-
The fallacy of tumor immunology: Evolutionary pressures, viruses as nature's genetic engineering tools and T cell surveillance emergence for purging nascent selfish cells
Authors:
Tibor Bakacs,
Katalin Kristof,
Jitendra Mehrishi,
Tamas Szabados,
Csaba Kerepesi,
Enikoe Regoes,
Gabor Tusnady
Abstract:
The US and Hungarian statistical records of the years 1900 and 1896, respectively, before the dramatic medical advances, show 32% and 27% deaths attributable to infections, whereas only 5% and 2% due to cancer. These data can be interpreted to mean that (i) the immune system evolved for purging nascent selfish cells, which establish natural chimerism littering the soma and the germline by conspeci…
▽ More
The US and Hungarian statistical records of the years 1900 and 1896, respectively, before the dramatic medical advances, show 32% and 27% deaths attributable to infections, whereas only 5% and 2% due to cancer. These data can be interpreted to mean that (i) the immune system evolved for purging nascent selfish cells, which establish natural chimerism littering the soma and the germline by conspecific alien cells and (ii) defense against pathogens that represent xenogeneic aliens appeared later in evolution.
`Liberating' T cells from the semantic trap of immunity and the shackles of the `two-signal' model of T cell activation, we point out theoretical grounds that the immune response to cancer is conceptually different from the immune response to infection. We argue for a one-signal model (with stochastic influences) as the explanation for T cell activation in preference to the widely accepted two-signal model of co-stimulation. Convincing evidence for our one-signal model emerged from the widespread autoimmune adverse events in 64.2% of advanced melanoma patients treated with the anti-CTLA-4 antibody (ipilimumab) that blocks an immune checkpoint. Harnessing the unleashed autoimmune power of T cells could be rewarding to defeat cancer. Assuming that immunization against isogeneic tumors also would be effective is a fallacy.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2016; v1 submitted 11 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
MiStImm: a simulation tool to compare classical nonsef-centered immune models with a novel self-centered model
Authors:
Tamás Szabados,
Csaba Kerepesi,
Tibor Bakács
Abstract:
Our main purpose is to compare classical nonself-centered, two-signal theoretical models of the adaptive immune system with a novel, self-centered, one-signal model developed by our research group. Our model hypothesizes that the immune system of a fetus is capable learning the limited set of self antigens but unable to prepare itself for the unlimited variety of nonself antigens. We have built a…
▽ More
Our main purpose is to compare classical nonself-centered, two-signal theoretical models of the adaptive immune system with a novel, self-centered, one-signal model developed by our research group. Our model hypothesizes that the immune system of a fetus is capable learning the limited set of self antigens but unable to prepare itself for the unlimited variety of nonself antigens. We have built a computational model that simulates the development of the adaptive immune system. For simplicity, we concentrated on humoral immunity and its major components: T cells, B cells, antibodies, interleukins, non-immune self cells, and foreign antigens. Our model is a microscopic one, similar to the interacting particle models of statistical physics and agent-based models in immunology. Furthermore, our model is stochastic: events are considered random and modeled by a continuous time, finite state Markov process, that is, they are controlled by finitely many independent exponential clocks.
We investigate under what conditions can an immune memory be created that results in a more effective immune response to a repeated infection. The simulations show that our self-centered model is realistic. Moreover, in case of a primary adaptive immune reaction, it can destroy infections more efficiently than a classical nonself-centered model.
Predictions of our theoretical model were clinically supported by autoimmune-related adverse events in high-dose immune checkpoint inhibitor immunotherapy trials and also by safe and successful low-dose immune checkpoint inhibitor combination treatment of heavily pretreated stage IV cancer patients who had exhausted all conventional treatments.
The MiStImm simulation tool and source codes are available at the address https://github.com/kerepesi/MiStImm.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2018; v1 submitted 3 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
A stochastic model of B cell affinity maturation and a network model of immune memory
Authors:
Tamás Szabados,
Gábor Tusnády,
László Varga,
Tibor Bakács
Abstract:
Many events in the vertebrate immune system are influenced by some element of chance. The objective of the present work is to describe affinity maturation of B lymphocytes (in which random events are perhaps the most characteristic), and to study a possible network model of immune memory. In our model stochastic processes govern all events. A major novelty of this approach is that it permits study…
▽ More
Many events in the vertebrate immune system are influenced by some element of chance. The objective of the present work is to describe affinity maturation of B lymphocytes (in which random events are perhaps the most characteristic), and to study a possible network model of immune memory. In our model stochastic processes govern all events. A major novelty of this approach is that it permits studying random variations in the immune process. Four basic components are simulated in the model: non-immune self cells, nonself cells (pathogens), B lymphocytes, and bone marrow cells that produce naive B lymphocytes. A point in a generalized shape space plus the size of the corresponding population represents nonself and non-immune self cells. On the other hand, each individual B cell is represented by a disc that models its recognition region in the shape space. Infection is simulated by an "injection" of nonself cells into the system. Division of pathogens may instigate an attack of naive B cells, which in turn may induce clonal proliferation and hypermutation in the attacking B cells, and which eventually may slow down and stop the exponential growth of pathogens. Affinity maturation of newly produced B cells becomes expressed as a result of selection when the number of pathogens decreases. Under favorable conditions, the expanded primary B cell clones may stimulate the expansion of secondary B cell clones carrying complementary receptors to the stimulating B cells. Like in a hall of mirrors, the image of pathogens in the primary B cell clones then will be reflected in secondary B cell clones. This "**-pong" game may survive for a long time even in the absence of the pathogen, creating a local network memory. This memory ensures that repeated infection by the same pathogen will be eliminated more efficiently.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
A new homeostatic model of the T cell system
Authors:
Tamas Szabados,
Tibor Bakacs
Abstract:
Our main tenet argues that the primary role of positive thymic selection and the resulting T cell population is the maintenance of a homeostatic equilibrium with self MHC-self peptide complexes. The homeostatic T cell repertoire can recognize infections non-specifically and this is an indirect (negative) recognition: the whole homeostatic T cell population together "holds a mirror" to the whole se…
▽ More
Our main tenet argues that the primary role of positive thymic selection and the resulting T cell population is the maintenance of a homeostatic equilibrium with self MHC-self peptide complexes. The homeostatic T cell repertoire can recognize infections non-specifically and this is an indirect (negative) recognition: the whole homeostatic T cell population together "holds a mirror" to the whole self, and any MHC-peptide complex that is "not reflected in the mirror" can be perceived by surrounding homeostatic T cells as a signal of the presence of a foreign entity. On the other hand, infection-specific T cell clones arise in a different pathway in the periphery, do not enter the thymus, and form a functionally different population. Here we summarize the basic assumptions and consequences of a logic-based new model, which differs from conventional models in many respects.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
