An ab-initio derivation to discuss the heterodyne versus direct detection decision problem for astronomical infrared interferometry
Authors:
E. A. Michael,
F. E. Besser,
M. Hadjara,
E. Moreno,
A. Berdja,
M. Pina,
G. Pereira
Abstract:
A consistent and explicit spectral comparison between heterodyne (HD) and direct detection (DD) derived from first principles including the atmospheric transmission and low beam-filling factors could not be found yet in literature but is needed for decisions in technology planification for future infrared interferometry facilities which are e.g. focused on planet formation. This task requires both…
▽ More
A consistent and explicit spectral comparison between heterodyne (HD) and direct detection (DD) derived from first principles including the atmospheric transmission and low beam-filling factors could not be found yet in literature but is needed for decisions in technology planification for future infrared interferometry facilities which are e.g. focused on planet formation. This task requires both, high sensitivity continuum and Doppler-resolved emission and absorption line detection in the mid-IR range (N- and Q-bands) at lower source temperatures (300-1000 K). The signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) are derived for both schemes within the same semi-classical theory, which consists of classical mode theory for coupling to an antenna and occupation of these modes by quanta of three radiation fields, the thermal signal, the thermal background, and for HD also the coherent local oscillator (LO). The effects of very small beam filling factors (interferometry) and atmospheric absorption/emission could be consistently incorporated this way, as well as quantum-noise propagation which allows in HD the consideration of balanced mixers with cross-correlation (CC). Especially, the transition from pre- to post-detection SNRs was considered meticulously. We do this all because the usually cited SNR-expressions were derived for a too simple and unrealistic case, and moreover contain some wrong assumptions. We introduce a novel HD scheme for astronomical interferometry gaining an order of magnitude in sensitivity against conventional HD and calculate that it should trespass the sensitivity of DD interferometry in the N- and Q-bands for a spectral resolution of R=10000, and should do also for R=300 with doable technical improvements. This result encourages to develop broad-band heterodyne technologies for future mid-infrared interferometry facilities and for new instruments at existing facilities.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
On the possibility of breaking the heterodyne detection quantum noise limit with cross-correlation
Authors:
E. A. Michael,
F. E. Besser
Abstract:
The cross-correlation sensitivity of two identical balanced photodiode heterodyne receivers is characterized. Both balanced photodiodes receive the same weak signal split up equally, a situation equivalent to an astronomical spatial interferometer. A common local oscillator (LO) is also split up equally and its phase difference between both receivers is stabilized. We show by semi-classical photon…
▽ More
The cross-correlation sensitivity of two identical balanced photodiode heterodyne receivers is characterized. Both balanced photodiodes receive the same weak signal split up equally, a situation equivalent to an astronomical spatial interferometer. A common local oscillator (LO) is also split up equally and its phase difference between both receivers is stabilized. We show by semi-classical photon deletion theory that the post-detection laser shot noise contributions on both receivers must be completely uncorrelated in this case of passing three power splitters. We measured the auto- and cross-correlation outputs as a function of weak signal power (system noise temperature measurement), and obtain a cross-correlation system noise temperature up to 20 times lower than for the auto-correlation system noise temperature of each receiver separately. This is supported by Allan plot measurements showing cross-correlation standard deviations 30 times lower than in auto-correlation. Careful calibration of the source power shows that the auto-correlation (regular) noise temperature of the single balanced receivers is already very near to the quantum limit as expected, which suggests a cross-correlation system noise temperature below the quantum limit. If validated further, this experimentally clear finding will not only be relevant for astronomical instrumentation but also for other fields like telecommunications and medical imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
