The FRET-based structural dynamics challenge -- community contributions to consistent and open science practices
Authors:
Eitan Lerner,
Benjamin Ambrose,
Anders Barth,
Victoria Birkedal,
Scott C. Blanchard,
Richard Borner,
Thorben Cordes,
Timothy D. Craggs,
Taekjip Ha,
Gilad Haran,
Thorsten Hugel,
Antonino Ingargiola,
Achillefs Kapanidis,
Don C. Lamb,
Ted Laurence,
Nam ki Lee,
Edward A. Lemke,
Emmanuel Margeat,
Jens Michaelis,
Xavier Michalet,
Daniel Nettels,
Thomas-Otavio Peulen,
Benjamin Schuler,
Claus A. M. Seidel,
Hamid So-leimaninejad
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) has become a mainstream technique for probing biomolecular structural dynamics. The rapid and wide adoption of the technique by an ever-increasing number of groups has generated many improvements and variations in the technique itself, in methods for sample preparation and characterization, in analysis of the data from such experiments, an…
▽ More
Single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) has become a mainstream technique for probing biomolecular structural dynamics. The rapid and wide adoption of the technique by an ever-increasing number of groups has generated many improvements and variations in the technique itself, in methods for sample preparation and characterization, in analysis of the data from such experiments, and in analysis codes and algorithms. Recently, several labs that employ smFRET have joined forces to try to bring the smFRET community together in adopting a consensus on how to perform experiments and analyze results for achieving quantitative structural information. These recent efforts include multi-lab blind-tests to assess the accuracy and precision of smFRET between different labs using different procedures, the formal assembly of the FRET community and development of smFRET procedures to be considered for entries in the wwPDB. Here we delve into the different approaches and viewpoints in the field. This position paper describes the current "state-of-the field", points to unresolved methodological issues for quantitative structural studies, provides a set of 'soft recommendations' about which an emerging consensus exists, and a list of resources that are openly available. To make further progress, we strongly encourage 'open science' practices. We hope that this position paper will provide a roadmap for newcomers to the field, as well as a reference for seasoned practitioners.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
Precision and accuracy of single-molecule FRET measurements - a worldwide benchmark study
Authors:
Björn Hellenkamp,
Sonja Schmid,
Olga Doroshenko,
Oleg Opanasyuk,
Ralf Kühnemuth,
Soheila Rezaei Adariani,
Anders Barth,
Victoria Birkedal,
Mark E. Bowen,
Hongtao Chen,
Thorben Cordes,
Tobias Eilert,
Carel Fijen,
Markus Götz,
Giorgos Gouridis,
Enrico Gratton,
Taekjip Ha,
Christian A. Hanke,
Andreas Hartmann,
Jelle Hendrix,
Lasse L. Hildebrandt,
Johannes Hohlbein,
Christian G. Hübner,
Eleni Kallis,
Achillefs N. Kapanidis
, et al. (28 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) is increasingly being used to determine distances, structures, and dynamics of biomolecules in vitro and in vivo. However, generalized protocols and FRET standards ensuring both the reproducibility and accuracy of measuring FRET efficiencies are currently lacking. Here we report the results of a worldwide, comparative, blind study, in whic…
▽ More
Single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) is increasingly being used to determine distances, structures, and dynamics of biomolecules in vitro and in vivo. However, generalized protocols and FRET standards ensuring both the reproducibility and accuracy of measuring FRET efficiencies are currently lacking. Here we report the results of a worldwide, comparative, blind study, in which 20 labs determined the FRET efficiencies of several dye-labeled DNA duplexes. Using a unified and straightforward method, we show that FRET efficiencies can be obtained with a standard deviation between $Δ$E = +-0.02 and +-0.05. We further suggest an experimental and computational procedure for converting FRET efficiencies into accurate distances. We discuss potential uncertainties in the experiment and the modelling. Our extensive quantitative assessment of intensity-based smFRET measurements and correction procedures serve as an essential step towards validation of distance networks with the ultimate aim to archive reliable structural models of biomolecular systems obtained by smFRET-based hybrid methods.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2017; v1 submitted 10 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.