Testing Assumptions Underlying a Unified Theory for the Origin of Grid Cells
Authors:
Rylan Schaeffer,
Mikail Khona,
Adrian Bertagnoli,
Sanmi Koyejo,
Ila Rani Fiete
Abstract:
Representing and reasoning about physical space is fundamental to animal survival, and the mammalian lineage expresses a wealth of specialized neural representations that encode space. Grid cells, whose discovery earned a Nobel prize, are a striking example: a grid cell is a neuron that fires if and only if the animal is spatially located at the vertices of a regular triangular lattice that tiles…
▽ More
Representing and reasoning about physical space is fundamental to animal survival, and the mammalian lineage expresses a wealth of specialized neural representations that encode space. Grid cells, whose discovery earned a Nobel prize, are a striking example: a grid cell is a neuron that fires if and only if the animal is spatially located at the vertices of a regular triangular lattice that tiles all explored two-dimensional environments. Significant theoretical work has gone into understanding why mammals have learned these particular representations, and recent work has proposed a ``unified theory for the computational and mechanistic origin of grid cells," claiming to answer why the mammalian lineage has learned grid cells. However, the Unified Theory makes a series of highly specific assumptions about the target readouts of grid cells - putatively place cells. In this work, we explicitly identify what these mathematical assumptions are, then test two of the critical assumptions using biological place cell data. At both the population and single-cell levels, we find evidence suggesting that neither of the assumptions are likely true in biological neural representations. These results call the Unified Theory into question, suggesting that biological grid cells likely have a different origin than those obtained in trained artificial neural networks.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
See and Copy: Generation of complex compositional movements from modular and geometric RNN representations
Authors:
Sunny Duan,
Mikail Khona,
Adrian Bertagnoli,
Sarthak Chandra,
Ila Fiete
Abstract:
A hallmark of biological intelligence and control is combinatorial generalization: animals are able to learn various things, then piece them together in new combinations to produce appropriate outputs for new tasks. Inspired by the ability of primates to readily imitate seen movement sequences, we present a model of motor control using a realistic model of arm dynamics, tasked with imitating a gui…
▽ More
A hallmark of biological intelligence and control is combinatorial generalization: animals are able to learn various things, then piece them together in new combinations to produce appropriate outputs for new tasks. Inspired by the ability of primates to readily imitate seen movement sequences, we present a model of motor control using a realistic model of arm dynamics, tasked with imitating a guide that makes arbitrary two-segment drawings. We hypothesize that modular organization is one of the keys to such flexible and generalizable control. We construct a modular control model consisting of separate encoding and motor RNNs and a scheduler, which we train end-to-end on the task. We show that the modular structure allows the model to generalize not only to unseen two-segment trajectories, but to new drawings consisting of many more segments than it was trained on, and also allows for rapid adaptation to perturbations. Finally, our model recapitulates experimental observations of the preparatory and execution-related processes unfolding during motor control, providing a normative explanation for functional segregation of preparatory and execution-related activity within the motor cortex.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
