefficients, the consumption of the lowest income households tends to drop less than that of the highest incomes in crisis times. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Amorphous Order & Non-linear Susceptibilities in Glassy Materials

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Francois Ladieu

Abstract: We review 15 years of theoretical and experimental work on the non-linear response of glassy systems. We argue that an anomalous growth of the peak value of non-linear susceptibilities is a signature of growing "amorphous order" in the system, with spin-glasses as a case in point. Experimental results on supercooled liquids are fully compatible with the RFOT prediction of compact "glassites" of in… ▽ More We review 15 years of theoretical and experimental work on the non-linear response of glassy systems. We argue that an anomalous growth of the peak value of non-linear susceptibilities is a signature of growing "amorphous order" in the system, with spin-glasses as a case in point. Experimental results on supercooled liquids are fully compatible with the RFOT prediction of compact "glassites" of increasing volume as temperature is decreased, or as the system ages. We clarify why such a behaviour is hard to explain within purely kinetic theories of glass formation, despite recent claims to the contrary. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: Contribution to be submitted to Dave Thirumalai Festschrift in The Journal of Physical Chemistry

Why does individual learning endure when crowds are wiser?

Authors: Benoît de Courson, Léo Fitouchi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: The ability to learn from others (social learning) is often deemed a cause of human species success. But if social learning is indeed more efficient (whether less costly or more accurate) than individual learning, it raises the question of why would anyone engage in individual information seeking, which is a necessary condition for social learning's efficacy. We propose an evolutionary model solvi… ▽ More The ability to learn from others (social learning) is often deemed a cause of human species success. But if social learning is indeed more efficient (whether less costly or more accurate) than individual learning, it raises the question of why would anyone engage in individual information seeking, which is a necessary condition for social learning's efficacy. We propose an evolutionary model solving this paradox, provided agents (i) aim not only at information quality but also vie for audience and prestige, and (ii) do not only value accuracy but also reward originality -- allowing them to alleviate herding effects. We find that under some conditions (large enough success rate of informed agents and intermediate taste for popularity), both social learning's higher accuracy and the taste for original opinions are evolutionary-stable, within a mutually beneficial division of labour-like equilibrium. When such conditions are not met, the system most often converges towards mutually detrimental equilibria. △ Less

Submitted 28 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 6 figures, 1 table

Self-Fulfilling Prophecies, Quasi Non-Ergodicity and Wealth Inequality

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Roger Farmer

Abstract: We construct a model of an exchange economy in which agents trade assets contingent on an observable signal, the probability of which depends on public opinion. The agents in our model are replaced occasionally and each person updates beliefs in response to observed outcomes. We show that the distribution of the observed signal is described by a quasi-non-ergodic process and that people continue t… ▽ More We construct a model of an exchange economy in which agents trade assets contingent on an observable signal, the probability of which depends on public opinion. The agents in our model are replaced occasionally and each person updates beliefs in response to observed outcomes. We show that the distribution of the observed signal is described by a quasi-non-ergodic process and that people continue to disagree with each other forever. These disagreements generate large wealth inequalities that arise from the multiplicative nature of wealth dynamics which make successful bold bets highly profitable. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2022; v1 submitted 17 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: Second revised version, 49 pages, 7 figures, 6 Appendices, resubmitted to JPE

Out-of-Equilibrium Dynamics and Excess Volatility in Firm Networks

Authors: Théo Dessertaine, José Moran, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We study the conditions under which input-output networks can dynamically attain a competitive equilibrium, where markets clear and profits are zero. We endow a classical firm network model with minimal dynamical rules that reduce supply/demand imbalances and excess profits. We show that the time needed to reach equilibrium diverges to infinity as the system approaches an instability point beyond… ▽ More We study the conditions under which input-output networks can dynamically attain a competitive equilibrium, where markets clear and profits are zero. We endow a classical firm network model with minimal dynamical rules that reduce supply/demand imbalances and excess profits. We show that the time needed to reach equilibrium diverges to infinity as the system approaches an instability point beyond which the Hawkins-Simons condition is violated and competitive equilibrium is no longer admissible. We argue that such slow dynamics is a source of excess volatility, through accumulation and amplification of exogenous shocks. Factoring in essential physical constraints absent in our minimal model, such as causality or inventory management, we then propose a dynamically consistent model that displays a rich variety of phenomena. Competitive equilibrium can only be reached after some time and within some restricted region of parameter space, outside of which one observes spontaneous periodic and chaotic dynamics, reminiscent of real business cycles. This suggests an alternative explanation of excess volatility in terms of purely endogenous fluctuations. Diminishing return to scale and increased perishability of goods are found to ease convergence towards equilibrium. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2021; v1 submitted 9 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 59 pages, 20 figures

On a Generalisation of the Marcenko-Pastur Problem

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marc Potters

Abstract: We study the spectrum of generalized Wishart matrices, defined as $\mathbf{F}=( X Y^\top + Y X^\top)/2T$, where $X$ and $Y$ are $N \times T$ matrices with zero mean, unit variance IID entries and such that $\mathbb{E}[X_{it} Y_{jt}]=c δ_{i,j}$. The limit $c=1$ corresponds to the Marcenko-Pastur problem. For a general $c$, we show that the Stietjes transform of $\mathbf{F}$ is the solution of a cub… ▽ More We study the spectrum of generalized Wishart matrices, defined as $\mathbf{F}=( X Y^\top + Y X^\top)/2T$, where $X$ and $Y$ are $N \times T$ matrices with zero mean, unit variance IID entries and such that $\mathbb{E}[X_{it} Y_{jt}]=c δ_{i,j}$. The limit $c=1$ corresponds to the Marcenko-Pastur problem. For a general $c$, we show that the Stietjes transform of $\mathbf{F}$ is the solution of a cubic equation. In the limit $c=0$, $T \gg N$ the density of eigenvalues converges to the Wigner semi-circle. △ Less

Submitted 20 September, 2020; v1 submitted 15 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, reference to the "Tetilla" law added

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 102, 062117 (2020)

Did lockdowns serve their purpose?

Authors: Serena Bradde, Benedetta Cerruti, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We show that the dynamics of the number of deaths due to Covid in different countries is to a large extent universal once the origin of time is chosen to be the start of the lockdown, and the number of death is rescaled by the total number of deaths after the lockdown, itself a proxy of the number of infections at the start of the lockdown. Such a curve collapse is much less convincing when normal… ▽ More We show that the dynamics of the number of deaths due to Covid in different countries is to a large extent universal once the origin of time is chosen to be the start of the lockdown, and the number of death is rescaled by the total number of deaths after the lockdown, itself a proxy of the number of infections at the start of the lockdown. Such a curve collapse is much less convincing when normalizing by the total population. Sweden, with its no-lockdown, light-touch approach, is the only outlier that deviates considerably from the average behavior. We argue that these model-free findings provide strong support for the effectiveness of the lockdowns in mitigating the lethality of the virus. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Short note, 4 pages, 3 figures

V-, U-, L-, or W-shaped economic recovery after COVID: Insights from an Agent Based Model

Authors: Dhruv Sharma, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Stanislao Gualdi, Marco Tarzia, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: We discuss the impact of a Covid-19--like shock on a simple model economy, described by the previously developed Mark-0 Agent-Based Model. We consider a mixed supply and demand shock, and show that depending on the shock parameters (amplitude and duration), our model economy can display V-shaped, U-shaped or W-shaped recoveries, and even an L-shaped output curve with permanent output loss. This is… ▽ More We discuss the impact of a Covid-19--like shock on a simple model economy, described by the previously developed Mark-0 Agent-Based Model. We consider a mixed supply and demand shock, and show that depending on the shock parameters (amplitude and duration), our model economy can display V-shaped, U-shaped or W-shaped recoveries, and even an L-shaped output curve with permanent output loss. This is due to the economy getting trapped in a self-sustained "bad" state. We then discuss two policies that attempt to moderate the impact of the shock: giving easy credit to firms, and the so-called helicopter money, i.e. injecting new money into the households savings. We find that both policies are effective if strong enough. We highlight the potential danger of terminating these policies too early, although inflation is substantially increased by lax access to credit. Finally, we consider the impact of a second lockdown. While we only discuss a limited number of scenarios, our model is flexible and versatile enough to accommodate a wide variety of situations, thus serving as a useful exploratory tool for a qualitative, scenario-based understanding of post-Covid recovery. The corresponding code is available on-line. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2021; v1 submitted 15 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 20 Pages. Model description within the main text. Discussion on multiple lockdowns added. See code for paper at https://gitlab.com/sharma.dhruv/markovid

Journal ref: PLoS ONE 16, e0247823 (2021)

Good speciation and endogenous business cycles in a constraint satisfaction macroeconomic model

Authors: Dhruv Sharma, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marco Tarzia, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: We introduce a prototype agent-based model of the macroeconomy, with budgetary constraints at its core. The model is related to a class of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs), which has been thoroughly investigated in computer science. The CSP paradigm allows us to propose an alternative price-setting mechanism: given agents' preferences and budgets, what set of prices satisfies the maximum nu… ▽ More We introduce a prototype agent-based model of the macroeconomy, with budgetary constraints at its core. The model is related to a class of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs), which has been thoroughly investigated in computer science. The CSP paradigm allows us to propose an alternative price-setting mechanism: given agents' preferences and budgets, what set of prices satisfies the maximum number of agents? Such an approach permits the coupling of production and output within the economy to the allowed level of debt in a simplified framework. Within our model, we identify three different regimes upon varying the amount of debt that each agent can accumulate before defaulting. In presence of a very loose constraint on debt, endogenous crises leading to waves of synchronized bankruptcies are present. In the opposite regime of very tight debt constraining, the bankruptcy rate is extremely high and the economy remains structure-less. In an intermediate regime, the economy is stable with very low bankruptcy rate and no aggregate-level crises. This third regime displays a rich phenomenology:the system spontaneously and dynamically self-organizes in a set of cheap and expensive goods (i.e. some kind of "speciation"), with switches triggered by random fluctuations and feedback loops. Our analysis confirms the central role that debt levels play in the stability of the economy. More generally, our model shows that constraints at the individual scale can generate highly complex patterns at the aggregate level. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2021; v1 submitted 24 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 14 Pages, 11 Figures. Updated Journal Reference

Journal ref: J. Stat. Mech. (2021) 063403

Non-parametric Estimation of Quadratic Hawkes Processes for Order Book Events

Authors: Antoine Fosset, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: We propose an actionable calibration procedure for general Quadratic Hawkes models of order book events (market orders, limit orders, cancellations). One of the main features of such models is to encode not only the influence of past events on future events but also, crucially, the influence of past price changes on such events. We show that the empirically calibrated quadratic kernel is well desc… ▽ More We propose an actionable calibration procedure for general Quadratic Hawkes models of order book events (market orders, limit orders, cancellations). One of the main features of such models is to encode not only the influence of past events on future events but also, crucially, the influence of past price changes on such events. We show that the empirically calibrated quadratic kernel is well described by a diagonal contribution (that captures past realised volatility), plus a rank-one "Zumbach" contribution (that captures the effect of past trends). We find that the Zumbach kernel is a power-law of time, as are all other feedback kernels. As in many previous studies, the rate of truly exogenous events is found to be a small fraction of the total event rate. These two features suggest that the system is close to a critical point -- in the sense that stronger feedback kernels would lead to instabilities. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 17 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables

How Much Income Inequality Is Too Much?

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We propose a highly schematic economic model in which, in some cases, wage inequalities lead to higher overall social welfare. This is due to the fact that high earners can consume low productivity, non essential products, which allows everybody to remain employed even when the productivity of essential goods is high and producing them does not require everybody to work. We derive a relation betwe… ▽ More We propose a highly schematic economic model in which, in some cases, wage inequalities lead to higher overall social welfare. This is due to the fact that high earners can consume low productivity, non essential products, which allows everybody to remain employed even when the productivity of essential goods is high and producing them does not require everybody to work. We derive a relation between heterogeneities in technologies and the minimum Gini coefficient required to maximize global welfare. Stronger inequalities appear to be economically unjustified. Our model may shed light on the role of non-essential goods in the economy, a topical issue when thinking about the post-Covid-19 world. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: Working paper, 11 pages

Schrödinger's ants: A continuous description of Kirman's recruitment model

Authors: José Moran, Antoine Fosset, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We show how the approach to equilibrium in Kirman's ants model can be fully characterized in terms of the spectrum of a Schrödinger equation with a Pöschl-Teller ($\tan^2$) potential. Among other interesting properties, we have found that in the bimodal phase where ants visit mostly one food site at a time, the switch time between the two sources only depends on the ``spontaneous conversion" rate… ▽ More We show how the approach to equilibrium in Kirman's ants model can be fully characterized in terms of the spectrum of a Schrödinger equation with a Pöschl-Teller ($\tan^2$) potential. Among other interesting properties, we have found that in the bimodal phase where ants visit mostly one food site at a time, the switch time between the two sources only depends on the ``spontaneous conversion" rate and not on the recruitment rate. More complicated correlation functions can be computed exactly, and involve higher and higher eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the Schrödinger operator, which can be expressed in terms of hypergeometric functions. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

By Force of Habit: Self-Trap** in a Dynamical Utility Landscape

Authors: José Moran, Antoine Fosset, Davide Luzzati, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: Historically, rational choice theory has focused on the utility maximization principle to describe how individuals make choices. In reality, there is a computational cost related to exploring the universe of available choices and it is often not clear whether we are truly maximizing an underlying utility function. In particular, memory effects and habit formation may dominate over utility maximisa… ▽ More Historically, rational choice theory has focused on the utility maximization principle to describe how individuals make choices. In reality, there is a computational cost related to exploring the universe of available choices and it is often not clear whether we are truly maximizing an underlying utility function. In particular, memory effects and habit formation may dominate over utility maximisation. We propose a stylized model with a history-dependent utility function where the utility associated to each choice is increased when that choice has been made in the past, with a certain decaying memory kernel. We show that self-reinforcing effects can cause the agent to get stuck with a choice by sheer force of habit. We discuss the special nature of the transition between free exploration of the space of choice and self-trap**. We find in particular that the trap** time distribution is precisely a Zipf law at the transition, and that the self-trapped phase exhibits super-aging behaviour. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures, 1 table

Equity Factors: To Short Or Not To Short, That Is The Question

Authors: Florent Benaych-Georges, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Stefano Ciliberti

Abstract: What is the best market-neutral implementation of classical Equity Factors? Should one use the specific predictability of the short-leg to build a zero beta Long-Short portfolio, in spite of the specific costs associated to shorting, or is it preferable to ban the shorts and hedge the long-leg with -- say -- an index future? We revisit this question by focusing on the relative predictability of th… ▽ More What is the best market-neutral implementation of classical Equity Factors? Should one use the specific predictability of the short-leg to build a zero beta Long-Short portfolio, in spite of the specific costs associated to shorting, or is it preferable to ban the shorts and hedge the long-leg with -- say -- an index future? We revisit this question by focusing on the relative predictability of the two legs, the issue of diversification, and various sources of costs. Our conclusion is that, using the same Factors, a Long-Short implementation leads to superior risk-adjusted returns than its Hedged Long-Only counterpart, at least when Assets Under Management are not too large. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2021; v1 submitted 23 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 11 figures. To appear in Journal of Investing

Zooming In on Equity Factor Crowding

Authors: Valerio Volpati, Michael Benzaquen, Zoltan Eisler, Iacopo Mastromatteo, Bence Toth, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Crowding is most likely an important factor in the deterioration of strategy performance, the increase of trading costs and the development of systemic risk. We study the imprints of \emph{crowding} on both anonymous market data and a large database of metaorders from institutional investors in the U.S. equity market. We propose direct metrics of crowding that capture the presence of investors con… ▽ More Crowding is most likely an important factor in the deterioration of strategy performance, the increase of trading costs and the development of systemic risk. We study the imprints of \emph{crowding} on both anonymous market data and a large database of metaorders from institutional investors in the U.S. equity market. We propose direct metrics of crowding that capture the presence of investors contemporaneously trading the same stock in the same direction by looking at fluctuations of the imbalances of trades executed on the market. We identify significant signs of crowding in well known equity signals, such as Fama-French factors and especially Momentum. We show that the rebalancing of a Momentum portfolio can explain between 1-2\% of order flow, and that this percentage has been significantly increasing in recent years. △ Less

Submitted 13 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures

Conditional Correlations and Principal Regression Analysis for Futures

Authors: Armine Karami, Raphael Benichou, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We explore the effect of past market movements on the instantaneous correlations between assets within the futures market. Quantifying this effect is of interest to estimate and manage the risk associated to portfolios of futures in a non-stationary context. We apply and extend a previously reported method called the Principal Regression Analysis (PRA) to a universe of $84$ futures contracts betwe… ▽ More We explore the effect of past market movements on the instantaneous correlations between assets within the futures market. Quantifying this effect is of interest to estimate and manage the risk associated to portfolios of futures in a non-stationary context. We apply and extend a previously reported method called the Principal Regression Analysis (PRA) to a universe of $84$ futures contracts between $2009$ and $2019$. We show that the past up (resp. down) 10 day trends of a novel predictor -- the eigen-factor -- tend to reduce (resp. increase) instantaneous correlations. We then carry out a multifactor PRA on sectorial predictors corresponding to the four futures sectors (indexes, commodities, bonds and currencies), and show that the effect of past market movements on the future variations of the instantaneous correlations can be decomposed into two significant components. The first component is due to the market movements within the index sector, while the second component is due to the market movements within the bonds sector. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2020; v1 submitted 27 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 12 pages, 14 figures, 1 table

Endogenous Liquidity Crises

Authors: Antoine Fosset, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: Empirical data reveals that the liquidity flow into the order book (depositions, cancellations andmarket orders) is influenced by past price changes. In particular, we show that liquidity tends todecrease with the amplitude of past volatility and price trends. Such a feedback mechanism inturn increases the volatility, possibly leading to a liquidity crisis. Accounting for such effects withina styl… ▽ More Empirical data reveals that the liquidity flow into the order book (depositions, cancellations andmarket orders) is influenced by past price changes. In particular, we show that liquidity tends todecrease with the amplitude of past volatility and price trends. Such a feedback mechanism inturn increases the volatility, possibly leading to a liquidity crisis. Accounting for such effects withina stylized order book model, we demonstrate numerically that there exists a second order phasetransition between a stable regime for weak feedback to an unstable regime for strong feedback,in which liquidity crises arise with probability one. We characterize the critical exponents, whichappear to belong to a new universality class. We then propose a simpler model for spread dynamicsthat maps onto a linear Hawkes process which also exhibits liquidity crises. If relevant for thereal markets, such a phase transition scenario requires the system to sit below, but very close tothe instability threshold (self-organised criticality), or else that the feedback intensity is itself timedependent and occasionally visits the unstable region. An alternative scenario is provided by a classof non-linear Hawkes process that show occasional "activated" liquidity crises, without having to bepoised at the edge of instability. △ Less

Submitted 19 February, 2020; v1 submitted 1 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 21 pages, 11 figures, 1 table