-
Graph-based sufficient conditions for indistinguishability of linear compartmental models
Authors:
Cashous Bortner,
Nicolette Meshkat
Abstract:
An important problem in biological modeling is choosing the right model. Given experimental data, one is supposed to find the best mathematical representation to describe the real-world phenomena. However, there may not be a unique model representing that real-world phenomena. Two distinct models could yield the same exact dynamics. In this case, these models are called indistinguishable. In this…
▽ More
An important problem in biological modeling is choosing the right model. Given experimental data, one is supposed to find the best mathematical representation to describe the real-world phenomena. However, there may not be a unique model representing that real-world phenomena. Two distinct models could yield the same exact dynamics. In this case, these models are called indistinguishable. In this work, we consider the indistinguishability problem for linear compartmental models, which are used in many areas, such as pharmacokinetics, physiology, cell biology, toxicology, and ecology. We exhibit sufficient conditions for indistinguishability for models with a certain graph structure: paths from input to output with "detours". The benefit of applying our results is that indistinguishability can be proven using only the graph structure of the models, without the use of any symbolic computation. This can be very helpful for medium-to-large sized linear compartmental models. These are the first sufficient conditions for indistinguishability of linear compartmental models based on graph structure alone, as previously only necessary conditions for indistinguishability of linear compartmental models existed based on graph structure alone. We prove our results by showing that the indistinguishable models are the same up to a renaming of parameters, which we call permutation indistinguishability.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2024; v1 submitted 19 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Structural Identifiability of Series-Parallel LCR Systems
Authors:
Cashous Bortner,
Seth Sullivant
Abstract:
We consider the identifiability problem for the parameters of series-parallel LCR circuit networks. We prove that for networks with only two classes of components (inductor-capacitor (LC), inductor-resistor (LR), and capacitor-resistor (RC)), the parameters are identifiable if and only if the number of non-monic coefficients of the constitutive equations equals the number of parameters. The notion…
▽ More
We consider the identifiability problem for the parameters of series-parallel LCR circuit networks. We prove that for networks with only two classes of components (inductor-capacitor (LC), inductor-resistor (LR), and capacitor-resistor (RC)), the parameters are identifiable if and only if the number of non-monic coefficients of the constitutive equations equals the number of parameters. The notion of the "type" of the constitutive equations plays a key role in the identifiability of LC, LR, and RC networks. We also investigate the general series-parallel LCR circuits (with all three classes of components), and classify the types of constitutive equations that can arise, showing that there are 22 different types. However, we produce an example that shows that the basic notion of type that works to classify identifiability of two class networks is not sufficient to classify the identifiability of general series-parallel LCR circuits.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2022; v1 submitted 13 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Identifiability of linear compartmental tree models and a general formula for input-output equations
Authors:
Cashous Bortner,
Elizabeth Gross,
Nicolette Meshkat,
Anne Shiu,
Seth Sullivant
Abstract:
A foundational question in the theory of linear compartmental models is how to assess whether a model is structurally identifiable -- that is, whether parameter values can be inferred from noiseless data -- directly from the combinatorics of the model. Our main result completely answers this question for models (with one input and one output) in which the underlying graph is a bidirectional tree;…
▽ More
A foundational question in the theory of linear compartmental models is how to assess whether a model is structurally identifiable -- that is, whether parameter values can be inferred from noiseless data -- directly from the combinatorics of the model. Our main result completely answers this question for models (with one input and one output) in which the underlying graph is a bidirectional tree; moreover, identifiability of such models can be verified visually}. Models of this structure include two families of models often appearing in biological applications: catenary and mammillary models. Our analysis of such models is enabled by two supporting results, which are significant in their own right. One result gives the first general formula for the coefficients of input-output equations (certain equations that can be used to determine identifiability) that allows for input and output to be in distinct compartments}. In another supporting result, we prove that identifiability is preserved when a model is enlarged and altered in specific ways involving adding a new compartment with a bidirected edge to an existing compartment.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2022; v1 submitted 15 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Identifiable paths and cycles in linear compartmental models
Authors:
Cashous Bortner,
Nicolette Meshkat
Abstract:
We introduce a class of linear compartmental models called identifiable path/cycle models which have the property that all of the monomial functions of parameters associated to the directed cycles and paths from input compartments to output compartments are identifiable and give sufficient conditions to obtain one. Removing leaks, we then show how one can obtain a locally identifiable model from a…
▽ More
We introduce a class of linear compartmental models called identifiable path/cycle models which have the property that all of the monomial functions of parameters associated to the directed cycles and paths from input compartments to output compartments are identifiable and give sufficient conditions to obtain one. Removing leaks, we then show how one can obtain a locally identifiable model from an identifiable path/cycle model. These identifiable path/cycle models yield the only identifiable models with certain conditions on their graph structure and thus we provide necessary and sufficient conditions for identifiable models with certain graph properties. A sufficient condition based on the graph structure of the model is also provided so that one can test if a model is an identifiable path/cycle model by examining the graph itself. We also provide some necessary conditions for identifiability based on graph structure. Our proofs use algebraic and combinatorial techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2021; v1 submitted 14 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
The set splittability problem
Authors:
Peter Bernstein,
Cashous Bortner,
Samuel Coskey,
Shuni Li,
Connor Simpson
Abstract:
The set splittability problem is the following: given a finite collection of finite sets, does there exits a single set that contains exactly half the elements from each set in the collection? (If a set has odd size, we allow the floor or ceiling.) It is natural to study the set splittability problem in the context of combinatorial discrepancy theory and its applications, since a collection is spl…
▽ More
The set splittability problem is the following: given a finite collection of finite sets, does there exits a single set that contains exactly half the elements from each set in the collection? (If a set has odd size, we allow the floor or ceiling.) It is natural to study the set splittability problem in the context of combinatorial discrepancy theory and its applications, since a collection is splittable if and only if it has discrepancy $\leq1$.
We introduce a natural generalization of splittability problem called the $p$-splittability problem, where we replace the fraction $\frac12$ in the definition with an arbitrary fraction $p\in(0,1)$. We first show that the $p$-splittability problem is NP-complete. We then give several criteria for $p$-splittability, including a complete characterization of $p$-splittability for three or fewer sets ($p$ arbitrary), and for four or fewer sets ($p=\frac12$). Finally we prove the asymptotic prevalence of splittability over unsplittability in an appropriate sense.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2019; v1 submitted 4 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
