-
Non-parametric Bayesian reconstruction of Galactic magnetic fields using Information Field Theory: The inclusion of line-of-sight information in ultra-high energy cosmic ray backtracking
Authors:
Alexandros Tsouros,
Abhijit B. Bendre,
Gordian Edenhofer,
Torsten Enßlin,
Philipp Frank,
Michalis Mastorakis,
Vasiliki Pavlidou
Abstract:
(abridged) Ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) are extremely energetic charged particles with energies surpassing $10^{18}$ eV. Their sources remain elusive, obscured by deflections caused by the Galactic magnetic field (GMF). This challenge is further complicated by our limited understanding of the three-dimensional structure of the GMF, as current GMF observations consist primarily of quantit…
▽ More
(abridged) Ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) are extremely energetic charged particles with energies surpassing $10^{18}$ eV. Their sources remain elusive, obscured by deflections caused by the Galactic magnetic field (GMF). This challenge is further complicated by our limited understanding of the three-dimensional structure of the GMF, as current GMF observations consist primarily of quantities integrated along the line-of-sight (LOS). Nevertheless, data from upcoming stellar polarisation surveys along with Gaia's stellar parallax data are expected to yield local GMF measurements.. In this work, we employ methods of Bayesian statistical inference in order to sample the posterior distribution of the GMF within part of the Galaxy. By assuming a known rigidity and arrival direction of an UHECR, we backtrack its trajectory through various GMF configurations drawn from the posterior distribution. Our objective is to rigorously evaluate our algorithm's performance in scenarios that closely mirror the setting of expected future applications. In pursuit of this, we condition the posterior to synthetic integrated LOS measurements of the GMF, in addition to synthetic local POS-component measurements. In this proof of concept work, we assume the ground truth to be a magnetic field produced by a dynamo simulation of the Galactic ISM. Our results demonstrate that for all locations of the observed arrival direction on the POS, our algorithm is able to substantially update our knowledge on the original arrival direction of UHECRs with rigidity $E/Z = 5 \times 10^{19}$ eV, even in the case of complete absence of LOS information. If integrated data is included in the inference, then the regions of the celestial sphere where the maximum error occurs diminishes greatly. Even in those regions the maximum error is diminished by a factor of about $3$ in the specific setting studied.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Nonlinear magnetic buoyancy instability and turbulent dynamo
Authors:
Yasin Qazi,
Anvar Shukurov,
Devika Tharakkal,
Frederick A. Gent,
Abhijit B. Bendre
Abstract:
Stratified disks with strong horizontal magnetic fields are susceptible to magnetic buoyancy instability (MBI). Modifying the magnetic field and gas distributions, this can play an important role in galactic evolution. The MBI and the Parker instability, in which cosmic rays exacerbate MBI, are often studied using an imposed magnetic field. However, in galaxies and accretion discs, the magnetic fi…
▽ More
Stratified disks with strong horizontal magnetic fields are susceptible to magnetic buoyancy instability (MBI). Modifying the magnetic field and gas distributions, this can play an important role in galactic evolution. The MBI and the Parker instability, in which cosmic rays exacerbate MBI, are often studied using an imposed magnetic field. However, in galaxies and accretion discs, the magnetic field is continuously replenished by a large-scale dynamo action. Using non-ideal MHD equations, we model a section of the galactic disc (we neglect rotation and cosmic rays considered elsewhere), in which the large-scale field is generated by an imposed $α$-effect of variable intensity to explore the interplay between dynamo instability and MBI. The system evolves through three distinct phases: the linear (kinematic) dynamo stage, the onset of linear MBI when the magnetic field becomes sufficiently strong and the nonlinear, statistically steady state. Nonlinear effects associated with the MBI introduce oscillations which do not occur when the field is produced by the dynamo alone. The MBI initially accelerates the magnetic field amplification but the growth is quenched by the vertical motions produced by MBI. We construct a 1D model, which replicates all significant features of 3D simulations to confirm that magnetic buoyancy alone can quench the dynamo and is responsible for the magnetic field oscillations. Unlike with an imposed magnetic field (arXiv:2305.03318,arXiv:2212.03215), the nonlinear interactions do not reduce the gas scale height, so the consequences of the magnetic buoyancy depend on how the magnetic field is maintained.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2023; v1 submitted 12 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Shedding light on the MRI driven dynamo in a stratified shearing box
Authors:
Prasun Dhang,
Abhijit Bendre,
Kandaswamy Subramanian
Abstract:
We study the magneto-rotational instability (MRI) driven dynamo in a geometrically thin disc ($H/R\ll 1$) using stratified zero net flux (ZNF) shearing box simulations. We find that mean fields and EMFs oscillate with a primary frequency $f_{\rm dyn} = 0.017$ ($\approx 9$ orbital period), but also have higher harmonics at $3f_{\rm dyn}$. Correspondingly, the current helicity, has two frequencies…
▽ More
We study the magneto-rotational instability (MRI) driven dynamo in a geometrically thin disc ($H/R\ll 1$) using stratified zero net flux (ZNF) shearing box simulations. We find that mean fields and EMFs oscillate with a primary frequency $f_{\rm dyn} = 0.017$ ($\approx 9$ orbital period), but also have higher harmonics at $3f_{\rm dyn}$. Correspondingly, the current helicity, has two frequencies $2f_{\rm dyn}$ and $4f_{\rm dyn}$ respectively, which appear to be the beat frequencies of mean fields and EMFs as expected from the magnetic helicity density evolution equation. Further, we adopt a novel inversion algorithm called the `Iterative Removal Of Sources' (IROS), to extract the turbulent dynamo coefficients in the mean-field closure using the mean magnetic fields and EMFs obtained from the shearing box simulation. We show that an $α-$effect ($α_{yy}$) is predominantly responsible for the creation of the poloidal field from the toroidal field, while shear generates back a toroidal field from the poloidal field; indicating that an $α-Ω$-type dynamo is operative in MRI-driven accretion discs. We also find that both strong outflow ($\bar{v}_z$) and turbulent pum** ($γ_z$ ) transport mean fields away from the mid-plane. Instead of turbulent diffusivity, they are the principal sink terms in the mean magnetic energy evolution equation. We find encouraging evidence that a generative helicity flux is responsible for the effective $α$-effect. Finally, we point out potential limitations of horizontal ($x-y$) averaging in defining the `mean' on the extraction of dynamo coefficients and their physical interpretations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Iterative removal of sources to model the turbulent electromotive force
Authors:
Abhijit B. Bendre,
Jennifer Schober,
Prasun Dhang,
Kandaswamy Subramanian
Abstract:
We describe a novel method to compute the components of dynamo tensors from direct magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations. Our method relies upon an extension and generalisation of the standard Högbom CLEAN algorithm widely used in radio astronomy to systematically remove the impact of the strongest beams onto the corresponding image. This generalisation, called the Iterative Removal of Sources (IR…
▽ More
We describe a novel method to compute the components of dynamo tensors from direct magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations. Our method relies upon an extension and generalisation of the standard Högbom CLEAN algorithm widely used in radio astronomy to systematically remove the impact of the strongest beams onto the corresponding image. This generalisation, called the Iterative Removal of Sources (IROS) method, has been adopted here to model the turbulent electromotive force (EMF) in terms of the mean magnetic fields and currents. Analogous to the CLEAN algorithm, IROS treats the time series of the mean magnetic field and current as beams that convolve with the dynamo coefficients which are treated as (clean) images to produce the EMF time series (the dirty image). We apply this method to MHD simulations of galactic dynamos, to which we have previously employed other methods of computing dynamo coefficients such as the test-field method, the regression method, as well as local and non-local versions of the singular value decomposition (SVD) method. We show that our new method reliably recovers the dynamo coefficients from the MHD simulations. It also allows priors on the dynamo coefficients to be incorporated easily during the inversion, unlike in earlier methods. Moreover, using synthetic data, we demonstrate that it may serve as a viable post-processing tool in determining the dynamo coefficients, even when the power of additive noise to the EMF is twice as much the actual EMF.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2024; v1 submitted 31 July, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Observational Signatures of Galactic Turbulent Dynamos
Authors:
Yann Carteret,
Abhijit B. Bendre,
Jennifer Schober
Abstract:
We analyse the observational signatures of galactic magnetic fields that are self-consistently generated in magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the interstellar medium through turbulence driven by supernova (SN) explosions and differential rotation. In particular, we study the time evolution of the Faraday rotation measure (RM), synchrotron radiation, and Stokes parameters by characterising the typ…
▽ More
We analyse the observational signatures of galactic magnetic fields that are self-consistently generated in magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the interstellar medium through turbulence driven by supernova (SN) explosions and differential rotation. In particular, we study the time evolution of the Faraday rotation measure (RM), synchrotron radiation, and Stokes parameters by characterising the typical structures formed in the plane of observation. We do this by defining two distinct models for both thermal and cosmic ray (CR) electron distributions. Our results indicate that the maps of RM have structures which are sheared and rendered anisotropically by differential rotation and that they depend on the choice of thermal electrons model as well as the SN rate. Synchrotron maps are qualitatively similar to the maps of the mean magnetic field along the line of sight and structures are only marginally affected by the CR model. Stokes parameters and related quantities, such as the degree of linear polarisation, are highly dependent on both frequency and resolution of the observation.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2022; v1 submitted 30 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Non-locality of the Turbulent Electromotive Force
Authors:
Abhijit B. Bendre,
Kandaswamy Subramanian
Abstract:
The generation of large-scale magnetic fields ($\overline{\mathbf{B}}$) in astrophysical systems is driven by the mean turbulent electromotive force ($\overline{\cal E}$), the cross correlation between local fluctuations of velocity and magnetic fields. This can depend non-locally on $\overline{\mathbf{B}}$ through a convolution kernel $K_{ij}$. In a new approach to find $K_{ij}$, we directly fit…
▽ More
The generation of large-scale magnetic fields ($\overline{\mathbf{B}}$) in astrophysical systems is driven by the mean turbulent electromotive force ($\overline{\cal E}$), the cross correlation between local fluctuations of velocity and magnetic fields. This can depend non-locally on $\overline{\mathbf{B}}$ through a convolution kernel $K_{ij}$. In a new approach to find $K_{ij}$, we directly fit the time series data of $\overline{\cal E}$ versus $\overline{\mathbf{B}}$ from a galactic dynamo simulation using singular value decomposition. We calculate the usual turbulent transport coefficients as moments of $K_{ij}$, show the importance of including non-locality over eddy length scales to fully capture their amplitudes and that higher order corrections to the standard transport coefficients are small in the present case.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2022; v1 submitted 22 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
On the Combined Role of Cosmic Rays and Supernova-Driven Turbulence for Galactic Dynamos
Authors:
Abhijit B. Bendre,
Detlef Elstner,
Oliver Gressel
Abstract:
Large-scale coherent magnetic fields observed in the nearby galaxies are thought to originate by a mean-field dynamo. This is governed via the turbulent electromotive force (EMF, $\overline{\mathcal{E}} $) generated by the helical turbulence driven by supernova (SN) explosions in the differentially rotating interstellar medium (ISM). In this paper we aim to investigate the possibility of dynamo ac…
▽ More
Large-scale coherent magnetic fields observed in the nearby galaxies are thought to originate by a mean-field dynamo. This is governed via the turbulent electromotive force (EMF, $\overline{\mathcal{E}} $) generated by the helical turbulence driven by supernova (SN) explosions in the differentially rotating interstellar medium (ISM). In this paper we aim to investigate the possibility of dynamo action by the virtue of buoyancy due to a cosmic ray (CR) component injected through the SN explosions. We do this by analysing the magnetohydrodynamic simulations of local shearing box of ISM, in which the turbulence is driven via random SN explosions and the energy of the explosion is distributed in the CR and/or thermal energy components. We use the magnetic field aligned diffusion prescription for the propagation of CR. We compare the evolution of magnetic fields in the models with the CR component to our previous models that did not involve the CR. We demonstrate that the inclusion of CR component enhances the growth of dynamo slightly. We further compute the underlying dynamo coefficients using the test-fields method, and argue that the entire evolution of the large scale mean magnetic field can be reproduced with an $α-Ω$ dynamo model. We also show that the inclusion of CR component leads to an unbalanced turbulent pum** between magnetic field components and additional dynamo action by the Rädler effect.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Characterising the Dynamo in a Radiatively Inefficient Accretion Flow
Authors:
Prasun Dhang,
Abhijit Bendre,
Prateek Sharma,
Kandaswamy Subramanian
Abstract:
We explore the MRI driven dynamo in a radiatively inefficient accretion flow (RIAF) using the mean field dynamo paradigm. Using singular value decomposition (SVD) we obtain the least squares fitting dynamo coefficients $α$ and $γ$ by comparing the time series of the turbulent electromotive force and the mean magnetic field. Our study is the first one to show the poloidal distribution of these dyna…
▽ More
We explore the MRI driven dynamo in a radiatively inefficient accretion flow (RIAF) using the mean field dynamo paradigm. Using singular value decomposition (SVD) we obtain the least squares fitting dynamo coefficients $α$ and $γ$ by comparing the time series of the turbulent electromotive force and the mean magnetic field. Our study is the first one to show the poloidal distribution of these dynamo coefficients in global accretion flow simulations. Surprisingly, we obtain a high value of the turbulent pum** coefficient $γ$ which transports the mean magnetic flux radially outward. This would have implications for the launching of magnetised jets which are produced efficiently in presence a large-scale poloidal magnetic field close to the compact object. We present a scenario of a truncated disc beyond the RIAF where a large scale dynamo-generated poloidal magnetic field can aid jet-launching close to the black hole. Magnitude of all the calculated coefficients decreases with radius. Meridional variations of $α_{φφ}$, responsible for toroidal to poloidal field conversion, is very similar to that found in shearing box simulations using the `test field' (TF) method. By estimating the relative importance of $α$-effect and shear, we conclude that the MRI driven large-scale dynamo, which operates at high latitudes beyond a disc scale height, is essentially of the $α-Ω$ type.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2020; v1 submitted 10 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Turbulent transport coefficients in galactic dynamo simulations using singular value decomposition
Authors:
Abhijit B. Bendre,
Kandaswamy Subramanian,
Detlef Elstner,
Oliver Gressel
Abstract:
Coherent magnetic fields in disc galaxies are thought to be generated by a large-scale (or mean-field) dynamo operating in their interstellar medium. A key driver of mean magnetic field growth is the turbulent electromotive force (EMF), which represents the influence of correlated small-scale (or fluctuating) velocity and magnetic fields on the mean field. The EMF is usually expressed as a linear…
▽ More
Coherent magnetic fields in disc galaxies are thought to be generated by a large-scale (or mean-field) dynamo operating in their interstellar medium. A key driver of mean magnetic field growth is the turbulent electromotive force (EMF), which represents the influence of correlated small-scale (or fluctuating) velocity and magnetic fields on the mean field. The EMF is usually expressed as a linear expansion in the mean magnetic field and its derivatives, with the dynamo tensors as expansion coefficients. Here, we adopt the singular value decomposition (SVD) method to directly measure these turbulent transport coefficients in a simulation of the turbulent interstellar medium that realizes a large-scale dynamo. Specifically, the SVD is used to least-square fit the time series data of the EMF with that of the mean field and its derivatives, to determine these coefficients. We demonstrate that the spatial profiles of the EMF reconstructed from the SVD coefficients match well with that taken directly from the simulation. Also, as a direct test, we use the coefficients to simulate a 1-D mean-field dynamo model and find an overall similarity in the evolution of the mean magnetic field between the dynamo model and the direct simulation. We also compare the results with those which arise using simple regression and the ones obtained previously using the test-field (TF) method, to find reasonable qualitative agreement. Overall, the SVD method provides an effective post-processing tool to determine turbulent transport coefficients from simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
GMRT observations of a first sample of Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS) candidates in the Northern sky
Authors:
Mukul Mhaskey,
Gopal-Krishna,
Surajit Paul,
Pratik Dabhade,
Sameer Salunkhe,
Shubham Bhagat,
Abhijit Bendre
Abstract:
We present an extension of our search for Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS) to the northern celestial hemisphere. With an inverted radio spectrum of slope $α$ > +2.5, these rare sources would either require a non-standard particle acceleration mechanism (in the framework of synchrotron self-absorption hypothesis), or a severe free-free absorption which attenuates pra…
▽ More
We present an extension of our search for Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS) to the northern celestial hemisphere. With an inverted radio spectrum of slope $α$ > +2.5, these rare sources would either require a non-standard particle acceleration mechanism (in the framework of synchrotron self-absorption hypothesis), or a severe free-free absorption which attenuates practically all of their synchrotron radiation at metre wavelengths. By applying a sequence of selection filters, a list of 15 EISERS candidates is extracted out by comparing two large-sky radio surveys, WENSS (325 MHz) and TGSS-ADR1 (150 MHz), which overlap across 1.03$π$ steradian of the sky. Here we report quasi-simultaneous GMRT observations of these 15 EISERS candidates at 150 MHz and 325 MHz, in an attempt to accurately define their spectra below the turnover frequency. Out of the 15 candidates observed, two are confirmed as EISERS, since the slope of the inverted spectrum between these two frequencies is found to be significantly larger than the critical value $α_c$ = +2.5: the theoretical limit for the standard case of synchrotron self-absorption (SSA). For another 3 sources, the spectral slope is close to, or just above the critical value $α_c$. Nine of the sources have GPS type radio spectra. The parsec-scale radio structural information available for the sample is also summarised.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Dynamo saturation in direct simulations of the multi-phase turbulent interstellar medium
Authors:
A. Bendre,
O. Gressel,
D. Elstner
Abstract:
The ordered magnetic field observed via polarized synchrotron emission in nearby disc galaxies can be explained by a mean-field dynamo operating in the diffuse interstellar medium (ISM). Additionally, vertical-flux initial conditions are potentially able to influence this dynamo via the occurrence of the magneto-rotational instability (MRI). We aim to study the influence of various initial field c…
▽ More
The ordered magnetic field observed via polarized synchrotron emission in nearby disc galaxies can be explained by a mean-field dynamo operating in the diffuse interstellar medium (ISM). Additionally, vertical-flux initial conditions are potentially able to influence this dynamo via the occurrence of the magneto-rotational instability (MRI). We aim to study the influence of various initial field configurations on the saturated state of the mean-field dynamo. This is motivated by the observation that different saturation behavior was previously obtained for different supernova rates. We perform direct numerical simulations (DNS) of three-dimensional local boxes of the vertically stratified, turbulent interstellar medium, employing shearing-periodic boundary conditions horizontally. Unlike in our previous work, we also impose a vertical seed magnetic field. We run the simulations until the growth of the magnetic energy becomes negligible. We furthermore perform simulations of equivalent 1D dynamo models, with an algebraic quenching mechanism for the dynamo coefficients. We compare the saturation of the magnetic field in the DNS with the algebraic quenching of a mean-field dynamo. The final magnetic field strength found in the direct simulation is in excellent agreement with a quenched $αΩ$~dynamo. For supernova rates representative of the Milky Way, field losses via a Galactic wind are likely responsible for saturation. We conclude that the relative strength of the turbulent and regular magnetic fields in spiral galaxies may depend on the galaxy's star formation rate. We propose that a mean field approach with algebraic quenching may serve as a simple sub-grid scale model for galaxy evolution simulations including a prescribed feedback from magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
On the magnetic quenching of mean-field effects in supersonic interstellar turbulence
Authors:
Oliver Gressel,
Abhijit Bendre,
Detlef Elstner
Abstract:
The emergence of large-scale magnetic fields observed in the diffuse interstellar medium is explained by a turbulent dynamo. The underlying transport coefficients have previously been extracted from numerical simulations. So far, this was restricted to the kinematic regime, but we aim to extend our analysis into the realm of dynamically important fields. This marks an important step on which deriv…
▽ More
The emergence of large-scale magnetic fields observed in the diffuse interstellar medium is explained by a turbulent dynamo. The underlying transport coefficients have previously been extracted from numerical simulations. So far, this was restricted to the kinematic regime, but we aim to extend our analysis into the realm of dynamically important fields. This marks an important step on which derived mean-field models rely to explain observed equipartition strength fields. As in previous work, we diagnose turbulent transport coefficients by means of the test-field method. We derive quenching functions for the dynamo α effect, diamagnetic pum**, and turbulent diffusivity, which are compared with theoretical expectations. At late times, we observe the suppression of the vertical wind. Because this potentially affects the removal of small-scale magnetic helicity, new concerns arise about circumventing constraints imposed by the conservation of magnetic helicity at high magnetic Reynolds numbers. While present results cannot safely rule out this possibility, the issue only becomes important at late stages and is absent when the dynamo is quenched by the wind itself.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
