-
No-signaling in Nonlinear Extensions of Quantum Mechanics
Authors:
Rohit Kishan Ray,
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
Devising a nonlinear extension of quantum mechanics is nontrivial because unphysical features such as supraluminal communication (signaling) are to be excluded. In this Letter, we show that the steepest entropy ascent formalism is a viable no-signaling extension belonging to a broader class of no-signaling nonlinear evolution equations for which the local evolution of a subsystem is not necessaril…
▽ More
Devising a nonlinear extension of quantum mechanics is nontrivial because unphysical features such as supraluminal communication (signaling) are to be excluded. In this Letter, we show that the steepest entropy ascent formalism is a viable no-signaling extension belonging to a broader class of no-signaling nonlinear evolution equations for which the local evolution of a subsystem is not necessarily bound to depend only on its reduced state. We prove that, in addition to the local reduced density operator, there is a broad class of local operators called `local perceptions', which are insensitive to unitary operations localized within other non-interacting systems.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2023; v1 submitted 27 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Method for Generating Randomly Perturbed Density Operators Subject to Different Sets of Constraints
Authors:
J. A. Montanez-Barrera,
R. T. Holladay,
G. P. Beretta,
Michael R. von Spakovsky
Abstract:
This paper presents a general method for producing randomly perturbed density operators subject to different sets of constraints. The perturbed density operators are a specified "distance" away from the state described by the original density operator. This approach is applied to a bipartite system of qubits and used to examine the sensitivity of various entanglement measures on the perturbation m…
▽ More
This paper presents a general method for producing randomly perturbed density operators subject to different sets of constraints. The perturbed density operators are a specified "distance" away from the state described by the original density operator. This approach is applied to a bipartite system of qubits and used to examine the sensitivity of various entanglement measures on the perturbation magnitude. The constraint sets used include constant energy, constant entropy, and both constant energy and entropy. The method is then applied to produce perturbed random quantum states that correspond with those obtained experimentally for Bell states on the IBM quantum device ibmq_manila. The results show that the methodology can be used to simulate the outcome of real quantum devices where noise, which is important both in theory and simulation, is present.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2022; v1 submitted 22 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
New definitions of thermodynamic temperature and entropy not based on the concepts of heat and thermal reservoir
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta,
Enzo Zanchini
Abstract:
From a new rigorous formulation of the general axiomatic foundations of thermodynamics we derive an operational definition of entropy that responds to the emergent need in many technological frameworks to understand and deploy thermodynamic entropy well beyond the traditional realm of equilibrium states of macroscopic systems. The new treatment starts from a previously developed set of carefully w…
▽ More
From a new rigorous formulation of the general axiomatic foundations of thermodynamics we derive an operational definition of entropy that responds to the emergent need in many technological frameworks to understand and deploy thermodynamic entropy well beyond the traditional realm of equilibrium states of macroscopic systems. The new treatment starts from a previously developed set of carefully worded operational definitions for all the necessary basic concepts, and is not based on the traditional ones of "heat" and of "thermal reservoir." It is achieved in three steps. First, a new definition of thermodynamic temperature is stated, for any stable equilibrium state. Then, by employing this definition, a measurement procedure is developed which defines uniquely the property entropy in a broad domain of states, which could include \textit{in principle}, even some non-equilibrium states of few-particle systems, provided they are separable and uncorrelated. Finally, the domain of validity of the definition is extended, possibly to every state of every system, by a different procedure, based on the preceding one, which associates a range of entropy values to any state not included in the previous domain. The principle of entropy non-decrease and the additivity of entropy are proved in both the domains considered.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Time-Energy and Time-Entropy Uncertainty Relations in Nonequilibrium Quantum Thermodynamics under Steepest-Entropy-Ascent Nonlinear Master Equations
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
In the domain of nondissipative unitary Hamiltonian dynamics, the well-known Mandelstam-Tamm-Messiah time-energy uncertainty relation $τ_{F}Δ_H\ge \hbar/2$ provides a general lower bound to the characteristic time $τ_F =Δ_F/|{\rm d} \langle F\rangle/dt|$ with which the mean value of a generic quantum observable $F$ can change with respect to the width $Δ_F$ of its uncertainty distribution (square…
▽ More
In the domain of nondissipative unitary Hamiltonian dynamics, the well-known Mandelstam-Tamm-Messiah time-energy uncertainty relation $τ_{F}Δ_H\ge \hbar/2$ provides a general lower bound to the characteristic time $τ_F =Δ_F/|{\rm d} \langle F\rangle/dt|$ with which the mean value of a generic quantum observable $F$ can change with respect to the width $Δ_F$ of its uncertainty distribution (square root of $F$ fluctuations). A useful practical consequence is that in unitary dynamics the states with longer lifetimes are those with smaller energy uncertainty $Δ_H$ (square root of energy fluctuations). Here we show that when unitary evolution is complemented with a steepest-entropy-ascent model of dissipation, the resulting nonlinear master equation entails that these lower bounds get modified and depend also on the entropy uncertainty $Δ_S$ (square root of entropy fluctuations). For example, we obtain the time-energy--and--time-entropy uncertainty relation $(2τ_{F}Δ_H/ \hbar)^2+(τ_{F}Δ_S/{k_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle B}}τ)^2 \ge 1$ where $τ$ is a characteristic dissipation time functional that for each given state defines the strength of the nonunitary, steepest-entropy-ascent part of the assumed master equation. For purely dissipative dynamics this reduces to the time-entropy uncertainty relation $τ_{F}Δ_S\ge {k_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle B}}τ$, meaning that the nonequilibrium dissipative states with longer lifetime are those with smaller entropy uncertainty $Δ_S$.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
The fourth law of thermodynamics: steepest entropy ascent
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
When thermodynamics is understood as the science (or art) of constructing effective models of natural phenomena by choosing a minimal level of description capable of capturing the essential features of the physical reality of interest, the scientific community has identified a set of general rules that the model must incorporate if it aspires to be consistent with the body of known experimental ev…
▽ More
When thermodynamics is understood as the science (or art) of constructing effective models of natural phenomena by choosing a minimal level of description capable of capturing the essential features of the physical reality of interest, the scientific community has identified a set of general rules that the model must incorporate if it aspires to be consistent with the body of known experimental evidence. Some of these rules are believed to be so general that we think of them as laws of Nature, such as the great conservation principles, whose "greatness" derives from their generality, as masterfully explained by Feynman in one of his legendary lectures. The second law of thermodynamics is universally contemplated among the great laws of Nature. In this paper we show that, in the past four decades, an enormous body of scientific research devoted to modeling the essential features of nonequilibrium natural phenomena has converged from many different directions and frameworks towards the general recognition (albeit still expressed in different but equivalent forms and language) that another rule is also indispensable and reveals another great law of Nature that we propose to call the \caporali{fourth law of thermodynamics}. We state it as follows: every nonequilibrium state of a system or local subsystem for which entropy is well-defined must be equipped with a metric in state space with respect to which the irreversible component of its time evolution is in the direction of steepest entropy ascent compatible with the conservation constraints. To illustrate the power of the fourth law, we derive (nonlinear) extensions of Onsager reciprocity and fluctuation-dissipation relations to the far-nonequilibrium realm within the framework of the rate-controlled constrained-equilibrium (RCCE) approximation (also known as the quasi-equilibrium approximation).
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2019; v1 submitted 15 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Steepest-entropy-ascent quantum thermodynamic framework for describing the non-equilibrium behavior of a chemically reactive system at an atomistic level
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta,
Michael von Spakovsky
Abstract:
Steepest-Entropy-Ascent Quantum Thermodynamics (SEAQT) provides a general framework for the description of non-equilibrium phenomena at any level, particularly the atomistic one. This theory and its dynamical postulate are used here to develop a general mathematical framework, which at an atomistic level, in particular, can be used to predict the non-equilibrium evolution in state of a closed, che…
▽ More
Steepest-Entropy-Ascent Quantum Thermodynamics (SEAQT) provides a general framework for the description of non-equilibrium phenomena at any level, particularly the atomistic one. This theory and its dynamical postulate are used here to develop a general mathematical framework, which at an atomistic level, in particular, can be used to predict the non-equilibrium evolution in state of a closed, chemically reactive mixture such as the one examined here, i.e., a mixture of hydrogen (H2) and flourine (F) contained in an isolated tank of fixed volume. The general framework provided, however, is written for a reactive system subject to multiple reaction mechanisms. To predict this evolution in state, both the energy and particle number eigenvalue problems for a dilute gas are set up and solved analytically. Wall and non-ideal-gas behavior effects are neglected, although the extension to dense gases is straightforward but left for a future paper. The system-level energy and particle number eigenvalues and eigenstates found are used in the nonlinear equation of motion of SEAQT to determine the time evolution of the thermodynamic state of the system, thus, effectively describing the reaction kinetics of the reaction and the system's relaxation to stable equilibrium. The predicted time evolution is then compared to the results of a standard detailed kinetic model used, in the near-equilibrium limit, to extract the single time constant needed by the SEAQT equation of motion.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2016; v1 submitted 15 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
A definition of thermodynamic entropy valid for non-equilibrium states and few-particle systems
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta,
Enzo Zanchini
Abstract:
From a new rigorous formulation of the general axiomatic foundations of thermodynamics we derive an operational definition of entropy that responds to the emergent need in many technological frameworks to understand and deploy thermodynamic entropy well beyond the traditional realm of equilibrium states of macroscopic systems. The new definition is achieved by avoiding to resort to the traditional…
▽ More
From a new rigorous formulation of the general axiomatic foundations of thermodynamics we derive an operational definition of entropy that responds to the emergent need in many technological frameworks to understand and deploy thermodynamic entropy well beyond the traditional realm of equilibrium states of macroscopic systems. The new definition is achieved by avoiding to resort to the traditional concepts of "heat" (which restricts $a$ $priori$ the traditional definitions of entropy to the equilibrium domain) and of "thermal reservoir" (which restricts $in$ $practice$ our previous definitions of non-equilibrium entropy to the many-particle domain). The measurement procedure that defines entropy is free from intrinsic limitations and can be applied, $in$ $principle$, even to non-equilibrium states of few-particle systems, provided they are separable and uncorrelated. The construction starts from a previously developed set of carefully worded operational definitions for all the basic concepts. Then, through a new set of fully spelled-out fundamental hypotheses (four postulates and five assumptions) we derive the definitions of energy and entropy of any state, and of temperature of any stable equilibrium state. Finally, we prove the principle of entropy non-decrease, the additivity of entropy differences, the maximum entropy principle, and the impossibility of existence of a thermal reservoir.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Essential equivalence of the GENERIC and Steepest Entropy Ascent models of dissipation for non-equilibrium thermodynamics
Authors:
Alberto Montefusco,
Francesco Consonni,
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
By reformulating the Steepest-Entropy-Ascent (SEA) dynamical model for non-equilibrium thermodynamics in the mathematical language of Differential Geometry, we compare it with the primitive formulation of the GENERIC model and discuss the main technical differences of the two approaches. In both dynamical models the description of dissipation is of the "entropy-gradient" type. SEA focuses only ont…
▽ More
By reformulating the Steepest-Entropy-Ascent (SEA) dynamical model for non-equilibrium thermodynamics in the mathematical language of Differential Geometry, we compare it with the primitive formulation of the GENERIC model and discuss the main technical differences of the two approaches. In both dynamical models the description of dissipation is of the "entropy-gradient" type. SEA focuses only onto the irreversible component of the time evolution, chooses a sub-Riemannian metric tensor as dissipative structure, and uses the local entropy density field as potential. GENERIC emphasizes the coupling between the reversible and irreversible components of the time evolution, chooses two compatible degenerate structures (Poisson and degenerate co-Riemannian), and uses the global energy and entropy functionals as potentials. As an illustration, we rewrite the known GENERIC formulation of the Boltzmann Equation in terms of the square-root of the distribution function adopted by the SEA formulation. We then provide a formal proof that in more general frameworks, whenever all degeneracies in the GENERIC framework are related to conservation laws, the SEA and GENERIC models of the irreversible component of the dynamics are essentially interchangeable, provided of course they assume the same kinematics. As part of the discussion, we note that equip** the dissipative structure of GENERIC with the Leibniz identity makes it automatically SEA on metric leaves.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2015; v1 submitted 19 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Steepest Entropy Ascent Model for Far-Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics. Unified Implementation of the Maximum Entropy Production Principle
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
By suitable reformulations, we cast the mathematical frameworks of several well-known different approaches to the description of non-equilibrium dynamics into a unified formulation, which extends to such frameworks the concept of Steepest Entropy Ascent (SEA) dynamics introduced by the present author in previous works on quantum thermodynamics. The present formulation constitutes a generalization…
▽ More
By suitable reformulations, we cast the mathematical frameworks of several well-known different approaches to the description of non-equilibrium dynamics into a unified formulation, which extends to such frameworks the concept of Steepest Entropy Ascent (SEA) dynamics introduced by the present author in previous works on quantum thermodynamics. The present formulation constitutes a generalization also for the quantum thermodynamics framework. In the SEA modeling principle a key role is played by the geometrical metric with respect to which to measure the length of a trajectory in state space. In the near equilibrium limit, the metric tensor is related to the Onsager's generalized resistivity tensor. Therefore, through the identification of a suitable metric field which generalizes the Onsager generalized resistance to the arbitrarily far non-equilibrium domain, most of the existing theories of non-equilibrium thermodynamics can be cast in such a way that the state exhibits a spontaneous tendency to evolve in state space along the path of SEA compatible with the conservation constraints and the boundary conditions. The resulting unified family of SEA dynamical models is intrinsically and strongly consistent with the second law of thermodynamics. Non-negativity of the entropy production is a readily proved general feature of SEA dynamics. In several of the different approaches to non-equilibrium description we consider here, the SEA concept has not been investigated before. We believe it defines the precise meaning and the domain of general validity of the so-called Maximum Entropy Production Principle. It is hoped that the present unifying approach may prove useful in providing a fresh basis for effective, thermodynamically consistent, numerical models and theoretical treatments of irreversible conservative relaxation towards equilibrium from far non-equilibrium states.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Recent Progress in the Definition of Thermodynamic Entropy
Authors:
Enzo Zanchini,
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
The principal methods for the definition of thermodynamic entropy are discussed with special reference to those developed by Carathéodory, the Keenan School, Lieb and Yngvason, and the present authors. An improvement of the latter method is then presented. Seven basic axioms are employed: three Postulates, which are considered as having a quite general validity, and four Assumptions, which identif…
▽ More
The principal methods for the definition of thermodynamic entropy are discussed with special reference to those developed by Carathéodory, the Keenan School, Lieb and Yngvason, and the present authors. An improvement of the latter method is then presented. Seven basic axioms are employed: three Postulates, which are considered as having a quite general validity, and four Assumptions, which identify the domains of validity of the definitions of energy (Assumption 1) and entropy (Assumptions 2, 3, 4). The domain of validity of the present definition of entropy is not restricted to stable equilibrium states. For collections of simple systems, it coincides with that of the proof of existence and uniqueness of an entropy function which characterizes the relation of adiabatic accessibility proposed by Lieb and Yngvason. However, our treatment does not require the formation of scaled copies so that it applies not only to collections of simple systems, but also to systems contained in electric or magnetic fields and to small and few-particle systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Steepest entropy ascent paths towards the Max-Ent distribution
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
With reference to two general probabilistic description frameworks, Information Theory and Classical Statistical Mechanics, we discuss the geometrical reasoning and mathematical formalism leading to the differential equation that defines in probability space the smooth path of Steepest Entropy Ascent (SEA) connecting an arbitrary initial probability distribution to the unique Maximum Entropy (MaxE…
▽ More
With reference to two general probabilistic description frameworks, Information Theory and Classical Statistical Mechanics, we discuss the geometrical reasoning and mathematical formalism leading to the differential equation that defines in probability space the smooth path of Steepest Entropy Ascent (SEA) connecting an arbitrary initial probability distribution to the unique Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt) distribution with the same mean values of a set of constraints. The SEA path is relative to a metric chosen to measure distances in square-root probability distribution space. Along the resulting SAE path, the metric turns out to be proportional to the concept of Onsager resistivity generalized to the far non-equilibrium domain. The length of the SEA path to MaxEnt provides a novel global measure of degree of disequilibrium (DoD) of the initial probability distribution, whereas a local measure of DoD is given by the norm of a novel generalized concept of non-equilibrium affinity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Steepest-Entropy-Ascent and Maximal-Entropy-Production Dynamical Models of Irreversible Relaxation to Stable Equilibrium from Any Non-Equilibrium State. Unified Treatment for Six Non-Equilibrium Frameworks
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
By suitable reformulations, we review the mathematical frameworks of six different approaches to the description of non-equilibrium dynamics with the purpose to set up a unified formulation of the Maximum Entropy Production (MEP) principle valid in all these contexts. In this way, we extend to such frameworks the concept of Steepest Entropy Ascent dynamics introduced by the present author in previ…
▽ More
By suitable reformulations, we review the mathematical frameworks of six different approaches to the description of non-equilibrium dynamics with the purpose to set up a unified formulation of the Maximum Entropy Production (MEP) principle valid in all these contexts. In this way, we extend to such frameworks the concept of Steepest Entropy Ascent dynamics introduced by the present author in previous work on quantum thermodynamics. Actually, the present formulation constitutes a generalization also in the quantum thermodynamics framework. The analysis emphasizes that in the SEA-inspired implementation of the MEP principle, a key role is played by the geometrical metric with respect to which to measure the length of a trajectory in state space. The metric tensor turns out to be directly related to the inverse of the Onsager's generalized conductivity tensor. We conclude that in most of the existing theories of non-equilibrium the time evolution of the state representative can be seen to actually follow in state space the path of SEA with respect to a suitable metric connected with the generalized conductivities. The resulting unified family of SAE/MEP dynamical models are all intrinsically consistent with the second law of thermodynamics. The nonnegativity of the entropy production is a general and readily proved feature of SEA dynamics. In several of the different approaches to non-equilibrium description we consider here, the SEA concept has not been investigated before. Therefore, it is hoped that the present unifying approach may prove useful in providing a fresh basis for effective, thermodynamically consistent, numerical models and theoretical treatments of irreversible conservative relaxation towards equilibrium from far non-equilibrium states.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2013; v1 submitted 13 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Rigorous and General Definition of Thermodynamic Entropy
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta,
Enzo Zanchini
Abstract:
The physical foundations of a variety of emerging technologies --- ranging from the applications of quantum entanglement in quantum information to the applications of nonequilibrium bulk and interface phenomena in microfluidics, biology, materials science, energy engineering, etc. --- require understanding thermodynamic entropy beyond the equilibrium realm of its traditional definition. This paper…
▽ More
The physical foundations of a variety of emerging technologies --- ranging from the applications of quantum entanglement in quantum information to the applications of nonequilibrium bulk and interface phenomena in microfluidics, biology, materials science, energy engineering, etc. --- require understanding thermodynamic entropy beyond the equilibrium realm of its traditional definition. This paper presents a rigorous logical scheme that provides a generalized definition of entropy free of the usual unnecessary assumptions which constrain the theory to the equilibrium domain. The scheme is based on carefully worded operative definitions for all the fundamental concepts employed, including those of system, property, state, isolated system, environment, process, separable system, system uncorrelated from its environment, and parameters of a system. The treatment considers also systems with movable internal walls and/or semipermeable walls, with chemical reactions and/or external force fields, and with small numbers of particles. The definition of reversible process is revised by introducing the new concept of scenario. The definition of entropy involves neither the concept of heat nor that of quasistatic process; it applies to both equilibrium and nonequilibrium states. The role of correlations on the domain of definition and on the additivity of energy and entropy is discussed: it is proved that energy is defined and additive for all separable systems, while entropy is defined and additive only for separable systems uncorrelated from their environment; decorrelation entropy is defined. The definitions of energy and entropy are extended rigorously to open systems. Finally, to complete the discussion, the existence of the fundamental relation for stable equilibrium states is proved, in our context, for both closed and open systems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Nonlinear Quantum Evolution Equations to Model Irreversible Adiabatic Relaxation with Maximal Entropy Production and Other Nonunitary Processes
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
We first discuss the geometrical construction and the main mathematical features of the maximum-entropy-production/steepest-entropy-ascent nonlinear evolution equation proposed long ago by this author in the framework of a fully quantum theory of irreversibility and thermodynamics for a single isolated or adiabatic particle, qubit, or qudit, and recently rediscovered by other authors. The nonlin…
▽ More
We first discuss the geometrical construction and the main mathematical features of the maximum-entropy-production/steepest-entropy-ascent nonlinear evolution equation proposed long ago by this author in the framework of a fully quantum theory of irreversibility and thermodynamics for a single isolated or adiabatic particle, qubit, or qudit, and recently rediscovered by other authors. The nonlinear equation generates a dynamical group, not just a semigroup, providing a deterministic description of irreversible conservative relaxation towards equilibrium from any non-equilibrium density operator. It satisfies a very restrictive stability requirement equivalent to the Hatsopoulos-Keenan statement of the second law of thermodynamics. We then examine the form of the evolution equation we proposed to describe multipartite isolated or adiabatic systems. This hinges on novel nonlinear projections defining local operators that we interpret as ``local perceptions'' of the overall system's energy and entropy. Each component particle contributes an independent local tendency along the direction of steepest increase of the locally perceived entropy at constant locally perceived energy. It conserves both the locally-perceived energies and the overall energy, and meets strong separability and non-signaling conditions, even though the local evolutions are not independent of existing correlations. We finally show how the geometrical construction can readily lead to other thermodynamically relevant models, such as of the nonunitary isoentropic evolution needed for full extraction of a system's adiabatic availability.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
Nonlinear Dynamical Equation for Irreversible, Steepest-Entropy-Ascent Relaxation to Stable Equilibrium
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
We discuss the structure and main features of the nonlinear evolution equation proposed by this author as the fundamental dynamical law within the framework of Quantum Thermodynamics. The nonlinear equation generates a dynamical group providing a unique deterministic description of irreversible, conservative relaxation towards equilibrium from any non-equilibrium state, and satisfies a very rest…
▽ More
We discuss the structure and main features of the nonlinear evolution equation proposed by this author as the fundamental dynamical law within the framework of Quantum Thermodynamics. The nonlinear equation generates a dynamical group providing a unique deterministic description of irreversible, conservative relaxation towards equilibrium from any non-equilibrium state, and satisfies a very restrictive stability requirement equivalent to Hatsopoulos-Keenan statement of the second law of thermodynamics. Here, we emphasize its mathematical structure and its applicability also within other contexts, such as Classical and Quantum Statistical Mechanics, and Information Theory.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Quantum thermodynamic Carnot and Otto-like cycles for a two-level system
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
From the thermodynamic equilibrium properties of a two-level system with variable energy-level gap $Δ$, and a careful distinction between the Gibbs relation $dE = T dS + (E/Δ) dΔ$ and the energy balance equation $dE = δQ^\leftarrow - δW^\to$, we infer some important aspects of the second law of thermodynamics and, contrary to a recent suggestion based on the analysis of an Otto-like thermodynami…
▽ More
From the thermodynamic equilibrium properties of a two-level system with variable energy-level gap $Δ$, and a careful distinction between the Gibbs relation $dE = T dS + (E/Δ) dΔ$ and the energy balance equation $dE = δQ^\leftarrow - δW^\to$, we infer some important aspects of the second law of thermodynamics and, contrary to a recent suggestion based on the analysis of an Otto-like thermodynamic cycle between two values of $Δ$ of a spin-1/2 system, we show that a quantum thermodynamic Carnot cycle, with the celebrated optimal efficiency $1 - (T_{low}/T_{high})$, is possible in principle with no need of an infinite number of infinitesimal processes, provided we cycle smoothly over at least three (in general four) values of $Δ$, and we change $Δ$ not only along the isoentropics, but also along the isotherms, e.g., by use of the recently suggested maser-laser tandem technique. We derive general bounds to the net-work to high-temperature-heat ratio for a Carnot cycle and for the 'inscribed' Otto-like cycle, and represent these cycles on useful thermodynamic diagrams.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2007;
originally announced March 2007.
-
Positive Nonlinear Dynamical Group Uniting Quantum Mechanics and Thermodynamics
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
We discuss and motivate the form of the generator of a nonlinear quantum dynamical group 'designed' so as to accomplish a unification of quantum mechanics (QM) and thermodynamics. We call this nonrelativistic theory Quantum Thermodynamics (QT). Its conceptual foundations differ from those of (von Neumann) quantum statistical mechanics (QSM) and (Jaynes) quantum information theory (QIT), but for…
▽ More
We discuss and motivate the form of the generator of a nonlinear quantum dynamical group 'designed' so as to accomplish a unification of quantum mechanics (QM) and thermodynamics. We call this nonrelativistic theory Quantum Thermodynamics (QT). Its conceptual foundations differ from those of (von Neumann) quantum statistical mechanics (QSM) and (Jaynes) quantum information theory (QIT), but for thermodynamic equilibrium (TE) states it reduces to the same mathematics, and for zero entropy states it reduces to standard unitary QM. The nonlinear dynamical group of QT is construed so that the second law emerges as a theorem of existence and uniqueness of a stable equilibrium state for each set of mean values of the energy and the number of constituents. It implements two fundamental ansatzs. The first is that in addition to the standard QM states described by idempotent density operators (zero entropy), a strictly isolated system admits also states that must be described by non-idempotent density operators (nonzero entropy). The second is that for such additional states the law of causal evolution is determined by the simultaneous action of a Schroedinger-von Neumann-type Hamiltonian generator and a nonlinear dissipative generator which conserves the mean values of the energy and the number of constituents, and (in forward time) drives any density operator, no matter how far from TE, in the 'direction' of steepest entropy ascent (maximal entropy increase). The equation of motion can be solved not only in forward time, to describe relaxation towards TE, but also backwards in time, to reconstruct the 'ancestral' or primordial lowest entropy state or limit cycle from which the system originates.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
The Hatsopoulos-Gyftopoulos resolution of the Schroedinger-Park paradox about the concept of "state" in quantum statistical mechanics
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
A seldom recognized fundamental difficulty undermines the concept of individual ``state'' in the present formulations of quantum statistical mechanics (and in its quantum information theory interpretation as well). The difficulty is an unavoidable consequence of an almost forgotten corollary proved by E. Schroedinger in 1936 and perused by J.L. Park, Am. J. Phys., Vol. 36, 211 (1968). To resolve…
▽ More
A seldom recognized fundamental difficulty undermines the concept of individual ``state'' in the present formulations of quantum statistical mechanics (and in its quantum information theory interpretation as well). The difficulty is an unavoidable consequence of an almost forgotten corollary proved by E. Schroedinger in 1936 and perused by J.L. Park, Am. J. Phys., Vol. 36, 211 (1968). To resolve it, we must either reject as unsound the concept of state, or else undertake a serious reformulation of quantum theory and the role of statistics. We restate the difficulty and discuss a possible resolution proposed in 1976 by G.N. Hatsopoulos and E.P. Gyftopoulos, Found. Phys., Vol. 6, 15, 127, 439, 561 (1976).
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2006; v1 submitted 9 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Time-energy and time-entropy uncertainty relations in dissipative quantum dynamics
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
We derive exact relations and general inequalities that extend the usual time-energy uncertainty relations from the domain of unitary Hamiltonian dynamics to that of dissipative dynamics as described by a broad class of linear and nonlinear evolution equations for the density operator. For non-dissipative dynamics, by using the Schroedinger inequality instead of the Heisenberg-Robertson inequali…
▽ More
We derive exact relations and general inequalities that extend the usual time-energy uncertainty relations from the domain of unitary Hamiltonian dynamics to that of dissipative dynamics as described by a broad class of linear and nonlinear evolution equations for the density operator. For non-dissipative dynamics, by using the Schroedinger inequality instead of the Heisenberg-Robertson inequality, we obtain a general exact time-energy uncertainty relation which is sharper than the usual Mandelstam-Tamm-Messiah relation $τ_FΔ_H\ge \hbar/2$. For simultaneous unitary/dissipative dynamics, the usual time-energy uncertainty relation is replaced by a less restrictive relation that depends on the characteristic time of dissipation, $τ$, and the uncertainty associated with the generalized nonequilibrium Massieu-function operator which defines the structure of the dissipative part of the assumed class of evolution equations. Within the steepest-entropy-ascent dissipative quantum dynamics of an isolated system introduced earlier by this author, we obtain the interesting time-energy and time-entropy uncertainty relation $(2τ_FΔ_H/ \hbar)^2+ (τ_FΔ_S/k_Bτ)^2 \ge 1$. We illustrate this result and various other inequalities by means of numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2006; v1 submitted 9 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
-
On the general equation of motion of quantum thermodynamics and the distinction between quantal and nonquantal uncertainties
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
A general quantum theory encompassing Mechanics, Thermodynamics and irreversible dynamics is presented in two parts. The first part is concerned exclusively with the description of the states of any individual physical system. It is based on a new nonlinear quantum equation of motion, which reduces to the Schroedinger equation of motion of motion of conventional quantum dynamics only under speci…
▽ More
A general quantum theory encompassing Mechanics, Thermodynamics and irreversible dynamics is presented in two parts. The first part is concerned exclusively with the description of the states of any individual physical system. It is based on a new nonlinear quantum equation of motion, which reduces to the Schroedinger equation of motion of motion of conventional quantum dynamics only under special conditions. It accounts for the implications of the laws of Thermodynamics as well as for irreversible phenomena, such as the natural tendency of an isolated system to transit from any non-equilibrium state to an equilibrium state of higher entropy. Conversely, the laws of Thermodynamics and irreversibility emerge as manifestations of the fundamental quantum dynamical behaviour of the elementary constituents of any material system. We call this part Quantum Thermodynamics. The second part of the theory, which contains the first as a special case, is concerned with the description of stochastic distributions of states in an ensemble of identical physical systems each of which individually obeys the laws of Quantum Thermodynamics. It is based on a new measure-theoretic description of ensembles. It accounts unambiguously for the essential distinction between two types of uncertainties that are generally present in an ensemble, namely, quantal uncertainties due to the inherent quantal nature of the states of each individual member system and nonquantal uncertainties due to the stochastic distribution of states. We call this part Quantum Statistical Thermodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2005;
originally announced September 2005.
-
What is the second law of thermodynamics and are there any limits to its validity?
Authors:
Elias P. Gyftopoulos,
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
In the scientific and engineering literature, the second law of thermodynamics is expressed in terms of the behavior of entropy in reversible and irreversible processes. According to the prevailing statistical mechanics interpretation the entropy is viewed as a nonphysical statistical attribute, a measure of either disorder in a system, or lack of information about the system, or erasure of info…
▽ More
In the scientific and engineering literature, the second law of thermodynamics is expressed in terms of the behavior of entropy in reversible and irreversible processes. According to the prevailing statistical mechanics interpretation the entropy is viewed as a nonphysical statistical attribute, a measure of either disorder in a system, or lack of information about the system, or erasure of information collected about the system, and a plethora of analytic expressions are proposed for the various measures. In this paper, we present two expositions of thermodynamics (both 'revolutionary' in the sense of Thomas Kuhn with respect to conventional statistical mechanics and traditional expositions of thermodynamics) that apply to all systems (both macroscopic and microscopic, including single particle or single spin systems), and to all states (thermodynamic or stable equilibrium, nonequilibrium, and other states).
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.
-
A nonlinear model dynamics for closed-system, constrained, maximal-entropy-generation relaxation by energy redistribution
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
We discuss a nonlinear model for the relaxation by energy redistribution within an isolated, closed system composed of non-interacting identical particles with energy levels e_i with i=1,2,...,N. The time-dependent occupation probabilities p_i(t) are assumed to obey the nonlinear rate equations tau dp_i/dt=-p_i ln p_i+ alpha(t)p_i-beta(t)e_ip_i where alpha(t) and beta(t) are functionals of the p…
▽ More
We discuss a nonlinear model for the relaxation by energy redistribution within an isolated, closed system composed of non-interacting identical particles with energy levels e_i with i=1,2,...,N. The time-dependent occupation probabilities p_i(t) are assumed to obey the nonlinear rate equations tau dp_i/dt=-p_i ln p_i+ alpha(t)p_i-beta(t)e_ip_i where alpha(t) and beta(t) are functionals of the p_i(t)'s that maintain invariant the mean energy E=sum_i e_ip_i(t) and the normalization condition 1=sum_i p_i(t). The entropy S(t)=-k sum_i p_i(t) ln p_i(t) is a non-decreasing function of time until the initially nonzero occupation probabilities reach a Boltzmann-like canonical distribution over the occupied energy eigenstates. Initially zero occupation probabilities, instead, remain zero at all times. The solutions p_i(t) of the rate equations are unique and well-defined for arbitrary initial conditions p_i(0) and for all times. Existence and uniqueness both forward and backward in time allows the reconstruction of the primordial lowest entropy state. The time evolution is at all times along the local direction of steepest entropy ascent or, equivalently, of maximal entropy generation. These rate equations have the same mathematical structure and basic features of the nonlinear dynamical equation proposed in a series of papers ended with G.P.Beretta, Found.Phys., 17, 365 (1987) and recently rediscovered in S. Gheorghiu-Svirschevski, Phys.Rev.A, 63, 022105 and 054102 (2001). Numerical results illustrate the features of the dynamics and the differences with the rate equations recently considered for the same problem in M.Lemanska and Z.Jaeger, Physica D, 170, 72 (2002).
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2006; v1 submitted 30 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Nonlinear extensions of Schrödinger-von Neumann quantum dynamics: a list of conditions for compatibility with thermodynamics
Authors:
Gian Paolo Beretta
Abstract:
We propose a list of conditions that consistency with thermodynamics imposes on linear and nonlinear generalizations of standard unitary quantum mechanics that assume a set of true quantum states without the restriction $ρ^2=ρ$ even for strictly isolated systems and that are to be considered in experimental tests of the existence of intrinsic (spontaneous) decoherence at the microscopic level.
We propose a list of conditions that consistency with thermodynamics imposes on linear and nonlinear generalizations of standard unitary quantum mechanics that assume a set of true quantum states without the restriction $ρ^2=ρ$ even for strictly isolated systems and that are to be considered in experimental tests of the existence of intrinsic (spontaneous) decoherence at the microscopic level.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2004;
originally announced February 2004.
