-
Probabilistic work extraction on a classical oscillator beyond the second law
Authors:
Nicolas Barros,
Sergio Ciliberto,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
We demonstrate experimentally that, applying optimal protocols which drive the system between two equilibrium states characterized by a free energy difference $ΔF$, we can maximize the probability of performing the transition between the two states with a work $W$ smaller than $ΔF$. The second law holds only on average, resulting in the inequality $\langle W \rangle \geq ΔF$. The experiment is per…
▽ More
We demonstrate experimentally that, applying optimal protocols which drive the system between two equilibrium states characterized by a free energy difference $ΔF$, we can maximize the probability of performing the transition between the two states with a work $W$ smaller than $ΔF$. The second law holds only on average, resulting in the inequality $\langle W \rangle \geq ΔF$. The experiment is performed using an underdamped oscillator evolving in a double-well potential. We show that with a suitable choice of parameters the probability of obtaining trajectories with $W \le ΔF$ can be larger than 90 %. Very fast protocols are a key feature to obtain these results which are explained in terms of the Jarzynski equality.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Multimode characterization of an optical beam deflection setup
Authors:
Alex Fontana,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Optical beam deflection is a popular method to measure the deformation of micro-mechanical devices. As it measures mostly a local slope, its sensitivity depends on the location and size of the optical spot. We present a method to evaluate precisely these parameters, using the relative amplitude of the thermal noise induced vibrations. With a case study of a micro-cantilever, we demonstrate the acc…
▽ More
Optical beam deflection is a popular method to measure the deformation of micro-mechanical devices. As it measures mostly a local slope, its sensitivity depends on the location and size of the optical spot. We present a method to evaluate precisely these parameters, using the relative amplitude of the thermal noise induced vibrations. With a case study of a micro-cantilever, we demonstrate the accuracy of the approach, as well as its ability to fully characterize the sensitivity of the detector, and the parameters (mass, stiffness) of the resonator.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Virtual potential created by a feedback loop: taming the feedback demon to explore stochastic thermodynamics of underdamped systems
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Nicolas Barros,
Jorge Pereda,
Sergio Ciliberto,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Virtual potentials are an elegant, precise and flexible tool to manipulate small systems and explore fundamental questions in stochastic thermodynamics. In particular double-well potentials have applications in information processing, such as the demonstration of Landauer's principle. In this chapter, we detail the implementation of a feedback loop for an underdamped system, in order to build a tu…
▽ More
Virtual potentials are an elegant, precise and flexible tool to manipulate small systems and explore fundamental questions in stochastic thermodynamics. In particular double-well potentials have applications in information processing, such as the demonstration of Landauer's principle. In this chapter, we detail the implementation of a feedback loop for an underdamped system, in order to build a tunable virtual double-well potential. This feedback behaves as a demon acting on the system depending on the outcome of a continuously running measurement. It can thus modify the energy exchanges with the thermostat and create an out-of-equilibrium state. To create a bi-stable potential, the feedback consists only in switching an external force between two steady values when the measured position crosses a threshold. We show that a small delay of the feedback loop in the switches between the two wells results in a modified velocity distribution. The latter can be interpreted as a cooling of the kinetic temperature of the system. Using a fast digital feedback, we successfully address all experimental issues to create a virtual potential that is statistically indistinguishable from a physical one, with a tunable barrier height and energy step between the two wells.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Thermal noise calibration of functionalized cantilevers for force microscopy: effects of the colloidal probe position
Authors:
Aubin Archambault,
Caroline Crauste-Thibierge,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Colloidal probes are often used in force microscopy when the geometry of the tip-sample interaction should be well controlled. Their calibration requires the understanding of their mechanical response, which is very sensitive to the details of the force sensor consisting of a cantilever and the attached colloid. We present analytical models to describe the dynamics of the cantilever and its load p…
▽ More
Colloidal probes are often used in force microscopy when the geometry of the tip-sample interaction should be well controlled. Their calibration requires the understanding of their mechanical response, which is very sensitive to the details of the force sensor consisting of a cantilever and the attached colloid. We present analytical models to describe the dynamics of the cantilever and its load positioned anywhere along its length. The thermal noise calibration of such probes is then studied from a practical point of view, leading to correction coefficients that can be applied in standard force microscope calibration routines. Experimental measurements of resonance frequencies and thermal noise profiles of raw and loaded cantilevers demonstrate the validity of the approach.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024; v1 submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Reliability and operation cost of underdamped memories during cyclic erasures
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Sergio Ciliberto,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The reliability of fast repeated erasures is studied experimentally and theoretically in a 1-bit underdamped memory. The bit is encoded by the position of a micro-mechanical oscillator whose motion is confined in a double well potential. To contain the energetic cost of fast erasures, we use a resonator with high quality factor $Q$: the erasure work $W$ is close to Landauer's bound, even at high s…
▽ More
The reliability of fast repeated erasures is studied experimentally and theoretically in a 1-bit underdamped memory. The bit is encoded by the position of a micro-mechanical oscillator whose motion is confined in a double well potential. To contain the energetic cost of fast erasures, we use a resonator with high quality factor $Q$: the erasure work $W$ is close to Landauer's bound, even at high speed. The drawback is the rise of the system's temperature $T$ due to a weak coupling to the environment. Repeated erasures without letting the memory thermalize between operations result in a continuous warming, potentially leading to a thermal noise overcoming the barrier between the potential wells. In such case, the reset operation can fail to reach the targeted logical state. The reliability is characterized by the success rate $R^s_i$ after $i$ successive operations. $W$, $T$ and $R^s_i$ are studied experimentally as a function of the erasure speed. Above a velocity threshold, $T$ soars while $R^s_i$ collapses: the reliability of too fast erasures is low. These experimental results are fully justified by two complementary models. We demonstrate that $Q\simeq 10$ is optimal to contain energetic costs and maintain high reliability standards for repeated erasures at any speed.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2024; v1 submitted 27 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Logical and thermodynamical reversibility: optimized experimental implementation of the NOT operation
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The NOT operation is a reversible transformation acting on a 1-bit logical state, and should be achievable in a physically reversible manner at no energetic cost. We experimentally demonstrate a bit-flip protocol based on the momentum of an underdamped oscillator confined in a double well potential. The protocol is designed to be reversible in the ideal dissipationless case, and the thermodynamic…
▽ More
The NOT operation is a reversible transformation acting on a 1-bit logical state, and should be achievable in a physically reversible manner at no energetic cost. We experimentally demonstrate a bit-flip protocol based on the momentum of an underdamped oscillator confined in a double well potential. The protocol is designed to be reversible in the ideal dissipationless case, and the thermodynamic work required is inversely proportional to the quality factor of the system. Our implementation demonstrates an energy dissipation significantly lower than the minimal cost of information processing in logically irreversible operations. It is moreover performed at high speed: a fully equilibrated final state is reached in only half a period of the oscillator. The results are supported by an analytical model that takes into account the presence of irreversibility. The Letter concludes with a discussion of optimization strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2023; v1 submitted 23 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Adiabatic computing for optimal thermodynamic efficiency of information processing
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Sergio Ciliberto,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Landauer's principle makes a strong connection between information theory and thermodynamics by stating that erasing a one-bit memory at temperature $T_0$ requires an average energy larger than $W_{LB}=k_BT_0 \ln2$, with $k_B$ Boltzmann's constant. This tiny limit has been saturated in model experiments using quasi-static processes. For faster operations, an overhead proportional to the processing…
▽ More
Landauer's principle makes a strong connection between information theory and thermodynamics by stating that erasing a one-bit memory at temperature $T_0$ requires an average energy larger than $W_{LB}=k_BT_0 \ln2$, with $k_B$ Boltzmann's constant. This tiny limit has been saturated in model experiments using quasi-static processes. For faster operations, an overhead proportional to the processing speed and to the memory dam** appears. In this article, we show that underdamped systems are a winning strategy to reduce this extra energetic cost. We prove both experimentally and theoretically that, in the limit of vanishing dissipation mechanisms in the memory, the physical system is thermally insulated from its environment during fast erasures, i.e. fast protocols are adiabatic as no heat is exchanged with the bath. Using a fast optimal erasure protocol we also show that these adiabatic processes produce a maximum adiabatic temperature $T_a=2T_0$, and that Landauer's bound for fast erasures in underdamped systems becomes the adiabatic bound: $W_a = k_B T_0$.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2024; v1 submitted 20 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Role of a cap** layer on the crystalline structure of Sn thin films grown at cryogenic temperatures on InSb substrates
Authors:
A. -H. Chen,
C. P. Dempsey,
M. Pendharkar,
A. Sharma,
B. Zhang,
S. Tan,
L. Bellon,
S. M. Frolov,
C. J. Palmstrom,
E. Bellet-Amalric,
M. Hocevar
Abstract:
Metal deposition with cryogenic cooling is widely utilized in the condensed matter community for producing ultra-thin epitaxial superconducting layers on semiconductors. However, a drawback arises when these films return to room temperature, as they tend to undergo dewetting. This issue is mitigated by cap** the films with an amorphous layer. In this study, we examined the impact of different in…
▽ More
Metal deposition with cryogenic cooling is widely utilized in the condensed matter community for producing ultra-thin epitaxial superconducting layers on semiconductors. However, a drawback arises when these films return to room temperature, as they tend to undergo dewetting. This issue is mitigated by cap** the films with an amorphous layer. In this study, we examined the impact of different in-situ fabricated caps on the structural characteristics of Sn thin films deposited at 80 K on InSb substrates. Regardless of the type of cap**, we observed that the films remained smooth upon returning to room temperature and were epitaxial on InSb in the cubic Sn ($α$-Sn) phase. However, we noted a correlation between alumina cap** with an electron beam evaporator and an increased presence of tetragonal Sn ($β$-Sn) grains. This suggests that heating from the alumina source may contribute to a partial phase transition in the Sn layer. The existence of the $β$-Sn phase induced superconducting behavior of the films by percolation effect. This study highlights the potential for modifying the structural properties of cryogenic Sn thin films through in-situ cap**, paving the way for precise control in the production of superconducting Sn films for integration into quantum computing platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2023; v1 submitted 29 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Linking fluctuation and dissipation in spatially extended out-of-equilibrium systems
Authors:
Alex Fontana,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
For systems in equilibrium at a temperature $T$, thermal noise and energy dam** are related to $T$ through the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT). We study here an extension of the FDT to an out of equilibrium steady state: a microcantilever subject to a constant heat flux. The resulting thermal profile in this spatially extended system interplays with the local energy dissipation field to pr…
▽ More
For systems in equilibrium at a temperature $T$, thermal noise and energy dam** are related to $T$ through the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT). We study here an extension of the FDT to an out of equilibrium steady state: a microcantilever subject to a constant heat flux. The resulting thermal profile in this spatially extended system interplays with the local energy dissipation field to prescribe the amplitude of mechanical fluctuations. Using three samples with different dam** profiles (localized or distributed), we probe this approach and experimentally demonstrate the link between fluctuations and dissipation. The thermal noise can therefore be predicted a priori from the measurement of the dissipation as a function of the maximum temperature of the micro-oscillator.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2023; v1 submitted 17 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Harmonic calibration of quadrature phase interferometry
Authors:
Baptiste Ferrero,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The two output signals of quadrature phase interferometers allow to benefit both from the high sensitivity of interferometry (working inside a fringe) and from an extended input range (counting fringes). Their calibration to reach a linear output is traditionally performed using Heydemann's correction, which involves fitting one output versus the other by an ellipse. Here we present two alternativ…
▽ More
The two output signals of quadrature phase interferometers allow to benefit both from the high sensitivity of interferometry (working inside a fringe) and from an extended input range (counting fringes). Their calibration to reach a linear output is traditionally performed using Heydemann's correction, which involves fitting one output versus the other by an ellipse. Here we present two alternative methods based on the linear response of the measurement to a sinusoidal input in time, which enables a direct calibration with an excellent linearity. A ten fold improvement with respect to the usual technique is demonstrated on an optical interferometer measuring the deflection of scanning force microscopy cantilevers.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Accelerating the heat diffusion: fast thermal relaxation of a microcantilever
Authors:
Basile Pottier,
Carlos Plata,
Emmanuel Trizac,
David Guéry-Odelin,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
In most systems, thermal diffusion is intrinsically slow with respect to mechanical relaxation. We devise here a generic approach to accelerate the relaxation of the temperature field of a 1D object, in order to beat the mechanical time scales. This approach is applied to a micro-meter sized silicon cantilever, locally heated by a laser beam. A tailored driving protocol for the laser power is deri…
▽ More
In most systems, thermal diffusion is intrinsically slow with respect to mechanical relaxation. We devise here a generic approach to accelerate the relaxation of the temperature field of a 1D object, in order to beat the mechanical time scales. This approach is applied to a micro-meter sized silicon cantilever, locally heated by a laser beam. A tailored driving protocol for the laser power is derived to quickly reach the thermal stationary state. The model is implemented experimentally yielding a significant acceleration of the thermal relaxation, up to a factor 30. An excellent agreement with the theoretical predictions is reported. This strategy allows a thermal steady state to be reached significantly faster than the natural mechanical relaxation.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2023; v1 submitted 3 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Virtual double-well potential for an underdamped oscillator created by a feedback loop
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Jorge Pereda,
Sergio Ciliberto,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Virtual potentials are a very elegant, precise and flexible tool to manipulate small systems and explore fundamental questions in stochastic thermodynamics. In particular double-well potentials have applications in information processing, such as the demonstration of Landauer's principle. Nevertheless, virtual double-well potentials had never been implemented in underdamped systems. In this articl…
▽ More
Virtual potentials are a very elegant, precise and flexible tool to manipulate small systems and explore fundamental questions in stochastic thermodynamics. In particular double-well potentials have applications in information processing, such as the demonstration of Landauer's principle. Nevertheless, virtual double-well potentials had never been implemented in underdamped systems. In this article, we detail how to face the experimental challenge of creating a feedback loop for an underdamped system (exploring its potential energy landscape much faster than its over-damped counterpart), in order to build a tunable virtual double-well potential. To properly describe the system behavior in the feedback trap, we express the switching time in the double-well for all barrier heights, combining for the first time Kramer's description, valid at high barriers, with an adjusted model for lower ones. We show that a small hysteresis or delay of the feedback loop in the switches between the two wells results in a modified velocity distribution, interpreted as a cooling of the kinetic temperature of the system. We successfully address all issues to create experimentally a virtual potential that is statistically indistinguishable from a physical one, with a tunable barrier height and energy step between the two wells.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2022; v1 submitted 24 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Force microscopy cantilevers locally heated in a fluid: temperature fields and effects on the dynamics
Authors:
Basile Pottier,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Atomic force microscopy cantilevers are often, intentionally or not, heated at their extremity. We describe a model to compute the resulting temperature field in the cantilever and in the surrounding fluid on a wide temperature range. In air and for common geometries, the heat fluxes in the cantilever and to the environment are of comparable magnitude. We then infer how the fluid-structure interac…
▽ More
Atomic force microscopy cantilevers are often, intentionally or not, heated at their extremity. We describe a model to compute the resulting temperature field in the cantilever and in the surrounding fluid on a wide temperature range. In air and for common geometries, the heat fluxes in the cantilever and to the environment are of comparable magnitude. We then infer how the fluid-structure interaction is modified due to heating, and predict the induced changes in the dynamics of the system. In particular, we describe how the resonance frequencies of the cantilever shift with a temperature increase due to two competing processes: softening of the cantilever, and decrease of the fluid inertial effects. Our models are illustrated by experiments on a set of cantilevers spanning the relevant geometries to explore the relative importance of both effects.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Dynamics of information erasure and extension of Landauer's bound to fast processes
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Using a double-well potential as a physical memory, we study with experiments and numerical simulations the energy exchanges during erasure processes, and model quantitatively the cost of fast operation. Within the stochastic thermodynamics framework we find the origins of the overhead to Landauer's Bound required for fast operations: in the overdamped regime this term mainly comes from the dissip…
▽ More
Using a double-well potential as a physical memory, we study with experiments and numerical simulations the energy exchanges during erasure processes, and model quantitatively the cost of fast operation. Within the stochastic thermodynamics framework we find the origins of the overhead to Landauer's Bound required for fast operations: in the overdamped regime this term mainly comes from the dissipation, while in the underdamped regime it stems from the heating of the memory. Indeed, the system is thermalized with its environment at all time during quasi-static protocols, but for fast ones, the inefficient heat transfer to the thermostat is delayed with respect to the work influx, resulting in a transient temperature rise. The warming, quantitatively described by a comprehensive statistical physics description of the erasure process, is noticeable on both the kinetic and potential energy: they no longer comply with equipartition. The mean work and heat to erase the information therefore increase accordingly. They are both bounded by an effective Landauer's limit $k_B T_{eff} \ln{2}$, where $T_{eff}$ is a weighted average of the actual temperature of the memory during the process.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2022; v1 submitted 25 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Information and thermodynamics: fast and precise approach to Landauer's bound in an underdamped micro-mechanical oscillator
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Jorge Pereda,
Nicolas Barros,
Sergio Ciliberto,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The Landauer principle states that at least $k_B T \ln 2$ of energy is required to erase a 1-bit memory, with $k_B T$ the thermal energy of the system. We study the effects of inertia on this bound using as one-bit memory an underdamped micro-mechanical oscillator confined in a double-well potential created by a feedback loop. The potential barrier is precisely tunable in the few $k_B T$ range. We…
▽ More
The Landauer principle states that at least $k_B T \ln 2$ of energy is required to erase a 1-bit memory, with $k_B T$ the thermal energy of the system. We study the effects of inertia on this bound using as one-bit memory an underdamped micro-mechanical oscillator confined in a double-well potential created by a feedback loop. The potential barrier is precisely tunable in the few $k_B T$ range. We measure, within the stochastic thermodynamic framework, the work and the heat of the erasure protocol. We demonstrate experimentally and theoretically that, in this underdamped system, the Landauer bound is reached with a 1 % uncertainty, with protocols as short as 100 ms.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2021; v1 submitted 19 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Thermo-optical bistability in silicon micro-cantilevers
Authors:
Basile Pottier,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
We report a thermo-optical bistability observed in silicon micro-cantilevers irradiated by a laser beam with mW powers: reflectivity, transmissivity, absorption, and temperature can change by a factor of two between two stable states for the same input power. The temperature dependency of the absorption at the origin of the bistability results from interferences between internal reflections in the…
▽ More
We report a thermo-optical bistability observed in silicon micro-cantilevers irradiated by a laser beam with mW powers: reflectivity, transmissivity, absorption, and temperature can change by a factor of two between two stable states for the same input power. The temperature dependency of the absorption at the origin of the bistability results from interferences between internal reflections in the cantilever thickness, acting as a lossy Fabry-Pérot cavity. A theoretical model describing the thermo-optical coupling is presented. The experimental results obtained for silicon cantilevers irradiated in vacuum at two different visible wavelengths are in quantitative agreement with the predictions of this model.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2021; v1 submitted 28 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Thermal noise of a cryo-cooled silicon cantilever locally heated up to its melting point
Authors:
Alex Fontana,
Richard Pedurand,
Vincent Dolique,
Ghaouti Hansali,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The Fluctuation-Dissipation Theorem (FDT) is a powerful tool to estimate the thermal noise of physical systems in equilibrium. In general however, thermal equilibrium is an approximation, or cannot be assumed at all. A more general formulation of the FDT is then needed to describe the behavior of the fluctuations. In our experiment we study a micro-cantilever brought out-ofequilibrium by a strong…
▽ More
The Fluctuation-Dissipation Theorem (FDT) is a powerful tool to estimate the thermal noise of physical systems in equilibrium. In general however, thermal equilibrium is an approximation, or cannot be assumed at all. A more general formulation of the FDT is then needed to describe the behavior of the fluctuations. In our experiment we study a micro-cantilever brought out-ofequilibrium by a strong heat flux generated by the absorption of the light of a laser. While the base is kept at cryogenic temperatures, the tip is heated up to the melting point, thus creating the highest temperature difference the system can sustain. We independently estimate the temperature profile of the cantilever and its mechanical fluctuations, as well as its dissipation. We then demonstrate how the thermal fluctuations of all the observed degrees of freedom, though increasing with the heat flux, are much lower than what is expected from the average temperature of the system. We interpret these results thanks to a minimal extension of the FDT: this dearth of thermal noise arises from a dissipation shared between clam** losses and distributed dam**.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021; v1 submitted 22 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Silicon cantilevers locally heated from 300K up to the melting point: temperature profile measurement from their resonances frequency shift
Authors:
Basile Pottier,
Felipe Aguilar,
Mickaël Geitner,
Francisco Melo,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
When heated, micro-resonators present a shift of their resonance frequencies. We study specifically silicon cantilevers heated locally by laser absorption, and evaluate theoretically and experimentally their temperature profile and its interplay with the mechanical resonances. We present a enhanced version of our earlier model [F. Aguilar Sandoval et al., J. Appl. Phys. 117, 234503 (2015)] includi…
▽ More
When heated, micro-resonators present a shift of their resonance frequencies. We study specifically silicon cantilevers heated locally by laser absorption, and evaluate theoretically and experimentally their temperature profile and its interplay with the mechanical resonances. We present a enhanced version of our earlier model [F. Aguilar Sandoval et al., J. Appl. Phys. 117, 234503 (2015)] including both elasticity and geometry temperature dependency, showing that the latter can account for 20% of the observed shift for the first flexural mode. The temperature profile description takes into account thermal clam** conditions, radiation at high temperature, and lower conductivity than bulk silicon due to phonon confinement. Thanks to a space-power equivalence in the heat equation, scanning the heating point along the cantilever directly reveals the temperature profile. Finally, frequency shift measurement can be used to infer the temperature field with a few percent precision.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2021; v1 submitted 1 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Large colloidal probes for atomic force microscopy: fabrication and calibration issues
Authors:
M. Chighizola,
L. Puricelli,
L. Bellon,
A. Podestà
Abstract:
Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a powerful tool to investigate interaction forces at the micro and nanoscale. Cantilever stiffness, dimensions and geometry of the tip can be chosen according to the requirements of the specific application, in terms of spatial resolution and force sensitivity. Colloidal probes (CPs), obtained by attaching a spherical particle to a tipless (TL) cantilever, offer se…
▽ More
Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a powerful tool to investigate interaction forces at the micro and nanoscale. Cantilever stiffness, dimensions and geometry of the tip can be chosen according to the requirements of the specific application, in terms of spatial resolution and force sensitivity. Colloidal probes (CPs), obtained by attaching a spherical particle to a tipless (TL) cantilever, offer several advantages for accurate force measurements: tunable and well-characterisable radius; higher averaging capabilities (at the expense of spatial resolution) and sensitivity to weak interactions; a well-defined interaction geometry (sphere on flat), which allows accurate and reliable data fitting by means of analytical models. The dynamics of standard AFM probes has been widely investigated, and protocols have been developed for the calibration of the cantilever spring constant. Nevertheless the dynamics of CPs, and in particular of large CPs, with radius well above 10 um and mass comparable, or larger, than the cantilever mass, is at present still poorly characterised. Here we describe the fabrication and calibration of (large) CPs. We describe and discuss the peculiar dynamical behaviour of CPs, and present an alternative protocol for the accurate calibration of the spring constant.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Engineered Swift Equilibration of brownian particles: consequences of hydrodynamic coupling
Authors:
Salambô Dago,
Benjamin Besga,
Raphaël Mothe,
David Guéry-Odelin,
Emmanuel Trizac,
Artyom Petrosyan,
Ludovic Bellon,
Sergio Ciliberto
Abstract:
We present a detailed theoretical and experimental analysis of Engineered Swift Equilibration (ESE) protocols applied to two hydrodynamically coupled colloids in optical traps. The second particle disturbs slightly (10% at most) the response to an ESE compression applied to a single particle. This effect is quantitatively explained by a model of hydrodynamic coupling. Then we design a coupled ESE…
▽ More
We present a detailed theoretical and experimental analysis of Engineered Swift Equilibration (ESE) protocols applied to two hydrodynamically coupled colloids in optical traps. The second particle disturbs slightly (10% at most) the response to an ESE compression applied to a single particle. This effect is quantitatively explained by a model of hydrodynamic coupling. Then we design a coupled ESE protocol for the two particles, allowing the perfect control of one target particle while the second is enslaved to the first. The calibration errors and the limitations of the model are finally discussed in detail.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020; v1 submitted 11 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Calibrated force measurement in Atomic Force Microscopy using the Transient Fluctuation Theorem
Authors:
Samuel Albert,
Aubin Archambault,
Artyom Petrosyan,
Caroline Crauste-Thibierge,
Ludovic Bellon,
Sergio Ciliberto
Abstract:
The Transient Fluctuation Theorem is used to calibrate an Atomic Force Microscope by measuring the fluctuations of the work performed by a time dependent force applied between a collo{ï}dal probe and the surface. From this measure one can easily extract the value of the interaction force and the relevant parameters of the cantilever. The results of this analysis are compared with those obtained by…
▽ More
The Transient Fluctuation Theorem is used to calibrate an Atomic Force Microscope by measuring the fluctuations of the work performed by a time dependent force applied between a collo{ï}dal probe and the surface. From this measure one can easily extract the value of the interaction force and the relevant parameters of the cantilever. The results of this analysis are compared with those obtained by standard calibration methods. a) present adress: ISIS, Univ.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Extended equipartition in a mechanical system subject to a heat flow: the case of localised dissipation
Authors:
Alex Fontana,
Richard Pedurand,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Statistical physics in equilibrium grants us one of its most powerful tools: the equipartition principle. It states that the degrees of freedom of a mechanical system act as a thermometer: temperature is equal to the mean variance of their oscillations divided by their stiffness. However, when a non-equilibrium state is considered, this principle is no longer valid. In our experiment, we study the…
▽ More
Statistical physics in equilibrium grants us one of its most powerful tools: the equipartition principle. It states that the degrees of freedom of a mechanical system act as a thermometer: temperature is equal to the mean variance of their oscillations divided by their stiffness. However, when a non-equilibrium state is considered, this principle is no longer valid. In our experiment, we study the fluctuations of a micro-cantilever subject to a strong heat flow, which creates a highly non-uniform local temperature. We measure independently the temperature profile of the object and the temperature yielded from the mechanical thermometers, thus testing the validity of the equipartition principle out of equilibrium. We demonstrate how the fluctuations of the most energetic degrees of freedom are equivalent to the temperature at the base of the cantilever, even when the average temperature is several hundreds of degrees higher. We then present a model based on the localised mechanical dissipation in the system to account for our results, which correspond to mechanical losses localised at the clam** position.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Extended Nyquist formula for a resistance subject to a heat flow
Authors:
Benjamin Monnet,
Sergio Ciliberto,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The Nyquist formula quantifies the thermal noise driven fluctuations of voltage across a resistance in equilibrium. We deal here with the case of a resistance driven out of equilibrium by putting it in contact with two thermostats at different temperatures. We reach a non-equilibrium steady state where a heat flux is flowing through the resistance. Our measurements demonstrate anyway that a simple…
▽ More
The Nyquist formula quantifies the thermal noise driven fluctuations of voltage across a resistance in equilibrium. We deal here with the case of a resistance driven out of equilibrium by putting it in contact with two thermostats at different temperatures. We reach a non-equilibrium steady state where a heat flux is flowing through the resistance. Our measurements demonstrate anyway that a simple extension of the Nyquist formula to the non uniform temperature field describes with an excellent precision the thermal noise. For a metallic ohmic material, the fluctuations are actually equivalent to those of a resistance in equilibrium with a single thermostat at the mean temperature between the hot and cold sources.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2019; v1 submitted 7 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
"Noiseless" thermal noise measurement of atomic force microscopy cantilevers
Authors:
Basile Pottier,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
When measuring quadratic values representative of random fluctuations, such as the thermal noise of Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) cantilevers, the background measurement noise cannot be averaged to zero. We present a signal processing method that allows to get rid of this limitation using the ubiquitous optical beam deflection sensor of standard AFMs. We demonstrate a two orders of magnitude enhan…
▽ More
When measuring quadratic values representative of random fluctuations, such as the thermal noise of Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) cantilevers, the background measurement noise cannot be averaged to zero. We present a signal processing method that allows to get rid of this limitation using the ubiquitous optical beam deflection sensor of standard AFMs. We demonstrate a two orders of magnitude enhancement of the signal to noise ratio in our experiment, allowing the calibration of stiff cantilevers or easy identification of higher order modes from thermal noise measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Low thermal fluctuations in a system heated out of equilibrium
Authors:
Mickael Geitner,
Felipe Aguilar Sandoval,
Eric Bertin,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
We study the mechanical fluctuations of a micrometer sized silicon cantilever subjected to a strong heat flow, thus having a highly non-uniform local temperature. In this non-equilibrium steady state, we show that fluctuations are equivalent to the thermal noise of a cantilever at equilibrium around room temperature, while its mean local temperature is several hundred of degrees higher. Changing t…
▽ More
We study the mechanical fluctuations of a micrometer sized silicon cantilever subjected to a strong heat flow, thus having a highly non-uniform local temperature. In this non-equilibrium steady state, we show that fluctuations are equivalent to the thermal noise of a cantilever at equilibrium around room temperature, while its mean local temperature is several hundred of degrees higher. Changing the mechanical dissipation by adding a coating to the cantilever, we recover the expected rise of fluctuations with the mean temperature. Our work demonstrates that inhomogeneous dissipation mechanisms can decouple the amplitude of thermal fluctuations from the average temperature. This property could be useful to understand out-of-equilibrium fluctuating systems, or to engineer low noise instruments.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2017; v1 submitted 13 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Dynamic stiffness of the contact between a carbon nanotube and a flat substrate in a peeling geometry
Authors:
Tianjun Li,
Lorène Champougny,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
We study the physics of adhesion and the contact mechanics at the nanoscale with a peeling experiment of a carbon nanotube on a flat substrate. Using an interferometric atomic force microscope and an extended force modulation protocol, we investigate the frequency response of the stiffness of the nano-contact from DC to 20 kHz. We show that this dynamic stiffness is only weakly frequency dependent…
▽ More
We study the physics of adhesion and the contact mechanics at the nanoscale with a peeling experiment of a carbon nanotube on a flat substrate. Using an interferometric atomic force microscope and an extended force modulation protocol, we investigate the frequency response of the stiffness of the nano-contact from DC to 20 kHz. We show that this dynamic stiffness is only weakly frequency dependent, increasing by a factor 2 when the frequency grows by 3 orders of magnitude. Such behavior may be the signature of amorphous relaxations during the mechanical solicitation at the nano-scale.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2017; v1 submitted 21 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
High Resolution Viscosity Measurement by Thermal Noise Detection
Authors:
Felipe Aguilar Sandoval,
Manuel Sepúlveda,
Ludovic Bellon,
Francisco Melo
Abstract:
An interferometric method is implemented in order to accurately assess the thermal fluctuations of a micro-cantilever sensor in liquid environments. The power spectrum density (PSD) of thermal fluctuations together with Sader's model of the cantilever allow for the indirect measurement of the liquid viscosity with good accuracy. The good quality of the deflection signal and the characteristic low…
▽ More
An interferometric method is implemented in order to accurately assess the thermal fluctuations of a micro-cantilever sensor in liquid environments. The power spectrum density (PSD) of thermal fluctuations together with Sader's model of the cantilever allow for the indirect measurement of the liquid viscosity with good accuracy. The good quality of the deflection signal and the characteristic low noise of the instrument allow for the detection and corrections of drawbacks due to both the cantilever shape irregularities and the uncertainties on the position of the laser spot at the fluctuating end of the cantilever. Variation of viscosity below 0.03 mPa$\cdot$s was detected with the alternative to achieve measurements with a volume as low as 50 $μ$L.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Simultaneous and accurate measurement of the dielectric constant at many frequencies spanning a wide range
Authors:
Roberto Pérez-Aparicio,
Caroline Crauste-Thibierge,
Denis Cottinet,
Marius Tanase,
Pascal Metz,
Ludovic Bellon,
Antoine Naert,
Sergio Ciliberto
Abstract:
We present an innovative technique which allows the simultaneous measurement of the dielectric constant of a material at many frequencies, spanning a four orders of magnitude range chosen between 10 --2 Hz and 10 4 Hz. The sensitivity and accuracy are comparable to those obtained using standard single frequency techniques. The technique is based on three new and simple features: a) the precise rea…
▽ More
We present an innovative technique which allows the simultaneous measurement of the dielectric constant of a material at many frequencies, spanning a four orders of magnitude range chosen between 10 --2 Hz and 10 4 Hz. The sensitivity and accuracy are comparable to those obtained using standard single frequency techniques. The technique is based on three new and simple features: a) the precise real time correction of the amplication of a current amplier; b) the specic shape of the excitation signal and its frequency spectrum; and c) the precise synchronization between the generation of the excitation signal and the acquisition of the dielectric response signal. This technique is useful in the case of relatively fast dynamical measurements when the knowledge of the time evolution of the dielectric constant is needed.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Resonance frequency shift of strongly heated micro-cantilevers
Authors:
Felipe Aguilar Sandoval,
Mickael Geitner,
Éric Bertin,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
In optical detection setups to measure the deflection of micro-cantilevers, part of the sensing light is absorbed, heating the mechanical probe. We present experimental evidences of a frequency shift of the resonant modes of a cantilever when the light power of the optical measurement set-up is increased. This frequency shift is a signature of the temperature rise, and presents a dependence on the…
▽ More
In optical detection setups to measure the deflection of micro-cantilevers, part of the sensing light is absorbed, heating the mechanical probe. We present experimental evidences of a frequency shift of the resonant modes of a cantilever when the light power of the optical measurement set-up is increased. This frequency shift is a signature of the temperature rise, and presents a dependence on the mode number. An analytical model is derived to take into account the temperature profile along the cantilever, it shows that the frequency shifts are given by an average of the profile weighted by the local curvature for each resonant mode. We apply this framework to measurements in vacuum and demonstrate that huge temperatures can be reached with moderate light intensities: a thousand {\textdegree}C with little more than 10 mW. We finally present some insight into the physical phenomena when the cantilever is in air instead of vacuum.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2015; v1 submitted 17 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Adhesion energy of single wall carbon nanotube loops on various substrates
Authors:
Tianjun Li,
Anthony AYARI,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The physics of adhesion of one-dimensional nano structures such as nanotubes, nano wires, and biopolymers on different material substrates is of great interest for the study of biological adhesion and the development of nano electronics and nano mechanics. In this paper, we present force spectroscopy experiments of a single wall carbon nanotube loop using our home-made interferometric atomic force…
▽ More
The physics of adhesion of one-dimensional nano structures such as nanotubes, nano wires, and biopolymers on different material substrates is of great interest for the study of biological adhesion and the development of nano electronics and nano mechanics. In this paper, we present force spectroscopy experiments of a single wall carbon nanotube loop using our home-made interferometric atomic force microscope. Characteristic force plateaux during the peeling process allows us to access to quantitative values of the adhesion energy per unit length on various substrates: graphite, mica, platinum, gold and silicon. By combining a time-frequency analysis of the deflexion of the cantilever, we access to the dynamic stiffness of the contact, providing more information on the nanotube configurations and its intrinsic mechanical properties.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Measurements of mechanical thermal noise and energy dissipation in optical dielectric coatings
Authors:
Tianjun Li,
Felipe A. Aguilar Sandoval,
Mickael Geitner,
Gianpietro Cagnoli,
Vincent Dolique,
Jérôme Degallaix,
Raffaele Flaminio,
Danièle Forest,
Massimo Granata,
Christophe Michel,
Nazario Morgado,
Laurent Pinard,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
In recent years an increasing number of devices and experiments are shown to be limited by mechanical thermal noise. In particular sub-Hertz laser frequency stabilization and gravitational wave detectors, that are able to measure fluctuations of 1E-18 m/rtHz or less, are being limited by thermal noise in the dielectric coatings deposited on mirrors. In this paper we present a new measurement of th…
▽ More
In recent years an increasing number of devices and experiments are shown to be limited by mechanical thermal noise. In particular sub-Hertz laser frequency stabilization and gravitational wave detectors, that are able to measure fluctuations of 1E-18 m/rtHz or less, are being limited by thermal noise in the dielectric coatings deposited on mirrors. In this paper we present a new measurement of thermal noise in low absorption dielectric coatings deposited on micro-cantilevers and we compare it with the results obtained from the mechanical loss measurements. The coating thermal noise is measured on the widest range of frequencies with the highest signal to noise ratio ever achieved. In addition we present a novel technique to deduce the coating mechanical losses from the measurement of the mechanical quality factor which does not rely on the knowledge of the coating and substrate Young moduli. The dielectric coatings are deposited by ion beam sputtering. The results presented here give a frequency independent loss angle of (4.70 $\pm$ 0.2)x1E-4 with a Young's modulus of 118 GPa for annealed tantala from 10 Hz to 20 kHz. For as-deposited silica, a weak frequency dependence (~ f^{-0.025}) is observed in this frequency range, with a Young's modulus of 70 GPa and an internal dam** of (6.0 $\pm$ 0.3)x1E-4 at 16 kHz, but this value decreases by one order of magnitude after annealing and the frequency dependence disappears.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2014; v1 submitted 31 December, 2013;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Microrheology measurements with a hanging-fiber AFM probe
Authors:
Clemence Devailly,
Justine Laurent,
Audrey Steinberger,
Ludovic Bellon,
Sergio Ciliberto
Abstract:
A method to measure the viscosity of liquids at microscales is presented. It uses a thin glass fiber fixed on the tip of the cantilever of an extremely low noise Atomic Force Microscope (AFM), which accurately measures the cantilever {deflection}. When the fiber is dipped into the liquid the dissipation of the cantilever-fiber system increases. This dissipation, linked to the liquid viscosity, is…
▽ More
A method to measure the viscosity of liquids at microscales is presented. It uses a thin glass fiber fixed on the tip of the cantilever of an extremely low noise Atomic Force Microscope (AFM), which accurately measures the cantilever {deflection}. When the fiber is dipped into the liquid the dissipation of the cantilever-fiber system increases. This dissipation, linked to the liquid viscosity, is computed from the power spectral density of the thermal fluctuations of the cantilever {deflection}. The {high sensitivity of the AFM} allows us to show the existence and to develop a model of the coupling between the dynamics of the fiber and that of the cantilever. This model {accurately} fits the experimental data. The advantages and draw-backs of the method are discussed
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Quadrature phase interferometer for high resolution force spectroscopy
Authors:
Pierdomenico Paolino,
Felipe A. Aguilar Sandoval,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
In this article, we present a deflection measurement setup for Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). It is based on a quadrature phase differential interferometer: we measure the optical path difference between a laser beam reflecting above the cantilever tip and a reference beam reflecting on the static base of the sensor. A design with very low environmental susceptibility and another allowing calibrat…
▽ More
In this article, we present a deflection measurement setup for Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). It is based on a quadrature phase differential interferometer: we measure the optical path difference between a laser beam reflecting above the cantilever tip and a reference beam reflecting on the static base of the sensor. A design with very low environmental susceptibility and another allowing calibrated measurements on a wide spectral range are described. Both enable a very high resolution (down to $\SI{2.5E-15}{m/\sqrt{Hz}}$), illustrated by thermal noise measurements on AFM cantilevers. They present an excellent long-term stability, and a constant sensitivity independent of the optical phase of the interferometer. A quick review shows that our precision is equaling or out-performing the best results reported in the literature, but for a much larger deflection range, up to a few $\SI{}{\micro m}$.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2013; v1 submitted 4 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Functionalized AFM probes for force spectroscopy: eigenmodes shape and stiffness calibration through thermal noise measurements
Authors:
Justine Laurent,
Audrey Steinberger,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
The functionalization of an Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) cantilever with a colloidal bead is a widely used technique when the geometry between the probe and the sample must be controlled, particularly in force spectroscopy. But some questions remain: how does a bead glued at the end of a cantilever influence its mechanical response ? And more important for quantitative measurements, can we still…
▽ More
The functionalization of an Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) cantilever with a colloidal bead is a widely used technique when the geometry between the probe and the sample must be controlled, particularly in force spectroscopy. But some questions remain: how does a bead glued at the end of a cantilever influence its mechanical response ? And more important for quantitative measurements, can we still determine the stiffness of the AFM probe with traditional techniques? In this article, the influence of a colloidal mass loading on the eigenmodes shape and resonant frequency is investigated by measuring the thermal noise on rectangular AFM microcantilevers with and without a bead attached at their extremities. The experiments are performed with a home-made ultra-sensitive AFM, based on differential interferometry. The focused beam from the interferometer probes the cantilever at different positions and the spatial shapes of the modes are determined up to the fifth resonance, without external excitation. The results clearly demonstrate that the first eigenmode almost doesn't change by mass loading. However the oscillation behavior of higher resonances present a marked difference: with a particle glued at its extremity, the nodes of the mode are displaced towards the free end of the cantilever. These results are compared to an analytical model taking into account the mass and the inertial moment of the load in an Euler-Bernoulli framework, where the normalization of the eigenmodes is explicitly worked out in order to allow a quantitative prediction of the thermal noise amplitude of each mode. A good agreement between the experimental results and the analytical model is demonstrated, allowing a clean calibration of the probe stiffness.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2013; v1 submitted 11 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Dissipation of micro-cantilevers as a function of air pressure and metallic coating
Authors:
Tianjun Li,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
In this letter, we characterize the internal dissipation of coated micro-cantilevers through their mechanical thermal noise. Using a home-made interferometric setup, we achieve a resolution down to 1E-14m/rtHz in the measurement of their deflection. With the use of the fluctuation dissipation theorem and of the Kramers-Kronig relations, we rebuilt the full mechanical response function from the mea…
▽ More
In this letter, we characterize the internal dissipation of coated micro-cantilevers through their mechanical thermal noise. Using a home-made interferometric setup, we achieve a resolution down to 1E-14m/rtHz in the measurement of their deflection. With the use of the fluctuation dissipation theorem and of the Kramers-Kronig relations, we rebuilt the full mechanical response function from the measured noise spectrum, and investigate frequency dependent dissipation as a function of the air pressure and of the nature of the metallic coatings. Using different thicknesses of gold coatings, we discuss the source of the internal viscoelastic dam**.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
Carbon nanotubes adhesion and nanomechanical behavior from peeling force spectroscopy
Authors:
Julien Buchoux,
Ludovic Bellon,
Sophie Marsaudon,
Jean-Pierre Aimé
Abstract:
Applications based on Single Walled Carbon Nanotube (SWNT) are good example of the great need to continuously develop metrology methods in the field of nanotechnology. Contact and interface properties are key parameters that determine the efficiency of SWNT functionalized nanomaterials and nanodevices. In this work we have taken advantage of a good control of the SWNT growth processes at an atomic…
▽ More
Applications based on Single Walled Carbon Nanotube (SWNT) are good example of the great need to continuously develop metrology methods in the field of nanotechnology. Contact and interface properties are key parameters that determine the efficiency of SWNT functionalized nanomaterials and nanodevices. In this work we have taken advantage of a good control of the SWNT growth processes at an atomic force microscope (AFM) tip apex and the use of a low noise (1E-13 m/rtHz) AFM to investigate the mechanical behavior of a SWNT touching a surface. By simultaneously recording static and dynamic properties of SWNT, we show that the contact corresponds to a peeling geometry, and extract quantities such as adhesion energy per unit length, curvature and bending rigidity of the nanotube. A complete picture of the local shape of the SWNT and its mechanical behavior is provided.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Steady state fluctuation relations for systems driven by an external random force
Authors:
Juan Ruben Gomez-Solano,
Ludovic Bellon,
Artyom Petrosyan,
Sergio Ciliberto
Abstract:
We experimentally study the fluctuations of the work done by an external Gaussian random force on two different stochastic systems coupled to a thermal bath: a colloidal particle in an optical trap and an atomic force microscopy cantilever. We determine the corresponding probability density functions for different random forcing amplitudes ranging from a small fraction to several times the ampli…
▽ More
We experimentally study the fluctuations of the work done by an external Gaussian random force on two different stochastic systems coupled to a thermal bath: a colloidal particle in an optical trap and an atomic force microscopy cantilever. We determine the corresponding probability density functions for different random forcing amplitudes ranging from a small fraction to several times the amplitude of the thermal noise. In both systems for sufficiently weak forcing amplitudes the work fluctuations satisfy the usual steady state fluctuation theorem. As the forcing amplitude drives the system far from equilibrium, deviations of the fluctuation theorem increase monotonically. The deviations can be recasted to a single master curve which only depends on the kind of stochastic external force.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Direct measurement of spatial modes of a micro-cantilever from thermal noise
Authors:
Pierdomenico Paolino,
Bruno Tiribilli,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
Measurements of the deflection induced by thermal noise have been performed on a rectangular atomic force microscope cantilever in air. The detection method, based on polarization interferometry, can achieve a resolution of 1E-14 m/rtHz in the frequency range 1 kHz ? 800 kHz. The focused beam from the interferometer probes the cantilever at different positions along its length and the spatial mo…
▽ More
Measurements of the deflection induced by thermal noise have been performed on a rectangular atomic force microscope cantilever in air. The detection method, based on polarization interferometry, can achieve a resolution of 1E-14 m/rtHz in the frequency range 1 kHz ? 800 kHz. The focused beam from the interferometer probes the cantilever at different positions along its length and the spatial modes' shapes are determined up to the fourth resonance, without external excitation. Results are in good agreement with theoretically expected behavior. From this analysis accurate determination of the elastic constant of the cantilever is also achieved.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2009; v1 submitted 29 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Frequency dependence of viscous and viscoelastic dissipation in coated micro-cantilevers from noise measurement
Authors:
Pierdomenico Paolino,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
We measure the mechanical thermal noise of soft silicon atomic force microscopy cantilevers. Using an interferometric setup, we have a resolution down to 1E-14 m/rtHz on a wide spectral range (3 Hz to 1E5 Hz). The low frequency behavior depends dramatically on the presence of a reflective coating: almost flat spectrums for uncoated cantilevers versus 1/f like trend for coated ones. The addition…
▽ More
We measure the mechanical thermal noise of soft silicon atomic force microscopy cantilevers. Using an interferometric setup, we have a resolution down to 1E-14 m/rtHz on a wide spectral range (3 Hz to 1E5 Hz). The low frequency behavior depends dramatically on the presence of a reflective coating: almost flat spectrums for uncoated cantilevers versus 1/f like trend for coated ones. The addition of a viscoelastic term in models of the mechanical system can account for this observation. Use of Kramers-Kronig relations validate this approach with a complete determination of the response of the cantilever: a power law with a small coefficient is found for the frequency dependence of viscoelasticity due to the coating, whereas the viscous dam** due to the surrounding atmosphere is accurately described by the Sader model.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2009; v1 submitted 18 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Thermal noise of microcantilevers in viscous fluids
Authors:
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
We present a simple theoretical framework to describe the thermal noise of a microscopic mechanical beam in a viscous fluid: we use the Sader approach to describe the effect of the surrounding fluid (added mass and viscous drag), and the fluctuation dissipation theorem for each flexural modes of the system to derive a general expression for the power spectrum density of fluctuations. This predic…
▽ More
We present a simple theoretical framework to describe the thermal noise of a microscopic mechanical beam in a viscous fluid: we use the Sader approach to describe the effect of the surrounding fluid (added mass and viscous drag), and the fluctuation dissipation theorem for each flexural modes of the system to derive a general expression for the power spectrum density of fluctuations. This prediction is compared with an experimental measurement on a commercial atomic force microscopy cantilever in a frequency range covering the two first resonances. A very good agreement is found on the whole spectrum, with no adjustable parameters but the thickness of the cantilever.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Single beam interferometric angle measurement
Authors:
Pierdomenico Paolino,
Ludovic Bellon
Abstract:
We present an application of a quadrature phase interferometer to the measurement of the angular position of a parallel laser beam with interferometric precision. In our experimental realization we reach a resolution of 6.8e-10 rad (1.4e-4 arcsec) for 1 kHz bandwidth in a 2e-2 rad (1 deg) range. This alternative to the optical lever technique features absolute calibration, independence of the se…
▽ More
We present an application of a quadrature phase interferometer to the measurement of the angular position of a parallel laser beam with interferometric precision. In our experimental realization we reach a resolution of 6.8e-10 rad (1.4e-4 arcsec) for 1 kHz bandwidth in a 2e-2 rad (1 deg) range. This alternative to the optical lever technique features absolute calibration, independence of the sensitivity on the thermal drifts, and wide range of measurement at full accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2007; v1 submitted 12 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
Coupling between aging and convective motion in a colloidal glass of Laponite
Authors:
Ludovic Bellon,
Mathieu Gibert,
Rodrigo Hernández
Abstract:
We study thermal convection in a colloidal glass of Laponite in formation. Low concentration preparation are submitted to destabilizing vertical temperature gradient, and present a gradual transition from a turbulent convective state to a steady conductive state as their viscosity increases. The time spent under convection is found to depend strongly on sample concentration, decreasing exponenti…
▽ More
We study thermal convection in a colloidal glass of Laponite in formation. Low concentration preparation are submitted to destabilizing vertical temperature gradient, and present a gradual transition from a turbulent convective state to a steady conductive state as their viscosity increases. The time spent under convection is found to depend strongly on sample concentration, decreasing exponentially with mass fraction of colloidal particles. Moreover, at fixed concentration, it also depends slightly on the pattern selected by the Rayleigh Bénard instability: more rolls maintain the convection state longer. This behavior can be interpreted with recent theoretical approaches of soft glassy material rheology.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2007; v1 submitted 21 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
Thermal noise properties of two aging materials
Authors:
L. Bellon,
L. Buisson,
M. Ciccotti,
S. Ciliberto,
F. Douarche
Abstract:
In this lecture we review several aspects of the thermal noise properties in two aging materials: a polymer and a colloidal glass.
The measurements have been performed after a quench for the polymer and during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state for the gel. Two kind of noise has been measured: the electrical noise and the mechanical noise.
For both materials we have obser…
▽ More
In this lecture we review several aspects of the thermal noise properties in two aging materials: a polymer and a colloidal glass.
The measurements have been performed after a quench for the polymer and during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state for the gel. Two kind of noise has been measured: the electrical noise and the mechanical noise.
For both materials we have observed that the electric noise is characterized by a strong intermittency, which induces a large violation of the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT) during the aging time, and may persist for several hours at low frequency. The statistics of these intermittent signals and their dependance on the quench speed for the polymer or on sample concentration for the gel are studied. The results are in a qualitative agreement with recent models of aging, that predict an intermittent dynamics. For the mechanical noise the results are unclear. In the polymer the mechanical thermal noise is still intermittent whereas for the gel the violation of FDT, if it exists, is extremely small.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Electrical noise properties in aging materials
Authors:
L. Buisson,
M. Ciccotti,
L. Bellon,
S. Ciliberto
Abstract:
The electric thermal noise has been measured in two aging materials, a colloidal suspension (Laponite) and a polymer (polycarbonate), presenting very slow relaxation towards equilibrium. The measurements have been performed during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state for the gel and after a quench for the polymer. For both materials we have observed that the electric noise is c…
▽ More
The electric thermal noise has been measured in two aging materials, a colloidal suspension (Laponite) and a polymer (polycarbonate), presenting very slow relaxation towards equilibrium. The measurements have been performed during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state for the gel and after a quench for the polymer. For both materials we have observed that the electric noise is characterized by a strong intermittency, which induces a large violation of the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT) during the aging time, and may persist for several hours at low frequency. The statistics of these intermittent signals and their dependance on the quench speed for the polymer or on sample concentration for the gel are studied. The results are in a qualitative agreement with recent models of aging, that predict an intermittent dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2004;
originally announced March 2004.
-
Intermittency in aging
Authors:
L. Buisson,
L. Bellon,
S. Ciliberto
Abstract:
The fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR) is measured on the dielectric properties of a gel (Laponite) and of a polymer glass (polycarbonate). For the gel it is found that during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state the fluctuation dissipation theorem is strongly violated. The amplitude and the persistence time of this violation are decreasing functions of frequency. Around…
▽ More
The fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR) is measured on the dielectric properties of a gel (Laponite) and of a polymer glass (polycarbonate). For the gel it is found that during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state the fluctuation dissipation theorem is strongly violated. The amplitude and the persistence time of this violation are decreasing functions of frequency. Around $1Hz$ it may persist for several hours. A very similar behavior is observed in polycarbonate after a quench below the glass transition temperature. In both cases the origin of this violation is a highly intermittent dynamics characterized by large fluctuations. The relevance of these results for recent models of aging are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2002;
originally announced October 2002.
-
Advanced memory effects in the aging of a polymer glass
Authors:
L. Bellon,
S. Ciliberto,
C. Laroche
Abstract:
A new kind of memory effect on low frequency dielectric measurements on plexiglass (PMMA) is described. These measurements show that cooling and heating the sample at constant rate give an hysteretic dependence on temperature of the dielectric constant $ε$. A temporary stop of cooling produces a downward relaxation of $ε$. Two main features are observed i) when cooling is resumed $ε$ goes back t…
▽ More
A new kind of memory effect on low frequency dielectric measurements on plexiglass (PMMA) is described. These measurements show that cooling and heating the sample at constant rate give an hysteretic dependence on temperature of the dielectric constant $ε$. A temporary stop of cooling produces a downward relaxation of $ε$. Two main features are observed i) when cooling is resumed $ε$ goes back to the values obtained without the cooling stop (i.e. the low temperature state is independent of the cooling history) ii) upon reheating $ε$ keeps the memory of all the cooling stops({\it Advanced memory}).
The dependence of this effect on frequency and on the cooling rate is analyzed. The memory deletion is studied too. Finally the results are compared with those of similar experiments done in spin glasses and with the famous experiments of Kovacs.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
-
Experimental study of the Fluctuation-Dissipation-Relation during an aging process
Authors:
Ludovic Bellon,
Sergio Ciliberto
Abstract:
The validity of fluctuation dissipation relations in an aging system is studied in a colloidal glass during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state. The evolution of the rheological and electrical properties is analyzed in the range $1Hz - 40Hz$. It is found that at the beginning of the transition the fluctuation dissipation relation is strongly violated in electrical measurements…
▽ More
The validity of fluctuation dissipation relations in an aging system is studied in a colloidal glass during the transition from a fluid-like to a solid-like state. The evolution of the rheological and electrical properties is analyzed in the range $1Hz - 40Hz$. It is found that at the beginning of the transition the fluctuation dissipation relation is strongly violated in electrical measurements. The amplitude and the persistence time of this violation are decreasing functions of frequency. At the lowest frequencies of the measuring range it persists for times which are about 5% of the time needed to form the colloidal glass. This phenomenology is quite close to the recent theoretical predictions done for the violation of the fluctuation dissipation relation in glassy systems. In contrast in the rheological measurements no violation of the fluctuation dissipation relation is observed. The reasons of this large difference between the electrical and rheological measurements are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2002; v1 submitted 14 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
-
Fluctuation-Dissipation-Theorem violation during the formation of a colloidal-glass
Authors:
L. Bellon,
S. Ciliberto,
C. Laroche
Abstract:
The relationship between the conductivity and the polarization noise is measured in a gel as a function of frequency in the range $1Hz - 40Hz$. It is found that at the beginning of the transition from a fluid like sol to a solid like gel the fluctuation dissipation theorem is strongly violated. The amplitude and the persistence time of this violation are decreasing functions of frequency. At the…
▽ More
The relationship between the conductivity and the polarization noise is measured in a gel as a function of frequency in the range $1Hz - 40Hz$. It is found that at the beginning of the transition from a fluid like sol to a solid like gel the fluctuation dissipation theorem is strongly violated. The amplitude and the persistence time of this violation are decreasing functions of frequency. At the lowest frequencies of the measuring range it persists for times which are about 5% of the time needed to form the gel. This phenomenology is quite close to the recent theoretical predictions done for the violation of the fluctuation dissipation theorem in glassy systems.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2000;
originally announced August 2000.
-
Memory in the aging of a polymer glass
Authors:
L. Bellon,
S. Ciliberto,
C. Laroche
Abstract:
Low frequency dielectric measurements on plexiglass (PMMA) show that cooling and heating the sample at constant rate give an hysteretic dependence on temperature of the dielectric constant $ε$. A temporary stop of cooling produces a downward relaxation of $ε$. Two main features are observed i) when cooling is resumed $ε$ goes back to the values obtained without the cooling stop (i.e. the low tem…
▽ More
Low frequency dielectric measurements on plexiglass (PMMA) show that cooling and heating the sample at constant rate give an hysteretic dependence on temperature of the dielectric constant $ε$. A temporary stop of cooling produces a downward relaxation of $ε$. Two main features are observed i) when cooling is resumed $ε$ goes back to the values obtained without the cooling stop (i.e. the low temperature state is independent of the cooling history) ii) upon reheating $ε$ keeps the memory of the aging history ({\it Memory}). The analogies and differences with similar experiments done in spin glasses are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2000; v1 submitted 11 June, 1999;
originally announced June 1999.
-
Temperature cycling during the aging of a polymer glass
Authors:
L. Bellon,
S. Ciliberto,
C. Laroche
Abstract:
Temperature cycling is used to study of aging properties of PMMA dielectric constant. If a negative temperature cycle is applied during the aging time the relaxation dynamics is just delayed for a time equal to the cycle period. In contrast this time shifting procedure cannot be applied to positive temperature cycles . The analogies and differences with similar experiments done in other aging sy…
▽ More
Temperature cycling is used to study of aging properties of PMMA dielectric constant. If a negative temperature cycle is applied during the aging time the relaxation dynamics is just delayed for a time equal to the cycle period. In contrast this time shifting procedure cannot be applied to positive temperature cycles . The analogies and differences with similar experiments done in other aging systems, such as spin glasses, orientational glasses and supercooled liquids, are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 1999; v1 submitted 12 May, 1999;
originally announced May 1999.
